THE GIVEAWAY HAS CLOSED. Winners will be announced on Wednesday (Feb 5) RULES: Leave a comment below (NOT A REPLY TO THIS COMMENT) stating: 1) Your opinions on these lights (for the manufacturers to see!) 2) what you liked/didn't like about this video 3) any other thoughts/feedback you might have :) There are 5 lights available, 4 Wurkkos HD01 (laser pointer models) in Black, Green, Green, and Silver, and 1 Wurkkos HD01 UV in Purple. All are cool white. The five (5) winners will be picked at random. I will reply to the winners' comments stating that they have won. If you have won, please send me an email (available on my channel's "About" tab) stating that you have won the giveaway. If you don't respond within 3 days I will select another. I will reply to your email with a code, which you ADD TO YOUR ORIGINAL COMMENT WITH AN EDIT to verify your identity. We will then proceed from there. First winner gets first pick of whichever light they want, second winner gets second pick, and so on. I will ship internationally.
1) amongst them really like the nitecore buts I can’t justify the price, cause I don’t need that much. Maybe less output and closer to $60-70? 2) video is pretty cool, I like your editing 3) Isn’t there other lights with this format under $100? Honestly I just don’t buy lights > $80
Great video. I have 3 different arkfelds but not the one you show cased. I also have the wuben x2 and edc29. I keep finding myself taking the edc 29 when I walk my dogs at night. I enjoy having access to 6500 lumens and a super bright strobe for self defense purposes. The pocket clip needs work as well as the waterproof rating. I wonder what a coyote would do if I turned 6500 lines on it. Keep up the good we work brother. I thoroughly enjoy your videos.
instead of "non replacable" i wish reviewers like you went with the ifixit route of scoring battery replacement difficulty on a scale of 1 to 10. every battery is replacable, the question is how difficult to source the cell and do the work, and how risky is it in terms of potentially damaging delicate connectors or cables
@@LuxWad I agree, and with right-to-repair gaining momentum, more battery makers will bring the price down by offering replacement cells. These might be 4 14500s packaged up.
@@LuxWad i also agree, awesome idea, like i said in my comment, these kind of lights should still have user serviceable batteries and no direct solder no matter what type or form factor used for the cell.
The thing people are missing about "non-replaceable" battery is that these Lithium batteries don't die after 5-10 years of USE, they die after 5-10 years of time. Sitting on a shelf, deactivated, can and will kill these batteries. A flashlight that you have used 20 times in 10 years can simply become perma-dead because of these non-replaceable batteries. A normal person who buys a flashlight does not need to, or expect to, or should expect to, buy a new flashlight for "new features" every 5-10 years. I have a 20 year old flashlight that works exactly the same as a new flashlight. Flashlights don't get "better" enough to justify having to "upgrade" them every 5 years for average people. The average consumer needs a device that can produce enough light to be able to see, as long as it does that, it absolutely does not need to be replaced, and the companies designing these devices in a way that causes them to not function after 5-10 years specifically to force consumers to buy new ones are acting maliciously. Additionally, if a consumer does need to buy a new flashlight for new features, then they can do so, WITHOUT having their old flashlight break, and they now have TWO working flashlights and can use the old one as a backup just in case. Non-Replaceable batteries are a form of planned-obsolescence to cause these devices that would work for much longer to otherwise stop working and become waste. The trend of non-replaceable batteries has caused e-waste devices to pile up a tremendous amount in junkyards simply because users cannot service or repair their devices and the devices are being designed to be disposable. Most people do not properly recycle electronics, because electronic disposal costs money, and many people do not even know that you are supposed to discard electronics in a specific way. For the record, not a single one of these flashlights sells replacement batteries. Though the Nitecore seems to be the worst since it cannot even be opened as it is assembled in a way that makes re-assembly effectively impossible.
Excellent point. Lithium-ion is not made with long shelf life in mind, and this format is a trap. Maybe once sodium-ion technology develops further and batteries last 15+ years whether on a shelf or in use, these will look attractive to my pocket. As it is, no thank you very much.
+1 I think these lights would be more viable if you could change the battery even if you need to tinket a little, solder and maybe break the light. I think it can be justified to get some of these lights but most likely not to get one of the expensive ones. Anyhow, I really hope this doesn't become the trend and tubes keep being the norm. A square flashlight is fine but please with a battery compartment.
That is true, but lithium-ion batteries are usually able to last 10 years or more without issue. If you keep the light charged instead of leaving it dead, the natural degradation of li-ion shouldn't really be noticeable
@@LuxWad also with the output and size....It wouldnt suprise me if there was a lipo battery in these even though it says li ion, ive scene that many times before in small high output devices
I have many lights and thought I would give the EDC29 A shot, it blew me away. The performance is far beyond what I expected. It fits well in my pocket. I don't even know it's there. The fact that it's so thin you do not realize its existence in your pocket makes it a joy to carry. This new form factor has got me hooked. Your information on each light seems to be spot on, as I've seen a few Thank you for the time and effort.
What I don't like is the lack of better emitters. Nichia 519A for the main emitter seems like a no-brainer. Your video is nice as always, what I would have liked to see/hear about is how good/clicky the buttons are on each light. Haptics are important to me.
519a would be great in these lights for sure. The Nitecore has really excellent clicky buttons, they are easy to operate blind. The Wurkkos buttons are a bit mushy but serviceable. The Arkfeld Ultra doesn't offer much feedback at all on the button, the ring is nice and smooth with clear detents. The Jetbeam's ring and button are much grittier and have more play.
I bought a Nitecore a few years ago, and had a problem with it. They wanted me to return it to China at my expense. Total crap for customer service. That's when I decided that there are too many light companies to deal with that kind of nonsense. Hank, Olight, Fenix, Acebeam, Sofirn, Wurkkos, Thrunite, Lumintop, and several companies have benefitted after my experience with Nitecore's poor customer service.
I get the target audience, but for me I’d either want bigger with replaceable batteries or smaller (particularly length). As for the video, I love the non-talking head with the beautiful B-roll. Also the mix of quantitative/qualitative data delivered in your calm voice. Quite relaxing! 😂
I have or had all of these. After having the Wurkkos in my pocket for 5 minutes, I packed it back up and sent it back because the corners were so sharp, they dug into my leg and after I noticed it, that's all I can think about.
I'm not an EDC guy at all, but these flashlights look so cool I kinda want one now. The magnet at the end of the Wurkkos HD01 would be very useful for working on my car. Would be nice if there was one with a stand that lets you set it on the ground at an angle when working on stuff. Very cool to see you go test the lights out in the field.
Great video comparison . Detailed explanation. Im really curious on these kind of edc lights and wanting one of these . For practical use you can’t go wrong with wurkkos.
Really like the form factor and size of these light. Perfect for pocket carry. The video really showed how great that sft40 is for throw. Keep up thevideos your killin it.
I really like these lights if you go into them to realistic expectations. I carry the edc29 after having the previous models. Got this one due to the physical lockout switch. Does great for edc and I have the option of high momentary turbo in an emergency. I don’t need all the other features and just want a pocketable tough light. UI is simple enough and it’s been reliable for me *knock on wood* Great overview of all these lights. They’re becoming more popular and it’s nice to hear the opinion from someone who’s better versed than most on them. Thanks for the content.
I like the form factor and have thought about picking up the Nitecore to try the new bar shape. I'm kind of bummed about the battery not being able to be replaced, I like the mag charger for people that might be just getting into the flashlight hobby but for me as a person with many chargers It's not for me. I'm also surprised olight changed their famous double click turbo to a triple click. I like that you showcased all of the lights in great detail and included a lot of beam shots of the various lights and modes. I'm excited to see your upcoming review on the similar shaped lights with replaceable batteries. I have 4 Hank Wang lights and for the price I don't think they can be beat. Especially since you get to customize what you get!
1) The Wurkkos HD01 is the best ones in my opinion. Not only it's the smallest, but it being the cheapest makes the non replaceable battery less of an issue. The side light could also be pretty useful for signaling, especially together with the magnetic base (e.g. using the bike in a foggy day) 2) There's nothing much I can say about the video except for the fact it's great. Informative, well produced and more importantly not needlessly long. 3) While I do like the flat designs, non replaceable batteries aren't for me. Producing e waste is bad enough and while I do see the uses here I don't like this trend getting to flashlights too. I just wish there was a replaceable battery small enough to make similar lights (maybe the 14500?) Anyway, again, great video. Can't wait for your review on the other two lights.
1. Nitecore EDC29 is a beast! It’s a good size. The UI is great. Perfect for self-defense (super bright) and tactical use. Olight Arkfeld Ultra has the perfect UI for flat style EDC (you can swap Turbo and Strobe). I prefer the Ultra for general use. There aren’t too many features (white, UV, laser). The magnet strength could be better or just use USB-C. JETBeam E26 has a nice design. The lack of moonlight is a dealbreaker. Wurkkos HD01 has too many features and the UI is complex. 2. I like the side-by-side comparisons. Impressive footage! It’s a bit like Project Farm in terms of formula. However, I find it easier to digest info when focusing on one flashlight and going through the features in the same order. That said, the comparison is probably better for people with too many options. 3. I wish manufacturers put more info about the UI in the printed manual. Olight and Armytek have some hidden features documented online but not in the printed manual. Nice work!
Your can reprogram the Olight to be double for turbo. Once you're in lockout, press the button quickly 10 or more times and hold your last press until the light blinks to switch turbo/strobe
Great one, I always love it when a new video of yours pops up, although i think in this case you should have waited a bit maybe, because the best is yet to come. Imalent GR35 has everything you need: SFT-25R, UV, laser, side light, magnet, dedicated lock switch, usb, charging case... On paper it's amazing. So far I like the Arkfeld Ultra the best, but GR35 has a slightly bigger battery and lower weight, too.
