Fate/Stay Night | Bad Ending 1 Discussion

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 вер 2018
  • Support the channel - / tsiahiv
    Subscribe for more content: goo.gl/wvduQG
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 425

  • @someoneelse4939
    @someoneelse4939 5 років тому +177

    Illya: "Break-a-leg, onii-chan!"

  • @certifiedswordlover.417
    @certifiedswordlover.417 5 років тому +642

    Shirou emiya: when plot armor doesn't work.

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +71

      of course it doesn't work. He never had any to begin with. How can something that does not exist work

    • @certifiedswordlover.417
      @certifiedswordlover.417 5 років тому +20

      @@amakusashirou3679
      Hell it might as well should be against him than with him otherwise he might should have none.

    • @fbiuzz
      @fbiuzz 5 років тому +77

      Remember that alternate timelines are a thing in Type Moon. Which means that there is literally a bunch of dead shirous around while the Shirou that survives is the one that lucks out.

    • @nullpoint3346
      @nullpoint3346 5 років тому +4

      @@amakusashirou3679
      "Nothingness"

    • @nullpoint3346
      @nullpoint3346 5 років тому +12

      @@fbiuzz
      His luck is only one parameter higher than the rest of them.

  • @Uchihabloodunlimited
    @Uchihabloodunlimited 5 років тому +398

    His blood-curdling scream from this bad end will be stuck in my mind for the rest of my days. That's why I can't truly like Illya no matter what. That shit traumatized me lmao.

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  5 років тому +129

      Yo that scream had me SHOOK. VA did a really good job on that one. I would've thought that he got hurt for real

    • @NicholasJScott
      @NicholasJScott 5 років тому +88

      I just can picture it
      Rin, Archer and Saber outside the church-faint blood curdling scream of Shiro in the distant-
      Rin:did you hear that?
      Saber:sounds like a little girl seeing a spider
      Archer:OH MY OH MY OH MY I AM WATCHING SHIRO GET HIS ASS BEAT...OH HIS LEGS NO LONGER EXIST...IS THAT HIS LUNG?! meh he ain't a master We servants can't let non "mages" see us remember
      Saber: he's right
      Rin:never did like his "people die when they are killed " thing
      Archer: PEOPLE DIE WHEN THEY ARE KILLED!!
      Shiro faint shout: I KNOW!!

    • @ivanbluecool
      @ivanbluecool 5 років тому +19

      @@NicholasJScott arched would get popcorn as his sister killed him for him. Plus he never really liked him anyways

    • @applewithsword616
      @applewithsword616 5 років тому +4

      @@ivanbluecool you know they are kinda same guy right ?

    • @applewithsword616
      @applewithsword616 5 років тому +2

      It would hurt even if his sister murdering his young version. Not his death. The fact his murderer is illya.

  • @ultrapotatomode3222
    @ultrapotatomode3222 5 років тому +518

    Kirei: "You sure about this fam?" Shirou: "Yeah it's not like dad has a long lost daughter who will kill me out of jealousy for being raised by him or something. lol." #deadbeatdadkiritsugu

  • @bananaapost2669
    @bananaapost2669 5 років тому +181

    Every ending is bad if im not revieved.

    • @nullpoint3346
      @nullpoint3346 5 років тому +6

      You'd kill us all by default if you came back, total elimination versus countless generations of pain... , torment... , and brutal murder...
      Okay, fine.
      Come on back to reality.

  • @otakudaikun
    @otakudaikun 5 років тому +394

    Illya, like many characters in Fate, does awful things for understandable reasons. As far as bad endings go, my personal favorite is the one that's hardest to obtain. You've gotta spend your entire playthrough being as mean as possible to Saber so she chooses the grail over Shirou.

    • @Raharu95
      @Raharu95 5 років тому +23

      What Tiger Dojo is that one if any? I'd love to see that scene

    • @cpgautam172
      @cpgautam172 5 років тому +2

      I am with you on that one bro

    • @applewithsword616
      @applewithsword616 5 років тому +13

      I must reach that ending. lol

    • @jacek107ify
      @jacek107ify 4 роки тому +56

      true even Rin was willing to kill Shirou if necessary, she tried to avoid it, but was ready to for it....
      we know when Shirou turned into Archer he was willing to backstab his allies and even kill innocents if it helped him to achieve his goal.....
      all of them suffered enough for normal person to go crazy,
      but none of them suffered even half close like Illya. Losing parents, haunted by ghosts
      having her skin burned every day...

