Parliament is completely Dysfunctional,We Need a National Movement to Revitalise it: Kapil Sibal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лип 2022
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
One of India’s most senior politicians, who has been a member of both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, says parliament has become “completely dysfunctional” and, he adds, “it is steadily getting worse”. Kapil Sibal says that whilst we know what needs to be done to revitalize parliament, on its own politicians will not implement the required measures and, therefore, it must fall on the people of India to raise their voice and say enough is enough and parliament has to change the way it functions. Within the people of India he identified lawyers as people who must lead what he called “a national movement” to change the functioning of parliament.
Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
It is sad to hear Mr.Sibal says everything depends on ordinary people to solve our problems, when presently a "ordinary man" is a very rare to be found in present day India.
It should be made constitutional that PM has to give answers of opposition in house for certain hours and certain day
Very genuine discussion
my thankful to all those .
Will such a day will come when all things will be discussed in Supreme Court and not in the Parliament ?
What a stupid question! Judiciary isn't meant for legislation.
The autocratic ruling dispensation has reduced the parliament to a joke at public expense. With zero governance, country is on auto pilot. Shocking to witness the lack of morals or responsibility to the nation from the very same who profess to be nationalists. Does not a single parliamentarian have a conscience?
I am certain there must be politicians with active conscience, but what I am bloody sure of is they are profoundly outnumbered by corrupt ones. The question is if they will show spine and stand defiantly in the face of goons and save democracy.
The two gujju thugs sponsored by Adani and Ambani never experienced Parliamentary process before 2014 and are used to autocratic rule of their state for over 15 years. Neither of them have proper education, were born and raised in ghettos and have no regard for the concept of 'Union of India'. These thugs can't comprehend that what they're doing is wrong on many levels, literally they have financial backing of every single gujju business of this country. So it's very delusional for all of us to have not realised that this reality was in the making for he last 8 years - it's high time people are waking up before it's too late.
Parliament was closed cameras are turned off and mp are fighting, this is what happening previously do you remember???
Things are coming to a head, sadly a disastrous one, the phoenix story is just a myth, SOCIETY, as the alternate life has not worked, there are cracks in the structure that are turning to crevices, no more is observation nonaligned, meaning, natural evolution has given way to cultural dogmas and beliefs. Belief being THE MOST WIDE SPREAD DISEASE OF MANKIND, and for which there is no vaccine. The worlds biggest temple of unity THE UNITED NATIONS is nothing but a symbol of INSANITY, where well dressed and supposedly educated people meet to celebrate mankind’s success story of DIVISION.
Agree with you n appreciate your concerns.
In the absence of a strong opposition these type of actions will keep increasing! No one to blame ! It is we who elected the Party with huge majority. What more you expect?
First American President Honorable George Washington realized it very soon. They suggest there should be two different Party in America Republican and Democrats they welcome to each other but never blame each other as it is happening in India. Sad to know about it.
The present government is strategically dismantling all opposition parties by criminal means ...they have nearly succeeded ....Hitler did the same
@@kasardevi8 All these doing because the fear of loosing their established kingdom they made out of bad intention, destruction to build worth and create violence on the name of Holiness but its a bitter truth no one get happy at the cost o blood and eyes. Good Luck for your success in Life you want as a Dream because No one like you on this planet Earth!
nowadays it is about jihad always. nothing on halala,triple talaq, hijab,forced halal, sar tan se juda. shine is wearing off.
From now the longer BJP stays in power it will be that dangerous for democracy in India.
Currently Modi is only focusing to target opposition..... topple governments......and hiding failures of last 7 years.......SORRY STATE OF AFFAIRS.
yes yes yes.
@@pragasamramaswamy1592 😂
That's absolutely right 👍
@@smitapatil3549 😂 ok Habibi
@@sounakchatterjee2694 everything that you don't understand is funny for you North Indians?😂
Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha has converted to stage of drama, now a days, which not only dangerous to democracy but common people also.
Mr. Karan Thapar, you're practice of journalism is a benchmark. People like Rajdeep Sardesai should ideally choose to follow in your footsteps👏👏
Respect. To both of you.
Nehru viewed Parliament as the most important institution of democracy. He made sure to attend parliament anyhow.
The power he commanded was atleast ten times more than this govt. It all comes down to the law makers how much they respect Democracy.
