Noir Désir - Tostaky (live Les Vieilles Charrues 2001) - REACTION - First Time hearing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 127

  • @user-tb8sy5bz7m
    @user-tb8sy5bz7m 11 місяців тому +66

    Noir désir is the name of the band. Tostaky is a contraction for "todo esta aqui". The song is in french and in spanish.
    Noir désir was my favorite band at that time till the singer Bertrand Cantat killed his girlfriend Marie Trintignant by hitting her as he was drunk. Marie was a well known actress and that caused a big emotion in France. Cantat was rejected by the other members of the band and Noir désir does'nt exist anymore.
    They left very good songs with very deep lyrics that we still listen now with a little bitterness.
    Other songs by Noir Désir: A ton étoile, Comme elle vient '(with an awesome video), Aux sombres héros de l'amer, Un jour en France, L'homme pressé, Le vent nous portera
    Other french rock bands to listen to:
    Trust: Antisocial (TRUST - ANTISOCIAL - CLERMONT (Coopérative de Mai))
    Téléphone: Un autre monde, Ca c'est vraiment toi, la bombe humaine, New York avec toi, Cendrillon
    Matmatah: Lambe an dro, L'apologie (LIVE @ Fête du bruit 2017) ...

    • @ppatocthereturn04
      @ppatocthereturn04 6 місяців тому +1

      excellent !!

    • @magict01
      @magict01 13 днів тому

      Bertrand Cantat came back with a band named "Detroit" and he his still sing solo now, he did feats with Shaka Ponk "palabra mi amor" and with Amadou&Mariam for example. But yes nothing can beat the original band, every album are great specially 666.667 club.

  • @ooO0VicariouS0Ooo
    @ooO0VicariouS0Ooo 11 місяців тому +21

    Probably one of the best rock french band ever.
    ...with a so sad story to end.
    Still be a fan of the band, me and my girlfriend have part of the lyrics of this song on our arms, and still follow Bertrand Cantat career, even if I can understand lot can't.
    "fun" fact: their last album was released on 9/11/01. Maybe it was a sign.

    • @emiliakonstanza737
      @emiliakonstanza737 2 місяці тому

      Now we have Gojira and Dagoba. 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

  • @marie-anneguibereau7344
    @marie-anneguibereau7344 9 місяців тому +42

    Noir Desir was the best French rock band. They were amazing live, and very political... But since the lead singer killed his girlfriend in a fist fight when he was drunk, I really have a hard time listening to his voice that I loved so... The lead guitar player, Serge Teyssot-Gay is an excellent musician too.

    • @Josephtao2
      @Josephtao2 6 місяців тому +4

      Bertrand Cantat c’est pas nous, mais Noir Désir c’est à nous.
      Bertrand Cantat is not us, but Noir Désir belongs to us.

    • @isabelle070209
      @isabelle070209 2 місяці тому +9

      C’était pas pendant une bagarre. Il l’a frappé à mort méthodiquement

    • @jamjam1312
      @jamjam1312 Місяць тому +1

      A fist fight! Non mais tu déconnes ? 😆

    • @todo_esta_aqui1936
      @todo_esta_aqui1936 Місяць тому

      ​@@isabelle070209 faux et absolument faux. Cantat a d'ailleurs été condamné à juste titre, pas la peine de le condamner pour davantage c'est déjà bien assez. Bagarre de junkieS. Qui a très mal tourné d'ailleurs. Que cela vous plaise ou non. Aucun mobile. Aucune préméditation.

    • @LonesomeCowgirl
      @LonesomeCowgirl Місяць тому

      ​@@isabelle070209Et il l'a laissée crever là pendant qu'il pleurait sur son sort au téléphone avec son frère à elle...

