Hi srj19901! I agree that Jackson is truly moving in this song, and when the chorus comes in, it swells and takes you with it like an ocean wave. It is always interesting to me, though, to hear a voice that gets as raspy as he is sounding here and still feel the message as we do. He may even have some vocal damage going on unless he had a bad cold - - I've only ever read him sing in this. Because the style can endure being gritty, however, it works, and probably better than if it were purely clean. It is most inspiring. I hope you keep your Kleenex next to your TV!
DayleSong oh, that definitely happened. In one interview he gave he said it took two years to vocally heal from his run of the show, which completely makes sense cause singing this way 8 shows a week for a year + or so must take a tool on one’s vocal cords! Considering this, they recorded the movie in 2016 (almost a year and a half after the off-broadway production opened). It was just before Phillipa Soo and Lin left their run... so the OBC was already leaving by then. The end of an era, that’s for sure.
*”Gospel is so down-to-earth even though they sing about the heavens!”* So profound. Please do Aaron Burr! Also, every time I hear “one last time,” I think of Ariana’s song first... 😂
Haha, Lindsey Squire! Clever allusion! Agreed! I hope we see a lot more of Jackson going forward. It's so refreshing to see someone so honestly connected in his work!
DayleSong jeez that’s a hard question... I think probably Room where it happens. It’s such a turning point in the show. Leslie Odom Jr. does such an amazing job it always catches me fully in the moment.
"Talk Less" is also a play on the suggestion that Burr makes to Hamilton during their introduction "Talk Less, Smile More". Burr uses "Smile More" in his wedding congrats to Hamilton, and Hamilton uses the whole phrase again in "The Room where it happens" while speaking to Burr.
Hi Nikki B! Yes, exactly. Well noted. This supports the observation I make in my Helpless-Burn video that Miranda repeats key words and phrases to hit on multiple meanings throughout the show. It's a good tactic, especially when there are so very many words to catch, that you catch important bits like that.
@@DayleSong Wow! Thank you for replying. I love discovering new things about the show. I watched all of the Hamilton videos you posted so far, and I really enjoyed your knowledge and insight. I look forward to more to come!
I love your reactions, Dayle! You should definitely do "It's Quiet Uptown". It's such an emotional gut punch. I think it's definitely another turning point in the story, where Alexander realizes that his actions do have consequences, and prices that he couldn't imagine paying.
Hi Taryn. This is an astute observation and one worth looking at. It spurs on ideas for me. It's Quite Uptown is definitely a poignant moment in the show and striking in its silence within a "noisy" score! (I say that affectionately, of course!)
Honestly Christopher Jackson makes a great George Washington and he has an amazing voice it gives me chills everytime and Lin’s voice is great too they are great friends, if you want to hear of Lin singing you should listen to found/tonight or cheering for me now
I've watched this channel a few times to see your reactions to the other Hamilton songs, but I greatly enjoyed this video as "One Last Time" is my favorite song, mainly because of the passion Christopher Jackson puts into it with every live performance I've seen of it. I'm happy to say as someone who loves watching ppl analyze the music in Hamilton that you pointing out that the song becomes a gospel towards the end is intriguing as in the show, each character raps or sings in a particular style that emphasizes that character's personality. In Washington's case, when he raps/sings, he doesn't play around with the beat and has a strict on beat cadence which reflects his militaristic mindset. However, "One Last Time" is where we see Washington give his final words and release all of his feelings being the head of the state off his chest, for a lack of better words. In the beginning, he keeps to his militaristic singing until his address is given, and I believe that right there is the turning point where Washington finally gets the chance to feel like the citizen he wants to be instead of the war veteran turned President. The ending is Washington's liberation from serving his country and his overwhelming joy of finally being released from leading the country. The adlibs, particularly Jackson's belt of "time" at the very end, also helps solidify the feeling of Washington finally having the opportunity to sigh and relax. All in all, loved the video, and thank you for shining a new nugget of analysis about Hamilton on me today! :)
I loved this song on the OBC album, but when I saw the staging for the first time, I cried. Watching the entire company, gathered in their family units, dressed in their finest and most formal clothing, to pay somber homage to the first and greatest American, touched me so very deeply.
Thank you for sharing your experience, Emily! I find the gospel basis of the music moving, too, especially when the chorus joins in. It all adds up to a very tender moment and humanizes our forefathers.
Hi QuietStar silence! Burr is definitely my next focus. The election scene would definitely be an interesting analysis of plot, charactes and voices! Great suggestion.
@@DayleSong burr's face in during the election gets me every time. But honestly burr is such an interesting charecter. The changes in him are so tangible. From being so reserved and private to openly campaigning
Another great analysis. Even though I have watched this scene multiple times I never knew why Hamilton was talking at the same time Washington was singing the goodbye speech. I just thought it was for dramatic effect. It makes so much sense now since it’s believed Hamilton wrote Washington’s goodbye speech. Can’t wait for your next Hamilton reaction.
