corrections: - I was thinking of fat-h makkah, technically a 'hijra' (migration) back to makkah, but I understand it's not referred to as THE Hijra - I am not certain if Bilal actually led people in prayer, so maybe calling him "imaam" might not be correct. But he was a mu'athin (man who calls athan) 12:05 I make a prophecy.. fulfilled at 21:45 and 27:47 28:08 quote this every time a muslim asks you where you get morality from, if they're trolling 49:25 tangent about slavery, wives..
Have you considered doing videos on certain philosophical and theological constructs in Islam? You seem capable. One possibility. The concept of submission.
According to the Koran, Mohamed was a celibate and chaste person who did not have a slave, and never waged any war nor participated in battles. He did not steal, and nor did he marry anyone - least of all a fictional 9 year old. According to clear Koran verses, Mohamed did not marry or have children but lived and died a virgin. He never killed or hurt anyone and preached goodness and freedom. Mohamed prayed for the sick and healed them and fed the hungry people, whilst fasting throughout his life. However, it is astonishing to me that there are people in the Western world who are supposedly civilized and educated and yet choose to believe in heresy and unverified stories about Islam and its prophet Muhammad. Nearly all quotes that are circulated about Mohamed were written nearly 600 years after Mohamed’s death, around the time of there Crusades and many were fabricated by disgruntled crusaders who intentionally made up stories about a fictional child bride and dozens of wives whereas Mohamed was a lifelong celibate who never married anyone. However, I except this type of ignorance from foolish and illiterate Moslems who will readily believe you today if you decide to claim that Mohamed had 5000 wives, but as educated Westerners, I do not except you to jump in the bandwagon and believe in these pathetic lies about a man who was tortured to death 1500 years ago for proclaiming God is One. The imaginary tale about a girl named Aisha was invented much later as well and it is possible that some random mentally disturbed women claimed she was Mahomed’s wife but historically there is no evidence to that information. There are many evidence that anyone who is sexually active becomes violent and angry and eventually they become biased and falsely blame innocents so if you want to find out the real truth about any faith or person, then become chaste from today. Adopt celibacy and you will see that this is a proven method to gain the truth.
Sounds like Iran needs a national day for its many secular people and apostates to come out of the closet, so to speak. Persia is too beautiful for much more of the current regime.
Thank you for this answer. I feel it is necessary to accept that all people are meant to be inherently united in mutual humanity. Religions can benefit us sometimes, so it is wise not to overtly criticize religious beliefs of others. The Koran never commands slaughtering of humans or animals. It was a false practice that started way after the prophet’s death. The Hadith or sayings of the prophet are 50% completely false along with many of his fictional wives and their stories. Muslims prayed towards the wailing wall and facing Jerusalem for the majority part of Islam. It was much later that they faced the temple of Abraham (which is Kaaba in Mecca) but in the Koran, it is specifically mentioned that wherever you face you will find God and that means you can face any place and pray. It is not at all necessary to face the kaaba. People do not face any particular side when praying inside the kaaba. Also, if you are Jewish, remember Mohamed never ever killed or hurt any Jew. It was musaylamah the liar, who was a Christian who impersonated the prophet after he died in 625 ad. And he claimed to be a prophet and waged many wars against the Jews. The Jews didn’t even exist in southern Arabia at that time. The stories of khayabar or Mohamed slaughtering Jews or marrying Jewish women is 100% false. Mohamed never married any Jewish women nor did he marry anyone or have any children according to the Koran. Please feel free to peruse the book on my profile as it offers life altering positive advice. I found that anyone who is sexually active ends up hating religion and eventually they begin to curse God or criticize religion. So, in case you find yourself hating religion, or despising Islam, I suggest you become celibate and I can guarantee that if you become chaste, you will become magnanimously open minded.
It is always a pleasure to read your comments every now and then even though they may be in one or two words. I miss your videos in your channel as there are no new uploads from you, yet I can assume you are a busy person now while giving priority to your own health and welfare. You may not know that it was you and The Masked Arab saved me from embracing Islam when I was looking to replace the God of the Bible with this 'oneness' 'mercy/merciful' 'the MOST compassionate' Allah. Take care my dear friend.
Idk why people like this think former just need to “pray.” When I was in doubt I also cried practising “sincere prayer” many times. I felt scared, alone and like a terrible person for having these doubts and begged Allah for help. I wanted more than anything to be “guided.” Amazingly, that didn’t get rid of reason and I soon realised crying for faith wouldn’t get me anywhere and practically is a nonsensical thing to do. Then when you leave, they gaslight you by saying “Allah knows you weren’t sincere and you just don’t deserve Jannah”. It’s so dumb but that’s a way they can protect Islam without reason, because reason can’t protect it.
@Dri Ven i knew a person with somewhat similar mindsets, he expressed his views on girls exposing their skin in public (he sounded very fanatic with words and threatening at the same time) and boom i punched him hard, called the police told he was misbehaving to me, which he wasn't obviously (my version of taquiya) i warned him not to even think of that again or I'll get him . . . You can understand . . . Yes he was my friend . . . Moral of story - steel can cut iron and Islam needs anti-Islamic mindsets rigid and minacious . . . we'll have to subdue this fanatic cult at any cost, Do you agree ?
@Dri Ven hahahah are you joking, quran is full of voilence, hatred, killing, butchering women's rights (A) Quran 2:191 “Slay the unbelievers wherever you find them.” (B) Quran 3:28 “Muslims must not take infidels as friends” (C) Quran 3:85 “Any religion other than Islam is not acceptable” (D) Quran 5:33 “Maim and crucify the infidels if they criticize Islam” (E) Quran 8:12 “Terrorize and behead those who believe in scriptures other than Quran” (F) Quran 8:60 “Muslims must muster all weapons to terrorize the infidels” (G) Quran 8:65 “The unbelievers are stupid; urge the Muslims to fight them” (H) Quran 9:5 “Whenever opportunity arises, kill the infidels wherever you catch them” (I) Quran 9:123 “Make war on infidels living in your neighborhood” (J) Quran 47:4 “Do not hanker for peace with infidels; behead them when you catch them” All I'm trying to do is to use islamic teachings to fight islam
Yasir Qadzi is just strawmanning us. The first question that came to my mind was what is the purpose of life and why Allah is testing me. After all I am his creation so if there is any flaw, that's his problem. Why to punish me for his mistake. The other question was definitely about Quran. I am a geologist and certainly know that moon was never splitted, that mountains are not pegs and biggest question that always bothered me was why my Hindu friends will go to hell.
Thanks, Aladdin. Have a suggestion if you don’t mind, regarding a recent post. Ever thought of being a narrator for radio or tv or audio books? You sound like soft spoken voice of reason. Can imagine you being voice of a Disney character. Might help with your funding issue. Good luck!
haha thanks Marco, but I doubt Disney would hire this Aladdin I think using my actual voice here bars me from most voice acting jobs, not that I had considered that career
I get your point. Such a shame it is this way. If I was still in medicine, I would hire you as a counsellor. Your last video with noodle highlighted your skills - a good ear and non-patronising advice
@@ApostateAladdin you may want to consider a career in psychiatry. Takes about 10 years but you really have a sensibility for that. Or Perhaps as a counselor too. Perhaps even a lawyer. I think you have a lot to offer in such areas.
@@nymgrace1227 oh I'm too much of a mess to take care of other people's messes for a living, especially when their lives are on the line 😭 But thank you!
5:30 great point man, thats why I came back to islam after leaving it for a week, and then i left it for good after like 5 months, but hey, I’m open to any evidence Islam wants to give, but unfortunately the more they twist the meanings of verses the more I’m content on the decision I’ve made.
