The "Renegade Indians" of Southern Nevada
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 бер 2020
- This video is dedicated to Phil Brigandi (1959-2019), may he rest in peace
Derived from a presentation at the Western Historical Association
WHA 2019 - Glitter in the Dust: The Transformation of Nevada
“Renegade Indians”: A Strain in Southern Nevada and its Parallels
------------------------------------------------------------
Connected videos:
0:25 - My previous conference presentation video: • The Problem of Vegas S...
10:20 - The History of Las Vegas: • The History of Las Veg...
12:05 - Social Banditry: • The Robin Hood complex...
14:45 - Music for History Nerds: • Music for History Nerd...
or generally there's always my documentary on the Western genre: • When the Western Genre...
------------------------------------------------------------
See pinned comment and its replies for references, notes, responses, and errata
------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS:
ua-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
Support the channel through PATREON:
/ cynicalhistorian
LET'S CONNECT:
Facebook: / cynicalcypher88
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / cynical_history
Subreddit: / cynicalhistory
This is episode is dedicated to Phil Brigandi (1959-2019), may he rest in peace
UA-cam remonetized this, but *UMG is claiming the revenue,* so please consider supporting the channel
by buying merch: teespring.com/stores/the-cynical-historian
Or by donating to my Patreon: www.patreon.com/CynicalHistorian
See following replies for corrections and additional info, but first, here are some related videos to check out:
0:25 - My previous conference presentation video: ua-cam.com/video/qY6A-3bIRcE/v-deo.html
10:20 - The History of Las Vegas: ua-cam.com/video/AyQtQogodYw/v-deo.html
12:05 - Social Banditry: ua-cam.com/video/VW_fEdrvmOI/v-deo.html
14:45 - Music for History Nerds: ua-cam.com/video/88jpX5Btnig/v-deo.html
or generally there's always my documentary on the Western genre: ua-cam.com/video/x6zD1sjnClM/v-deo.html
*[reserved for errata]*
*Bibliography*
Reminiscences:
Andress, Donna. _Eldorado Canyon and Nelson, Nevada: Historical Documents Reminiscences Commentary._ Second Edition. Boulder City, Nev., 1999.
Gacey, Charles. “Frontier Justice In El Dorado: Charles Gracey's Story.” _Nevada Historical Quarterly_ 29, no. 2 (Summer, 1986): 120-121.
Perkins, George E. “On the Trail of a Renegade Pahute: A Personal Experience.” _Desert Magazine_ 3, no. 1 (November 1939): 22-25.
Pollard, Walter D. “Letters.” _Desert Magazine_ 3, no. 2 (December 1938): i.
Reid, Harry. _Searchlight: The Camp that didn’t Fail._ Reno: University of Nevada, 1998.
Riggs, John L. “The Reign of Violence in El Dorado Canyon.” _Third Biennial Report of the Nevada Historical Society_ (1911-1912): 95-107.
Newspapers:
“‘What’s in a Name: Wit and Tragedy Found in those of the Desert,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 18 August 1906.
“Piutes on Man Hunt,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 25 November 1910.
“Canyon Tragedy,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 26 November 1910.
“Trailing Queho,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 14 January 1911.
“Indian Creeo on Warpath,” _Clark County Review,_ 26 November 1910.
“Hunt for Renegade,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 4 January 1911.
“Still Dead,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 13 September 1913.
“End of Redhanded Career,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 8 June 1913.
“Mysterious Murder in Eldorado Canyon,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 25 January 1919.
“Search Being Made for Two Missing Men,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 25 January 1919.
“Two Skeletons at Forlorn Hope Spring,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 15 February 1919.
“No New Developments in Hunt for Queho,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 22 February 1919.
“Found Gruesome Relic of Handcock and Taylor Murder,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 3 March 1919.
“Search for Queho Brings no Results,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 3 April 1919.
“State Offers $2000 Reward for Queho,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 17 May 1919.
“Grim Tragedy of Early Days Shown in Finding of Woman’s Skeleton,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 4 April 1928.
“Steve Tecope, Peaceful Indian, Is Held Guilty; Outlaw Brother Hides in Hills,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 12 November 1931.
“Charmed Life of Jack Logg,” _Las Vegas Age,_ 5 February 1937.
Ed Ainsworth, “Mummy of Bad Old Indian Starts Feudin’ in Nevada,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 2 May 1940.
Ed Ainsworth, “Advent of New Heir Adds to Mummy Tangle,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 4 May 1940.
