@@joskojansa1235 I'm not sure what you point is but as far as I know Goebbels was not a philosopher, he had a Ph.D. in history and literature, yes his novel Michael and his diaries deal vaguely with religious-philosophical ideas but with no real aptitude, his great power lay in his masterful ability as an orator. If you could show me evidence of this reputation as a highly repeated philosopher then I would be very interested.
@@joskojansa1235 gobbeles was great at what he did I.e propoganda. His ideology might have been degenerate as Reinhard heydrich used to say "if I had a face like that cripple gobbles I would never talk of master race" But that doesn't mean he was not a great mind
$3-4,000 a class is not an exaggeration. I am a university student, I see the prices everyday. Textbooks for a class like this can easily be $300-400, and often times they force you to buy a particular edition that you couldn’t otherwise find online
I have found many people (college students and non students) take notes on UA-cam videos and lectures such as this. It’s all self knowledge. A degree doesn’t necessarily mean you learned anything, it means you passed the tests and got the points, which now a days is very easy to cheat
Conning from the same position, but I've gotta say i don't think much is really mafe for that platform yet. Wheeling a tv in to discuss a movie can be distracting, and the projectors now have a strong semblence to classic chalk boards or marker boards. Students should be given a way to interact with the material through the touch boards available now.
Depends on the subject. Sometimes you need exact quotes and formulation (like mathematics) that would take too much time of the lecture. In this case it is easier to present it on a powerpoint. But then more elaborate examples and such will be taken on the board.
@@ErkaaJ Math and logic are best demonstrated as a performance, though I have found that power point is excellent for extended quotes and the reconstruction of arguments.
its amazing seeing people in their professions like this guy with philosophy and seeing them be so passionate it makes things so much more interesting especially when they teach it in fun ways
@Language and Programming Channel well there would be no problem with that, axioms are highly probable assumptions themselves other that I think therefore I am that is the only thing we 100% factually know. I wouldn't be fallacious since altruistic traits can be observed.
🐟 02. A BRIEF EXPLANATION FOR “LIFE”: Everything, both perceptible and imperceptible - that is, any gross or subtle object within the material universe which can ever be perceived with the senses, plus the subject (the observer of all phenomena) - is what most persons actually refer to when they use the term “GOD”. REAL God is Impersonal Absolute Nothingness (otherwise called “The Tao”, “The Great Spirit”, “Brahman”, “Pure Consciousness”, “Eternal Awareness”, “Independent Existence”, “The Ground of All Being”, “The Undifferentiated Substratum of Reality”, “The Unified Field”, et cetera). “God” is One Reality, but just as a knife cannot cut itself, or fire cannot burn itself, “God” cannot know Himself (or at least EXPERIENCE Himself), and so, has manifested this phenomenal universe within Himself. Therefore, this world of duality is really just a play of consciousness within Consciousness. N. B. The word “God” is, by definition, a title of the male Deity, and is not to be taken literally here. Apparently, this phenomenal universe was “created” (within Consciousness) with the initial act (the so-called “Big Bang”), and from that first deed, every action that has ever occurred has been a direct or indirect result of it. Just as every particle of matter in the universe was once contained in the ’singularity’, Infinite Consciousness was NECESSARILY present at the Big Bang, and is in no way an epiphenomenon of a neural network. “Sarvam khalvidam brahma” (‘all this is indeed Brahman’). There is NAUGHT but Eternal Being, Conscious Awareness, Causeless Peace - and you are that! Everything which can be presently perceived, both tangible and immaterial, including we human beings, is a consequence of that initial manifestation. That is the most accurate and logical explanation for “karma” - everything was preordained from the initial spark, and every action since has unfolded as it was predestined in ETERNITY. The notion of retributive (“tit for tat”) karma is just that - an unverified notion. Whatever state in which we currently find ourselves, is the result of two factors - our genetic make-up at conception and our present-life conditioning (which may include mutating genetic code). Every choice ever made by every human (and non-human animal) was determined by those two factors ALONE, thus free-will is purely illusory, despite what most believe. Because we are temporarily residing within this dualistic universe, we experience both pleasure and pain. Suffering and pain are NOT synonymous. Suffering is due to a false sense of personal doership - the belief that one is a separate, independent author of one’s thoughts and deeds. There are five MANIFESTATIONS of suffering: 1. Guilt 2. Blame 3. Pride 4. Anxiety 5. Regrets about the past and expectations for the future These types of suffering are the result of not properly understanding what was explained above - that life is a series of happenings and NOT caused by the individual living beings. No living creature, including us humans, has personal free-will. There is only the Universal, Divine Will at play, acting through every body, to which William Shakespeare famously alluded when he scribed “All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players.” The human organism is simply a biological machine, comprised of the five gross material elements and the three subtle material elements. So, now that you understand life, and the reason why we are suffering here in this (supposedly) material universe, you are now able to be liberated from all forms of suffering, RIGHT? WRONG! It is imperative to find an authentic spiritual master to assist you to come to the above realization, by slowly undoing your past conditioning. Just as you have been conditioned over an entire lifetime to think one way, you need to be re-conditioned to think another. Even if you follow a competent teacher, you may still not come to a full understanding of life, but if you are sincere, humble and dedicated, you will definitely find more peace in your daily life (all of which was DESTINED to occur, of course). Furthermore, if it was ordained, you may be fortunate enough to accept discipline from a truly enlightened master, and subsequently realize the aforementioned fundamental concepts, by practicing at least one of the four systems of yoga (religion) described in the Holy Scripture, “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”. Best wishes for your unique, personal journey towards unalloyed peace and happiness! “The meaning of life is life itself.” ************* “A wise Rabbi once said 'If I am I because you are you, and you are you because I am I, then I am not I, and you are not you'. In other words, we are not separate.” Professor Dr. Alan Wilson Watts, British-American Philosopher. (06/01/1915 - 16/11/1973). “What you seek is seeking you.” Jalāl ad-Dīn Muhammad Rūmī, Persian Sunni Muslim poet, jurist, Islamic scholar, theologian, and Sufi mystic. (30/09/1207 - 17/12/1273).