Hi B. Patterson! Nice hearing from you again. I'm glad you gained some insight from my talk! Hamilton is rich with detail and for all the elements that may not be exactly historical--in order to facilitate the theater of the story--there is a lot of history to glean from it. And that informs how it would be directed and played. Glad you're looking forward to the next one already! Thanks!
Another thing that I notice is that Hamilton starts reading the letter, since supposedly they were his words. As Washington stars singing them, people go forward kind of to represent how for us they're Washington's words, when supposedly, they were Washigton's thoughts wiith Hamilton's words
Haha! Indeed, Dominique! I do get caught up in the story quite a bit, but that is where everything begins. How we approach character and our singing the songs must come from a deep understanding of the material, which is really only the road map, but without it, we don't do the work service. People have suggested I react to First Burn for which I can give more attention to the voices and performances, and I'm excited to do so.
Fantastic review! New sub. Thank you for knowing/ researching what you are taking about! Thanks for explaining nuances often missed ( gospel style)! Thank you for having your video volume & mic volume in sync! As Lin said, this is the most well rehearsed movie cast ever, having performed 400+ shows before the pro-shot was made! I have always respected GW for stepping down & setting that precedent for the new country. Can you imagine 45 yrs of service! I would highly suggest Wait For It (giving insight into Burrs motivation it lack there of)or Non-Stop (highlights Hamilton’s motivation). Take a Break has fabulous harmonies & Its Quiet Uptown is gut wrenching as consequences play out. Renee G has experienced the loss of a child & her voice is so real & raw in that song, it moves me to tears every time! Keep Hamilton coming!! Lin also said in an interview that he gave the best singing parts to his castmates as he prefers rap.
Your videos are interesting to watch. Also, I don't know if you just ommited that by accident, but with the musical themes Lin-Manuel Miranda gave the main characters, he gave themes to sections of the narative too. In "one last time" when the chorus start singing they are using the exact musical theme for the arrival of Thomas Jefferson - Thomas Jefferson's coming home...
This song bought the entire audience to their feet when I saw Hamilton. Chris Jackson is an Amazing performer. I will never forget this moment as long as I live♥️
Thank you for sharing that special moment in the theater. There's nothing like a live performance, and I'm sure it was electric! They stay with you forever and the memories continue to thrill us. Thanks for watching!
It's kinda funny how amazing all these performers are. The actors are outstanding, the dancers are outstanding, everyone is living their role and delivering with their whole soul. Then you have Lin who arguable is the least strongest but definitely doing the same. But even standing next to all those people he still holds his own, and when you remember that he wrote everything, which I guess gives him a little wiggle room lol.
A few historical notes, Hamilton made lieutenant colonel, never was a general. Most of his combat experience was company/battery grade command in the field artillery. However, his command at Yorktown was over an infantry battalion. He however as you note spent most of his time on Washington's staff, which while not particularly glorious is to this day an incredibly important role. In terms of the president's address, the reality is they are Hamilton's words and Washington's words. The reality is that president's rarely write their own speeches or addresses, but, they are involved. Presumably a cover page written by the president which includes key points that must be hit would be a highly effective manner to deal with this. It is also super important for the president's speech writing team to be very keen on the president's beliefs and interests. All addresses would of course be subject to review by the president, and if he feels the need to revise he obviously can and likely does.
Thank you, Adam! I must have misread about him being Lt. Col. and not a general. I really have no idea about military ranks and functions, so my apologies for that. What was most important for me to note was that they had a long-established and close association that was also professional. It is very true about presidents and their speech writers. Obama's speech writer actually gets interviewed on the radio very often now! Not many if any have a public face. I know Nixon largely wrote his own speeches and is considered a speech-writing genius, but that is rare or perhaps unique. Thanks for the detailed insight! One of these days I'll read Chernow's bio of Hamilton!
@@DayleSong Awesome, and just to clarify I was not attempting to be insulting or anything like that. I just think it's good to share our knowledge so we can all learn together. Your analysis of the scene was great, I especially enjoyed how you note the different levels of storytelling going on between the actors.
@@Artill3rybby No insult taken! I love sharing info in the chats and learning more from comments. And definitely, correcting the errata is welcome. Thanks for taking the time to write in. Keep it coming!
@@Artill3rybby There is a citation (in the wiki article on Alexander Hamilton) that Hamilton was made a Major General during the Quasi-War of 1798-1800. Though I should note that this rank was appointed to him while he served in the United States Army. So I would surmise that the highest rank he achieved in the Continental Army was Lt. Colonel.
Lol, psychobetha! There's also Vampires from the same publisher up there. 'Tis the season! I see that it's prominent and was wondering if someone would point it out. I'm glad you did! And thank you for enjoying the video.