Ed Ainsworth, “Queho Causing as much Trouble Dead as Alive,” _Los Angeles Times,_ 3 May 1940.
“Queho’s Secret Hideout,” Treasure with Bill Berud, 1958, TV, ua-cam.com/video/2rVvVtZPMYE/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/bwHpYjWtwx4/v-deo.html.
Paul Eastman, “The Strange Tale of the Indian Outlaw Queho,” _Las Vegas Sun,_ 13 January 1980.
Phillip I. Earl, “Burial of Queho,” _Las Vegas Review Journal,_ 18 August 1996.
KJ Evans, “Scoundrel or Scapegoat,” _Las Vegas Review Journal,_ 7 February 1999.
Phillip Gomez, “Serial Killer came to End of the Trail in Pahrump,” _Pahrump Valley Times,_ 1 September 2006.
Secondary:
Blackhawk, Ned. _Violence over the Land: Indians and Empires in the Early American West._ Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2006.
Brown, Richard Maxwell. _Strain of Violence: Historical Studies of American Violence and Vigilantism._ New York: Oxford University Press, 1975.
Brown, Richard Maxwell. “Historiography of Violence in the American West.” In _Historians and the American West,_ edited by Michael Malone, 234-269. Lincoln: University of Nebraska, 1985.
Brown, Richard Maxwell. _No Duty to Retreat: Violence and Values in American History and Society._ New York: Oxford University Press, 1991.
Brown, Richard Maxwell. “Western Violence: Structure, Values, Myth.” _Western Historical Quarterly_ 24, no. 1 (February 1993): 4-20.
Brown, Richard Maxwell. “Violence.” In _The Oxford History of the American West,_ edited by Clyde Milner II, Carol O’Connor, and Martha Sandweiss, 393-425. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.
Hall-Patton, Joseph. “Avote.” _Dezert Magazine_ (Fall, 2013).
Hebner, William Logan. _Southern Paiute: A Portrait._ Logan: Utah State University Press, 2010.
Hollon, W. Eugene. _Frontier Violence: Another Look._ London: Oxford University Press, 1974.
Land, Barbara and Myrick Land. _A Short History of Las Vegas._ Reno: University of Nevada Press, 1999.
Lingenfelter, Richard. _Death Valley and the Amargosa: A Land of Illusion._ Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988.
McGrath, Roger D. _Gunfighters Highwaymen & Vigilantes: Violence on the Frontier._ Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984.
Moehring, Eugene. _Resort City in the Sunbelt: Las Vegas, 1930-2000._ Reno: University of Nevada Press, 2000.
Moehring, Eugene. _Reno, Las Vegas, and the Strip: A Tale of Three Cities._ Reno: University of Nevada Press, 2014.
Moehring, Eugene and Michael Green. _Las Vegas: A Centennial History._ Reno: University of Nevada Press, 2005.
Paher, Stanley. _Las Vegas: As It Began - As It Grew._ Las Vegas, Nev.: Nevada Publications, 1971.
Reeve, W. Paul. _Making Space on the Western Frontier: Mormons, Miners, and Southern Paiutes._ Urbana: University of Illinois, 2006.
Slotkin, Richard. _Regeneration through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600-1860._ Middletown, Conn.: Wesleyan University Press, 1973.
Slotkin, Richard. _The Fatal Environment: The Myth of the Frontier in the Age of Industrialization, 1800-1890._ New York: Atheneum Books, 1985.
Slotkin, Richard. _Gunfighter Nation: The Myth of the Frontier in Twentieth-Century America._ New York: Atheneum Books, 1992.
Am so sorry for your lose
@@CynicalHistorian
UA-cam hates critical analyses of historical event's.
It much prefers simplistic infographics.
Im sorry to hear about you're friend.
Im sure he would be proud of you're work.
I know I am.
having just buried a friend this past Friday the pain in your voice was heartbreaking
Ah buddy. I am so sorry for your loss. What a nice tribute this video was.
Sorry for your loss. However, he lives on within you your family and all who knew him.
The impact of great men is that when they pass, you will never be short of people to remember them with. In 20 years you'll be at a bar and get chatting to some random person who knew him, they'll have great stories to share you can both raise a toast to him.
Sounds like he's already been celebrated with every video Cypher made and will make.
Rest in peace phil sounded like a great guy, sorry for your loss
I'm sorry to hear about Phil man. You have my condolences
Nice work. The "old west" is sorely under represented on you-tube. Would love more on the subject.
I'm working on a Lincoln County War video
@@CynicalHistorian Sweet!
Check out bloody beaver podcast! Really great stuff about the old west.
