Not Fixing Things Right
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 жов 2024
- The plaintiff says she brought her Mercedes to the defendant’s shop for repairs, but it wasn’t running right when she picked it up. There was even black smoke coming from the tailpipe. She took the car to another mechanic who told her the defendant did nothing to fix the car, so she’s suing for her money back. The defendant says he repaired areas of the car, but the plaintiff burned out her fuel pump and it’s unrelated to the repairs he did. He denies owing anything and is countersuing for towing costs.
27-030
“Both of them are losers but they’re okay”. I can’t with hallway dude😂😂
Love him! 😂😂
We need a little tour because I always wonder what's around that corner 🤣
Meeee toooo
You and me both!!! 😂😂😂
Love how people who don't know anything about how cars work, also wants to tell you how cars work.
She lost as soon as turned the key. NEVER buy a used Mercedes, especially one that's old. A money pit with wheels.
Did you actually watch the story. She bought it 10 years previous. She owned it for 10 years, not a used car, in that sense
When I fixed my brakes, the ac went out. Fixed the ac, and then my windshield cracked. All within the same month. Just happens. Doesn’t mean the mechanic that fixed my brakes was waiting on the side of the road with a rock to crack my windshield 😂
😂
Exactly. When she said her car has never turned off on her that doesn't mean the car didn't have issues.
I don’t consider a car that’s 10 years old . Old . I mean if I pay $50,000 for a vehicle sometimes even $100000 for a pick up . I’m going to expect it to last… it not like changing underwear . I mean what we are suppose to buy a new car every 3 years or something ? I can understand a car 17-20 years old . But to expect people to buy a whole new car after ten years as if they shouldn’t expect their investment to last , is crazy to me .
In 10 years things go wrong and also this it’s assumed that the car is properly serviced and maintained….. she already had ongoing issues with the car… if it goes unchecked for sometime eventually it’s going to…
10 years may jot be super old, but kerp in mind manufacturer warranties end in roughly 10 years on a brand new vehicle. And if you don’t maintain said vehicle in that 10 years, stuff is gonna break. I doubt this girl is the original owner, and she didnt find anything wrong driving around her car with th ‘’check engine light’’ on, and smelling of gas. Her response to that was literally ‘’I never had that problem before. I’ve always drivin it like that .” Heck, she didn’t even care there was oil in her antifreeze. She only brought it in because someone else told her that the problem might get worse if she didn’t take care of it now. So yes, 10 years is pretty old for a car that has not been maintained properly.
10 years is officially "old" in car age - Things simply wear out in that amount of time - And cars aren't "investments" they are depreciating assets built for human convenience (luxuries), no different than an Iphone or smart TV - Not to mention this was a Mercedes which are way more complex than some simple little Toyota or Chevy so the cost of ownership on an "old" one will naturally be significantly higher to keep it on the road.
Cars are NOT investments... They lose value the second you drive it off the lot. Lmfao
As a mechanic, I can tell you most people do not care about their cars and expect them to run for 20 years just by getting by on oil changes. And by the time you guys bring it to us, it’s holding on by a thread and expect us to work miracles. People need to learn what PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE is. It means replacing BEFORE it goes bad. Replace your belt, replace your fluids, replace your plugs, replace your gaskets. Help us help you lol
Sometimes fixing an old car will create problems in other areas of the car. There is nothing they could've done that would've damaged her fuel pump.
Don't put it past mechanics to disconnect stuff and try to upcharge you....There's a lot of dishonest mechanics out there I've come across many in my lifetime
@@josha.bdoge2 That does happen. I have been a mechanic my whole life and I've seen other mechanics do that. But a "burned fuel pump" happens as a result of high resistance in the armature after when it is worn out. It is common on higher mileage cars and there is no way to fake it.
Exactly!!
Yep! Defendant should have gotten the shop's diagnostic fee out of her. That fee is often put towards repairs, but only if you have their shop do the work!
Worked on Mercedes for years, replaced the radiator because oil in the coolant. The guy should be put out of business, he is a joke. The first scan would have shown a week fuel sending unit. He ripped her off
She's the type of person that will constantly say oh everything was fine until this person touched it.
She will expect every single thing to be fixed by that one person who touched it.
10-year-old car probably has 150,000 mi on it, A lot more than a radiator is going to break
Yep! Defendant should have gotten the shop's diagnostic fee out of her. That fee is often put towards repairs, but only if you have their shop do the work!
