Great job!! Really like the pop-up packs. I use the 18 most of the season, and switch to the 38 when I need the layers. Keep my predator platform on the outside and stick my boot blankets in the load shelf, it I want em I got em, if not, they take up no space. Had the same issue with digging deep in the 38, so I just stuff a layer I'll never use to fill the space on the bottom. I live in Alberta, so by the time it gets that cold for the layers, bulk & weight pretty much goes out the window!
@@TheBudgetSportsman Good to hear! I self film and saddle hunt too, but climb using ropes (DRT) and wanted something with easy access to without digging through the bag. Anyways, Awesome review!
They seem to be a big name for western hunters. Randy Newberg is one of their brand ambassadors. I’m normally not one to go for the “premium” products but my old Walmart backpack was at its end of its life. Between saddle hunting on public land last year and an out of state hunt this year that HOPEFULLY will require me to haul out a very large quarter of meat, this pack seemed like the right fit for me.
Awesome! I heard you mention the out of state hunt a while ago! Definitely excited to follow along with you....you will be taking the cameras won’t you???
Just received my MR PU28, purchased specifically for saddle hunting in the NE. Love the ability to put sticks/platform in the load shelf area. I also ordered some accessory straps from MR to be able to strap my bow onto the outside of the pack, for hands free hiking, when bombing a long way from the truck. The 38 would be nice to pack a set of bibs in for late season cold weather hunting but, figure I may be able to pack that layer in the shelf area, as well, to avoid being soaked in sweat on arrival to my tree. We’ll see.
Yes, that’s what I did this year...packed bibs and extra layers in the shelf on the 28. Let me know how the accessory straps work for holding your bow. I’ve considered doing the same.
It’s usually up close to 35 lbs. 14lbs - saddle, ropes, platform, sticks 12lbs - camera gear Plus the weight of the backpack puts you over 30. Then the odds and ends like water snacks, kill kit, first aid kit…all add a couple more pounds. It definitely sounds like a lot when everyone is trying to cut weight but the pack handles it well and I’m way more comfortable and mobile then I have ever been with a climber or hang on.
Great review. I'm new to saddle hunting... do you climb with the pack on your back, taking 1 stick out at a time as you go? And, if so, are they pretty easy to pull out while wearing the pack?
I'm interested in the MR Pop Up 38 but you keep talking about "Saddle Hunting". Saddle Hunting in Montana is "off your horse"- from the saddle, usually elk hunting. I am wondering if you're wearing the pack , does it interfere with the cantle (back of your saddle) while riding? Wish it had more pockets. Thanks and good video
My apologies, I am not referring to saddle hunting from a horse. Here on the east coast it is popular to hunt from a tree saddle much like an arborist would use. I’m not much help when it comes to any hunting involving a horse, though I would love to have that experience.
@@TheBudgetSportsman I’ve never looked up the price on them. I don’t mind paying a little more for good quality that’s going to last and save money in the long run. 👍
These bags don’t seem to have enough pockets. Everything has to be planned out because your stacking everything on top of things. Is the pack waterproof or do you need to carry a rain cover for it?
Are you still using these packs for saddle hunting or have you moved on to something else? Looking at the eberlestock x2 or one of the trophyline packs. Thanks!
The standoffs are a little wider and they don’t pack quite as well in the same configuration. I’ve been putting them crossways in the bottom of the load shelf. The “posts” are in the bottom of the shelf and the standoffs are sticking out in either side. The down side is that you are definitely a wider load and can hang up a little easier.
I just got pop up 28 last week I really love it I had a trophyline C.A.Y.S backpack it had a lot go good features but without a frame back your gets sour. My back doesn't get sour anymore it's a huge difference. This backpack makes you more mobile with ability to quarter out a deer up to 80lbs is a game changer. From my research a lot easier than a deer cart.
Hi there thanks for the nice video , great review . Listen i have a question , i mobile hunter , i use the lonewolf alpha stand with lonewolf e steps sticks. I was wondering if I can attach the frame to my stand. Is the bag detached from the frame ? Thanks so much
Yes it is possible to completely remove the bag from the frame. Mystery Ranch also makes some different style of frames that you may be able to purchase without a bag.
You are spot on Nate with your assessment of these two packs, the bigger brother 38 and the smaller sibling 28. The Pop up 28 would be perfect 👌 for day hunts, perhaps an overnight, while the 38 would be great for a 3 or 4 day backcountry backpack style hunt out west. Not sure if that out of state tag is such a hunt out west or to the Midwest for big whitetail like Iowa? For me I am looking for a pack that I can day hunt, bring some saddle gear, maybe an extra layer depending upon the time of year. Plus I want to be able to use the meat 🍖 shelf to take a whitetail quartered out of some deep and steep places in West Virginia. Plus do multiple 1-3 day backcountry trips out west staying mobile for a week to 10 days. So the Pop up 38 might be better for me. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on these two packs. My dilemma would be one kind of do all compromise pack or two packs that are better suited for each type hunt.