    • @madestmadhatter
      @madestmadhatter 4 роки тому +24

      All I did was decide to discuss strategies with Rin instead of Saber before taking on berserker. You literally just need to be nice to the other girls to fail to earn enough saber points for the good end.

  • @parkermaisterra8532
    @parkermaisterra8532 5 років тому +130

    You sure those guys who said Ilya was kind, sweet and merciful were'nt talk about fate/Kaleid Ilya? I mean the Ilya of the Fate/stay night is a full blown murderous psychotic murder loli.

    • @GurenEinzbern
      @GurenEinzbern 5 років тому +43

      I think they are refering to HF Illya...
      *looks at HF True Ending with tears*

    • @Leukresnt
      @Leukresnt 5 років тому +24

      Reminder that Illya is at the bottom list of whom kills Shirou the most in F/SN

    • @nullpoint3346
      @nullpoint3346 5 років тому +31

      @@Leukresnt
      But she probably has the most brutal kills.

    • @brobot550
      @brobot550 5 років тому +4

      I remember it in the bonus hotspring scene of Taiga and Ilya, talking about who killed shirou first in the game. Lmao xD

    • @LeonGun8
      @LeonGun8 5 років тому +23

      She actually hardly ever kills him. Just brutally mutilates him. Most of her endings imply that she gives him a new body and basically makes him her new "pet".
      Then again, that's like pointing out how Caster doesn't kills Shirou in a few of the bad ends. Sure,Shirou doesn't dies, but he's basically either a slave (to Ilya) or paralized and used as a magic item (Caster bad end).

  • @agravain9006
    @agravain9006 5 років тому +98

    Nasu is psycho sometimes

    • @zolo2036
      @zolo2036 5 років тому +14

      i feel like the bad ends really help contextualize all of the characters in the story, really great idea tsaih

  • @user-zx8gb5qb1r
    @user-zx8gb5qb1r 5 років тому +70

    I know she over did it, but let's not forget here that she thinks shiro took kiristsugu away from her (she doesn't know kiritsugu or shiro wasn't at fault , but the Einzberns are) and she was brutally trained and treated by the Einzberns in all of those years while shiro was under the care of her dad who she thinks abandoned her. On top of that the Einzberns probably trained her in a way that she would be brutal in mind in order to win the war.

    • @xavmanisdabestest
      @xavmanisdabestest 3 роки тому +12

      She knows shiro isn't to blame how would a kid be to blame for the actions of an adult

  • @Random-eh9uc
    @Random-eh9uc 4 роки тому +26

    Saber literally like : seriously dude

  • @Gogetossj50
    @Gogetossj50 5 років тому +95

    -"A few choices"
    Please correct if I am wrong bur isn't the majority of the endings "bad endings". Last time I checked Shirou can die like 40+ times in the 3 routes.

    • @overlordreviews7351
      @overlordreviews7351 5 років тому +38

      Not all bad endings ends with shirou "dying", just some of them like...37

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  5 років тому +21

      No I wasn't saying there's only a few bad endings, just a few choices that lead into those endings.

    • @Gogetossj50
      @Gogetossj50 5 років тому +1

      Overlord Reviews You get the point.

    • @P1ay3r7
      @P1ay3r7 5 років тому +14

      There is one ending where you live the "Harem life". Rin is Saber's master, and I can't remember the fuck why, Rin and Saber go to live in your house and happy ending. However, this is not a true ending.
      Also, there is a bad ending in the Heaven's feel route called Mind of Steel/Superhero. You are given two choices; Save Sakura or Become a Superhero.
      If you choose to become a Superhero, Shirou goes into full Kiritsugu mode. Some people believe this route is the path of becoming Archer Alter, but there is no proof.

    • @LeonGun8
      @LeonGun8 5 років тому +16

      Actually, you have distinctions of "bad endings" too.A "Dead End" means Shirou died, period. A "Bad End" means Shirou is in a bad situation, often incapacitated or outright paralized by some magical means. In this very specific ending the video claims Shirou died and then she took the body to fuck around with it. Which is WRONG, it is implied in this end,and confirmed in a later Bad End, that she takes a barely alive Shirou to the castle, transfers his soul to a "doll" and keeps him as his playmate. He's technically alive, sort off. But still counts as alive.

  • @phoenixag196
    @phoenixag196 5 років тому +404

    So basically, for making the logical decision that most of us would and saying yeet to all the awkward 2-3 somes:
    *They broke his Nico Nico Knees*

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +40

      Ouch the pun hit me like i was Shirou

    • @P1ay3r7
      @P1ay3r7 5 років тому +19

      And it hurt like sitting in Seiza but both legs and feet bending the wrong way

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +7

      Oh wait, I AM SHIROU!

