Unrelated to the video, and it's taken me like 5 months, but I've now watched all of classic who, because of this channel. I thank our lord and saviour dwfan91
Thank you for making feel like I’m not a freak for just constantly rewatching a show I discovered on my own on PBS. Your rant was my favorite part of this video. Thanks for being you.
There is one more factor for an epic title, shouting out the title name for dramatic effect. My favourite example of this, is to shout, "THE WEB OF FEEEAR". If it sounds absolutely epic, dramatic and purely mystical, then it's definitely an S tier. If I was to shout, "THE GUNFIGGHTERS". It just isn't there, there's nothing to go off here. It's not really mystical nor dramatic. It's an F tier. idk I think I'm going crazy from watching Classic Who.
1) The toymaker was never called “The celestial toymaker” in the original story, so dropping that title for his return in the Giggle makes perfect sense to me! We don’t call the monk “the time meddler” either so at least it’s consistent. 2) If the idea that Grace is the “Woman who fell to earth” is true (something I’m surprised you didn’t mention but you was in a bit to deep at that point) that means she’s the only companion who gets an episode named After her in the 13th doctors entire run. Bit of a letdown TBH the companions in Chris tenure needed more development. Yaz could’ve benefited from a episode like “Amy’s choice”
I love how your descent into madness and then ascent out of it and then into it again is observable. After a certain amount of regular sized videos, you release something upwards of an hour and just go INSANE talking about Doctor Who. Good video.
i, dwfan92, humbly accept this video while we patiently wait for your Capaldi deep dive side note, hella pumped for the new season and it happens to drop just after my birthday. good year to get older
Early happy Birthday! The Capaldi Era video (which will likely turn into Moffat era in general) will probably come out after the new season because I'll be focusing on new content about that
Honestly the Pertwee and Baker era titles were pretty unoriginal. They were all titled "The deadly X of X" and stuff like that. They even made of fun of this fact in the curse of fatal death.
I'm hyped for the new season, HOWEVER, we all know the issues with the timing, BUT, a big but is that it is released just after my gcse's start soooo... I sad.
Great video to watch so soon after I achieved my dream of completing autism by committing every serial/episode title ever to memory. Love seeing that there are other people as dedicated to wasting their own time over this show as me lol
You say you're rambling about random stuff no one cares about again? I care, although it can be debated whether I count as someone or not. Thanks for keeping it real.
When I first heard ‘The Faceless Ones’ I assumed it was some cool classic horror-esq idea and was super pumped to watch it one day. Wasn’t quite what I expected when I first saw it though 😅
Season 1 for me would of been X. The Church on Ruby Road 1. Trapped in Space 2. The Devil’s Chord 3. Standing Still 4. 73 Yards 5. Finetime 6. A Night to Remember 7. The Legend of Ruby Sunday 8. Empire of Death
48:00 I think my issue with Rosa is that it basically regurgitates the same pop-history retelling you typically get when it had the opportunity to do something far more interesting with the actual history involved. I wouldn’t even b take issue with it if Demons of the Punjab wasn’t doing exactly that in the same season. I have a different but related issue with Legend of the Sea Devils in that Cheng I Sao was such an interesting figure to play around with, and they squandered her potential so hard. Not only was she a pirate so powerful and successful that she forced the government to compromise and let her retire with all her money, but she was also doing all of this as a woman in the 1800s. Did we get a story that did her justice, then? No, and that’s not even talking about the sea devils.
eh i don't really mind, yeah demons of the punjab is a step above but 'pop-history' is pretty much every dr who historical. i don't think they really needed to reinvent the wheel for a rosa parks story
S42: Church on Ruby Road - Empire of Doom S41: Star Beast - Giggle S40: Halloween Apocalypse - Power of The Doctor S39: Spyfall - Revolution of the Daleks Etc. Etc. Etc. ..... S31: Next Doctor - End of Time
An interesting fact I saw from Twitter is that Chibnill never titled an Episode on any of the Companions because RTD had Rose, Runaway Bride, Smith & Jones, Church on Ruby Road. The Moff had Amy's Choice, the Girl who waited, plus The Impossible Astronaut. Also, I do see a sight pattern of good episodes having good names, however I would say an Episode like Nikola's Tesla Night of Terrors is an awful title but great Episode. Likewise with Bells of Saint John, I almost wish it was titled Clara? Now for a bad episode with a great name, I think of Nightmare in Silver or Wedding of River Song.
