STOP Doing CALISTHENICS. Do This Instead.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 164

  • @LeeWeiland
    @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +14

    🛑 Don't miss the point of this video. Free Training: www.pacificrimathletics.com/online-reg?el=yt-calisthentics-is-bad Don't mistake videos for instruction. Positive vibes ONLY. Subscribe so you can make progress. See you in training.

    • @jenniferbongalon1758
      @jenniferbongalon1758 4 місяці тому

      how am i gonna train like i should following your advice when there are no powerbatics communities in our country that i know of coach Lee?
      i wanna do what you do, but i wanna do it under your watchful eye so i can learn from you everything that i need to do.... and not do😔

  • @MithutheBakra
    @MithutheBakra Рік тому +12

    Don't let the title fool you. The main idea is to fill in the gaps where calisthenics fails (he says this himself later in the vid).

  • @robertgeiger42
    @robertgeiger42 Рік тому +257

    I disagree. How do you know strength/athleticism isn’t being gained when doing calisthenics? It’s anecdotal and subjective. For me personally, I gained immense strength, mobility, flexibility, and athleticism once I started doing cali’s 13mo ago and been weight lifting for 15 years. I love your videos but this one didn’t do anything for me.

    • @eacali.17
      @eacali.17 Рік тому +45

      He never said those things won't be built he is basically saying add variety to your workouts you may be able to do a hollow body hold but can u mirror it with a back bridge? Powerbatics training will definitely help you with Cali and lifting.

    • @weichseltraut
      @weichseltraut Рік тому +15

      It's all individual. For me it answers the question I've been asking myself lately. I'm training calisthenics for about 1 year, now I feel weaker after every session. My training focussed to much on one specific point instead of movement itself, now I know for sure..

    • @eacali.17
      @eacali.17 Рік тому +3

      @@weichseltraut thx for the input and good luck on your journey.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +55

      1. Athleticism is typically referring to competitive sport or one's ability to perform at that level and not fitness/exercise. Strength, flexibility, and mobility are but singular aspects, in addition to power (a form of strength), skill (strength applied), and sustainability (strength over long term). This is part of the problem many see in Crossfit, i.e. that they tried to turn fitness into a sport. It's just not the same thing. Sport has a high degree of variability and unpredictability, which traditional calisthenics (not freestyle or competitive) as a modality of *fitness* simply does not have, which is why we use Ninja Strength (similar to calisthenics) as but 1 element of Powerbatics training. We understood its 1-dimensionality from the very get-go. And that's part of why we built katas into each element...to foster the other aspects of strength such as skill, sustainability, etc.
      2. If by anecdotal and subjective you mean 1000's of data points, 1000's of students (many of whom are competitive athletes and performers), and nearly a decade officially (unofficially 30 years of teaching)...then sure 😂
      3. Glad you like the videos. Don't miss the point in this one. Hope this reply helps clarify for the masses.
      Btw, nobody really needs to get bent out of shape...train however you want, it's not the end of the world.

    • @ahmedjaved7711
      @ahmedjaved7711 Рік тому +7

      I like this guys approach to be passionate but also then not care either

  • @Back2NatureZeroHero
    @Back2NatureZeroHero Рік тому +103

    That's why I am practising not only calisthenics but animal flow, breakdancing, inline skating, capoeira, tai chi even juggling and now powerbatics. All these things are developing you in so many different ways.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +14

      There ya go

    • @BronzeFury3
      @BronzeFury3 Рік тому

      True approach👍💪

    • @RedZambala
      @RedZambala Рік тому +3

      Have you time for life, work, studies, meditations?!