  • @quaresma9003
    @quaresma9003 11 місяців тому +115

    Il faudra bien a un moment qu'on lui suggère TRUST "antisocial"

    • @Tiisiphone
      @Tiisiphone 9 місяців тому +5

      Oui! ❤

    • @eliseprevost2233
      @eliseprevost2233 8 місяців тому +6

      Entièrement d'accord Et n'oublions pas Police Milice

    • @mbx6823
      @mbx6823 7 місяців тому +2

      et un peu de gojira ^^

    • @thaeros
      @thaeros 7 місяців тому +3

      ou fff, le plus connu etant "le pire et le meilleur" mais je préfère "dans les bras de morphée) ( seconde plus connu etant " barbes"!

    • @nicolaslache5228
      @nicolaslache5228 7 місяців тому +3

      @@eliseprevost2233 et surtout TRANXEN 200 !!! 😉

  • @Tiisiphone
    @Tiisiphone 11 місяців тому +18

    I used to love this band and saw them many times on stage. It was my favorite french band. Unfortunately, since singer Bertrand Cantat beat his partner to death, I cannot listen to their songs anymore. Some people say I should separate the artist from the man, but I can't. I don't judge people who still listen to them, but as far as I'm concerned I cannot help but seeing Bertrand's girfriend bloodied, broken face when I hear Noir Désir"s songs.

    • @pitikiwi01
      @pitikiwi01 11 місяців тому +3

      🙏👏👏👏 respect for that

    • @marie-anneguibereau7344
      @marie-anneguibereau7344 9 місяців тому +3

      I feel exactly the same. ND was my absolute favorite band and now it hurts to listen to Cantat's voice.

    • @tokepine6169
      @tokepine6169 8 місяців тому +1

      But comme elle vient is still (for me) the best french song and the rest of the band did nothing

  • @kristianmapage9742
    @kristianmapage9742 11 місяців тому +23

    Thx ! Yes, please, Noir Désir, "le vent l'emportera".

    • @flatericoyzo
      @flatericoyzo 7 місяців тому

      c'est ça. 2 salles, 2 ambiances.

    • @AngelinaJolie734
      @AngelinaJolie734 7 місяців тому +1

      Celle-ci a été écrite par Manu Chao. Ce serait une bonne transition pour aller vers la Mano Negra. 😛

  • @Jamzy-gi3ft
    @Jamzy-gi3ft 11 місяців тому +7

    I was there! thx for the video.

  • @eliseprevost2233
    @eliseprevost2233 11 місяців тому +24

    Also a Famous song "Le vent l'emportera", "lhomme pressé" In 2003, singer Bertand Cantat killed his partner, Marie Trintignant, during an episode of domestic violence in Vilnius, Lithuania, which earned him a sentence of eight years in prison. Following his conditional release in 2007 and then total release in 2010. This feminicide affair caused a huge scandal in France

  • @kalikarma7025
    @kalikarma7025 7 місяців тому +6

    The golden years of the french rock !

  • @SandraMiserez-me2zd
    @SandraMiserez-me2zd 7 місяців тому +4

    I'm french this is my favorit band thank you for your react and Bertrand Cantat sing french and spanish too for this song Tostaky

  • @Sebbb-v9k
    @Sebbb-v9k 8 днів тому

    Great band, great song, great show !

  • @nasshera3491
    @nasshera3491 7 місяців тому +5

    The best French band ever... their texts were very powerful and should translated...

  • @manoul71
    @manoul71 7 місяців тому +3

    great reaction it was one of the best rock french band years ago

  • @danguid2753
    @danguid2753 10 місяців тому +3

    7:27 2001 is the year of the concert, the song dates from 1992.

  • @Wabashable
    @Wabashable 8 місяців тому +6

    this is an epic rock moment

  • @stephaniee.9384
    @stephaniee.9384 24 дні тому

    this is a masterpiece, music, lyrics, energy, build up. I would say that this is kinda the french "Killing in the name", (another of my favorite of all time) 90's powerful punch in your face.

  • @bzhhxc7420
    @bzhhxc7420 7 днів тому

    J'étais à ce concert, quels souvenirs 🤩

  • @reynaldparisel3852
    @reynaldparisel3852 7 місяців тому +7

    Le concert a lieu en Bretagne et le drapeau est un drapeau breton !