right I’m onto the unhinged part of the video now and i’m sort of getting what you mean (people read the titles as they review and this influences their placing)- and I agree Chibnall was good. Here’s an idea, video where you rename all the lower ranked episodes. Make better relevant names, then get people to rank with the wrong names and see if it does have an observable impact. Can you tell i’m in the midst of economics revision
Personally not a fan of the Aztecs or the Reign of terror. Saying that might make me seem like i dont like the things historical whixh isnt the case i do just genuinely think that these episodes are quite dull. Not to mention the gaping plot hole in the Aztecs as to why Barbara couldnt just order the Aztecs to break down the wall hiding the Tardis. I love most the others but these stuck with me.
I need to get the certified dwfan91 review of these hypothetical episode titles (if I get bored enough I’ll make a video on what the Idle Era would look like, also dw it’s only 8 episodes because they’re in the classic format): I’m Nobody, Who Are You?(season opener, builds up mystery around the Doctor) Antediluvia(Silurians at their height during the Mesozoic) The Evening Star (don’t like this one, I’m trying to figure out a better title. If you have any ideas for a title for an intrigue story set on an airship colony high enough in Venus’s atmosphere to have livable air pressure, please share them) In Plain Sight (Mansa Musa rutan story I mentioned before) The Things That Lived On Mars(Ice Warriors) Evolution, alternatively Beneath a Silver Sky(rogue nanotech threatens to consume all resources on a far future Earth) Alternative Paths(The Monk meddles) The Second Sun(an alien people bathe in the light of an interplanetary laser which has taken so long to get there that they think it’s another sun and the forgot about the war that made someone fire it at them)
I love fan projects so definitely keep it up! These all sound great as well but for the sake of constructive criticism, I will force myself to 'rate' them at your behest. So keep in mind that A- this is all in good fun, I love fan projects and I like all these titles and B- I suck at making episode titles😂 1- I’d say this is probably the weakest, as either part of the title would probably work better by itself. I imagine this is a back and forth in the actual story and makes more sense in context though 2- I like this one, probably my favourite 3- You say you don’t like this one but I think it’s pretty cool. Although it does sound like a newspaper 4- This one’s cool, sounds like a VNA title 5- I get the reference to ‘Thing from Another World’ but similarly to that title I think maybe turn ‘things’ to the singular ‘thing’ (?) If I had to force a criticism ofc. 6- I think I prefer the second version of the title 7- This is a good one although even if unintended I find the idea of an episode called “The Monk Meddles” (akin to the Doctor Dances) funnier. Depends on the tone of the story you’re trying to tell I suppose. 8- And your final title, while cool, might not be climactic enough for a finale. Unless of course this isn’t a full season structure and these are all individual stories in which case, very cool. Thank you for sharing this and I hope my comment was helpful! Overall, all very good, well done!
@@dwfan91- This season is more of an anthology-type format similar to Series 11. The next season, on the other hand, I haven't developed much, but I plan on having the central antagonist be the Great Vampires.
Finally, I shall find out what the Bells of St John and Death in Heaven are referring to! Edit: nevermind Edit edit: just like you, I always think the "last time" sequence in Bad Wolf is absolutely peak ;)
Yeah I did see this; the main people I see negatively affected by this and fans outside the UK as its likely people like me will be able to pick it up discounted from physical locations- so the price hike is really unfair. But even with that aside, its just a ridiculous pricing scheme.
I feel like its one of the things I say over and over again in every video so it'd be trodden ground but maybe. If you watch my Dot and Bubble video at 22:40 I describe in detail my full thoughts on the episode so you can look at that if you're curious
I don’t think the chibnal era is bad, i prefer rtd or moffat, but its still good, im rewatching modern who (so that the blue line is on every episode 😅) and i have 71 episodes left, mostly season 11, 12 & 13… but thats probably because its over hated lol. 10 days to go! Btw i make lego doctor who stuff on my channel, I’m uploading a doctor who trailer in lego (15th doctor) when i hit 100 subs, and i’ll upload all the clips from the s1 trailers in order, on the 9th of May!