Article 19 laughing in silence 😆
But we most blady Indian against nehru..i think because there mind was washed by bjp WhatsApp University... social media
Which Nehru, the one preaches Gandhi-ism to people, and after that drinks, smokes, sleeps with lot of women, The corruption, family rule, power mongering started with him and swept all over India.
So he dismissed Kerala assembly without any reason simply to please his daughter, who was so adamant in her demand on it.
I like karan thapar. His questioning is what makes him different from other journalists.
I remember his interview which concluded with " Apni dosti bani rahe"
Has any BJP leader in the present Central govt have guts to face Karan's interview.
The PM has in a different capacity but buckled under the strain of questions and Mujhe pyas lekghi hai or could I have some water.
Dosti bani rahe, bus. Remember who said it to Karan Thapar?
I would like to see Sambit Patra to appear on this show!!! 😂
@@0rhythm_divine0 damnit Patra will never sit infront of Karan even in a private function.
@@0rhythm_divine0 Good idea. Sambit Patra will face Karan Thapar - ooyiin ooyiin, puiin puiin 🤣🤣
This is the first time I heard Mr Sibal. Amazing thought process. Left a very hopeless message in the end though. Lawyers must lead this movement. But who are those lawyers?
The general consioucenes of the public needs to rise before its too late. That can only happen when there is a leader who can lead this movement to its logical conclusion. The current opposition is just not good enough, hope a miracle happens before this toxic Hindutva changes India forever.
The lawyer who want to change in the system which has initiated from own inner voice to bring light in Society through own effort. no name come under it, in filthy way. Hope you can realize it.
@@sandeepshah105 Exactly there is no opposition leader so why blame the current Govt. And please Hindutva is not toxic its Muslims all over the over the world . Russia also needed to hire Syrian and Chechenian's (both Muslims) to be brutal in was in Ukraine
@@sandeepshah105 Hindutva says pray any god or even multiple gods and its all fine. Muslims say - I will pick 1 god and hence I am am minority, give me special privileges. And if I become majority then I'll violate all laws and pass my own law. How is the latter fair. how about each hindu picks 1 god alone and call themselves minority and seek special privileges? lets do a census and determine minorities.
@@samyvik2888 First, Hindutva is ant Hindu, Hindutva is a political movement started by RSS and Savarkar who coined this word was atheist who had little interest in religion. Similarly the counterpart of RSS, the Muslim League's founder Mr Jinnah hardly behaved like a Muslim. He was fond of alcohol, married a Parsi lady, wore western style clothes etc. What you are saying is what Hindutva (and not Hinduism) preaches. Interestingly, this is what the Muslim League also said, we need a separate country as these " Hindu" infidels will destroy us. Get out of your biasness, Muslims (and Hindus) are not monoliths.
I love your presence and thank you for the IMPORTANT work you do Karan. I donated for a year. Stay free✊🏻
A functional democracy needs a educated citizen, sadly India lack this.
partha, anubarta is part of tmc democracy. lol
No democracy, no freedom of speech, no debate! What is going on inside the Parliament? Can we tell the parliamentarians as Law makers?
You don't want Freedom of Speech as you say you do. You don't want people to have the right to call yo nabi what he was a warlord, ped0 pig.
Excellent presentation of the day today affairs in our Parliament! Salute to both participants in this discussion.
The parliament looks totally dysfunctional with the opposition too weak to take on the Govt. The sessions are immersed in clawing at each other rather than being constructive. But this is understandable cause the BJP govt. thrives under such situations at all levels.
Had Dr Ambedkar been alive today he would have revitalized the Parliament by now with sound systems and practices. Our great heritage of wisdom and knowledge has gone down. Entry into Both the houses need to be streamlined. Not all should be allowed.
Short and crisp and extremely thought provoking interview….. Thank you both….
Great program! Karan Thapar looks unwell and even sounds different than his usual self. I wonder if is recovering from Covid. Anyway, good luck with a speedy recovery. Karan is a shining jewel in the crown of Indian journalism.
Intellectual pimp, good at linking Madam to happiness
Indian voters are not matured mature enough to adopt a democratic system, if democracy is in it's real meaning how a country can vote for a communal majoritarian government? All this will continue and expect more
That's why you have gone to the doors of Mulayam and Akhilesh and likes. That's great Mr Sibal.
Excellent editorial…
Thank You Sir
Truth to be told, I only come to the wire, for Karan Thapar's show!!!