Cypher hearing your voice break was so hard man, thanks for doing what do you do, we all are thankful for your time and effort man, you're the best
OMG I met Phil Brigandi! RIP
I used to live in the OC and Riverside and SB counties and also visited the Ramona Pageant several times.
Sorry for your loss.
I'm sorry for the loss of your friend. That dedication is a kindness.
Very sorry for your loss, I'm sure you do Phil proud by continuing on your own career and sharing your knowledge and love of history with the rest of us.
I’m so sorry to hear about your loss. I love your videos and am sad I’m getting this on my feed 3 years later.
I am so sorry for your loss...you do great work and are very much appreciated
I am sorry for your loss-prayers to his family and all who knew him.
Ive been in that same exact situation a few years ago when my uncle died. He has a die hard liberal (few things we disagreed on), but had a passion for history. He either had a stroke in the showe (he was a smoker), or he just slipped but whatever it was broke is neck. rest in peace Dave Wolverton
Well wherever he be heaven, hell, the abyss or nothingness may we hope to meet such a great sounding man their when our own time comes. I'm sorry for your loss and hope you the best in these trying times.
I'm sorry for ur loss buddy I know my message came late but u honor his name with ur continuous great work
Shout out to the natives out here in Nevada! The battles of pyramid lake are a neat piece to learn up in the north. I’m out here in Reno! And Rest In Peace to Phil, sorry for the loss of a great piece to our story. My wife and I are trying to see all of the historical markers around the state so we can appreciate the place we grew up.
Phil was the "Grand Plaquero" for a historical society we're in called E Clampus Vitus. We plaque a lot of sites in Nevada. Phil was in charge of keeping track of those monuments. If you're looking for good sites to visit, I'd highly recommend looking up ECV plaques. Just can't beat the local passion of a drinking historical society (or a historical drinking society, take your pick)
The Cynical Historian I’ll look into that! My neighbor growing up was a clamper but I didn’t have too many conversations with him. Born and raised out here and I feel like it’s still a brand new place.
Another vid well worth the time. Well done !! Sorry for your loss !!!
What a poignant tribute to a friend, fellow historian, and mentor. You're carrying the torch strong. Found this to be an insightful and thought provoking piece. Now, I have to read the paper. 💜
Much respect! 🌎🌄
So sorry for the loss. I know it hurts to lose a friend and mentor and i hope you and your family stay together during this sensitive time
My hat is off to the memory of Phil. The world sorely needs historians. How else are we going to remember our past?
I’m so sorry for your loss. May he Rest In Peace, and may his dedication and love for history live on through you.
I'm sorry for your loss. This video is a great tribute.
I hope you'll be able to continue your educational work on this platform, despite its apparent shortcomings.
rest in peace phil. its good that you spread his name. We die twice, once when you die for real and again when you are spoken of for the last time, and the 20 thousand people who saw this video will keep his memory alive
Great video Cypher, and sorry for your loss. Hope you're doing well during this crazy time
Keep up the great work you are doing! Love your channel. Phill sounds like an amazing individual. I'll light a candle in his memory and honer.... And read a book he has written.
Dude, I am so sorry for your loss. He sounds like a great person and I’m sure he would be very proud of you!
A great video on a sad history. I especially like that last quote.
Just discovered your channel, I'm so sorry for your loss.
Sorry to for loss, it took alot of dedication & professionalism to go on with this video as if he was still here to help you do so
My deepest condolences CH, may Phil rest in peace, and his memory be a blessing.
I have to say, You Tube tends to let me down with it's channel recommendations, but this is a really good channel. I'm hooked.
RIP Phil
Great vid as usual, Cypher.
Sorry about your loss. Thank you for the videos. Maybe you could do some content on 3 rivers kings canyon sequoia ❤️💪🏼
Who, how am I’m just finding out about you??? Omg. Amazing content. I think I love you.
I'm sorry for your loss Cypher. Phil sounded like a great guy.
You should definitely try to tackle the history of the Mormons in the west. I looked a little into their history for a class paper recently, and holy hell did I fall into a rabbit hole of confusion and controversy in the little bit that I researched. I think you might find some interesting material to make a video/discussion about.
It is definitely an interesting peice of history and to some extent legend.
I am most sorry for your loss.
Very sorry for your loss. He may be gone but his work lives on in written form and in you, as well anyone he worked with. RIP
Sorry for your loss Cypher
Cheers to Phil, you beautiful man.
My condolences on your loss
What a great video!
