I am convinced that the secret of the Bessler wheel is something that is right out in the open, staring everyone right in the face. That is the junction where the pendulum upright and crossbar meet. In the original drawings it cannot be determined whether or nor the pendulum assembly is connected to the bar that runs from the inner support to the outer support or not. I believe that the pendulum assembly is constructed to slide back and forth on said bar within the confines of the U shaped capture at the top of the assembly at the same time as the pendulum is swinging.
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
channels like this bother me. if you're going to pretend to be about science, explain why perpetual motion isn't possible, or at least be honest and explain how you made the machine appear to work. this is going to do nothing except misinform kids who are interested in science.
harvesting energy from gravity is possible even NASA proves it by doing en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_assist but to make some energy from gravity and collect it ... it needs very good understanding of physics and geometry
Excellent reproduction! This design of his looks like a clock mechanism using pendulums to regulate/govern wheel speed , but obviously powered by the weight. Obviously when the weight reaches the floor, it will stop adding its energy to the system and it will all stop. It is unfortunate that this is the only wheel of his illustrated; not the 54+ days one. But it seems quite important, in a visually allegorical way. Certainly, it can be considered a window into the engineering mind of Bessler. At the very least I would interpret from this, that the energy which moves all his wheels moves through the weights, and is applied to the wheels rotation. Some say the hammering was made to mask the other noises so the hidden mechanisms could not be guessed. But I believe they were essential in transferring their acquired momentum to aid its rotation direction.
Jetzt hast du schon so ein tolles Rad gebaut. Jetzt wäre es noch super wenn du das Phänomen in dem Rad zeigen könntest z.B. durch eine Plexiglasscheibe. Ich denke die Meisten kommen dann wieder mit Thermodynamik und Co aber wer sagt denn das der Mensch die Natur komplett verstanden hat?
For those who are interested: (hopefully this does not get deleted) 1. It's very suspicious that at from 0:34 onward, you cannot see the top of the wheel/machine. 1a. Notice the speed at what the hammers are being lifted and dropped. 1b. Notice at 1:04, the hammers are lifted and dropped at a slower rate, already. The wheel is spinning slower. 2. At 1:14 Again, I need to see the top of the wheel. It is very possible to have another wheel spinning the wheel on this machine.. 3. At 1:46, you can see the top of the wheel to ensure no outside driving force. Too bad the clip stops at 1:56, the wheel was not spinning for long. This video should be A LOT longer, WITH a top view of the wheel to see "perpetual motion" 4. I will need to see what is inside of the wheel. It is possible to have a spring or string, winding mechanism of some sort. 5. Lastly, I will need to see underneath the table to make sure there are no electronics. Thank you, Neil R (EE)
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
This is an educational channel and all the replicas presented are motorized in no way they claimed any perpetual motion, they just show us how it would look if they worked.
The Big Wheel is indeed the 'power source'. Benjamin Franklin made a similar device, much smaller. The large wheel was sealed up air-tight; the flat sides remain somewhat flexible while the circumference is made strongly. As ambient air pressure changes throughout the day, the sides of the wheel are bent inward or outward. This puts compression or tension on the axles of the Great Wheel. One notes that this 'pumping action' of the axle is the motive force that drives the machine onward. It runs, no doubt. It is also externally powered. Franklin's 'water-drop' electrical generator does indeed harvest 'free-energy' from the Air, all you have to do is keep filling it with water. Lifting water to fill the tank 'charges' it up! The falling water-drops (gravity) provides all the energy needed to generate electricity. Many examples of 'Ambient Engines' exist. Daily changes in pressure, sunlight, air temperature and relative humidity have driven many other machines. They work, but are a kind of 'parlor trick'.
Totaler Quatsch!! Sie unterstellen Betrug ! Das Rad funktioniert ähnlich wie eine Uhr, aber ohne von Federn aufgezogen worden zu sein! Das ist ganz große Mechanikerkunst und scheinbar außerhalb ihres mechanischen Verständnisses! Finden Sie sich damit ab, dass Ihr Wissen nicht ausreicht! Von allein kommt ein normaler Mensch nicht drauf!(Ging mir auch so!)