Adriaan de Jager To read the remaining twenty-nine chapters of “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”, which are the most authoritative, accurate and profound spiritual precepts so far in human history, Email: prophet4god@icloud.com with the acronym “FISH” in the subject field. 🐟 “The gateway to KNOWLEDGE is ignorance”. 🤓 CONTENTS: 00. PROLOGUE 01. PREFACE 02. A BRIEF EXPLANATION FOR “LIFE” 03. CONCEPTS Vs THE TRUTH 04. SCIENCE Vs RELIGION 05. THE PHENOMENAL UNIVERSE 06. CONSCIOUSNESS/AWARENESS 07. GOD (OR NOT) 08. KARMA (ACTION & REACTION) 09. REINCARNATION (OR NOT) 10. EGO (THE SENSE OF SELF): 11. FREE-WILL Vs DETERMINISM 12. LAW, MORALITY, & ETHICS 13. SIN (MISSING THE MARK) 14. DIVINE & DEMONIC NATURES 15. SUFFERING & HAPPINESS 16. YOGA/RELIGION 17. AWAKENING, LIBERATION, & ENLIGHTENMENT 18. THE THREE MODES 19. THE FOUR SOCIAL CLASSES 20. THE PRIESTHOOD 21. THE MONARCHY 22. NON-MONARCHICAL GOVERNANCE 23. THE BUSINESS OWNERS 24. THE WORKING-CLASS 25. THE ROLE OF FEMALES 26. FEMINISM 27. MARRIAGE 28. SEX & TRANSVESTISM 29. SOCIAL ETIQUETTE 30. FOOD AND DIET
I used to be student in engineering, but now I am a stduent in philosophy. Though I don’t focus on analytic philosophy, I do believe I need to have a serious study of it. Now here comes to chance. Thamk you, professor Bonevac.
I got bored in self isolation and I loved every second. My personal insight is : If the world is a mental construct that means we have control over our reality.
Only if the world is our own mental construct. If it was the mental construct of some all powerful being ie God, we would still not have control over the nature of reality.
Also, another way of thinking about it would be: if the world was our own mental construct then we would be able to control reality. We can not control reality. Therefore the world is not a mental construct.
@@naomiaalbregtse1482 Certain interpretations are more in accordance with our perception of reality, and certain interpretations are just logically incoherent.
Even though this area of philosophy can quickly become extremely complicated Bonevac, kept it human and understandable. If you are young pray for a teacher of this quality. I needed a few courses to finish off a degree in my early 30s and had to suffer through a course in prepositional logic.. ugh.
Very nice to see the upload! As well, excellent work on the recording layout. Appreciating too that you have to work with the classroom and many were designed without uploading in mind! Keep up the excellent work professor!!!
@@Zumastraphy Hrithik Ravi deleted his comment, but he is the one who said moron, not me. I tried to explain it to him. I told him that he does not need to say moron.
A reading list for the lectures would be nice. I've been looking for a detailed lecture series on the analytic tradition so thanks a lot for uploading!
Professor Bonevac, you are one of the most engaging, coherent and educative people one can find. The only thing - sound. This video too to an extent but specifically with the Fall 2016 videos which are the most informative and easy to digest lectures on philosophy you can dream to find. Especially when you are not facing the cam and you are at some distance from it you are really barely intelligible and for someone who is not a native like me (despite my level steadily approaching nativeness) and doesn't naturally fill in all the blanks that can't be heard it is hard to go through the videos. Please either edit out the ambient noise and bump up midtones or consider using a microphone, a pilot/telemarketer one, not a classic TV reporter stick with a ball.
