But Is It Really Activated Charcoal? (Make your own and then test it..)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- Here’s how to make your own activated charcoal and then use this simple filter test to see how well it works..
Cody’s activated charcoal video.. • Making Activated Carbon
(Yes, all the wildlife was released at the end of filming..)
Here's our main UA-cam channel.. / wayoutwestx2
And here's my online shop www.ironpig.ie
And here's our Patreon page if you could spare a little to help.. www.patreon.com/user?u=2761318
And here's the Fairtube Union's page - fairtube.info/
If you need to contact me ... rustyironpig @ gmail.com
I would leave the two filtered samples on the window sill and see which grows things first. (If you have a time-laps camera, it might be an additional data point.)
The activated charcoal might be a better surface to grow things on, which can screw the results. To do a real test you would make agar plates and put a drop of water on each. boiling some potatoes and evaporating the liquid from the water will give you a good agar substitute because the starchy sugar mix is perfect for mold and bacteria to feed on. The faster and bigger the growth colony on each dish the more contaminates the sample contained.
PS. You can also dissolve some antibiotics in water and paint some on the half of the dish without contaminates and you will get a clean line where the growth stops if it is effective against those things, and if it spreads further those are antibiotic resistant/immune.
I'd like to see the activated vs regular RINSED charcoal. The grayness could just be ash. Also like to see a PPM meter reading on both. Even regular charcoal that has merely been rinsed of ash is pretty powerful stuff. I have charcoal all over the place and don't need more but I might do a small test batch just using the rocket...
Putting steam into the bottom of the kiln first was a great idea so steam filters up through the still hot coals. Little dangerous though as it could blast you. Been burned that way myself
Flash boiling can be very powerful, but I do think his method should be OK since charcoal have very low heat capacity (that is the reason you can walk on glowing coal without burn the skin of your feet).
@@bknesheim There's little worry from the coal, it's the white hot end of the pipe that could cause an issue. Already does blast some of the water out on camera, that could have been worse.
I think spreading the hot coals and spraying them would get better results. The water needs to get as deep into the wood as possible before turning to steam. It may even be beneficial to load the retort with wet charcoal. This matches the normal process the closest, where they first produce coal and then add steam. Putting the water in the bottom will drop the temperature and the steam moving up through the coals will have no pressure. Adding water from the top allows the coals to extinguish, soak, and get steamed from the rising heat coming from the coals below. This should increase the internal pressure.
Thanks, all. I thought the pipe to the bottom was worth trying first, but it's not as satistying as the hissing/cracking you get from the top down. I should test the different layers to see if there's any detectable change. So many interesting things to do!
@@wayoutwest-workshopstuff6299 I like one option you have with the pipe to the bottom. You can extinguish the lower layer and stop it completely from burning and still continue the fire on top. That should increase the yield some and make it easier to control the radiated heat. Making a little less hot to do the work is always nice. 🙂
This is an essential skill that everyone should know, because when the zombie apocalypse happens, you will have to filter water with campfire charcoal.
“…so it’s full of eggshells.”
Well, of course it is.
What are they for i wonder?
@@djhscorp feeding back to the chickens. heating the egg shells kills any bacteria and makes the calcium in the shells easier for the chickens to digest.
@@zifnabalias5062 Also a good source of calcium for your garden if you need that. Lots of great uses after they've been dried/cooked!
I use them in the garden but had no idea they were fed back to the chickens
The things you learn on you tube
@@djhscorp Oysters shells or egg shells
Cool video! Science is not about the equipment you use. I'm sure Cody would enjoy watching you work just like the rest of us :)
Watching Cody for years and not even doing something illegal. Legendary.
"The stove is only warm part of the day, so it's full of eggshells." Yes, mhmm that makes sense.
That's a nice stove though. I was recently in a house that was literally being moved to another location and they had a stove that was a little larger than that converted to use gas. They wanted to make sure it didn't get damaged because it was hard to get another and it costs about 15k CAD. They were never very common here.
I enjoy Cody’s Lab myself. I’m a Rough Science geek who enjoys using basic science to accomplish goals around the home. Even regular charcoal has some level of usefulness as a filter medium.
That's a blast from the past, "Rough Science".
Without any context there is some fantastic absurdist humour on your channel. "This time of year the stove is only warm for some of the day, so it's full of eggshells."
there is an other (I think easier) way to measure the surface of the charcoal: you mix some Saltwater use the coal as electrodes, put some AC through it and measure the resistance. The bigger the surface area, the lower the resistance will become. Some years ago I sorted different kind of coals with that method.
you could use bamboo as your source of biomass and you should be able to demonstrate that activated bamboo charcoal is even much better than activated tree charcoal
If you were forced to rely on this process for water filtration, every extra advantage you can give the charcoal would be valuable in reaching cleaner water:
-bubbling air through the raw water to activate aerobic bacteria and destroy anaerobic life
-giving settling time for aerobic processes to consume the remaining oxygen and die off
-flocculation by adding alum or iron salts to make mechanical filtration more effective
-coffee filters or fine cloth as a pre-filter to remove bulk material
-seeping through stoneware or terracotta for fine particulate removal
-and finally, after running it through the charcoal, boiling it!