Especially on a mercedez
"Both of them are losers, but they're ok." Oh Doug🤦🏾♀️😂
Lol!! Dougie to the plaintiff in her way out- “you know it’s interesting the defendant said “he’d showed you the burned fuel pump”, but you’re saying that never happened?? That’s interesting!
Plaintiff- “Yeah, it’s interesting to me too”!! Lol!!! I don’t think she realizes Doug was basically saying someone was lying about that, & I think he meant her, but she didn’t get it?!! 😮
Been watching the new Tribunal Court. I'm so picky about my court shows and missing the people's court compared to the new show. I love Judge Marilyn though, just not the new setup. 😢
I agree. I think the new show is awful, so scripted! I’m so disappointed! She should have just retired. I don’t know why she agreed to this type of forum.
@@maureenostermann291 Money and an easy job for her. Can't blame her for staying cashing in on easy money.
I Am not a fan of the tribunal court or Marilyn's new show. ..blows my mind that they cancel one court show to spend thousands on a new court show and somehow fucking it up. If it ain't broke don't fix it
I’m with all of you. I watch an episode of the new show and quickly turned it off. Didn’t like it at all. I’ll just stick to the original People’s Court.
Yes I agree the new show is trash!
WE, even women, ALL know now that this MAN does adequate repairs. Thanks for "exposing" him.
"Inadequate" repairs not "adequate" repairs....he has now been exposed!!🤗
@@LLStark NOPE -- "adequate" repairs exposed by a LIAR
@@mikemontana3443 OH, 🆗
GOTCHA 👌
A lot of times, it's one thing after another with a car. Sometimes it's better to just replace the car. Some mechanics are shady but that's in every profession. They can't be liable for everything. Sometimes things go one after another. Sticky situation.
With older cars especially foreign cars, once you touch something. It's like opening a can or worms 🪱, more trouble pops up...old wires breaking, old metal fitting leaking
@@chrispellicci6587 So true !!
She's out of gas! What? She knew she didn't have proof? 🤣🤣🤣
The plaintiffs hair is so beautiful. It’s so shiny!
No it's not. Not a beauty contest. Who's says " It so shiny. Shut up sound stupid
@@teet-zi8ksyour a hater lol. She was just giving a compliment that had nothing to do with the case please shut up
@@teet-zi8ks ok if you say so 😂
@@teet-zi8ksYou sound jealous because the compliment wasn't about you.
Why have a luxury vehicle and NOT take it to the shop that specializes in that specific vehicle 🤦🏾♀️
The fuel pump and the radiator are like night and day. That is like on opposite sides of the engine. This happens when you're fixing one part of a car and something else fails. That happened to me while I was working on my son's car, After replacing the brakes, I noticed the motor mounts (engine) were sounding funny so I had to replace them. One part had absolutely nothing to do with the other.
In this case the fuel pump is under the back seat so opposite ends of the car.
Agreed
She shouldn't drive a car that she can't afford to fix.
“Both of them are loosers but they’re okay“ 🤣🤣🤣
It seems like some people who drive a Mercedes can't afford to keep it properly maintained.
Doug!! 🙌🏾🤣🤣🤣💀 "Both of them are losers, but they're OK!" 😅 12:52
The plaintiff is relying on the post-hoc fallacy: This preceded that, therefore it caused it.
That philosophy class is working huh 😂
This is a case of the knee bone connected to the neck bone. Do some research before trying to sue a person out of their work. She had absolutely no understanding of how the vehicle works and wanted to claim the guy didn't do it right. 😂
So 10 year old Mercedes needs a lot of work. But expects a mechanic to get it back to new for free.
People like this women piss me off on another level
The plaintiff is a lovely lady but she owns a ten-year-old car. It's common to have multiple problems as cars age. My parts at age 74 are breaking down too. 😄😄😄
I am personally friends with the Plaintiff and I can tell you for fact she is the sweetest person ever and she's so cool. And she has trained her daughter so well. I did tell her after this aired that she should've contacted my brother because he's a mechanic.
You're friends with her and you let her go on TV and embarrass herself?
Why do people talk about "training" children? You train animals, not people 🙄
@@Irod567relax.
Mentioning her child is irrelevant.
Going to your brother would not have changed anything.
A radiator and a fuel pump are not related or involved.
She has a Mercedes which was her first mistake.
Every mechanic go through customers like her who don't understand how cars work and therefore think it must be them doing something wrong.