I thoroughly enjoy it. 😉
and i like that you like poonam Dhillon
An alarming state of affairs, clearly discussed between the two - they being well educated and aware of the way administration of a great nation should be carried out. More of the public will slowly come to realise this too and probably it would be too late by the time the common man on the streets wakes up to the reality
Qqq
Karan Thapar the legend!
Modi ka kya interview tha woh?
Karanji 👏🙌
Karan is man with ball of steel
Yes I watched that interview - Apni dosti bani rahe
Thanks
Who is watching this interview? A very small percentage, how does one reach the majority, and even if you do, what is their capacity to perceive. Ex Chief Justice of the high court, Markande Katju said eighty percent of Indians are idiots, and they have voted, now, you can only do this🤷🏻
Lol please read about what's happening in Italy and their election of so called technocrat as the leader of nation. Just passing on statements is not fact and what kind of chief justice he is when he can't accept ones own personal views which are the basics of democracy
Absolutely true, Sir...! Thanks, for the program.
We Indian's deserve this government, like the saying goes, "you elect jokers you get
You elect jokers you get a circus🎪.
Sadly, the people of the country are in a sleep mode. Who will awaken them?
Thanks!
Thanks Mr. Karan Thapar of WIRE News Channel and Mr. Kapil Sibbal of lNC. GOOD Discussions & Fair Analysis. HaleluJah Amen SHALOM 🙏👍🙏
This is an important interview. Member of Parliament, Shri Kapil Sibal ji has dealt with many important issues relating to functioning of parliament. Unfortunately, there has been a systematic erosion of the authority of parliament in the recent past. Parliament is an elected body by the people and if MPs are not allowed do their duties, we are failing the people. The ruling party with their majority is not respecting the conventions and practices hitherto being followed. The antidefection law must be scrapped lock stock and barrel . If an elected MLA or MP wants to defect to another party, first he should sign his legislative post and should be debarred from contesting elections for next five years. It is a very sensible opinion. If it is followed, there will hardly be any defection. Now the disgruntled politicians have made a mockery of Indian democracy by their lust for money and power. The 'resort politics' is a new dimension being followed nowadays. How is it that many elected MLAs flying in chartered flights to far off places and pull the strings to bring down the duly elected government? Who actually fiances their flight charges, stay in five star hotels etc? All this is done in the name of the people, who elected them on certain party ticket. If an MLA chooses to defect to another party, disregarding the will of the people, the people and the party which got them elected on their party ticket become helpless and mere spectators. This is murder of democracy and should be condemned.
Raise your voice 🗣️ against Unemployment, Inflation, Injustice, Hate. Save your Democracy save the constitution. Live For Humanity spread only love 🕊️. Jai Hind 🙏
Unfortunate to witness people with no adequate qualification given power,,,,
Exactly
Please study what's happening in Italy when they elected so called technocrat as leader. And what did technocrat like MMS did when rupee dropped 20% within span of months.
Yes,,study about italy seems to be more important than worry about why India govt selling PSU s, why rupee value is going down,why is inflation so high,why sc judges historical press conference and said democracy in danger, why are we paying huge tax on petrol deisel, why is banks npa has sky rocket, lakhs of crores loan waved off to slected industrialists,,,why is there severe joblessness in our country,,,,
@@ARN830 then what did technocrat MMS did why don't you answer that, my question is with people like you who go on with half baked facts. Bringing technocrats is not a fix
@@ARN830 if you consider selling of PSU is wrong then you are so dumb and Don't even know basics economics. Please read what did PVNR do in 1991
Very important interview for all public administration subject students!!!
Kapil sir only talks is not sufficient. What you said in the end is the necessity of the hour to save this country. I request you and all the respected unbiased lawyers and ex-defence officers and other activists to lead the common people to protest to bring back the democracy. Serious.
Before 2014, people of India had trouble with price rise, falling rupee, unemployment, corruption and border security.
Now, under the toxic influence of Hindutva, people don't care about historic prise rise, record fall of rupee, highest unemployment in history, corruption of Smriti Irani & Adani, petrol prices, fall in press freedom index, fall in hunger index and China capturing our land in AP & Ladhak.
Couldn't have summarised better!!!!! It's not just the standard of our parliament, we, the people of India have collectively degraded in terms of prioritising issues and morality.
Now people needed to be worried for removing our pants by nagpur half knickers
Can you please share how historic is the rupee fall on yoy basis rather just showing current numbers and also historic price rise show them on yoy numbers rather just current value of it. Just showing numbers is not data proving the point and the context of numbers is data
Thank you, Karan. That was a great interview with Kapil Sibal. What now?