All that being said, I suspect the water from your hose pipe is still more reliably safe. ;-)
Wow. Thank you for sharing this video about activated charcoal
2:00 I was just pondering opening a new tab and shopping for a microscope.
Done. 42 bucks for an educational one with a carrying case. There's kid toy ones for under 20 bucks that would work just fine.
And I agree with you one the "Which one to drink." But I'd still boil it first. Oh, and if you have nice clear water and want to disinfect it in bulk, it only takes 1/4 of a TEASPOON of "Pool Shock," or Calcium Hypochlorite, to sterilize a 55 gallon (200~ litre) barrel. For the sample of filtered water in the standard charcoal, I would use 1/2 of a teaspoon.
And when you buy your Pool Shock or whatever other brand you get, CHECK THE INGREDIENTS CAREFULLY.
The only two you want to see are:
Calcium Hypochlorite, in the 68-70% range, and
INERT INGREDIENTS.
Anything else listed is biocides and fungicides that will kill us.
the pond smoothie looked delicious
Interesting, Tim. As are the readers suggestions.
The fact that you make your own charcoal is wonderful. That you take time to activate it is even better. Clean water for you. Why people argue over the quality is beyond me. Keep on doing what you do. It’s wonderful
The water sure looks clean! If you start out with flowing water from a river I'm sure it would be no problem to drink it.
Superb stuff. Takes me back decades, trying to get students through long lost nuffield A level courses. These were easily undergraduate level and we all had a great time encouraging and devising everything from standard ecological stuff to slug bait production, memory in small mammals and evaluation of chalk and charcoal for filters. Every child should be allowed to explore this area of science. Too often H and S has killed good experimentation dead. Glad you fly the flag for innovation. I have a beautiful wind driven pump system from a well. It is 84 ft down the inspection caisson. Also a gasometer and generator using sewage and years ago chicken manure. Sadly not running now. . My ancestors were keen on self sufficiency and so had a gas lit house! Cheers
Ha! Sounds good - any videos to show us of the pump?
Fascinating 'jug and bucket' chemistry. Have learned a lot about charcoal from this series and glad I have been be default using water to quench my biochar made in a bathtub. Didn't know I was improving it by adding the water / steam.
I’ve recently discovered this channel and
I love it. Thank you. I want to share something that you may be able to take advantage of. Thermal insulation material for installation in fire boxes and the like. I believe the best insulation material is
Dry White Wood Ash powder.
The next best is charcoal.
Proof of charcoal is
Hold a piece of charcoal in your hand light it and blast compressed air on the end away from your hand. It will flow white hot and radiate enormous amounts of heat while you are holding the cold end in your bare hand. See how close you can hold it.
White hot say half an inch away from the cold end. Well dry white wood ash is even better than that.
Also I love the railway and monorail ideas.
I love everything you are doing
Thanks
Thanks, Ian. Interesting.
Very cool. Would love to see some soil experiments using pond water inoculated biochar!
Now you can boil the activated water and it would be drinkable
If we all live up to Cody's standards we'd get nothing done. Lol
never realized that wetting it was an important step, it just made practical sense to me to soak it so that it cools down and doesnt reignite. a couple times i even filled my retort with dirt to keep the oxygen away from the hot coals while they cool. plus i like watering my plants with black water. ha
I learned more in this clip than in a year if science classes. If things get really bad and I can’t find clean water I’ll hop a plane and visit Tim.
In the Caribbean we've been using charcoal like forever ...it's also great to brush your teeth with ...
My girl said she needed more of that charcoal toothpaste and said it was great, and I’m like “you mean that’s all it is! Heck I can make that!” I wonder how hard it is to just make tooth paste.
I wish I could have visited when I was out near Galway a year ago.
Really loving these experiments Tim - such a fascinating topic with such potential for both carbon sink and fertiliser
A white background (like piece of paper held behind the glasses) makes the difference in appearance while comparing more prominent. One of the view things i memorized from chemistry lessons back in school ;)
I am sure Cody would approve!
Well, I was one of the sent sceptics, now a true convert.
Not that I ever want activated charcoal, all that I make is for casting ally and a kebab tandoor.
Rowen Atkinson knows his shit yo! Yeah Science!!!!!!!!!!
The stove is only warm sometimes, so its full of eggshells. A yes perfectly logical :D
If I have understood this, then any filter - even a cloth handkerchief - is better than no filter; a large layer of charcoal is better than a handkerchief; and activated charcoal is better than raw charcoal. - notwithstanding toxic chemicals that might be partway out of the wood (Australians will think of Oleander branches).