    • @ulisesavila2879
      @ulisesavila2879 5 років тому +18

      All the "logic" ideas lead to dead endos

    • @namoma4922
      @namoma4922 2 роки тому +1

      You lost your legs privileges

  • @TsiahIV
    @TsiahIV  5 років тому +276

    We still love you Illya 👍

    • @otakulifeoftrueculture777
      @otakulifeoftrueculture777 5 років тому +16

      haters going to hate on lolis that doesn't bother me Illya still has my heart as always best girl #1 ^__-

    • @tonyinfinite5174
      @tonyinfinite5174 5 років тому +24

      Now if only they gave her a normal route rather than a magical girl show i'd sell my soul for her route that was cut in f/sn

    • @otakulifeoftrueculture777
      @otakulifeoftrueculture777 5 років тому +16

      the magical girl series was great to me but the people wasn't waiting for that they were waiting for the truth Illya ufotable route 26 episode anime series

    • @tonyinfinite5174
      @tonyinfinite5174 5 років тому +6

      I still wait for that to this day illya ufotable route the dream will never die

    • @adamchu2001
      @adamchu2001 5 років тому +1

      Everyone saying illya is not evil im just going to say that it is only for the prisma illya

  • @ted3788
    @ted3788 5 років тому +183

    please make more of these! this is such an original idea, and its a blast from the past for visual novel fans!

    • @vickq123
      @vickq123 5 років тому +4

      My thoughts exactly, also might need to get the bad ends I "missed" lol.

    • @Kakaragi
      @Kakaragi 3 роки тому +1

      The bad ends are definitely something the anime fans miss out on

  • @espurrseyes42
    @espurrseyes42 5 років тому +76

    Even I can't defend Illya this time. I guess Shirou deserves some crap for backing out of the war, but did she really have to "Fred from SpongeBob" him?
    That's the MY LEG guy.

    • @myhoang2194
      @myhoang2194 Рік тому

      his legs was still there, it was just 2d

  • @Brokenbadge
    @Brokenbadge 5 років тому +16

    That leg thing is fucking hilarious, gotta love tsiah and his laugh inducing descriptions.

  • @AscendtionArc
    @AscendtionArc 5 років тому +34

    That certainly put's Illya inviting Shirou to her house in a very different light.

  • @GurenEinzbern
    @GurenEinzbern 5 років тому +56

    Like you've said these bad endings with Illya really creeps me out especially when "Die Lorelei" plays.

    • @baylego
      @baylego 5 років тому +8

      Ryuu Alexius I got that one the frist time I played it, I wasn't expecting to be raped (mentally) by a loli and not enjoying it

    • @applewithsword616
      @applewithsword616 5 років тому

      @@baylego wait........ What

    • @P1ay3r7
      @P1ay3r7 5 років тому +5

      @@baylego well, in one ending you become illya's doll and it's implied she uses you as she pleases, including sexually.
      Before the final release, illya would fuck you, but they removed it. It's even mentioned in one of the Taiga's Dojo
      EDIT: Bad ending 7 Heaven's Dress.

  • @callisto1234
    @callisto1234 5 років тому +188

    yup, thats illya everyone. if we compare how gil killed ilya and how she killed shirou, Gil has the moral high ground. Lets not forget, illya IS NOT a little girl. she 18! an adult in most places. so this wasnt cruelty against children, it was more akin to euthanasia!

    • @LeonGun8
      @LeonGun8 5 років тому +35

      Well, except for the fact Gil did it for the jollies while Ilya was raised for ten years to hate Kiritsugu and his son. The Einzbern family is also a strange family in that they are not taught much in terms of morals. She was ordered to obtain the Holy Grail and that everyone else was an obstacle to be slaughtered. In a way it is actually telling that, as cruel as she treated Shirou, she disobeys the orders given to her and preserves Shirou's mind inside a doll (yes, in all her endings it is either outright stated or implied that she sends Shirou's mind inside a "doll"). This shows she at least has a sense of attachment to him, morality aside.

    • @jetx2599
      @jetx2599 5 років тому +24

      LeonGun8 gill did it to obtain the heat in order to create a vessel. He had a goal. Not for shits and giggles. Gilgamesh > Illya when it comes to this situation surprisingly

    • @matthewmclean6574
      @matthewmclean6574 5 років тому +23

      If a murderer kills another person for the sake of murdering more people, regardless of the victim being a murderer I wouldn't exactly call it "the moral high ground".