@Language and Programming Channel Lol! So someone with the title 'Language and Programming Channel' has just called arguably the greatest philosopher of the 20th century, a tool.
When this gentleman was in elementary school music class as a pupil and they handed him the triangle to play it may have sounded like a certain John cage piece of music ,however it may have gone on far longer than 4:33. Excellent lecture really enjoyed it, best regards from the UK
I wish i could have a chance to attend this wonderful class. But thanks to UA-cam. Because at some point i really imagine myself sitting there. And in my thoughts, philosophy is knowledge. it is wisdom.
Bertrand Russell put one thing out nicely. Philosophy is the third wonder, after religion and science. Thanks so much for these classes for public access. made free.
Such a great lecturer. I can't recall very many lecturers teaching with this sort of engagement with the class. A real asset to UT, to philosophy and to students. I wish he'd teach a course in LOGIC!
WHAT A KNOWLEDGEABLE LECTURER AND WONDERFUL CONTENT FROM SOCRATES,PLATO, ARISTOTLE TO AL GHAZALI,AVICENNA, AVERROIS TILL NOW PHILOSOPHY IS LEARNING OF HOW UNIVERSAL PROPERTIES+CONCEPT MAKE OBJECT,LOGIC,REASON AND THOUGHTS
A good story is an excellent way out of the problem. It offers much more to chew on than concepts that are too precise and therefore disconnected from actual life.
I found the whole 48 minute lecture very intriguing. I heard every word. Everyone has their own perspective on reality because of their upbringing. E.g. the people they talk to, the place they live in, how they were raised, etc,etc. The things you mentioned like about God, religion, law, those are just different types of realities that we accept and perceive differently. Very thought provoking, very enlightening to who we are and very interesting indeed. Thanks for the lecture.
Something that has occurred to me is that the "psycho-sociological-economic" dynamic of the classroom teaching "form"-itself-sheds light on this philosophical concern with the understanding of forms. If the class was instead a gardening class, and the goal to grow a garden, the "meaning" of the forms would necessarily be taken for granted in order to effectively accomplish the planting of the garden. By observing the philosophy class, and then the gardening class, and then contrasting the "thought exchange" in the philosophy class with the "action exchange" taking place in the gardening class, we may, here, find our answer to the question of the truth about forms. Not in the contemplation of ideas, but in their planting,
This was awesome. I wish it could have been longer haha. That's the thing about good philosophy it really gets good about an hour or so into it and then its out of time lol. Def going to watch more videos. I could have listened for another 3 hours easily :)
According to Plato ( c.428 - c.348bc ), when we are born we fly over the back of heaven and see all these perfect forms, such as a perfect chair and a perfect bed etc, but when we are born we lose this vision, but the one perfect form in heaven as on Earth is love, which gives an inkling of perfect forms in heaven. Unlike materialistic objects which are perceived with the senses forms such as goodness and honesty etc are understood only by reasoning which is why philosophy is so important.
Fascinating. The Counterfeit Problem parallels the function I used for my Irrationality Principle: that for every True statement that can be made, there are an infinite number of possible True statements whose Truth values conflict with or otherwise contradict the established axioms inherent within any perceived Truth. Where Logic is a function determined by the Emotional content of an argument multiplied by a factor of perceived Authority, absolutely anything can be believed, and it is necessarily impossible to confirm any particular Truths as objective relative to any other consistent set of Truths. My go to example is the split between Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, with Relativity inherently implying its own inability to explain certain functions of Quantum Mechanics. Both are highly accurate and valuable Truths, yet their mutual existence contradict each other.
dit is een voorbeeld dat je met een goede voorbereiding bijna alles kan creëren : een marketingcampagne/een college - kunst. Zolang je maar goed na denkt wat maakt "iets" en wat maakt datgene "goed"/"waardevol"/ het waard te horen #ditisergoptimistischmaa inmijnogendewaarheid
Pretty good for a free lecture xD. I wish more people would watch this, most people just give me blank stares or incredibly poor responses whenever I bring up epistemology (the thought -> world mapping question, Hume, etc.). The most common problem today is people both assuming and denying the entire concept of reality simultaneously under the so-called "social construct" model. A little bit of thought and education would do these types a great favor.
This was great. Kind of reminds me of the idea that I can never know what your perception of blue is. We can agree on the colour of all blue objects being blue, and we can agree that the light that reflects into our eyes transmits the same information to our brains, but if was to see through your mind's eye perhaps your brain interprets the information of all colours to be the inverse of how my brain interprets them. Or maybe even your conception of what colour means is so radically different from mine that I wouldn't even recognise what you were thinking. But it's irrelevant because I will never see through your mind's eye, and we have calibrated our thoughts with language such that all our ideas align to avoid confusion even if what we are thinking is different. If anyone knows of any philosophers that touch on that sort of point specifically I'd love to know. I was agreeing with Kant's mind independent lumina as well until Hegel had to come along and ruin it all >:(
Philosophy may also be said to be the (high level) study of the essential characteristics of the material world around us and then trying to see whether these essential characteristics of matter are sufficient to provide a logical and convincing explanation regarding who we are and what our mind is made of, relating the external features to the anatomy of our body and considering, above all, the essential characteristics of consciousness and the conscious personality.