I think the 28 is a great day pack but might be too small for overnights and the 38 is great for short overnights but wouldn’t be good for those 10 day hunts. I think I would go for a pop up for day hunts and a larger MR pack for the longer hunts.
@@TheBudgetSportsman I definitely agree with you 100%. If I went with the 38 I would be limited as you mentioned to about 3 days then have to head back to the truck to restock and possibly move areas and stay mobile. If I wanted to stay longer I would have to run the Metcalf, Marshall or Beartooth. I will get the smaller pack for now since I mostly will be using it for day hunts, saddle hunting and if I get to go pronghorn hunting. Then keep an eye out for sales on a larger pack later on for any longer hunts. Thank you again for your thoughts and advice
If you are asking about my entire saddle hunting setup with the backpack in was 33-35 pounds. If you are on Facebook, you can check out this post about the individual weights. I believe I even posted a spreadsheet breakdown of the weight in the comments. facebook.com/photo?fbid=10220266628109237&set=basw.Abq6wq3rflnnEK2Ff_gMy1VroeDZ0g5psewcfTKJPEKGhiWpOecOKYQgPFbIEvUZjc06Y3KbiUjOCaAkKNRztX8oRDuHdr7kqAyM6R8H2mdHW8N2YIVSeuaTkocxZ28Lw7kjby1Q09E5D31weFEPpgZJ&opaqueCursor=AbosAXwXRd8RUiZVjIs8maKzX6Z67M2w_YV7c-P4Z-qpp_SxltPZ8XuYWFoOper7v3YDsX0BCcYJNvbpesSaiuqvV_bvU-BPuABP7IfCHy0rUSjvwxkg1vNVDXOGyFPlDrQJKJcuiwQ0gAnoRlyHy2Ydzdzviblat5PjP0MsJi47JAboq594UrMASZ97ePT9QtSFm17qQ7HYWHt99Z69kGj9xKMnJQeE-OoLIUItqe3sY4PQZbdS3Vvf6hzmofW6TlnwD_jiYW3J5eC1u_oD4ddNuNN-yacHvYok_bvazk-Y_rsZhA5tWTHRMh0MHs_9Iytr_VrG2QXMo9LaFNXKyNbz3O27pHntgsbt80up3VmyHAs4BqbdFeTRx5zR4AG7vTjBeQuh0vLsVNYWG_qAVAhBfcIK1PXpyxmcxAvaLbrtTHmkpWAZzux3QyvZNuutu8EcnX_cJZwsItzmY9tvmihDoO9dchcDAgszuVI-uzwYVg60dqQfEwjt7ImtRgQSgHMOycBePdkaXyh-_MZJG_xrUiUZUB7VkYVb4TS-Xn5wrJMAr5j3JynaD67F52PUbu6S11keO9yfURl642hgHvnacByiV_J4o8iSt-CyRRmCkhMpwTRZ9E-WCBbI-bVeP9I3JFPd3yvk4523T4SCj3FYugY9lRT8XmRpvW7NaNuQSsVBxY5G1xvWGUMHOLm04OWK99DYlOpNfnSUec8XHHud4oMEzmOWnRKU0K8_ewtIl-KW5dyIv32eNfB4qergNBUV37agFPuDS76PFcs6VaxV
I just ordered a Pop-up 38. Gearing up for my first hunt out west this year.
Nice. Good luck out west. I went for the first time last fall.
Great job!! Really like the pop-up packs. I use the 18 most of the season, and switch to the 38 when I need the layers. Keep my predator platform on the outside and stick my boot blankets in the load shelf, it I want em I got em, if not, they take up no space. Had the same issue with digging deep in the 38, so I just stuff a layer I'll never use to fill the space on the bottom. I live in Alberta, so by the time it gets that cold for the layers, bulk & weight pretty much goes out the window!
Still living my MR packs. Thanks for watching.
Just picked one up for $200 and after
Watching this video I can’t wait to get
My hands on it! Awesome review
Nice! That’s a great price. I’m sure you will enjoy it!
Just bought the 28 for the same reasons. Looking forward to putting it to work!
I’ve been loving mine!
@@TheBudgetSportsman Good to hear! I self film and saddle hunt too, but climb using ropes (DRT) and wanted something with easy access to without digging through the bag. Anyways, Awesome review!
