@@JoJoTinkRN same! My skintone is always pulling for the warmer colour in the mix: eyeshadow or lipstick. So unless it is straight up grey, they always look the other colour in the mix for me
I see green looking at the mini Retro. I see that it’s a bit cool toned but I remember I was so confused when it first came out and people said it was grey, lol, cos I don’t see that at all.
Omg yes I see green in the ND mini retro and was confused when other people said it was gray! This also happens with the melt millennial pinx palette I see baby pink and baby blue and some people say it’s pink and gray.
I have Mini Retro. It really does change colors depending on what you pair it with on your eye. I see gray & silver in the video. But green in person. But when I look at it compared to Mini Gold it changes to a gray-green. I think that it's kinda interesting what different colors people see in the same palette.
I have been eyeing your number one palette and I think you convinced me to finally grab it. 🙈 It’s just the perfect little palette! Also, I LOVE your makeup in this video! 😍
That's so interesting about the mini retro palette! I have never seen silver looking at it and even referred to Temptalia's review/watches where she refers to the matte as a warm-toned green. I bet that makes the taupey shimmer beside it look more green than it actually is.
Just ordered the mini retro palette in the latest sale here in Australia. It’s like $45 here! Missed out on the bronze palette though which is $112 here! I need to get my hands on those elf palettes though. Also ordered the mini glam too!
i’m loving these eyeshadow palette ranking videos. i just finished watching your ranking of hyped eyeshadow palettes: good, bad, or rightfully so. great video. keep up the great work. you work super hard and it’s not going unnoticed. you throw out at the very least 3-4 videos a week. i’m so glad i found you through sam march. i love your videos.
At first I didn’t understand essences air palettes. The shadows are so light they don’t show up. But then I tried them as a topper on my eyeshadows. They transform your shadows into something absolutely beautiful. You definitely need to try it.
I have to say I do see the green undertones on that shade, but I also feel like that’s what ND does regularly on her palettes. Like the Gold Palette, it does come with neutrals and I get the whole “only a pop of blue” but the undertones on some of the shades are actually very different, at least that’s what they look to me
My friend has the mini retro palette. When I saw it I was like, ooh I love these greens! She said they were greys and I was so confused😂. I think it has to do with the pink backgrounds since red contrasts with green so it would bring out those tones
I agree with you on swapping out Digital in Naked Ultraviolet. I did a lot of looks pairing the purples with a teal shimmer I’m project panning and it looked amazing, I think the palette would benefit from a shade like that. Especially with Lucid in there.
Girl you’ve got to get the ND Mini Nude palette. It’s my all time favourite palette. I can’t even explain to you how incredible it is. One of the shades is one of those multi-dimensional shimmers thats a bronze but reflects a bunch of different colours depending on the light. You’ve gotta get it, you won’t regret it.
i’m still dying to get the mini glam and the mini retro. i actually see green and silver in the mini retro. thank you for ranking the elf mini palette. i ordered it on ulta and i love it. they have a couple others that i’m probably going to end up getting.
The Natasha Denona shadows look a lovely sage green on camera to me. The one that confuses me is when people describe the urban decay ultraviolet shade as green. It looks like a pastel pale blue to me, I can't see any yellow in it at all!
I just bought the Sigma Cor De Rosa when they had half off sale on their palettes. I love it. The quality & pigmentation is high. It beautifully fills the rose gold colorstory slot in my collection. I picked up Enchanted, too, based on Kelly's recommendation. It's very pretty. I like the look of the Ofra palettes. But they are just a bit too pricey for me. If they went on sale, I'd probably buy the beach one. I say that like I didn't buy both the ND Mini Gold & the Mini Retro @ $25 each. I'm looking pretty hard at the Mini Glam palette. I've had very good luck with ND eyeshadows. I do recommend them. Except the Mini Lila. It wasn't worth the $12.50 I paid for it.
The Sigma Beauty Cor-de-Rosa palette I wasn't surprised was at the ranking you put it. I think it's a pretty palette, and there a couple times I've almost bought it, but since I recently bought the Freja Diva palette from Oden's Eye, I think I'm good for now! I think the Freja Diva palette seems to be a slightly less neutral/basic version of the same color story.
Looks green to me. I'm guessing it's because people have different monitors/screens. Mine is more warm toned so I see green. A cooler toned one will show grey.
The Natasha Denona mini retro palette gives me maybelline blushed nudes vibes. The shades in the palette are a sage green- it is more on the green side but a more muted grayish green color!
