It's tricky because I kinda split Poppy into two lists of like Pre and Post Metal era, it's really hard to compare the genres lol. I mean songs like 'Software Upgrade' is sick, but so is 'They're all Around Us' but in a completely different way, just different eras. I started listening to her Pre-Metal, and so I naturally think those songs will forever be unforgettable even if I prefer the metal era overall.
Yeah making a tierlist for Poppy is for sure a bit complicated cause there's just so many genres involved lol, but yeah on a personal taste level I definitely love more of the metal stuff, but also love pretty much anything she does!
As someone currently doing reactions on Poppy, I'm going to use this video as refrence for which songs I react to lmaoo. Good shit dude! This is a fun watch
I was giving an upvote because this video is so fun even if "I Disagree". HOLY CRAP, are you and me the only people that think Software Upgrade is the best song off P.C????? I've never heard anyone else with that opinion! The only rating that makes me vomit is Metal! That's S+ tier.
Oh shit I never thought about it that way! I think if she did that and added some of the Zig outtakes to Zig, I personally would have loved Stagger and Zig so much more
I love it I agree with you in many things ! But for me I think Fill the crown Immature couture My style All the things she said Deserve a higher rank ! 💖🌸
I’d have put motorbike in F. agree with the Am I a girl album, the first half just isn’t really the same. Choke EP is probably my most listened to, the Birthday Massacre sounding chorus on Meat is great. Poppy’s cover of Fear of Dying impressed me, I was quite worried with loving the original so much. Spit however didn’t really do much for me. It just sounded like the same song that Kittie released over 20 years ago.
Oh that's fun that you say that because The Attic personally makes my skin crawl! I think it's incredible we all love an artist so much but can have polar opposite opinions
I love how youre like I made it before so itll be easy but youre struggling to rank LMAO also you say im think before each rank but no a single thought is behind those eyes 😭JEGEKDHSKKSS
I would be perfectly satisfied with Fill The Crown and listen to it often, if it wasn't for the fecking guest vocals from Marilyn Manson. That's who it is. I used to be obsessed with Marilyn Manson. But now I can't stand to hear his voice. I can't know if the allegations against him are true, but the damage is done. I've gone and cancelled him in my mind.
Tbh i had no clue there was any drama with Fill the Crown lol. I just don't like the song much bc its like a 50/50 split of 'uncredited male vocal' and 'Poppy'. Like, if that male vocal was credited I wouldn't have minded.
@@bobair2 "in" Ahn; infinidimensional way; smarty pants; Who do you think you are?;: don't you Know Who I AAMM?;: are you cummin' Ahn t'Me?;: cuz i am single; and poly;
i will not accept any fill the crown slander
One of my favorites.
It's tricky because I kinda split Poppy into two lists of like Pre and Post Metal era, it's really hard to compare the genres lol. I mean songs like 'Software Upgrade' is sick, but so is 'They're all Around Us' but in a completely different way, just different eras. I started listening to her Pre-Metal, and so I naturally think those songs will forever be unforgettable even if I prefer the metal era overall.
Yeah making a tierlist for Poppy is for sure a bit complicated cause there's just so many genres involved lol, but yeah on a personal taste level I definitely love more of the metal stuff, but also love pretty much anything she does!
Metal the genre or Metal the song?
@@whom382metal the genre
😭😭 nooo i love chic chick, fashion after all, and iconic
Everyone has different taste, and im glad there's someone to enjoy those songs :D
OMG those are Poppy's worst songs but "I Disagree" applies and I'll give you a break.
Im screaming cuz Pocket Shapes and In a minute are in my S tier while their your least fav songs-
Yeah haha, that seems to be a controversial topic in this comment section...
As someone currently doing reactions on Poppy, I'm going to use this video as refrence for which songs I react to lmaoo. Good shit dude! This is a fun watch
Oh shit I actually watched ur reaction on 'theyre all around us' loll, good luck making ur videos, man!
@@av1re.mp486 oh wow thats lowkey a bit crazy 🤯 you too! Really entertaining watch
Thank you! Your video was also enjoyable, keep it up!
I love sit stay so much
YESS ITS THE BEST
I was giving an upvote because this video is so fun even if "I Disagree". HOLY CRAP, are you and me the only people that think Software Upgrade is the best song off P.C????? I've never heard anyone else with that opinion! The only rating that makes me vomit is Metal! That's S+ tier.
YESS ANOTHER SOFTWARE UPGRADE FAN!!
