God the timing of peter saying 'your trousers have fallen down' literally as the ship explodes takes me aback so much everytime like sir have some compassion
Fifth Doctor is my favorite because he can be rambling about anything and then out of nowhere will say shit like “I came and went like a summer cloud” and I think that shit’s beautiful and completely encapsulates him. Poetry
Honestly, these behind-the-scenes commentaries with the four of them always feel like they all snuck into a recording booth with drinks and watched their old episodes just to take the mick. Love it!
Honestly, I wish that chaotic energy had translated to the in-show character interactions because this team are my absolute favourite when it comes to audio commentary 😂
haha I think it does a little but you’re right it would’ve been nice to have an even more chaotic tardis team. i love this cast though they’re hilarious
Fifth Doctor - The oldest, wiser and mature brother Nyssa - The mature older sister Adric and Tegan - The annoying younger siblings that everyone loves and hates
They absolutely would have done if this was modern Who. I wouldn’t be surprised if a significant portion of Tenant and Smith’s TARDIS teams dialogue was taken verbatim from actual conversations between the actors.
That's what really frustrates me. Jan and Peter specifically have a really good relationship, Peter gently winding up Janet at every opportunity, Janet going off on one. I cannot conceive of why, when faced with such obvious chemistry between the two, they decided to limit their characters to 'grumpy bitch who hates the TARDIS' and 'ever so nice and affable but rather boring as a result'. Its a tragic waste. It could have been one of the best TARDIS teams if they actually allowed them to behave like people. JNT was...you know, bad.
I've always enjoyed the cast commentary on the Pete Davidson videos with this line up. It's like they're doing a cross between nostalgia and Mystery Science Theater 3000.
Watching the commentary for Earthshock was like watching an episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000 where the main cast laughed and giggled at the bad special effects, actors who had no idea what they were doing on the show and bloopers like when the script supervisor was standing on set turning pages in a binder. Even so, Earthshock is one of my favorite stories from the original run of Doctor Who.
I already adore these and I'm not even halfway through this video! I have a humble request for a video like this for The Five Doctors' commentary, since there's a moment where they all say "no not the mind probe!" together. That, and K9 and Company (which is an hour of Elisabeth Sladen and John Leeson regretting every second of doing the show).
I would love to do a Five Doctors commentary but unfortunately I don’t have a copy of it at the moment! If I manage to get my hands on it I will though :) I should be able to do the K9 and Company one I just need to listen to it first lol
Peter Davidson is my favourite fifth because he and jannet fildeing give a great profamce as the fifth doctor and Tegan and Sara Sutton give great profamce as Nyssa
Time seems to heal most wounds - I had no idea they had good commentary tracks on the releases - it is just great to hear them laugh and say things in jest with each other
“I don’t remember any of this.” Is Matthew suppressing memories due to bullying PTSD? I’ve heard that the only person who would have lunches with him at Conventions was Deborah Watling. (RIP)
I've seen all of Peter Davison's episodes only once (when I made my way through the series, so most of them I've only seen once) but I have great appreciation for him as the Doctor, and he seems like a great guy in real life.
honestly there’s so many good little quips like that from the cast it’s sometimes hard to condense it down to less than 10 minutes lmao. also some of them unfortunately don’t work too well without more context but I’d love to include them all!
@@na256 usually I have the DVDs with the audio commentaries and I just use handbrake and makemkv to convert them to mp4 (involves choosing the right audio track in handbrake etc.) A while ago I found torrents of a few stories that also had the audio commentary track but I don’t think they exist anymore? They were on internet archive and got taken down. The versions I come across on most sites don’t seem to have it 🤔 hope this helps!!
@@jread3906 I don’t necessarily think the cast believe classic who is ‘shit’ (perhaps moffat does but that’s another story). I mean yeah they do spend a lot of the time recounting ‘dodgy’ effects, sets and plots (to the extent of saying the same thing every time and even then it’s mostly Janet for the 5th Doctor stories, although nothing against her) but they also spend plenty of time praising what they did right. I’m not sure if you’ve personally watched any of the commentaries in full but of course you’re going to get a lot of the ‘look how stupid this was’ in my videos because I’ve personally handpicked out all the times the cast made funny quips about it. honestly fair enough if you have actually sat through hours of these commentaries and you’ve come to that conclusion, but I think that but to call Davison the ‘Shatner of Who’ is a bit much. He’s still a fan favourite and obviously the cast and crew still generally love him to bits. I don’t think he’s perfect but hey none of us are lmao. I think he also appreciates fans as long as you’re not crazy. And if he wanted to distance himself from the show he certainly wouldn’t still be acting in it.
The total lack of reverence at Adric's death has me in absolute tears every time.
