thanks for a wonderful talk. About 44 minutes in they assert that it will not be possible to prevent proliferation of AI technology, but it's not clear to me why they think that. In his book Chip War, Chris Miller explains that all AI depends on advanced microchips and all advanced microchips depend on an extremely complex and expensive manufacturing process combined with rare technical expertise. If a state restricts the sale of the microchips and the machine tools and classifies the technical know-how then why wouldn't they be able to prevent, or at least slow, proliferation? They just explained in the preceding minutes that nuclear non-proliferation efforts have had some considerable success. Isn't that an important part of how nuclear non-proliferation success was achieved?
Newton's Laws + Special Relativity = History ⇆ Human Psychology #Manifestation "The gentlest, most reasonable man may, if he wears a large moustache, sit as it were in its shade and feel safe."
Well my eyes have been prised open. What, as a relatively powerless citizen, can I do? Maybe I'm one of the lucky ones benefitting from a large measure of personal freedom. Is that freedom to disappear? How about democracy, democratic processes, coming down to street level, to personal contact with our representatives, and not just for elections? Is there a model for that? How about snail mail filtering out the lies?
All I hear from these fellows is thinly veiled glee at the prospect of being masters of the universe, disguised as an urge to save humanity from a death spiral of destruction. As my favorite social critic H.L. Mencken once wrote: "The urge to save humanity is almost always only a false-face for the urge to rule it. Power is what all messiahs really seek: not the chance to serve"
Keep private sector out of govt n governance out. The incentives do not align. Don’t agree with Mustafa on this one. Live example- 2008 financial crisis shows the Value’ (or rather abuse) of including industry actors in governance and regulatory/govt. decision-making (aka- Henry Paulson and Co.). 2023, His ‘expertise’ (or lack of right decisions) are evident in the windfall govt largesse to bankers and banking sector- at expense of every other sector, human development….etc etc. Now it is a much entangled mess and Govt. cannot figure it out.
Excellent summary of the issues and the urgency of addressing them.
thanks for a wonderful talk. About 44 minutes in they assert that it will not be possible to prevent proliferation of AI technology, but it's not clear to me why they think that. In his book Chip War, Chris Miller explains that all AI depends on advanced microchips and all advanced microchips depend on an extremely complex and expensive manufacturing process combined with rare technical expertise. If a state restricts the sale of the microchips and the machine tools and classifies the technical know-how then why wouldn't they be able to prevent, or at least slow, proliferation? They just explained in the preceding minutes that nuclear non-proliferation efforts have had some considerable success. Isn't that an important part of how nuclear non-proliferation success was achieved?
Newton's Laws + Special Relativity = History ⇆ Human Psychology #Manifestation
"The gentlest, most reasonable man may, if he wears a large moustache, sit as it were in its shade and feel safe."
What???
Fascinating discussion. Thank you!
Well my eyes have been prised open. What, as a relatively powerless citizen, can I do? Maybe I'm one of the lucky ones benefitting from a large measure of personal freedom. Is that freedom to disappear? How about democracy, democratic processes, coming down to street level, to personal contact with our representatives, and not just for elections? Is there a model for that? How about snail mail filtering out the lies?
I have this issue but haven't read it yet. So this is great.
Very interesting discussion, much to think about!
All I hear from these fellows is thinly veiled glee at the prospect of being masters of the universe, disguised as an urge to save humanity from a death spiral of destruction. As my favorite social critic H.L. Mencken once wrote: "The urge to save humanity is almost always only a false-face for the urge to rule it. Power is what all messiahs really seek: not the chance to serve"
interesting on the tech side, naive (i.e liberal naivety) on the political and thus also on the geopolitical side
Keep private sector out of govt n governance out. The incentives do not align. Don’t agree with Mustafa on this one. Live example- 2008 financial crisis shows the Value’ (or rather abuse) of including industry actors in governance and regulatory/govt. decision-making (aka- Henry Paulson and Co.). 2023, His ‘expertise’ (or lack of right decisions) are evident in the windfall govt largesse to bankers and banking sector- at expense of every other sector, human development….etc etc. Now it is a much entangled mess and Govt. cannot figure it out.