I saw the Imalent announcement, it looks neat. I couldn't wait any longer though, I had these sent to me back in September so I already took way too long lol. There's always a newer, better light coming soon
I'm the happy owner of EDC29 for several days. I also have flashlights from Hank (D4K and D3AA) so I am between tube and flat flashlights too! The power of the EDC29 blew me away - it's insane and I think I'm willing to sacrifice replaceable batteries for this amount of power. After all, the built-in battery will last for hundreds of charges - thousands of hours. I will probably buy a new flashlight by then :D Olight Arkfeld Ultra also appeals to me, but it is very expensive, and after the last purchase of EDC29, I no longer have the funds... I would love to have a flashlight with a laser, because I have never had such a gadget and I'll be happy to test it ! Your beamshots are very nice to watch - you have great conditions and darkness for recording, as well as a great view on the city! Professional film editing aswell, which makes it looks really good. Wish you all the best!
"Great video! Here are my thoughts: For the manufacturers: These compact built-in battery flashlights seem super convenient for everyday use. I love the portability and the fact that they’re rechargeable-no more buying batteries! However, it would be great to see more details on battery life and durability over time. A brighter lumen option or adjustable brightness settings would also be a nice upgrade for future models. About the video: I really liked how clear and concise the demonstration was. The side-by-side comparison with other flashlights was super helpful! If I had to suggest something, maybe adding a real-life use case (like camping or power outages) would make it even more relatable. Other feedback: Overall, this was a solid review! It’s clear you put effort into testing and explaining the features. Keep up the great work, and I’m looking forward to more reviews like this!"
I think these lights are great with all their features and the form factor i think it's a fair trade for not having an easily replacable battery. I especially like the Wurkkos given the price point and color options
This is a product category I didn't know exited but now I really want one haha Great video going over each of them very in-depth. Wouldve been nice if you included a table showing a summarized features-price based on your recommendations so we can refer back to them when we are looking at purchasing any of them! Hope I wind one :D!
I'd personally like to see someone make a single 18650 version of these lights. Maybe some sort of hybrid flood and throw setup. Enjoyed the video, looking forward to the Wuben review as well!
I really like when flashlight manufacturers, especially nitecore here, don’t over inflate their lumen output. Of course I expect a little rounding up, but keeping it reasonable is a breath of fresh air. This video also does a great job of presenting opinions as guidance while still showing the objective details which led there because everybody has different priorities and preferences.
I was just looking at the EDC29 but for that pricepoint the lack of water resistance makes me feel like the Wurkos is probably a better EDC for the price
I like these lights, Im just impartial to Hanks enthusiast lights so thats what I run on a normal basis. I like this video because LuxWad posted it and he always drops bangers (best flashlight channel on youtube)
I love my Olight Arkfeld Ultra. Seriously considering getting the Wurkkos Pro too. I liked how thorough your video is! I didn’t like the shaky video in the very beginning but I’m being nitpicky. I very much liked and agree with your opinions on the buttons of the lights.
You can change the setting on the arkfeld so it’s switches the turbo mode to double click and to make the strobe turn on by triple click. Love that flash light!
1. I think the lights have great value especially for someone thats not a huge flashlight nerd like some of us 😂. Most people dont care about CRI and beam patterns or want to figure out external battery choices and storage and they just need a pocketable light that is easy to use and works. 2. As usual your video quality is top notch. And I appreciate you using the lights for long periods of time in order to give honest use reviews and not generalities or forst impressions. 3. I think these lights would be especially perfect for flashlight nerds to give valuable gifts to people that arent as invested in the hobby. Simple use, rugged enough, but still they would get a taste of how fun flashlights can be, and share in the joys of "conquering the dark" as you say.
1) All looked good, current Olight fan. Will look at the others going forwards. Light profile is quite key so next investment would potentially be a Wurkkos. 2) First time watchers nice presentation and flow, no negatives. 3) Looking fwd to watch more from you.
Of all these lights, I'd say the Wurkokos is the most interesting to me simply because of the price. As you mentioned, it's a good way to try the flat form factor and as the proprietary battery degrades, I will be out less money. Sure, the new next big thing will probably come out by the time the battery degrades, but I'd rather it be swappable so I can keep it as a backup or give it away to someone. I'm always happy to see a video from this channel. They're always very thorough while also entertaining to watch. A flat flashlight was on my radar, so I'll probably have to pick one up soon and this video will be a great source for when I pull the trigger. Keep doing what you're doing assuming you're still enjoying making videos! This channel was the reason I got my first Hanklight and why I am the flashlight guy among my friends! :)
Definitely interested in this design of light, for an edc light I dont mind the battery being built in since many of our other daily items are the same. I always have a secondary light for work and also when im on the go that have removeable batteries plus usual have a power bank as well. The video was good, clear, and informative on all the lights.
Wow this is an absolutely great video. Thorough, easy to watch, and entertaining. Your knowledge on lights clearly supersedes most people, including myself but I have a couple suggestions for your videos. The graphs were the best part for me, but they were confusing to read and I didn't know what to look for. Maybe a comparison of the area under the curve for each light to show which one has the best total runtime? Also your second graph on the Nitecores was hard to read and understand since they're all the same colour and the only distinction is the dashes. This would normally be fine on smaller graphs, but the dashes are so small and so close that it becomes hard to tell. Other than that, the execution, the animation, the topics covered were all amazing. I do have a couple other categories I was hoping you'd cover about these lights. - I wish you talked more about people who own the traditional tubes and now we're looking for what's closest to what we love in our tube, but in a thinner, sleeker package. I come from an Olight Baton so obviously I looked at the Arkfield first and I would have loved to know how similar it is as an experience to what I already have. My experience has been, I charge it ever couple months, use it frequently and daily on medium to low settings, occasionally high, and often abuse it. I am looking for that same build quality, battery durability in the Arkfield. The real question I'm asking myself is can these other lights replicate that at a cheaper price, or should I just stick with boring reliable Olights. - The other category/topic I wanted to see is what kind of wear they go through, given of course that these are EDC lights. These lights will be in and out of pockets thousands of times, dropped, scratched and sliding across the floor, used as hammers, you name it. You did mention the build quality is the best, the feel was the best in the Arkfield, and that it was worth it's price tag there, but I want to see by how much. Is it worth the $20 I'm paying over the E26? Or is the E26 just going to loose a little big more paint sooner but still function just as well.. You covered this topic decently, but compared to how in depth and well done the rest of the review was, I think this category was overshined by your other great work. Your reviews are so detailed that I think even without these couple small tweaks and a couple other categories covered, you have hands down the best reviews I've seen so far. You are succinct, well spoken, and have a decent perspective on what most people might be looking for in a light. I'm not really one for giveaways, I am mostly commenting because you make such great content and I want it to be even better.
I really like the Wurkkos HD01! I've been looking for a new EDC light for work on my machines and it would fit perfect in my overalls. I would eventually like to try all of these though. Very cool video can't wait to try the Olight as well.
1) these are worth it for the lasers. EDC flashlights should be fun and having a dog/cat toy with you is a lot of fun 2) Runtime plots were handy and pretty. Lofi intro is very fitting 3) Glad to see Wurkkos still putting out quality for cheap!
I myself like to see extra little side features eg. the rbg LEDs, the UV or the led light - people will have use cases for these and them being inexpensive means that more people can have them or even multiples. I'm glad you gathered all the B roll footage with the light performance on the mountains and using the UV, makes it feel like a complete buying guide here on youtube
Those flashlights are really cool looking. I would definitely buy one if i had some money. The video was quite good, but not that much for me because of complicated stats of flashlights. I would definitely recommend that channel to my friends
Not having to mess with swapping batteries at the worst times is a huge plus-just charge it up at night, and you're good to go. Way more convenient than dealing with dead batteries when you actually need the light. The video was solid! I liked seeing them in action, but it would've been cool to get a bit more on how they hold up over time, like durability after some real use. Either way, appreciate the giveaway and the chance to win!
I had the wurkkos for a bit before i gave it to my dad i thought it was alright, honestly i didnt find much use from the extra functions and I am doing perfectly fine with my d3aa which i have in my wallet. Great video love the graphs as always! Honestly was surprised by the lumens the nitecore got out. Thanks for the giveaway!
1) I like the nitecore for its sheer power. Although in my opinion, a UV flashlight has the plus that you can cure different plastics. 2) I like that the video is informative and that you showed battery ones at the end. Also, I think your opinion in the end why you will keep on the tube lights make sense and gives value to the video. 3) These lights are pretty cool, dint know they existed, thanks.
You can switch the setting of the turbo and strobe mode on the Arkfeld by pressing the power button a number of times (ten times, I believe). It should say so in the manual. Not a deal breaker for me
I like this style of lights because of their size; I find them more pleasant to carry in my pocket. The interfaces are quite interesting. The issue for me is with the non-replaceable batteries.
Well, I only like one or two years into flashlight. These new flat form factor are in my opinion kinda love or hate it for some people. Wurkkos already famous by great price to performance, and this light is no exception. I think perfect value for someone who want to try flat light. The other light (olight, nitecore, jetbeam) I'm sure also have great quality, But me personally havent tried any of those brand. It always great to see your video comparing light with different price bracket (and also mention the price), so viewer can make decision more easily.
Just got the Wurkkos HD01 Pro, great light. Have you seen the TrustFire Mini X3 and the new Fenix E06R? Also, what do you think about the Wuben X2 Pro?
I have very mixed thoughts on the X2 Pro - genius ideas, questionable execution. I want Wuben to make more, it's awesome, but also I wouldn't recommend it in its current form. I haven't seen that Fenix before, it looks really neat. Not really a size I care for though
You can change the Arkfeld Ultra to double-click for turbo. Put the light into lockout (hold the button for 4 seconds), then click the button at least 10 times quickly.
I like that these lights are slim, I feel like the form factor will make it easier to grab and go carry. I really like then cinematography of your videos, makes it very esthetically pleasing and entertaining along with being informative. Im looking forward to the wuben x2pro review, based off what I read online its not that solid of a light.
I've been considering getting a Nitecore EDC29 for the past two months now, but I've scared to pull the trigger because of no replacable battery and potentially better options around the corner. I like that this video compared many different options and different price points and no yelling, this was a calm video. I also like the beam tests for each one of the lights and charts to compare different lights and when the turbo modes fall off. I'm just getting into the flashlight world and I'm not sure which direction to go in.