I think "The Giggle" is a meh title. C Tier for me, maybe I'm just a sucker for titles that think they're cleverer than they are as opposed to the perfunctory ones.
I respect your opinions, but sorry, I have to ask: Are you seriously saying "The Angels take Manhattan" is a better episode than " Blink" because in Blink there are logic mistakes like the Angles do not freeze when they see their faint reflection in the window? *cough* Maby you haven't noticed... but in TAtM... THE STATUE OF LIBERTY somehow made it's way to a random hotel in the city WITHOUT beeing seen by anyone! 🤣🤣🤣 Would you be so kind and explain this to me kind sir? 🧐🤣
Also,completly unrelated: You just put "Journey to the centre of the Tardis" in D tier for me. I have to disagree with that. This title is an omage to the book "Journey to the centre of the earth" by Jules Verne, whitch is one of my favorite books of all time. (He also wrotw "around the world in 80 days" or "20.000 leaks under the sea") So the title might be long but this episode and especially the title will always hold a special place in my heart.
Personally i woulda included a cringe tier there’s a few Dinosaurs on a spaceship - feels a bit try hard idk Power of three - lame asf screams filler to me Arachnids in the uk - irrelevant sex pistols reference?? 💀 Spyfall - parody? Idk just feels childish Nikola tesla - cant rlly explain this one Just some that when i first heard it i thought fuck that (and still do)
graphic design is my passion
clearly
sure
"Horse of Destruction" from The Myth Makers is easily my favourite individual part title. Out of context, it just sounds bizarre
I am partial myself to "The Death of Dr Who" from the Chase
this guy sure likes doctor who, he might be some kind of fanatic about the show, but idk
The 91st, even
The original you might say
Unrelated to the video, and it's taken me like 5 months, but I've now watched all of classic who, because of this channel. I thank our lord and saviour dwfan91
this is the best news I've ever received🙏 Thank you so much for sharing this
I have also decided to watch Classic Who because of this and other channels
@@dwfan91- Of course, and I urge other Nuwhovians to follow our messiah, dwfan91, into the light of bygone times
@@thechameleons7868 actually huge, how far in are you
I finished Marco Polo earlier today, I'm working my way through slowly in my free time
This is what peak DW content looks like & I mean it
In my native language (Czech), Doctor Who: The Movie was named 'Boj s časem', which can be translated as 'A race against time', which is kinda cool :D
that's awesome!
Thank you for making feel like I’m not a freak for just constantly rewatching a show I discovered on my own on PBS.
Your rant was my favorite part of this video.
Thanks for being you.
Thank you for being you too🫡
Honestly just… no words. This is Doctor Who content. Definitive Doctor Who content.
Thank you so much!
Let’s see what the G.O.A.T of DW content cooked up
🫡🫡🫡
You know it’s gonna be a good video when you hear
What’s up everybody
After this: Talking about Doctor Who title sequences until I go insane (I would watch the whole thing. I have strong opinions on the matter)
I may have to
@@dwfan91- 😍😍😍
There is one more factor for an epic title, shouting out the title name for dramatic effect. My favourite example of this, is to shout, "THE WEB OF FEEEAR". If it sounds absolutely epic, dramatic and purely mystical, then it's definitely an S tier. If I was to shout, "THE GUNFIGGHTERS". It just isn't there, there's nothing to go off here. It's not really mystical nor dramatic. It's an F tier.
idk I think I'm going crazy from watching Classic Who.
This is 100% accurate
the goat is back with ESSENTIAL videos we all love 🎉🎉🎉
Better get comfortable, this is going to be a ride
UA-cams holiest Dr Who tuber is back
Thank you as always jesus christ
The Enemy of the World should be higher. Great damn title. The enemy... of the whole world?? Who is this guy. I'm seated! Great episode too.
lol only just realised that grace is the woman who fell to earth 😢
1) The toymaker was never called “The celestial toymaker” in the original story, so dropping that title for his return in the Giggle makes perfect sense to me! We don’t call the monk “the time meddler” either so at least it’s consistent.