A world without morality or religion will be full of virgin sacrifice, gladiator fighting, feeding religious people to lions for fun in stadiums or marrying one’s own mother and son and daughter and grandchildren or sexually assaulting newborn children and murdering and torturing babies in satanic rituals like Aztecs or inheriting the fathers wife by the son and stripping women naked and not allowing them to cover their private parts, that was the worlds without organized religion and truth is , there is nothing worse than a world without organized religion. What about a world without morality or religion? What was life like before Abrahamic religion? Can man make laws to legalize torture and assault and slavery (Of Course call it prisoner of war if it makes you feel better and the bonds money bail money) but what about legalizing incest and etc? Without Abrahamic religions, who will decide it is wrong? What about legalizing cannibalism, virgin sacrifice, gladiator fighting etc. The only way we can be humans is if we all become chaste and give up depraved sexual practices. Some people hate Islam because they believe in fake historical stories. Because history even at that time was written by the winners. Saladin's mercy towards those men who assaulted his sister was unimaginable. The amount of madness the crusaders did towards Muslims and the way he forgave most of them was what made Christians of that time appreciate him . But today Christian’s have become so insane in regard towards their hatred towards Muslim that not only does their media constantly curse and blame everything and every crime on Muslims only that religion and no other criminals religion is mentioned , but they got to destroy the history and re-edit it and lie about it taking it only out of context to make themselves hate and blame Muslims even more . The jealousy is absolutely disgusting. I have never ever seen Muslims hating Christian’s nearly as much as Christian’s hate Muslims although in the last 24 years 17 Muslim countries had approximately 700,000 drones dropped by nato while not a single Christian’s country was attacked by Muslims. Not only that, Times magazine reports that starting from 1800, almost 180,000 books have been written by Christian’s cursing Islamic prophet Muhamad, while Muslims wrote over 30,000 books praising Jesus and Virgin Mary. It tells you something about them. Not only that Christian’s UA-camrs also started a mania 3 years ago blaming Middle East for enslaving all of Europe based on the unsubstantiated account of one man of Scandinavia whose wife was kidnapped, when the using of evidence starting from Elizabeth the 1st's court account shows records of royal disgraced English ship captain’s using Berber boats and their flags to kidnap and enslave thousands of people across Europe and selling them to the highest bidder. While it is true that some Muslims did buy those slaves but treated them better than their own families making them and their children's ministers and kings and caliphs of their nation. But Christian have become mentally obsessed with hating every bit of Islam including Muhamad's life story which historians claim to be 90% false with his entire life story written 600 years after his death. While Christians are busy hating Muslims , all of Europe is becoming pagan and Buddhist and soon they’ll ban Christianity in Europe and take down the entire Catholic Church for not giving them enough gender sexual rights and outright ban the Bible so, please if you are Christian, become chaste and celibate to control your hatred and passion and make Europe Christian again because right now wiccan is the fastest growing religion in England . Please stop hating on Muslims and Islam, the only religion that loves and respects Mary and Jesus more than any other religion in the world.
Thanks Aladdin. Great job. I am stuck between tribal Islamic culture and rationality but my mind is clear. Unfortunately I can not be brave like you. May be my children
27:25 "we have to think about whether the questions are flawed when the questions question the rationale of our unchangeable book , cos the book is unchangeable forever and there is no flaw in it".. 🤦🏻♀️🤣 And they still say its not a cult
At18:45 he says "you accepted" , when a child is born how could she or he have accepted anything, a human mind carries on growing till 25, and even after that our experiences keep on increasing ,so how can an infant/newborn accept?
You accepted Islsm as a baby in the same way you accepted a pacifier put in your mouth to shut you up and stop you from crying, annoying your parents with your needs. The only difference is that your mother eventually replaced that pacifier with actual food, nourishing you. Islam puts the pacifier in and never takes it out.
You accepted Islsm as a baby in the same way you accepted a pacifier put in your mouth to shut you up and stop you from crying, annoying your parents with your needs. The only difference is that your mother eventually replaced that pacifier with actual food, nourishing you. Islam puts the
Thumbs up. I also asked like you when i was a Seventh Day adventist and i found FLAWS... and unanswered questions. You actually find Questions like i do always. You have very high awareness bro
At 32:17 he says "rather than answering every question, take a step back and challenge your own understanding. Challenge your own paradigm before you challenge the Quran and the Sunnah." I find this argument so insidious. I could take him up on that challenge, but at the end of it, I would still want to know the answers to those questions. Is he hoping that we will get so distracted from our questions that we'll forget to ask again, or is he trying to intimidate us into pretending we're no longer curious?
I appreciate this so much. I had no idea this vid was out there. But I've heard of the holes in the narrative expose. Yesterday I did a tik tok on the holes in narrative. This is going to be a great follow up tik tok for me. Ta for the azomg work you do.
About the Aicha issue, I don’t understand how you can think the whole « it was a very long time ago, customs were different, etc » argument is valid. If Mohammed was the chosen one and blessed with a timeless truth, he should have known that marrying a six-year-old girl is wrong and at that such a young age you can NEVER be consenting.
Also, it completely backfires on the "fitreh" argument. Because if God installed in you morality that makes people find child marriage wrong, then God doesn't agree with Muhammad's marriage, so why and when did God change his mind?
@@iparipaitegianiparipaitegi4643 There is not a shred of proof that says Christianity is the true religion, so yes, it requires ultimately just belief.
@@Dhfhucudu if you actually studied the theology with an open mind you would actually have some ground to stand on making statements like that. I personally have studied most main line religions and most evidence points to Christianity being the truth in my experience.
@@Metanoia000 I already have ground to stand with the very definition of what proof is. I never said whether or not a religion is true…just that there’s no proof…
So the fitrah tells us now that muhammed's marriage to aisha was wrong. The fitrah must be right now, if not then the fitrah isnt an objective compass. Why didnt the fitrah of the ancients know that, that type of marriage was wrong???
Qadhi said: even if you don't believe in god, keep praying sincerely, because what have you got to lose? (Pascal wager) But how can anyone sincerely pray to a god whose very existence he doubts? There's an innate contradiction that Qadhi, as a believer for whom god is the default truth and reality, is blind to.
Hi there Apostate Aladdin, It would be greatly appreciated if you could add timestamps for longer length discussions such as this, as many of us like to skip to the relevant topics that come to interest. Due to busy schedules. Thank you, Sincerely - Rational Dogma
Amazing work brother. Your calm, intellectual tone (but still with very visible emotions which is great) is perfectly suited for discussing this crucial issues. As a former catholic i find it striking how many aspects are pretty much similiar if not the same in both of our experiences of religious conditioning. Allah be praised that we kept our sensitivity and critical thinking🎉😂
His comparison to Romeo and Juliet doesn’t even make sense. 13 and 14 is not the same as 6/9 and a grown man. 13 and 14 are comparable ages. Kids are discovering themselves at this time, they’re discovering feelings, romantic feelings are manifesting between peers… there is just NO comparison between Muhammad and Aisha. Also I know I’m late but I’m just discovering this channel lol
20:39 They might even have pressured Muhammad to reduce it. Like on many other instances when his followers demanded something and suddenly, two days later Allah came up with a new rule. Umar and the veiling comes to mind. "One night Sauda bint Zam`a the wife of the Prophet (ﷺ) went out at `Isha' time and she was a tall lady. `Umar addressed her and said, "I have recognized you, O Sauda." He said so, as he desired eagerly that the verses of Al-Hijab (the observing of veils by the Muslim women) may be revealed. So Allah revealed the verses of "Al-Hijab" (A complete body cover excluding the eyes)." - Sahih al-Bukhari 146
21:20 i loathe the fellas who are educated coming down to this level of local imams in mixing personal etiquette or actions to self justify or stop questioning an action of an "eternally iconic" person.. Do they assume everyone is dumb to be moved by emotion?? Nd repeat like goats "yiyiyeeessss oh sheik.."