I get the multitool idea, as well as the form factor. I don't see why a rectangular replaceable battery is a bridge too far, though. Excellent video style but yeah: like you, I'll wait out this first wave.
All the lights look really practical and cool, but the Nitecore looks to me like the 'tacticooler,' lol. Like you said, moonlight is vital, and I would have liked it if you mentioned the lumen output of the moonlights. Thanks for making me addicted to Hanklight with your past videos! Really great video as always!
The Wurkkos flashlight is a very neat light! It has so many features - high output front emitter, green laser, white flood side lights, and finally, nice RGB bonus array! It’s a lot. Fortunately, the user interface is reasonably straightforward. USB-C charging is great, but I do not love the fact that the battery can never be replaced. Still, for this price, it’s a great way to get so many features!
I liked the idea of flat light. I have the original Arkfeld and just ordered the more compact nitecore edc 23. Wished it was water proof. Like the video not too short and not too long. Was those beam shot at Mission Peak?
Hello. 1. The Wurkkos HD01 is coincidently my favorite one. 2. I like your relaxed narration and objective conclusion at the end of the video. These edc category flashlights with build in batteries are definitelly a handy products, made smaller. Downsize is of course the fact that the battery is built in. No question about that. 3. When it comes to Olight - Imho they should build in also USB-C charging port.
i have my eye on the wurkkos light, looks really nice. also have other models from them and olight and all are great quality. the video was very informative and I might be getting the wurkkos now because of this vid. right now i am enjoying the trustfire mini x3. thanks!
I think this silly l style of light is a good option to have. Carry-ability is an important consideration and these generally being slimmer helps (of course there are tradeoffs). Great video, it has it all - graphs, outdoor shots, etc. Thanks.
Thanks! Great form factor, but a non-replaceable battery is a dealbreaker for me. Typical LuxWad video, which is excellent, informative and gets a like!
Really liking the EDC29. The output looks amazing in your videos. I'm torn between that or the HD01 Pro. What I really like about your videos is that you provided multiple beam shots in different landscape. It makes testing/reviewing the lights more practice for multiple environments. Hope to win the giveaway!
The Nitecore appears to have the most features, but it also seems a bit overly complicated and "tacticool." Olight is an instant no for me due to its proprietary charger. Jetbeam and Wurkkos seem like the best options, though I'm not sure if I'd ever have a real use for UV. For me, the top priority is runtime/battery life since the battery isn't replaceable-this kind of device will likely sit in a backpack for long periods, so I want to be sure it's always ready to use. I had no idea these flat-style flashlights even existed, so your video was my first introduction to them. You did a fantastic job explaining the differences and highlighting their features. I really like the slim design, and the USB-C charging is a huge plus since I could just plug it into my laptop while working instead of carrying a separate 18500 charger. Keep up the great work!
I echo your comment about the Olight charger. It's well engineered and works flawlessly but it's also completely unnecessary. I think they're just showing off with it. Sooner or later they will have to come to their senses and design a USB charging system.
Love Wurkkos for the giveaway! 1) that Nitecore is a beast! How can they possibly be getting that much light of that size!? The Jetbeam has the coolest look to my eyes. I like OLIGHT for the craftsmanship but I’m not a fan of proprietary charging/batteries. For me the Wurkkos is the winner because of the price for what you get. 2) Your videos are great as always! Been dying to see the best one drop. Production is second to none. 3) I wonder if you would be willing to do some recommendations based on your personal collection and current carry. An everyday carry video.
1) I'm liking the mode selector on the Olight and JetBeam along with the tailswitch. The exposed usb port might not be the best choice, since as you said it'll definitely get gunked, but I imagine it will be similar to phone ports, so not a big deal but still, I would like to see a flap nonetheless. Wurkkos keeps it simple and cheap, great choice for those who just want to test the form factor/features (UV, laser). 2) The watching experience is great, enough information in a short format video that doesn't feel rushed at all, with some very nice close-ups of the lights. 3) I agree with the moonlight problem, I find it essential in a flashlight, especially in the EDC category. I outright did not buy a few edc lights because of a lacking moonlight mode (ie too bright/non existent).
1. I really like this flat style EDC form, it fits better in the pocket, less chance of it rolling over when placed somewhere. 2. My favorite part of the video is that you showed outdoors uses and urban uses , most creators usually just show one side. 3. I wish there was still a way to make them magnetic or at least a swivel head 4. I'll take the green or black laser one but I'll settle for UV 😜
1) I like the idea of these flat bodied lights, I just haven't gotten behind the outputs yet. I generally gravitate more towards throwers in a neutral tint, and these all are more floody in cool white 2) The video was a good comparison of all the "normal" flat body options out there, I don't really think there is much you missed 3) Keep up the good work! Looking forward to the SK05 Pro review
Coming into this, I only knew about the Nightcore, but it's amazing how much lumen output these compact flashlights can deliver. The jetbeam really stood out to me-I love its design and performance. This was an excellent comparison, and I'll definitely be tuning in again!
Love the Arkfeld, I've got 2 of them (one with a swapped FFL351A 3700k Rosy tint emitter). I was also tempted to buy the Wurkkos version given the price. Thanks for the video, I appreciate your thoroughness and plentiful beam shots!
Thanks for doing the giveaway! 1) I think these flat style flashlight are definitely handy and innovative. While I too prefer replacing batteries, I think by the time the built in battery dies, it's time for a new flashlight anyways. 2) Really great video, from the calming music, the informative information, the graphs, the beamshots, the editing. I really don't have anything negative to say. 3) As for other feedback. I just wish some companies give a bit better quality control. I love my HD01 Pro and Arkfeld Pro, but both of their lasers shoot on an angle when holding it from the side. Better quality control means less warranty claims. Thanks again OP.😊
For what its worth, I've been carrying my standard Arkfeld for about a year and with standard mechanic/EDC use there is no noticeable battery degradation. In fact I'm frequently surprised how long I can carry and use it before it loses just one bar.
My problem with all of them is the lack of immediately replaceable battery (my AngelEyes solves this admirably BUT has no laser). The JetBeam lacks a moonlight mode. The OLight doesn’t use USB-C. The Nitecore isn’t waterproof. And the remaining contender had the worst power/runtime. If the next version of the JetBeam has a moonlight mode… I’ll consider it.
well what i meant to say is i like the button on the newer sofirn IF24 its really good i wish more lights would use that switch one of these ligths you reviewed uses the same switch so thats cool to see
1) EDC light doesn't need UV, laser would likely regularly come in handy. A flood/throw combo would probably be better. And please also offer something else than cool white 2) I liked that you described the interface, especially pointing out the 3 click turbo on Olight 3) Keep it up
This is a great comparison. The EDC29 is most appealing to me as I don’t mind the extra size and the performance is really compelling. Pricy though! I wonder if we will see these combo emitters in other lights.
Nitecore has used the combo emitters in several of their lights to great effect, it will be interesting to see if any other companies try this approach too
The only one I have is the olight and I absolutely love it. I got one of those in blue as well and that’s pretty cool too. I always like these videos. I’ve never had a complaint with the way this channel does things. I can’t think of anything I didn’t like except for that there aren’t enough videos coming out so I get excited whenever I see one from this channel and if you don’t put out enough of them, I’ll be very sad.😂 2:46 I almost forgot to mention that if you don’t like it’s strobing on a double press and you’d rather it go to turbo I think you press the button 10 times very fast or something like that and it will change it until you press it 10 times again if you like the other way, it’s set up better. That’s on the Olight just to clarify. So it can be changed and I just can’t remember the formula right now butif it’s not in the user manual, just contact Olight customer service or go on the Facebook group and you could probably find out in about two minutes how to do it.
1: I think these lights are pretty darn cool. I've been going down the rabbit hole of these kinds of EDC flashlights and am trying to narrow it down to what I want in one and which ones are offered. 2: I loved the fact that you put them all through the rounds, comparing them and actually testing them in the dark (lots of videos out there don't even do this). The production value here is stellar compared to other reviewers/youtubers. 3: I think you did a great job, covering all the bases for these types of lights. I'd love to see an eventual video about the Trustfire X3, and the newly announced Fenix E06R. Both seem very similar in specs. Great video!
1) Companies are getting closer to perfecting these flat style flashlights. What I would like to see, is one with a dedicated throwy main LED, bright flood on the side like the Wurkkos, UV with ZWB2 filter, and a crisp, clean, no artifacts straight shooting laser. Bonus if it could be powered by 2x 14500. 2) Honestly a great video, you covered all the fine details and professionally made. 3) Companies shouldnt invest so much on the packaging box, its a waste of money, let the great product inside the packaging do the wow factor. Thanks for doing this giveaway. Goodluck everyone.
I've been meaning to get my first "serious" light for a while now, not that I need one, I just want one. I've been eyeing the Wurkkos TS25, but then they announced the successor, TS26 and I'm still waiting for it (and also eyeing the X4 Stellar as an alternative). Both are not very EDC-able, considering I'm already EDC-ing a Victorinox Spirit X and these things do add up in weight and bulk. I have to say I see the appeal of these jack of all trade type of lights, which gives 2nd thoughts. The video itself is very well made, keeping it brief. It's a good starting point for those interested in this form-factor and type of light to dig deeper into the types of LEDs, color temp, CRI or whatever one prioritizes. I wonder how well those side light would perform in a light painting use case, that's another thing I'm kinda curious about getting into lately.
Personally haven't tried this form factor yet due to the non-removable battery but I've got to say this got me itching. The HD01 seems like the best value but I love the rotary switch of the arkfeld. A neutral white emitter wouldn't hurt either. The nitecore's screen is lovely but not my priority on something sleek for comfortable edc. Loved the video, no complaints. Maybe sharing which one is your favorite / you end up grabbing the most and why.