2) If the idea that Grace is the “Woman who fell to earth” is true (something I’m surprised you didn’t mention but you was in a bit to deep at that point) that means she’s the only companion who gets an episode named After her in the 13th doctors entire run. Bit of a letdown TBH the companions in Chris tenure needed more development. Yaz could’ve benefited from a episode like “Amy’s choice”
This is one of the reasons I love dwfan91, he does the most random videos you don’t get anywhere else. I love them.
I love how your descent into madness and then ascent out of it and then into it again is observable. After a certain amount of regular sized videos, you release something upwards of an hour and just go INSANE talking about Doctor Who. Good video.
Thank you😂 Looking forward to yours too🫡
Eyyo what’s with In The Forest of the Night and Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror not taking place at night?
im not watching this video but im listening to it while i poop, lovely audio
the perfect way to enjoy the videos
that's a long poop
i, dwfan92, humbly accept this video while we patiently wait for your Capaldi deep dive
side note, hella pumped for the new season and it happens to drop just after my birthday. good year to get older
Early happy Birthday! The Capaldi Era video (which will likely turn into Moffat era in general) will probably come out after the new season because I'll be focusing on new content about that
Honey stop what your doing, dwfan91 just uploaded
😂
Honestly the Pertwee and Baker era titles were pretty unoriginal. They were all titled "The deadly X of X" and stuff like that. They even made of fun of this fact in the curse of fatal death.
unoriginally EPIC more like
The Deadly Assassin judges you.
I'm hyped for the new season, HOWEVER, we all know the issues with the timing, BUT, a big but is that it is released just after my gcse's start soooo... I sad.
damn the timing is teeeerrible😭
Am I really about to watch a 1 hour long video ranking Doctor Who episode titles?
...Yes. Yes I am.
Because you're the GOAT
you should make another video with this exact same title but make it a ranking of the opening credits
Great video to watch so soon after I achieved my dream of completing autism by committing every serial/episode title ever to memory. Love seeing that there are other people as dedicated to wasting their own time over this show as me lol
A new hour long dwfan video!?! It must be Christmas!
You say you're rambling about random stuff no one cares about again? I care, although it can be debated whether I count as someone or not. Thanks for keeping it real.
When I first heard ‘The Faceless Ones’ I assumed it was some cool classic horror-esq idea and was super pumped to watch it one day.
Wasn’t quite what I expected when I first saw it though 😅
This is such a video /pos. I love doctor who titles so glad someone is talking about them
Yasssss love me an episode title analysis.
At the airport, with a pint, with some dwfan91, this shit is glorious.
Season 1 for me would of been
X. The Church on Ruby Road
1. Trapped in Space
2. The Devil’s Chord
3. Standing Still
4. 73 Yards
5. Finetime
6. A Night to Remember
7. The Legend of Ruby Sunday
8. Empire of Death
48:00 I think my issue with Rosa is that it basically regurgitates the same pop-history retelling you typically get when it had the opportunity to do something far more interesting with the actual history involved. I wouldn’t even b take issue with it if Demons of the Punjab wasn’t doing exactly that in the same season. I have a different but related issue with Legend of the Sea Devils in that Cheng I Sao was such an interesting figure to play around with, and they squandered her potential so hard. Not only was she a pirate so powerful and successful that she forced the government to compromise and let her retire with all her money, but she was also doing all of this as a woman in the 1800s. Did we get a story that did her justice, then? No, and that’s not even talking about the sea devils.
eh i don't really mind, yeah demons of the punjab is a step above but 'pop-history' is pretty much every dr who historical. i don't think they really needed to reinvent the wheel for a rosa parks story
S42: Church on Ruby Road - Empire of Doom
S41: Star Beast - Giggle
S40: Halloween Apocalypse - Power of The Doctor
S39: Spyfall - Revolution of the Daleks
Etc. Etc. Etc. .....
S31: Next Doctor - End of Time
An interesting fact I saw from Twitter is that Chibnill never titled an Episode on any of the Companions because RTD had Rose, Runaway Bride, Smith & Jones, Church on Ruby Road. The Moff had Amy's Choice, the Girl who waited, plus The Impossible Astronaut.
