Resistant Tapioca Starch - Legit Keto Ingredient or Scam? Is It Safe on Keto?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 кві 2021
- I've been seeing "resistant tapioca starch" show up in a number of keto baking products lately, along with claims that it has only 1 or zero grams net carbs (vs 13-14 grams in "regular" tapioca starch). In this video, I do a few blood glucose tests and I see how resistant tapioca starch behaves in a simple baking experiment.
Is this stuff the real deal? Or does it spike my blood sugar like a number of other supposedly "keto friendly" products have? Does it cause me inflammation? And if it passes those tests, will it have a place in a keto baker's pantry?
Big thanks to Janie Wang at Modernist Pantry for sourcing this product for me!
Modernist Pantry on UA-cam: / @modernist_pantry
📲Learn more about the Levels CGM program: levels.link/seriousketo
👉Get 15% off your Keto Mojo purchase: bit.ly/330F9C0
This applies to kits only and is applied during checkout.
Products used in this video:
Cuisinart mini food processor: amzn.to/3rLoIVE
Scotty's keto bread mix: amzn.to/31S2wyV
Bob's Red Mill tapioca starch: amzn.to/3ufDkOG
🏪 Serious Keto Amazon Store (where you can find the tools and ingredients I use): www.amazon.com/shop/seriousketo
👨🍳You can contribute to SeriousKeto's recipe test lab and enjoy some "behind-the-scenes" perks by becoming a channel member: / @seriousketo
-
👕 Get SeriousKeto merchandise: teespring.com/stores/seriousk...
📷 Follow SeriousKeto on Instagram: / seriousketo
👨🏻 Follow SeriousKeto on Facebook: / seriousketocooking
-
SeriousKeto is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. - Навчання та стиль
A little more info:
I had actually filmed a test of tapioca starch as a thickener, but cut it out of the video - both for time reasons and because I plan to do a comparison video of multiple thickeners to see if there is a keto substitute that works as well as corn starch. SPOILER ALERT: tapioca starch doesn't seem to have any liquid thickening properties.
Also, when I filmed day two of this video yesterday, my ketones were at .7. Today, they are at 1.3. So besides not affecting my blood glucose, there was also no negative impact on my ketones.
Thank you for all your research. I am so grateful for you and your amazing channel. BTW can't make a donut to save my life and crave house donuts saved me 😁
Tapioca starch needs to be heated to thicken
@@jeaninestaum3633 I did heat it.
Would you consider trying arrow root
Check this out and do a test --- you tube search ---keto cream cheese banana bread ketoserts ----- I suggest using native forest canned coconut milk instead of almond milk or heavy cream
I don't think i could have drunk that 🤢..aw the pain you go to for us.....
Your next t-shirt should say "Serious Guinea Pig" 😁
Thanks for doing the experiment. In Chinese cooking, we use Tapioca starch just like corn starch. If Tapioca starch is Keto compliance, it will open up a lot of possibilities for crunchy food: You can coat chicken wings with tapioca flour to make it crispy, or possibility of making tempura batter for deep fry.
I think we should all give you a continuous standing ovation. For taking one for the team, in the name of science, in spite of the negative effectsTo your blood sugar, and your inflammation. Love the videos, and love your channel! Keep up the good work.
This is such a valuable video! You are so willing to "walk the line" with your dieting experiments. I would be wrecked if I did tests on myself the way you do. I have to either contain myself or cut loose because it is such a struggle for me to recover and get my diet back on track if get thrown out of ketosis. Which is why I love it when you conduct tests. I put a lot of value in your tests and your results.
Interestingly, my ketones yesterday (when I filmed day two), my ketones were at .7. Today, they are 1.3. So not only did these not have any appreciable impact on my blood glucose, they also didn't have any affect on my ketones. Bonus!
I can’t believe how much you do for our keto community. There’s no one else out there who does such extensive, comprehensive and thoughtful testing and analysis. Thank you for all that you do!
I want to say first that I love the science behind your videos. It's reminiscent of Alton Brown's Good eats. I hope you take that as a compliment. Secondly you really do take one for the team in your videos when you are testing your glucose levels. When I eat off plan and my glucose goes up I feel like excrement! You keep doing what you do and I'll keep watching!
