This version of Luna's song makes since. We know that she was banished to the moon as Nightmare Moon, so I believe that the time she spent there was full if anger and hate, not the sadness and regret that most sing. Absolutely beautiful.
I feel like both make sense to me, with each version coming from a different aspect of Luna. The darker, anguished version from the nightmare side, and the sweeter sadder version from the more innocent Luna from beneath the armour.
@@ElfMaidWithInternet in my head cannon Luna sings her soliloquy when the pain of her banishment is still fresh. However, even in her soliloquy Luna has the line at the end "My pain grows, I can't know, are you still the same?" to me that sounds like she is holding onto her anger so she doesn't need to face her shame. Her reply on the other hand is sung in the later years of her banishment, when she fully accepts that what she did was wrong.
On one side is Celestia ,who blames herself for Luna’s banishment and wants to see her again, and on the other side is Luna ,who tries to ignore the fact that she still cares for Celestia and is controlled by rage and jealousy. I love how these two are mixed.
the reason why Luna's voice is like that because she is the princess of the night, her voice need to be dark, deep and majestic while Celestia is Bright/day high. Luna's voice sounds beautiful to me, Luna's voice is just how it is because she is the night princess 👸
Its been years but im back to these vids, i still love how Luna's part still includes "and carry my sorrow in kind" while the rest is like PERFECTLY bittersweet, that one line is their common ground
This needs to be in an episode in season 5, where Celestia and Luna were remembering when Luna was still banished. It might give Celestia a better image, plus help us to see the events that happened from Luna's banishment to her release. It needs to happen. HASBRO, NOW!
Your are right the most of us think she has banished her sister and okay she is not there but i want to see whats happend while luna was in the moon how celestia missed her or the past of the 2 how its happened that luna was so angry and not so oh they sleep on the wonderfoul night of her maybe it was a bigger think or are they more alicorns ore the parents of the 2
the reason Lunas voice is how it is, is because she's Luna. She's the princess of the night, her voice is meant to sound shallow, deeper and dark for affect. It's for character, while Celestia is the princess of the sun/ day, bright, high and majestic.
J-J-J-Just B-B-B-Be G-G-Glad Your Not S-S-S-SAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Crying with 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999SAD99999999999999999999999SO999999999999999999999999SAD9999999999999 Empty Tissue Boxes Around Me*
God, it's been 6 years since this video was released and I still remember perfectly the emotion I felt when I heard it, it always ended up moving me lol
U N K N O W N After catching so many parodies and spoofs, I eventually caved and started bingeing just to see what the fuss was all about. Gotta say, it's not bad. Good storytelling, character development. Kinda cheesy at points but it's directed towards a younger demographic, so what can you expect? But this song is probably the best thing that I've found related to the show. Keep it on repeat at times when I just wanna feel something. 😅
Celestia: surely there is no pony so lovely and so beloved as I. Me: Jesus you're full of yourself. Jk I love you both. I know that was when you were young and foolish.
ok the lullaby was great, I haven't heard the soliloquy before now. You add the soliloquy to the lullaby as a duet and I almost cried... its just so sad and compelling. You really feel for the sisters with their pain and sorrow. I so wish could get a recording of this duet.
I think hasbro need to make a comeback for us who adults we need a really story for this man. I need to see the turn of neglect, jealousy, anguish, how the villains they fought played apart in their relationships demise and more into the elements/ celestia managing to use the elements without Luna. Matter a fact Luna needs her own movie. But from hasbro’s drawing style, original voice actors and perspective etc. not some Netflix or Disney remake. Like legitimate hasbro. I’d cry bro
Luna...u are amazing and sensitive and your night is amazing most people don't appreciate how wonderful your night can be because they are asleep through it but you had a point and you are so much more loved than you know. Forgive us for being so blind! :')
When I'm listening to Luna, what I hear is her fighting with herself, I hear anger, but at the same time I hear forgiveness I know that's probably not what the true song ment, but I like my idea because I can relate to Luna so much
Its actually so sad how they ended the series but I can't blame them I mean the series carried on for how long, like if we count the very very old version almost like twelve-ish years(please correct me if I'm wrong with the years etc XD.).
