Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd Ratings *Learn about Improveasy here* improveasy.com/eco4-check Subscribe to United We Stand here: www.uwsonline.com/subscribe.php
Was really happy with the performance, especially in the first half. I felt taking Zirkzee off blunted our attacking threat and control of the game somewhat. It’s was great to meet you outside the ground and pick up United we stand. Keep up the good work & safe travels to Italy!
We looked really good until the subs. Our possession and chance creation in the first half was excellent. Faded by the end of the match and could have lost it. Signs of improvement though, but two tough league matches coming up and they will show us whether we have made progress or not.
I think I'm more disappointed with yesterdays result than any others so far this season, Utd were so much better than they have been in a long time & just couldn't get a goal, should've been 3 points.
@@Chriztefur Seems to do extremely well internationally for his managers! And you cannot fault his goal contribution, which is or was recently the highest in the league. Agree he is Hollywood with licence to be. But he needs a club manager with ability to change tactically but he doesn’t have one!
He tries passes that just aren't on. Nothing to do with vision. These passes are just not on. Carrick, Beckham or scholes would never attempt some of these Hollywood passes. Nothing to do with the manager.
Zirkzee is becoming a vital player and he is the type of link and continuity player we have needed . A lot of things come from his short slick passes . It was a good game whereby the goalkeepers decided the result , but Man Utd dominated the play and had the majority of the chances .
Bruno should’ve been subbed off. ETHs substitutions are a real concern. When w as the last time you can remember ETH changing the formation or tactics midway through the game? He just doesn’t seem to have a plan B? Being stubborn is never a good thing.
Stop blaming the manager do u realize we got alot of dunce players who cannot multi task its a big concerns our fans doesn't realize we keep blaming managers stop the bs don't let the players get a pass because wen they see comments like this they think they r not the problem thats wat been killing us for ages these players stay on social media and they strive on blaming managers we need to b more measured in our analysis
@@michaelphillips4470 3 years and over a half of a BILLION POUNDS spent on these “dunce players”. This is his team, these are his tactics. 2-2-1 to start the season, 11th place. 👍you’re right, this is GREAT! 🙄
I don't know... I don't trust players who are just getting to grips with Plan A to be capable of pivoting to a Plan B mid-game. That just sounds like a recipe for disaster.
Rashford barely touched the ball yet gets the same score as someone who was knitting our play together and could have scored. As soon as Zirkzee went off we lost our flow
@@SeriousBartYT Perhaps you need to go back to school to understand the nuances of the English language. It is perfectly exceptable for a fan to use the term, "We." When talking about their club. "We are United."
@@harveysmith100 Oh I completely got what you were implying. I was curious to know why you used the word 'we'. The way I look at it is that the soccer players are just mere employees of manchester united incorporation, their jerseys are uniforms for their workplace and just like they don't come and see us at work, I don't see a point in people seeing them work.
@@SeriousBartYT Like you said, the way you look at it. The way most of us look at it, is closer to a religion. Many of those players wore that shirt when they were eight years old, to them, it is everything.
Bruno deserved no more than a 5…. Very poor game from him. Was hoping he would be subbed off tbh… Max deserved a 7 as well imo. Subs made little to no difference…
I think it’s time to start addressing the Bruno sized elephant in the room. He’s brilliant at times but also creates some issues with this lack of versatility and attitude.
Cheers mate, enjoy the trip. I think there's a problem with the final edit Andy, right at the end of the scrolling scores it seemed to fade just as Jonny's name came up 🤣
Disagree on some of the ratings Andy, Rashford was complete trash. Zirkzee made the whole team tick. Bruno dropped a 3/10 and stunk the place up. Holjund in for Bruno for the Spurs game.