What? We are supposed to use our minds, but please only in order to conclude that Islam is true? Mr. Qadhi, I can understand that you are not planning to topple all the things you have accomplished in your life... But who gives you the right to advise others to choose the same path? If you decide it feels more comforting, for you, to believe "Allah knows so much more than we will ever be able to understand" - fine. But how about admitting that usually emotional desire, and not rational thinking, makes someone believe in a superdaddy?
YQ is a pure sophist, as are all these dawah guys; but he's a Yale guy so can make a somewhat richer word salad and appeal to authority, for those who put stock in that. Re the age of Aisha - he defends Momo based on cultural relativism. Ok, maybe... MAYBE we could give him a pass on that count... but not if you're going to say he's the perfect human an all ways for all times. And that's exactly what this transparent sad sack tries to pull. I agree @apostatealaddin: it's very hard to be a YQ type, having dedicated one's life to BS... few people have the courage to pull out of such a mess.... ah the eternal yin-yang of guilt/innocence/victim/victimizer within the same individual.
@Nanny Pooh-Pooh. Exactly. These YQ types are well paid to corrupt the truth to fit into their religious doctrine. Moreover the elephant in the room regarding Aisha is Momo used his policitical influence & citing Allah's approval through a dream ( sahih al bkhari 5125 & Vol 9, book 87, number 139-140 narrated by Aisha) to steal Aisha from her betrothed Jubayr Ibn Mutim. And what about his multiple sex slaves besides is 13 wives for a sexy spiritual way of life.🤣🤣🤣
The argument to think, reason and question until you accept the Quran and then turn your brain off sounds like a terrifyingly good reason for nerdy thinkers like myself to never accept it. I tried reading that book a few weeks after 9/11 because I wanted to understand the viewpoint that has such a different concept of martyrdom than Christianity does. It was not instinctively "good".
The title of this video raised a question "Isn't he the one who said that the Qur'an's standard narrative has holes and it cannot answer pressing questions"? So I watched till the end. Nothing he said makes sense. I laughed at your expressions though your eyes. They widened at the same time as mine. 😂😂
25:10 - Yasir, is being deliberately obtuse here. Romeo and Juliet were both adolescent kids, who chose each other, fell in love or lust or whatever, as kids hitting puberty often do. Romeo wasn’t a 50 year old warlord coercing his best buddy and right hand man to give him his 6 year old daughter in marriage (sic) by dangling political power in front of him. It could be argued that while Rome & Juliet was a tale about star (age appropriate) star crossed lovers, Aisha’s marriage was about two powerful older men using the girls in their family as fodder to strengthen family & political alliances. Abu Bakr also asked for the hand of 14 year old Fatimahs but Mohammed refused him citing their inappropriate age difference.
@@iamzimj6724 i am convinced 100% percent that the characters in the texts of the Abrahamic faiths are fictional, and that belief in those faiths have hindered human progress
@@12yearoldscotch The prophet of islam also has non contemporary sources to prove his existence, for example the byzantines [romans] , armenians, copts [egyptians] and the sassanids [persians] had written about him.
summary: as a young , decided to educate and support the religion he was born in, when he discovered that it was coal the treasure was too late to change careers, now trying to avoid unemployment.
I am curious what Muslims think when you say that you will put your mindset back to a believer? I do it often as a ex-catholic, I never considered that I was lied to. The teachers believed, so I guess from that they thought it was true. It might not seem logical, but it is so logical that it looks illogical but it is logical.
His argument about reason being subordinated to belief, which is “suprarational” mirrors Martin Luther’s idea that reason served faith but but must be subordinated to it by serving it. Interesting that so many apologetically positions between Islam and Christianity are very similar.
People can question at any part of thier lives not just 16, 17, etc provided they are allowed to question and face new accurate information about Thier previously held Ideas
Yasir is saying once you decide the Koran is from God, you are supposed to suspend your critical faculties and not question Islam. But that is not how out minds, work. We ask questions when things don't seem to make sense or add up. That is normal.
18:40 The 5 daily prayers aren't really from Quran (at least not in a clear way). You'll find them from hadith, so he's not correct there. The Shia reject those hadith, which is why they essentially pray 3 times a day
17:33 did he really just say that??? So blindly follow; submit; accept blindly and expect that we won’t know everything…yes, I was raised that way and I just accepted it but I if I have questions it just goes back to what he was saying…just believe/submit and accept we won’t know everything
Even if I m convince the existence of God, but I can never convince that Mohd as the perfect role model for all times, he had 9 wives at one time, including his daughter in law, and at 52 married a 6 yrs old. He was a caravans robber, A genocidal warlord with multiple sax slaves. What kind of rilegion will have such role model?
Good point about the "standard questions" (at 2:50). Im new to this and would really appreciate it if someone could refer me to a rough list of these "standard questions" P.s. i think its also "core" issues he mentions at 9:30
It's very strange to hear the exact same things Christian conservatives have said for decades bow coming out of the mouths of imams. Perhaps they've been saying it too but not in a language i speak. Still ... It's so revealing. Islam is having a very hard time adapting to modernity. This week take patience, persistence, compassion and ultimately cultural resistance. It will have to from within the Islamic world itself.
A scholar in any religion is the same as a scholar in Zues or Odin/Thor or any other mythology. Choosing to major in theology or becoming a scholar in religion is like marrying your kidnapper, because you are becoming an expert in myths you were brainwashed in as an innocent child. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist, , , ,
He's wrong, of course, about 'fitra'. From a purely Child Pyschology angle, children do not have innate understanding of what is good and bad - it DOES have to be taught via parents, cares and teachers.
Oh? Has this been researched? Genuinely curious. I vaguely remember some experimental psych study that found innate empathy .. but that's not the same as morality. (But it is often argued to be the basic foundation of human morality.)
@@Robespierre-lI Hi. It's complex with kids isn't it and the nature/nurture aspect has never been resolved. What I was meaning is kids can show an innate sense of caring - for their soft toys and a new baby etc...but they are also quite cruel and can hurt pets , other kids , say nasty things, lie, steal and do in but there is a feeling that up to a certain age they have no rational argument for what they are doing or truly know it's 'wrong' until an adult points it out. Think of your gorgeous , loved, well fed and looked after pussy cat - he still plays with mice and birds and might even bring them to you as a present. Is that cruel? Innate? Learnt?
Exactly the same argument of his "This book cannot be from human" the same argument Mormons use to justify that the Book of Mormon is divine or some Hindus use to prove Upanishads Puranas cant be from human since they predict very well the age of the Earth etc
Hindus (or Vedists) don't defend their books are divine. In fact, there are many contributors to the Ved, Upanishad, Puran amd even Bhagvad Gita. In addition., all information (not just from these books) has been passed on through Shruti (telling/reading) and Smriti (memory), si, not everything has been written down. That's why "Hinduism" isn't organised & everyone takes whatever they want to take from it. Please don't confuse the Abrahamic religions with Vedism.
@@nnbg8000 I'm aware. I'm not saying they are the same, really comparable as there are many strands of hinduism though there are definitely some sects of it which try to defend it through similar means. Such as atheist tjump had a debate with hare krishnas in MDD titled "Does science lead to Hare Krishna?" where the hindu guys present the striking similarity between the age of the Earth and universe 'in the puranas and the Scientific cosmological observations.
What's the point of asking questions if the answers are illogical because as YQ puts it "faith is beyond the realm of logic". Basically you r encouraged to ask, but don't expect a logical answer.