This makes it so much easier for others who are trying to lower their sugar intake. Thanks for experimenting!
Glad it was helpful!
Interesting experiment. So glad we have you to blaze the trail! I’ll definitely be watching for updated info after you try other brands of tapioca starch. Could be a game-changer, no?
Thanks for taking one for the team!
I do love these experiment on ingredient videos. Those results were unexpected.
Taking a couple for the team!
Thanks
OOOOOh so exciting!!! Loved this one.
Thanks for all this work. This is good to know. Love your content.
Very excited about this too!!! As always thank you for the time (and money) you spend helping us all!!!!!!!!!!
I appreciate your experiments and your integrity.
You took one for the team.
Great job
I find these test experiments fascinating
Thank you Steve for your experiments!!
This is so exciting! Thanks for all this!!! Hugs!
Wow Steve, thanks for chugging down a mixture of that stuff and water for experimental purposes! That's dedication and much appreciated!
Thanks Steve for doing this and sharing it
Awesome video Steve.
I love your keto food science/experiment videos. Good job. Thank you for informing us!
Looking forward to the other resistance starch experiments thanks for all your hard work we love and appreciate you
Thank you so much for being our keto science guinea pig! I've really been enjoying some of the new "keto" breads and it is so helpful to know its probably ok for my sometimes dirty/sometimes clean keto lifestyle.
Very interesting experiment!
I love your commitment to trying these products out for us. If things turn out well with the additional testing, I would certainly be interested in trying the resistant tapioca starch myself. Thanks again for being the guinea pig for the rest of us, and I'm happy you didn't have any inflammation issues because of it.
Another excellent video, thank you Steve!
That was very interesting - I'll be watching for the next experiment.
This could be a game changer.
Thanks for your hard work. Thanks Steve Jennifer 😄
Happy Easter to you and your family. God Bless you and thank you for days upon days of tireless research you do for all of us so that we can live a healthy and happier life. There's no greater gift.
Very neat. Thanks for sacrificing again for us. Wonder what else you are going to do with that. Love the kitchen science. Thanks for posting.
Very interesting. Your a trooper for trying that out just with water. Thanks Steve.
Thanks, Janie Wang and Steve
I bought the bobs red mill brand based on another keto recipe but never used it. I’m glad to see you doing this for the team.
Thank you for the review! You are so awesome 😁
You're AWESOME!!! Thank you for all you do!!
Oh I just love your food science content. Actually I just love all your content 🤷🏻♀️😄 Thanks for all your work on this
Steve you are such a good chemist always trying to help us how to make good keto delicious food thank you. God Bless you.
Great video! Curiosity over the ingredient list in Carbonaut bread brought me here. Thank you, and subscribed!
woo so interesting! thank you for being our guinea pig and an informative video as always!
Enjoyed the video. I just received some keto products with the tapioca resistant starch so was a helpful video. Thx!
I bought the Lakanto brownie mix at Costco, got it home, read the label and thought "uh-oh". First ingredient is tapioca fiber. Did some internet research and thought it might be a no-go. I don't know if it's the same stuff as resistant tapioca starch, but I figured I'd better test myself. Ate one brownie fasted, and at the 30 minute mark my blood glucose was actually lower than before eating it. At 2 hrs my BC was 10 points higher than at the start, so I was relieved. Incidentally, I made the brownies with olive oil instead of coconut oil (we were traveling) and they were WAY too greasy that way. Thanks for doing this vid. Interested in knowing how labeling works for this stuff...whether "tapioca fiber" in the Lakanto brownies is the same stuff you tested in the video.
If there's ethithrytol/monkfruit in the mix, that's temporarily lowering the blood sugar
I bought the box of brownie mix also. Haven't used it yet but so glad to hear your results.
@@jacobdebernardi4385 Hmmm. Is this because my body is "faked out" and pumps out insulin?