Durp Dawg You got in reversed. Luna's Soliloquy is closer to canon as she was still Nightmare Moon at the time this song takes place (during her banishment)
Sir Aroun when luna just got in the moon prison she said should not did that. Then thousands of years luna wanted to get out and when she got out she hated Celestia more.
As everyone before me I agree that this is the most beautiful song that I have heard. Both people should have been given an award for great singing and lyrics. But most credit goes to Ponyphonic for being the first to make most of these songs. Not sure if Luna's reply and Luna's soliloquy were created by Ponyphonic since i can't find the vid for it on his/her account. Nonetheless, great duet involving the corrupted Luna' reply. And the other by Celestia. Least you have Lyrics.
I really like this. I've seen other versions for Lunas reply and they are saying that she's sorry but in the show she came back as Nightmare Moon so she was probably Nightmare on the moon too so she probably wasn't sorry but in this she's still annoyed with what Tia did.
Then why did when Luna was back to her normal self she said in tears; "I'm so sorry! I missed you so much, big sister!" I guess when Luna was Nightmare Moon, she was balancing her evil side and her normal self.
+Queen Jinx Koopa It's because she was no longer Nightmare Moon. Because she no longer had the jealousy against her sister. And maybe though Luna became Nightmare Moon she was still able to see what she was doing but had no control .
It's good but the person who was singing for Luna was...well off key and the lyrics are for higher pitch, you can tell when the girl voicing Luna starts to sing higher towards the middle it sounds better.
When I made the video, the black bars on top and bottom were a mistake, but they worked perfectly for this. Some of the lyrics were wrong but otherwise very well done.
![Aurelleah - Midnight Lament [Feat. ButterflyIdentity & Decibelle] [Orchestral Aria]](/img/n.gif)
The people who wrote this should get awards for singing and songwriting, seriously, it's brilliant.
Couldn't agree more.
Leona Midnight YEAH THATS TRUE
Gladius Gaming Why?
IKR
This version of Luna's song makes since. We know that she was banished to the moon as Nightmare Moon, so I believe that the time she spent there was full if anger and hate, not the sadness and regret that most sing. Absolutely beautiful.
I would give this another like, but I don’t want to ruin the meme
I feel like both make sense to me, with each version coming from a different aspect of Luna. The darker, anguished version from the nightmare side, and the sweeter sadder version from the more innocent Luna from beneath the armour.
@@ElfMaidWithInternet in my head cannon Luna sings her soliloquy when the pain of her banishment is still fresh. However, even in her soliloquy Luna has the line at the end "My pain grows, I can't know, are you still the same?" to me that sounds like she is holding onto her anger so she doesn't need to face her shame. Her reply on the other hand is sung in the later years of her banishment, when she fully accepts that what she did was wrong.
On one side is Celestia ,who blames herself for Luna’s banishment and wants to see her again, and on the other side is Luna ,who tries to ignore the fact that she still cares for Celestia and is controlled by rage and jealousy. I love how these two are mixed.
the reason why Luna's voice is like that because she is the princess of the night, her voice need to be dark, deep and majestic while Celestia is Bright/day high. Luna's voice sounds beautiful to me, Luna's voice is just how it is because she is the night princess 👸
Yeah 🤣
•Princess Twilight Sparkle• But Luna has a bright tone and Celestia's tone is richer so...
•Princess Twilight Sparkle• bruh...really....HOW THE BLOODY HELL TO GET THE VOICE CHARACTER LUNA DUDE!!!!!!
i think it sounds awsome tbh
•Princess Twilight Sparkle• I didn't even notice that her voice was low
Its been years but im back to these vids, i still love how Luna's part still includes "and carry my sorrow in kind" while the rest is like PERFECTLY bittersweet, that one line is their common ground
I cannot stop to shed some tears to this perfect presentation on both Celestia's and Lunas past.