Also, I do see a sight pattern of good episodes having good names, however I would say an Episode like Nikola's Tesla Night of Terrors is an awful title but great Episode. Likewise with Bells of Saint John, I almost wish it was titled Clara?
Now for a bad episode with a great name, I think of Nightmare in Silver or Wedding of River Song.
Great video but it was a strange choice to include RTD, Moffat and Chibnal’s doctor who fanfiction as well as making it the second half of the video
TRUE
Which is funny, because they themself think the stuff they make is fanfiction.
Yeah I reiterate the GOAT comments. Feel bare happy when I see u got more subs. Creeping to the 14k 💪
The waffiling is crazy 💀
right I’m onto the unhinged part of the video now and i’m sort of getting what you mean (people read the titles as they review and this influences their placing)- and I agree Chibnall was good. Here’s an idea, video where you rename all the lower ranked episodes. Make better relevant names, then get people to rank with the wrong names and see if it does have an observable impact. Can you tell i’m in the midst of economics revision
Personally not a fan of the Aztecs or the Reign of terror. Saying that might make me seem like i dont like the things historical whixh isnt the case i do just genuinely think that these episodes are quite dull. Not to mention the gaping plot hole in the Aztecs as to why Barbara couldnt just order the Aztecs to break down the wall hiding the Tardis. I love most the others but these stuck with me.
I need to get the certified dwfan91 review of these hypothetical episode titles (if I get bored enough I’ll make a video on what the Idle Era would look like, also dw it’s only 8 episodes because they’re in the classic format):
I’m Nobody, Who Are You?(season opener, builds up mystery around the Doctor)
Antediluvia(Silurians at their height during the Mesozoic)
The Evening Star (don’t like this one, I’m trying to figure out a better title. If you have any ideas for a title for an intrigue story set on an airship colony high enough in Venus’s atmosphere to have livable air pressure, please share them)
In Plain Sight (Mansa Musa rutan story I mentioned before)
The Things That Lived On Mars(Ice Warriors)
Evolution, alternatively Beneath a Silver Sky(rogue nanotech threatens to consume all resources on a far future Earth)
Alternative Paths(The Monk meddles)
The Second Sun(an alien people bathe in the light of an interplanetary laser which has taken so long to get there that they think it’s another sun and the forgot about the war that made someone fire it at them)
I love fan projects so definitely keep it up! These all sound great as well but for the sake of constructive criticism, I will force myself to 'rate' them at your behest. So keep in mind that A- this is all in good fun, I love fan projects and I like all these titles and B- I suck at making episode titles😂
1- I’d say this is probably the weakest, as either part of the title would probably work better by itself. I imagine this is a back and forth in the actual story and makes more sense in context though
2- I like this one, probably my favourite
3- You say you don’t like this one but I think it’s pretty cool. Although it does sound like a newspaper
4- This one’s cool, sounds like a VNA title
5- I get the reference to ‘Thing from Another World’ but similarly to that title I think maybe turn ‘things’ to the singular ‘thing’ (?) If I had to force a criticism ofc.
6- I think I prefer the second version of the title
7- This is a good one although even if unintended I find the idea of an episode called “The Monk Meddles” (akin to the Doctor Dances) funnier. Depends on the tone of the story you’re trying to tell I suppose.
8- And your final title, while cool, might not be climactic enough for a finale. Unless of course this isn’t a full season structure and these are all individual stories in which case, very cool.
Thank you for sharing this and I hope my comment was helpful! Overall, all very good, well done!
@@dwfan91- This season is more of an anthology-type format similar to Series 11. The next season, on the other hand, I haven't developed much, but I plan on having the central antagonist be the Great Vampires.
Just here to join in on the Mark Gatiss love.
W
Also, thanks for the cookie I guess!
What psychos favourite episode is The Awakening?
One hour banger, guess it took awhile to go crazy hahaha
Finally, I shall find out what the Bells of St John and Death in Heaven are referring to!
Edit: nevermind
Edit edit: just like you, I always think the "last time" sequence in Bad Wolf is absolutely peak ;)
40:35 the angels just weren't looking at that bit
What do you think is the best way to view the lost episodes? Novelisations? Telesnaps? Something else?