    • @BronzeFury3
      @BronzeFury3 Рік тому +2

      @@RedZambala this is life if you have not noticed.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +6

      People don't realize how much they can do in a day

  • @RakanXYZ
    @RakanXYZ Рік тому +39

    I agree that calisthenics culture is dogmatic about maintaining strict form and most movements are performed in the sagittal plane with little focus on transverse and other rotations. This has become a much more pronounced issue for me over the last year. Calisthenics should be about building strength and dynamism in movements, and increasing range of motion and achieving your bodies optimal functional potential. Ring based Gymnastics is the closest and ancestoral relative to calisthenics and is about connecting skills and allowing things to flow in a rhthym and unfortunately this was lost somewhere in the evolutionary path, and isometric skill movements are seen as the pinnacle of calisthenic success.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +8

      Good post. You could help write our videos.

    • @polepino
      @polepino Рік тому

      Interesting, are you saying that calisthenics was the ancestor of gymnastics? I always thought the opposite. My training combines bits of both and some weights.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +1

      Just train

  • @erickesquivel8609
    @erickesquivel8609 Рік тому +1

    Thought the title was click bait, stuck around, subscribed. Great insights and application of principles!

  • @cookieMonsterSincho
    @cookieMonsterSincho Рік тому +8

    Tried some of the beginner katas, they are killer! But by working on many of the athletics statics those katas can improve, I think calisthenics is just a modern word for part of athletics, which give a great base to develop more smart training systems, and this can not be a bad thing in my humble opinion, any way thank you for inspiration 🙌💪

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +5

      How did katas go? Basically I'm trying to share more depth that connects movement, coordination, etc. so people can understand how to get to higher, more creative levels. Static, calisthenics-oriented like Ninja Strength, etc. are just a small piece of the puzzle.

    • @cookieMonsterSincho
      @cookieMonsterSincho Рік тому

      @@LeeWeiland tried to jump 360 degrees from the horse stand and it was really challenging for me )) a did not have the coordination to do so )

    • @cookieMonsterSincho
      @cookieMonsterSincho Рік тому +1

      @@LeeWeilandI’m so impressed by the holistic method you share, with my little background in yoga, I can say that you are an advocate of an amazing approach with combination of explosive movement with hardcore training and flexibility.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Right on

  • @AverageGabriel
    @AverageGabriel Рік тому +5

    Why you do this to me... I might as well stop exercise completely because now imt so confused.
    Everyone has something new to say to bring all my training and experience back to square one with hard questions.
    I think I'm just gonna give up watching UA-cam. ☠️
    Everything is bad for my gains now.

  • @onofresilva9325
    @onofresilva9325 Рік тому +3

    You complicating this for me, now I don't know what to do. Thanks! I just want to look good and be strong, being strong as having strength. Now I'm lost

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +9

      Being lost is the way to new discovery.

  • @generalkowalski8507
    @generalkowalski8507 9 місяців тому

    this video was quite insightful and inspirational, thanks for sharing this.

  • @Lawfulassembly
    @Lawfulassembly Рік тому +14

    Thanks Lee, you really put some good things into perspective and I totally agree with you. As you always say you're only as strong as your weakest link. I've experienced this time and time again with many different injuries and I am someone who tries to work on every part of my body and always challenged it and new ways to keep getting stronger

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Awesome, thanks for being here

    • @SameLif3
      @SameLif3 Рік тому +1

      @@LeeWeilandwhat are ur thoughts on gymnastics for men?

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Better more well rounded more fun things can be done

  • @michel8620
    @michel8620 Рік тому

    Dankjewel Lee:) Nu begonnen met free training:) Gr. Michel uit Holland:)

  • @LoveJJWiley
    @LoveJJWiley Рік тому +2

    Hello, Lee Wieland, the Calisthenics Guru! Greetings from the charming Menomonie, WI, a stone's throw away from the booming Eau Claire, the 4th fastest-growing city in the U.S.! It's fascinating to watch your videos, but it's also a bit bittersweet. You see, we're missing out on a key ingredient - a dedicated gym to put those teachings into practice. How fantastic would it be to have a vibrant calisthenics haven right here? Imagine the ripples it could create in our health-conscious community! 🎉👍

  • @darlenecarruthers-shelton837
    @darlenecarruthers-shelton837 Рік тому +2

    Thank You! I need strength in those areas, badly. Now I truly understand! Thank You

  • @regprofant8609
    @regprofant8609 Рік тому +4

    It sounds great but I’m 80 years old with a bad right knee and left shoulder but they are gradually getting better. So where’s your facility?