Always figured that he used some type of long term windup springs--or else it was real. Great model, interesting videos. I notice all of your models seem to "work". Maybe you are Bessler reincarnated!
@@jhovanyurrea8898 Yeah well people are getting misinformed. If veproject1 had put something like, “Check my about page,” then they wouldn’t be misinformed.
@@edcdecl I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
All these demos are motorized. This disclamer is at the end of his blog page veproject1.blogspot.ca/. "These Perpetual Motion Machines are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors."..." I'd like to inspire these people by demonstrating Unworkable Perpetual Motion Machines that were designed centuries ago. "
If you check the last video that I posted on my channel, I'd say based on the description that he gave, that is it. I am continuing on with my project.
Fact: Using the word “machine” with perpetual motion or energy, will give it a beginning and an end, making it finite. With this new and better understanding of perpetual devices, its meaning will need updating in defining it as finite. This way, these devices or machines will not violate the laws of thermodynamics, laws of nature, laws of physics, makes them patentable. ~Guadalupe Guerra
Consider this...If you were to place the offset arms that are on the ends of the main axle at an equal 180 degrees and thus making the pendulums swing exactly opposite each other.Then make the upper pendulum pivots, into slides instead of a pivot, letting the whole pendulum slide from one end of the u shaped piece to the other, at the end of each swing.Would this create enough of a boost to the wheel to keep it going?Of course we will never know just what bessler had inside the actual wheel but I have given many hours of contemplation to the subject of this particular machine over the years and have thoughts that this might work.
If there is no electric motor in this device, then this is driven by the bending moments induced by the weights on the pendulums, similar to a trebuchet, on each side.
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
Yo creo que quien ha reproducido la máquina de Bessler, lo ha logrado: ahora bien, si es así, debiera percibir pequeñas anomalías de tiempo y gravitatorias, que pudieran sentirse por el operador -al mantenerse la máquina de PM un tiempo significativo funcionando. Ello le ocurrió a un inventor hace varias decenas de años (al cual tampoco le creyeron que el logro era auténtico). Su nombre : Paine.
@@arturovasquez9720 I found the key to how to turn a mechanical movement mechanism. I am sending you the various posts on messenger, if you then have some clarification write me on messanger ok
Why do you say? I didn't see any motor or strange things. This machine makes perfect sense to me, the forces are equilibrated and I think that the people like you, the ones that just say that don't just the reasons. Can you just go fuck yourself?, please?
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
non voglio declassare il sistema delle ruote perche il sitema rotatorio con le leve non e accettato dai ingiegneri loro dicono che con le leve non si puo fare il ruotismo pero quando lo vedono voglono sapere come e fatto ma non e possibile la rotazione e 1 a 1con le leve ce un attrezzo che non posso dire che ce ma non si vede PARTO con un motore di 1.5KW che fa 1400 giri che vengono ridotti a 40 che sono uguali in uscita che li moltiplico a1600 per fare funzionare un generatore che mi da 13KW che e anche piccolo per la potenza che sviluppa ( 1550KW circa a 40 giri ) a 1600 giri la potenza e di 39KW l attrezzo lo si puo vedere su UA-cam scrivendo MOLTIPLICATORE DI POTENZA
I understand that this apparently breaks a law, but can't we just think past that? I dont really think of it as a law, i kind of think of it as a theory, and in theory it shouldnt work but i think its possible for a perpetual motion machine
Peter actually, i remembered where i heard it, and it is in fact a Rube Goldberg quote. He was even referring to perpetual motion machines. I'm not saying you stole it, but you didn't make it up; You probably just heard it and forgot about it, and then thought you came up with it for this comment. If you want to see the video (it's excellent; Goldberg was hilarious and very intelligent) it's called "something for nothing". Another great perpetual motion video is the one that youtuber Physics Girl made. (She even included that Rube Goldberg quote in her video.) So, you didn't make up that quote, but it is from a really great video that you should watch if you like science, and debunking things like perpetual motion.
