Andrew Lyord Weber actually said in a interview "Nightwish cover of the phantom. Is my favorite off theatre version." Back when he did the anniversary tour of the phantom of the opera. Not a bad endorsement.
"Can she do it?" Yes sir she can! Bringing all the weight up there, too, also have you noticed how her vibrato matches the beat of the song? That's such a cool detail to me. Marco and Tarja are both so powerful ya, but they harmonise really nicely together. 🙏🏽🌷 I feel like you'd really enjoy The Siren, maybe! It has beautiful story telling and really interesting singing styles, it's a very not-like-any-other song :)
"Can she do it?". She is a classically trained lyrical soprano. Please listen to her take on Mein Herr Marquiz, you`ll here her singing in her brighter soprano tone hitting the E6. Fantastic stuff and very different style compered to when she`s singing symphonic metal, naturally.
Yes, her name is Tarja (Tar-ya) Turnunen, the original lead singer. Tuomas did the arrangement, and Andrew Lloyd Weber loved it. It was part of a set, song #5 in an 18 song show. The concert was in Helsinki in 2005 (End of an Era DVD), the end of a long tour and Tarja's last show with Nightwish. but she didn't know it. After the concert , the guys gave her the open letter dismissing her from the band after 9 years and 5 albums. She has gone on to a long solo career. If you want to hear Tarja on a Nightwish song, stay with this show and try Wishmaster, The Siren, Nemo, Over the Hills and Far Away, or the show closer, Wish I Had An Angel.
Or he could do literally any song from the Wishes to Eternity DVD, or, better yet, check the Once upon a tour concert they did in Romania in 2004 that nobody ever listens to because nobody ever recommends it.
Tarja Susanna Solei Turnen - Cabuli ( Taa-rrr-ee-a Two-rU-nen) is classically trained with a Masters degree. And for that matter Marko himself is classically trained and fronted for Taro a band he formed with his brother. And if you check out her solo career footage live at woodstock Poland she shows real range and power covering Muse's Supremacy. She is a mezzo soprano with a warm round chest voice. That high note in Supremacy would blow the roof off, were they not on an outdoor stage. The other thing you will see with 20 years experience is how she owns the stage. Her power over the crowd. She calls her fans her winter storm. Now metal especially Symphonic metal is a sound they created together after hearing Tarja sing. They started in 1996 and this was October 21, 2005. Last show of ONCE upon a tour. 9 years together. And since then her discography, and work outside of just music is incredible. Also much more than just what you hear in Nightwish. I also have to point out she isn't an opera singer but more Chamber music suited but that is deep dive into differences not usually known by the general public. Classical music you can try the whole Beauty and the Beat concert. In addition she has a side project called Outlanders. Electronic music with guitar and drums. Guest starring legends in the business. With videos shot in the Caribbean nation of Antigua. Or her blue grass versions of 2 classics with the Finnish hillbillys Steve N'Seagulls in their Seagull's Nest. Helps to know the band's founding members are from Kites Finland a rural area along the Russian border. So they took the girl out of the country but not the country out of the girl. One thing to note about this performance, Webber himself labeled this his favourite non stage version.
I understand that you come from a different world but I'm going to make an argument that for musical theatre and even opera to continue to thrive that new arrangements and new approaches, including infusing metal into the mix, is essential. I say this as someone who has only come into symphonic metal in the last few years (so I don't have a particular bias towards metal) but who has been basically bored to tears by traditional musical theatre and sick of the tired old tropes and scores of opera (although Malcom McLaren's Carmen and Madame Butterfly managed to spark some excitement). So, to see Nightwish, be it with Tarja and Marko or Floor and Henk, reimagine this is refreshing. This is what the future of musical theatre could be if anyone is paying attention. BTW, I know this will probably be seen as heretical, but I think Antonio Banderas' performance of this song as the Phantom is the most snooze-worthy of them all.