    • @LeonGun8
      @LeonGun8 5 років тому +22

      It IS shits and giggles when you turn a simple "kill and retrieve object" mission into "let's play around, torture the target for no reason and then retrieve object which I will use to start an armageddon which will kill billions of people worldwide".
      At least Ilya has her own valid reasons, however twisted, to hate Kiritsugu and Shirou. Her strange love-hate relationship with Shirou and her actions during her bad ends all revolve around this. Gilgamesh was just being a dick and playing with a defeated opponent just because he found her "unsightly" in order to obtain an item necessary for his plan to kill the weak modern humans that he found to be lowly insects "unworthy of living in his kingdom".

    • @matthewmclean6574
      @matthewmclean6574 5 років тому

      +LeonGun8 that is literally what I just said only mine was in Layman's terms

  • @xuanathan
    @xuanathan 4 роки тому +13

    Illya: “Vibe check”
    Shirou: OH GOD OH FUCK I GOT JACKALL LEGS

  • @shutup1037
    @shutup1037 5 років тому +29

    Saber hit him on the leg btw with a steel pole
    Shiiiitt Donate for Shirou's legs
    I'm dying XDXDXD

  • @tonyo743
    @tonyo743 5 років тому +16

    *what used to be my legs have turned into 2d objects* Thank You.

  • @midnight4956
    @midnight4956 5 років тому +15

    I’m losing my shit hearing you explain about Shirou Legs and how he got torture! And Stricken as the outro? Nice choice my dude!

  • @ariesdemiurge
    @ariesdemiurge 4 роки тому +5

    I cannot unhear that description of Shirou's knees.

  • @mitchellalexander9162
    @mitchellalexander9162 5 років тому +36

    Honestly I think the More Possible and Interesting Bad Endings for FSN are:
    From Fate:
    -Texture from Fate and UBW where Shirou declines Rin's alliance and the Next school Day she Gandrs Shirou, strangles him unconscious, and Shirou gets amnesia somehow from this. Would be more practical if he just died.
    -Missing Ariadne (A failed attack on Ryuudou Temple by Shirou and Saber interrupted by Rider)
    -Dress of Heaven: The one where Shirou agrees to be Illya's Servant when he's kidnapped by her only to have his mind Transferred into 'something else'
    -Night Without Dawn: The Fate Route's Berserker fight going South when Shirou doesn't stop Saber from using her NP to just kill Berserker right there. (SPOILERS It doesn't work.)
    -Two Caster Endings that are basically the same in Fate Route at some point Saber gets hit by Rule Breaker and she's forced to kill Shirou by Caster if you make a bad call during the fight.
    -A couple of Day 15 Endings are interesting
    UBW Bad Ends:
    Third Death: What happens when you follow Rin's orders blindly.
    -Hypnos: The explanation for WHY exactly Shirou had to Strip Issei rather than just asking him about Caster at school
    -Killer: Kuzuki kicking your **** in.
    -Hazy: You chooseing to ally with Caster.
    -Sword and Magic, One Conclusion, and Heaven's Fall
    Heavens feel Route:
    -Miserable Lone Force
    -Geas: Where Rin kills Sakura.
    -Stone Coffin (Which is a little Humorous)
    -Superhero (Which I'm Just going to let you Guess what it entails ;) )
    Layered Curse of the Womb Realm Mandala
    -Sparks Liner High and Femme Fatale ( which could share a vid honestly)

  • @Squidward-jv7go
    @Squidward-jv7go 5 років тому +7

    Lol the way the music comes in when Illya says “yeah, and?” is damn creepy

  • @AllOtakuProductions
    @AllOtakuProductions Рік тому +7

    "We should protect her at all cost, when she's not brutally turning our legs into pancakes!" 😂

  • @stevenchoza6391
    @stevenchoza6391 5 років тому +30

    Ilya was planning to do this even when she didn’t kill you.
    Also, insert obligatory “Please do a Joan of Arc video” comment here.
    Please do a Joan of Arc video!

  • @idreadFell365
    @idreadFell365 5 років тому +6

    The moment he severed his contract with Saber, his plot armor (Avalon) stop working.

  • @EssTsuko
    @EssTsuko 5 років тому +13

    these videos never disappoint,shit had me rolling

  • @AlukardBenXIII
    @AlukardBenXIII 5 років тому +14

    1. JESUS CHRIST MAN!!!
    2. Gilgamesh or Ozymandias
    Still ain't giving up

  • @blastmako05
    @blastmako05 5 років тому +9

    ...Ow...just, ow.
    Can't wait for the next one.