  • @eacali.17
    @eacali.17 Рік тому +17

    I just finished an offload weak and decided to hit a frog stand while watching this. I Accidently leaned too far forward and had to hit a bent arm tuck handstand in a split second to control it and avoid a face plant. That ninja strength is no joke 😂Great vid Lee👍🏿👍🏿

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +11

      Nice. I say things are "magic" because students often "accidentally" hit new moves. Example: front flip and as soon as you land hop half turn. Students will accidentally start landing front flip half twist. There's hundreds of these examples and frog stand is one. Frog stand for 60 seconds a day beats wall handstand every time. But people won't do the boring silly looking stuff.

    • @eacali.17
      @eacali.17 Рік тому +2

      @@LeeWeiland 100% 🔥

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +3

      🥷💪

    • @eacali.17
      @eacali.17 Рік тому +6

      @@LeeWeiland I respect how you're so interactive in the comments it always surprises me 😂

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Right on

  • @briolivia
    @briolivia Рік тому

    This is interesting. I'm getting into calisthenics to help with my pole journey. Joint mobility is a MUST. Definitely going to subscribe

  • @davidj6702
    @davidj6702 Рік тому +12

    Love and appreciate the knowledge your passing on to guys like me who looking for a new way of training. Keep it up man

  • @JuicyxJosh
    @JuicyxJosh 7 місяців тому

    From what I can take from all of this is just don’t limit yourself when it comes to training. That’s all.

  • @finnjuniperdenaro
    @finnjuniperdenaro Рік тому +1

    So Great! Thank you Lee! ♡

  • @potterspride1
    @potterspride1 Рік тому +4

    I came across a guru once stating you should not follow just a single guru and expect them to guide you through your entire life. This video is essentially echoing that statement. Be your own guru people and seek out the wisdom of others. Thanks Lee, I knew you were a great coach.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +2

      And that's the way we structured our training...it's not just me coaching people it's a team so if there's things a person needs other PT's who know it better can hop in.

  • @Batterybus
    @Batterybus Рік тому +15

    Personally I have found from experience both weights and Calisthenics are essential for strength and mobility.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +5

      They're both helpful tools but the scope of the video is beyond that

    • @Batterybus
      @Batterybus Рік тому +1

      @LeeWeiland Understood. BTW. Have you considered writing a book on, say, the very basics? I think it would be great.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +1

      Not really. I like making videos. Maybe one day we'll make a multi-volume set of books or something.

    • @Batterybus
      @Batterybus Рік тому +2

      @@LeeWeiland Put me down for a copy/copies. 🙂 Love your site.

    • @mcharbo8726
      @mcharbo8726 Рік тому +1

      @@LeeWeiland Yeah, even a print-out PDF or ring-bound book with basic photos, organized by progressive movements would be a nice thing. Trying to avoid screens while doing workouts, but following along with the videos or writing down the progressions/katas is cumbersome. I know, I know it's an excuse, but - just sayin', someone would buy the book ;)

  • @PauloBerni699
    @PauloBerni699 Рік тому

    The program reminds me of Ginastica Natural and Integral Bambu. The former, a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu sólo movement and mobility based flow incorporating animal and gymnastics like movements conducive to grappling athleticism. The latter is a system of navigating through a complex bamboo pole structure with one’s whole body requiring strength, agility, and momentum, clinging at times and fluid whole body motions at other times. This is also rooted in Brazilian workout culture.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Skills then dynacombos then katas...powerful movement

  • @HeavyMachinesVision
    @HeavyMachinesVision Рік тому

    Is training calisthenic until become master can be good for martial arts? I mean, for fighting preparation

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Not really...calisthenics is too linear

  • @savagetheentertainer
    @savagetheentertainer Рік тому +8

    So what's freestyle calisthenics? Because that's all dynamics and transitions

  • @kushagragupta8068
    @kushagragupta8068 Рік тому +1

    You nneed to make powerbatics tutorial videos now.