I love it how scared you looked for Tarja before she did the high note at the end😂 I am always here for the old Nightwish❤️ please continue doing also the old singers of Nightwish. I do love hearing Floor, too, with Nightwish😊 Note worthy thing is that Tarja was sick during this concert, so her voice might have not been the strongest in this one but personally, I don’t hear it. Something that affects to their pronunciation is their Finnish accent. During Nightwish time, Tarja sometimes had quite thick accent (not in this performance, though). Nowadays, she doesn't have as thick accent, anymore when she sings, only when she speaks.
you might be the first person i've seen who wasn't somehow blown away by Marco :D this sure is a special version, Tuomas likes to put twists in his songs. Marco sounds a lot of more sinister but so does Tarja, it's the Gothic Metal Phantom of the Opera not everyone needed but that the world deserved :)))
This version is my favorite, the pairing of Tarja's rich dark classical vocals and Marko's rough heavy metal vocals created pure magic! My very close second favorite version is Tommy Johansson's!!! He takes on both parts and masters both!!! 😊
I have seen The Phantom Mange quite a few times at the theatre. I really love that musical. Still, the Nightwish version of that track is my favorite :-)
THANKS for some TARJAWISH !!!!! Amazing that she was ill for this performance !!!!! TARJA solo when counting her best of and half out OUTLANDERS album has 10 studio and 5 live brilliant albums !!!!! 💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘
All hale the REAL TRUE QUEEN 👑 of NIGHTWISH and of ALL FEMALE SYMPHONIC METAL SINGERS!!!!, the very beautiful looking and very unique voice of the enchanting TARJA!!!!!😀👍👍👍🤘
That's THE only Siren, Tarja Turunen❤ This was Fall, Helsinki, Finland 2005, "End of an Era" Tour concert. I was 18 then, I'm now 37. This was the last time we heard the Siren, the Viking, the Pirate, the Vampire & the Zombie all perform together. I'll never forget it... Beautiful venue, beautiful country. Thanks for sporting this reaction video!!! Cheers from Portland, OR! 😎🍻
Tar-e-ya my friend. J's are usually pronounced as Y's. No worries. It is just a metal thing. However, Tarja can actually sing full opera. I think you will like the more recent version from Nightwish with Floor and Henk Poort. ua-cam.com/video/TM23gaT4zkY/v-deo.html - Nightwish - The Phantom Of The Opera (ft. Henk Poort) (LIVE)
I really love that you said that Tarja doesn't sing full opera because even though she trains in the classical world she "departs" a bit to do it her way. but everyone says that she sings very "opera" and it is not like that. if you want to listen to Tarja singing a real aria I recommend: mein herr marquis etc if you want to listen to Tarja in recent times (she uses more vocal resources) I recommend shadow play in her show circus life live (she plays the piano too) or more symphonic metal I recommend stargazers or ciaran's well (I can get you the link if you want). I can also offer you something with house or electronic music or some Christmas music or dark Christmas music. Tarja is very versatile.
Lots of reactors come here for Tarja (Tarya), but always get shock by Marko Hietala, the Viking Bassist with the voice of a Thunder. Andrew Lloyd Webber has said once that this is his favorite version of the musical.
2 things: 1 - This version of live The Phantom of the Opera has been known as the best version ever performed in metal music due to the composition. Your comment on Marko had reached the top of his peak tone, I recommend you rewatch it without focusing on Tarja. Even the vocalists of Phantom, Hank Poort of Netherland, was impressed and copied Markocs style because it's ao menacing. 2 - Nightwish has released the remastered official version of Nightwish' The Phantom of the Opera with Floor Jansen and Henk Poort during live show in Netherland. You should react to that also. Henk Poort was the original stage Phantom in Netherland.
This is the absolute best rendition to me! But opera is one of the top three on my hate list. however i got one eception on two of the three! In this casse it's how they work of eachother and the fact that the phantomm actually seem to have a character. in all the other versions he's just background noice.
You're the only person who did not like Marco here! Wow I'm amazed. In fact this might be the best version of the song because of marco. but tastes differ that's life, no critique here.
I think you were unnecessarily critical. In my opinion, this song is just as good as the Floor+Hank version in Dutch T.V. (I'm not saying it's better), but at the same time it's completely different, more metal and darker, and the peak at the end is exactly as it should be.
Floor and Henk Poort just recently (like less than a month ago) performed Phantom of the Opera with Nightwish at a concert. I think you will really enjoy that performance.