  • @fatecontrast79
    @fatecontrast79 5 років тому +7

    I could not sleep after seeing this ending..

  • @zolo2036
    @zolo2036 5 років тому +1

    love the idea of this series i dont know if ul only do a few bad ends or all but its a cool point of view that is REALLY under represented given how much is out there regarding stay night

  • @salmanige318
    @salmanige318 5 років тому +28

    So are these gonna happen with the good ending.

  • @adz4528
    @adz4528 5 років тому +1

    Lmao I hope you make this a series Tsiah!

  • @rafaelcastor2089
    @rafaelcastor2089 5 років тому

    A discussion about the bad endings? Hell yeah! Hoping for more vids

  • @josecuestas7246
    @josecuestas7246 8 місяців тому +1

    Raiden: "There are Fates worse than death."

  • @jerri3221
    @jerri3221 4 роки тому

    Ok this was my 2nd vid of yours and straight up hilarious

  • @alsosprachzarathustra4756
    @alsosprachzarathustra4756 5 років тому +7

    Well people do in fact die of being killed. And shirou also learned that just because he was correct in making his decision it didn’t mean he was right

    • @eggynuts7735
      @eggynuts7735 Рік тому

      being correct is being right lol, ur just being sentimental

    • @alsosprachzarathustra4756
      @alsosprachzarathustra4756 Рік тому +1

      @@eggynuts7735 You should try watching fate stay night, unlimited blade works to be specific. Instead of trying to correct a joke from 4 years ago.

    • @eggynuts7735
      @eggynuts7735 Рік тому

      @@alsosprachzarathustra4756 i already watched it 3 weeks ago, also a joke needs to have comedic humour or a funny punchline into it, not you ovulating

    • @alsosprachzarathustra4756
      @alsosprachzarathustra4756 Рік тому

      @@eggynuts7735 What? Or maybe you’re just to slow or didn’t actually pay attention to the show you just watched. “Just because you’re correct doesn’t mean you’re right.” Is the quote Shirou said to archer and became a meme. If you actually used 2 of your overcharged brain cells to take in what you watched 3 weeks ago then you wouldn’t feel the need to comment.

  • @habenomabebe8526
    @habenomabebe8526 4 роки тому +2

    Dude you are too funny especially in this video. I was dying!

  • @SuperGodzilla2
    @SuperGodzilla2 4 роки тому +4

    holy fuck... didnt think Illya was that evil. i mean its one thing to kill a person, but its another thing when you destroy their body bit by bit while keeping him alive the whole time

  • @josecuestas7246
    @josecuestas7246 8 місяців тому +1

    Even if sounds weird, i can't help in think that the bad ending "Forest of no return" of Fate route, look similar to the "Yharnam Sunrise" ending of Bloodborne.
    By the fact that the main protagonists (Shirou/Paleblood Hunter), accepts to surrender their positions as Master and Hunter to the arbiters (Kotomine/Gehrman), leading to that the protagonists be free from the Holy Grail war and the Hunter's Dream.
    Though that this choice come with some consequences; Gehrman executes the Paleblood Hunter, and Shirou is tortured permanently by Illya.

  • @cringelord1395
    @cringelord1395 5 років тому

    I really like your analysis videos especially on original FSN, funny yet informative. I hope that you will do more FSN videos and less FGO

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому +83

    Gilgamesh is not wrong most of the time in a weird way. I love him so i will be non biase. Kills ilya in ubw who was a enemy. Tells sakura to die when she has the chance before she goes into a psycho and kills and shames many heroes. Joins with kirie because tokiami while smart was an idiot as the same time. Wants saber so he has good taste. Not rin as she reminds him of ishar the original THOT who took enkidu. Plus he likes small chest. And should have destroyed sakura and her goo but was too arrogant.

    • @ivanbluecool
      @ivanbluecool 5 років тому +5

      Its a matter of perspective. I do wonder what or how the ilya route would go. Would ilya take shirou night one but after kirie tells shioru Kirisugu and his past with ilyas family. Then i feel it would go into ilya explaining why she hates shioru as she was told he ran from her and loved shirou instead. I would love to see that. And somehow shirou tells her that Kirisugu tried to get her free and team up. Would be cool to see as emiya archer knew she was his sister and probaly saw her die from her last year of life as a homunculus

    • @PeachDragon_
      @PeachDragon_ 5 років тому +26

      Gilgamesh: "Hey rin, you look like my ex, guess who's gonna die horribly"

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +4

      HE WANTED TO CAUSE MASS GENOCIDE!