@@barbarachen1428 I don't understand the exact mechanism, but I do know that berberine and metformin activate the AMPK pathway, which among other things signals the liver to release less glucose to the bloodstream. I'd have to look into it more, but given that the recommended dose is 1-1.5g a day, I think taking 3g at once was just not a good idea
I want to thank you so much! I get very excited when there is a new product to share with us. I love your UA-cam Channel. I look forward to baking using it.
I still plan on testing a couple of other brands to see the glucose impact, but I'll be starting some baking experiments next week. 🙂
What a lad! Thanks for doing this Steve, you da best! 😁🤘
Cant wait for more recipes with this product!
Jenny wang rocks ❤️ thanks for helping out in our keto journey.
Thanks Steve for doing the uncomfortable testing for us.
You are one brave man to drink that stuff plain. But thanks for really working hard to keep variables down and working thru decent scientific methods
Wow! I love your kitchen science videos❤️👍.
I thank you...for all your work !
This was very interesting! I’m looking forward to your next video and new info!!! Have a wonderful Easter!
Thanks. You too.
Thanks Steve for all that you do for us….
👏👏👏👏. Thank’s for doing all this for us👍👏👍
Before I went keto I was gluten free. I made a flat bread with coconut flour and tapioca flour. My son dub it the best pb and j sandwich he had ever had. I think it was heavenly fans recipe before she was keto. I may gave to get some tapioca starch to see what i can do, at least try to recreate my sons favorite peanut butter and jelly.. he isnt keto.. Thank you for this.
Thank you Steve for being our guinea pig🎈 happy Easter to you and your family 🦋 I look forward to the future recipes💗🎈🦋
Same to you!
Wow. This has me intrigued. I think I missed the Lupini cookie video because I can’t find it. Now I’m confused on which one to try. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks for the review. I would have been hesitant to get bread made from Tapioca resistance starch. Costco now sells Keto bread using resistant Tapioca starch!
Thank you for another great video.
Cool! Thanks for sharing this - it's so interesting!
Thanks 4 the sacrifice and posting the results. ;:9
Very helpful. Thank you!
Thanks, really appreciate your videos!!
Thanks for another informative podcast. I just used whey isolate protein as breading on chicken nuggets and it was great. Since I do not test or check my BG I do not know impact.
🤣 I was never into science in school, but watching all of your experiments (and testing) are so much more interesting and not to mention fun! Keep them coming👍🏾
You do so much for us! Thankyou.
Wow I’m shocked
Great job and thanks for drinking the nastiness for us!
Hey Steve! Loving the white bread chauffles recipe. Making a quadruple batch right now! Easy peasy with the four waffle dash with the side wells for overflow. Can't believe I found it on Amazon! It makes the little round waffle just like the mini!
Awesome 👍🏻
My favorite recipe post gluten free, pre Keto was Brazilian cheese bread; little cheesy popovers made with tapioca starch. I miss them. Oh boy, is subbing in resistant tapioca starch could bring these back into my life, it would be very exciting! Thanks for the super interesting content!!
That stuff is insanely addicting.
Wow bud ... way to take one for the team!!! You're a good man. I wonder if something like Tapioca Resistant Starch could conceivably be to make a roux for gumbo? Man, we gotta find something, I'm craving some good gumbo!!!
Thank you Steve, I was waiting for this video. I’m very acquainted with tapioca from my past way of eating, it is so common from where I come from. It’d be good news if I can use it again. The question for me is are there two different starches in tapioca?
Awesome. Been looking at some keto friendly products and seen Tapioca starch and have avoided them because of it. Might do some experiments of my own now 😉
The more, the merrier. 😉
I only decided to try that pizza crust after watching your video and Have to say you rock! My glucose levels barely increased and I’m still in a state of ketosis. :)
Cool. I love your science experiments 😁.
Thank you!
You're so brave!
Thank you for this videos. Now I will go to Whole Foods to get the Redmills Tapioca starch.
Keto bubble tea!!! 🙌
You're a genius!
I actually just thought bubble tea
This is pretty cool stuff!
Thank you for doing the testing so we didn't have to!
You do a lot for us. Thanks, I don’t think I would try it in just water.
“I’m going to make a couple of Chaffles,” I knew it! I might love my dash mini more than my car and I knew what you were going to say. We love you Steve!!!