The law of conservation of energy is a law of science that states "energy cannot be created or destroyed, but only changed from one form into another or transferred from one object to another." so yeah create energy is impossible...it only change
+Orestas Vanagas NASA use of gravity assist is not an over unity machine. They are using the fact that planets have a different speed than the spacecraft. Every time a spacecraft uses gravity assist the speed of the planet around the sun goes down ever so slightly so a very small amount of the planets kinetic energy gets transferred to the spacecraft. Since this contraption is going the same speed and direction as the planet it is sitting on no energy can be transfered.
The hammers wheight a little more so they force the wheights to keep swinging, wich again gets the hammers lifting, wich again keeps the wheights swinging, and they Are conected to the wheel. Buuuut i would rather look for the motor
sono cose ingiegnose che dimostrano la capacita della persona pero sono inap plicabili il mio attrezzo composto da un gioco di leve (6) non ci sono nessun tipo di ruote ma solo leve dove ottengo una rotazione parto con un motore di 1.5KWche mi fa 1400 giri che vengono ridotti a 40 giri che sono uguali in uscita che collego un generatore che mi da 13KW questo lo si puo vedere si UA-cam scrivendo MOLTIPLICATORE DI POTENZA
секрет вращения сего творения заключается в моторчике на батарейках, спрятанном внутри колеса. Если автор хочет доказать обратное, пускай крафтит данную модель с прозрачным колесом.
I am convinced that the secret of the Bessler wheel is something that is right out in the open, staring everyone right in the face. That is the junction where the pendulum upright and crossbar meet. In the original drawings it cannot be determined whether or nor the pendulum assembly is connected to the bar that runs from the inner support to the outer support or not. I believe that the pendulum assembly is constructed to slide back and forth on said bar within the confines of the U shaped capture at the top of the assembly at the same time as the pendulum is swinging.
Nice job as always recreating these different inventions.
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
This channel is the best joke ever. Delivered with utter sincerity. I don't laugh externally, but inside I've lost my sides.
channels like this bother me. if you're going to pretend to be about science, explain why perpetual motion isn't possible, or at least be honest and explain how you made the machine appear to work. this is going to do nothing except misinform kids who are interested in science.
harvesting energy from gravity is possible even NASA proves it by doing en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_assist but to make some energy from gravity and collect it ... it needs very good understanding of physics and geometry
+Orestas Vanagas it takes motion from the earth The "assist" is provided by the motion of the gravitating body as it pulls on the spacecraft
mike Rempel so it's basically slingshot waiting to shot out something
take a look at finsrud's machine, it's the closest we can get to perpetual motion
Excellent reproduction! This design of his looks like a clock mechanism using pendulums to regulate/govern wheel speed , but obviously powered by the weight. Obviously when the weight reaches the floor, it will stop adding its energy to the system and it will all stop. It is unfortunate that this is the only wheel of his illustrated; not the 54+ days one. But it seems quite important, in a visually allegorical way. Certainly, it can be considered a window into the engineering mind of Bessler. At the very least I would interpret from this, that the energy which moves all his wheels moves through the weights, and is applied to the wheels rotation. Some say the hammering was made to mask the other noises so the hidden mechanisms could not be guessed. But I believe they were essential in transferring their acquired momentum to aid its rotation direction.
Jetzt hast du schon so ein tolles Rad gebaut. Jetzt wäre es noch super wenn du das Phänomen in dem Rad zeigen könntest z.B. durch eine Plexiglasscheibe.
Ich denke die Meisten kommen dann wieder mit Thermodynamik und Co aber wer sagt denn das der Mensch die Natur komplett verstanden hat?