Been looking forward to Andy's take on the game , I actually think we are playing some really good football at the moment, bad result but seeds of something, and to be fair onana won us a point but we should have won the game
Everything good came through Zirkzee when he came off and Rashford came on we lost all impetus. I don't get this Rashford Is playing well, he scored a few goals but not playing well
Andy be honest! A decision has to be made about Bruno Fernandes! Yet again Bruno Fernandes is shocking- When is this player going to get dropped & ETH finds another way to play without Bruno- Even Old Man Eriksen is looking Sharper We Need A Plan For Bruno Fernandes but it feels like the Bruno topic many Fan Channels are Choosing to Avoid- With Zirkzee looking more like a 10, do we still need Bruno- & wouldnt Zirkzee thrive better in the Bruno Position!
Bruno isnt firing - he was a bit off it today. I dont understand the decision to bench MR10. Maybe fear of injury crises but you've got to play him when he's on form
A player who hadn't hit the net since March scores 3 in 2 then is dropped and it's a football decision? Not a fan of Rashford as much but that is a baffling decision
I think it was more to give Garnacho a start after a few substitute appearances where he's smashed it. I also think he did it with an eye on Wednesday.
Onana - 8 Dalot - 7 De Ligt - 7 Martinez - 7 Mazraoui - 6 Mainoo - 6 Eriksson - 7 Amad - 6 Garnacho - 6 Fernandes - 6 Zirkzee - 6 Subs: (Didn’t give ratings) Rashford Hojlund Ugarte And after doing this I see Andy has recapped at 8:26
After watching Liverpool's highlights from yesterday, I'm far from upbeat about United. We remain so far off the form needed. Bruno was in and out yesterday and that lack of fluency is all over the squad. Very happy to be completely wrong but top 4 is looking a long way off yet again.
Cant believe how low we have sunk,this was another toothless performance, better side in the first half but their manager improved them after the break, in contrast Ten Hag had us going backwards with his changes, we did not deserve to win!
We got battered there 4-0 last year, are we seeing progress, they went to Brighton and selhurst and controlled large parts but were just not seeing it in the results which is inevitably how you get judged
you need to be sprinkling the gold dust to stay in the team, i love andy but i didn't see much gold dust from anyone in the front 3 and in the midfield. the back 4, the keeper and zirkzee looked really good, amad and grenacho are decent the rest are struggling.
People have to wake up to the fact that Bruno is simply not good enough.......he's a second rate player and will never cut it in the Premiership. If Ten Hag's system is going to work, he has to replace Fernandes and Rashford.......the pair of them are consistently inconsistent, and cannot perform at the level that will get us challenging for the league. If Fergie was in the dugout, those 2 wouldn't even make it on to the bench until they could prove they can be reliable performers......it's that simple.
Can't score in the premier League shocking again don't know what to make of it we needed to get Harry Kane when he became available man is a goal machine these are the players we need at the club proven at the top level we were always able to get top players now it's a struggle big time ffs
Andy is a manager and a manager as big as a club like ours supposed to manage to always get the team he's managing the vitals points the cycle needs 🤷♂️ well this lads outta of his depths with his favouritism management how he could not see Bruno was having a mare and not whip him off is beyond me when he whipped Casa off against the bindippers that ain't management putting favouritism over 3 points for the cub which is to be honest is to big a job for the man his woeful substitutions ain't helping the so called project even, last gasp management , I just see another shift in management of our club mid season and favouritism is going to be the mans downfall ,we need points not mollycoddlin sulky players that's not putting in a shift and no doubt believe me he'll pick another player out soon enough to have a go at to cover up his shitty management of a cub just to big for his management qualities 🇾🇪💯🇾🇪
Is it a coincidence? After Bruno signed the last contract, before this new contract, he had a stinking few months, almost a season. I hope he doesn't repeat his poor form this time. "HOLLYWOOD" passes? People are being influenced by Mark Goldbridge....That's his language :-) Last night he criticised Bruno for playing a pass with the outside of his foot. I've got news for him, there are people that feel just as comfortable playing with the outside as with the inside of the foot, all depends what you want to do with the ball, direction you want to bend the ball will dictate a lot on what part of the foot you kick the ball. I don't remember anybody teaching me how to kick a ball at the age 6 but I do remember my school PE teacher forcing me to kick with my right foot as well. I learned the rest playing on the street with my mates, that's what usually happens in South America.