"No, we were just trying not to laugh"
I remember crying the first time I saw it. And I did love that scene where Doctor #10 rescues him.
@@MsLogjam he never rescued adric, i think that's an edit someone made
@@amycatass Well, bummer.
"Stop making fun of my TARDIS" is such a Doctor thing to say, Pete. hahaha
God the timing of peter saying 'your trousers have fallen down' literally as the ship explodes takes me aback so much everytime like sir have some compassion
"Nothing to put your hands in now"
"No hands either"!
Fifth Doctor is my favorite because he can be rambling about anything and then out of nowhere will say shit like “I came and went like a summer cloud” and I think that shit’s beautiful and completely encapsulates him. Poetry
so true
Honestly, these behind-the-scenes commentaries with the four of them always feel like they all snuck into a recording booth with drinks and watched their old episodes just to take the mick. Love it!
tbh I don’t think you’re too far off the truth hahaha
@@fifthdoctor 🤣😂
My favorite commentary is the arc of Infinity with Peter teasing Colin he was after his job 😂
@@cdst8888 So funny!
Someone has said in the past that they “encourage” them by letting them drink hahahahaha
Honestly, I wish that chaotic energy had translated to the in-show character interactions because this team are my absolute favourite when it comes to audio commentary 😂
haha I think it does a little but you’re right it would’ve been nice to have an even more chaotic tardis team. i love this cast though they’re hilarious
Fifth Doctor - The oldest, wiser and mature brother
Nyssa - The mature older sister
Adric and Tegan - The annoying younger siblings that everyone loves and hates
They absolutely would have done if this was modern Who. I wouldn’t be surprised if a significant portion of Tenant and Smith’s TARDIS teams dialogue was taken verbatim from actual conversations between the actors.
That's what really frustrates me. Jan and Peter specifically have a really good relationship, Peter gently winding up Janet at every opportunity, Janet going off on one. I cannot conceive of why, when faced with such obvious chemistry between the two, they decided to limit their characters to 'grumpy bitch who hates the TARDIS' and 'ever so nice and affable but rather boring as a result'. Its a tragic waste. It could have been one of the best TARDIS teams if they actually allowed them to behave like people. JNT was...you know, bad.
They seem to be a little better about it in the Big Finish audios. But then, the folks at Big Finish seem to have a very chaotic energy themselves.
I've always enjoyed the cast commentary on the Pete Davidson videos with this line up. It's like they're doing a cross between nostalgia and Mystery Science Theater 3000.
yes honestly they never fail to disappoint :)
Weirdo role call
Peter
Janet
Sarah Sutton
Mattheeeew
Even if the writers never seemed to know what to do with their characters, it is gratifying that they all make for quite the team of actors 😂
7:17 Adric's death at the end of Earthshock was one of Doctor Who's saddest moments.
It really was matt(e) finish
Watching the commentary for Earthshock was like watching an episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000 where the main cast laughed and giggled at the bad special effects, actors who had no idea what they were doing on the show and bloopers like when the script supervisor was standing on set turning pages in a binder. Even so, Earthshock is one of my favorite stories from the original run of Doctor Who.
I already adore these and I'm not even halfway through this video! I have a humble request for a video like this for The Five Doctors' commentary, since there's a moment where they all say "no not the mind probe!" together. That, and K9 and Company (which is an hour of Elisabeth Sladen and John Leeson regretting every second of doing the show).
I would love to do a Five Doctors commentary but unfortunately I don’t have a copy of it at the moment! If I manage to get my hands on it I will though :) I should be able to do the K9 and Company one I just need to listen to it first lol
@@fifthdoctor ooohhhh lovely! Enjoy ☺️
Adric dies and they laugh. Same.
Even Matthew is laughing at his character dying!
This is one of the commentaries that I always return to on a bad day, along with Kinda, The Three Doctors, Frontier in Space and The Green Death.
This commentary can be summed up like this. "You can easily catch VD from a Cyberman's crotch". :D
pretty much!
“Matt(e) Finish” STOPPPP I’M CRYINGGGG 😂
Featuring the voices of:
-Peter Davison - Fifth Doctor
-Janet Fielding - Tegan
-Sarah Sutton - Nyssa
And
-Matthew Waterhouse - Adric
Why did it take me so long to get the Boom Boom Waterhouse joke?
I love it when the cast watch their episodes and have a giggle at how goofy it was🤣
Please make more of these! The Two Doctors commentary is hilarious there is so much to choose from 😂
The unison on "AIRLOCK" lol!
To quote David Banks from this episode, EXCELLENT.
I definitelly need to watch the rest of the audio commentary, it sounds great.
It’s pretty funny!