There are not many, but some Flour fans who all but want to erase Tarja, so they bully reactors who give her any kind of attention. That’s one of the reasons why they’re giving you so much grief about Marco. Actually I’ve heard other reactors comment Marco may be a bit too heavy so you’re not alone. Me? This is my fav version, but I don’t expect it to be everyone’s. And I’m not under the impression that any singer is perfect.
Hi there great reaction I'd love to see your reaction to any version with Sarah Brightman My preference is with Antonio Banderas, link below... m.ua-cam.com/video/j9qLfyLowjg/v-deo.html And one should never compare the vocalists but the performance in itself and I'm a bit biased by my preferences so for me personally the best so far is with Floor and Henk in Beste Zangers and all of Nightwish's other versions also kind of lightyears ahead of the musicals Greetings from Sweden
In Marko's defense, you were speaking over him elevating.
Marko and Tarja were in high 5th octave. And there was a fantastic build. What were you watchin"? 🧐
I addmit I am a huge NW and Floor fan, but I prefer this version over all others.
Andrew Lyord Weber actually said in a interview "Nightwish cover of the phantom. Is my favorite off theatre version." Back when he did the anniversary tour of the phantom of the opera.
Not a bad endorsement.
Of course she can do it, she sings opera since her teens years.
"Can she do it?" Yes sir she can! Bringing all the weight up there, too, also have you noticed how her vibrato matches the beat of the song? That's such a cool detail to me.
Marco and Tarja are both so powerful ya, but they harmonise really nicely together. 🙏🏽🌷
I feel like you'd really enjoy The Siren, maybe! It has beautiful story telling and really interesting singing styles, it's a very not-like-any-other song :)
"Can she do it?". She is a classically trained lyrical soprano. Please listen to her take on Mein Herr Marquiz, you`ll here her singing in her brighter soprano tone hitting the E6. Fantastic stuff and very different style compered to when she`s singing symphonic metal, naturally.
She was the best, all the dark gothic operatic magic was gone after she left. 😢
Yes, her name is Tarja (Tar-ya) Turnunen, the original lead singer. Tuomas did the arrangement, and Andrew Lloyd Weber loved it. It was part of a set, song #5 in an 18 song show. The concert was in Helsinki in 2005 (End of an Era DVD), the end of a long tour and Tarja's last show with Nightwish. but she didn't know it. After the concert , the guys gave her the open letter dismissing her from the band after 9 years and 5 albums. She has gone on to a long solo career.
If you want to hear Tarja on a Nightwish song, stay with this show and try Wishmaster, The Siren, Nemo, Over the Hills and Far Away, or the show closer, Wish I Had An Angel.
Or he could do literally any song from the Wishes to Eternity DVD, or, better yet, check the Once upon a tour concert they did in Romania in 2004 that nobody ever listens to because nobody ever recommends it.
Tarja Susanna Solei Turnen - Cabuli ( Taa-rrr-ee-a Two-rU-nen) is classically trained with a Masters degree. And for that matter Marko himself is classically trained and fronted for Taro a band he formed with his brother.
And if you check out her solo career footage live at woodstock Poland she shows real range and power covering Muse's Supremacy. She is a mezzo soprano with a warm round chest voice. That high note in Supremacy would blow the roof off, were they not on an outdoor stage. The other thing you will see with 20 years experience is how she owns the stage. Her power over the crowd. She calls her fans her winter storm.
Now metal especially Symphonic metal is a sound they created together after hearing Tarja sing. They started in 1996 and this was October 21, 2005. Last show of ONCE upon a tour. 9 years together. And since then her discography, and work outside of just music is incredible. Also much more than just what you hear in Nightwish. I also have to point out she isn't an opera singer but more Chamber music suited but that is deep dive into differences not usually known by the general public. Classical music you can try the whole Beauty and the Beat concert. In addition she has a side project called Outlanders. Electronic music with guitar and drums. Guest starring legends in the business. With videos shot in the Caribbean nation of Antigua. Or her blue grass versions of 2 classics with the Finnish hillbillys Steve N'Seagulls in their Seagull's Nest. Helps to know the band's founding members are from Kites Finland a rural area along the Russian border. So they took the girl out of the country but not the country out of the girl.