Yep. Maslow's hierarchy of needs - if your priority is to feed and house your children, you're unlikely to be spending much time pondering the bigger questions. It's also, though, down to the internet and the ability of people to fact check the claims of religions and imams at the push of a button. "Islam doesn't come with anything irrational"??? How about flying horses for one? 🦄 "We might never understand why we pray so many times a day, etc, etc...." Er, possibly because Mo was making the whole thing up?? 🤷🏼♂️
We question all religions because some aspects of the stories are provably wrong, so as the Qur'an copies much from the Torah, including Adam and Eve and the Great Flood of Noah which are apocryphal, We question because we are better educated, and we judge books according to new knowledge. We also question in the knowledge that stories which have existed for over 1000 years don't require "revelation", just a pair of ears.
I really disagree with a yasir about living in the moment being useless. being present has actually changed me for the better. That doesn’t make me feel empty. I actually feel fuller in life without Islam. Also, living in the moment just means enjoying your time on earth, it doesn’t mean you’re ignoring the plans of the future or the reflection and introspection of the past. I’m appalled by this horrifically dangerous misinformation he spreads.
This Sheik and the Muslims who say ohhh nobody objected to Muhammads marriage to Aisha is a lie.... Her own father did. Sahih al-Bukhari 5081 Narrated 'Urwa: The Prophet (ﷺ) asked Abu Bakr for `Aisha's hand in marriage. Abu Bakr said "But I am your brother." The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "You are my brother in Allah's religion and His Book, but she (Aisha) is lawful for me to marry." حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ يُوسُفَ، حَدَّثَنَا اللَّيْثُ، عَنْ يَزِيدَ، عَنْ عِرَاكٍ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ، أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم خَطَبَ عَائِشَةَ إِلَى أَبِي بَكْرٍ فَقَالَ لَهُ أَبُو بَكْرٍ إِنَّمَا أَنَا أَخُوكَ، فَقَالَ " أَنْتَ أَخِي فِي دِينِ اللَّهِ وَكِتَابِهِ وَهْىَ لِي حَلاَلٌ ". Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5081In-book reference : Book 67, Hadith 19USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 62, Hadith 18 Abu Bakr tried to appeal to Muhammads humanity but because he has none he rejected it. It has always been criminals throughout history that has wanted to marry or have sex with children. Yet also Muslims are so delusional and brainwashed by Izlam and think it's so perfect and beautiful and nothing wrong with it.... it completely goes over their head that Muhammad was a mafia boss of his cult and who could dare question him when he controlled everyone by fear. Also, American law was about a 13 year old marrying another 13 year old not a 6 year old marrying a 50 year old perverted creep. These arguments are so pathetic and not only that NOBODY IS CLAIMING AMERICAN LAW IS TOTALLY PERFECT AND THE BEST PATTERN OF EXAMPLE FOR ALL HUMANITY LIKE MUSLIMS DO ABOUT THEIR PROPHET. What the hell is wrong with these people. If your stupid religion requires you to defend this kind of stuff.... it's not coming from a divine source but from the pit of hell pretending to be something holy.
"Why are Muslim leaving Islam?". I wonder. That is not a good question, actually. A better question is "Why would any person be Muslim?". That is a better question. Because I can find hundreds of reasons, thousands of reasons, why people should run way from Islam.
"the true believer is like a camel with a ring in his nose , being driven where he is lead" lmao, that says it all doesn't it. how absolutely shameless.
I just found your videos and I'm a bit late to the comments but I feel compelled to make a comment. It sounds as if his message is to just slip into your roles, follow the rules and be robotic like mindless zombies, until death. You're not allow to enjoy the short life you are given. Just go through the motions, don't think and do as you're told especially if you're born female. It's a dead religion. No progress, no growth, no joy, no curiosity, no emotion.. If you're placed on earth to be a stringless puppet for God to terrorize then what is the point. Just live in fear and sadness. A waste of life. No wonder people are leaving. We have brains for a reason.
You can’t question marriage with a 5 year old girl and consuming marriage at 9! Nooooo, that’s eternal, that is true! So, if you decide to marry a 5 year old, you may regret in a few months. Amazing logic! 💥 kaboom, there goes Islam! Beloved Muslim brothers and sisters, come home to the only true God, the God of the “kitab”. Your Quran confirms its authority over and over again. That is the Truth, and that is a decision that you will never regret! ✝️😉
corrections:
- I was thinking of fat-h makkah, technically a 'hijra' (migration) back to makkah, but I understand it's not referred to as THE Hijra
- I am not certain if Bilal actually led people in prayer, so maybe calling him "imaam" might not be correct. But he was a mu'athin (man who calls athan)
12:05 I make a prophecy.. fulfilled at 21:45 and 27:47
28:08 quote this every time a muslim asks you where you get morality from, if they're trolling
49:25 tangent about slavery, wives..
👍👍👍
Ex-Muslim from Iran and I love you dear Aladdin ❤️
@@mreza84 ❤👍
Have you considered doing videos on certain philosophical and theological constructs in Islam? You seem capable.
One possibility. The concept of submission.
According to the Koran, Mohamed was a celibate and chaste person who did not have a slave, and never waged any war nor participated in battles. He did not steal, and nor did he marry anyone - least of all a fictional 9 year old. According to clear Koran verses, Mohamed did not marry or have children but lived and died a virgin. He never killed or hurt anyone and preached goodness and freedom. Mohamed prayed for the sick and healed them and fed the hungry people, whilst fasting throughout his life.
However, it is astonishing to me that there are people in the Western world who are supposedly civilized and educated and yet choose to believe in heresy and unverified stories about Islam and its prophet Muhammad. Nearly all quotes that are circulated about Mohamed were written nearly 600 years after Mohamed’s death, around the time of there Crusades and many were fabricated by disgruntled crusaders who intentionally made up stories about a fictional child bride and dozens of wives whereas Mohamed was a lifelong celibate who never married anyone. However, I except this type of ignorance from foolish and illiterate Moslems who will readily believe you today if you decide to claim that Mohamed had 5000 wives, but as educated Westerners, I do not except you to jump in the bandwagon and believe in these pathetic lies about a man who was tortured to death 1500 years ago for proclaiming God is One. The imaginary tale about a girl named Aisha was invented much later as well and it is possible that some random mentally disturbed women claimed she was Mahomed’s wife but historically there is no evidence to that information. There are many evidence that anyone who is sexually active becomes violent and angry and eventually they become biased and falsely blame innocents so if you want to find out the real truth about any faith or person, then become chaste from today. Adopt celibacy and you will see that this is a proven method to gain the truth.
Ex-Muslim here, from Iran.
I love you dear Aladdin, you are very brave 👍❤️
There are so many in Iran, there should be an official day for all of you to come out.
Sounds like Iran needs a national day for its many secular people and apostates to come out of the closet, so to speak.
Persia is too beautiful for much more of the current regime.
Thank you for this answer. I feel it is necessary to accept that all people are meant to be inherently united in mutual humanity. Religions can benefit us sometimes, so it is wise not to overtly criticize religious beliefs of others. The Koran never commands slaughtering of humans or animals. It was a false practice that started way after the prophet’s death. The Hadith or sayings of the prophet are 50% completely false along with many of his fictional wives and their stories. Muslims prayed towards the wailing wall and facing Jerusalem for the majority part of Islam. It was much later that they faced the temple of Abraham (which is Kaaba in Mecca) but in the Koran, it is specifically mentioned that wherever you face you will find God and that means you can face any place and pray. It is not at all necessary to face the kaaba. People do not face any particular side when praying inside the kaaba. Also, if you are Jewish, remember Mohamed never ever killed or hurt any Jew. It was musaylamah the liar, who was a Christian who impersonated the prophet after he died in 625 ad. And he claimed to be a prophet and waged many wars against the Jews. The Jews didn’t even exist in southern Arabia at that time. The stories of khayabar or Mohamed slaughtering Jews or marrying Jewish women is 100% false. Mohamed never married any Jewish women nor did he marry anyone or have any children according to the Koran. Please feel free to peruse the book on my profile as it offers life altering positive advice. I found that anyone who is sexually active ends up hating religion and eventually they begin to curse God or criticize religion. So, in case you find yourself hating religion, or despising Islam, I suggest you become celibate and I can guarantee that if you become chaste, you will become magnanimously open minded.