I love this scene. This is probably my favorite moment in history as well when George Washington-great man- did maybe one of the greatest things anyone's done. He stepped down. Hamilton was right when he said he could have continued. He could easily have turned it into a sort of monarchy and he didn't, and this scene captures it- and overall the musical shows his wonderful. It's moving and just phenomal overall. I love the actor and I love what he did with the role.
Lin Manuel Miranda is more than an actor, more than a singer, he really is a genius musician and writer, Broadway will never be the same after Hamilton and history has its eyes on him.
This song is soooo relevant today. People in power who are still so thirsty for more power. You see it in most countries. Disgusts me, honestly. Great insights! Love this song, always tears me up. How about reacting to Dear Evan Hansen? I love Waving Through a Window ❤️
I agree, Chellikot! Theater often reflects the socio-political climate of its day, and Hamilton is a shining example, especially in that Miranda uses a contemporary filter to represent an historical time. Corruption is disgusting and disheartening, and all the more we must be on top of it and write shows to inspire peace and prosperity. How amazing that we had a Washington with all his caring and insight to start us off. What I did not realize until reading more about the historical moment of One Last Time was how heated and factioned politics became so early on. Yes, I knew there was disagreement and fighting in Congress, but since Washington has this shining reputation, it seemed that the executive branch might have had more concordance for awhile. Naive, perhaps, to think that. But that's what I love about such a show like this. It brings history into a 3-dimensional perspective that we were not taught in school. Dear Evan Hansen is a great suggestion--another show that goes into depth about the human condition. I'm on this Hamilton kick for now, but I'll keep that in mind!
Hi love your channel! I know that this is an underrated song in the musical but I would love an analysis of “Washington on Your Side”. I don’t know why I love it so much but it’s constantly on repeat for me.
I loved how Hamilton fades into Washington so seamlessly. And the contrast between how they deliver the speech. Hamilton writes the words and delivers it straightforward and without much melody, similar to the rap/spoken word he has used for most of the rest of the play. This spoken word delivery may represent how he still does not fully understand why Washington is resigning. The tone he delivers it in is also melancholy and sad, reflecting how he himself feels about Washington resigning. In contrast, Washington’s delivery of his farewell address is more melodic and emotional, reflecting how he is more expressive with his joyful emotions than Hamilton (who for the majority of this play has always been singing/writing/fighting against someone), and his tone shows how he himself knows the good his resignation will bring for America, as well as how he is deserving of a break after so many years of service, being proud of both himself for accomplishing such an impossible feat and everyone in America who has worked fought under him to make it possible.
There’s a performance of this song in Kennedy Center when the cast of Hamilton was paying homage to their creators and there’s literally a choir that comes forward to sing (instead of the ensemble) and it’s one of the most beautiful performances I’ve ever seen! You should check that out if you haven’t yet. ua-cam.com/video/4wYwA2LRShQ/v-deo.html
Another great review! This might be my favorite scene from the show. It's a least the most profound; conveying both why Washington is so revered and what makes this country so unique at a visceral level that books and classes can't quite pull off. I still get chills every time the chorus comes in with "George Washington's going home". Would like see your take on "Say no to this"?
Thank you, delcapslock100! This scene stands out for me, too. Miranda pays great tribute to both men's legacies with this exchange. You get a real sense of greatness at work that cannot be conveyed by mere facts. Once again, we are put in the room where it happens! I'll take a look at Say No to This. That one is not widely requested. Is that another one of your favorite moments?
@@DayleSong Yes I do like that one, in part for the sheer musicality of it but also how perfectly it captures the power of sexual allure, as one of the greatest minds in American history has his reputation and family all but destroyed by a pair of two-bit con artists (per Chernow's book). And Jasmine Jones' nails the role on every level with her amazing voice and as femme fatale with the steamy interplay with Miranda.
@@delcapslock100 Nice. I have yet to read Chernow's book, but the musical takes that stance. Jasmine is great in that role, too. I'll take a look-see to consider a review. Thanks for this!
I hope you do more of the songs regarding hamilton's relationship with Angelica and Eliza, I would love to see your thoughts and comparisons on their interactions. That being said, I hope you give First Burn a listen to! Great analysis as always!
Thanks for the idea, Claire. That would be good fodder for focusing in on Hamilton, which would take multiple analyses! First Burn has been suggested, and I'm very curious about it, so hang in there! I'm sure I'll react to it soon.