Kick it with his knees if he wants but the ball needs to arrive with a member of your own team. He's a pain in the backside and needs to be taken off when he has these games.
Poor team selection and failure to respond to Glasner’s changes, followed by awful substitutions, are repeatable offences by our inept manager. GONE BY NOVEMBER
Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd Ratings *Learn about Improveasy here* improveasy.com/eco4-check
Subscribe to United We Stand here: www.uwsonline.com/subscribe.php
Maz a 6 are you joking....he was one of our best players!!
As Andy says, all ratings are verified in advance of publication by the relevant authorities
Agreed, always an option and trustworthy on the ball
Have to agree I thought Maz was impressive throughout
This is the one that stuck out, at least a 6.5-7
@PeteMarshall-tp3ih
Agreed mate, He is seemingly always one of best players. Been the standout signing so far.
For me the only starter who deserved less than 7 was Bruno
Bruno 5 for me, Maz a 7 or 8.
Was really happy with the performance, especially in the first half. I felt taking Zirkzee off blunted our attacking threat and control of the game somewhat. It’s was great to meet you outside the ground and pick up United we stand. Keep up the good work & safe travels to Italy!
We looked really good until the subs. Our possession and chance creation in the first half was excellent. Faded by the end of the match and could have lost it. Signs of improvement though, but two tough league matches coming up and they will show us whether we have made progress or not.
We haven’t mate. Or at least enough progression. The manager repeats his mistakes game after game. Gone by November.
I think I'm more disappointed with yesterdays result than any others so far this season, Utd were so much better than they have been in a long time & just couldn't get a goal, should've been 3 points.
At least the performance was good though. We can build on that
Bruno is a bit of an enigma. He's a top class player but he can also be a problem.
……… and he doesn’t have a manager capable of decisions to help him!
@@eamonnpotts5063Lmao, Bruno has been like this for every manager he’s played for. He’s Hollywood, and that can be good but it’s also an issue
@@Chriztefur
Seems to do extremely well internationally for his managers! And you cannot fault his goal contribution, which is or was recently the highest in the league.
Agree he is Hollywood with licence to be. But he needs a club manager with ability to change tactically but he doesn’t have one!
He tries passes that just aren't on. Nothing to do with vision. These passes are just not on. Carrick, Beckham or scholes would never attempt some of these Hollywood passes. Nothing to do with the manager.
He struggles playing half ground
Lack of goals in this side is a huge concern...
Zirkzee is becoming a vital player and he is the type of link and continuity player we have needed . A lot of things come from his short slick passes . It was a good game whereby the goalkeepers decided the result , but Man Utd dominated the play and had the majority of the chances .
Zirkzee will be that double figure goal scorer, sure of it. Hoiland will chip in also. Patience by us & confidence by them. United will get there.
@@SpireUtd Oh yes please. Hope springs eternal. When things click it will be brilliant to watch. 👍
It all fell apart when Zirkzee went off.
Bruno should’ve been subbed off. ETHs substitutions are a real concern. When w as the last time you can remember ETH changing the formation or tactics midway through the game? He just doesn’t seem to have a plan B? Being stubborn is never a good thing.
Stop blaming the manager do u realize we got alot of dunce players who cannot multi task its a big concerns our fans doesn't realize we keep blaming managers stop the bs don't let the players get a pass because wen they see comments like this they think they r not the problem thats wat been killing us for ages these players stay on social media and they strive on blaming managers we need to b more measured in our analysis
@@michaelphillips4470 3 years and over a half of a BILLION POUNDS spent on these “dunce players”. This is his team, these are his tactics. 2-2-1 to start the season, 11th place. 👍you’re right, this is GREAT! 🙄
The Manager should have a plan B, before or during the game
I don't know... I don't trust players who are just getting to grips with Plan A to be capable of pivoting to a Plan B mid-game. That just sounds like a recipe for disaster.