Good analysis!
Thank you so much!
It is always a pleasure to read your comments every now and then even though they may be in one or two words. I miss your videos in your channel as there are no new uploads from you, yet I can assume you are a busy person now while giving priority to your own health and welfare. You may not know that it was you and The Masked Arab saved me from embracing Islam when I was looking to replace the God of the Bible with this 'oneness' 'mercy/merciful' 'the MOST compassionate' Allah. Take care my dear friend.
@@timetoreason181 He posts articles on his Medium now, you can find them on the Community tab on his page :)
Love your channel brother. It takes great courage to speak against Islam because apostasy is punishable by death according to Shariah.
Caste system
@@rakkhnaka What is the "caste" system?
Do you mean that bad practices and ideas excuse and justify the bad practices and ideas of Islam?
@@paulthomas281 if you want I will explain it bro...
@@paulthomas281 It's basically a societal hierarchy in Hindu Society. Peasants and proletariat folks at the bottom, Priest and noblemen at the time.
You are the gentle voice of reason. Wish you well friend.
Idk why people like this think former just need to “pray.” When I was in doubt I also cried practising “sincere prayer” many times. I felt scared, alone and like a terrible person for having these doubts and begged Allah for help. I wanted more than anything to be “guided.” Amazingly, that didn’t get rid of reason and I soon realised crying for faith wouldn’t get me anywhere and practically is a nonsensical thing to do. Then when you leave, they gaslight you by saying “Allah knows you weren’t sincere and you just don’t deserve Jannah”. It’s so dumb but that’s a way they can protect Islam without reason, because reason can’t protect it.
@Dri Ven wow so how do you describe your faith??
Secular muslim??
@Dri Ven jazakallah for your time.
@Dri Ven i knew a person with somewhat similar mindsets, he expressed his views on girls exposing their skin in public (he sounded very fanatic with words and threatening at the same time) and boom i punched him hard, called the police told he was misbehaving to me, which he wasn't obviously (my version of taquiya) i warned him not to even think of that again or I'll get him . . . You can understand . . . Yes he was my friend
. . . Moral of story - steel can cut iron and Islam needs anti-Islamic mindsets rigid and minacious . . . we'll have to subdue this fanatic cult at any cost, Do you agree ?
@Dri Ven all i did was to apply Islamic / Quranic teachings to my behaviour to Jihaad against Islam itself and you're calling it rotten . . . Wallah
@Dri Ven hahahah are you joking, quran is full of voilence, hatred, killing, butchering women's rights
(A) Quran 2:191 “Slay the unbelievers wherever you find them.”
(B) Quran 3:28 “Muslims must not take infidels as friends”
(C) Quran 3:85 “Any religion other than Islam is not acceptable”
(D) Quran 5:33 “Maim and crucify the infidels if they criticize Islam”
(E) Quran 8:12 “Terrorize and behead those who believe in scriptures other than Quran”
(F) Quran 8:60 “Muslims must muster all weapons to terrorize the infidels”
(G) Quran 8:65 “The unbelievers are stupid; urge the Muslims to fight them”
(H) Quran 9:5 “Whenever opportunity arises, kill the infidels wherever you catch them”
(I) Quran 9:123 “Make war on infidels living in your neighborhood”
(J) Quran 47:4 “Do not hanker for peace with infidels; behead them when you catch them”
All I'm trying to do is to use islamic teachings to fight islam
Yasir Qadzi is just strawmanning us. The first question that came to my mind was what is the purpose of life and why Allah is testing me. After all I am his creation so if there is any flaw, that's his problem. Why to punish me for his mistake. The other question was definitely about Quran. I am a geologist and certainly know that moon was never splitted, that mountains are not pegs and biggest question that always bothered me was why my Hindu friends will go to hell.
You and Infidel Noodle are doing great work. Keep it up :)
Thanks, Aladdin. Have a suggestion if you don’t mind, regarding a recent post. Ever thought of being a narrator for radio or tv or audio books? You sound like soft spoken voice of reason. Can imagine you being voice of a Disney character. Might help with your funding issue. Good luck!
haha thanks Marco, but I doubt Disney would hire this Aladdin
I think using my actual voice here bars me from most voice acting jobs, not that I had considered that career
I get your point. Such a shame it is this way.
If I was still in medicine, I would hire you as a counsellor. Your last video with noodle highlighted your skills - a good ear and non-patronising advice
That's very flattering. Thank you :)
@@ApostateAladdin you may want to consider a career in psychiatry. Takes about 10 years but you really have a sensibility for that. Or Perhaps as a counselor too. Perhaps even a lawyer. I think you have a lot to offer in such areas.
@@nymgrace1227 oh I'm too much of a mess to take care of other people's messes for a living, especially when their lives are on the line 😭
But thank you!
5:30 great point man, thats why I came back to islam after leaving it for a week, and then i left it for good after like 5 months, but hey, I’m open to any evidence Islam wants to give, but unfortunately the more they twist the meanings of verses the more I’m content on the decision I’ve made.
_watch 'Apostate Report: Why Muslims Leave Islam and the Consequences They Face' by Ex-Muslims of North America on Sep 30, 2021_
cannot find it
Here it is: ua-cam.com/video/1e-4BpXPIWI/v-deo.html
Your text is unclear
A world without morality or religion will be full of virgin sacrifice, gladiator fighting, feeding religious people to lions for fun in stadiums or marrying one’s own mother and son and daughter and grandchildren or sexually assaulting newborn children and murdering and torturing babies in satanic rituals like Aztecs or inheriting the fathers wife by the son and stripping women naked and not allowing them to cover their private parts, that was the worlds without organized religion and truth is , there is nothing worse than a world without organized religion. What about a world without morality or religion? What was life like before Abrahamic religion? Can man make laws to legalize torture and assault and slavery (Of Course call it prisoner of war if it makes you feel better and the bonds money bail money) but what about legalizing incest and etc? Without Abrahamic religions, who will decide it is wrong? What about legalizing cannibalism, virgin sacrifice, gladiator fighting etc. The only way we can be humans is if we all become chaste and give up depraved sexual practices.