I ended up grabbing the Jetbeam and the Nitecore the most, I liked the throwier beams and the interfaces the best. I didn't use the Wurkkos much compared to the rest, just because it felt very similar to my previous arkfelds so it wasn't as 'new' to me
1) I don't have any lights in this form factor, but I am intrigued. The built in battery is a little concerning because it makes the light disposable. If I get 10 years out of it I'd be fine with it. I have seen a copper Arkfeld that is really snazzy, so it's really about the design with these. There's something to be said for that, for sure. 2) This is the first video of yours I've seen, and it's very well done. You covered pretty much everything I wanted to know about these. Thanks. 3) I'll be interested to check out your next video of the new styles that take removable batteries.
Fantastic video as always. I can't get over the production quality compared to other youtubers with many more subscribers. I'll be honest, I love the Arkfeld, but the price compared to the Wurkkos makes it hard to justify. I like the look of the Jetbeam, but I've never tried one so can't speak on my personal experiences with them. As for the Nitecore, build seems decent and I do like the little screen on it. It's expensive, but the price is consistent with Nitecore lights, so I'll accept that.
Things I like on this type of lights: metal construction, the mode preview can be extremely useful especially I always forget how things cycle modes, the presence of three different kind of light emission (white flashlight, uv, laser); would love to see an easy-er way to change batteries (not a fast swap like in bigger formats with cells but something that could be done at home with a screwdriver) I'd say the video is nearly perfect: good comparison on pretty much anything needed to know, direct, not too long, and still complete
I think Nitecore has been above and beyond any of it's competitors for a very long time now, and the output comparison shows for itself, but the one thing that I was concerned about and wanted to know more is how hot it got?
Because of the materials and construction, it doesn't get very hot in the hand unless you repeatedly activate turbo multiple times. However, with all that heat building up inside the light, it make me concerned about the longevity of the components
1. I actually like these lights, so much so that I’m waiting on a Nitecore EDC29 which is taking forever to ship to my location. Yes, I prefer tubes, they are prettier, can have way better run times, replaceable batteries, and nicer light quality, but the best light is always the one you have with you. These lights have finally opened the door to have something inconspicuous but highly performant in your pocket in the kind of situations where an 18650 would get you peppered with “is that a flashlight in your pocket?” jokes. 2. This video was great, glad to see you back in action. I liked that you highlighted their relative strengths, like the Wurkkos being the poorest performing but also the most accessible. 3. I sometimes think in the enthusiast community we forget that everyone else doesn’t care about beam quality, tint, or proprietary / built-in batteries. A lot of users out there just need something that performs well for their use case. If your use case is having a thing of beauty to look at, a shelf full of Hank lights is probably what you need, but if you just need a lot of light for a reasonably long time from something that can fit in your pocket, a light with bad tint and a built-in battery might be a winner for you. I think we would do well to remember that. 🙂
You make a great point, the best light is the one you have - and if this makes that easier, that's a good thing. As much as I like my Emisars they aren't actually that great for pocket carry being on the thicker side for 18650 lights.
You hit the nail on the head there and actually got me thinking as well. None of my lights are shelf queens, I use all of them as often as is practical, I sometimes even create excuses to use them, like walking instead of driving, or going looking for owls in the tall trees in our garden with no serious prospect of spotting one, just to get to use my throwers, but if I’m honest, my favourite lights and my most frequently used lights are not the same lights, and that’s totally okay. I expect the Nitecore to be with me whenever I need to use the train and might not be back before dark. There’s a dark patch on the path from our local station which doesn’t usually warrant a lot of light, but it would sure be nice to have access to a massive burst for a few seconds to see what’s around if I’m walking along and hear a noise next to the road that I’m not entirely sure I trust. It’s an absolute winner for that use case. Of course I could just take one of my gnarly tactical throwers for that kind of scenario, but that would mean having to take a backpack as well, which might be an encumbrance at my destination, or getting funny looks all day long for wearing a holster, because 21700 duty lights don’t go into pants pockets without a fight.
I’d like to see Wurkkos experiment more with this form factor, but please give us a neutral/warm white High CRI version! If the price is right I would probably buy 10 and give them out for gifts. That’s exactly what I did with the TS21 last year, and Nitecore Tip CRI several years back. I love your graphs. In this case, if you’re not paying close attention the model names on the graph are easy to mix up. Consistently including the brand would be handy, even though it’s more busy looking. I’m not too worried about battery degradation and replacability as long as the light is affordable. All my old Nitecore keychain lights still charge and run fine.
I like these lights, as you said i understand the form factor but I would really need to try and edc one to find out. They all do look really nice, you didn't mention charge speed but I could overlook some things if it charged blazing fast like 20w or more preferably. I personally really prefer replaceable batteries but I could be swayed some if the battery was user serviceable such as if you wanted to take it apart, the battery was not direct solder if a lipo, and if round cells were used, some kind of tensioned system would be awesome. That way it isn't a throw away light and you could replace it but isnt something you would be doing everyday. Lastly Anduril has kinda become a must with flashing pads internally available for the ones that want to upgrade....im still wishing one day the usb-c port will be data linked to the main processor so firmware can be updated and flashed that way. thanks for the video as always and If i won one it would be nice to see if edc'ing 1 of these could change my mind.
@@LuxWad thanks, i bet you the nitcore is pd charging compatible so most likely can charge at 9v 1amp or something like that, others are prolly all 5v 500mah to 1amp max lol
1) Your opinions on these lights (for the manufacturers to see!) I have long left the flashlight scene for decades and was astounded to see the new flat form factor lights with sealed lithium polymer batteries. The Nitecore EDC29 is the most impressive with its fancy OLED display, but assuming this light will last me for a full 8 years I wonder if Nitecore will still have the exact replacement for the OLED display, let alone the built-in sealed battery. Even if Nitecore still stocks on parts for the EDC29 model years down the road, I'm not sure if it would be cost effective to have it repaired long after the warranty expires. If I had to eventually discard the EDC29 it would be a expensive e-waste. I'm a Wurkkos fan therefore I would gravitate towards the HD01 series. The HD01 Pro has a simple UI and does the job of illuminating darkness without denting one's budget. It also makes an a thoughtful gift for family and friends. Those who are not into flashlights will be impressed by the futuristic look of any of these flat shaped lights. Non flashlight folk will appreciate the ease of recharging these flashlights via the USB-C port and not having to bother with external battery chargers. Except for the cigarette lighter shaped Wuben EDC pocket light which was briefly highlighted, I'm afraid I don't know much of the other competing brands in this video. 2) what you liked/didn't like about this video I applaud your choice of testing the lights by the hillside, overlooking the vast bright lights of the beautiful city in the distance. The runtime charts helped me to understand all of these flashlight's step down times and sustained outputs. The videography is awesome, I liked the shallow DoF macro shots of one or two of these lights and the top-down view of them in your pants pocket. This review could also use rudimentary comparison beam tests of the ultraviolet LED using fluorescent material in the dark. 3) any other thoughts/feedback you might have :) I wished you had conducted the outdoor beam tests by illuminating the same target area instead of different places, so that viewers can visually compare the beam profiles and flood patterns. Other than that I have little else to critique about your production quality. Keep up the good work! 😊☺️
Awesome little giveaway - thank you to Wurkkos for their continued support of the hobby community. Their HD01 is easily inexpensive enough to try out this category of flashlight design without the worry of the price tags the others carry. Sure, it's lacking in some ways and the side-light is not the first choice for me when I want flood, but it's a decent jack-of-all trades... If I were more interested in stuff like the Nitecore multi-emitter setup or proprietary alloys from Olight, I still think they're priced relatively well for their given performance. Nice review as always - thank you for offering the side-by-side comparisons... I haven't seen much for these things so it's a bit hard to compare well.
The nitecore is very impressive, the wurkkos seems like great value. What's been holding me off from these lights so far is non-replaceable batteries. Overall, great video though!
Glad to see this pop up in my feed this morning. I never see the trustfire mini x3 in these flat light videos. I compared a few flat lights before and I really liked it. The thing I didn't like about the wurkkos is the double sided clip which always gets caught on stuff and then you gotta bend it back. And why don't these companies realize we want warm, high cri emitters. The battery thing never really bothered me, but I can see the drawback. I also found that the uv lights are not very bright for using outdoors to hunt scorpions.
The trustfire design is interesting, I haven't seen it before but there is this review from 1lumen: 1lumen.com/review/trustfire-mini-x3/ Seems to be a decent versatile option, though the performance is not quite as good as these lights
![DANGEROUSLY FUN - Emisar D4V2 [In-Depth Review]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Dk3Q1YYqU2c/mqdefault.jpg)
THE GIVEAWAY HAS CLOSED. Winners will be announced on Wednesday (Feb 5)
RULES:
Leave a comment below (NOT A REPLY TO THIS COMMENT) stating:
1) Your opinions on these lights (for the manufacturers to see!)
2) what you liked/didn't like about this video
3) any other thoughts/feedback you might have :)
There are 5 lights available, 4 Wurkkos HD01 (laser pointer models) in Black, Green, Green, and Silver, and 1 Wurkkos HD01 UV in Purple. All are cool white.
The five (5) winners will be picked at random. I will reply to the winners' comments stating that they have won. If you have won, please send me an email (available on my channel's "About" tab) stating that you have won the giveaway. If you don't respond within 3 days I will select another.
I will reply to your email with a code, which you ADD TO YOUR ORIGINAL COMMENT WITH AN EDIT to verify your identity. We will then proceed from there.
First winner gets first pick of whichever light they want, second winner gets second pick, and so on. I will ship internationally.
1) amongst them really like the nitecore buts I can’t justify the price, cause I don’t need that much. Maybe less output and closer to $60-70?