  • @stephaniee.9384
    @stephaniee.9384 24 дні тому

    this riff will never get old, it's from 1992, 4th album, i'm 17 again in 2 sec (i'm 49), pure energy and I'm pretty sure that every french between 30 to 70 knows this riff. I saw them the first time in a tiny bar before they became really huge, 1989 with their 2nd album. i'm too young to be a Telephone band fan (my older brother gens), Noir Desir is THE french rock band of my generation (75). (i won't admit any contradiction on that hahahaha) They were hard, true ones, sweat and riff, against any rewards, no commercial stuff, you won't find many TV with them, live music spirit at his best, true rockers. the lyrics are poems, real modern poetry, not the "nice" one. It's deep with a layers of meanings, lot of engaged politics and socials lyrics, even the most simple "accessible" pop ones are satirics most of the time. I won't comment private matters of the singer, each one is free to dissociate the music from life, or not. They are and will stay the best F... french rock band for me. still listening theirs live performance more than 30 years later. thank you for you giving a try :) Edit : 3rd time in a row and I get goosebumps each time. This song is really strong about the suffering of america latina for centuries and modern era fa...ism. (don't know if this word is censured or not)

  • @JuliettePertugues
    @JuliettePertugues 10 місяців тому +3

    Hi mister D,
    I first wanted to say that you're really better than a lot of other american reacting youtube channels (much more sincere and true)...
    Another french revolutionnary huge song you should like is "TORTURE" by LOFOFORA. (lyrics are great also...
    Thanks and blesses mister D

  • @alexguich5417
    @alexguich5417 25 днів тому +1

    I was there 23 years ago! 🤩

  • @ss974
    @ss974 6 місяців тому +5

    It's not an United Statizen flag, this flag is called "Gwenn ha du" from... original : Breizh / French : Bretagne / english : "little" Brittany.
    He have white and black stripes and hermines on top left. You can google "Gwenn ha du" or "drapeau breton" for a visual.
    It's a very old country who is now a regional part of France.
    For fact, this concert was during a festival in Bretagne but you can see it all over the world, very very proud peoples.

  • @genevievepaniagua4283
    @genevievepaniagua4283 Місяць тому +2

    The French band "Louise attaque" is a very excellent band too

  • @MurielHugo-h2e
    @MurielHugo-h2e 11 місяців тому +4

    Noir désir, tostaky tatoué sur mon bras , à vie

  • @LetsChillPage
    @LetsChillPage 10 місяців тому +3

    Hello from South France, Uncle D, 🌴🌞
    I have given a translation of this song, there are two years on lyrics translate, with all the explanations you need to understand why French/Spanish is used in the text (the song’s theme, in fact). You’ll also find there a translation of “Le vent nous portera” (The wind will carry us), another banger of them. 😉
    Peace, folks. ☮👈😎

  • @patrickblanchard4575
    @patrickblanchard4575 Місяць тому

    Noir Désir is a French Band!

  • @kikoo2023
    @kikoo2023 2 місяці тому +1

    As many people, i l'Ile-de-France this band until the drama

  • @guiluxfantastic
    @guiluxfantastic Місяць тому

    The title of the album, Tostaky, is the slang contraction of “todo está aquí” in Spanish (meaning “everything is here”), one of the rallying slogans of the Mexican revolutionaries led by Emiliano Zapata.

  • @thaeros
    @thaeros 7 місяців тому +1

    the BAND name is noir desir and the song "tostaky" for what i heard it was a " shorten word" for " todo esta aqui" i don't know what it mean in spanish i had that it's "all is ours" but i don't speak spanish even if spain is right nex to my coutry ( france)!

  • @arianemartin9659
    @arianemartin9659 Місяць тому

    Mon groupe préféré ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @christopheambroise9220
    @christopheambroise9220 2 місяці тому +2

    Tostaky = abreviation in spanish : todos estan ahi , here there use castillan slang .