This needs to be in an episode in season 5, where Celestia and Luna were remembering when Luna was still banished. It might give Celestia a better image, plus help us to see the events that happened from Luna's banishment to her release. It needs to happen. HASBRO, NOW!
Your are right the most of us think she has banished her sister and okay she is not there but i want to see whats happend while luna was in the moon how celestia missed her or the past of the 2 how its happened that luna was so angry and not so oh they sleep on the wonderfoul night of her maybe it was a bigger think or are they more alicorns ore the parents of the 2
Anyone else agree but me
Hello Brony for from 6 years! Just saying that MLP has... ended. I like your idea and got sad that it never got in the show-
the reason Lunas voice is how it is, is because she's Luna. She's the princess of the night, her voice is meant to sound shallow, deeper and dark for affect. It's for character, while Celestia is the princess of the sun/ day, bright, high and majestic.
ikr
I think I saw you in the shelter 2 soundtrack?
The Fandom fan club me? o3o
Yes
:3
I listen to this before I fall asleep xD is that just me?
nope, me too
I mean, it is titled a Lullaby for a reason. cx
I do it to
no
No it's not just you... If I don't listen ratio it, I can't sleep...
I just keep on listening to this song
MAKE IT STOP!!!!
J-J-J-Just B-B-B-Be G-G-Glad Your Not S-S-S-SAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Crying with 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999SAD99999999999999999999999SO999999999999999999999999SAD9999999999999 Empty Tissue Boxes Around Me*
you want another box
Valerie Gago
N-No.... Woman at the store:Mister,where are all the tissues? Employee:Uh,She Bought Them,
o okay
Valerie Gago
just be glad you don;t know about the song "What you know" by Two Door Cinema Club,It's Catchy ;~;
Even 6 years later...this song is always so endlessly beautiful and i still cry at the chorus towards the end...
God, it's been 6 years since this video was released and I still remember perfectly the emotion I felt when I heard it, it always ended up moving me lol
It's a duet! I love it!! Great voice who sang it!
I have never really been a big fan of MLP, but I have to say this is one of the most moving peices of music I have everheard
100% true
been what? 3 years, and no sequel? make one or I die XP
"for the time of my vengeance is nigh!!!!!!!!"
I love that part!!!!!😄
😈🌌
I LOVE this version of the duet because when people over-lap the two, it just sounds....uggghhhh...... so I like when they are separate like this :P
This is, so far, the best representation of Luna during her banishment I have seen (or heard, as the case is). Well done.
I havent even watched a single episode of mlp but here I am.. Love it tho
U N K N O W N
After catching so many parodies and spoofs, I eventually caved and started bingeing just to see what the fuss was all about.
Gotta say, it's not bad. Good storytelling, character development. Kinda cheesy at points but it's directed towards a younger demographic, so what can you expect?
But this song is probably the best thing that I've found related to the show. Keep it on repeat at times when I just wanna feel something. 😅
Celestia: surely there is no pony so lovely and so beloved as I.
Me: Jesus you're full of yourself. Jk I love you both. I know that was when you were young and foolish.
ok the lullaby was great, I haven't heard the soliloquy before now. You add the soliloquy to the lullaby as a duet and I almost cried... its just so sad and compelling. You really feel for the sisters with their pain and sorrow. I so wish could get a recording of this duet.
two words, one great app audio pocket
LUNA IS BEST PRINCESS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ikr
Yas
Yes never underestimate the power of the night
Switch some pronouns around and this actually feels VERY Thor and Loki.
Winston_Graham yesss I feel it
Yea...i just realize that...
VERY
*YESSSSS*
100th like TwT
Who is still listening to this in 2019
Lol just me ok
Im listening to it in 2020 aka the worst year
Raya Raptor facts
2021
@@rayaraptor3611 it's not
@@oofylover4221 it really is though
That is very moving. I have to get a tissue now.