2) video is pretty cool, I like your editing
3) Isn’t there other lights with this format under $100? Honestly I just don’t buy lights > $80
Great video. I have 3 different arkfelds but not the one you show cased. I also have the wuben x2 and edc29. I keep finding myself taking the edc 29 when I walk my dogs at night. I enjoy having access to 6500 lumens and a super bright strobe for self defense purposes. The pocket clip needs work as well as the waterproof rating. I wonder what a coyote would do if I turned 6500 lines on it. Keep up the good we work brother. I thoroughly enjoy your videos.
instead of "non replacable" i wish reviewers like you went with the ifixit route of scoring battery replacement difficulty on a scale of 1 to 10. every battery is replacable, the question is how difficult to source the cell and do the work, and how risky is it in terms of potentially damaging delicate connectors or cables
this is a great suggestion
@@LuxWad I agree, and with right-to-repair gaining momentum, more battery makers will bring the price down by offering replacement cells. These might be 4 14500s packaged up.
@@LuxWad i also agree, awesome idea, like i said in my comment, these kind of lights should still have user serviceable batteries and no direct solder no matter what type or form factor used for the cell.
The thing people are missing about "non-replaceable" battery is that these Lithium batteries don't die after 5-10 years of USE, they die after 5-10 years of time. Sitting on a shelf, deactivated, can and will kill these batteries. A flashlight that you have used 20 times in 10 years can simply become perma-dead because of these non-replaceable batteries.
A normal person who buys a flashlight does not need to, or expect to, or should expect to, buy a new flashlight for "new features" every 5-10 years. I have a 20 year old flashlight that works exactly the same as a new flashlight. Flashlights don't get "better" enough to justify having to "upgrade" them every 5 years for average people. The average consumer needs a device that can produce enough light to be able to see, as long as it does that, it absolutely does not need to be replaced, and the companies designing these devices in a way that causes them to not function after 5-10 years specifically to force consumers to buy new ones are acting maliciously. Additionally, if a consumer does need to buy a new flashlight for new features, then they can do so, WITHOUT having their old flashlight break, and they now have TWO working flashlights and can use the old one as a backup just in case.
Non-Replaceable batteries are a form of planned-obsolescence to cause these devices that would work for much longer to otherwise stop working and become waste. The trend of non-replaceable batteries has caused e-waste devices to pile up a tremendous amount in junkyards simply because users cannot service or repair their devices and the devices are being designed to be disposable. Most people do not properly recycle electronics, because electronic disposal costs money, and many people do not even know that you are supposed to discard electronics in a specific way.
For the record, not a single one of these flashlights sells replacement batteries. Though the Nitecore seems to be the worst since it cannot even be opened as it is assembled in a way that makes re-assembly effectively impossible.
Excellent point. Lithium-ion is not made with long shelf life in mind, and this format is a trap.
Maybe once sodium-ion technology develops further and batteries last 15+ years whether on a shelf or in use, these will look attractive to my pocket. As it is, no thank you very much.
+1
I think these lights would be more viable if you could change the battery even if you need to tinket a little, solder and maybe break the light.
I think it can be justified to get some of these lights but most likely not to get one of the expensive ones.
Anyhow, I really hope this doesn't become the trend and tubes keep being the norm.
A square flashlight is fine but please with a battery compartment.
That is true, but lithium-ion batteries are usually able to last 10 years or more without issue. If you keep the light charged instead of leaving it dead, the natural degradation of li-ion shouldn't really be noticeable
@@LuxWad also with the output and size....It wouldnt suprise me if there was a lipo battery in these even though it says li ion, ive scene that many times before in small high output devices
@@LuxWad You want to keep it at less than max charge though, right?
I have many lights and thought I would give the EDC29 A shot, it blew me away. The performance is far beyond what I expected. It fits well in my pocket. I don't even know it's there. The fact that it's so thin you do not realize its existence in your pocket makes it a joy to carry. This new form factor has got me hooked. Your information on each light seems to be spot on, as I've seen a few
Thank you for the time and effort.
you are a blessing to the flashlight community
Is there a 'flashlight community'?
What I don't like is the lack of better emitters. Nichia 519A for the main emitter seems like a no-brainer.
Your video is nice as always, what I would have liked to see/hear about is how good/clicky the buttons are on each light. Haptics are important to me.
519a would be great in these lights for sure.
The Nitecore has really excellent clicky buttons, they are easy to operate blind. The Wurkkos buttons are a bit mushy but serviceable. The Arkfeld Ultra doesn't offer much feedback at all on the button, the ring is nice and smooth with clear detents. The Jetbeam's ring and button are much grittier and have more play.
Got a Nitecore. Not waterproof. Returned.
yeah im not a fan of nitecore
idk why people keep buying nitecores. Olight prices at less than olight quality/features. The bad QC reports are also numerous.
@@NorthBorneoLights I have a number of olight and nitecore torches, for actual use I prefer my nitecores. they just preform way better
@@NorthBorneoLights facts i hate O-light and there fan boys lol sofrin and wurkkos make great lights for way way cheaper
I bought a Nitecore a few years ago, and had a problem with it. They wanted me to return it to China at my expense. Total crap for customer service. That's when I decided that there are too many light companies to deal with that kind of nonsense. Hank, Olight, Fenix, Acebeam, Sofirn, Wurkkos, Thrunite, Lumintop, and several companies have benefitted after my experience with Nitecore's poor customer service.
Your videography and editing skills are absolutely incredible man I imagine a hell of a lot of work goes into these videos I appreciate it!
I get the target audience, but for me I’d either want bigger with replaceable batteries or smaller (particularly length).
As for the video, I love the non-talking head with the beautiful B-roll. Also the mix of quantitative/qualitative data delivered in your calm voice. Quite relaxing! 😂
I have or had all of these. After having the Wurkkos in my pocket for 5 minutes, I packed it back up and sent it back because the corners were so sharp, they dug into my leg and after I noticed it, that's all I can think about.
They are pretty sharp, I didn't really mind but I can see why that would be a dealbreaker
I'm not an EDC guy at all, but these flashlights look so cool I kinda want one now. The magnet at the end of the Wurkkos HD01 would be very useful for working on my car. Would be nice if there was one with a stand that lets you set it on the ground at an angle when working on stuff. Very cool to see you go test the lights out in the field.
That's where the side light becomes more useful too. It gets REALLY bright. you could clip to your hat...
Great video comparison . Detailed explanation. Im really curious on these kind of edc lights and wanting one of these . For practical use you can’t go wrong with wurkkos.
Really like the form factor and size of these light. Perfect for pocket carry. The video really showed how great that sft40 is for throw. Keep up thevideos your killin it.
I agree, better emitters would be very welcome. Would like to see replaceable batteries as well. Love the vids!
I really like these lights if you go into them to realistic expectations. I carry the edc29 after having the previous models. Got this one due to the physical lockout switch. Does great for edc and I have the option of high momentary turbo in an emergency. I don’t need all the other features and just want a pocketable tough light. UI is simple enough and it’s been reliable for me *knock on wood*
Great overview of all these lights. They’re becoming more popular and it’s nice to hear the opinion from someone who’s better versed than most on them. Thanks for the content.
I like the form factor and have thought about picking up the Nitecore to try the new bar shape. I'm kind of bummed about the battery not being able to be replaced, I like the mag charger for people that might be just getting into the flashlight hobby but for me as a person with many chargers It's not for me. I'm also surprised olight changed their famous double click turbo to a triple click. I like that you showcased all of the lights in great detail and included a lot of beam shots of the various lights and modes. I'm excited to see your upcoming review on the similar shaped lights with replaceable batteries. I have 4 Hank Wang lights and for the price I don't think they can be beat. Especially since you get to customize what you get!
1) The Wurkkos HD01 is the best ones in my opinion. Not only it's the smallest, but it being the cheapest makes the non replaceable battery less of an issue. The side light could also be pretty useful for signaling, especially together with the magnetic base (e.g. using the bike in a foggy day)
2) There's nothing much I can say about the video except for the fact it's great. Informative, well produced and more importantly not needlessly long.
3) While I do like the flat designs, non replaceable batteries aren't for me. Producing e waste is bad enough and while I do see the uses here I don't like this trend getting to flashlights too. I just wish there was a replaceable battery small enough to make similar lights (maybe the 14500?)
Anyway, again, great video. Can't wait for your review on the other two lights.
1. Nitecore EDC29 is a beast! It’s a good size. The UI is great. Perfect for self-defense (super bright) and tactical use. Olight Arkfeld Ultra has the perfect UI for flat style EDC (you can swap Turbo and Strobe). I prefer the Ultra for general use. There aren’t too many features (white, UV, laser). The magnet strength could be better or just use USB-C. JETBeam E26 has a nice design. The lack of moonlight is a dealbreaker. Wurkkos HD01 has too many features and the UI is complex.
2. I like the side-by-side comparisons. Impressive footage! It’s a bit like Project Farm in terms of formula. However, I find it easier to digest info when focusing on one flashlight and going through the features in the same order. That said, the comparison is probably better for people with too many options.
3. I wish manufacturers put more info about the UI in the printed manual. Olight and Armytek have some hidden features documented online but not in the printed manual.
Nice work!
Your can reprogram the Olight to be double for turbo.
Once you're in lockout, press the button quickly 10 or more times and hold your last press until the light blinks to switch turbo/strobe
Great one, I always love it when a new video of yours pops up, although i think in this case you should have waited a bit maybe, because the best is yet to come. Imalent GR35 has everything you need: SFT-25R, UV, laser, side light, magnet, dedicated lock switch, usb, charging case... On paper it's amazing. So far I like the Arkfeld Ultra the best, but GR35 has a slightly bigger battery and lower weight, too.
I saw the Imalent announcement, it looks neat. I couldn't wait any longer though, I had these sent to me back in September so I already took way too long lol. There's always a newer, better light coming soon
I'm the happy owner of EDC29 for several days. I also have flashlights from Hank (D4K and D3AA) so I am between tube and flat flashlights too! The power of the EDC29 blew me away - it's insane and I think I'm willing to sacrifice replaceable batteries for this amount of power. After all, the built-in battery will last for hundreds of charges - thousands of hours. I will probably buy a new flashlight by then :D
Olight Arkfeld Ultra also appeals to me, but it is very expensive, and after the last purchase of EDC29, I no longer have the funds...
I would love to have a flashlight with a laser, because I have never had such a gadget and I'll be happy to test it !