In my opinion the best way to consume the missing episodes is through the audio books. Not the most accessible but definitely the most enjoyable
1:00:57 LMAOOOOOOO i dont even like these episodes but i absolutely love the titles because of the meaning/reason (what a shock)
GOOOAAAAAAT UPLOAD
THE GOAT POSTED !!!
YOU ALREADY KNOW🙏
Hey, I don't know if you've seen this but season 1 on dvd is £40, blu ray £50 and steelbook is £60! I think that's outrageous, what about you?
Yeah I did see this; the main people I see negatively affected by this and fans outside the UK as its likely people like me will be able to pick it up discounted from physical locations- so the price hike is really unfair. But even with that aside, its just a ridiculous pricing scheme.
@@dwfan91- Good thing we have CeX in the UK 😂
Morning FIRE!! 🔥🔥🔥
What tier would you put the title "Doctor Who and the Silurians" compared to just "The Silurians" as seen in this video?
S tier
this video WHAT your hard drive??
😳
You should make a video about why you don’t like blink. It is definitely one of the opinions of all time.
I feel like its one of the things I say over and over again in every video so it'd be trodden ground but maybe. If you watch my Dot and Bubble video at 22:40 I describe in detail my full thoughts on the episode so you can look at that if you're curious
I don’t think the chibnal era is bad, i prefer rtd or moffat, but its still good, im rewatching modern who (so that the blue line is on every episode 😅) and i have 71 episodes left, mostly season 11, 12 & 13… but thats probably because its over hated lol. 10 days to go! Btw i make lego doctor who stuff on my channel, I’m uploading a doctor who trailer in lego (15th doctor) when i hit 100 subs, and i’ll upload all the clips from the s1 trailers in order, on the 9th of May!
dwfan91 is the doctor who fandom's muad'dib
Show us the Torchwood titles!!! ❤
I think "The Giggle" is a meh title. C Tier for me, maybe I'm just a sucker for titles that think they're cleverer than they are as opposed to the perfunctory ones.
who is your favorite classic who writer?
Do we judge the episodes based on the titles, or do we judge the titles based on the episodes?
I judge episodes based on their quality
What’s the ambient tune that starts at 10:45?
51:55 to skip the part where dwfan91 loses it and get back into sanity (sorry dwfan91)
😂😂
Peak video
Thank you as always my goat🙏
I respect your opinions, but sorry, I have to ask: Are you seriously saying "The Angels take Manhattan" is a better episode than " Blink" because in Blink there are logic mistakes like the Angles do not freeze when they see their faint reflection in the window? *cough* Maby you haven't noticed... but in TAtM... THE STATUE OF LIBERTY somehow made it's way to a random hotel in the city WITHOUT beeing seen by anyone! 🤣🤣🤣
Would you be so kind and explain this to me kind sir? 🧐🤣
Angels Take Manhattan has swag blink has no sauce
Also,completly unrelated: You just put "Journey to the centre of the Tardis" in D tier for me. I have to disagree with that. This title is an omage to the book "Journey to the centre of the earth" by Jules Verne, whitch is one of my favorite books of all time. (He also wrotw "around the world in 80 days" or "20.000 leaks under the sea")
So the title might be long but this episode and especially the title will always hold a special place in my heart.
@@dwfan91- I see 🤣
@@diamant_2dot0 I got the reference, I get why you like the title
You’re both wrong, The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone is the best weeping angel story
why not include the new episodes not yet released? I think it would have made sense seeing as you're attempting to rank the standalone titles
LETSS GOOOOOO
ERIC!
10:35 SO TRUE!
Helll yeeeahhhh brother!!!!!
👑
Lets gooooo
Personally i woulda included a cringe tier there’s a few
Dinosaurs on a spaceship - feels a bit try hard idk
Power of three - lame asf screams filler to me
Arachnids in the uk - irrelevant sex pistols reference?? 💀
Spyfall - parody? Idk just feels childish
Nikola tesla - cant rlly explain this one
Just some that when i first heard it i thought fuck that (and still do)
All of these are completely fine💀
Well, I watched it
Did u seriously guess Sutekh hahaha
YEH
ALREADY???
Siu
Please completely lose the plot and end up rambling more often.