*Gives a tissue*
Gweneth Cole (Uses it.) Thank you Gweneth Cole
*hugs* You okay now?
Gweneth Cole Yeah. Thanks again.
I think hasbro need to make a comeback for us who adults we need a really story for this man. I need to see the turn of neglect, jealousy, anguish, how the villains they fought played apart in their relationships demise and more into the elements/ celestia managing to use the elements without Luna. Matter a fact Luna needs her own movie. But from hasbro’s drawing style, original voice actors and perspective etc. not some Netflix or Disney remake. Like legitimate hasbro. I’d cry bro
oh wow! I just can't stop listening to it. It's beautiful :3
I love it! It must've took a lot of time to think about the lyrics and editing! Congratulations you earned a like! ^-^
The creator of the lyric ua-cam.com/video/KyfrP7AInds/v-deo.html
I did the effect of lyric
beautiful effects and beautiful background to go with such a beautiful song im in tears of how beautiful it was T-T
Truly gorgeous. It really makes my heart burst. The songs alone are amazing, but the duet almost made me burst into tears. :)
This song has always been beatiful.
Me and my sister singed this song i was LUNA MISS LITTLE PERFECT & my sister was QUEEN LITTLE MISS (MOST PERFECT)PERFECT CELESTIA SO BEAUTIFUL ^-^
Amazing!!! I've heard this song before but this is the best I have ever seen!
Thanks, I agree
Thank you for uploading, I loved this ! 😃
This is way too beautiful to not have been given any awards yet. Simply gorgeous and such talent. (also a cool theory on how things went down)
This song slaps hardcore with the bass in the car
Lindooo!!!!!!
Adoro essa música, fica na cabeça...
I alway cry my eyes out when Luna goes "my pain grows, I can't know, are you still the same"
Luna...u are amazing and sensitive and your night is amazing most people don't appreciate how wonderful your night can be because they are asleep through it but you had a point and you are so much more loved than you know.
Forgive us for being so blind!
:')
To be honest this sounds like something that would be in The Lion King.
Yes. Yes it does :-)
Yes,If Mufasa Killed Scar,And Mufasa And Scar were a girl,Then Yes,Very Yes
I like this video because I love duets. I hope you all agree.
Me too!!!
Why have not more people seen this? It's excellent!
I love it! I sing it over and over again.
My daughter falls asleep to it...we love it 🙌🏼
When I'm listening to Luna, what I hear is her fighting with herself, I hear anger, but at the same time I hear forgiveness I know that's probably not what the true song ment, but I like my idea because I can relate to Luna so much
Its actually so sad how they ended the series but I can't blame them I mean the series carried on for how long, like if we count the very very old version almost like twelve-ish years(please correct me if I'm wrong with the years etc XD.).
This is beautiful and it fights them so well. It's so tragic but wonderful
It's wonderful, beautiful song! I think I can't stop sing it
Totally. I didn't feel it was accurate, all the other songs where she begs Celestia to take her back. This is so moving and so real.
totally true
My opinion is that Luna's Soliloquy is more headcanon-like. But both versions are brilliant.
kimichan5 Why would she? She was still Nightmare Moon when she got out, clearly she still hated Celestia.
Durp Dawg You got in reversed. Luna's Soliloquy is closer to canon as she was still Nightmare Moon at the time this song takes place (during her banishment)
Sir Aroun when luna just got in the moon prison she said should not did that. Then thousands of years luna wanted to get out and when she got out she hated Celestia more.
This is amazing! I love it!
Like if you cry every time...
*Cries so much tears* .....Why is this song so sad...it has sooooooooo much FEELS!!!!!!!!
I really love this song and it made me cry.