  • @blackcyril
    @blackcyril 2 місяці тому

    He sings also a texte or song from Léo ferré "les armes". Fantastic lyrics and his voice is excellent.

  • @Redgethechemist
    @Redgethechemist 2 місяці тому

    I was in the crowd for this concert! It was crazy. And the striped flag is Brittany’s flag, inspired by the American one. You can spot it in almost every event in France.

  • @QuirinJoseph
    @QuirinJoseph 5 місяців тому +2

    From this band ''l'homme pressé'' that is an extraordinary song with the clip u may like that, sure🎉,

  • @gropichgraupich2856
    @gropichgraupich2856 2 місяці тому +1

    A ton etoile ... another masterpiece

  • @etiennebrun8760
    @etiennebrun8760 Місяць тому

    I WAS IN THAT CROWD IN 2001 ! :D

  • @SLV06
    @SLV06 2 місяці тому +1

    U have a new subscriber ! ✌

  • @babarizz
    @babarizz 28 днів тому +1

    Try Mano Negra a french rock band from 80's they mixed Spanish and French lyrics (Manu Chao was the leader if you know him)... Popular rock punk rock

  • @chrismeng1725
    @chrismeng1725 8 місяців тому +4

    J'y était ...

  • @manoul71
    @manoul71 7 місяців тому +1

    excellent !!

  • @sseb421
    @sseb421 25 днів тому

    I was at that concert ❤

  • @musicsavage
    @musicsavage 7 місяців тому +2

    Je crois qu'il s'est bien fait décrasser les oreilles le ricain! 😂😂

  • @jeremytari856
    @jeremytari856 25 днів тому

    Le vent l'emportera est magnifique

  • @corsept777
    @corsept777 2 місяці тому +4

    Et pourquoi pas essayer un bon groupe de metal français.....Gojira....avec le titre : born for one thing

  • @tylerdurden7854
    @tylerdurden7854 21 день тому +1

    Il y avait dans ce groupe l essence de la rage des français

    • @pitikiwi01
      @pitikiwi01 6 днів тому

      surtout l'essence d'un assassin et d'un monstre

  • @etiennebrun8760
    @etiennebrun8760 Місяць тому

    That's not "your" flag in the audience. It's the "Gwen a Du" (transl : the White and black) : the flag of Brittany. Because this concert was in Brittany, in Carrhaix during "Les Vieilles Charrues" one of the biggest french festival.
    The Gwen A Du might be seen in any event, from Cycling Races, to soccer matches, strikes/demonstrations, fests, olympics, ... all over the world ! (because Brittons are proud AF of their culture and flag)

  • @pmp1350
    @pmp1350 2 місяці тому +2

    Thé flag is the britany flag ! French people don’t love flags like Americans…

  •  11 місяців тому +10

    It was not your flag aha, it was Brittany flag ! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Brittany

  • @naama4
    @naama4 4 дні тому +1

    Le chanteur de ce groupe est un monstre, qui a tué sa maitresse, et provoqué la mort de son épouse

  • @floodlandbbs
    @floodlandbbs 25 днів тому

    @ReactionsbyD very funny video ! thank you !!! I first live Tostaky on stage back in 1993! (not 2001!) it was a totally insane, now time is gone, NoirDésir is dead :( you should try ShakaPonk live !

  • @retropaganda8442
    @retropaganda8442 8 місяців тому +3

    The black and white American flag is actually Brittany's flag ;p

  • @skyzoDBois
    @skyzoDBois 8 місяців тому +1

    One of my favorite band ever, i live near the place of this festival and my brother was at this concert, a legendary one. (and it's not an american flag, it's the flag of Brittany ;) )

  • @Sir77Hill
    @Sir77Hill 10 місяців тому +5

    This guy is a killer... I mean, literally...
    But still, this song is 🔥

  • @pascalsettimelli449
    @pascalsettimelli449 7 місяців тому

    C’était cool merci

  • @sonmi4517
    @sonmi4517 7 місяців тому +3

    Hi, not US Flag but Brittany flag. Same shape so could be confusing. The "Vielles charrues" (old plows) festival is seated in Brittany (west area of France). See en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Brittany.
    Kisses from France.