I watched this I believe a year or so ago but never realised that you are doing the Plato and Aristotle pose from the famous painting "The School of Athens." In your thumbnail.
Nothing like a free education.
Adam Bell As it should be
@@nasaman23 completely agree
It is not free. Someone else is paying for it.
damn skippy
college is just paying for the degree the knowledge is “free” via the internet and/or library
I’m not even in college... I’m just really bored so I decided to learn about philosophy.
Fuck yea boi
y ,no shit
Same
We need to be taught by good teachers.
😂😂😂
A good teacher makes any subject ten times better. No need for a powerpoint, he's engaging folks.
Goebbles was highly respected as philosopher, before 1936. Respected by american mainstream inteligentsia.
@@joskojansa1235 I'm not sure what you point is but as far as I know Goebbels was not a philosopher, he had a Ph.D. in history and literature, yes his novel Michael and his diaries deal vaguely with religious-philosophical ideas but with no real aptitude, his great power lay in his masterful ability as an orator. If you could show me evidence of this reputation as a highly repeated philosopher then I would be very interested.
It's been a year ,Josko,waiting.....
@@joskojansa1235 gobbeles was great at what he did I.e propoganda. His ideology might have been degenerate as Reinhard heydrich used to say "if I had a face like that cripple gobbles I would never talk of master race"
But that doesn't mean he was not a great mind
Modern day college charges $3,000-4,000 for this class, plus a $500 text book.
UA-cam- free
Well yes. This class and 20 others plus the three papers you write (which NO ONE will write after watching a UA-cam video). You get what you pay for.
Exaggeration, usually thats the price of one year, and a textbook can be bought for less than $100 or 200 depending if it's used
$3-4,000 a class is not an exaggeration. I am a university student, I see the prices everyday. Textbooks for a class like this can easily be $300-400, and often times they force you to buy a particular edition that you couldn’t otherwise find online
I have found many people (college students and non students) take notes on UA-cam videos and lectures such as this.
It’s all self knowledge.
A degree doesn’t necessarily mean you learned anything, it means you passed the tests and got the points, which now a days is very easy to cheat
@@mrpinkpony same
I like blackboard lectures. No need for fancy projectors and boring power-points.
agree with you
Conning from the same position, but I've gotta say i don't think much is really mafe for that platform yet. Wheeling a tv in to discuss a movie can be distracting, and the projectors now have a strong semblence to classic chalk boards or marker boards.
Students should be given a way to interact with the material through the touch boards available now.
Why not both?
Depends on the subject. Sometimes you need exact quotes and formulation (like mathematics) that would take too much time of the lecture. In this case it is easier to present it on a powerpoint. But then more elaborate examples and such will be taken on the board.
@@ErkaaJ Math and logic are best demonstrated as a performance, though I have found that power point is excellent for extended quotes and the reconstruction of arguments.
I AM A STUDENT OF HISTORY BUT THIS LECTURE IS AN EYE OPENER TO ME IN HISTORY AND HENCEFORTH, I WILL ALWAYS APPLY PHILOSOPHY INTO HISTORY LESSONS.
WHAT? I CAN’T HEAR YOU!
I hear voices
Will you always shout your way through life?
@asala bayo I hope your education has done you well to this day. How are you doing?
THATS GOOD TO HEAR BUDDY!!!
its amazing seeing people in their professions like this guy with philosophy and seeing them be so passionate it makes things so much more interesting especially when they teach it in fun ways
When you find someone like your favorite professor at university.
Teaching different subjects.
UA-cam is gold.
0:20 "Philosophy is thoughts that are at rest."
Socrates ( c.470 - 399bc )
Philosophy is existentialism.
@@spiritualopportunism4585 yes we think deeply because we find value in surviving objectively or not, we are an organism after all.
@Language and Programming Channel well there would be no problem with that, axioms are highly probable assumptions themselves other that I think therefore I am that is the only thing we 100% factually know.
I wouldn't be fallacious since altruistic traits can be observed.
@@spiritualopportunism4585 existentialism is a form of philosophy
@@KingBullet123 please bitch, linguistics alone do not refine knowledge -- nor do you assert philosophy via words.
We need more great teachers like this in our universities ..
This is such a beautiful explanation of the things that happened in philosophy and leaves you questioning
"what is reality and who am I?".
this is the farthest down the rabbit hole that i have ever been.
....and i want to keep going.
