Only an honorable mention for Firth of Fifth. Insanity. My favourite song ever. Every section is incredible and it has the finest guitar solo ever performed. Nad you must know how this solo established Steve Hackett amongst the pantheon of all musicians.
My brother and I did a challenge on coming up with the ultimate Genesis double CD , with a maximum of 24 tracks ( 12 per CD ) . We also had to work within the time constraints of a CD . We allowed a couple of segues to count as 1 track . ( like Fly on a Windshield segueing into Broadway Melody ). This was my selection : CD 1 : The Light Dies Down on Broadway Squonk Dancing With the Moonlit Night Blood on the Rooftops Anyway ...In That Quiet Earth Get 'Em Out by Friday The Lamia Can-Utility and the Coastliners Return of the Giant Hogweed ( Live version from the Live album ) Undertow The Cinema Show / Aisle of Plenty CD 2 : Watcher of the Skies Burning Rope Firth of Fifth Mad Man Moon Time Table One for the Vine Ripples Behind the Lines Guide Vocal Seven Stones Afterglow In The Rapids / It
That was really fun guys! 👏👏 I love Nad Sylvan and his work on the Genesis Revisited tours. I was surprised that Firth of Fifth missed the album and that Snowbound made it. Although I have come to really like Snowbound over the years (especially after discovering its macabre meaning juxtaposed with the beautiful music) it just doesn't beat Firth of Fifth for me. ❤
Glad so so happy that I’ve been made aware of this vocalists and some all ways was Peter Gabriel fan last time I saw Rainbow Finsbury Park N London 1973 October I think visually fantastic and the sound where have I been jezzsaidscrists give it up the One and Only Nad Sylvan🎶🎶🎶
You gotta have dancing with the moonlit knight and the entire duke suite come on now. Also Nad seems like a gentle sweet and interesting guy enjoyed listening to him.
If we're talking strictly pre-Lamb, Nursery Cryme through Selling England alone would already yield three obvious essentials per album: The Musical Box The Return of the Giant Hogweed The Fountain of Salmacis Watcher of the Skies Can-Utilty and the Coastliners Supper's Ready Dancing with the Moonlit Knight Firth of Fifth The Cinema Show If you wanted to top it off with one more pre-Lamb track to make it a top-10, you gotta include at least one from Trespass, which obviously would have to be The Knife (perhaps also include Looking for Someone, and Stagnation, if you want the top-12). Now add the entire Lamb album as your bonus track, and then you're in business!! 😜👍
And Then There Were Three has come a long way. Burning Rope and Many Too Many crop up on the David Myers CDs and leaves me thinking where does that tune come from? Oh, it's from the stuff after W&W I didn't bother with. Excellent album. 33:13 great question for Nad. I think my favorites are Supper's Ready The Battle of Epping Forest Fly on a Windshield / Broadway Melody of 1974 Colony of Slippermen The Musical Box Anyway (or The Lamia on Wednesdays) White Mountain The Fountain of Salmacis Robbery, Assault and Battery One for the Vine
Nobody chose "The Lamia" or "Dusk" or "Stagnation" from "Trespass". There are really so many to choose from...but I'm not a fan of "And Then There Were Three", I've even gone back and listened to it lately, it sounds contrived and stiff with Rutherford assuming guitar duties, they were floundering without Hackett.
Both my 9 y.o and 6 y.o absolutely love Supper's ready, and my oldest likes Nad better than Peter Gabriel :) He was actually very surprised (as was I) to hear Nad sings on Icarus ascending, a fantastic rendition of Richie Haven's tone and singing.
I enjoyed the discussion very much, thank you, especially hearing from Nad. I agree with only a few of your selections though. Nad’s selections were the best. Maybe I missed it, but surely Blood on the Rooftops was not omitted.
Nad is a phenominal singer (better than Gabriel in my opinion). How he learns all of the complex Genesis lyrics is amazing & beyond my comprehension! Would love to hear how he does that.
I'm sorry...Please Don't Ask, Snowbound, Mad Man Moon, really??? All good songs, but ultimate Genesis??? My twelve (in this order for optimal flow) would be: Watcher of The Skies, Dancing With Moonlight Knight, I Know What I Like, The Lamb, Counting Out Time, Carpet Crawlers, Firth Of Fifth, Dance On A Volcano, Down And Out, No Reply At All, Supper's Ready, and The Musical Box
Only an honorable mention for Firth of Fifth. Insanity. My favourite song ever. Every section is incredible and it has the finest guitar solo ever performed. Nad you must know how this solo established Steve Hackett amongst the pantheon of all musicians.
One of these days “...In That Quiet Earth” will get the love it deserves! Awesome insight from Nad and the gang. Please keep these coming!
That would definitely be the Genesis track with my all-time favorite analog synth solo by Mr. Banks!!
ua-cam.com/video/nsDagicUoDo/v-deo.html
Mad Man Moon. Such a stunning gorgeous expansive tune.
Nad - so glad you mentioned Visions of Angels.