Your beamshots are very nice to watch - you have great conditions and darkness for recording, as well as a great view on the city! Professional film editing aswell, which makes it looks really good. Wish you all the best!
Yes when this battery is finished in 10 years or just even 5, there will be totally new flashlights out there that you might buy anyway.
@@Gieszkanne Consumerist ahh mindset.
"Great video! Here are my thoughts:
For the manufacturers: These compact built-in battery flashlights seem super convenient for everyday use. I love the portability and the fact that they’re rechargeable-no more buying batteries! However, it would be great to see more details on battery life and durability over time. A brighter lumen option or adjustable brightness settings would also be a nice upgrade for future models.
About the video: I really liked how clear and concise the demonstration was. The side-by-side comparison with other flashlights was super helpful! If I had to suggest something, maybe adding a real-life use case (like camping or power outages) would make it even more relatable.
Other feedback: Overall, this was a solid review! It’s clear you put effort into testing and explaining the features. Keep up the great work, and I’m looking forward to more reviews like this!"
I think these lights are great with all their features and the form factor i think it's a fair trade for not having an easily replacable battery. I especially like the Wurkkos given the price point and color options
This is a product category I didn't know exited but now I really want one haha
Great video going over each of them very in-depth.
Wouldve been nice if you included a table showing a summarized features-price based on your recommendations so we can refer back to them when we are looking at purchasing any of them!
Hope I wind one :D!
Interesting....I like the shape but no High CRI option is a deal breaker for me.
I'd personally like to see someone make a single 18650 version of these lights. Maybe some sort of hybrid flood and throw setup. Enjoyed the video, looking forward to the Wuben review as well!
I really like when flashlight manufacturers, especially nitecore here, don’t over inflate their lumen output. Of course I expect a little rounding up, but keeping it reasonable is a breath of fresh air. This video also does a great job of presenting opinions as guidance while still showing the objective details which led there because everybody has different priorities and preferences.
I was just looking at the EDC29 but for that pricepoint the lack of water resistance makes me feel like the Wurkos is probably a better EDC for the price
I like these lights, Im just impartial to Hanks enthusiast lights so thats what I run on a normal basis.
I like this video because LuxWad posted it and he always drops bangers (best flashlight channel on youtube)
I love my Olight Arkfeld Ultra. Seriously considering getting the Wurkkos Pro too.
I liked how thorough your video is!
I didn’t like the shaky video in the very beginning but I’m being nitpicky.
I very much liked and agree with your opinions on the buttons of the lights.
You can change the setting on the arkfeld so it’s switches the turbo mode to double click and to make the strobe turn on by triple click. Love that flash light!
1. I think the lights have great value especially for someone thats not a huge flashlight nerd like some of us 😂. Most people dont care about CRI and beam patterns or want to figure out external battery choices and storage and they just need a pocketable light that is easy to use and works. 2. As usual your video quality is top notch. And I appreciate you using the lights for long periods of time in order to give honest use reviews and not generalities or forst impressions.
3. I think these lights would be especially perfect for flashlight nerds to give valuable gifts to people that arent as invested in the hobby. Simple use, rugged enough, but still they would get a taste of how fun flashlights can be, and share in the joys of "conquering the dark" as you say.
1) All looked good, current Olight fan. Will look at the others going forwards. Light profile is quite key so next investment would potentially be a Wurkkos.
2) First time watchers nice presentation and flow, no negatives.
3) Looking fwd to watch more from you.
Of all these lights, I'd say the Wurkokos is the most interesting to me simply because of the price. As you mentioned, it's a good way to try the flat form factor and as the proprietary battery degrades, I will be out less money. Sure, the new next big thing will probably come out by the time the battery degrades, but I'd rather it be swappable so I can keep it as a backup or give it away to someone.
I'm always happy to see a video from this channel. They're always very thorough while also entertaining to watch. A flat flashlight was on my radar, so I'll probably have to pick one up soon and this video will be a great source for when I pull the trigger. Keep doing what you're doing assuming you're still enjoying making videos! This channel was the reason I got my first Hanklight and why I am the flashlight guy among my friends! :)
Definitely interested in this design of light, for an edc light I dont mind the battery being built in since many of our other daily items are the same. I always have a secondary light for work and also when im on the go that have removeable batteries plus usual have a power bank as well. The video was good, clear, and informative on all the lights.
Wow this is an absolutely great video. Thorough, easy to watch, and entertaining. Your knowledge on lights clearly supersedes most people, including myself but I have a couple suggestions for your videos.
The graphs were the best part for me, but they were confusing to read and I didn't know what to look for. Maybe a comparison of the area under the curve for each light to show which one has the best total runtime? Also your second graph on the Nitecores was hard to read and understand since they're all the same colour and the only distinction is the dashes. This would normally be fine on smaller graphs, but the dashes are so small and so close that it becomes hard to tell.
Other than that, the execution, the animation, the topics covered were all amazing. I do have a couple other categories I was hoping you'd cover about these lights.
- I wish you talked more about people who own the traditional tubes and now we're looking for what's closest to what we love in our tube, but in a thinner, sleeker package. I come from an Olight Baton so obviously I looked at the Arkfield first and I would have loved to know how similar it is as an experience to what I already have. My experience has been, I charge it ever couple months, use it frequently and daily on medium to low settings, occasionally high, and often abuse it. I am looking for that same build quality, battery durability in the Arkfield. The real question I'm asking myself is can these other lights replicate that at a cheaper price, or should I just stick with boring reliable Olights.
- The other category/topic I wanted to see is what kind of wear they go through, given of course that these are EDC lights. These lights will be in and out of pockets thousands of times, dropped, scratched and sliding across the floor, used as hammers, you name it. You did mention the build quality is the best, the feel was the best in the Arkfield, and that it was worth it's price tag there, but I want to see by how much. Is it worth the $20 I'm paying over the E26? Or is the E26 just going to loose a little big more paint sooner but still function just as well.. You covered this topic decently, but compared to how in depth and well done the rest of the review was, I think this category was overshined by your other great work.
Your reviews are so detailed that I think even without these couple small tweaks and a couple other categories covered, you have hands down the best reviews I've seen so far. You are succinct, well spoken, and have a decent perspective on what most people might be looking for in a light.
I'm not really one for giveaways, I am mostly commenting because you make such great content and I want it to be even better.
Thanks for your feedback, especially on the graphs, it's very helpful!
I really like the Wurkkos HD01! I've been looking for a new EDC light for work on my machines and it would fit perfect in my overalls. I would eventually like to try all of these though. Very cool video can't wait to try the Olight as well.
1) these are worth it for the lasers. EDC flashlights should be fun and having a dog/cat toy with you is a lot of fun 2) Runtime plots were handy and pretty. Lofi intro is very fitting 3) Glad to see Wurkkos still putting out quality for cheap!
Don’t use lasers as a dog toy. It discourages them unlike cats
I myself like to see extra little side features eg. the rbg LEDs, the UV or the led light - people will have use cases for these and them being inexpensive means that more people can have them or even multiples. I'm glad you gathered all the B roll footage with the light performance on the mountains and using the UV, makes it feel like a complete buying guide here on youtube
Those flashlights are really cool looking. I would definitely buy one if i had some money.
The video was quite good, but not that much for me because of complicated stats of flashlights.
I would definitely recommend that channel to my friends
Not having to mess with swapping batteries at the worst times is a huge plus-just charge it up at night, and you're good to go. Way more convenient than dealing with dead batteries when you actually need the light.
The video was solid! I liked seeing them in action, but it would've been cool to get a bit more on how they hold up over time, like durability after some real use.
Either way, appreciate the giveaway and the chance to win!
I had the wurkkos for a bit before i gave it to my dad i thought it was alright, honestly i didnt find much use from the extra functions and I am doing perfectly fine with my d3aa which i have in my wallet. Great video love the graphs as always! Honestly was surprised by the lumens the nitecore got out. Thanks for the giveaway!
i really want the hd001 but the main gripe with any of these flashlights is no standard removeable battery....
1) I like the nitecore for its sheer power. Although in my opinion, a UV flashlight has the plus that you can cure different plastics.
2) I like that the video is informative and that you showed battery ones at the end. Also, I think your opinion in the end why you will keep on the tube lights make sense and gives value to the video.
3) These lights are pretty cool, dint know they existed, thanks.
You can switch the setting of the turbo and strobe mode on the Arkfeld by pressing the power button a number of times (ten times, I believe). It should say so in the manual. Not a deal breaker for me
I like this style of lights because of their size; I find them more pleasant to carry in my pocket. The interfaces are quite interesting. The issue for me is with the non-replaceable batteries.
Well, I only like one or two years into flashlight.
These new flat form factor are in my opinion kinda love or hate it for some people.
Wurkkos already famous by great price to performance, and this light is no exception. I think perfect value for someone who want to try flat light.
The other light (olight, nitecore, jetbeam) I'm sure also have great quality, But me personally havent tried any of those brand.
It always great to see your video comparing light with different price bracket (and also mention the price), so viewer can make decision more easily.
nitecore EDC29 selector and the arkfeld selector switch do impress me
Just got the Wurkkos HD01 Pro, great light. Have you seen the TrustFire Mini X3 and the new Fenix E06R? Also, what do you think about the Wuben X2 Pro?
I have very mixed thoughts on the X2 Pro - genius ideas, questionable execution. I want Wuben to make more, it's awesome, but also I wouldn't recommend it in its current form.
I haven't seen that Fenix before, it looks really neat. Not really a size I care for though
@LuxWad thanks for the info, much appreciated!
You can change the Arkfeld Ultra to double-click for turbo. Put the light into lockout (hold the button for 4 seconds), then click the button at least 10 times quickly.
I like that these lights are slim, I feel like the form factor will make it easier to grab and go carry. I really like then cinematography of your videos, makes it very esthetically pleasing and entertaining along with being informative. Im looking forward to the wuben x2pro review, based off what I read online its not that solid of a light.