🐟 02. A BRIEF EXPLANATION FOR “LIFE”:
Everything, both perceptible and imperceptible - that is, any gross or subtle object within the material universe which can ever be perceived with the senses, plus the subject (the observer of all phenomena) - is what most persons actually refer to when they use the term “GOD”.
REAL God is Impersonal Absolute Nothingness (otherwise called “The Tao”, “The Great Spirit”, “Brahman”, “Pure Consciousness”, “Eternal Awareness”, “Independent Existence”, “The Ground of All Being”, “The Undifferentiated Substratum of Reality”, “The Unified Field”, et cetera).
“God” is One Reality, but just as a knife cannot cut itself, or fire cannot burn itself, “God” cannot know Himself (or at least EXPERIENCE Himself), and so, has manifested this phenomenal universe within Himself. Therefore, this world of duality is really just a play of consciousness within Consciousness. N. B. The word “God” is, by definition, a title of the male Deity, and is not to be taken literally here.
Apparently, this phenomenal universe was “created” (within Consciousness) with the initial act (the so-called “Big Bang”), and from that first deed, every action that has ever occurred has been a direct or indirect result of it.
Just as every particle of matter in the universe was once contained in the ’singularity’, Infinite Consciousness was NECESSARILY present at the Big Bang, and is in no way an epiphenomenon of a neural network.
“Sarvam khalvidam brahma” (‘all this is indeed Brahman’). There is NAUGHT but Eternal Being, Conscious Awareness, Causeless Peace -
and you are that!
Everything which can be presently perceived, both tangible and immaterial, including we human beings, is a consequence of that initial manifestation. That is the most accurate and logical explanation for “karma” - everything was preordained from the initial spark, and every action since has unfolded as it was predestined in ETERNITY. The notion of retributive (“tit for tat”) karma is just that - an unverified notion.
Whatever state in which we currently find ourselves, is the result of two factors - our genetic make-up at conception and our present-life conditioning (which may include mutating genetic code). Every choice ever made by every human (and non-human animal) was determined by those two factors ALONE, thus free-will is purely illusory, despite what most believe.
Because we are temporarily residing within this dualistic universe, we experience both pleasure and pain.
Suffering and pain are NOT synonymous.
Suffering is due to a false sense of personal doership - the belief that one is a separate, independent author of one’s thoughts and deeds.
There are five MANIFESTATIONS of suffering:
1. Guilt
2. Blame
3. Pride
4. Anxiety
5. Regrets about the past and expectations for the future
These types of suffering are the result of not properly understanding what was explained above - that life is a series of happenings and NOT caused by the individual living beings. No living creature, including us humans, has personal free-will. There is only the Universal, Divine Will at play, acting through every body, to which William Shakespeare famously alluded when he scribed “All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players.”
The human organism is simply a biological machine, comprised of the five gross material elements and the three subtle material elements.
So, now that you understand life, and the reason why we are suffering here in this (supposedly) material universe, you are now able to be liberated from all forms of suffering, RIGHT?
WRONG! It is imperative to find an authentic spiritual master to assist you to come to the above realization, by slowly undoing your past conditioning. Just as you have been conditioned over an entire lifetime to think one way, you need to be re-conditioned to think another.
Even if you follow a competent teacher, you may still not come to a full understanding of life, but if you are sincere, humble and dedicated, you will definitely find more peace in your daily life (all of which was DESTINED to occur, of course).
Furthermore, if it was ordained, you may be fortunate enough to accept discipline from a truly enlightened master, and subsequently realize the aforementioned fundamental concepts, by practicing at least one of the four systems of yoga (religion) described in the Holy Scripture, “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”. Best wishes for your unique, personal journey towards unalloyed peace and happiness!
“The meaning of life is life itself.”
*************
“A wise Rabbi once said 'If I am I because you are you, and you are you because I am I, then I am not I, and you are not you'.
In other words, we are not separate.”
Professor Dr. Alan Wilson Watts,
British-American Philosopher.
(06/01/1915 - 16/11/1973).
“What you seek is seeking you.”
Jalāl ad-Dīn Muhammad Rūmī,
Persian Sunni Muslim poet, jurist, Islamic scholar, theologian, and Sufi mystic.
(30/09/1207 - 17/12/1273).
@@TheWorldTeacher bruhhh you are to smart for me
Adriaan de Jager
Kindly repeat that in ENGLISH, Miss.☝️
@@TheWorldTeacher YOU have a better understanding of life than me
Adriaan de Jager
To read the remaining twenty-nine chapters of “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”, which are the most authoritative, accurate and profound spiritual precepts so far in human history, Email:
prophet4god@icloud.com
with the acronym “FISH” in the subject field.