  • @majorphenom1
    @majorphenom1 Рік тому

    Thanks for sharing 🙏🏾

  • @joh_kun5530
    @joh_kun5530 Рік тому +3

    Combining the building of strength in the basics, weight training, bodybuilding and those Katas you mentioned sounds pretty good to me. Stacking this on top of some sort of martial art would build me a pretty damn athletic physique.
    Would a more freestyle approach to those Katas be an appropriate or good alternative however?
    And how about weak link training? Overloading exercises and positions that a majority would deem dangerous, what are your thoughts on that?

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +2

      Learn organized training first before freestyle anything

  • @TheJerry44
    @TheJerry44 Рік тому +1

    3:25 War Eagle!

  • @Learn_Listen_Love
    @Learn_Listen_Love Рік тому

    Great video

  • @Khalid-qk3tq
    @Khalid-qk3tq Рік тому +1

    Can I do them in home because I’m have super social anxiety and depression but I want to work out and become more healthy because I’m fat skinny and I think my body isn’t great looking

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Don't worry about anything...you're a masterpiece

  • @BorealScott
    @BorealScott Рік тому +1

    Very useful!

  • @domi4231
    @domi4231 3 місяці тому

    where is this trainings place

  • @taekfute
    @taekfute Рік тому +1

    Fair

  • @truefistofthenorthstar2044
    @truefistofthenorthstar2044 Рік тому +5

    But coach Lee isn't all of that in essence typically called calisthenics?

  • @avezmeie5322
    @avezmeie5322 Рік тому

    Man you look like Damien Tomaso (Cyril Raffaelli) from District 13 ;D

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +1

      Cyril was one of my influences for freerunning. Solid singular flips.

  • @maxgeorge5376
    @maxgeorge5376 Рік тому +2

    Yes, I agree.
    Learning some calisthenic tricks not enough.
    Running 1min should be better.

  • @santoss5807
    @santoss5807 Рік тому +4

    Parkour and tricking are better then :))

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +4

      In some regards yes. But the wear and tear on joints will require upkeep through a Ninja Strength style training.

  • @GeraltOfRivia99
    @GeraltOfRivia99 11 місяців тому

    This modern world we live in is destroying me does anyone else in the western world want a total culture change? i wish there was some kind of retreat, group of people or different city i can move to where theres no internet, no fast food, active lifestyle and physical labour job. Theres so much corporate greed, fast food restaurants, beer stores and junk bombarded in our face today and its destroying people

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  11 місяців тому

      I shared this with our team. It's a good reminder of the mission and vision of our company.

  • @BillyJStorm
    @BillyJStorm Рік тому +1

    Struggling with the back bridge twist in lvl 1 handstand kata - reckon prolly need my hands under my shoulder more...

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +1

      Yes that's typical. Usually shoulder and upper spine mobility.

    • @BillyJStorm
      @BillyJStorm Рік тому

      Thank you for your reply, much appreciated 🙏

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Thanks for being here

  • @L.Lavender
    @L.Lavender Рік тому +1

    Hello Lee, I am writing to you here as I filled out a Linked In application to a remote video editing position for your company Pacific Rim Athletics. I just wanted to confirm with you if this is in fact a legitimate position coming out of your company as I have some suspicions. Thank you so much.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Yes we are seeking a highly qualified video editor. However, there is also scams that happen through Indeed so watch out.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      And no it is not from Linked In. Our job is on Indeed.

    • @L.Lavender
      @L.Lavender Рік тому

      @@LeeWeiland Okay, I did apply on Linked In, so I guess that was a scam. If you are looking for a video editor I am interested, where would I apply?