I've been considering getting a Nitecore EDC29 for the past two months now, but I've scared to pull the trigger because of no replacable battery and potentially better options around the corner. I like that this video compared many different options and different price points and no yelling, this was a calm video. I also like the beam tests for each one of the lights and charts to compare different lights and when the turbo modes fall off. I'm just getting into the flashlight world and I'm not sure which direction to go in.
I get the multitool idea, as well as the form factor. I don't see why a rectangular replaceable battery is a bridge too far, though. Excellent video style but yeah: like you, I'll wait out this first wave.
All the lights look really practical and cool, but the Nitecore looks to me like the 'tacticooler,' lol. Like you said, moonlight is vital, and I would have liked it if you mentioned the lumen output of the moonlights. Thanks for making me addicted to Hanklight with your past videos!
Really great video as always!
The Wurkkos flashlight is a very neat light! It has so many features - high output front emitter, green laser, white flood side lights, and finally, nice RGB bonus array! It’s a lot. Fortunately, the user interface is reasonably straightforward. USB-C charging is great, but I do not love the fact that the battery can never be replaced. Still, for this price, it’s a great way to get so many features!
I liked the idea of flat light. I have the original Arkfeld and just ordered the more compact nitecore edc 23. Wished it was water proof. Like the video not too short and not too long.
Was those beam shot at Mission Peak?
The beamshots were taken in a Utah location
Hello.
1. The Wurkkos HD01 is coincidently my favorite one.
2. I like your relaxed narration and objective conclusion at the end of the video. These edc category flashlights with build in batteries are definitelly a handy products, made smaller. Downsize is of course the fact that the battery is built in. No question about that.
3. When it comes to Olight - Imho they should build in also USB-C charging port.
i have my eye on the wurkkos light, looks really nice. also have other models from them and olight and all are great quality. the video was very informative and I might be getting the wurkkos now because of this vid. right now i am enjoying the trustfire mini x3. thanks!
I think this silly l style of light is a good option to have. Carry-ability is an important consideration and these generally being slimmer helps (of course there are tradeoffs).
Great video, it has it all - graphs, outdoor shots, etc. Thanks.
Thanks! Great form factor, but a non-replaceable battery is a dealbreaker for me. Typical LuxWad video, which is excellent, informative and gets a like!
Really liking the EDC29. The output looks amazing in your videos. I'm torn between that or the HD01 Pro. What I really like about your videos is that you provided multiple beam shots in different landscape. It makes testing/reviewing the lights more practice for multiple environments. Hope to win the giveaway!
The Nitecore appears to have the most features, but it also seems a bit overly complicated and "tacticool." Olight is an instant no for me due to its proprietary charger. Jetbeam and Wurkkos seem like the best options, though I'm not sure if I'd ever have a real use for UV. For me, the top priority is runtime/battery life since the battery isn't replaceable-this kind of device will likely sit in a backpack for long periods, so I want to be sure it's always ready to use.
I had no idea these flat-style flashlights even existed, so your video was my first introduction to them. You did a fantastic job explaining the differences and highlighting their features. I really like the slim design, and the USB-C charging is a huge plus since I could just plug it into my laptop while working instead of carrying a separate 18500 charger.
Keep up the great work!
I echo your comment about the Olight charger. It's well engineered and works flawlessly but it's also completely unnecessary. I think they're just showing off with it. Sooner or later they will have to come to their senses and design a USB charging system.
Love Wurkkos for the giveaway!
1) that Nitecore is a beast! How can they possibly be getting that much light of that size!? The Jetbeam has the coolest look to my eyes. I like OLIGHT for the craftsmanship but I’m not a fan of proprietary charging/batteries. For me the Wurkkos is the winner because of the price for what you get.
2) Your videos are great as always! Been dying to see the best one drop. Production is second to none.
3) I wonder if you would be willing to do some recommendations based on your personal collection and current carry. An everyday carry video.
You can can have dubble press for turbo on the olight.
1) I'm liking the mode selector on the Olight and JetBeam along with the tailswitch. The exposed usb port might not be the best choice, since as you said it'll definitely get gunked, but I imagine it will be similar to phone ports, so not a big deal but still, I would like to see a flap nonetheless. Wurkkos keeps it simple and cheap, great choice for those who just want to test the form factor/features (UV, laser).
2) The watching experience is great, enough information in a short format video that doesn't feel rushed at all, with some very nice close-ups of the lights.
3) I agree with the moonlight problem, I find it essential in a flashlight, especially in the EDC category. I outright did not buy a few edc lights because of a lacking moonlight mode (ie too bright/non existent).
1. I really like this flat style EDC form, it fits better in the pocket, less chance of it rolling over when placed somewhere.
2. My favorite part of the video is that you showed outdoors uses and urban uses , most creators usually just show one side.
3. I wish there was still a way to make them magnetic or at least a swivel head
4. I'll take the green or black laser one but I'll settle for UV 😜
I'm so excited that I'm going to use your link for the Wurkkos HD01 in laser black and not even wait to see if I could win a giveaway.
1) I like the idea of these flat bodied lights, I just haven't gotten behind the outputs yet. I generally gravitate more towards throwers in a neutral tint, and these all are more floody in cool white
2) The video was a good comparison of all the "normal" flat body options out there, I don't really think there is much you missed
3) Keep up the good work! Looking forward to the SK05 Pro review
Olight Arkfeld Ultra shortcuts for Turbo and Strobe can be swapped.
Coming into this, I only knew about the Nightcore, but it's amazing how much lumen output these compact flashlights can deliver. The jetbeam really stood out to me-I love its design and performance. This was an excellent comparison, and I'll definitely be tuning in again!
Love the Arkfeld, I've got 2 of them (one with a swapped FFL351A 3700k Rosy tint emitter). I was also tempted to buy the Wurkkos version given the price. Thanks for the video, I appreciate your thoroughness and plentiful beam shots!
Thanks for doing the giveaway!
1) I think these flat style flashlight are definitely handy and innovative. While I too prefer replacing batteries, I think by the time the built in battery dies, it's time for a new flashlight anyways.
2) Really great video, from the calming music, the informative information, the graphs, the beamshots, the editing. I really don't have anything negative to say.
3) As for other feedback. I just wish some companies give a bit better quality control. I love my HD01 Pro and Arkfeld Pro, but both of their lasers shoot on an angle when holding it from the side. Better quality control means less warranty claims.
Thanks again OP.😊
I feel like none of the lights were really surefire winners since all of them were non replaceable and I like the tactile response and modes available
For what its worth, I've been carrying my standard Arkfeld for about a year and with standard mechanic/EDC use there is no noticeable battery degradation. In fact I'm frequently surprised how long I can carry and use it before it loses just one bar.
My problem with all of them is the lack of immediately replaceable battery (my AngelEyes solves this admirably BUT has no laser). The JetBeam lacks a moonlight mode. The OLight doesn’t use USB-C. The Nitecore isn’t waterproof. And the remaining contender had the worst power/runtime. If the next version of the JetBeam has a moonlight mode… I’ll consider it.
any flashlight that takes 18650 is my go to. even my battery backup charger holds 3 18650 batteries so i can interchange anytime.
I think all of these lights are a good option! I like my Olight a lot I use it everyday. Especially when I travel. Great video very detailed!
well what i meant to say is i like the button on the newer sofirn IF24 its really good i wish more lights would use that switch one of these ligths you reviewed uses the same switch so thats cool to see
1) EDC light doesn't need UV, laser would likely regularly come in handy. A flood/throw combo would probably be better. And please also offer something else than cool white
2) I liked that you described the interface, especially pointing out the 3 click turbo on Olight
3) Keep it up
This is a great comparison. The EDC29 is most appealing to me as I don’t mind the extra size and the performance is really compelling. Pricy though! I wonder if we will see these combo emitters in other lights.
Nitecore has used the combo emitters in several of their lights to great effect, it will be interesting to see if any other companies try this approach too
@@LuxWad Oh good to know! Obviously I'm not super familiar with Nitecore's lineup :P
I really like my arkfeld, but only after swapping out the emitter. The build quality is really nice, especially if you can get it on sale.
The only one I have is the olight and I absolutely love it. I got one of those in blue as well and that’s pretty cool too. I always like these videos. I’ve never had a complaint with the way this channel does things. I can’t think of anything I didn’t like except for that there aren’t enough videos coming out so I get excited whenever I see one from this channel and if you don’t put out enough of them, I’ll be very sad.😂 2:46 I almost forgot to mention that if you don’t like it’s strobing on a double press and you’d rather it go to turbo I think you press the button 10 times very fast or something like that and it will change it until you press it 10 times again if you like the other way, it’s set up better. That’s on the Olight just to clarify. So it can be changed and I just can’t remember the formula right now butif it’s not in the user manual, just contact Olight customer service or go on the Facebook group and you could probably find out in about two minutes how to do it.
1: I think these lights are pretty darn cool. I've been going down the rabbit hole of these kinds of EDC flashlights and am trying to narrow it down to what I want in one and which ones are offered.
2: I loved the fact that you put them all through the rounds, comparing them and actually testing them in the dark (lots of videos out there don't even do this). The production value here is stellar compared to other reviewers/youtubers.
3: I think you did a great job, covering all the bases for these types of lights. I'd love to see an eventual video about the Trustfire X3, and the newly announced Fenix E06R. Both seem very similar in specs.
Great video!
1) Companies are getting closer to perfecting these flat style flashlights. What I would like to see, is one with a dedicated throwy main LED, bright flood on the side like the Wurkkos, UV with ZWB2 filter, and a crisp, clean, no artifacts straight shooting laser. Bonus if it could be powered by 2x 14500.
2) Honestly a great video, you covered all the fine details and professionally made.
3) Companies shouldnt invest so much on the packaging box, its a waste of money, let the great product inside the packaging do the wow factor.
Thanks for doing this giveaway. Goodluck everyone.
One other best of all is Rovyvon E90, side red, UV and warm white with even bigger battery than any of those.