Some people hate Islam because they believe in fake historical stories. Because history even at that time was written by the winners. Saladin's mercy towards those men who assaulted his sister was unimaginable. The amount of madness the crusaders did towards Muslims and the way he forgave most of them was what made Christians of that time appreciate him . But today Christian’s have become so insane in regard towards their hatred towards Muslim that not only does their media constantly curse and blame everything and every crime on Muslims only that religion and no other criminals religion is mentioned , but they got to destroy the history and re-edit it and lie about it taking it only out of context to make themselves hate and blame Muslims even more . The jealousy is absolutely disgusting. I have never ever seen Muslims hating Christian’s nearly as much as Christian’s hate Muslims although in the last 24 years 17 Muslim countries had approximately 700,000 drones dropped by nato while not a single Christian’s country was attacked by Muslims. Not only that, Times magazine reports that starting from 1800, almost 180,000 books have been written by Christian’s cursing Islamic prophet Muhamad, while Muslims wrote over 30,000 books praising Jesus and Virgin Mary. It tells you something about them. Not only that Christian’s UA-camrs also started a mania 3 years ago blaming Middle East for enslaving all of Europe based on the unsubstantiated account of one man of Scandinavia whose wife was kidnapped, when the using of evidence starting from Elizabeth the 1st's court account shows records of royal disgraced English ship captain’s using Berber boats and their flags to kidnap and enslave thousands of people across Europe and selling them to the highest bidder. While it is true that some Muslims did buy those slaves but treated them better than their own families making them and their children's ministers and kings and caliphs of their nation. But Christian have become mentally obsessed with hating every bit of Islam including Muhamad's life story which historians claim to be 90% false with his entire life story written 600 years after his death. While Christians are busy hating Muslims , all of Europe is becoming pagan and Buddhist and soon they’ll ban Christianity in Europe and take down the entire Catholic Church for not giving them enough gender sexual rights and outright ban the Bible so, please if you are Christian, become chaste and celibate to control your hatred and passion and make Europe Christian again because right now wiccan is the fastest growing religion in England . Please stop hating on Muslims and Islam, the only religion that loves and respects Mary and Jesus more than any other religion in the world.
you always are on point. keep bringing light to the darkness
Thanks Aladdin. Great job. I am stuck between tribal Islamic culture and rationality but my mind is clear. Unfortunately I can not be brave like you. May be my children
Move away your children will be better off for it. I don’t envy the position you’re in brother I hope for the best for your family
I understand u.. because i have the same problem.. the moment u announce leaving your faith your family life is gone
@@Ahmed-ze1kk that is a sad thing!
Religion beliefs over invidual freedom!
It is sad!
@@cocomamaforever3477 hey trust me, i just trimmed my beard a little and I got the worst if it…
@@Ahmed-ze1kk 😂, women cannot do their eyebrows it is a sin!
Haram 😀😀
27:25 "we have to think about whether the questions are flawed when the questions question the rationale of our unchangeable book , cos the book is unchangeable forever and there is no flaw in it"..
🤦🏻♀️🤣
And they still say its not a cult
It's a way around saying "don't ask questions. Shut up. Believe. Submit."
GREAT CHANNEL MAN.
I really like how you debunk the speech of the muslim apologetics, expressing implicit meaning.
At18:45 he says "you accepted" , when a child is born how could she or he have accepted anything, a human mind carries on growing till 25, and even after that our experiences keep on increasing ,so how can an infant/newborn accept?
You accepted Islsm as a baby in the same way you accepted a pacifier put in your mouth to shut you up and stop you from crying, annoying your parents with your needs.
The only difference is that your mother eventually replaced that pacifier with actual food, nourishing you. Islam puts the pacifier in and never takes it out.
You accepted Islsm as a baby in the same way you accepted a pacifier put in your mouth to shut you up and stop you from crying, annoying your parents with your needs.
The only difference is that your mother eventually replaced that pacifier with actual food, nourishing you. Islam puts the
I laughed out loud when I heard "Supranatural" or something like that. The mental gymnastics you have to go through to keep your faith.
Thumbs up. I also asked like you when i was a Seventh Day adventist and i found FLAWS... and unanswered questions. You actually find Questions like i do always. You have very high awareness bro
Thanks for doing this!
Another excellent video!
What he is saying is don't ask questions about Islam.
Muslims: "Trust me, brother."
At 32:17 he says "rather than answering every question, take a step back and challenge your own understanding. Challenge your own paradigm before you challenge the Quran and the Sunnah."
I find this argument so insidious. I could take him up on that challenge, but at the end of it, I would still want to know the answers to those questions. Is he hoping that we will get so distracted from our questions that we'll forget to ask again, or is he trying to intimidate us into pretending we're no longer curious?
A few years later the same Yasir Qadhi said "THE STANDART NARRATIVE HAS HOLES"
I think his lecture will encourage more muslims to leave Islam
If they decided to think for themselves.
I appreciate this so much. I had no idea this vid was out there. But I've heard of the holes in the narrative expose.
Yesterday I did a tik tok on the holes in narrative. This is going to be a great follow up tik tok for me. Ta for the azomg work you do.
Wow - Romeo and Juliet were 14 and 13. That was much better than 6 and 52!!!
Right? Like should two teenagers get married? No! But it's better than an old man and a person who just graduated from being a toddler.
About the Aicha issue, I don’t understand how you can think the whole « it was a very long time ago, customs were different, etc » argument is valid. If Mohammed was the chosen one and blessed with a timeless truth, he should have known that marrying a six-year-old girl is wrong and at that such a young age you can NEVER be consenting.
Also, it completely backfires on the "fitreh" argument. Because if God installed in you morality that makes people find child marriage wrong, then God doesn't agree with Muhammad's marriage, so why and when did God change his mind?
What he said can be applied to any religion. Just believe and don't ask too many questions.
Wrong. With St Thomas of Aquinas, christianity has married faith and reason.
@@iparipaitegianiparipaitegi4643 There is not a shred of proof that says Christianity is the true religion, so yes, it requires ultimately just belief.
@@Dhfhucudu if you actually studied the theology with an open mind you would actually have some ground to stand on making statements like that. I personally have studied most main line religions and most evidence points to Christianity being the truth in my experience.
@@Metanoia000 I already have ground to stand with the very definition of what proof is. I never said whether or not a religion is true…just that there’s no proof…
@@Dhfhucudu what’s your evidence gravity exists again?
So the fitrah tells us now that muhammed's marriage to aisha was wrong. The fitrah must be right now, if not then the fitrah isnt an objective compass. Why didnt the fitrah of the ancients know that, that type of marriage was wrong???
Muhammad’s ﷺ marriage to Aisha رضي الله عنها wasn’t wrong in any way.
That and sexual slavery. Alcohol? Banned! Pork? Hell nah! Selling and raping slaves? Allah said “keep it”
Honest question , what do you know about the marriage you speak of?
@@LeoMessi_22 Thanks for demonstrating how religion promotes evil and while failing utterly, attempts to justify vile actions.
@@LeoMessi_22نحن أكبر!
"Take a step back and question your questions.". Okay. Why are we asking these questions? Because we want to know the answers.
😂
😂❤❤
“Question your own questions!” = gaslight yourself 😀
Qadhi said: even if you don't believe in god, keep praying sincerely, because what have you got to lose? (Pascal wager)
But how can anyone sincerely pray to a god whose very existence he doubts? There's an innate contradiction that Qadhi, as a believer for whom god is the default truth and reality, is blind to.
Hi there Apostate Aladdin,
It would be greatly appreciated if you could add timestamps for longer length discussions such as this, as many of us like to skip to the relevant topics that come to interest. Due to busy schedules.
Thank you,
Sincerely - Rational Dogma
Amazing work brother. Your calm, intellectual tone (but still with very visible emotions which is great) is perfectly suited for discussing this crucial issues. As a former catholic i find it striking how many aspects are pretty much similiar if not the same in both of our experiences of religious conditioning. Allah be praised that we kept our sensitivity and critical thinking🎉😂
His comparison to Romeo and Juliet doesn’t even make sense. 13 and 14 is not the same as 6/9 and a grown man. 13 and 14 are comparable ages. Kids are discovering themselves at this time, they’re discovering feelings, romantic feelings are manifesting between peers… there is just NO comparison between Muhammad and Aisha.
Also I know I’m late but I’m just discovering this channel lol
20:39 They might even have pressured Muhammad to reduce it. Like on many other instances when his followers demanded something and suddenly, two days later Allah came up with a new rule. Umar and the veiling comes to mind.