Good review Nate. I must live under a rock...first time I’ve ever heard of Mystery Ranch! 😮 Definitely looks like some premium options!! 👍
They seem to be a big name for western hunters. Randy Newberg is one of their brand ambassadors.
I’m normally not one to go for the “premium” products but my old Walmart backpack was at its end of its life. Between saddle hunting on public land last year and an out of state hunt this year that HOPEFULLY will require me to haul out a very large quarter of meat, this pack seemed like the right fit for me.
Awesome! I heard you mention the out of state hunt a while ago! Definitely excited to follow along with you....you will be taking the cameras won’t you???
I wouldn’t leave home without the cameras. I have to figure out how to film from ground rather than in a tree.
I’m excited for ya!! 👍
Just received my MR PU28, purchased specifically for saddle hunting in the NE. Love the ability to put sticks/platform in the load shelf area. I also ordered some accessory straps from MR to be able to strap my bow onto the outside of the pack, for hands free hiking, when bombing a long way from the truck. The 38 would be nice to pack a set of bibs in for late season cold weather hunting but, figure I may be able to pack that layer in the shelf area, as well, to avoid being soaked in sweat on arrival to my tree. We’ll see.
Yes, that’s what I did this year...packed bibs and extra layers in the shelf on the 28.
Let me know how the accessory straps work for holding your bow. I’ve considered doing the same.
Definitely going with the 38 for my bugout bag
I think you’re going to enjoy it. I certainly do.
I've been looking at these and the Treehouse. Haven't made a decision yet, but appreciate the comparison!
Hope it helps you make the right decision.
GREAT video highlighting the differences between these two packs! Really helps!
Thank you Jarrod. I’m glad you found it helpful!
Just ordered my pop up 28. Super excited
I love mine! I hope you enjoy yours as well!
Great review!! Just wish they had more camo options.
That would be nice
This is a solid review, thank you! Subbed
Thanks for the sun!
Great video. What is your total pack weight for your typical filmed hunt out of your 28?
It’s usually up close to 35 lbs.
14lbs - saddle, ropes, platform, sticks
12lbs - camera gear
Plus the weight of the backpack puts you over 30. Then the odds and ends like water snacks, kill kit, first aid kit…all add a couple more pounds.
It definitely sounds like a lot when everyone is trying to cut weight but the pack handles it well and I’m way more comfortable and mobile then I have ever been with a climber or hang on.
Great review. I'm new to saddle hunting... do you climb with the pack on your back, taking 1 stick out at a time as you go? And, if so, are they pretty easy to pull out while wearing the pack?
I just watched your video that answered this question.
I'm interested in the MR Pop Up 38 but you keep talking about "Saddle Hunting". Saddle Hunting in Montana is "off your horse"- from the saddle, usually elk hunting. I am wondering if you're wearing the pack , does it interfere with the cantle (back of your saddle) while riding? Wish it had more pockets. Thanks and good video
My apologies, I am not referring to saddle hunting from a horse. Here on the east coast it is popular to hunt from a tree saddle much like an arborist would use. I’m not much help when it comes to any hunting involving a horse, though I would love to have that experience.
Good review. I’ve not heard much about these packs.
I feel strange even recommending an expensive pack, but so far I’ve found them to her very well built, comfortable and versatile.
@@TheBudgetSportsman I’ve never looked up the price on them. I don’t mind paying a little more for good quality that’s going to last and save money in the long run. 👍
These bags don’t seem to have enough pockets. Everything has to be planned out because your stacking everything on top of things.
Is the pack waterproof or do you need to carry a rain cover for it?
Are you still using these packs for saddle hunting or have you moved on to something else? Looking at the eberlestock x2 or one of the trophyline packs. Thanks!
I’m still using them. I use primarily the 28.
I was wondering how you pack your backpack if you use the skeletor sticks?
The standoffs are a little wider and they don’t pack quite as well in the same configuration. I’ve been putting them crossways in the bottom of the load shelf. The “posts” are in the bottom of the shelf and the standoffs are sticking out in either side. The down side is that you are definitely a wider load and can hang up a little easier.
Yeah, I'm never dropping that much on a backpack. Good review, if you or others can afford it, great! Itll certainly last!
I certainly understand that sentiment. Thanks for watching anyways.
@@TheBudgetSportsman wouldn't missed it, love watching your channel.
I just got pop up 28 last week I really love it I had a trophyline C.A.Y.S backpack it had a lot go good features but without a frame back your gets sour. My back doesn't get sour anymore it's a huge difference. This backpack makes you more mobile with ability to quarter out a deer up to 80lbs is a game changer. From my research a lot easier than a deer cart.