For those who are interested: (hopefully this does not get deleted)
1. It's very suspicious that at from 0:34 onward, you cannot see the top of the wheel/machine.
1a. Notice the speed at what the hammers are being lifted and dropped.
1b. Notice at 1:04, the hammers are lifted and dropped at a slower rate, already. The wheel is spinning slower.
2. At 1:14 Again, I need to see the top of the wheel. It is very possible to have another wheel spinning the wheel on this machine..
3. At 1:46, you can see the top of the wheel to ensure no outside driving force. Too bad the clip stops at 1:56, the wheel was not spinning for long. This video should be A LOT longer, WITH a top view of the wheel to see "perpetual motion"
4. I will need to see what is inside of the wheel. It is possible to have a spring or string, winding mechanism of some sort.
5. Lastly, I will need to see underneath the table to make sure there are no electronics.
Thank you,
Neil R (EE)
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
This is an educational channel and all the replicas presented are motorized in no way they claimed any perpetual motion, they just show us how it would look if they worked.
los felicito por estos videos que ilustran
The Big Wheel is indeed the 'power source'.
Benjamin Franklin made a similar device, much smaller.
The large wheel was sealed up air-tight; the flat sides remain somewhat flexible while the circumference is made strongly.
As ambient air pressure changes throughout the day, the sides of the wheel are bent inward or outward.
This puts compression or tension on the axles of the Great Wheel.
One notes that this 'pumping action' of the axle is the motive force that drives the machine onward.
It runs, no doubt.
It is also externally powered.
Franklin's 'water-drop' electrical generator does indeed harvest 'free-energy' from the Air, all you have to do is keep filling it with water. Lifting water to fill the tank 'charges' it up!
The falling water-drops (gravity) provides all the energy needed to generate electricity.
Many examples of 'Ambient Engines' exist.
Daily changes in pressure, sunlight, air temperature and relative humidity have driven many other machines.
They work, but are a kind of 'parlor trick'.
Totaler Quatsch!! Sie unterstellen Betrug ! Das Rad funktioniert ähnlich wie eine Uhr, aber ohne von Federn aufgezogen worden zu sein! Das ist ganz große Mechanikerkunst und scheinbar außerhalb ihres mechanischen Verständnisses! Finden Sie sich damit ab, dass Ihr Wissen nicht ausreicht! Von allein kommt ein normaler Mensch nicht drauf!(Ging mir auch so!)
Always figured that he used some type of long term windup springs--or else it was real. Great model, interesting videos. I notice all of your models seem to "work". Maybe you are Bessler reincarnated!
but none of these models work tho all they do is misinform people good thing I had a teacher that thought me better
@@jhovanyurrea8898 Yeah well people are getting misinformed. If veproject1 had put something like, “Check my about page,” then they wouldn’t be misinformed.
@@edcdecl I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
So where can we see this scale model?
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
All these demos are motorized. This disclamer is at the end of his blog page veproject1.blogspot.ca/. "These Perpetual Motion Machines are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors."..." I'd like to inspire these people by demonstrating
Unworkable Perpetual Motion Machines that were designed centuries ago. "
Would gravity respond with bigger wheel and less weight?
If you check the last video that I posted on my channel, I'd say based on the description that he gave, that is it. I am continuing on with my project.
Fact: Using the word “machine” with perpetual motion or energy, will give it a beginning and an end, making it finite. With this new and better understanding of perpetual devices, its meaning will need updating in defining it as finite. This way, these devices or machines will not violate the laws of thermodynamics, laws of nature, laws of physics, makes them patentable. ~Guadalupe Guerra
Consider this...If you were to place the offset arms that are on the ends of the main axle at an equal 180 degrees and thus making the pendulums swing exactly opposite each other.Then make the upper pendulum pivots, into slides instead of a pivot, letting the whole pendulum slide from one end of the u shaped piece to the other, at the end of each swing.Would this create enough of a boost to the wheel to keep it going?Of course we will never know just what bessler had inside the actual wheel but I have given many hours of contemplation to the subject of this particular machine over the years and have thoughts that this might work.