  • @jujunantes752
    @jujunantes752 2 дні тому

    The flag is Brittany's flag. It looks a lot like the American flag but is black and white (Gwen a du in breton language).

  • @sylvainesteve5222
    @sylvainesteve5222 7 місяців тому

    « Métal urbain » was such a kick ass group from France, a early punk group. Listen to the 45t « Paris Maquis »

  • @ciscomars
    @ciscomars 3 місяці тому +1

    Tostaky=Todo esta qui

  • @rapidoo51
    @rapidoo51 11 місяців тому +1

    Now it's time for Till Lindemann ft' Apocalyptica - Helden

  • @tylerdurden7854
    @tylerdurden7854 12 днів тому

    Le vent nous portera

  • @michellaporte958
    @michellaporte958 5 днів тому

    à l'époque, en ecoutant çà, je me suis dit, que ND s'inspirait trés fortement de Soundgarden, période Badmotherfucker

  • @338-p5e
    @338-p5e 5 місяців тому +1

    Very difficult to understand lyrics of this band, because there is a lot of histories and politics references. If a french don't know the band before, he don't understand all anymore. A lot of people, because it is in a summer festival. The singer is French and comme from Britain (in France). Lyrics are very complicated, even for a french...

    • @Lili-vd3zh
      @Lili-vd3zh 3 місяці тому +2

      @@338-p5e non le chanteur est bordelais

  • @PersonOM
    @PersonOM 3 місяці тому

    Oh, oh, oh ! Si t'aime bien Noir désir (et dieu sait que si je te dit ça, ça va le rendre fou parce que ça trahis juste que le peu de considération que le rock à dans notre pays tellement la scène peu étre riche de talent.) mais j'aimerais te présenter Le groupe Français CAFÉ BERTRAND.
    Le groupe qui m'a fait aimer profondément le Rock.

  • @pitikiwi01
    @pitikiwi01 6 днів тому

    c'est drôle de voir l'engouement et la fidélité des fans ci dessous alors que cet homme est un assassin et un monstre. comme quoi, on en a vraiment rien à foutre des femmes et ça changera jamais.

  • @MrPaulangela
    @MrPaulangela Місяць тому +2

    Et nous pleurons encore Marie , assassinée par ce gennial chanteur😢

  • @Cascas422
    @Cascas422 7 місяців тому +1

    😍😍😍

  • @DarthShayanTool.
    @DarthShayanTool. 6 місяців тому

    This song is about the USA ^^

  • @ggousier
    @ggousier 6 місяців тому +6

    Quand tu vois ce que pouvait être la scène français il y a un peu plus de 20 ans et quand tu vois Aya Nakamura aujourd'hui t'as envie de te pendre 🤣.

    • @salome1009
      @salome1009 4 місяці тому

      Pardon j'ai pas l'habitude d'intervenir, surtout pout faire de l'humour noir, mais en lisant les commentaires je ne pouvais pas m'empêcher de penser à Christina Rady... Et là, je vous lis... So ironic :) J'y pense tristement, et on l'oublie souvent... For those who don't know, Christina was Cantat's wife, supporting him during the process for murder, and always here for him. She suicides, hanging herself, few ears ago, after talking about cruely he made on her. So sad. I can(t hear Cantat's voice any more.

    • @ggousier
      @ggousier 4 місяці тому

      @@salome1009 Très noir pour le coup là, limite glauque.

    • @salome1009
      @salome1009 4 місяці тому

      @@ggousier oui j'avoue, je suis pas fière de moi, mais parler de pendaison sur le thème de Cantat/ND, c'est un peu osé... sorry, peace and love.