Thanks Steve
I sure wish someone would start up a keto restaurant chain , personally I like going out to eat and not great at cooking for just myself
Thanks for telling us this. You have no one else that will go to such strug..... to tell us these things.
I'm a ketovore, have been for about 8 months now. I eat OMAD and I eagerly await your vids. Steve, thank you for joining me on my journey. I can't wait to see your next podcast. 🥰
What is OMAD eating ?
@@judydonnelly1456 One Meal a Day.
I love the fact that you DRANK that (yuck) but what a pure form of a test!
Steve the lengths you go to for your viewers knows no bounds.
Appreciate the chugging of such an appetizing drink. Thank you for such an informative video. Looking forward to a follow up on another brand of tapioca flour! Oh and your hair looks great! Lol
Very helpful.
Really interested in the possibilities of this for baking! I’ve been making quick breads and cakes with Lupina flour lately and they have been great. My non-keto peeps can’t tell the difference between these and the real deal. No other flours used, just Lupina brand lupin flour! If this tapioca flour turns out to be keto friendly I think we may have a keto baking game changer between these two flours. Thanks so much!
I encourage you to try the Aviate brand of lupini flour when your run out of Lupina. I liked Lupina brand, but I LOVE the stuff from Aviate. I'll definitely be trying a blend of the lupini flour with the tapioca starch to see how it bakes up.
@@SeriousKeto i can't wait!!!!!!
@@SeriousKeto if you're looking for a great keto thickener, I've been making a roux with 1/4 cup lupin flour and 3T fat then slowly adding 32 oz liquid. At the end of cooking, I drizzle in 1/8 t xanthan gum that has been dissolved in about 1T of olive oil. It comes out fantastic! I've been making beef stew this way, and hubs can't tell the difference from non keto gravy. I feel like I've found the holy grail. :)
One more thing😆
You mentioned in a recent podcast about viewership being lower. I commented on that video that i was notified just after it went live. This video, however, I only got the notification today. Wanted to let you know if you wanted to factor that into your data.
very odd...
Ok so now I’m curious about cassava flour. Since tapioca comes from the cassava root, but the difference is that the cassava flour is the whole root dried and ground which means it has more fiber...whereas the tapioca starch comes from the starch being rinsed from the pulp and then evaporated till they have just the starch. I would really be curious to see your glucose reaction to cassava flour.
I'm curious too. 😉
I’m interested in that test too. I miss Paõ de Queijo!
@@SeriousKeto Me too.
@@lindagiangreco1976 love that Brazilian cheese bread. 😉
That could give a serious boost to quite a few of the Paleo foods sales. Siete Grain Free products, Birch Benders Paleo mix, Late July grain free chips, etc. I could tortilla chips again! (without having to make my own).
Thank you so much for the video. I recently did a blood sugar test on my favorite chocolate choc zero hazelnut and it spiked 30 points! Ugh i’ll do another test but that’s sad for me everybody’s different.
@@tracyandrirs8863 I just tested mine after some Choc Zero syrup and my bs was 168. Was probably 95 before. Yikes.
Some people don't respond well, glucose-wise, to soluble corn fiber.
Would love to see you do the Bob's Potato starch and potato flour.
I suspect I will do that fairly soon. 😉
Thanks Steve. I need that one
When you do it. Can you not heat the potato starch
Steve,have you tried Brazilian sour tapioca starch? I use that in my popovers and its amazing, but I haven't experimented with it in other baked goods yet. It has a different, grainier texture. Love your experiments
Pre-keto, I used it in Pão de Queijo, though I haven't since going keto. Sorry...
Wow!!!!!!!! Thank you for doing that test! What do you think causes it to be resistant based on your brilliant scientific mind? This is exciting!
I need to experiment more before I render a verdict.
Of course!!!
(I love your answer!!) 😁😁😁
Very surprising results. You could be on to something here Steve!
My take away today! I can make chaffles with cream cheese! My current favorites are still mozzarella and the blanco mexican cheese! They both hold any flavors I add very well! I’m trying cream cheese next!
I've been told that full fat ricotta also works well, though I haven't tried it.
Thanks for sharing 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