+Bob Brueckner Sounds good. Build one and let us know!! I always figured he used wind up mechanism, but who knows.
Bravo gai understood how it works of which you have highlighted but that it works has all the elements to work that I know to make it run-
If there is no electric motor in this device, then this is driven by the bending moments induced by the weights on the pendulums, similar to a trebuchet, on each side.
much simple to have perpetual work, only blessing air at the weel
how does it work, surely in the 1700's there would be no way without a loud steam engine
+The best username I could come up with Maybe a fake pic or something? Or you push it one time and after a long time it stands.
The best username I could come up with Springs like in a watch
could have been pneumatic, they had compressed air rifles "around" that time. Lewis and clark used them in the early 1800s.
very nice !
That set up has a really large base to it. Big enough you could almost hide something in it like a motor and batteries perhaps
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
@@umbertobattaglia6321 conservation of energy? Yes I know it.
Where you buy this things? Please tell me
+Eduardomv Brenda These things are fake. Stupid
+Peter Fischer hey what is your problem i like this machines
Yea, he is a realy nice builder, but also a nice faker.
I don't hint he knows they're fake, but he still wants one because they look cool
Nice perpetual motion
A+
Yo creo que quien ha reproducido la máquina de Bessler, lo ha logrado: ahora bien, si es así, debiera percibir pequeñas anomalías de tiempo y gravitatorias, que pudieran sentirse por el operador -al mantenerse la máquina de PM un tiempo significativo funcionando. Ello le ocurrió a un inventor hace varias decenas de años (al cual tampoco le creyeron que el logro era auténtico). Su nombre : Paine.
@@umbertobattaglia6321 Well, I ask you, then...
@@arturovasquez9720 I found the key to how to turn a mechanical movement mechanism. I am sending you the various posts on messenger, if you then have some clarification write me on messanger ok
what's inside wheel?
+Michael Zajac a hamster and a carrot
Thanks for keep uploading these videos! They're very interesting and functional; maybe I built one of these machines for a scientific fair. Thanks. ;)
+Julián Jiménez they are cool, but you know they are all fake right?
Why do you say? I didn't see any motor or strange things. This machine makes perfect sense to me, the forces are equilibrated and I think that the people like you, the ones that just say that don't just the reasons. Can you just go fuck yourself?, please?
Julián Jiménez just try it and tell me later
+Julián Jiménez go take a physics lesson first
Julián Jiménez try it... you'll just cry in you're science fair..
Not quite attaining PM yet, but a beautifully crafted model.
I inform you to make yourself understood if you respect my principle to which I refer everything is possible, but first you must know it, certainly it is not the 2nd principle of thermodynamics, if you want to know it, ask.
Sajnos mind a mai napig senki sem tudta reprodukálni.Lehet,hogy régen is voltak csalók!?
I suspect there is an electromagnetic inside the base that somehow causes the wheel to rotate.
こういうので発電できますかね？
でもコスパ悪いよね。
+skm Tellu
仮にできたとしても
そういう問題じゃないよwww
non voglio declassare il sistema delle ruote perche il sitema rotatorio con le leve non e accettato dai ingiegneri loro dicono che con le leve non si puo fare il ruotismo pero quando lo vedono voglono sapere come e fatto ma non e possibile la rotazione e 1 a 1con le leve ce un attrezzo che non posso dire che ce ma non si vede PARTO con un motore di 1.5KW che fa 1400 giri che vengono ridotti a 40 che sono uguali in uscita che li moltiplico a1600 per fare funzionare un generatore che mi da 13KW che e anche piccolo per la potenza che sviluppa ( 1550KW circa a 40 giri ) a 1600 giri la potenza e di 39KW l attrezzo lo si puo vedere su UA-cam scrivendo MOLTIPLICATORE DI POTENZA
I understand that this apparently breaks a law, but can't we just think past that? I dont really think of it as a law, i kind of think of it as a theory, and in theory it shouldnt work but i think its possible for a perpetual motion machine
Wooow running for 54 days, that means you could charge your phone for 54 days with it.