    • @Nosferatu1969
      @Nosferatu1969 24 дні тому

      parce que maintenant les français sont remplacés, meme dans la musique!!! soyons réaliste!!!!!

  • @assassindelasaucisse.4039
    @assassindelasaucisse.4039 2 місяці тому

    Sorry, it's a Corsican flag, not a US flag ;p

  • @vvv-n9k
    @vvv-n9k 8 місяців тому +3

    boycott in France but great song

  • @ludwigg98859
    @ludwigg98859 День тому

    hello my friend, i’m French and i recommanded you to listen Hubert Félix Thiéfaine :)

  • @alarak6360
    @alarak6360 8 місяців тому +5

    Try the band " Shaka Ponk ", you'll love them and the energy they have

  • @thaeros
    @thaeros 7 місяців тому

    noir desir was a popular band until the singer killed his girlfriend ( maybe accidentaly they was both drunk and drugged but he still had killed his girl)! At that time the others band member mostly thow him out and broke the band and he was condamed some peoples said not enought i will said we don't knowed what really happened if it was an accidental murder or a volontary murder so i'm reserving my jugement!

  • @hede1574
    @hede1574 7 місяців тому

    try "Freedom For King Kong - Sodocratie"

  • @jpmissdeNice
    @jpmissdeNice 7 місяців тому +1

    Orgasmic song

  • @evetoutsimple3338
    @evetoutsimple3338 3 місяці тому +4

    Idem, je ne peux plus l'écouter. Il a tué Marie Trintignant, adorable actrice.
    Rouée de coups et laissée à l'agonie dans leur chambre d'hôtel. 🤔😠

  • @Effet-danger
    @Effet-danger 3 місяці тому +2

    Et je croyait que les francais ne savait pas faire de rock n'roll si sa c pas une mandale dans les dents c quoi ? 🤟🤟

  • @jadejade3092
    @jadejade3092 26 днів тому

    Pas un groupe de scène pour moi. Les enregistrement studio sont mille fois mieux. Et le Tostaki qu’il chante 😂😂😂😂 non!!! Pas moyen

  • @petro3556
    @petro3556 4 місяці тому

    alors soyons désinvolte, n'ayons l'air de rien....

  • @laurentusson7738
    @laurentusson7738 7 місяців тому +1

    Essaye aussi shaka ponk, un autre groupe de rock français très engagé politiquement

  • @Leonduprat
    @Leonduprat 5 днів тому

    I never liked them ! One of the few Rock Bands we had in France ended up in such a disaster with the lead singer the leftist rebel who thought he was Marlon Brando of some sort punched
    his girlfriend more than 20 times and left her to die like a dog in a sleazy hotel Room by 2003 Game Over for his career

  • @preventiondechets1767
    @preventiondechets1767 7 місяців тому +1

    il faut que tu écoutes aussi du Shaka Ponk.

  • @MrBlakemortimer
    @MrBlakemortimer 8 місяців тому +5

    Faut boycotter noir désir point barre

    • @333amoromniavincit9
      @333amoromniavincit9 7 місяців тому +1

      Et pourquoi ???

    • @syl3556-gs1zx
      @syl3556-gs1zx 7 місяців тому +3

      @@333amoromniavincit9 peut etre parce qu il a tué une femme a coup de poing dans la gueulle , vraiment t as oublié ça ? STUPIDE QUESTION

    • @333amoromniavincit9
      @333amoromniavincit9 7 місяців тому +7

      @@syl3556-gs1zx Et noir désir en est responsable ? Stupide réaction !

    • @syl3556-gs1zx
      @syl3556-gs1zx 7 місяців тому

      @@333amoromniavincit9 c est le leader du groupe , et pourquoi defendre un assassin? abruti

    • @kpm3254
      @kpm3254 6 місяців тому +4

      Ne pas confondre le groupe avec la personne.....vraiment une reaction totalement debile......De plus il a été juger et fait sa peine mais si cela ne te convient pas libre a toi de contacter les instances juridiques pour ré étudier le dossier!