Pretty good and reasonable ranking; Loved the fun editing, great video! 👏
Thank you so much, I'm glad you enjoyed it!!
Pretty good ranking (apart from the American Kids getting C tier!).
Where would you put Everybody Wants to be Poppy?
BLOODMONEY in B?
ELITA REFERENCED I AM IN LOVE WITH YOU (subscribing)
I have been a metal fan my whole life and love her... but I love "I'm Poppy" lol. Also, "Voicemail" is so dope
1:29 the Sleigh bells and Elita
So where would you place 3.14 then? 👁️
13:52 IDKHBTFM MENTIONED
Flicker and Linger go well with Stagger, wish they were there over Shapes and Pocket. Plus they look nice back to back on a tracklist!
Oh shit I never thought about it that way! I think if she did that and added some of the Zig outtakes to Zig, I personally would have loved Stagger and Zig so much more
Thank you for this video 🖤
I'm glad you enjoyed!
Fill the Crown has a S tier music video though
thank you youtube for recommending this to me
Glad you enjoyed, man!
She's my favorite, too
To me theres 4 different types of poppy, pop poppy, mixed pop/metal poppy, industrial electronic poppy, and pure metal/rock poppy
13:00 interclude
Please do a tier list with her unreleased songs. There are hidden gems in there like 'blush'
This might be a good idea actually...
@@av1re.mp486 I'll wait for your video to drop
I love it I agree with you in many things !
But for me I think
Fill the crown
Immature couture
My style
All the things she said
Deserve a higher rank !
💖🌸
i love poppy
bloodmoney is like the best song off the album
I would try to do this but put everything S tier.. also “that man” in full the crown is rumored to be Marilyn Manson !
Chic Chick and Iconic in F tier 🤔 choices
hey.. i never said it wouldn't be a controversial video.. :)
Don't ever rank again
Where would you place New Way Out?
Oooh that's a good one, prolly A tier!
elita and jazmin bean mentioned omg 😍
YESSS I LOVE THEM !!
Reyal
poppy is dope
I agreed with everything till u started ranking "Am I a Girl" aka my favorite album T.T
Finally i found someone that Hates the first sings on am i a girl?, they are p.c songs but way worse i always skip them.
Yes, right!! They just don't hit the same..
I’d have put motorbike in F. agree with the Am I a girl album, the first half just isn’t really the same.
Choke EP is probably my most listened to, the Birthday Massacre sounding chorus on Meat is great.
Poppy’s cover of Fear of Dying impressed me, I was quite worried with loving the original so much. Spit however didn’t really do much for me. It just sounded like the same song that Kittie released over 20 years ago.
Very respectable opinions also
omg i love poppy so much
Edit: omg your opinions are gonna make me throw up
YAYYY I LOVE POPPY
flicker, linger and especially the attic are kinda some of her best songs……
Oh that's fun that you say that because The Attic personally makes my skin crawl! I think it's incredible we all love an artist so much but can have polar opposite opinions
imo all of Flux is an S tier and Stagger and Shapes are S tier because S names and also i like em
All those low-tier songs… o.o
Pleasee 😭 motorbike deserves better
Aristocratic is minimum A
I was kinda hoping you would just keep putting every song at S tier, lol
I love how youre like I made it before so itll be easy but youre struggling to rank LMAO also you say im think before each rank but no a single thought is behind those eyes 😭JEGEKDHSKKSS
Yeah that lobotomy I got definitely isn't working wonders 🥴
Stagger is so gooddddd
I would be perfectly satisfied with Fill The Crown and listen to it often, if it wasn't for the fecking guest vocals from Marilyn Manson. That's who it is. I used to be obsessed with Marilyn Manson. But now I can't stand to hear his voice. I can't know if the allegations against him are true, but the damage is done. I've gone and cancelled him in my mind.
Tbh i had no clue there was any drama with Fill the Crown lol. I just don't like the song much bc its like a 50/50 split of 'uncredited male vocal' and 'Poppy'. Like, if that male vocal was credited I wouldn't have minded.
AHHHH i finally found another poppy fan!1!1!1!
wrong;
In what way?
@@bobair2
"in" Ahn;
infinidimensional way;
smarty pants;
Who do you think you are?;:
don't you Know Who I AAMM?;:
are you cummin' Ahn t'Me?;:
cuz i am single;
and poly;
Opinions are subjective, making it almost impossible to be wrong.
Maybe you should have just gone with the comedy and said “I disagree”
666th viewer😈
1:28 DYSANIA MENTIONED?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?