    • @PeachDragon_
      @PeachDragon_ 5 років тому +3

      @@amakusashirou3679 he was right!
      THE WORLD NEEDS A NEW PLAGUE!

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +1

      @@PeachDragon_ THE WORLD NEEDS TO BE SAVED!EVERYONE MUST BE SAVED AND HAPPY

  • @sirrealgaming6913
    @sirrealgaming6913 5 років тому

    The Bad Ends are what originally got me to love fate as a series strangly enough

  • @vincentshadetree
    @vincentshadetree 3 роки тому +4

    That go fund me is hilarious!

  • @madmohawk6560
    @madmohawk6560 5 років тому +2

    Hey I was wondering if there was more info about the Grail Mud and the different ways it could affect people like we know that it revived the Spook master Kirei Kotomine but what else does it do. Like could it make Alter humans? Would exposure to a body part affect the whole or would it just destroy it?
    Would it reduce humans to a more Beast-like state or affect their mentality so that say a sweet and innocent child could suddenly have Sadistic tendencies? What would it do to a Homunculus? We know it brings the dark side of a servant out so what about Chaotic Evil servants would it just make them insane? At the same time what about those under True Neutral.
    Oh god I think I might have a Magus mindset... or i'm one curious boi with way to much time on hand... hopefully the latter wouldn't want to accidental a psycho loli *looks at Illya and Sakura*.

  • @burnerforburnersake9944
    @burnerforburnersake9944 5 років тому +14

    The endings that broke me was mind of steel and femme fatale.

  • @k9fox775
    @k9fox775 5 років тому

    I fucks with this all the way my guy please keep this going as a series

  • @Udiyvli
    @Udiyvli 5 років тому +2

    Holy shit that was funny. You sir get a sub. Keep it up.

  • @jamaldavis831
    @jamaldavis831 5 років тому +3

    Shirou should've never skipped leg day

  • @Gogetossj50
    @Gogetossj50 5 років тому +4

    So on a scale from 0 to 10 with 10 being a Happy Tree Friends episode how much do you rank the brutality of this bad ending with?

  • @bhsr_
    @bhsr_ 5 років тому +40

    Illya waited for her dad to come home in vain, became a master that could control not only a berserker but the berserker form of the STRONGEST GREEK HERO EVER, goes to a foreign country and finds out her dad ‘abandoned’ her for a weak ass ginger who pussed out of the grail war. Ye i’d chop him up too

    • @LeonGun8
      @LeonGun8 5 років тому +11

      Actually, she already knew of Shirou. It is stated in extra material that his grandfather tells her point blank that Kiritsugu abandoned her and replaced her with a son.

    • @asuraspath2262
      @asuraspath2262 5 років тому +2

      You can't do shit. Your a weeb lol, stay in your basement.

    • @LegendXD00
      @LegendXD00 4 роки тому +11

      bhsr you must be incredibly fucked in the head to make an excuse like that just to defend her kid because you hit ironically admitted Gilgamesh wasn’t wrong in slaughtering that psycho. Shirou literally did nothing to her and your trying to justify something like that?Yea ok

    • @kelvinwebley6971
      @kelvinwebley6971 3 роки тому +2

      Nigga u fucked up
      Cuz in this end, shirou hardly knows illya

  • @thatmotivatedchris6749
    @thatmotivatedchris6749 4 роки тому +6

    Today I had an argument with another fate fan and at some point this ending was brought up and I said (oh well it's a bad ending you fucked up and then restart simple as that)
    Because just as explained in the video I used to get mad over what happened to her in ubw it wasn't until later on that same day that I saw this video and ended up thinking
    (Welp I'm done defending her from now on after watching this)
    Moral of the story is do your research before you say something dumb.

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  4 роки тому +3

      Not a lot of people know about this to be fair though, but yeah illya has her moments for sure. She low-key did something worse than this in the actual route

  • @GrimgoreIronhide
    @GrimgoreIronhide 2 роки тому +3

    Rin has by this point already learned that Shirou knows virtually nothing about magic and cant even cast simple spells. While its difficult to say what's going through her head at this point Rin isnt aware of Shirou's fanatical desire to be a hero at this point either, not did she know of Illya's personal grudge against Shirou. I don't think she was particularly surprised by his choice to back out. While Rin may well have have had a bad feeling about him leaving, but this would have been her heart rather than her head talking.
    Basically the choice to back out is very reasonable and the logical side of Rin agrees with this choice.