@@DayleSong Looking forward to it, Dayle! Take a Break would also be great but I'm sure you get enough requests as it is. Thank you for taking the time to respond~
@@percyptuous All recommendations are welcome, Claire! I can't get to all of them, certainly, but both popular votes and ideas that pique my interest rise to the top of my selection process. I'll look into Take a Break for sure. Keep 'em coming! And thanks! 😊
That isn't *quite* true RE parties. It's true that there weren't organized parties like we think of them today, but there was a clear divide starting (at least) with the fight to replace the Articles of Confederation with the new Constitution. At that time, it was the Federalists vs the Anti-Federalists.
the final half of the song is also the last 2 paragraphs of George Washington's Farewell address, sans a few lines (I'll outline in brackets the removed sections) Though, in reviewing the incidents of my administration, I am unconscious of intentional error, I am nevertheless too sensible of my defects not to think it probable that I may have committed many errors. [ _Whatever they may be, I fervently beseech the Almighty to avert or mitigate the evils to which they may tend._ ] I shall also carry with me the hope that my country will never cease to view them with indulgence; and that, after forty five years of my life dedicated to its service with an upright zeal, the faults of incompetent abilities will be consigned to oblivion, as myself must soon be to the mansions of rest. [ _Relying on its kindness in this as in other things, and actuated by that fervent love towards it ,_ _which is so natural to a man who views in it the native soil of himself and his progenitors for several generations,_ ] I anticipate with pleasing expectation that retreat in which I promise myself to realize, [ _without alloy,_ ] the sweet enjoyment of partaking, in the midst of my fellow-citizens, the benign influence of good laws under a free government, the ever-favorite object of my heart, and the happy reward, as I trust, of our mutual cares, labors, and dangers. _George Washington_ _United States_ _19th September, 1796_
Thanks, Kentaurus! How interesting to read the unexpurgated paragraphs. Thanks for that. The sections removed certainly aren't as lyrical or colloquial as the ones chosen.
Hi Onlylexy! I highly recommend Hamilton. It's a cultural phenomenon! But don't cry, I haven't forgotten about Chloe x Halle! They are one of the next videos on my non-musical song list. My progress has been slow this summer, but I will pick up speed! 😊
Hi Superman 74, This is not a first watching. I've seen the Hamifilm and did some research to highlight points I want to discuss in the various sections. I hope you're enjoying them. The vocal coach videos are first watch.
@@DayleSong Cool thanks for the response. I've never been into music theater but I have seen (and loved) Rent in the past. Hamilton, in my inexperienced opinion, is Amazing, and worth every penny I spent to go see it live. I can't wait for in The Heights!
You Yes, Hamilton is a different brand of musical theater altogether and it is amazing, I find, especially as I peel away a few layers. In the Heights will be another superevent for sure! I'll have stuff on that, too, when it comes out. Thanks for writing in!
DayleSong yup! She wrote it during quarantine and it really resonated with me. Btw thanks for taking the time to respond to comments and I really like your channel! I thought I was already subscribed but I guess I wasn’t. (Don’t worry I fixed that lol) anyway keep up the good work!
It doesn't matter how many times I watch it, it will make me cry. Chris Jackson has one of the most beautiful voices I've ever heard, I swear to God.
Hi srj19901! I agree that Jackson is truly moving in this song, and when the chorus comes in, it swells and takes you with it like an ocean wave. It is always interesting to me, though, to hear a voice that gets as raspy as he is sounding here and still feel the message as we do. He may even have some vocal damage going on unless he had a bad cold - - I've only ever read him sing in this. Because the style can endure being gritty, however, it works, and probably better than if it were purely clean. It is most inspiring. I hope you keep your Kleenex next to your TV!
DayleSong oh, that definitely happened. In one interview he gave he said it took two years to vocally heal from his run of the show, which completely makes sense cause singing this way 8 shows a week for a year + or so must take a tool on one’s vocal cords! Considering this, they recorded the movie in 2016 (almost a year and a half after the off-broadway production opened). It was just before Phillipa Soo and Lin left their run... so the OBC was already leaving by then. The end of an era, that’s for sure.
*”Gospel is so down-to-earth even though they sing about the heavens!”*
So profound. Please do Aaron Burr! Also, every time I hear “one last time,” I think of Ariana’s song first... 😂
I know you love you your Ariana! Yes, Aaron Burr will be next!
Nicholas Cage was looking for the wrong national treasure. Turns out it was Chris Jackson the whole time.
Haha, Lindsey Squire! Clever allusion! Agreed! I hope we see a lot more of Jackson going forward. It's so refreshing to see someone so honestly connected in his work!
I get shivers when I hear George Washington's parts. A beautiful, velvety voice that hits me right in the tearfactory
I can’t wait for more!! Hopefully Room where it Happens or Wait for It is next!!
Hi Nicole.Thank you! Which song is your favorite among the two?
Yes please either or both!
@@kellydavis1837 Thanks for voting, Kelly! It helps direct my work.
DayleSong jeez that’s a hard question... I think probably Room where it happens. It’s such a turning point in the show. Leslie Odom Jr. does such an amazing job it always catches me fully in the moment.
YESSS
"Talk Less" is also a play on the suggestion that Burr makes to Hamilton during their introduction "Talk Less, Smile More". Burr uses "Smile More" in his wedding congrats to Hamilton, and Hamilton uses the whole phrase again in "The Room where it happens" while speaking to Burr.
Hi Nikki B! Yes, exactly. Well noted. This supports the observation I make in my Helpless-Burn video that Miranda repeats key words and phrases to hit on multiple meanings throughout the show. It's a good tactic, especially when there are so very many words to catch, that you catch important bits like that.