Please add this whole thing to Spotify. Please 🙏
I listen to this every day before I go to sleep 😴 I have no clue why. But it is a really good song or lullaby
use audio pocket you can use like UA-cam red but its(gasp)free. it can also loop songs. I sleep to it. it gives me dreams
This is so beautiful it made me cry
I absolutely love this song. It's the most beautiful well written song I have ever heard.
And I am not the man in the photo I am I girl
I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE IT!
I herd this song like 1,000 times! and I love it! 😇😘😍😜
and having a sis is worst then I thought!
+Brandy Vargas so have i
Brava! This is fantastic!
Thank you very much!
this was great
This turns out to be my lullaby :P
This was really great! :D
Thank you!
made me cry, love this.
Me too
SUCH BEAUTY!!!!!!
I love it I hear this if I DON'T HAVE something to watch
That was amazing it made me cry as well
I love the line fate has been cruel and order unkind
that was amazing! i dont have words! the sub you is the only think i can do.. .. i LOVVVEE IT !! :D
Wow ^_^
:3
to* sub you
^_^
hhihihi ^^
Made me cry a bit
This song is so sad😢. But it made me cry😢.That was a sad lullaby.😢😢💜
Me too💜💙💚💛❤️😫😩😖😭
me to when i first heard it but I'm so use now i don't any more
It made me cry too
Oh men! This is just giving me feels
love both versions but this is just perfect
As everyone before me I agree that this is the most beautiful song that I have heard. Both people should have been given an award for great singing and lyrics. But most credit goes to Ponyphonic for being the first to make most of these songs. Not sure if Luna's reply and Luna's soliloquy were created by Ponyphonic since i can't find the vid for it on his/her account. Nonetheless, great duet involving the corrupted Luna' reply. And the other by Celestia. Least you have Lyrics.
Luna's soliloquy was made by Ponyphobic if I'm not mistaken. But Luna's reply was made by someone else for sure.
Me and my bff went all the way to, 6:05 XDDD :3
Omg so beautiful just makes me cry. So please make a 10 hour pull any for a princess.
Let's just say it's fantastic
I cried so sad it just touches my heart
I love it!
Beauterful song u made it better with lyrics
love it!! IT'S PERFECT 😍😍😍😙😙😘😘💓❤
Who else is listening to this before they go to sleep
I love the night and ist darkness
I always play this every sunset
Some of the lyrics that they "share" are wrong because they don't alway have the exact same lyrics, but otherwise, this is great!!!
That was awesome.
So beautiful
It's beautiful!
8:41 i love the part
8:54 😭
I'm gonna ruin some of ya'll by saying this, but-
"For the time of my vengeance is _neigh_ "
STOP IT BRO LOL
Bootiful song! I sing the duet withy cousin. I am Luna when we sing it and she is Tia.
I really like this. I've seen other versions for Lunas reply and they are saying that she's sorry but in the show she came back as Nightmare Moon so she was probably Nightmare on the moon too so she probably wasn't sorry but in this she's still annoyed with what Tia did.
Then why did when Luna was back to her normal self she said in tears; "I'm so sorry! I missed you so much, big sister!" I guess when Luna was Nightmare Moon, she was balancing her evil side and her normal self.
+Queen Jinx Koopa It's because she was no longer Nightmare Moon. Because she no longer had the jealousy against her sister. And maybe though Luna became Nightmare Moon she was still able to see what she was doing but had no control .
It's good but the person who was singing for Luna was...well off key and the lyrics are for higher pitch, you can tell when the girl voicing Luna starts to sing higher towards the middle it sounds better.
***** Not really Luna's voice is on the high but deep side if that makes sense.
When I made the video, the black bars on top and bottom were a mistake, but they worked perfectly for this. Some of the lyrics were wrong but otherwise very well done.
Thank you very much, it is a great compliment especially coming from the author of the video
First time i hear this song I CRIES
"Bear" up my lullaby. hueh hueh.
this song is amazing! :3
Thats definitely a tear jerker to sau the least
id like to see a colt version of this
I love it so much :3
good job