The frame really makes all the difference.
Hi there thanks for the nice video , great review . Listen i have a question , i mobile hunter , i use the lonewolf alpha stand with lonewolf e steps sticks. I was wondering if I can attach the frame to my stand. Is the bag detached from the frame ? Thanks so much
Yes it is possible to completely remove the bag from the frame. Mystery Ranch also makes some different style of frames that you may be able to purchase without a bag.
@@TheBudgetSportsman thanks so much for the reply, god bless you.
You are spot on Nate with your assessment of these two packs, the bigger brother 38 and the smaller sibling 28. The Pop up 28 would be perfect 👌 for day hunts, perhaps an overnight, while the 38 would be great for a 3 or 4 day backcountry backpack style hunt out west. Not sure if that out of state tag is such a hunt out west or to the Midwest for big whitetail like Iowa?
For me I am looking for a pack that I can day hunt, bring some saddle gear, maybe an extra layer depending upon the time of year. Plus I want to be able to use the meat 🍖 shelf to take a whitetail quartered out of some deep and steep places in West Virginia. Plus do multiple 1-3 day backcountry trips out west staying mobile for a week to 10 days. So the Pop up 38 might be better for me.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on these two packs. My dilemma would be one kind of do all compromise pack or two packs that are better suited for each type hunt.
I think the 28 is a great day pack but might be too small for overnights and the 38 is great for short overnights but wouldn’t be good for those 10 day hunts. I think I would go for a pop up for day hunts and a larger MR pack for the longer hunts.
@@TheBudgetSportsman I definitely agree with you 100%. If I went with the 38 I would be limited as you mentioned to about 3 days then have to head back to the truck to restock and possibly move areas and stay mobile. If I wanted to stay longer I would have to run the Metcalf, Marshall or Beartooth. I will get the smaller pack for now since I mostly will be using it for day hunts, saddle hunting and if I get to go pronghorn hunting. Then keep an eye out for sales on a larger pack later on for any longer hunts. Thank you again for your thoughts and advice
Cool video! Just subscribed
Do you know about how much your pop up 28 setup weighed?
If you are asking about my entire saddle hunting setup with the backpack in was 33-35 pounds. If you are on Facebook, you can check out this post about the individual weights. I believe I even posted a spreadsheet breakdown of the weight in the comments.
facebook.com/photo?fbid=10220266628109237&set=basw.Abq6wq3rflnnEK2Ff_gMy1VroeDZ0g5psewcfTKJPEKGhiWpOecOKYQgPFbIEvUZjc06Y3KbiUjOCaAkKNRztX8oRDuHdr7kqAyM6R8H2mdHW8N2YIVSeuaTkocxZ28Lw7kjby1Q09E5D31weFEPpgZJ&opaqueCursor=AbosAXwXRd8RUiZVjIs8maKzX6Z67M2w_YV7c-P4Z-qpp_SxltPZ8XuYWFoOper7v3YDsX0BCcYJNvbpesSaiuqvV_bvU-BPuABP7IfCHy0rUSjvwxkg1vNVDXOGyFPlDrQJKJcuiwQ0gAnoRlyHy2Ydzdzviblat5PjP0MsJi47JAboq594UrMASZ97ePT9QtSFm17qQ7HYWHt99Z69kGj9xKMnJQeE-OoLIUItqe3sY4PQZbdS3Vvf6hzmofW6TlnwD_jiYW3J5eC1u_oD4ddNuNN-yacHvYok_bvazk-Y_rsZhA5tWTHRMh0MHs_9Iytr_VrG2QXMo9LaFNXKyNbz3O27pHntgsbt80up3VmyHAs4BqbdFeTRx5zR4AG7vTjBeQuh0vLsVNYWG_qAVAhBfcIK1PXpyxmcxAvaLbrtTHmkpWAZzux3QyvZNuutu8EcnX_cJZwsItzmY9tvmihDoO9dchcDAgszuVI-uzwYVg60dqQfEwjt7ImtRgQSgHMOycBePdkaXyh-_MZJG_xrUiUZUB7VkYVb4TS-Xn5wrJMAr5j3JynaD67F52PUbu6S11keO9yfURl642hgHvnacByiV_J4o8iSt-CyRRmCkhMpwTRZ9E-WCBbI-bVeP9I3JFPd3yvk4523T4SCj3FYugY9lRT8XmRpvW7NaNuQSsVBxY5G1xvWGUMHOLm04OWK99DYlOpNfnSUec8XHHud4oMEzmOWnRKU0K8_ewtIl-KW5dyIv32eNfB4qergNBUV37agFPuDS76PFcs6VaxV
Awesome thanks!
No problem!