@@DayleSong Wow! Thank you for replying. I love discovering new things about the show. I watched all of the Hamilton videos you posted so far, and I really enjoyed your knowledge and insight. I look forward to more to come!
I love your reactions, Dayle! You should definitely do "It's Quiet Uptown". It's such an emotional gut punch. I think it's definitely another turning point in the story, where Alexander realizes that his actions do have consequences, and prices that he couldn't imagine paying.
Hi Taryn. This is an astute observation and one worth looking at. It spurs on ideas for me. It's Quite Uptown is definitely a poignant moment in the show and striking in its silence within a "noisy" score! (I say that affectionately, of course!)
Would love to hear your review of “Take A Break” and “Nonstop”! Theres so much story being told in both songs and you’re so insightful! Thank you
Thanks for the compliment, Jen M! I'll consider those. I'm not as familiar with them offhand. I love a good song that tells the story!
Non stop !! Yes honestly my favorite at least I think 🤣
Honestly Christopher Jackson makes a great George Washington and he has an amazing voice it gives me chills everytime and Lin’s voice is great too they are great friends, if you want to hear of Lin singing you should listen to found/tonight or cheering for me now
I've watched this channel a few times to see your reactions to the other Hamilton songs, but I greatly enjoyed this video as "One Last Time" is my favorite song, mainly because of the passion Christopher Jackson puts into it with every live performance I've seen of it. I'm happy to say as someone who loves watching ppl analyze the music in Hamilton that you pointing out that the song becomes a gospel towards the end is intriguing as in the show, each character raps or sings in a particular style that emphasizes that character's personality. In Washington's case, when he raps/sings, he doesn't play around with the beat and has a strict on beat cadence which reflects his militaristic mindset. However, "One Last Time" is where we see Washington give his final words and release all of his feelings being the head of the state off his chest, for a lack of better words. In the beginning, he keeps to his militaristic singing until his address is given, and I believe that right there is the turning point where Washington finally gets the chance to feel like the citizen he wants to be instead of the war veteran turned President. The ending is Washington's liberation from serving his country and his overwhelming joy of finally being released from leading the country. The adlibs, particularly Jackson's belt of "time" at the very end, also helps solidify the feeling of Washington finally having the opportunity to sigh and relax.
All in all, loved the video, and thank you for shining a new nugget of analysis about Hamilton on me today! :)
I loved this song on the OBC album, but when I saw the staging for the first time, I cried. Watching the entire company, gathered in their family units, dressed in their finest and most formal clothing, to pay somber homage to the first and greatest American, touched me so very deeply.
Thank you for sharing your experience, Emily! I find the gospel basis of the music moving, too, especially when the chorus joins in. It all adds up to a very tender moment and humanizes our forefathers.
I would love to see you review Wait for it or the election of 1800. Leslie's acting in both are absolutely amazing
Hi QuietStar silence! Burr is definitely my next focus. The election scene would definitely be an interesting analysis of plot, charactes and voices! Great suggestion.
@@DayleSong burr's face in during the election gets me every time. But honestly burr is such an interesting charecter. The changes in him are so tangible. From being so reserved and private to openly campaigning
Another great analysis. Even though I have watched this scene multiple times I never knew why Hamilton was talking at the same time Washington was singing the goodbye speech. I just thought it was for dramatic effect. It makes so much sense now since it’s believed Hamilton wrote Washington’s goodbye speech. Can’t wait for your next Hamilton reaction.
Hi B. Patterson! Nice hearing from you again. I'm glad you gained some insight from my talk! Hamilton is rich with detail and for all the elements that may not be exactly historical--in order to facilitate the theater of the story--there is a lot of history to glean from it. And that informs how it would be directed and played. Glad you're looking forward to the next one already! Thanks!
Another thing that I notice is that Hamilton starts reading the letter, since supposedly they were his words. As Washington stars singing them, people go forward kind of to represent how for us they're Washington's words, when supposedly, they were Washigton's thoughts wiith Hamilton's words
Washington starts to sing in a gospel fashion. Is: We call that ‘Taking it to church.’ 😁
Im sure you've already got tons of requests for it but I'd love to see your breakdown of Wait For It from Aaron Burr.
Thanks, Noel! I have received a ton of requests for Wait for It, but every vote counts to drive my content. I will look at that one next.
This should be called historian reacts to one last time.
Haha! Indeed, Dominique! I do get caught up in the story quite a bit, but that is where everything begins. How we approach character and our singing the songs must come from a deep understanding of the material, which is really only the road map, but without it, we don't do the work service. People have suggested I react to First Burn for which I can give more attention to the voices and performances, and I'm excited to do so.
