On Nagaland's Statehood Day, abridged ep 304 on the state and its story of insurgency
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- PM Modi on Friday greeted the people of Nagaland on their 61st Statehood Day. In episode 304 of #CutTheClutter, originally published on 31 October, 2019, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta discussed the geography, demographics and turning points of India's first insurgency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
I've seen many videos of people talking about the insurgency and political issues in Nagaland and Naga areas but no body talks about the atrocity done by the Indian Army since the beginning of the political movement. Thousands of Innocent villagers being killed, men being torture in front of their wife and children, women being raped, houses and villages burn down and uprooted, force labour, violations of human rights. Nobody talks about the trauma innocent Nagas have face.
Truely said...📌
AFSA ..is the main reason ....which was end ...yeah Naga's are suffered a lot ...due to political instability just like in Manipur now ....but we can do much better with peace .....
My Granny was brutally raped by 10 Indian Army soldiers.
She is at her 80's now.
She still got the trauma. She can't hear people talking Hindi as it flashes back all the memory.
We Nagas are patriotic and accepts wholeheartedly as an Indian now. But remember the scars will never be healed no matter how much we try to forget it.
SG sir, its very surprising to see a journalist of your stature and experience not mentioning grouping/ concentration of innocent civilians by indian army even in passing while narrating naga history.
True
JAPANESE METHOD IN MANCHURIA IN 1930s, same were used by Indians against Nagas
📌
Honestly, this episode didn't cover the cruelty of India Army towards the Nagas.
Therefore, i strongly disagree with this episode.
Talk about the atrocities committed by the Indian army against innocent Naga villages. Men ,women and kids as well.
Do you have an iota of knowledge how 'insurgency' (according to Indians) started? And how it got more active in political and social life of the Nagas?
The untold stories of Indian Armies atrocities to the people of Nagas is the main cause. Please note it. How can we forget the mass murder, rape, maiming on suspicion, torturing, grouping of villagers, etc by the Indian Armies? No wonder, the older folks still avoid, run away when they see the Armies till today, because they have succeded in instilling fear in us (though, not the new generation of Nagas).
The historic account of Nagas written by Kaka D. Iralu, 'The Naga Saga' was banned by the Indian Government due to the reasons best known to them. Well, we only see it as a hypocrisy.
Knowledge is power, but little knowledge is very dangerous. Therefore, all aspects need to be included in sharing such complex history.
Thank you and appreciate your coverage of the northeast. loved the details and history of Nagaland.
Thank you sir.....for the coverage!
But its only on one side of the coin??
Hope you will come through.....!
To be more precise
Ukhrul district of manipur and Phek district of nagaland share borders. People of Ukhrul can come to nagaland walking and need not do so through myanmar or the plains of manipur valley.
Many,many,many innocent Naga's were kill by the Indian army during that war
Keeping aside all the atrocities committed by indian army against the Innocent Naga population is how you script a new history?
I like shakher gupta story telling❤
He presented many things inaccurately, also never mentioned the cruelty defence force has put the local public through. The Indian Army is Racist even though they have many diff regiments, it's not in the structure of the army but in the heart of personnel.
I can guarantee that Nagaland is the only state in India where peace is prevails ..loving people ..I just love it
Talk about atrocities done to the NAGAS,. Or talk about why was there a need for NAGA FREEDOM FIGHTERS,(not insurgency).
#CutTheClutter
As an NRI, I see a lot of friends from the neighbouring countries here.
Hence, I was curious to know what could be the reasons/ what is India not doing "strategically correct" that is leading to a growing anti-India sentiment in the people of Bhutan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Maldives? (as they are very important neighbours to us)
It's what India generally had with these countries, 'The Big Brother' attitude.
Always telling various governments, about what they should or shouldn't do has lead to that sentiments.
But, it's the other way round as well. Most people in India despise Bangladeshis and consider them freeloaders and radicals.
Also, if India starts a totally business oriented approach with these 'neighbours', they are most likely to not feel pretty good about it after sometime, as all that nationalism can be for domestic posturing, but may backfire on economic, trade and security grounds.
This is hypocritic one sided narration. Journalism should be true and critical to both sides.
" Nagas have every right to be Independent", Mahatma Gandhi, 19th July, 1947.
Fact is, Nagas are forcefully integrated into Indian Union with Men killed, women raped, Villages burnt, innocent beaten to death by the operation of indian Government in 1950s. In 1963, Nagaland was created as separate State of India bifurcating Naga communities to Nagaland, Manipur, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh and Myanmar creating further complications. This is why Nagas are present all over NorthEast India. Nagas did not spread but bifurcated by Indian govt into many states.
It was brilliant. Thanks.