My brother and I did a challenge on coming up with the ultimate Genesis double CD , with a maximum of 24 tracks ( 12 per CD ) . We also had to work within the time constraints of a CD . We allowed a couple of segues to count as 1 track . ( like Fly on a Windshield segueing into Broadway Melody ).
This was my selection :
CD 1 : The Light Dies Down on Broadway
Squonk
Dancing With the Moonlit Night
Blood on the Rooftops
Anyway
...In That Quiet Earth
Get 'Em Out by Friday
The Lamia
Can-Utility and the Coastliners
Return of the Giant Hogweed ( Live version from the Live album )
Undertow
The Cinema Show / Aisle of Plenty
CD 2 : Watcher of the Skies
Burning Rope
Firth of Fifth
Mad Man Moon
Time Table
One for the Vine
Ripples
Behind the Lines
Guide Vocal
Seven Stones
Afterglow
In The Rapids / It
Thanks guys - a great Ultimate Genesis album (a few surprises!). Looking forward to getting my copy of Spiritus Mundi 🌝
Love Nad's contribution to Noisy Diners! Can't wait for the CD release.
Love you Nad!! A great year is ahead!
That was really fun guys! 👏👏
I love Nad Sylvan and his work on the Genesis Revisited tours. I was surprised that Firth of Fifth missed the album and that Snowbound made it. Although I have come to really like Snowbound over the years (especially after discovering its macabre meaning juxtaposed with the beautiful music) it just doesn't beat Firth of Fifth for me. ❤
This was so wonderful!
Glad so so happy that I’ve been made aware of this vocalists and some all ways was Peter Gabriel fan last time I saw Rainbow Finsbury Park N London 1973 October I think visually fantastic and the sound where have I been jezzsaidscrists give it up the One and Only Nad Sylvan🎶🎶🎶
Need to check out Nad’s new album!
I can’t be the only one who is hearing that constant beeping sound.
Yeah it's there a bit in the first 10 minutes. It goes away.
NAAAAAAD!!!!
Please Don’t Ask is an amazing song!!
Very nice double album there.
You gotta have dancing with the moonlit knight and the entire duke suite come on now. Also Nad seems like a gentle sweet and interesting guy enjoyed listening to him.
If we're talking strictly pre-Lamb, Nursery Cryme through Selling England alone would already yield three obvious essentials per album:
The Musical Box
The Return of the Giant Hogweed
The Fountain of Salmacis
Watcher of the Skies
Can-Utilty and the Coastliners
Supper's Ready
Dancing with the Moonlit Knight
Firth of Fifth
The Cinema Show
If you wanted to top it off with one more pre-Lamb track to make it a top-10, you gotta include at least one from Trespass, which obviously would have to be The Knife (perhaps also include Looking for Someone, and Stagnation, if you want the top-12).
Now add the entire Lamb album as your bonus track, and then you're in business!! 😜👍
Blood on the rooftops!!
Nad!!!
And Then There Were Three has come a long way. Burning Rope and Many Too Many crop up on the David Myers CDs and leaves me thinking where does that tune come from? Oh, it's from the stuff after W&W I didn't bother with. Excellent album.
33:13 great question for Nad.
I think my favorites are
Supper's Ready
The Battle of Epping Forest
Fly on a Windshield / Broadway Melody of 1974
Colony of Slippermen
The Musical Box
Anyway (or The Lamia on Wednesdays)
White Mountain
The Fountain of Salmacis
Robbery, Assault and Battery
One for the Vine
Nobody chose "The Lamia" or "Dusk" or "Stagnation" from "Trespass". There are really so many to choose from...but I'm not a fan of "And Then There Were Three", I've even gone back and listened to it lately, it sounds contrived and stiff with Rutherford assuming guitar duties, they were floundering without Hackett.
Both my 9 y.o and 6 y.o absolutely love Supper's ready, and my oldest likes Nad better than Peter Gabriel :) He was actually very surprised (as was I) to hear Nad sings on Icarus ascending, a fantastic rendition of Richie Haven's tone and singing.
I enjoyed the discussion very much, thank you, especially hearing from Nad. I agree with only a few of your selections though. Nad’s selections were the best. Maybe I missed it, but surely Blood on the Rooftops was not omitted.
Can someone tell me what the intro music to the PR Podcast is? I've been wondering for two years now.
Mindwalk Blvd - “Art Crime”
ua-cam.com/video/-cBDCiE6I2o/v-deo.html
Beep
Nad is a phenominal singer (better than Gabriel in my opinion). How he learns all of the complex Genesis lyrics is amazing & beyond my comprehension! Would love to hear how he does that.
I'm sorry...Please Don't Ask, Snowbound, Mad Man Moon, really??? All good songs, but ultimate Genesis???
My twelve (in this order for optimal flow) would be: Watcher of The Skies, Dancing With Moonlight Knight, I Know What I Like, The Lamb, Counting Out Time, Carpet Crawlers, Firth Of Fifth, Dance On A Volcano, Down And Out, No Reply At All, Supper's Ready, and The Musical Box
Down And Out ? Really ? No Reply At All ??? REALLY ???????
@@glerp10000000000 Down And Out is not that bad... but I'm really sorry for you, because you got no reply at all (from Jeffrey) 🤣