Fantastic review! New sub. Thank you for knowing/ researching what you are taking about! Thanks for explaining nuances often missed ( gospel style)! Thank you for having your video volume & mic volume in sync! As Lin said, this is the most well rehearsed movie cast ever, having performed 400+ shows before the pro-shot was made! I have always respected GW for stepping down & setting that precedent for the new country. Can you imagine 45 yrs of service! I would highly suggest Wait For It (giving insight into Burrs motivation it lack there of)or Non-Stop (highlights Hamilton’s motivation). Take a Break has fabulous harmonies & Its Quiet Uptown is gut wrenching as consequences play out. Renee G has experienced the loss of a child & her voice is so real & raw in that song, it moves me to tears every time! Keep Hamilton coming!! Lin also said in an interview that he gave the best singing parts to his castmates as he prefers rap.
Your videos are interesting to watch.
Also, I don't know if you just ommited that by accident, but with the musical themes Lin-Manuel Miranda gave the main characters, he gave themes to sections of the narative too. In "one last time" when the chorus start singing they are using the exact musical theme for the arrival of Thomas Jefferson - Thomas Jefferson's coming home...
This song bought the entire audience to their feet when I saw Hamilton. Chris Jackson is an Amazing performer. I will never forget this moment as long as I live♥️
Thank you for sharing that special moment in the theater. There's nothing like a live performance, and I'm sure it was electric! They stay with you forever and the memories continue to thrill us. Thanks for watching!
It's kinda funny how amazing all these performers are. The actors are outstanding, the dancers are outstanding, everyone is living their role and delivering with their whole soul. Then you have Lin who arguable is the least strongest but definitely doing the same. But even standing next to all those people he still holds his own, and when you remember that he wrote everything, which I guess gives him a little wiggle room lol.
A few historical notes, Hamilton made lieutenant colonel, never was a general. Most of his combat experience was company/battery grade command in the field artillery. However, his command at Yorktown was over an infantry battalion. He however as you note spent most of his time on Washington's staff, which while not particularly glorious is to this day an incredibly important role. In terms of the president's address, the reality is they are Hamilton's words and Washington's words. The reality is that president's rarely write their own speeches or addresses, but, they are involved. Presumably a cover page written by the president which includes key points that must be hit would be a highly effective manner to deal with this. It is also super important for the president's speech writing team to be very keen on the president's beliefs and interests. All addresses would of course be subject to review by the president, and if he feels the need to revise he obviously can and likely does.
Thank you, Adam! I must have misread about him being Lt. Col. and not a general. I really have no idea about military ranks and functions, so my apologies for that. What was most important for me to note was that they had a long-established and close association that was also professional. It is very true about presidents and their speech writers. Obama's speech writer actually gets interviewed on the radio very often now! Not many if any have a public face. I know Nixon largely wrote his own speeches and is considered a speech-writing genius, but that is rare or perhaps unique. Thanks for the detailed insight! One of these days I'll read Chernow's bio of Hamilton!
@@DayleSong Awesome, and just to clarify I was not attempting to be insulting or anything like that. I just think it's good to share our knowledge so we can all learn together. Your analysis of the scene was great, I especially enjoyed how you note the different levels of storytelling going on between the actors.
@@Artill3rybby No insult taken! I love sharing info in the chats and learning more from comments. And definitely, correcting the errata is welcome. Thanks for taking the time to write in. Keep it coming!
@@Artill3rybby There is a citation (in the wiki article on Alexander Hamilton) that Hamilton was made a Major General during the Quasi-War of 1798-1800. Though I should note that this rank was appointed to him while he served in the United States Army. So I would surmise that the highest rank he achieved in the Continental Army was Lt. Colonel.
Wow! I am in awe of your analyses, great work!
Thank you so much, Sofia! I'm glad you are enjoying them. I'll get more posted soon. Anything in particular you would enjoy a reaction to?
love this video, but my eye keeps going to “ghosts” behind you because i have it on my own bookshelf 🤣
Lol, psychobetha! There's also Vampires from the same publisher up there. 'Tis the season! I see that it's prominent and was wondering if someone would point it out. I'm glad you did! And thank you for enjoying the video.
@@DayleSong i’ll have to check out Vampires 😁
I love this scene. This is probably my favorite moment in history as well when George Washington-great man- did maybe one of the greatest things anyone's done. He stepped down. Hamilton was right when he said he could have continued. He could easily have turned it into a sort of monarchy and he didn't, and this scene captures it- and overall the musical shows his wonderful. It's moving and just phenomal overall. I love the actor and I love what he did with the role.
Lin Manuel Miranda is more than an actor, more than a singer, he really is a genius musician and writer, Broadway will never be the same after Hamilton and history has its eyes on him.