It's like someone giving you a haircut and all of a sudden you say your pinky toe hurts
It is a hard stress that you have to do to make them to related and say it's the barber fault
There are a few things the mechanic said that caught my attention. He said he saw oil in the radiator and said he changed the radiator but changing the radiator would do nothing to stop oil from getting into the coolant. Then he said he showed her the burnt out fuell pump. To do that he would have had to drop the fuel tank, pulled the pump out and disconnect it from the wiring and hose, then put it all back. That would have been the same labor as replacing the pump.
I recently recently i took my van in for a strong vibration. The mechanic changed the fuel pump, and injectors. The vibration was still there. Turns out it was the motor mounts. The first mechanics had not even checked them.
Doug: Both of them are losers but they’re ok. I can’t with Doug. 😂
I could have sworn he said the engine was flooding and he did a few tricks to fix the problem then turned around and checked the problem again and said No oil was going to the engine?? Well, sounds like he messed something up to me.
The defendant reminded me a bit of Jon Lovitz ..Made me think of the Devil on People's Court skit from SNL.
She drives 10 year old Mercedes trying to be money. She tried to scam mechanic for money. Back to no money for her
No fuel gauge working is related to the fuel pump. She admitted to all of these problems before she brought in her car.
I would never own a Mercedes or BMW over 3 yrs old they are maintenance nightmares and will drain your wallet, This mechanic was very competent , This chic is whacked!
she's SOL. It's kind of surprising how many times the audience with Harvey gets everything wrong. Maybe it's being put on the spot....maybe they don't watch the People's Court.
He was asking children their opinion. Nobody should ever do that.
A good analogy the judge couldve used is getting a flat tyre repaired today doesnt mean your engine wont blow up tomorrow
I'm a mechanic and I used to own my own shop. We had a guy have his Explorer towed in with a bad starter. We replaced it. Two days later he was driving down the highway with a trailer on the back and his engine threw a rod, totally killing it. He came in furious and wanted to know what we could have done installing that starter to cause his engine to blow. I said it probably wasn't anything to do with his starter but instead the fact that his Explorer had over 170k miles. But I gave him my insurance companies number and told him he was free to file a claim if he felt we were responsible. The adjuster determined that he had a major lack of maintenance as well as pulling a trailer with a load that was well above his vehicle's recommended towing capacity. His claim was denied of course.
I can make a case where it would.
When it's an old car like that. Anything can happen at any moment.
Don’t buy an expensive car if you can’t afford to maintain it!!
She didn't take care of her car 😂😂talking bout it's been like that for years and ran .. shits gotta get changed every certain years her tryna get an auto shop to pay for her broke down car is crazy 😂
Idk how people are just bypassing this detail. I knew the case was over after that. Bih didn’t do a damn thing to maintain her car. She thought her luck was gonna last forever. Now that she wore and tore it, she wanna be mad at everyone but herself, lol
So you knew you didnt have proof, but you filed anyway for the inconvenience he caused? What a great use of the legal system. 🙄
WHY do so many people come into this 🏛️ room with sooo much ARROGANCE and then expect 👩🏻⚖️Milian to rule in their favor as if their higher and better than God almighty himself?? 🤔🤨
I work for an automotive manufacture people have super high expectations from mechanics because they have no idea how it all works. She literally sued for a fuel
pump for a decade old car 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 RIDICULOUS
All the new episodes on the court shows for example Judge Judy, The People's Court, Judge Mathis ....
All the new episodes are rubbish rubbish rubbish rubbish!
But what also is lost is the interaction between the judge and the original bailiff's.
Sometimes just to leave the old version is the best!!
If you drive a USED Benz or BMW, you need to make the money needed to fix them! Can NOT go cheap with these cars.
Used to work at a used car dealership. Low-income people who wanted to look like they had money kept buying those used Benz and BWM. Many of those cars got repoed because once they broke down and the buyers could not afford the repair bills. The owner did not want bad reviews for his business, so he had them sign another paper with those cars stating that they understood maintenance/repair bills cost are high and the vehicle would be repoed if they failed to keep up with the car payment. It also included an estimate of what repairs/maintenance would cost. Sure enough, they still bought them, and some of those vehicles returned to be sold gain.
I don't know who she's trying to impress, I hope it's not a guy.
@@marilynwillett804of course it’s a guy. Or girl. I bet it’s for social media, or to make her coworkers jealous. Gotta keep up appearances!