🐟
“The gateway to KNOWLEDGE is ignorance”. 🤓
CONTENTS:
00. PROLOGUE
01. PREFACE
02. A BRIEF EXPLANATION FOR “LIFE”
03. CONCEPTS Vs THE TRUTH
04. SCIENCE Vs RELIGION
05. THE PHENOMENAL UNIVERSE
06. CONSCIOUSNESS/AWARENESS
07. GOD (OR NOT)
08. KARMA (ACTION & REACTION)
09. REINCARNATION (OR NOT)
10. EGO (THE SENSE OF SELF):
11. FREE-WILL Vs DETERMINISM
12. LAW, MORALITY, & ETHICS
13. SIN (MISSING THE MARK)
14. DIVINE & DEMONIC NATURES
15. SUFFERING & HAPPINESS
16. YOGA/RELIGION
17. AWAKENING, LIBERATION, & ENLIGHTENMENT
18. THE THREE MODES
19. THE FOUR SOCIAL CLASSES
20. THE PRIESTHOOD
21. THE MONARCHY
22. NON-MONARCHICAL GOVERNANCE
23. THE BUSINESS OWNERS
24. THE WORKING-CLASS
25. THE ROLE OF FEMALES
26. FEMINISM
27. MARRIAGE
28. SEX & TRANSVESTISM
29. SOCIAL ETIQUETTE
30. FOOD AND DIET
I'm about to start my philosophy course in fall. I can't wait. I hope I have a great teacher like you!
How was it bro?
@@aladdinkayqubad1645 he turned into hitler with a woman body
How u doing bro 👋👋👋👋
hope it’s going well, cream cheese!!!
Philosophy is the study of the presuppositions of every field of thought.
Sings: “It ain’t necessarily so...” 🎤
@@TheWorldTeacher 😅
In the two years since writing your comment, have you heard any convincing rebuttals/amendments?
0:20 “The Love of Wisdom”
-the literal meaning of the word
I used to be student in engineering, but now I am a stduent in philosophy. Though I don’t focus on analytic philosophy, I do believe I need to have a serious study of it. Now here comes to chance. Thamk you, professor Bonevac.
Man, I actually am in the same process. Electrical Engineering student wanting to study philosophy. How was it for you?
@@Danielle-rs4bk Philosophy is great. But studying Evolution is even better. The source is rich.
@@comdrive3865 lol rich?
You both got bored of engineering?
looking forward to watching the whole series!
Thanks fo the upload
I got bored in self isolation and I loved every second. My personal insight is : If the world is a mental construct that means we have control over our reality.
Only if the world is our own mental construct. If it was the mental construct of some all powerful being ie God, we would still not have control over the nature of reality.
Also, another way of thinking about it would be:
if the world was our own mental construct then we would be able to control reality.
We can not control reality.
Therefore the world is not a mental construct.
It could be because there is no scientific way to prove anything is real it’s all up to interpretation
Even if it is a mental construct that does not necessarily give u the ability to control it.
@@naomiaalbregtse1482 Certain interpretations are more in accordance with our perception of reality, and certain interpretations are just logically incoherent.
Even though this area of philosophy can quickly become extremely complicated Bonevac, kept it human and understandable. If you are young pray for a teacher of this quality. I needed a few courses to finish off a degree in my early 30s and had to suffer through a course in prepositional logic.. ugh.
Lies again? Vigrx Plus
How did things turn out?
I was gonna pop this on to help me relax and fall asleep but this guy is just too good of a lecturer
I'm so happy I found this video! I was upset when I found out I didn't need a philosophy course for my major. Thank you!!
I like that this dudes passionate 👍
there should be more passionate teachers^^
Not too "passionate"
@@RicStaR2410 hahaha
He tries simplicity,
but gets confusion
He really loves what does. I really appreciate it ♥️♥️
It is so terrific to watch a good teacher. So engaging.
Very nice to see the upload! As well, excellent work on the recording layout. Appreciating too that you have to work with the classroom and many were designed without uploading in mind! Keep up the excellent work professor!!!
This is the type of teatchers the world needs!
Teachers* you shouldn’t be watching college lessons if you can’t spell words that you learn in kindergarten
HowToVideos- Tech 🥱
Yout holiness.
Thanks for uploading these lectures, they are great. I love how you drew a straight line through the history of philosophy.
Just keep in mind that Bonevac is a Tump Supporter
Loved your style of teaching.... Felt as if I am sitting in a classroom
@Hrithik Ravi He felt as if he is "sitting in" a classroom. No need to say moron.
@@keishaleitogores3344 you’re a sad human
@@Zumastraphy What did I do?
@@Zumastraphy Hrithik Ravi deleted his comment, but he is the one who said moron, not me. I tried to explain it to him. I told him that he does not need to say moron.
A reading list for the lectures would be nice. I've been looking for a detailed lecture series on the analytic tradition so thanks a lot for uploading!