Why not PM debate on this topic. PM does not attend parliament at all.
Glad to see two legends, Karan is the best interviewer and sibal is the best capable person who can answer Karan.
A good leader with well educated and clear vision
Saving democracy by defending all the money launders of the country. Now time to rush out to Calcutta !
whats his credibility
Why only parliament, look at the judiciary, it's even in a bigger mess and modi is romping over it.
Like Gogoi the ex SC judge who had the temerity to challenge anyone incl. NDTV's Srinivasan question of why he took up a position in the Rajya Sakha. We call it "Wee man syndrome" instead of the political negative term poison dwarf.
There is a HUGE segment The Wire is not reaching, for which you need ‘on ground reporting’, the likes of National Dastak, do consider a partial link up. I repeat, THE SEGMENT IS HUGE.
.सभ्यता की सारी मर्यादा तोड दी गयी इतनी नौटंकी की गयी.......सोनियाजी का कोई कसुर नहीं था....एक जमाने मे उन्होंने , पी.एम. बनने से भी ईनकार किया था....कोई भी आए और बिना वजह मांफी मांगने के लिये शोर करे, ये कैसा न्याय..?
Your views are mature bold and unbiased .wish you all the best .
Parliament is in Shambles .
I request Karan Thapar ji, to interview our CJI, justice Ramnna in near future!!! 🙏
As a ordinary people of India I want all pillar of democracy should be neutral.
The most appropriate discussion in the hour of need
Parliament can run without opposition MPs.
Keep it up!! Independent press has disappeared. 27 MPs is a controversial. India is today a semi-police state !!
Karan...your questions are valid and to the point, I appreciate, but will it have an impact on people who vote?
Great interview with good questions and equally good answers.
Beautiful interview sir 👌👌🙏👌🙏👌🙏🙏
Fearless Mr. Thapar should've asked his Father why we lost to china in 1962.... Everyone knows who you are.... It's Pity to see The Father of Zero Loss Theory, Mr. Kapil Sibal in such a helpless condition, The Supreme Court has now refused to take dictations from him.... No sermons please....
A fine job by both. If Karan would not interrupt the interviewee repeatedly it would be even better...
Dear. Karan Thapar congratulation. For having. Invited thiru.kapil sibal for have a discussion about the present functioning of the parliament
सही कहा है
Only for a chosen few people, the Parliament is dysfunctional and not for the public. As such, there is no need for any movement.
MPs of Parliament should be given their salaries and allawances should be paid as per their attendance and Work out put of the Parliament only.
Any legislation passed without discussion in the parliament can’t be called as valid legislation under rules.
It's the need of the hours to get Narendra Modi seated in an Interview before Karan Thapar. I hope Narendra Modi will be even unable to answer a single question despite being the Head of the Government. He will at that very moment abscond. Such an arrogant and dumb PM India elected to power who lacks guts to face debate even in Parliament. Then, what's the function of Parliament ?
Very true .
nowadays it is about jihad always. nothing on halala,triple talaq, hijab,forced halal, sar tan se juda. shine is wearing off.
Karan pls interview Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann MP Sangrur because he is a huge newsmaker.
FM had time to shout at Sonia Gandhi
Perhaps 80% parliamentarians may not understand your beautiful discussion##MPs need education 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Democratic public Revolution especially by farmers is only remedy to remove away the dysfunctionality....
O agree no case at the time of Investigation should be discussed but when trial is on discussions be allowed.It is the essence of democracy and Rule of Law
A very sensible and relevant interaction.
We are fast, if not already there, fast descending from being a democracy to ending up as not even an autocracy but a dictatorship.
probably with the corruption at its peak in 2014 and even now (as you see in Bengal) we needed a dictator very badly for some time to force as be honest. normally an y habit of the society takes a full generation of 20-25yrs to have a lasting impact of change
Not only the speaker but the governor, the president and even the PM of the country is not expected to work on behalf of a party for the reason they represent the entire country now having been elected to the respective posts and hence are supposed to function in a totally unbiased manner and in the interest of the country.
Why cant the concerned people from opposition setup a live conference outside the parliament and show the flaws in these bills that get passed. This will show that opposition has value to add. The only thing happens in parliament is noise and nothing else.
On today's guest and others.