This song is soooo relevant today. People in power who are still so thirsty for more power. You see it in most countries. Disgusts me, honestly. Great insights! Love this song, always tears me up. How about reacting to Dear Evan Hansen? I love Waving Through a Window ❤️
I agree, Chellikot! Theater often reflects the socio-political climate of its day, and Hamilton is a shining example, especially in that Miranda uses a contemporary filter to represent an historical time. Corruption is disgusting and disheartening, and all the more we must be on top of it and write shows to inspire peace and prosperity. How amazing that we had a Washington with all his caring and insight to start us off. What I did not realize until reading more about the historical moment of One Last Time was how heated and factioned politics became so early on. Yes, I knew there was disagreement and fighting in Congress, but since Washington has this shining reputation, it seemed that the executive branch might have had more concordance for awhile. Naive, perhaps, to think that. But that's what I love about such a show like this. It brings history into a 3-dimensional perspective that we were not taught in school. Dear Evan Hansen is a great suggestion--another show that goes into depth about the human condition. I'm on this Hamilton kick for now, but I'll keep that in mind!
man i love christopher jackson SO much, i really hope he comes out with an album one day. loved the video btw always on point 👌
I love you're commentary...very insightful. I would love your next post to be "It's Quite Uptown " It's So sad...Yet So Beautiful. Be Safe.
Hi love your channel! I know that this is an underrated song in the musical but I would love an analysis of “Washington on Your Side”. I don’t know why I love it so much but it’s constantly on repeat for me.
I took the song to also mean teaching leadership across the world how to say goodbye and limit themselves to terms.
Would love to see 'Wait for It' next
I would love to hear "Wait for it" sung by Aaron Burr in the play aka Leslie Odom Jr.
Just do all the songs of Hamilton to make everyone happy 😊😘
Hi Elisa! That's funny. I may eventually get around to it! What would you enjoy next?
I always cry when Washington breaks at the end of the song
Hi Virgilious! His is a remarkably sensitive performance! We all feel for Washington in this moment!
I’d love to see you react to the story of tonight or any other song with Anthony Ramos
Definitely want "Wait for It!"
Thanks, Peggy! You may not have to *Wait for It* long! Stay tuned! 😊
Loving your videos! I would love your take on Burr’s songs and arc!
Thank you for the suggestion, Lauren! I'm truly glad you are enjoying this series. I believe I'll tackle Burr's song(s) next. Stay tuned!
I loved how Hamilton fades into Washington so seamlessly. And the contrast between how they deliver the speech. Hamilton writes the words and delivers it straightforward and without much melody, similar to the rap/spoken word he has used for most of the rest of the play. This spoken word delivery may represent how he still does not fully understand why Washington is resigning. The tone he delivers it in is also melancholy and sad, reflecting how he himself feels about Washington resigning. In contrast, Washington’s delivery of his farewell address is more melodic and emotional, reflecting how he is more expressive with his joyful emotions than Hamilton (who for the majority of this play has always been singing/writing/fighting against someone), and his tone shows how he himself knows the good his resignation will bring for America, as well as how he is deserving of a break after so many years of service, being proud of both himself for accomplishing such an impossible feat and everyone in America who has worked fought under him to make it possible.
I believe you should also look at "In the Heights" which is Lin Manuel Miranda's other Broadway musical he wrote.
I think Miranda was also teaching the audience to say goodbye. I loved the play so much I had difficulty getting to the end.... Hamilton's death.
There’s a performance of this song in Kennedy Center when the cast of Hamilton was paying homage to their creators and there’s literally a choir that comes forward to sing (instead of the ensemble) and it’s one of the most beautiful performances I’ve ever seen! You should check that out if you haven’t yet.
ua-cam.com/video/4wYwA2LRShQ/v-deo.html
You should do "Wait For It" next! :D
Another great review! This might be my favorite scene from the show. It's a least the most profound; conveying both why Washington is so revered and what makes this country so unique at a visceral level that books and classes can't quite pull off. I still get chills every time the chorus comes in with "George Washington's going home".
Would like see your take on "Say no to this"?
Thank you, delcapslock100! This scene stands out for me, too. Miranda pays great tribute to both men's legacies with this exchange. You get a real sense of greatness at work that cannot be conveyed by mere facts. Once again, we are put in the room where it happens! I'll take a look at Say No to This. That one is not widely requested. Is that another one of your favorite moments?
@@DayleSong Yes I do like that one, in part for the sheer musicality of it but also how perfectly it captures the power of sexual allure, as one of the greatest minds in American history has his reputation and family all but destroyed by a pair of two-bit con artists (per Chernow's book). And Jasmine Jones' nails the role on every level with her amazing voice and as femme fatale with the steamy interplay with Miranda.
@@delcapslock100 Nice. I have yet to read Chernow's book, but the musical takes that stance. Jasmine is great in that role, too. I'll take a look-see to consider a review. Thanks for this!
I would LOVE for you to do a character arc like you did for Eliza, but with Burr instead
Probably should add the whole "1776" as a companion to Hamilton it covers other issues.
I hope you do more of the songs regarding hamilton's relationship with Angelica and Eliza, I would love to see your thoughts and comparisons on their interactions.
That being said, I hope you give First Burn a listen to!