Suhas Nafday, MD, USA
This episode on the political development of Nagas seemed to be marred by a blatant bias in favor of the ruling government. The narrator's attempt to curry favor compromised the objectivity of the narration, resulting in a skewed perspective. The comprehensive narration lacked the necessary depth and fairness, veering towards an imprecise portrayal of events. Such one-sided storytelling not only undermines the credibility of the information but also does a disservice to the audience seeking a balanced understanding of political developments.
The entire North East was never part of 'India' and was taken by the Brits. India as usual thought of itself as the inheritor of the British Raj which is laughable. To this day, north east isn't well integrated with India and probably never will.
Those who don't know history 🤣..brother why Assam speak Assamese which is sister language of odia and bengoli ,, why Manipur majority religion is hindu ...if that wasn't a part of india ...most of nagaland taken by Myanmar .... Azad hind fouz first hosted falg on moirang 14 April 1944...😂 Laughable by you thoughts...learn history
If you ho back to old days BCE days when jejus Christ wasn't take birth,, Thailand .Myanmar ,Cambodia all are great connection with india infact Indonesia ....they all are following buddist and hindu religion ...they also read ramayan - Rama ken the state book of Thailand , even though they are buddist , Indonesia flite name is Garuda the egale in Hindu mythology , they still use Ganesh as it there money , and respect buddist and hindu god ...if you don't know history then you should learn it first ...india has a strong cultural hold on these state ... brother ...bekakoof dusro ko banao jo gadha hai hum jayse padhe likhe indian ko nahi ,,and mai ye bhi janta hun Naga's ek folk religion tha usko Christian missionaries ne ake khatam kiya ....it's ok believe and religion is your personal choice but ye thodi na ho sakta hai ki past ko galt boldo😂
@@Mbbs-bb6zz why many Indian dialects and customs come from central Asia and Persia? Why Hinduism is a vedic culture artifact which itself comes from central Asia?
@@Mbbs-bb6zz you confuse 'connection' and cultural exchanges with ownership.
@@Jkl62200 Hinduism don't comes from central asia ,, it's born in indus valley civilization 5000 years ago 😂 go read mate .... They are called meluha by Persian and Mesopotamian ,, they invented use of copper and iron and the pasupati seal of majhenjodaro ànd dancing girl seal fier alter all are evidence
Independence to nagalaim
Sir,kukizo demand for separation administration remains legit provided under constitution. As a citizen of this democratic country every lives matter "equality of life" , rights to religion, education, property.
Honestly, the influence of the Nagas on the rest of North Eastern people has been positive as well as negative. IMO, I saw that being proud of our own identity was very important. But that came with a lot of chauvinism and disregard towards other communities.
They're a fun-loving bunch of people but then again we you get close to them they're riddled with hedonism and some derived it without respect for others' boundaries.
They were the most extravagant people and always a standard above the rest of us. Until we realised where the funding and exposure were coming from. The poor condition of infrastructure in their state and self-funding out of government allocations. And I'm speaking of the 1990s & 2000s yet even in 2023 it isn't much different when it comes to public infrastructure.
I've seen many people ruin their lives "trying to keep up with the Jones". Over time they became a burden everywhere they went and a stereotype most want to disassociate from. Even themselves.
Overall, it is high time that the insurgency and extortionist behaviour is ridiculed in Nagaland. This promoted a generation to live a lifestyle of hooligans and bullies without consequences. They paved the way for tribalism among youths instead of camaraderie and fraternity.
The youths of Manipur are also similar. That toxic nature led to the on-going issue in Manipur.
Please enlighten me on how the NAGA FREEDOM fighters or (insurgency as u would put) led to tribalism
Guptaji how can you blame army and intelligence for infighting, when their was head hunting between tribes as late as 1986.
Why GOI is so reluctant to solve the naga political issue. People are fed up of the rebel as well as the GOI. Things may get worse because of people's frustrations
It's disappointing that you didn't do single CTC on Mizoram election
It will come today babu , let the complete result come in
Its General zuheto not Aheto who surrender
You have already told that story before also ....
Loved the monologue.
Another Twisted story on its own way.
Through those peace makers and intelligences agent they were able to break the unity it was well played.......or else it would have been a different story altogether.............
Happy hornbill festival
Zuheto not Aheto
Many talks abt Nagas bt nt really understand Nagas by those talkatives. 😁😁 They only trying to confused.
Dude you have called people of tirap Nagas but they have moved to the supreme court to expel naga word from their ST Certificates and they do not want to be recognised as Other Nagas. And tirap dist does not share borders with nagaland Longding dist does. I am from Lohit dist 👍
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Kuknalim🫡
Very one sided story of yours sir. Truth must be told!
Please don't count the ones in manipur, they're not counted😂😂 they are kacha😂😂
Third class journalism.