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

    Are you gonna talk morw about the apostle. I'm now addicted to hearing more abiut them and how they can connect to fgoone day in a huge mega story

  • @izzy5549
    @izzy5549 4 роки тому +5

    The go fund me 😭😭😂🤣

  • @TrivonikaQuintrellDemary
    @TrivonikaQuintrellDemary 5 років тому +2

    Great review always keep it illya damn I thought she was innocent Shirou never will have a good ending

  • @HHH-rf2hv
    @HHH-rf2hv 5 років тому

    Nice, I read all the good end but never touched the bad end, this series is good

  • @glhf2
    @glhf2 5 років тому

    Will you be covering the rest of the bad endings?

  • @ProudNL99
    @ProudNL99 5 років тому +5

    But..
    Why is the gofundme link not in the description?

  • @richardwalker2881
    @richardwalker2881 5 років тому +1

    Makes you wonder if chloe would of been a far more BRUTAL counter guardian in order to protect ilya, as her brother, father and sakura saber each have a much more dangerous counter guardian form, plus this ending is FAR more extreme of a refusal to call

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому +10

    Archer would be happy. His sister did the work for him so archer woild be proud of ilya.

  • @namelesssaiyan4022
    @namelesssaiyan4022 5 років тому

    How would the story play out with Shirou out of the picture? How would Rin manage both Saber and Archer (if possible)?

  • @PeachDragon_
    @PeachDragon_ 5 років тому +32

    Gilgamesh was the true hero, he slayed the monster known as illya
    #GilgameshDidNothingWrong

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +2

      He attempted to cause mass genocide....that is super wrong

    • @PeachDragon_
      @PeachDragon_ 5 років тому +2

      @@amakusashirou3679 do you have the proofs?

    • @amakusashirou3679
      @amakusashirou3679 5 років тому +5

      Maybe the death of billions?

    • @allenwalker8766
      @allenwalker8766 5 років тому +3

      The ones that stopped Gilgamesh from killing everyone were the true heroes

  • @dstillable
    @dstillable 5 років тому

    More of these for sure.

  • @darthutah6649
    @darthutah6649 4 роки тому

    One of these days, they need to make shots of all of the bad endings

  • @nezuhood175
    @nezuhood175 2 роки тому +1

    BRA! She on that Straight Psychopath Energy!

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому +1

    Are you gonna do more about the apostle. I heard somewhere fou from fgo is related to primate. Is that true. If so. Could fou become a beast class servant or helper to play with as we need a beast play servant one day to play with and a level 1 or 3 star would not make the game broken like rulers back in rhe day

    • @shadowedge2782
      @shadowedge2782 5 років тому +1

      ivanbluecool Spoiler!
      Fou isn't related to Primate Murder...
      He IS Primate Murder.

    • @ivanbluecool
      @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

      @@shadowedge2782 oh yeah I knew that. Do you think he will be playable one day and as he is tiny be a 3 star and get stronger like mashu does. I would like that. First beast class servant or helper would be nice. To balance the game out. Make him weak until more units are added

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

    This reminds me of little what if scenario i think up. Like if prisma ilya switched minds with stat night ilya. How would that change the series. Hercules would still protect her and her maids act the same. Prisma ilya would team up with shirou and then rin and the war is basically over as shinji would join out of fear of dying

  • @tempest6056
    @tempest6056 4 роки тому +1

    illya may have killed shiro on bad endings, but she saved shiro by giving informations and by sacrifing her life on HF

  • @lincolnbeckett8791
    @lincolnbeckett8791 5 років тому

    I went to a video that shows this bad ending in full, and actually found the comments shown in this video. LOL

  • @Yassinegaming200
    @Yassinegaming200 7 місяців тому

    This is the first time I'm seeing this and bad end 1 is so messed up and sad and disturbing and ....
    But the crowdfunding made me almost cry of laughter (during class).
    Yes, I'm reading the VN for the first time ever.

  • @grapesvine
    @grapesvine 5 років тому +3

    Are we sure Ryuunosuke Uryuu isn't her dad?

  • @Scazura
    @Scazura 5 років тому +5

    When you think about it, this is legit the first time Ilya laid eyes on Shirou. All that pent up anger she felt towards Kiritsugu was then pretty much directed at him, so essentially a "Kill on Sight" mentality.
    Still doesn't excuse what she did, but torturing Shirou like that was probably her vengeance towards Kiritsugu.