No, you could hammer your phone 54 days with it...
But I am sure, not every hamster could last for 54 days!
at least hes being honest
Eu sou de onde vcs não imaginam 🙆
very simple machine. just as simple as you if you think it realy works ;p
i can't remember who this quote is from, but i love it.
(rube goldberg maybe?)
i made that up myself :D
Peter actually, i remembered where i heard it, and it is in fact a Rube Goldberg quote. He was even referring to perpetual motion machines. I'm not saying you stole it, but you didn't make it up; You probably just heard it and forgot about it, and then thought you came up with it for this comment. If you want to see the video (it's excellent; Goldberg was hilarious and very intelligent) it's called "something for nothing". Another great perpetual motion video is the one that youtuber Physics Girl made. (She even included that Rube Goldberg quote in her video.) So, you didn't make up that quote, but it is from a really great video that you should watch if you like science, and debunking things like perpetual motion.
+Calvin Lee oh yeah.. thats possible oft course. yeah phyiksgirl makes great videos!
Peter Her videos are definitely great! I love Physics Girl.
как это работает?
+Иван Пертов работает от батарейки, как и все остальные механизмы на этом канале.
esta muy bien que de fascinado.
The law of conservation of energy is a law of science that states
"energy cannot be created or destroyed, but only changed from one form into another or transferred from one object to another."
so yeah create energy is impossible...it only change
oh yeah if this machine work, it will accelerate infinitely
gravity is a force . it's a fact. you can collect it's energy by doing en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_assist
but you need input
+Orestas Vanagas NASA use of gravity assist is not an over unity machine. They are using the fact that planets have a different speed than the spacecraft. Every time a spacecraft uses gravity assist the speed of the planet around the sun goes down ever so slightly so a very small amount of the planets kinetic energy gets transferred to the spacecraft. Since this contraption is going the same speed and direction as the planet it is sitting on no energy can be transfered.
well yes, but aren't all atoms basically "perpetual motion" machines, essentially? Don't they all "move forever"?
@@orestasvanagas9572 But what is a 'force' ?
Better ask Leonardo Da Vinci.
Ok someone smarter than me explain how this works please.
The hammers wheight a little more so they force the wheights to keep swinging, wich again
gets the hammers lifting, wich again keeps the wheights swinging, and they Are conected to the wheel.
Buuuut i would rather look for the motor
Wikipedia resonance.
(if not wrong)
It doesn't lol.
das hasguns it doesn't... because it's fake Orr maybe it has some hidden power source...
ProShooter orr? (not the the problem that is has two r`s, but rather, that it need to be "because"
Another bluff
+Blue Sky This ain't no bluff!
sono cose ingiegnose che dimostrano la capacita della persona pero sono inap plicabili il mio attrezzo composto da un gioco di leve (6) non ci sono nessun tipo di ruote ma solo leve dove ottengo una rotazione parto con un motore di 1.5KWche mi fa 1400 giri che vengono ridotti a 40 giri che sono uguali in uscita che collego un generatore che mi da 13KW questo lo si puo vedere si UA-cam scrivendo MOLTIPLICATORE DI POTENZA
Что это такое и принцип не ясен.
5st.
I m fed up of this channel.. He never explains anything... So weird
奇怪了,人類麼可能在天上飛?所以飛機出現了!!
секрет вращения сего творения заключается в моторчике на батарейках, спрятанном внутри колеса. Если автор хочет доказать обратное, пускай крафтит данную модель с прозрачным колесом.
fake
fake hide motor
Perpetual motion machines are impossible. Period.
with current understanding of geometry the anwser is : no
They are possible if we can create a super lubricant
+William The Beast toroidal magnets
@JamesonCrate but until they lose it... it can be used for a while? can it?
fake
fake