I wish I could have gotten one for the video, they have a cool MAO version too
I've been meaning to get my first "serious" light for a while now, not that I need one, I just want one. I've been eyeing the Wurkkos TS25, but then they announced the successor, TS26 and I'm still waiting for it (and also eyeing the X4 Stellar as an alternative). Both are not very EDC-able, considering I'm already EDC-ing a Victorinox Spirit X and these things do add up in weight and bulk.
I have to say I see the appeal of these jack of all trade type of lights, which gives 2nd thoughts.
The video itself is very well made, keeping it brief. It's a good starting point for those interested in this form-factor and type of light to dig deeper into the types of LEDs, color temp, CRI or whatever one prioritizes.
I wonder how well those side light would perform in a light painting use case, that's another thing I'm kinda curious about getting into lately.
The side lights would probably be very nice for light painting, I didn't think about that
Personally haven't tried this form factor yet due to the non-removable battery but I've got to say this got me itching. The HD01 seems like the best value but I love the rotary switch of the arkfeld. A neutral white emitter wouldn't hurt either. The nitecore's screen is lovely but not my priority on something sleek for comfortable edc.
Loved the video, no complaints. Maybe sharing which one is your favorite / you end up grabbing the most and why.
I ended up grabbing the Jetbeam and the Nitecore the most, I liked the throwier beams and the interfaces the best. I didn't use the Wurkkos much compared to the rest, just because it felt very similar to my previous arkfelds so it wasn't as 'new' to me
Edc 23 goes crazy imo
1) I don't have any lights in this form factor, but I am intrigued. The built in battery is a little concerning because it makes the light disposable. If I get 10 years out of it I'd be fine with it. I have seen a copper Arkfeld that is really snazzy, so it's really about the design with these. There's something to be said for that, for sure.
2) This is the first video of yours I've seen, and it's very well done. You covered pretty much everything I wanted to know about these. Thanks.
3) I'll be interested to check out your next video of the new styles that take removable batteries.
Fantastic video as always. I can't get over the production quality compared to other youtubers with many more subscribers.
I'll be honest, I love the Arkfeld, but the price compared to the Wurkkos makes it hard to justify. I like the look of the Jetbeam, but I've never tried one so can't speak on my personal experiences with them. As for the Nitecore, build seems decent and I do like the little screen on it. It's expensive, but the price is consistent with Nitecore lights, so I'll accept that.
Rotary interface, more than one button and display are nice. Non-replaceable battery is not.
Things I like on this type of lights: metal construction, the mode preview can be extremely useful especially I always forget how things cycle modes, the presence of three different kind of light emission (white flashlight, uv, laser); would love to see an easy-er way to change batteries (not a fast swap like in bigger formats with cells but something that could be done at home with a screwdriver)
I'd say the video is nearly perfect: good comparison on pretty much anything needed to know, direct, not too long, and still complete
Also you made me want one now even though I didn't think I needed ahaha
I think Nitecore has been above and beyond any of it's competitors for a very long time now, and the output comparison shows for itself, but the one thing that I was concerned about and wanted to know more is how hot it got?
Because of the materials and construction, it doesn't get very hot in the hand unless you repeatedly activate turbo multiple times. However, with all that heat building up inside the light, it make me concerned about the longevity of the components
1. I actually like these lights, so much so that I’m waiting on a Nitecore EDC29 which is taking forever to ship to my location. Yes, I prefer tubes, they are prettier, can have way better run times, replaceable batteries, and nicer light quality, but the best light is always the one you have with you. These lights have finally opened the door to have something inconspicuous but highly performant in your pocket in the kind of situations where an 18650 would get you peppered with “is that a flashlight in your pocket?” jokes.
2. This video was great, glad to see you back in action. I liked that you highlighted their relative strengths, like the Wurkkos being the poorest performing but also the most accessible.
3. I sometimes think in the enthusiast community we forget that everyone else doesn’t care about beam quality, tint, or proprietary / built-in batteries. A lot of users out there just need something that performs well for their use case. If your use case is having a thing of beauty to look at, a shelf full of Hank lights is probably what you need, but if you just need a lot of light for a reasonably long time from something that can fit in your pocket, a light with bad tint and a built-in battery might be a winner for you. I think we would do well to remember that. 🙂
You make a great point, the best light is the one you have - and if this makes that easier, that's a good thing. As much as I like my Emisars they aren't actually that great for pocket carry being on the thicker side for 18650 lights.
You hit the nail on the head there and actually got me thinking as well. None of my lights are shelf queens, I use all of them as often as is practical, I sometimes even create excuses to use them, like walking instead of driving, or going looking for owls in the tall trees in our garden with no serious prospect of spotting one, just to get to use my throwers, but if I’m honest, my favourite lights and my most frequently used lights are not the same lights, and that’s totally okay.
I expect the Nitecore to be with me whenever I need to use the train and might not be back before dark. There’s a dark patch on the path from our local station which doesn’t usually warrant a lot of light, but it would sure be nice to have access to a massive burst for a few seconds to see what’s around if I’m walking along and hear a noise next to the road that I’m not entirely sure I trust. It’s an absolute winner for that use case.
Of course I could just take one of my gnarly tactical throwers for that kind of scenario, but that would mean having to take a backpack as well, which might be an encumbrance at my destination, or getting funny looks all day long for wearing a holster, because 21700 duty lights don’t go into pants pockets without a fight.
I’d like to see Wurkkos experiment more with this form factor, but please give us a neutral/warm white High CRI version! If the price is right I would probably buy 10 and give them out for gifts. That’s exactly what I did with the TS21 last year, and Nitecore Tip CRI several years back.
I love your graphs. In this case, if you’re not paying close attention the model names on the graph are easy to mix up. Consistently including the brand would be handy, even though it’s more busy looking.
I’m not too worried about battery degradation and replacability as long as the light is affordable. All my old Nitecore keychain lights still charge and run fine.
Thanks for the feedback!
I like these lights, as you said i understand the form factor but I would really need to try and edc one to find out. They all do look really nice, you didn't mention charge speed but I could overlook some things if it charged blazing fast like 20w or more preferably. I personally really prefer replaceable batteries but I could be swayed some if the battery was user serviceable such as if you wanted to take it apart, the battery was not direct solder if a lipo, and if round cells were used, some kind of tensioned system would be awesome. That way it isn't a throw away light and you could replace it but isnt something you would be doing everyday. Lastly Anduril has kinda become a must with flashing pads internally available for the ones that want to upgrade....im still wishing one day the usb-c port will be data linked to the main processor so firmware can be updated and flashed that way. thanks for the video as always and If i won one it would be nice to see if edc'ing 1 of these could change my mind.
I didn't test charge speed, but I did find the Nitecore charged extremely quickly
@@LuxWad thanks, i bet you the nitcore is pd charging compatible so most likely can charge at 9v 1amp or something like that, others are prolly all 5v 500mah to 1amp max lol
1) Your opinions on these lights (for the manufacturers to see!)
I have long left the flashlight scene for decades and was astounded to see the new flat form factor lights with sealed lithium polymer batteries. The Nitecore EDC29 is the most impressive with its fancy OLED display, but assuming this light will last me for a full 8 years I wonder if Nitecore will still have the exact replacement for the OLED display, let alone the built-in sealed battery.
Even if Nitecore still stocks on parts for the EDC29 model years down the road, I'm not sure if it would be cost effective to have it repaired long after the warranty expires. If I had to eventually discard the EDC29 it would be a expensive e-waste.
I'm a Wurkkos fan therefore I would gravitate towards the HD01 series. The HD01 Pro has a simple UI and does the job of illuminating darkness without denting one's budget. It also makes an a thoughtful gift for family and friends. Those who are not into flashlights will be impressed by the futuristic look of any of these flat shaped lights. Non flashlight folk will appreciate the ease of recharging these flashlights via the USB-C port and not having to bother with external battery chargers.
Except for the cigarette lighter shaped Wuben EDC pocket light which was briefly highlighted, I'm afraid I don't know much of the other competing brands in this video.
2) what you liked/didn't like about this video
I applaud your choice of testing the lights by the hillside, overlooking the vast bright lights of the beautiful city in the distance. The runtime charts helped me to understand all of these flashlight's step down times and sustained outputs.
The videography is awesome, I liked the shallow DoF macro shots of one or two of these lights and the top-down view of them in your pants pocket.
This review could also use rudimentary comparison beam tests of the ultraviolet LED using fluorescent material in the dark.
3) any other thoughts/feedback you might have :)
I wished you had conducted the outdoor beam tests by illuminating the same target area instead of different places, so that viewers can visually compare the beam profiles and flood patterns. Other than that I have little else to critique about your production quality. Keep up the good work! 😊☺️
Thanks for the feedback!
@LuxWad You're welcome and good luck to the winners! 🔦🙂
Awesome little giveaway - thank you to Wurkkos for their continued support of the hobby community. Their HD01 is easily inexpensive enough to try out this category of flashlight design without the worry of the price tags the others carry.
Sure, it's lacking in some ways and the side-light is not the first choice for me when I want flood, but it's a decent jack-of-all trades... If I were more interested in stuff like the Nitecore multi-emitter setup or proprietary alloys from Olight, I still think they're priced relatively well for their given performance.
Nice review as always - thank you for offering the side-by-side comparisons... I haven't seen much for these things so it's a bit hard to compare well.
The nitecore is very impressive, the wurkkos seems like great value. What's been holding me off from these lights so far is non-replaceable batteries. Overall, great video though!
Glad to see this pop up in my feed this morning. I never see the trustfire mini x3 in these flat light videos. I compared a few flat lights before and I really liked it. The thing I didn't like about the wurkkos is the double sided clip which always gets caught on stuff and then you gotta bend it back. And why don't these companies realize we want warm, high cri emitters. The battery thing never really bothered me, but I can see the drawback. I also found that the uv lights are not very bright for using outdoors to hunt scorpions.
The trustfire design is interesting, I haven't seen it before but there is this review from 1lumen: 1lumen.com/review/trustfire-mini-x3/
Seems to be a decent versatile option, though the performance is not quite as good as these lights