I haven't tried the other elements palettes, so I can't speak to those, but the Earth palette is pretty good. It's virtually all kind of mid-tone moderately metallic shimmer shades. If you're like me, and you're all about a one-shadow wonder, this is a pretty nice palette of those with a broader range of colors than the other palettes in this line up. Re: the ND Retro Palette, I definitely got it because of those (what look to me like) green shadows :)
The mini retro, I thought silver when I first saw it but a certain way you turn the palette it looks green. I had bad luck with an older ND mini (Tropical I think is what it was called).
I just recently bought the mini star and I looooove it!! I kept fighting ND bc for that price I’ll buy indie but I really enjoyed that lil baby! I must get retro now 🤦🏻♀️😆
To me those ND shades are definitely green but they are cool toned greens, hence the grey-ish undertone. Green shadows are typically warm toned, so have a yellow undertone, which is probably why a lot of people don't see these as green 😊
Sorry, this is completely off topic of this video but...do you own much from Korean beauty companies? I'm having trouble to trying to find cruelty free Korean brands
Every day when your video pops up in my notification feed, I get a smile on my face and then your smile lights up the screen. Your positivity and obvious love and dedication to your subscribers is second to none. Thank you for this video and the amazing video concepts you present to us every week. Be well. Be safe!! 💜 OH! And I also have the Mini Retro palette and those 2 shades in question are 100% green to me. I remember when you featured the palette in a Will I Buy It and when you said you weren’t sure you liked the pinks and grays together (or something like that..lol ) I remember thinking, “Wait, they’re green not gray and silver!?!” Maybe everyone sees those colors differently but it’s wild to think about. I use that palette mostly for those 2 shades because I love green looks. Anyway, just adding my opinion! 😊
The official shade descriptions in the mini retro are Industrial- green taupe with silver reflects and '60s- greenish grey 🤣
That is exactly what I see in mine!
That’s what I see. I create some gorgeous “green” looks with those 2 colors.
@@JoJoTinkRN same! My skintone is always pulling for the warmer colour in the mix: eyeshadow or lipstick. So unless it is straight up grey, they always look the other colour in the mix for me
That's a pretty good description 🤣
That description totally clears that up for me. How do they come up with this stuff?
😂🤣😂
I see green looking at the mini Retro. I see that it’s a bit cool toned but I remember I was so confused when it first came out and people said it was grey, lol, cos I don’t see that at all.
Omg yes I see green in the ND mini retro and was confused when other people said it was gray! This also happens with the melt millennial pinx palette I see baby pink and baby blue and some people say it’s pink and gray.
Really excited to hear those Essence palettes get ROASTED again. Also that high pony &bold lip combo- yesss girl.
Thank you, Hannah!
Lol it's hilarious to see her roast those.
Idk if they've ever had good palettes 🤔 Embarrassing
Kelly just described my overall experience with Essence products. I "could" make it work. But, do I "want" to? Love the honesty, Kelly. 💖💖💖
The shades from the Mini Retro Palette look pretty green 🤷♀️
That’s what I thought too! I bought it and I still don’t k ow what shades they are hahah they really change based on what you pair them with
I have Mini Retro. It really does change colors depending on what you pair it with on your eye. I see gray & silver in the video. But green in person. But when I look at it compared to Mini Gold it changes to a gray-green. I think that it's kinda interesting what different colors people see in the same palette.
I have been eyeing your number one palette and I think you convinced me to finally grab it. 🙈 It’s just the perfect little palette! Also, I LOVE your makeup in this video! 😍
Thank you!!
Hey Andrea I love your videos too! Keep em coming😉
Hi, Andrea! Love your channel. 💖
The Nd palette seems like a sage grey green color? 🤣🤣
That's so interesting about the mini retro palette! I have never seen silver looking at it and even referred to Temptalia's review/watches where she refers to the matte as a warm-toned green. I bet that makes the taupey shimmer beside it look more green than it actually is.
Definitely looks green to me!
I am doing my makeup RIGHT NOW to film this video! These palette rankings are so hard for me lol
Just ordered the mini retro palette in the latest sale here in Australia. It’s like $45 here! Missed out on the bronze palette though which is $112 here! I need to get my hands on those elf palettes though. Also ordered the mini glam too!
The ND mini retro has Always pulled green in my eyes 👀
Fun to see this video!
i’m loving these eyeshadow palette ranking videos. i just finished watching your ranking of hyped eyeshadow palettes: good, bad, or rightfully so. great video. keep up the great work. you work super hard and it’s not going unnoticed. you throw out at the very least 3-4 videos a week. i’m so glad i found you through sam march. i love your videos.