I let my 25-litre pails of roof water stand for 24 hours before handkerchief filtering. All rain water is boiled (tea, coffee, bread-baking, fruit bottling etc) and I have great confidence in my gut bacteria and immune system.
Cheers, Chris
Followed Cody for the last few years, I love his approach to things as I do with you.
Both keep me tuned In, learning and entertained.
Wow! That's very clean!
very interesting Tim thanks for explaining
Very interesting experiment Tim!
Nicely Done!
Thank you for taking the time to make this informative video!
I'm having a blast with these videos, this series. Thank you!
Nice experiment Tim, thank you.
Yep. I knew there would be criticism. And yes you are right.
Thank you for explaining it so simply! This is great content
great science class, thank you
It's a great starting point. Thank you.
Amazing Sandra and Shoestring Tim
An interesting comparison!
Good on you for doing it and setting things right. Always respect that.
Very satisfying, thank you. Hadn't realised the 'spent' charc was useful too.
I love so much that you did the experiment in such an accessible way. I'm tempted to try recreating it just for the sheer elegance and the fact that it would probably cause my dad glee.
Thank you, sir!
I would think something like a rock crusher would need 4 plates of steel some pin sitting in a grove which a geared rail could be used so you can adjust how big the bottom gap is to allow the charcoal to fall through then at the top of the crushing plate a cam either pushing on something or a camed pulley to a small pulley which could be powered by an electric motor or then another pulley on the small pulley to be connected to your stationary engine.
Enjoyed the video bro, the technical stuff went right over my head but over all I enjoyed it. Safe travels
I truely like the accurate and thorough way You do the things You do. It's very interesting and fun to watch. Thanks!
Brilliant as ever. Your films never fail to raise a smile, and despite being (I like to think) pretty practical and well rounded (and incredibly modest, obviously) I always learn something. Thanks Tim!
Handy knowledge to have come the apocalypse.
Love your approach to everything and life Tim. Keep it up and I too know which one I’d drink!
Well done!! I prefer your method as it has a very practical outcome with low tech input.........albeit with a lot of cogitation / trial and error . My approach to virtually everything new I'm attempting. I have an engineering workshop and a woodworking workshop on my property ( I'm a retired builder who has taken to beekeeping ) . Thank you for your marvellous videos, you continue to inspire me.
surprisingly found cody'slab is already on my subscribed list, don't have any memory about it
Very cool Tim :)
Fun! And doesn't hurt to confirm your findings, and I'm sure you'll gain finesse and improve technique a tiny bit each batch. Keep on Tim! Love seeing the videos.
Now I understand just how important this wood chip charcoal thing is. I will have to do the same once I aquire the land for it.
Well, I'm convinced 😊
Awesome i needed that info. Thank you very much😇😁
After watching Cody's "steam" video, I wondered if simply including water in the generator would do the same thing. Adding steam to a 500°+ pot just seemed redundant.
To avoid contaminating my carbon with unknowns, I added RO water at the beginning of the firing process and kept it under heat until all the water was boiled off.
So far, it seems to have 'activated' my carbon... (test to follow).
It would have been nice to compare a commercial carbon to your testing samples...
and yes, using the iodine method.
Interesting stuff, thanks for sharing.
A true scientist!
thanks for the videos! isnt youtube a small world cody is a great source for information among others. i could probably list a dozen channels most of us have watched and frequently am surprised by people like you who present mostly one area of content referencing other providers i watch who cover other areas of interest. its quite the operation you have developing with a waste nothing approach which is now uncommon.
Very interesting. Please keep it up.
Good job 👍👍👍Thank you for sharing. 🇨🇦
Good man Tim😊
Fascinating thank you for that. I had the suspicion that activated charcoal and bio char was a con to sell waste charcoal dust. You've convinced me otherwise. Cheers J
Chlorine is easily tested with pool water quality test sticks. Table salt is easily tested with an ohm meter (just fuse the probes together with a rubber band and dip the whole tip to remove variables in distance and surface).
I don't know what it would tell though, but you would get actual numbers if you want to compare your methods for making AC with no or minimal investment.
I love your "rough science" approaches!
At the end of the experiment, I think that it would have been questionable form for him to say, "I told you so." Well, he didn't, and he didn't because he has the level of dignity and temperament required to run a successful youtube channel.
I, however do not have that kind of temperment, so... "He toldya so!" : P
Brilliant.
Wow good job ,am surprised that was great
As soon as I saw your video on activated charcoal, instantly thought of Cody. suspected you might be a viewer already :) Clearly needs a collaboration video!