One thing to note about this performance, Webber himself labeled this his favourite non stage version.
"SOILE" 😹 (not 'Solei' which referres more to Spain or France than in Finnish names)
I know typos happens 🙈
✌️😎🇫🇮💙💯
I understand that you come from a different world but I'm going to make an argument that for musical theatre and even opera to continue to thrive that new arrangements and new approaches, including infusing metal into the mix, is essential. I say this as someone who has only come into symphonic metal in the last few years (so I don't have a particular bias towards metal) but who has been basically bored to tears by traditional musical theatre and sick of the tired old tropes and scores of opera (although Malcom McLaren's Carmen and Madame Butterfly managed to spark some excitement). So, to see Nightwish, be it with Tarja and Marko or Floor and Henk, reimagine this is refreshing. This is what the future of musical theatre could be if anyone is paying attention. BTW, I know this will probably be seen as heretical, but I think Antonio Banderas' performance of this song as the Phantom is the most snooze-worthy of them all.
I love it how scared you looked for Tarja before she did the high note at the end😂
I am always here for the old Nightwish❤️ please continue doing also the old singers of Nightwish.
I do love hearing Floor, too, with Nightwish😊
Note worthy thing is that Tarja was sick during this concert, so her voice might have not been the strongest in this one but personally, I don’t hear it.
Something that affects to their pronunciation is their Finnish accent. During Nightwish time, Tarja sometimes had quite thick accent (not in this performance, though). Nowadays, she doesn't have as thick accent, anymore when she sings, only when she speaks.
you might be the first person i've seen who wasn't somehow blown away by Marco :D this sure is a special version, Tuomas likes to put twists in his songs. Marco sounds a lot of more sinister but so does Tarja, it's the Gothic Metal Phantom of the Opera not everyone needed but that the world deserved :)))
He’s not a vocal coach or expert on voice training. Only a regular youtuber. Never will understand how gorgeous is Marco and Tarya duet.
I think It’s the best version
Yes I concur ....... she did it ! 😉
After this one, you have to go a lot more into the past… „Walking in the air“ with Nightwish and Tarja ❤🏆‼️
This version is my favorite, the pairing of Tarja's rich dark classical vocals and Marko's rough heavy metal vocals created pure magic! My very close second favorite version is Tommy Johansson's!!! He takes on both parts and masters both!!! 😊
I have seen The Phantom Mange quite a few times at the theatre. I really love that musical. Still, the Nightwish version of that track is my favorite :-)
When Tarja looks in the mirror she sees nothing cause there`s only one Tarja!
This version is actually Andrew Lloyd Webber's favourite version of his composition
This youtuber don’t know Andrew Lloyd Webber. Probably only know The Phantom of the Opera by UA-cam.
This is the best version ever!!
I concur!!
ofcourse tarja can do it
Even Andrew Lloyd Webber thinks so
THANKS for some TARJAWISH !!!!!
Amazing that she was ill for this performance !!!!!
TARJA solo when counting her best of and half out OUTLANDERS album has 10 studio and 5 live brilliant albums !!!!!
💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘
All hale the REAL TRUE QUEEN 👑 of NIGHTWISH and of ALL FEMALE SYMPHONIC METAL SINGERS!!!!, the very beautiful looking and very unique voice of the enchanting TARJA!!!!!😀👍👍👍🤘
That's THE only Siren, Tarja Turunen❤ This was Fall, Helsinki, Finland 2005, "End of an Era" Tour concert. I was 18 then, I'm now 37. This was the last time we heard the Siren, the Viking, the Pirate, the Vampire & the Zombie all perform together. I'll never forget it... Beautiful venue, beautiful country. Thanks for sporting this reaction video!!! Cheers from Portland, OR! 😎🍻
Tar-e-ya my friend. J's are usually pronounced as Y's. No worries. It is just a metal thing. However, Tarja can actually sing full opera. I think you will like the more recent version from Nightwish with Floor and Henk Poort.