As a resident of Las Vegas and someone whose been through Nelson plenty of times, I really appreciate you explaining the history of Eldorado Canyon.
Rest in Peace Phil 🇺🇸✝️
Yeah a year later and I'm first seeing this and hearing the vibrato in your voice I know what it feels like to hurt when you're trying to speak about someone. Trust me bro there's something better on the other side for the good ones..
I'm as cynical as you but I know the universe cannot punish us. I refuse to believe that this testing ground that we are currently on does not reward us at the end. No maybe that's my judeo Christian background but I'm as much of an atheist can possibly be but that scared as I am of the other side because I don't know. I want to truly believe that there is something better on the other side.
When I lost my first & only son (26 months) over 10 years ago, the only thing people can say is I'm sorry for your loss and nothing that people say can ever ever ever be enough. Everything happens for a reason my ass. I feel you and I'm glad that you're using the adversity as fuel not cynicism or procrastination. Thank you for all that you do and thank you now for the future videos and future books all your future productions I will be supporting them Joe.
Damned good video.
I'm sorry for your loss.
Damn it you made me cry and it wasn't even 2 minutes in. I'm so sorry. For Phil
My deepest condolences, Cypher. ❤
Beautiful!
I'm sorry for your loss. Though we are historians so we will not forget Phil.
Sorry for your loss. May he rest in power.
That’s tragic man, my thoughts and prayers goes out to you and your family.
Saw this thumbnail in my notifications, really thought the background was just one big pizza.
my colorization skills are lacking
So very sorry for your loss.
Damn, Cypher. Phil sounds like he was a great guy. You have my condolences, man.
Hearing those Nevada town names are giving me Fallout New Vegas flash backs!
I’m so sorry for your loss
I just came across your channel and immediately subscribed thank you for uploading such great content, also I want to extend my condolences to you and Phil's family .
Sorry for your loss.
I'm sad for your loss, dude 😔
Well done. Rest in peace Phil history is more complete having known you
Same age as my dad. He had a massive heart attack in december and lives to tell the tale..
Awesome content dude! I love history. I found that out in 8th grade when we started US history not ancient BS. At first I was exiled to the corner for bieng disruptive then as it got interesting to me i was let back into the general population cuz i got a freekin A+. Sje made a whole announcement how i was the worst then a A student. It felt good. I was still the devil in all other periods tho heheh.
Condolonces for Phil Brigandi
Hey quick question, you mentioned the Indians, part of the posse, shot the body of the dead outlaw. Was there any mention of why they might have done so? I have a few theories: maybe religious implications like thinking he was a wendigo, or maybe they blamed him for the continuing violence between the two groups. However, this is just speculation on my part.
Anyways, great video, and sorry for your loss.
I’m really sorry to hear about your friend
4:09 Laughs! "The Old Spanish Trail"
I'm sorry for your loss
Sorry for your loss man:/
I'd love to see your take on the "Willy Boy" story.
The last posse of the old west.
Aka,how a feud between a chief & his would be son-in-law became a man hunt.
May Phil rest in peace.
#LANDBACK
I never want to hear you cry again :( so sad
RIP phil
My condolences, bud.
We will miss you Phil
RIP Phil
I'm extremely sorry for your and your family's loss
I’d have to say the underlying causes of the Paiute killings vs the 10/1 shooting were very, very different, if not complete opposites.
Condolence for your lose.
Hugs hugs hugs
Those Indians sound like really cool dudes.
Although I love history, I can never become a historian, I’m just too biased on many the things taught in history.
Rip Phil I hope your doing okay
CH, if you want to do more research vis a vis Indians, how about taking on Alternative Hypothesis' recent video denying the genocide of Indians? I get if you don't want to even acknowledge him but it'd be interesting to see an actual video on it.
Somewhat related, just bought RED DEAD REDEMPTION II to help me sit out the virus
May your uncle rest in peace
RIP Phil Burgundy
RIP Phil, at least he is now at rest
R.I.P.
Rip
Not first
Wait, you know how to pronounce Nevada?!
.
I'm sorry to hear about your woes with the colossally pathetic twits at YT. They should get out of the ad business - instead - creators should be expected to get advertising or revenue and then YT can take a cut (agreed upon in a contract betwixt creator and YT) to cover the costs of their operations . . . they are a platform _not_ a publisher . . .
First
Please stop calling us indians.
OMG I met Phil Brigandi! RIP
I used to live in the OC and Riverside and SB counties and also visited the Ramona Pageant several times.
Sorry for your loss.
RIP Phil
RIP phil