Professor Bonevac, you are one of the most engaging, coherent and educative people one can find. The only thing - sound. This video too to an extent but specifically with the Fall 2016 videos which are the most informative and easy to digest lectures on philosophy you can dream to find. Especially when you are not facing the cam and you are at some distance from it you are really barely intelligible and for someone who is not a native like me (despite my level steadily approaching nativeness) and doesn't naturally fill in all the blanks that can't be heard it is hard to go through the videos.
Please either edit out the ambient noise and bump up midtones or consider using a microphone, a pilot/telemarketer one, not a classic TV reporter stick with a ball.
0:20 "Philosophy is a battle against the bewitchment of our intelligence by means of language."
Ludwig Wittgenstein ( 1889 - 1951 )
Loved it
Ie battle against deception
I think Seneca thought the same right?
@@lilbucketz1129
I honestly don't know LilBucketZ.
@Language and Programming Channel
Lol! So someone with the title 'Language and Programming Channel' has just called arguably the greatest philosopher of the 20th century, a tool.
well it was nice to see this.u r a great teacher sir.we all need ur support and ur guide for our future
this channel is wonderful to listen while working! Thanks for sharing.
I've listened to this lecture like, 8 times. It's very informative. It's a good training tool rather than just a teaching tool.
The world would be a much better place if education like this didn’t lead to a 20-year debt.
The way you encourage students alone is a huge build of confidence! Truly incredible stuff!! Thank you so much
I watched this video on LSD and I now Understand what life is .. god bless
Anyone who hasn't studied philosophy before, this is perfect! Awesome...
i like this format. we can see the screen and you. Nice video sir.
Take
Fakme
Amazing, man
Finally some lectures on the analytic tradition!
When this gentleman was in elementary school music class as a pupil and they handed him the triangle
to play it may have sounded like a certain John cage piece of music ,however it may have gone on far longer than 4:33.
Excellent lecture really enjoyed it, best regards from the UK
You, sir, are a blessing.
I wish i could have a chance to attend this wonderful class. But thanks to UA-cam. Because at some point i really imagine myself sitting there. And in my thoughts, philosophy is knowledge. it is wisdom.
Grest teacher of broad ideas with challenging questions - his ideas just flowed. Wonderful.
Bertrand Russell put one thing out nicely. Philosophy is the third wonder, after religion and science. Thanks so much for these classes for public access. made free.
Great lecture, I learned because it was so interesting. Daniel you are enthusiastic, thank you.
I'm getting the understanding of it now, you explaining really well, and thank you
An actually substantive lecture on philosophy, by someone who obviously knows the material well.
Such a great lecturer. I can't recall very many lecturers teaching with this sort of engagement with the class. A real asset to UT, to philosophy and to students. I wish he'd teach a course in LOGIC!
Fantastic lecture. Thank You!
What a gift this video is.
I've been exploring similar ideas in my recent videos. It's always inspiring to find others who are just as passionate.
I'm on my break at work....love it
WHAT A KNOWLEDGEABLE LECTURER AND WONDERFUL CONTENT FROM SOCRATES,PLATO, ARISTOTLE TO AL GHAZALI,AVICENNA, AVERROIS TILL NOW PHILOSOPHY IS LEARNING OF HOW UNIVERSAL PROPERTIES+CONCEPT MAKE OBJECT,LOGIC,REASON AND THOUGHTS
according to berkeley ideas are
1 concrete
2 abstract
3 both
His laughter is filled with that dear delight.
Whoa!! Incredible work, sir.
He is enjoying so freaking much that I am also enjoying watching him
A good story is an excellent way out of the problem. It offers much more to chew on than concepts that are too precise and therefore disconnected from actual life.
I watch your lectures for entertainment, as well as education, wonderful.
I want to take a teaching profession after seeing you sir.
Thank you! 1st day: SUBSCRIBED!!
Good lecture sir
This was really impressive ❤
I found the whole 48 minute lecture very intriguing. I heard every word. Everyone has their own perspective on reality because of their upbringing. E.g. the people they talk to, the place they live in, how they were raised, etc,etc. The things you mentioned like about God, religion, law, those are just different types of realities that we accept and perceive differently. Very thought provoking, very enlightening to who we are and very interesting indeed. Thanks for the lecture.
Something that has occurred to me is that the "psycho-sociological-economic" dynamic of the classroom teaching "form"-itself-sheds light on this philosophical concern with the understanding of forms. If the class was instead a gardening class, and the goal to grow a garden, the "meaning" of the forms would necessarily be taken for granted in order to effectively accomplish the planting of the garden. By observing the philosophy class, and then the gardening class, and then contrasting the "thought exchange" in the philosophy class with the "action exchange" taking place in the gardening class, we may, here, find our answer to the question of the truth about forms. Not in the contemplation of ideas, but in their planting,
Thank you so much for this generous resource.
Thanks for the upload ....
Amazing!! Thank you!!!
This was awesome. I wish it could have been longer haha. That's the thing about good philosophy it really gets good about an hour or so into it and then its out of time lol. Def going to watch more videos. I could have listened for another 3 hours easily :)
Thank you for this fantastic series, you are a great lecturer.