Huh, I thought innoculated and activated were two terms for the same process with no steam mentioned. So this is news to me. Hey that goose water is perfect for any fruit trees or shrubs! You know I like your cone kiln, but without the expense a good hole in the ground works great as well. Instead of square you just dig rectangular as it also fits your stems well. If I remember right it was skillcult or another interesting channel a hand full of years ago had a good video series on what he was up too. I liked it because it was so versatile. You dig where you want a charcoal bed, get it burning, keep layering your cuttings till the hole is full and then cover with earth and or water and either harvest the charcoal and use wherever or just bury and garden on top of it. Just like those old charcoal kiln spots are the greenest spots in the forest still today, so can it work for your homestead. IN THEORY, LOL! Great seeing all the fun you get up too.
Unless your on peat bogs, stone and high water tables....I forgot you were located across the pond.
Exactly - if we could dig a hole it would fill with water in no time : - )
@@wayoutwest-workshopstuff6299 That would put a damper on the whole endeavor.
Tim you are a brilliant man I hope to meet you one day and shake your hand respect you always
I must say your channel has impressed me more than Cody’s!
very informatve!
Fascinating 🤨
Just found your channel starting with the wood chopper, the kiln build and now the activated charcoal test. Downright fascinating. Looking forward to watching more and learning. Im a machinist so would love to see some used in cooking up some steel.
Thanks, Martin - you saw the one where I test some in a forge? Lots more to experiment needed..
@@wayoutwest-workshopstuff6299 not yet. Will be looking for it.
Nice simple demonstration. I have no doubt that there was some steam activation. But it's hard to tell if both samples reached the same level of charing.
Very interesting.
Of cause we know what glas you would drink for sure:
the left one - the fourty shade of greens as an irish , what else. Will harden you for sure.
just kidding - great idea and proof of concept
Nice qualitative test, but it would be nice to also include the iodine test so we get a quantitative measure of the improvement.
Using charcoal from the same batch would be more accurate and since the hardness and density of the charcoal make a difference, a measure by weight instead of volume should also improve the result (less important if it is from the same batch 🙂).
I bet you could use that old tank you used as a retort as the vessel to activate the charcoal further.
Food dye might make a reasonable test too.
Activated won't filter everything alive. A friend did the same filtering in a College experiment - then drank the water! He was just fine after a week in the Hospital!
Very sciencey... should start a new series, barnyard science.
I didn't understand which one was activated charcoal in Cody's Activated charcoal video
Awesome
The difference between regular charcoal and activated charcoal is how often you have to change the filter.
A tds meter and use tap water to see the reduction in total dissolved solids would test your charcoal. I think you will get pure water with a little more packing.
We all know the green tea is the most flavorful
Science thwarted by sausages. Oh, well-just grab some kitchen tools; do some science on the lawn. Nicely done.
I wonder if the tamping, (tapping the tube filled with AC) could have caused a difference? This is where a double blind test would be perfect. (Hand someone else charcoal A and B and a methodology for testing and see what results they get.)
I watched your last two video's on char making and your method for making the char is pretty much the same as mine including water for stopping the process. I sort of wondered about the activated bit I knew that the shock of cooling the hot char quickly created more fissures and cells in the char and that equals more homes for and surface area to achieve biochar. After watching your experiment with the homemade filter and pondwater you pointed out an interesting thing. That is what is actually activated charcoal mean? One thing I have learned about UA-cam is there is always people who get great pleasure in pointing out what they see as your shortcomings and the safety policeman get me. Just because its dangerous for them to do something a certain way does not mean its dangerous for another person who has the sense to keep their body parts out of moving machinery etc. I saw the oven full of egg shells we ground ours all up the other day with the char very satisfying to use everything. John
Activated charcoal are from commercial suppliers would normally have an increase in surface area of about 3-3.5 times . An index could be used where 1 is non treated charcoal and the index for treated charcoal would indicate how efficient the treatment was.
@@bknesheim Thanks for the explanation and help. John
Thanks, John. I think I'm just a step or two behind you, watching all your experiments too. Our climate and soil are completely different from yours, but we're both having fun experimenting, aren't we?
@@wayoutwest-workshopstuff6299 Its interesting that we live in totally different parts of the world and about opposite in terms of climate and yet we do pretty much the same sort of things. As far as the fun factor its about as good as it gets plenty of toys and learning lots. John
The eggshells. So the idea is to mix them into the biochar?
Makes me wonder about the potshards that have been found in the Amazon biochar and the purpose it served.
Biochar in general has me wondering about what effect forest fires have. And is there much effect to the soil from just straight charcoal created from those fires and or when it rains or from water bombing therefore, to some degree creating biochar.
Thank you so much for this :) I'm curious, why wouldn't the act of smashing it to smitherenes not do the "activation" of creating fisures and holes? I would be very interested to see that activated charcoal compared to that made in the barrel, simply allowing all the fuel to escape and not burn.
the cracks are microscopic - you can't make them mechanically