ua-cam.com/video/TM23gaT4zkY/v-deo.html - Nightwish - The Phantom Of The Opera (ft. Henk Poort) (LIVE)
I really love that you said that Tarja doesn't sing full opera because even though she trains in the classical world she "departs" a bit to do it her way. but everyone says that she sings very "opera" and it is not like that. if you want to listen to Tarja singing a real aria I recommend: mein herr marquis etc if you want to listen to Tarja in recent times (she uses more vocal resources) I recommend shadow play in her show circus life live (she plays the piano too) or more symphonic metal I recommend stargazers or ciaran's well (I can get you the link if you want). I can also offer you something with house or electronic music or some Christmas music or dark Christmas music. Tarja is very versatile.
MARCO HIETALA💪💪🤘🔥🤗!!
Lots of reactors come here for Tarja (Tarya), but always get shock by Marko Hietala, the Viking Bassist with the voice of a Thunder.
Andrew Lloyd Webber has said once that this is his favorite version of the musical.
2 things:
1 - This version of live The Phantom of the Opera has been known as the best version ever performed in metal music due to the composition. Your comment on Marko had reached the top of his peak tone, I recommend you rewatch it without focusing on Tarja. Even the vocalists of Phantom, Hank Poort of Netherland, was impressed and copied Markocs style because it's ao menacing.
2 - Nightwish has released the remastered official version of Nightwish' The Phantom of the Opera with Floor Jansen and Henk Poort during live show in Netherland. You should react to that also. Henk Poort was the original stage Phantom in Netherland.
This is the absolute best rendition to me! But opera is one of the top three on my hate list. however i got one eception on two of the three! In this casse it's how they work of eachother and the fact that the phantomm actually seem to have a character. in all the other versions he's just background noice.
Listen to, Song to the moon by Dvorak or Supremacy by Muse. Tarja is one of a kind and amazing✨❤️🤘🏻
Oh, I agree, great choice! And I would like to add "Innocence", she does miracles in that one too!
In the Finnish language "J" is soft, so "Tarja" comes out as TAR-YA, approximately.
Tarja make this song far far better away than Floor! She really have support air for this track and power❤ Tarja is the Queen ❤
You're the only person who did not like Marco here! Wow I'm amazed. In fact this might be the best version of the song because of marco. but tastes differ that's life, no critique here.
They've just released a new live version with Floor where she holds the end note for like 12 seconds or so. It's bonkers.
Good but not this good
You don't know his or hers range.
I think you were unnecessarily critical. In my opinion, this song is just as good as the Floor+Hank version in Dutch T.V. (I'm not saying it's better), but at the same time it's completely different, more metal and darker, and the peak at the end is exactly as it should be.
Floor and Henk Poort just recently (like less than a month ago) performed Phantom of the Opera with Nightwish at a concert. I think you will really enjoy that performance.
🤩👌💥💯🎼
🤘😎 🇫🇮 💙
There are not many, but some Flour fans who all but want to erase Tarja, so they bully reactors who give her any kind of attention. That’s one of the reasons why they’re giving you so much grief about Marco. Actually I’ve heard other reactors comment Marco may be a bit too heavy so you’re not alone. Me? This is my fav version, but I don’t expect it to be everyone’s. And I’m not under the impression that any singer is perfect.
👍💕
Marco is the star here. You must listen to Floor and Henk in Amsterdam (december 2022)🤟🏻🤟🏻🎶🎶
Why do you guys come over to the few reactions that this era gets and insult it. It’s just pathetic.
Hello ,you must listen spanish singers, India Martinez , El aire y el baile , o Pastora Soler quédate conmigo
She could've done it better. But I guess it was at the end of the concert.
Can she do it? Really... cba ^^
Please react to Halsey and Harry Styles
ok.......
Hi there great reaction
I'd love to see your reaction to any version with Sarah Brightman
My preference is with Antonio Banderas, link below...
m.ua-cam.com/video/j9qLfyLowjg/v-deo.html
And one should never compare the vocalists but the performance in itself and I'm a bit biased by my preferences so for me personally the best so far is with Floor and Henk in Beste Zangers and all of Nightwish's
other versions also kind of lightyears ahead of the musicals
Greetings from Sweden