This is amazing, thank you very much sir!
According to Plato ( c.428 - c.348bc ), when we are born we fly over the back of heaven and see all these perfect forms, such as a perfect chair and a perfect bed etc, but when we are born we lose this vision, but the one perfect form in heaven as on Earth is love, which gives an inkling of perfect forms in heaven. Unlike materialistic objects which are perceived with the senses forms such as goodness and honesty etc are understood only by reasoning which is why philosophy is so important.
Fascinating. The Counterfeit Problem parallels the function I used for my Irrationality Principle: that for every True statement that can be made, there are an infinite number of possible True statements whose Truth values conflict with or otherwise contradict the established axioms inherent within any perceived Truth. Where Logic is a function determined by the Emotional content of an argument multiplied by a factor of perceived Authority, absolutely anything can be believed, and it is necessarily impossible to confirm any particular Truths as objective relative to any other consistent set of Truths.
My go to example is the split between Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, with Relativity inherently implying its own inability to explain certain functions of Quantum Mechanics. Both are highly accurate and valuable Truths, yet their mutual existence contradict each other.
@@MaulqasmPK You're describing with Words I made my Ape brain think as Thoughts a while ago.
It be like that sometimes.
dit is een voorbeeld dat je met een goede voorbereiding bijna alles kan creëren : een marketingcampagne/een college - kunst. Zolang je maar goed na denkt wat maakt "iets" en wat maakt datgene "goed"/"waardevol"/ het waard te horen #ditisergoptimistischmaa inmijnogendewaarheid
goede observatie!
Love the energy from this guy.
You should do a podcast version of these.
Thank you for sharing.......
SO
GOOD!
wooahh, i think ive learned now😊 thanks to you sir
From Philippines
Siddhartha Gauthama was the Enlightened one, the Greatest philosopher the human civilisation, humanity has seen known so far.🌹
Philosophy is the contemplation of ideas, principles and problems,etc...
Pretty good for a free lecture xD. I wish more people would watch this, most people just give me blank stares or incredibly poor responses whenever I bring up epistemology (the thought -> world mapping question, Hume, etc.).
The most common problem today is people both assuming and denying the entire concept of reality simultaneously under the so-called "social construct" model. A little bit of thought and education would do these types a great favor.
My philosophy: Point the camera at the subject.
ua-cam.com/video/XCGkVyyDOcU/v-deo.html
You’d enjoy Deleuze
Hahaha Good one!
the side angle is more sylistic
Wow, you are a very good teacher, Very well explained :)
Thank you! 😃
This was great. Kind of reminds me of the idea that I can never know what your perception of blue is. We can agree on the colour of all blue objects being blue, and we can agree that the light that reflects into our eyes transmits the same information to our brains, but if was to see through your mind's eye perhaps your brain interprets the information of all colours to be the inverse of how my brain interprets them. Or maybe even your conception of what colour means is so radically different from mine that I wouldn't even recognise what you were thinking. But it's irrelevant because I will never see through your mind's eye, and we have calibrated our thoughts with language such that all our ideas align to avoid confusion even if what we are thinking is different. If anyone knows of any philosophers that touch on that sort of point specifically I'd love to know.
I was agreeing with Kant's mind independent lumina as well until Hegel had to come along and ruin it all >:(
Great lecture. Not enough on my guy Spinoza but towards the end we are ideas in a world mind nailed it.
Seems very intresting
Amazing!
Changed my life
Perfect teacher 👌👌
Thankyou Daniel! :)
What if a Biological Species more advanced than ours has its own Symbolic Conceptual Systems relative to its Survival?
How do you determine that it is necessary for or even relative to that species' survival in the first place?
Philosophy may also be said to be the (high level) study of the essential characteristics of the material world around us and then trying to see whether these essential characteristics of matter are sufficient to provide a logical and convincing explanation regarding who we are and what our mind is made of, relating the external features to the anatomy of our body and considering, above all, the essential characteristics of consciousness and the conscious personality.
Thank you, Daniel.
My pleasure!
I watched this I believe a year or so ago but never realised that you are doing the Plato and Aristotle pose from the famous painting "The School of Athens." In your thumbnail.
😉
Great teacher. He reminds me of Ray Manzarek from The Doors
Manzarek was my idol in high school; I played keyboards and learned a bunch of the Doors songs!
For a syllabus with a list of readings in the course, see philosophical.space/327.
Thanks a lot Dr.!
Could I ask you to enable to add automatic captioning on all of your analytic tradition course?
Daniel Bonevac
Daniel Bonevac
Sir do you have anything on Foucault’s power and knowledge.
Archaeology and genealogy as critique framework.
I’m watching this because I can’t fall asleep but I always want to sleep in class
The “wow…dude” at the end after the thing w the chalk was so funny