I find it so interesting when you say you don't like pink eyeshadow looks because I swear you wear it a lot and I'm not complaining :)
Yay! Ranking (palettes) is always my fave series. My fave palette of 2020 is CP All That-it’s my perfect color story and formula
I haven’t tried that one but it looks pretty!
Oh my goodness. That pink eyeshadow is POPPING out of the screen!! Love.
Also I love it with that lip!
At first I didn’t understand essences air palettes. The shadows are so light they don’t show up. But then I tried them as a topper on my eyeshadows. They transform your shadows into something absolutely beautiful. You definitely need to try it.
The cheek products you have on today look STUNNING!
I have to say I do see the green undertones on that shade, but I also feel like that’s what ND does regularly on her palettes. Like the Gold Palette, it does come with neutrals and I get the whole “only a pop of blue” but the undertones on some of the shades are actually very different, at least that’s what they look to me
My friend has the mini retro palette. When I saw it I was like, ooh I love these greens! She said they were greys and I was so confused😂. I think it has to do with the pink backgrounds since red contrasts with green so it would bring out those tones
Your hair is always the cutest Kelly 😍😍
I love this eyelook! I had to recreate it right the second I saw it, so glad I had a similar shade on hand!
I agree with you on swapping out Digital in Naked Ultraviolet. I did a lot of looks pairing the purples with a teal shimmer I’m project panning and it looked amazing, I think the palette would benefit from a shade like that. Especially with Lucid in there.
Love the pink looks lately!
Been saving this video to focus on. Lol! But I love your look! Simple eyes with a bold lip is just so awesome!
My sephora order us waiting on me at home. I got the natasha denona mini retro and mini glam lol. Very nice to see them both in your video!
Now I feel like I need the Mini Retro palette!!! I love your ranking videos
Your Pebbles Flintstone hair is everything!
Haha thank you!!
Girl you’ve got to get the ND Mini Nude palette. It’s my all time favourite palette. I can’t even explain to you how incredible it is. One of the shades is one of those multi-dimensional shimmers thats a bronze but reflects a bunch of different colours depending on the light. You’ve gotta get it, you won’t regret it.
i’m still dying to get the mini glam and the mini retro. i actually see green and silver in the mini retro. thank you for ranking the elf mini palette. i ordered it on ulta and i love it. they have a couple others that i’m probably going to end up getting.
I absolutely see gray in the mini retro palette 😂 I wouldn't even think green unless you said something!
Your makeup and hair looks so good.
Mini retro shades look pretty green to me but I’ve never seen it in person. I want one of the mini pallets so much!
Your eye shadow looks amazing! I want this exact color and to wear it the exact same way!
Love this makeup look! Very unique pairing! Now I’m inspired to be more daring
The Natasha Denona shadows look a lovely sage green on camera to me.
The one that confuses me is when people describe the urban decay ultraviolet shade as green. It looks like a pastel pale blue to me, I can't see any yellow in it at all!
I just bought the Sigma Cor De Rosa when they had half off sale on their palettes. I love it. The quality & pigmentation is high. It beautifully fills the rose gold colorstory slot in my collection. I picked up Enchanted, too, based on Kelly's recommendation. It's very pretty.
I like the look of the Ofra palettes. But they are just a bit too pricey for me. If they went on sale, I'd probably buy the beach one.
I say that like I didn't buy both the ND Mini Gold & the Mini Retro @ $25 each. I'm looking pretty hard at the Mini Glam palette. I've had very good luck with ND eyeshadows. I do recommend them. Except the Mini Lila. It wasn't worth the $12.50 I paid for it.
The Sigma Beauty Cor-de-Rosa palette I wasn't surprised was at the ranking you put it. I think it's a pretty palette, and there a couple times I've almost bought it, but since I recently bought the Freja Diva palette from Oden's Eye, I think I'm good for now! I think the Freja Diva palette seems to be a slightly less neutral/basic version of the same color story.
I really want to try your top 3 haha. Im also loving todays look♥️
Looks green to me. I'm guessing it's because people have different monitors/screens. Mine is more warm toned so I see green. A cooler toned one will show grey.
The Natasha Denona mini retro palette gives me maybelline blushed nudes vibes. The shades in the palette are a sage green- it is more on the green side but a more muted grayish green color!
😱 we are twinning with the eye makeup!!!!!
Twins!
I love the ultra violet, such a great palette. And easy to use.
Great palette ranking , love it
Your makeup looks fav today! I thought you were wearing BITE Acai Smash (totally bought cause you recommended it.) Are they similar?
I never realized people thought the mini retro looked grey! It looks like a perfect sage color to me!
Same!
the ND mini retro shades look green to me but I have never seen it in person!