Great analysis as always!
Thanks for the idea, Claire. That would be good fodder for focusing in on Hamilton, which would take multiple analyses! First Burn has been suggested, and I'm very curious about it, so hang in there! I'm sure I'll react to it soon.
@@DayleSong Looking forward to it, Dayle! Take a Break would also be great but I'm sure you get enough requests as it is. Thank you for taking the time to respond~
@@percyptuous All recommendations are welcome, Claire! I can't get to all of them, certainly, but both popular votes and ideas that pique my interest rise to the top of my selection process. I'll look into Take a Break for sure. Keep 'em coming! And thanks! 😊
That isn't *quite* true RE parties. It's true that there weren't organized parties like we think of them today, but there was a clear divide starting (at least) with the fight to replace the Articles of Confederation with the new Constitution. At that time, it was the Federalists vs the Anti-Federalists.
Wait for it
Thanks for the vote, Lisa! It's on my list!
Great reaction! Could you do Ten Duel Commandments?
Hi Carlos! That would be a good one to analyze! Thanks for the suggestion!
YES! Enjoyed it!
Hi Jeffery! Thanks for watching and commenting here again! Glad you enjoyed it. So much more to cover in this series!
the final half of the song is also the last 2 paragraphs of George Washington's Farewell address, sans a few lines (I'll outline in brackets the removed sections)
Though, in reviewing the incidents of my administration, I am unconscious of intentional error,
I am nevertheless too sensible of my defects not to think it probable that I may have committed many errors.
[ _Whatever they may be, I fervently beseech the Almighty to avert or mitigate the evils to which they may tend._ ]
I shall also carry with me the hope that my country will never cease to view them with indulgence;
and that, after forty five years of my life dedicated to its service with an upright zeal,
the faults of incompetent abilities will be consigned to oblivion,
as myself must soon be to the mansions of rest.
[ _Relying on its kindness in this as in other things, and actuated by that fervent love towards it
,_
_which is so natural to a man who views in it the native soil of himself and his progenitors for several generations,_ ]
I anticipate with pleasing expectation that retreat in which I promise myself to realize, [ _without alloy,_ ]
the sweet enjoyment of partaking, in the midst of my fellow-citizens,
the benign influence of good laws under a free government,
the ever-favorite object of my heart, and the happy reward, as I trust,
of our mutual cares, labors, and dangers.
_George Washington_
_United States_
_19th September, 1796_
Thanks, Kentaurus! How interesting to read the unexpurgated paragraphs. Thanks for that. The sections removed certainly aren't as lyrical or colloquial as the ones chosen.
subscribin incase you cover more songs (wait for it/room where it happens/battle of Yorktown/non-stop)
Hi, Ok! Yes, I have some of those planned for reactions soon. Thanks for subscribing!
Oh please do songs from the filmed stage version of CATS not the new movie, Memory especially, when you're done with Hamilton that is.
Interesting idea, Kelly. I saw the original production. Is the film of Broadway or West End?
DayleSong the stage production is a mixture of different UK productions with only three people from the broadway production
Had been really looking forward to more chloe and Halle. Cant watch these since I haven't seen the play yet.😭
Hi Onlylexy! I highly recommend Hamilton. It's a cultural phenomenon! But don't cry, I haven't forgotten about Chloe x Halle! They are one of the next videos on my non-musical song list. My progress has been slow this summer, but I will pick up speed! 😊
@@DayleSong Oh, I plan on it! I look forward to it!
And I want to rearange you books 😅
😂 You're welcome to come on over and reshelve if you really want! Do you suggest by category or size?
Take a break & blow us all away/stay alive should be your next video.
Thanks for the suggestion, AppleFlavoredTea! Burr is my next focus, for sure! Good ideas here!
Have you seen these clips before you react to them or is this the first time you are watching this?
Hi Superman 74, This is not a first watching. I've seen the Hamifilm and did some research to highlight points I want to discuss in the various sections. I hope you're enjoying them. The vocal coach videos are first watch.
@@DayleSong Cool thanks for the response. I've never been into music theater but I have seen (and loved) Rent in the past. Hamilton, in my inexperienced opinion, is Amazing, and worth every penny I spent to go see it live. I can't wait for in The Heights!
You Yes, Hamilton is a different brand of musical theater altogether and it is amazing, I find, especially as I peel away a few layers. In the Heights will be another superevent for sure! I'll have stuff on that, too, when it comes out. Thanks for writing in!
You should react to “future me” by Billie Eilish!!!
Hi Penny! Ooh, her newest release? So hard to keep up with all these productive artists! Thanks for the recommendation. I'll check it out!
DayleSong yup! She wrote it during quarantine and it really resonated with me. Btw thanks for taking the time to respond to comments and I really like your channel! I thought I was already subscribed but I guess I wasn’t. (Don’t worry I fixed that lol) anyway keep up the good work!
How can you call this a reaction video when you pause every 5 seconds to rant?