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      We advertise through Indeed

  • @ahmadmohammed8534
    @ahmadmohammed8534 Рік тому

    hello @LeeWeiland i train 6 days a week i do a push pull legs calisthenics ofc but should i do holds on one day and motion in another day for example frogpose and some other holds on Munday and on Thursdays i do different types of pushups or should i just mise them together and time is not a problem for me btw

  • @LukaszStolarczuk
    @LukaszStolarczuk Рік тому

    That is why I do calisthenics and capoeira. ^_^

  • @hwowownkyouma8702
    @hwowownkyouma8702 Рік тому

    so should i make a session involving all my skills and just mess around doing stuff that develops my skills more to actual situations

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      There's a balance between systemization and organic

  • @mcharbo8726
    @mcharbo8726 Рік тому

    Suggestions for those of us folks who can't afford to come down to train? ie. Anyone from Canada? Aside from finding a community and coach with ur lvl of experience, resources and discipline?

    • @mcharbo8726
      @mcharbo8726 Рік тому +3

      This video got to me. I hit a wall with weightlifting. The same wall I hit with Yoga - the moves are isolated and improvement is on apparently within the limited range of the exercises. Calisthenics seemed to be a better direction for me, but you're right - it is still isolated and geared towards the "peak" moves like muscle up, planche, front-lever, etc.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Online Training with my team. Msg them and they'll help you.

  • @mohbel4884
    @mohbel4884 Рік тому +4

    Calestnics is at least using th3 hole b9dy and core all9ng with any exercise hich is lack8ng big time in power lifting that's isolating muscles 2hich is lese than one dimension

  • @Nebuala
    @Nebuala Рік тому

    So would calisthenics still work if I don’t isolate training like all on the bar I do a muscle up into a planche at the top and then go into a crab stance on top

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Still work?

    • @void_ling
      @void_ling Рік тому +1

      ⁠@@LeeWeilandI believe what they mean is could slight modifications to calisthenics exercises be effective for the goal of building “total body strength”.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Modifications aren't necessary...I think the point is being missed...I'll work on being more clear in future videos

  • @mooodoo4544
    @mooodoo4544 Рік тому

    Where can i watch the handstand moves you described?

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      They're sprinkled throughout our videos and channels.

    • @mooodoo4544
      @mooodoo4544 Рік тому

      @@LeeWeiland is there a video which sums them up?

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      Released tomorrow on powerbatics channel

  • @profie24
    @profie24 Рік тому +2

    How can I prevent tendonitis, that's my biggest obstacle that always sets me way back when I'm in the middle of training. Training according to body feeling doesn't work I never really get muscle soreness and have no useful feedback from the body on how long I need to take a break. My new approach now is to create a sophisticated training plan and stay 30% below muscle failure in 90% of the training time. Do you have any experience with this? Your athletes do training that looks extremely hard and super prone to tendonitis.

    • @ieatalot2
      @ieatalot2 Рік тому

      Same here. 😩

    • @cozmo8849
      @cozmo8849 Рік тому

      Static isometric or overcoming isometrics for the specific area.

  • @prateekl968
    @prateekl968 Рік тому +1

    After so many years I finally see something new 😳😯

  • @gingobingo1567
    @gingobingo1567 Рік тому +6

    But you have a lot of videos saying chalistenics is very good.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому +3

      Where? I rarely even use the word "calisthenics." It's just a tool, and a tool can be used for good or bad. We teach Powerbatics...and Ninja Strength (similar to calisthenics) is just 1 element therein.

    • @gingobingo1567
      @gingobingo1567 Рік тому +1

      @@LeeWeiland Ok maybe not using the word chalistenics but you have a lot of videos on the "V stance" for example.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      V stand is just a human static position

  • @josephmalone253
    @josephmalone253 Рік тому

    How long is training? I need the full works.

    • @LeeWeiland
      @LeeWeiland  Рік тому

      We have students up to 8 years running now...like Vennie

  • @peposo7
    @peposo7 Рік тому

    Wow. Voltron...😁