People need to stop buying cars that they can not afford to maintenance.
When parts are replaced, old worn parts are then forced to work at the level of the new ones. This sometimes exposes issues that otherwise would go unnoticed. Such is the nature of repairs on older vehicles. I feel her pain but I don't think she had much of a case, there.
Just replaced a fuel pump ,cost me over a $1,000. She couldn't afford it. Bye gurl
She caused the suit because she thinks she's a victim because she has a 10-year-old Mercedes that has issues, which is known as one of the most unreliable cars especially when it comes to durability, but thinks the mechanic had ill intent.
What sad is a lot of people have thoughts like that also smh
Sis I hope you one day realize that you were not a victim in this situation at all
It was judgement for the defendant from the get go.
she is totally out of luck, thank you judge
That's why it wouldn't start, the fuel pump
Sis, based off the list of issues that car was trouble trouble. Want a foreign car pay foreign prices.
I'm sick of these people buying old, cheap luxury cars and getting surprised when they break down! Mercedes, Audi, and BMW, are known to suffer from mechanical and electrical problems just a couple of years from the manufacturing date, rich people buy them before either A, they have the money for repairs or B, they have the money to eat the cost and trade-in for a new one altogether. Mercedes of all of them are the absolute WORST to buy used, especially when they are old! Just remember people, a 10-year-old Mercedes doesn't make you rich! 😂😂😂
She didn't buy an old car. She bought is fairly new and used the crap out of it.
A childs mind in an adults body.
Rough justice on BOTH sides. OUCH.
She is out of luck. A fuel pump is not related to the radiator. Hey, cars have issues with time.
Defendant should have gotten the shop's diagnostic fee out of her. That fee is often put towards repairs, but only if you have their shop do the work!
Another completely ignorant Plaintiff. First of all, if you have an older German luxury car, don't take it to a mechanic who doesn't specialize in that make. Secondly- crap happens to older luxury cars- that's why they are so affordable for people who can't afford a new one.Unless you have the money to keep it running, know that it was traded in by someone who got sick of paying for repairs.
Auto repair shops routinely mark up the price of parts..... it's what helps keep their shops open. Some are reasonable, some are not, but most all of them do that. LaShohn'da seems to believe that because a car still runs, there can be nothing wrong with it. I'm pre-laughing when she eventually needs an oil pump or some other internal parts for her Mercedes that typically costs 5 times more than they would for Ford.
I’m a mechanic and a burnt fuel pump isn’t the shops fault
It’s her for failing to maintain the car.
My husband said the same thing. Not the shops fault and it’s all about upkeep.
Old German cars are horrible when the warranty runs out, especially if you dont keep it properly maintained. They are the worst because of cost/labor, and ppl dont realize it until its too late. And that's the problem🤷♂️
*He didn't do anything wrong, now I dont believe her at all!🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Sounds like she found herself the cheapest Mercedes she could find. Then is surprised it has issues.
I will never own a German car again 💸💸
@@BCNeil probably from a used car lot...I bet it looked good too🤣
These are the mutant crew being surveyed! 😮
The mechanic was honest with her. He could've of easily said that the head gasket was bad on the motor and charged her more money. Transmission oil in the radiator is a easier fix and cheaper. On a Mercedes gas gage not working sign of fuel pump going bad.
Its a dang 10yr or so Mercedes so it's time for things to go wrong lol😂
My Mercedes is 5 years old, i got it brand new in 2019… now it started to act up and i have to repair ton of stuff 😫 and it cost a lot.
That’s why I never bought one nice looking but expensive
Never have a Mercedes after the warranty period, even if your loan is longer.
Don’t buy a car you can’t afford. Geez Louise. Not the brightest bulb this gal.
4:00 I'm not an auto mechanic but everything she's describing sounds like a fuel pump to me. That has NOTHING to do with a radiator.
The lady stated her coolant was full of oil. SHE STATED IT. Therefore her radiator would also have oil. This isn't rocket science. If your radiator is full of oil, is not going to work. No you can't wash the oil out.
Parts for a Mercedes is expensive
She knows nothing
She has a 10 year old Mercedes and all these things are wrong with it lol 😂. Not if she would’ve bought a Honda or Toyota. Ppl like buying a German car but when it comes to repair and maintenance want a Japan car price
This is why you never fill out a work order. You take it in to get a diagnostic and have them tell you everything they found..... If they supposedly fix everything on their diagnostic and the car still doesn't work, and they say. Oh, we found something else. No, you did a full diagnostic. Why didn't you tell me that initially?