I am going to listen to the earth shock cometary at some point now that I have watched earth shock all the way through
Peter Davidson is my favourite fifth because he and jannet fildeing give a great profamce as the fifth doctor and Tegan and Sara Sutton give great profamce as Nyssa
I could listen to a podcast with these four.
@@imrustyokay me too tbh
I'm glad to find a fellow Fifth Doctor DVD commentary enjoyer! If you're still doing these I'd love to see Warriors of the Deep, that one's hilarious.
Oh yeah it’s definitely on the list! :)
Time seems to heal most wounds - I had no idea they had good commentary tracks on the releases - it is just great to hear them laugh and say things in jest with each other
“I don’t remember any of this.”
Is Matthew suppressing memories due to bullying PTSD?
I’ve heard that the only person who would have lunches with him at Conventions was Deborah Watling. (RIP)
i would hope not 😬
“This *is* Matt(e) Finish” wow okay that’s,,, poor Adric
I've seen all of Peter Davison's episodes only once (when I made my way through the series, so most of them I've only seen once) but I have great appreciation for him as the Doctor, and he seems like a great guy in real life.
oh what a delight!! its so cool to see that you uplodad these to youtube, hell yeah
If only they'd been like this in the show.
I wish you had the bit where Sarah Sutton sends up Beryl saying "Position your men down there"
honestly there’s so many good little quips like that from the cast it’s sometimes hard to condense it down to less than 10 minutes lmao. also some of them unfortunately don’t work too well without more context but I’d love to include them all!
Please make more of these.
Will do! There’s a few others on my tiktok (@fifthdoctor) but I will try and upload some more here soon :)
Adric was my least favourite companion, so I love this story 🥰
@@thenationaltimelyactionhou9328 💀
Such a great commentary.. cracks me up every time we have it on
why have I never listened to this before XD
the commentaries are hidden gems
He's just trodden in Snyder lol
i am a cyberman, i have come to destroy you :)
❤ this TARDIS team
Okay this video is amazing and all but you've got to tell me the app you used to get the gallifreyan icons for your phone apps
thanks lol i used this site to translate: adrian17.github.io/Gallifreyan/
and also the shortcuts app to change the app images :)
BOOM BOOM WATERHOUSE
Please do more videos like this
See, they couldn't get away of this in America. They're supposed to be so serious!
Unless, they're doing Rifftrax, of course....
I don't like Janet much, but she does rile up the others in a pretty entertaining way
2:52 😆
Black Orchid is even better !
part two :)
That was fun, thanks for that! 👍🙂
Man, Peter sounds really friendly in the commentary.
I’m detecting a hint of sarcasm
Where did this audio commentary come from? I need to hear more of this!
it’s on the earthshock dvd :)
2:59 I’m sorry but what do you use to make your phone look like that? I want some awesome skins too.
I used widgetsmith and shortcuts! :) I have an iPhone if that helps. you can look up tutorials online on how to customise your app icons.
Where do you get the audio commentaries from?
@@na256 usually I have the DVDs with the audio commentaries and I just use handbrake and makemkv to convert them to mp4 (involves choosing the right audio track in handbrake etc.) A while ago I found torrents of a few stories that also had the audio commentary track but I don’t think they exist anymore? They were on internet archive and got taken down. The versions I come across on most sites don’t seem to have it 🤔 hope this helps!!
is this from the dvd or the blu ray?
afaik it’s on both but I personally have the bluray copy :)
I'm a berk I know but this "wasn't classic Who shit" stuff sort of annoys me. Davison is the Shatner of Who now. Basically says we were all wankers!
@@jread3906 I don’t necessarily think the cast believe classic who is ‘shit’ (perhaps moffat does but that’s another story). I mean yeah they do spend a lot of the time recounting ‘dodgy’ effects, sets and plots (to the extent of saying the same thing every time and even then it’s mostly Janet for the 5th Doctor stories, although nothing against her) but they also spend plenty of time praising what they did right. I’m not sure if you’ve personally watched any of the commentaries in full but of course you’re going to get a lot of the ‘look how stupid this was’ in my videos because I’ve personally handpicked out all the times the cast made funny quips about it. honestly fair enough if you have actually sat through hours of these commentaries and you’ve come to that conclusion, but I think that but to call Davison the ‘Shatner of Who’ is a bit much. He’s still a fan favourite and obviously the cast and crew still generally love him to bits. I don’t think he’s perfect but hey none of us are lmao. I think he also appreciates fans as long as you’re not crazy. And if he wanted to distance himself from the show he certainly wouldn’t still be acting in it.
Crap like this is the reason the DVD/blueray is so overpriced. It's why I resort to watching the show illegally for free online.
lmao real. i pretty much try and watch everything for free and then just go and buy the DVDs anyway tho 😅