"One night Sauda bint Zam`a the wife of the Prophet (ﷺ) went out at `Isha' time and she was a tall lady. `Umar addressed her and said, "I have recognized you, O Sauda." He said so, as he desired eagerly that the verses of Al-Hijab (the observing of veils by the Muslim women) may be revealed. So Allah revealed the verses of "Al-Hijab" (A complete body cover excluding the eyes)." - Sahih al-Bukhari 146
I have been binge watching your videos- you are so calm- i can listen to you all day lol
Circular reasoning with blinkers on. 3,5 and 7 are auspicious numbers in numerology being prime numbers (indivisible).
21:20 i loathe the fellas who are educated coming down to this level of local imams in mixing personal etiquette or actions to self justify or stop questioning an action of an "eternally iconic" person..
Do they assume everyone is dumb to be moved by emotion?? Nd repeat like goats "yiyiyeeessss oh sheik.."
Thanks Alladin
Always grateful to see you do these things.
It's absurd how Islam demands foolish congregation out of a people that are smart..
Cognitive dissonance on display. Love your work AA.
I'm pretty sure he confuses spiritual needs with need for belonging and life goals
What? We are supposed to use our minds, but please only in order to conclude that Islam is true?
Mr. Qadhi, I can understand that you are not planning to topple all the things you have accomplished in your life...
But who gives you the right to advise others to choose the same path?
If you decide it feels more comforting, for you, to believe "Allah knows so much more than we will ever be able to understand" - fine.
But how about admitting that usually emotional desire, and not rational thinking, makes someone believe in a superdaddy?
Yeah
You are dangerous man lol keep doing your reaction videos they are awesome
Thank thinking! 😊
Great video, keep going!
YQ is a pure sophist, as are all these dawah guys; but he's a Yale guy so can make a somewhat richer word salad and appeal to authority, for those who put stock in that. Re the age of Aisha - he defends Momo based on cultural relativism. Ok, maybe... MAYBE we could give him a pass on that count... but not if you're going to say he's the perfect human an all ways for all times. And that's exactly what this transparent sad sack tries to pull. I agree @apostatealaddin: it's very hard to be a YQ type, having dedicated one's life to BS... few people have the courage to pull out of such a mess.... ah the eternal yin-yang of guilt/innocence/victim/victimizer within the same individual.
@Nanny Pooh-Pooh. Exactly. These YQ types are well paid to corrupt the truth to fit into their religious doctrine. Moreover the elephant in the room regarding Aisha is Momo used his policitical influence & citing Allah's approval through a dream ( sahih al bkhari 5125 & Vol 9, book 87, number 139-140 narrated by Aisha) to steal Aisha from her betrothed Jubayr Ibn Mutim. And what about his multiple sex slaves besides is 13 wives for a sexy spiritual way of life.🤣🤣🤣
The argument to think, reason and question until you accept the Quran and then turn your brain off sounds like a terrifyingly good reason for nerdy thinkers like myself to never accept it. I tried reading that book a few weeks after 9/11 because I wanted to understand the viewpoint that has such a different concept of martyrdom than Christianity does. It was not instinctively "good".
What is point of applying your mind to the Quran if you are not allowed to conclude that it is False?
Crux reposted that a daughter of an Ex-Indonesia president and some
30,000 indonesia have just left ISLAM IN ☝️1 day
( a starting of THE TSUNAMI ?)
I recommend reading Ibn Warraq's " why I am not a Muslim". Very intetesting things said there. The Qu'ran Chapter is very shocking.
The title of this video raised a question "Isn't he the one who said that the Qur'an's standard narrative has holes and it cannot answer pressing questions"? So I watched till the end. Nothing he said makes sense. I laughed at your expressions though your eyes. They widened at the same time as mine. 😂😂
Solid analysis. My suggestion is to pause the video then comment instead of talking over while he is speaking. Also, try to soften your language
25:10 - Yasir, is being deliberately obtuse here. Romeo and Juliet were both adolescent kids, who chose each other, fell in love or lust or whatever, as kids hitting puberty often do.
Romeo wasn’t a 50 year old warlord coercing his best buddy and right hand man to give him his 6 year old daughter in marriage (sic) by dangling political power in front of him.
It could be argued that while Rome & Juliet was a tale about star (age appropriate) star crossed lovers, Aisha’s marriage was about two powerful older men using the girls in their family as fodder to strengthen family & political alliances. Abu Bakr also asked for the hand of 14 year old Fatimahs but Mohammed refused him citing their inappropriate age difference.
Yeah cannot comprehend why children should be fit to be married to men?????? It is creepy to say the least
“Prove he is a prophet.” How about asking Muslims to first prove he actually existed.
@@iamzimj6724 show me the historiography.
@@iamzimj6724 true, for you to find evidence would take a lifetime because you would be looking for things that don’t exist
@@iamzimj6724 i am convinced 100% percent that the characters in the texts of the Abrahamic faiths are fictional, and that belief in those faiths have hindered human progress
@@12yearoldscotch The prophet of islam also has non contemporary sources to prove his existence, for example the byzantines [romans] , armenians, copts [egyptians] and the sassanids [persians] had written about him.
@@بنت_الحق please refer me to the manuscript/s dated to the years 610-633 that mention the prophet by name, as having lived in the Mecca.
19:20- he broke his own pot. . yaaaaa qaaadhi . .. 🤦🏻♀️... We all heard the holes in the narrative
Ya, ya I've heard about the holey narrative too. How can he forgot what he said?
summary: as a young , decided to educate and support the religion he was born in, when he discovered that it was coal the treasure was too late to change careers, now trying to avoid unemployment.
I am curious what Muslims think when you say that you will put your mindset back to a believer? I do it often as a ex-catholic, I never considered that I was lied to. The teachers believed, so I guess from that they thought it was true. It might not seem logical, but it is so logical that it looks illogical but it is logical.
His argument about reason being subordinated to belief, which is “suprarational” mirrors Martin Luther’s idea that reason served faith but but must be subordinated to it by serving it. Interesting that so many apologetically positions between Islam and Christianity are very similar.
People can question at any part of thier lives not just 16, 17, etc provided they are allowed to question and face new accurate information about Thier previously held Ideas
Two of the most brilliant chaps ive ever seen
Yasir is saying once you decide the Koran is from God, you are supposed to suspend your critical faculties and not question Islam. But that is not how out minds, work. We ask questions when things don't seem to make sense or add up. That is normal.
I think reaction videos are the most important ones
18:40 The 5 daily prayers aren't really from Quran (at least not in a clear way). You'll find them from hadith, so he's not correct there. The Shia reject those hadith, which is why they essentially pray 3 times a day
the story of meraj was later added to islam by persians , it is originally story of a zoroastrian priest going to heaven to meet ahura mazda .
Hi Aladdin,
can you please put sources links next time in the description?
And thanks again ;)
17:33 did he really just say that??? So blindly follow; submit; accept blindly and expect that we won’t know everything…yes, I was raised that way and I just accepted it but I if I have questions it just goes back to what he was saying…just believe/submit and accept we won’t know everything
Any native arabs in here other than ala aldin and me🙈?
Not a native Arab but an Arabophile with great admiration for Arabic language though. Does that count?
Lord God was I shaking my head left to right at his words lol
Even if I m convince the existence of God, but I can never convince that Mohd as the perfect role model for all times, he had 9 wives at one time, including his daughter in law, and at 52 married a 6 yrs old. He was a caravans robber, A genocidal warlord with multiple sax slaves. What kind of rilegion will have such role model?
Good point about the "standard questions" (at 2:50). Im new to this and would really appreciate it if someone could refer me to a rough list of these "standard questions"
P.s. i think its also "core" issues he mentions at 9:30
It's very strange to hear the exact same things Christian conservatives have said for decades bow coming out of the mouths of imams. Perhaps they've been saying it too but not in a language i speak. Still ... It's so revealing.
Islam is having a very hard time adapting to modernity. This week take patience, persistence, compassion and ultimately cultural resistance. It will have to from within the Islamic world itself.