  • @idmunster4714
    @idmunster4714 5 років тому +10

    You better not say the Superhero ending is a bad ending since that's the only good Heaven's feel ending.

    • @mintythegreenoreo64
      @mintythegreenoreo64 5 років тому

      except it goes against literally everything else in HF.

    • @idmunster4714
      @idmunster4714 5 років тому

      why do you think i like it?

    • @travisoliver6741
      @travisoliver6741 5 років тому

      @@idmunster4714 You do know that Superhero Shirou=EMIYA (Alter) right?

    • @idmunster4714
      @idmunster4714 5 років тому

      @@travisoliver6741 no it doesn't and there isn't any reason to think that plus EMIYA alter is an extremely recent addition to the series so why would he be the result of a route that has literally never been expanded on before?

  • @touchedme1637
    @touchedme1637 5 років тому +3

    A go fund me for Shiros legs
    ☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  5 років тому +1

      Lmaoo, glad to see you still rocking with me my boy

    • @touchedme1637
      @touchedme1637 5 років тому

      @@TsiahIV Yee work got me busy. But Im coming back

  • @YT-hates-my-Japanese-name
    @YT-hates-my-Japanese-name Рік тому

    Dude, you hilarious, man. xD

  • @seongjin-woo8683
    @seongjin-woo8683 3 роки тому

    Didn't shirou only have 2 command seals left?
    If Kirei took 2 then left 1
    How many did he really took?

  • @Chief-Remeldian-Olympus
    @Chief-Remeldian-Olympus 5 років тому

    Love this version of Illya not the other one.

  • @nomanhand
    @nomanhand 5 років тому +2

    #gildidnothingwrong

  • @silvrsurfer
    @silvrsurfer 3 роки тому

    Can someone explain to me why the church/kirei didn't protect him?

  • @Ayahuasca98
    @Ayahuasca98 Рік тому

    Love seeing the illya slander. Feels good man.

  • @oshogupta1
    @oshogupta1 5 років тому +1

    Never miss leg day guys

  • @someguywithabirdface2583
    @someguywithabirdface2583 4 роки тому +1

    I wonder In this timeline , shinji literally become John wick

  • @accelerei7619
    @accelerei7619 Рік тому

    The go fund me part has me rolling xD

  • @JadedWarlock
    @JadedWarlock 5 років тому

    When you're older sister decides to wreck your shit before taking you home to have tea.

  • @AceKite00
    @AceKite00 5 років тому +1

    Illyasviel was resentful towards Kiritsugu for allegedly abandoning her for some random kid and she made Shirou pay in his place. Now i dont condone what she did in that ending, but i sympathize with her emotions. Good thing it never actually turned out that way and theyre both on great terms. Knowing that she can be easily reasoned with, i still love her. All the descriptions of gore dont bother me.

    • @ivanbluecool
      @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

      Stronger man than me. The bear doll scares me more. Being a soul in a doll. And ilya would die thinking she had Kirisugu love im her doll in some weird way. But heavens feel shows her and shirou as a team which i like. And hate as ilays route was scrapped for sakura but we have small hints of it in heavens feel

  • @loverofjesusMKII
    @loverofjesusMKII 5 років тому +3

    Illya, why though? We all still love her though

  • @fuzzie6299
    @fuzzie6299 Рік тому

    R.I.P Shirou's legs

  • @mordi9286
    @mordi9286 5 років тому

    Shriou: AW CRAP, NOT MA SHINS

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

    Still many more to come. Issie killing shirou by possession. Rin wiping his memory. Sakura laughing and apologizing while shirou is dying with saber next to him while sakura makes fun of rin for being a virgin.

  • @TheSwitchblademc
    @TheSwitchblademc 5 років тому +2

    I literally can't stop laughing

  • @thewhite2018
    @thewhite2018 5 років тому

    Damn
    I still love her.

  • @YashiroKasumi
    @YashiroKasumi 5 років тому

    Shirou's screams really make this scene disturbing - then Die Lorelei plays.

  • @Anonymous-zb7st
    @Anonymous-zb7st 5 років тому

    Where's part 2?

  • @nomanhand
    @nomanhand 5 років тому

    pls do emiya assassin fate lore

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool 5 років тому

    Do yhe heart of steel ending or super man ending next. Show that its a good thing shirou stops sakura but becomes Kirisugu 2.0 and then emiya altwr as kiara messes him up

  • @CCRLH85
    @CCRLH85 5 років тому

    You know she blames him for taking her father away.