OH yeah I definitely see GREENS - they're very muted grey toned green, but.... to me it actually kind of matches the Dog Mama Tee you have lol
Good afternoon Kelly!! 😊Finally, my lunch break.😳 Excited to watch this!!! 🤗 Absolutely love your channel and your content 💞💖 Thank you for this video
These neon pastel pink eyes though!!! 😍
I haven't tried the other elements palettes, so I can't speak to those, but the Earth palette is pretty good. It's virtually all kind of mid-tone moderately metallic shimmer shades. If you're like me, and you're all about a one-shadow wonder, this is a pretty nice palette of those with a broader range of colors than the other palettes in this line up.
Re: the ND Retro Palette, I definitely got it because of those (what look to me like) green shadows :)
Love your ranking videos, been looking forward to this one 😀 💗 Adore your look, just gorgeous 😍
Love your eyeshadow it’s amazing
Thank you, Sally!
I love ranking videos! So excited for this one.
Thank you, Maggie!
The mini retro, I thought silver when I first saw it but a certain way you turn the palette it looks green. I had bad luck with an older ND mini (Tropical I think is what it was called).
For mini retro palette, I see green!!!!!
Can we talk about your highlight though??? 😍😍😍
You’re such a breath of fresh air 😊 great videos, so positive
Thank you!!
I just recently bought the mini star and I looooove it!! I kept fighting ND bc for that price I’ll buy indie but I really enjoyed that lil baby! I must get retro now 🤦🏻♀️😆
To me those ND shades are definitely green but they are cool toned greens, hence the grey-ish undertone. Green shadows are typically warm toned, so have a yellow undertone, which is probably why a lot of people don't see these as green 😊
That is some pink shadow. You go, Glen Coco.
Love eyeshadow palettes Rancing 🎀♥️ thank you for this amazing Video 🥳 lovely greats from Vienna Austria
I have had my eye on the Natasha Denona mini palettes for a while. They may be in my cart next VIB sale.
Love this video so much!!! I need to go through and do this tag with my collection
I LOVE that Sigma Palette. Lol - A lot of influencers are starting to complain about bigger packaging so I do see that getting smaller.
I would love if they switched to smaller!
@@KellyGooch - I hope they do! Keep talking about it and I do believe the companies listen.
Green. 100%, I always thought pink & green was an odd pairing when the pallette came out!
I love these rankings videos! I so wish Ulta carried Natasha Denona because I'd snap those two minis up with my points in a heartbeat🤩
Sorry, this is completely off topic of this video but...do you own much from Korean beauty companies? I'm having trouble to trying to find cruelty free Korean brands
The mini retro palette is grey in my opinion!
I still really want the new sigma palette. I definitely dont need it, but it's so pretty! I dont really have any warm toned palettes in my collection.
When I use those shades from the mini retro they look green on me. Maybe has to do with skin tones? :)
The ND Retro palette looks very green on me (FYI I have fair neutral skin tone)
this look is so cute!!!
Green! 🌱
I think the matte shade is an army green, and the shimmer looks silvery to me
Kelly, I'd lost you for awhile and found you again!🖐 And Ofra discount code? AMEN and thank you!
Looks like an army green and a silvery green to me.
I'm definitely seeing green in that palette hahaha
Is this like the Blue vs White dress challenge? 😂😂 Greeeeen lol, green
Haha yes!!
I definitely see green! 😂 it does look like it has some grey in it but I guess I see mostly green
looks green to me
Okay those are definitely green shadows in the mini ND palette.
OMG I love this look! Xxx
This makeup is awesome
Thank you!
I like mini palettes, thank you for the video
Omg you look gorgeous!
Thank you!
prettiest makeup look yet
Thank you!
the matte looks green to me but the shimmer looks more silver
To me, those have always looked 100% green!
Thank you...
Wow, love your makeup!
Thank you!!
Nice
Green
GRAY/GREEN!!! for sure. Lol.
Every day when your video pops up in my notification feed, I get a smile on my face and then your smile lights up the screen. Your positivity and obvious love and dedication to your subscribers is second to none.
Thank you for this video and the amazing video concepts you present to us every week. Be well. Be safe!! 💜
OH! And I also have the Mini Retro palette and those 2 shades in question are 100% green to me. I remember when you featured the palette in a Will I Buy It and when you said you weren’t sure you liked the pinks and grays together (or something like that..lol ) I remember thinking, “Wait, they’re green not gray and silver!?!” Maybe everyone sees those colors differently but it’s wild to think about. I use that palette mostly for those 2 shades because I love green looks. Anyway, just adding my opinion! 😊
I think they look green 😁
love! 💟
i`m team green
They looks green for me, at least in the pan
it looks green to me