Overtime and you may disagree with this, people have come around respecting Tommy’s game including myself. Boring character and obvious winner edit yes, but people have opened their eyes to how impressive his game was despite not having idols, no immunity wins, no advantages, and avoiding making fire. He relied solely on his social bonds and adapted to any bad situation thrown his way. Meanwhile Ben has to use idols in back to back tribal councils and win fire making to stay in the game in three consecutive rounds.
Thought we were ranking winners not seasons. Tommy is a decent player having a great social game. The season is absolutely trash but Tommy is a good winner
I actually found the Dan storyline fascinating. Yeah it was icky but I like a little controversy. And the drama with Janet, Missy and Elisabeth - riveting TV in my opinion. Finally we have contestants not acting like boring gamebots. Sorry but I thought the Dan stuff made the season more interesting, not worse.
Even putting aside the obvious fact that it’s Dan all that that story does is help out boring and unlikable people and actively fuck over the best characters
Mine would have been : Richard Hatch : BORING Tina Wesson : WOO YEAH BABY! Ethan Zohn : It is perfect down to the last minute detail Vecepia Towery : That was...AMAZING! Brian Heidik : THROW TV Jenna Morasca : THROW TV Sandra Diaz Twine : That was....AMAZING! Amber Bkrich : Nice Chris Daughtery : Nice Tom Wesman : Nice Danni Boatwright : WOO YEAH BABY! Aras Basakauskas : Nice Yul Kwon : That was....AMAZING! Earl Cole : That was.....AMAZING! Todd Herzog : Nice Parvati Shallow : That was....AMAZING! Bob Crowley : Nice JT Thomas: WOO YEAH BABY! Natalie White : BORING Sandra Diaz Twine : That was..AMAZING! Judd Fabio Birza : WOO YEAH BABY! Boston Rob Mariano : That was...AMAZING! Sophie Clarke : Nice Kim Spradlin : WOO YEAH BABY! Denise Stapley : That was...AMAZING! John Cochran : That was....AMAZING! Tyson Apostol : Nice Tony Vlachos : Nice Natalie Anderson : That was....AMAZING! Mike Holloway : Nice Jeremy Collins : WOO YEAH BABY! Michelle Fitzgerald : WOO YEAH BABY! Adam Klein : That was perfect, down to the last minute detail Sarah Lacina : WOO YEAH BABY! Ben Driebergen : WOO YEAH BABY! Wendell Holland : Nice Nick Wilson : Nice Chris Underwood : I mean, it's alright Tommy Sheehan : Throws tv Tony Vlachos : WOO YEAH BABY! Erika Casupanan : WOO YEAH BABY! Maryanne Oketch : It was perfect down to the last minute detail Mike Gabler : Throws TV Yamyam Arocho : That was...AMAZING Dee Valladres : That was...AMAZING Kenzie Petty : I mean, it's alright
For the most part I can agree with these. Tony has 2 of the best winner stories ever. Yul has a great story despite the messiness of his season. Glad Rob's story got a more so positive meme since he's entertaining and his great gameplay is the only compelling part of that season.
The volcano was truly one of the more compelling characters 😂 and the long game joke of Rob calling Philip fat then Tyson calling him a portly chap later. 🎉
I'm gonna be honest here, I don't know how any of these ranking relate to each other. I guess Perfect is the top one, and Ron Swanson throwing away the thing is the bottom. But other than that...
I thought they were all going to be different but I guess I’ve wasted 3 mins of my life on way dumber things (like writing this comment) all the love haha ❤
Just a friendly reminder this is not about gameplay it’s about story and entertainment factor
@@myperspectiveisimnotblind My opinion of each winner's story. It isn't that deep.
You're gonna piss a lot of people off with this video
I love it
Fabio's story was excellent: bro chilled the whole season and won million bucks
Can we give some slack to Natalie White? It's not fully her fault that her winning story is BARELY shown to us 😭
I am Natalie big fan, but even I must admit that it wasn't shown because it wasn't that interesting
I was ready to swing when i knew Yul was coming up. You passed the vibe check.
He's my favorite Survivor winner, and I'm glad to see him recognized in this vid!
Tommy was a boring character but like rob said. If you win you win and hate it or not he played a great game
Most underrated winner. Played an old school game in new school Survivor
It is Dee-Cent😂😂😂
45 was indeed, Dee-cent.
Overtime and you may disagree with this, people have come around respecting Tommy’s game including myself. Boring character and obvious winner edit yes, but people have opened their eyes to how impressive his game was despite not having idols, no immunity wins, no advantages, and avoiding making fire. He relied solely on his social bonds and adapted to any bad situation thrown his way. Meanwhile Ben has to use idols in back to back tribal councils and win fire making to stay in the game in three consecutive rounds.
That is why Ben's winner story is more fun.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Fun doesn’t mean great gameplay
Right, but the title of this video...
You know the video is good when it's made by Once Upon an Island
It is deeeeeecent. Tell'em lad.
I just can’t help but get over how perfectly you nailed Tony in 40. The GOAT.
Once Upon an Island posts a meme video.
Me: WOO YEAH BABY!
Thought we were ranking winners not seasons. Tommy is a decent player having a great social game. The season is absolutely trash but Tommy is a good winner
Ranking winner stories. How compelling is their individual story?