Come on. Women have to stop acting like victims because they didn't get everything they wanted. I hate those comments "I just want women to know what he's doing." What you meant was "Just fix everything, but do it for free.
Every single person that's outside and answer the question do not know anything about cars. 🤦🏿♂️
It's sad
Status and fashion, problems follow ....
5:10 a burnt out fuel pump is usually caused by driving a car routinely until the fuel gauge is just about on “E”. The fuel keeps the pump lubricated so less fuel equals less lubrication which causes the fuel pump to burn out….
I love how some defendants counter-sue for something they were never going to charge for in the first place.
... and the judge just agreed with me.
You agree with her
@@lostsoul1278 We agree with each other, but I wrote it here before she said it on my screen, so I got there first.
I think he had a case. The car was towed in and he was working on it. She came in and took it without paying for his work.
@@mexicanspec At the 11:00 minute point, the judge thinks otherwise. (Click on the blue time to the left to go to that point in the video.)
I know because he admitted he wasn't going to charge her for the work, but he did do the work and she came in and grabbed the car. @@BobBlumenfeld
When I get a diagnostic, which can cost $200+, I expect the mechanic to tell me everything that's wrong with my car. If I think a radiator will fix my issues, but it is actually a radiator plus a head gasket, then I need to know. I might choose to just junk it instead of going down a rabbit hole of repairs.
Mechanics, is this a fair ask? I imagine your diagnostic tools are like the tester at Autozone that can spit out a code of issues needing repairs.
Unfortunately it doesn't always work that way. In your example of a blown head gasket and bad radiator- you have to repair the radiator first before you can continue to diagnose to find a blown head gasket.
Similar to if a car doesn't start- you diagnose a failed fuel pump but after replacing the fuel pump it runs rough due to ignition issues. Some things have to be diagnosed and repaired first before other diagnostics can be performed.
Should have bought a Toyota! Mid 2000's are extremely problematic.
Radiator and fuel pump.. 2 opposite ends of the car.. Totally not related
Plaintiff don't understand how things work outside of her head. The defendant was just being petty.
12:01 you're really going to make that speech? Just because you don't have any mechanical skills doesn't mean some girls are badass farm girls who can get a broken John Deere to run
Plaintiffs hair is beautiful🔥
There is nothing beautiful about that fake hair. 😂
@@DavidKen878You seem jealous.
@@miguelus.81 Of tracks?
@@DavidKen878 Because the compliment wasn't for you, and no one likes you.
I used to work in a repair shop, and see nonsense like this from time to time. Example: "You gave me a complete tune-up, and now one of my tires is flat. WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY CAR???" Duh.
That’s old ass car…girl bye
That car was a piece of junk
Two different problems with the car. One was that tranny fluid was leaking in the radiator , and the other the bad fuel pump. O2 sensors, coils too .
Not surprised . Some models start having tons of problems after getting older.
Sue the mechanic because he fixed the problem you told him to , and left the one you told him to leave ? You are fond of your judgement.
An older Mercedes ? Think … the car is so expensive in the beginning, so do you think people that buy them would care about how expensive it would be fix and maintain? Expect to pay $$$$$ .
The intro has me weak 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Have a great day y’all !!!
Please do the same??
U too
😊
She tried it.
Big time 😂
She completely outve her mind . Car has 100 problems she wants to fix 2 of them and blames him when it doesn’t work 😂😂 typical
Well, isn't she special. 😊
She said she knew she didn't have any evidence but still filed the suit? She seems like a scam artist to me. Trying to get a freebie.
One day someone go smack Doug (interviewer at the end). Lol
Why do they talk to these idiots on the street? 😮💨
Oil in anti freeze is bad. The engine doesn't have long to go.
Timing does matter
The plaintiff that she had additional issues that were explained to her by the defendant. She was just out the money grab & defaming the defendant even though it seemed to me that he was being quite generous in not charging her for the extra hours he spent diagnosing everything that she needed done to get that old vehicle back into proper working order.
The Defendant was on here before. He looks familiar.
Another Stupid Car Owner and the audience in the video were future litigants thinking the mechanic was at fault for something he never worked on.
10 Year old German car. Unless you get the very expensive yearly maintenance from the dealer, those cars are nothing but a money pit.