Each one has a good answer and great speach to deliver everywhere. Whereas each one of these has a personal fear, greed, and ego to deal with in real prectice.
Today's guest Mr. Sibbal is no other.
Shri Kapil Sibal ji,
What ,in your opinion, are the reasons for the lack of proper debate in the parliament houses ?
Could it be because, the present opposition is devoid of speakers and competent members ?
The second issue you observed is the diminishing periods of functioning of parliament houses .
Could you clarify if it is because the opposition indulges in disruptions instead of debating ?
Is it that the opposition is falling in to a trap being laid by BJP by unwittingly indulging in disruptions ?
Then you in to quite bjp leaders who defended disruptions .
But do you think the issues that BJP was disrupting were about corruption and refusal of ruling party to allow any discussion unlike today's issues which are not national but personal line ED questioning Soniaji and Rahul baba !
Then,Shri Karan Thapar,our great Naionalist who was happy to escape to a more civilised country ,talks about revitalising the parliament .
Can you tell how many in the present opposition who can command the respect of the house lije Vajpayiji,Sushma,Pramod Mahajan and scores if others ?
About the scrutiny part, don't you think opposition hadly attends the standing committees and rarely contributes to the proposed legislations objectively .
And sending to select or standing committee delay the legislative process , as a norm .
Unfortunately, the quality of opposition is so degenerated that people have stopped expecting any thing meaningful from opposition...
Defection law !
Your a happy part of PV forming a minority govt but now you oppose the same law !
PMLA !
Can you explain to us what your objection is to the anendanent which denies bail,permits arrests without FIR and puts the onus in the accused to prove his guilt or otherwise.
You seem to be thinking that judiciary is failing the country !
Is it because courts are giving judgements in favour of Govt even if they are legally and ethically right !
And finally, you seem to be instigating people to revolt against elected Govt .
Sorry to say, this attitude if yours didn't add to your image and reputation of a man who can boldly stands up against dynasts
At this critical juncture,we need more democracy at the centre of democracy.
We need more democracy at power centre..
When journalists are independent,principled rather than partisan you actually get quality talk and healthy content like healthy food and the audience like myself is actually educated on the reality of the country on the ground and get to have healthy patriotism rather than be part of a cult!
ABSOLUTELY.......
Mr. karan thapar, raise the question why do palimenterian need all three concessions instead of the janta. they do not need any perks. their salary us enough. if they serving the country. and their pension also should be stopped.
As usual you are excellent and very nice to hear you Thaper sir and even Kapil sir.
Very very informative. Whatever little we have understood as a lay man,we certainly owe it you Mr.karan thapar
Thank you.
Such an enlightening interview!!
Sir' when public voted a person for a one ideology. He shifted to other ideology party in mid term of period for own intrest.Is it not the DHOKA to the public of that area who seleted / voted him.
We are always with neutral and intellectual media.
When half knickers made in nagpur rule the government they will remove all full pants of opposition
Absolutely 👍👍👍👍👍
Karan thapar the great journalist is interviewing the kapil sibal member of rajsabha and former senior congress leader. Discussion about what is happening in the parliament. I SALAUTE TO them. JARNAIL SINGH SIVIA
Excellent Programme. Keep it up !
Were is Anna Hazare now, pls interview him and if he says no make him . He is the one who changed everything.
Interesting. It's an eye opener. I thought we are the worst. Mean Pakistani parliament. Very unfortunate for both the countries. Addressing public issues in such a shoddy manners causes disillusionment amongst people, and this is certainly not good for democracy.
Support fearless journalism that is unafraid to ask tought questions to only right wings. They dont like to ask questions to peaceful community, congress and left ecosystem.
Greatful Sir
Our tax money spent on these MP/MLAs and they work 2 to 8% parliament time. What a shame
Good interview as all institution demoralised. Thanks both
It's natural... Some Dogs always keep Barking. They are Habituated. Weather they are Full stomach or Hungry.
🚩🇮🇳🚩
You are the best Mr. Thapar
Video is very meaningful
And pragmatic
Karan thapar ji is congratulated for realistic questions
Supreme Court itself unable to protect own c. J. I. From Pegasus remember his decision and a lady of court both were not punished while one should be
The intellectuals like your selves should encourage fearless speakers like Kanhiya Kumar ,Madam Srinate should take the lead to initiate a National Movement and Soon.
The scrutinisation of the legislative bills by the standing committee is extremely important as it would ensure the accountability of the members of the parliament