A scholar in any religion is the same as a scholar in Zues or Odin/Thor or any other mythology. Choosing to major in theology or becoming a scholar in religion is like marrying your kidnapper, because you are becoming an expert in myths you were brainwashed in as an innocent child. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist, , , ,
He is basically saying submit your mind to prophet mo
good summary 🙂
Meaninglessness can be liberating it needs not be depressed about.
On number 4 of minutes I agree with the speaker; Qadir in that human beings have spiritual needs. At core we are a soul not solely material
He's wrong, of course, about 'fitra'. From a purely Child Pyschology angle, children do not have innate understanding of what is good and bad - it DOES have to be taught via parents, cares and teachers.
Oh? Has this been researched? Genuinely curious. I vaguely remember some experimental psych study that found innate empathy .. but that's not the same as morality. (But it is often argued to be the basic foundation of human morality.)
@@Robespierre-lI Hi. It's complex with kids isn't it and the nature/nurture aspect has never been resolved. What I was meaning is kids can show an innate sense of caring - for their soft toys and a new baby etc...but they are also quite cruel and can hurt pets , other kids , say nasty things, lie, steal and do in but there is a feeling that up to a certain age they have no rational argument for what they are doing or truly know it's 'wrong' until an adult points it out. Think of your gorgeous , loved, well fed and looked after pussy cat - he still plays with mice and birds and might even bring them to you as a present. Is that cruel? Innate? Learnt?
We should judge any religion by the worst of its teachings
Exactly the same argument of his "This book cannot be from human" the same argument Mormons use to justify that the Book of Mormon is divine or some Hindus use to prove Upanishads Puranas cant be from human since they predict very well the age of the Earth etc
Hindus (or Vedists) don't defend their books are divine. In fact, there are many contributors to the Ved, Upanishad, Puran amd even Bhagvad Gita. In addition., all information (not just from these books) has been passed on through Shruti (telling/reading) and Smriti (memory), si, not everything has been written down. That's why "Hinduism" isn't organised & everyone takes whatever they want to take from it. Please don't confuse the Abrahamic religions with Vedism.
@@nnbg8000 I'm aware. I'm not saying they are the same, really comparable as there are many strands of hinduism though there are definitely some sects of it which try to defend it through similar means. Such as atheist tjump had a debate with hare krishnas in MDD titled "Does science lead to Hare Krishna?" where the hindu guys present the striking similarity between the age of the Earth and universe 'in the puranas and the Scientific cosmological observations.
What's the point of asking questions if the answers are illogical because as YQ puts it "faith is beyond the realm of logic". Basically you r encouraged to ask, but don't expect a logical answer.
Yep. Maslow's hierarchy of needs - if your priority is to feed and house your children, you're unlikely to be spending much time pondering the bigger questions. It's also, though, down to the internet and the ability of people to fact check the claims of religions and imams at the push of a button.
"Islam doesn't come with anything irrational"??? How about flying horses for one? 🦄
"We might never understand why we pray so many times a day, etc, etc...." Er, possibly because Mo was making the whole thing up?? 🤷🏼♂️
We question all religions because some aspects of the stories are provably wrong, so as the Qur'an copies much from the Torah, including Adam and Eve and the Great Flood of Noah which are apocryphal, We question because we are better educated, and we judge books according to new knowledge. We also question in the knowledge that stories which have existed for over 1000 years don't require "revelation", just a pair of ears.
Romio an juliet they were both young, not the an older man with a young girl
I really disagree with a yasir about living in the moment being useless. being present has actually changed me for the better. That doesn’t make me feel empty. I actually feel fuller in life without Islam. Also, living in the moment just means enjoying your time on earth, it doesn’t mean you’re ignoring the plans of the future or the reflection and introspection of the past. I’m appalled by this horrifically dangerous misinformation he spreads.
That sheikh sounds so hypocritical.
Omg im so angry and frustrated about all this bullshit,
Same😢
Yasir is like a pendulum swing left and right without anything to rest on.
Watching
This Sheik and the Muslims who say ohhh nobody objected to Muhammads marriage to Aisha is a lie.... Her own father did.
Sahih al-Bukhari 5081
Narrated 'Urwa:
The Prophet (ﷺ) asked Abu Bakr for `Aisha's hand in marriage. Abu Bakr said "But I am your brother." The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "You are my brother in Allah's religion and His Book, but she (Aisha) is lawful for me to marry."
حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ يُوسُفَ، حَدَّثَنَا اللَّيْثُ، عَنْ يَزِيدَ، عَنْ عِرَاكٍ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ، أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم خَطَبَ عَائِشَةَ إِلَى أَبِي بَكْرٍ فَقَالَ لَهُ أَبُو بَكْرٍ إِنَّمَا أَنَا أَخُوكَ، فَقَالَ " أَنْتَ أَخِي فِي دِينِ اللَّهِ وَكِتَابِهِ وَهْىَ لِي حَلاَلٌ ".
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5081In-book reference : Book 67, Hadith 19USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 62, Hadith 18
Abu Bakr tried to appeal to Muhammads humanity but because he has none he rejected it. It has always been criminals throughout history that has wanted to marry or have sex with children. Yet also Muslims are so delusional and brainwashed by Izlam and think it's so perfect and beautiful and nothing wrong with it.... it completely goes over their head that Muhammad was a mafia boss of his cult and who could dare question him when he controlled everyone by fear.
Also, American law was about a 13 year old marrying another 13 year old not a 6 year old marrying a 50 year old perverted creep. These arguments are so pathetic and not only that NOBODY IS CLAIMING AMERICAN LAW IS TOTALLY PERFECT AND THE BEST PATTERN OF EXAMPLE FOR ALL HUMANITY LIKE MUSLIMS DO ABOUT THEIR PROPHET. What the hell is wrong with these people. If your stupid religion requires you to defend this kind of stuff.... it's not coming from a divine source but from the pit of hell pretending to be something holy.
👏 👏👏
Thank you for that😮
16:37 That's exactly how I feel about Islam😂😂😂
"Why are Muslim leaving Islam?". I wonder.
That is not a good question, actually. A better question is "Why would any person be Muslim?". That is a better question.
Because I can find hundreds of reasons, thousands of reasons, why people should run way from Islam.
He told that we need to think and reflect but again he say not on the revelation of Islam. What he mean ?
"the true believer is like a camel with a ring in his nose , being driven where he is lead" lmao, that says it all doesn't it. how absolutely shameless.
This is the "Holes in the Narrative" guy. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I just found your videos and I'm a bit late to the comments but I feel compelled to make a comment. It sounds as if his message is to just slip into your roles, follow the rules and be robotic like mindless zombies, until death. You're not allow to enjoy the short life you are given. Just go through the motions, don't think and do as you're told especially if you're born female. It's a dead religion. No progress, no growth, no joy, no curiosity, no emotion.. If you're placed on earth to be a stringless puppet for God to terrorize then what is the point. Just live in fear and sadness. A waste of life. No wonder people are leaving. We have brains for a reason.
Watched all of it
yeah today muslim and muslim teacher alwys says that ooh islam wants to abolish slavery etc etc and I always feel odd...
thank you for the video
You can’t question marriage with a 5 year old girl and consuming marriage at 9!
Nooooo, that’s eternal, that is true!
So, if you decide to marry a 5 year old, you may regret in a few months.
Amazing logic!
💥 kaboom, there goes Islam!
Beloved Muslim brothers and sisters, come home to the only true God, the God of the “kitab”. Your Quran confirms its authority over and over again. That is the Truth, and that is a decision that you will never regret! ✝️😉
Ex-Muslim you tube channels are very informative.
23:24 Exactly!