Tommy sucks because he supported Dan
Dan is a turd in the Island of the Idols cereal bowl. Even if I pick the turd out of the bowl, I still have no interest in that bowl of cereal.
I actually found the Dan storyline fascinating. Yeah it was icky but I like a little controversy. And the drama with Janet, Missy and Elisabeth - riveting TV in my opinion. Finally we have contestants not acting like boring gamebots. Sorry but I thought the Dan stuff made the season more interesting, not worse.
Even putting aside the obvious fact that it’s Dan all that that story does is help out boring and unlikable people and actively fuck over the best characters
Tom Westman will always be my GOAT
Mine would have been :
Richard Hatch : BORING
Tina Wesson : WOO YEAH BABY!
Ethan Zohn : It is perfect down to the last minute detail
Vecepia Towery : That was...AMAZING!
Brian Heidik : THROW TV
Jenna Morasca : THROW TV
Sandra Diaz Twine : That was....AMAZING!
Amber Bkrich : Nice
Chris Daughtery : Nice
Tom Wesman : Nice
Danni Boatwright : WOO YEAH BABY!
Aras Basakauskas : Nice
Yul Kwon : That was....AMAZING!
Earl Cole : That was.....AMAZING!
Todd Herzog : Nice
Parvati Shallow : That was....AMAZING!
Bob Crowley : Nice
JT Thomas: WOO YEAH BABY!
Natalie White : BORING
Sandra Diaz Twine : That was..AMAZING!
Judd Fabio Birza : WOO YEAH BABY!
Boston Rob Mariano : That was...AMAZING!
Sophie Clarke : Nice
Kim Spradlin : WOO YEAH BABY!
Denise Stapley : That was...AMAZING!
John Cochran : That was....AMAZING!
Tyson Apostol : Nice
Tony Vlachos : Nice
Natalie Anderson : That was....AMAZING!
Mike Holloway : Nice
Jeremy Collins : WOO YEAH BABY!
Michelle Fitzgerald : WOO YEAH BABY!
Adam Klein : That was perfect, down to the last minute detail
Sarah Lacina : WOO YEAH BABY!
Ben Driebergen : WOO YEAH BABY!
Wendell Holland : Nice
Nick Wilson : Nice
Chris Underwood : I mean, it's alright
Tommy Sheehan : Throws tv
Tony Vlachos : WOO YEAH BABY!
Erika Casupanan : WOO YEAH BABY!
Maryanne Oketch : It was perfect down to the last minute detail
Mike Gabler : Throws TV
Yamyam Arocho : That was...AMAZING
Dee Valladres : That was...AMAZING
Kenzie Petty : I mean, it's alright
Todd deserves the goat meme or the awesome meme
Tommy deserves the it's alright meme! I thought his social game was good!
Will there be a runner up edition, lmao?
Brian in season 4 was hilarious, definitely not boring. Also he played a solid social and physical game
S5
That works ! I wonder what they've cooked up for Survivor 50 ?
For the most part I can agree with these. Tony has 2 of the best winner stories ever. Yul has a great story despite the messiness of his season. Glad Rob's story got a more so positive meme since he's entertaining and his great gameplay is the only compelling part of that season.
The volcano was truly one of the more compelling characters 😂 and the long game joke of Rob calling Philip fat then Tyson calling him a portly chap later. 🎉
Imagine throwing away your tv for Tommy's win but not Ben's lel
*For Tommy's story
can someone explain to me what the soccer meme means? i don’t really get it
It is deeeeecent. Tell'em lad.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Ah. i hear it now. at first i thought it was them saying too soon
I love these 😂😂😂
These are fun.
And surprisingly, no one got the Steve Carell meme! 😅
savage
So you only know 6 memes?
9 were used in this video, 10 in yesterday's. I am open to meme suggestions for next year's video.
Calling Mike Holloway perfect and Natalie Anderson decent?! What a crazy world we live in
*Their stories.
@@OnceUponAnIsland yeah, I ready the title, doesn’t change anything for me 🤷🏻♀️
You’re decent for V and Todd, Kim ..Unacceptable.
For their stories? Yes.
You’re right! The show sucked at telling their stories. 🫶🏽
I'm gonna be honest here, I don't know how any of these ranking relate to each other. I guess Perfect is the top one, and Ron Swanson throwing away the thing is the bottom. But other than that...
Someone figured it out on yesterday's season rankings. I will see if anyone can figure it out here :)
*dumpster*
Booooring
I mean it’s alright
Deeeeeceeent
Yeah baby
Nice
That was awesome
That’s why he’s the goat
Perfect
Don't know why we're celebrating Ben and Gabler but okay
I thought they were all going to be different but I guess I’ve wasted 3 mins of my life on way dumber things (like writing this comment) all the love haha ❤
Brian deserves the worst possible tier for me lol
This was a another *click* nice video
how about merge episodes next
Cagayan: “It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details.”
You have a problem
Chris U - tv to trash can
He should go home at day 8
But his story is decent.
Gabler being the best winner of the new era is still the funniest shit ever
Can’t relate to B.Rob and Ben reactions 🤢🤢🤢
Pearl islands Sandra is so overrated.