Rashford and Zirkzee same score? 😂😂😂😂 English passport of course 🤦♂️
Rashford barely touched the ball yet gets the same score as someone who was knitting our play together and could have scored. As soon as Zirkzee went off we lost our flow
United got worse when Rashford came on
Same reason why redknapp is crying about him, english passport. Makes you sick
Just subbed because this is always a good review.
We know we should have won but the performance keeps getting better.
Who are we? Did you play?
@@SeriousBartYT Perhaps you need to go back to school to understand the nuances of the English language.
It is perfectly exceptable for a fan to use the term, "We." When talking about their club.
"We are United."
@@harveysmith100 Oh I completely got what you were implying. I was curious to know why you used the word 'we'. The way I look at it is that the soccer players are just mere employees of manchester united incorporation, their jerseys are uniforms for their workplace and just like they don't come and see us at work, I don't see a point in people seeing them work.
@@SeriousBartYT Like you said, the way you look at it.
The way most of us look at it, is closer to a religion.
Many of those players wore that shirt when they were eight years old, to them, it is everything.
@@SeriousBartYT 🤔??? 🤪
Bruno deserved no more than a 5…. Very poor game from him. Was hoping he would be subbed off tbh…
Max deserved a 7 as well imo.
Subs made little to no difference…
Bruno exposed ua-cam.com/users/shortsU3nN5Hh0ZNA?si=bFmzenVSVmslqbXW
I think it’s time to start addressing the Bruno sized elephant in the room. He’s brilliant at times but also creates some issues with this lack of versatility and attitude.
We’re knitting together. We need to up the tempo, it’s that simple.
Nice one Andy - safe travels 🇾🇪
Cheers mate, enjoy the trip. I think there's a problem with the final edit Andy, right at the end of the scrolling scores it seemed to fade just as Jonny's name came up 🤣
The editor needed something to entertain themselves with after a 0-0
Dalot was super tonight. Right back out of possession. Midfielder in possession. Never stopped running. Brilliant 👏
Disagree on some of the ratings Andy, Rashford was complete trash. Zirkzee made the whole team tick. Bruno dropped a 3/10 and stunk the place up. Holjund in for Bruno for the Spurs game.
Bruno has been shocking so far. Odd that our captain doesn't get more stick.
Been looking forward to Andy's take on the game , I actually think we are playing some really good football at the moment, bad result but seeds of something, and to be fair onana won us a point but we should have won the game
Fair comment
When is it time to start having the Bruno conversation?
Last season!
I already started ua-cam.com/users/shortsU3nN5Hh0ZNA?si=bFmzenVSVmslqbXW
Garnacho was worth more than a six?
Andy Mitten verifier service😂! Thanks Andy🎉
they all get 9 for that first half. (Bruno kept giving the ball away, though, especially 2nd half)
Martinez 7? He was realistically lucky to be on the pitch
Red mist, desperation & madness got into him 😂 bless.
Everything good came through Zirkzee when he came off and Rashford came on we lost all impetus. I don't get this Rashford Is playing well, he scored a few goals but not playing well
Conversation needed about Bruno, worst player on the pitch, he needs a spell on the bench
United can't sell him as he's just gotten a new deal. @richyclubsport5155
Really crap start to the season. You can put up with his strange habits when he's also scoring but he keeps missing great chances
Exactly or at least take him off the pitch and get someone else on.
Andy be honest! A decision has to be made about Bruno Fernandes!
Yet again Bruno Fernandes is shocking-
When is this player going to get dropped & ETH finds another way to play without Bruno- Even Old Man Eriksen is looking Sharper
We Need A Plan For Bruno Fernandes but it feels like the Bruno topic many Fan Channels are Choosing to Avoid-
With Zirkzee looking more like a 10, do we still need Bruno- & wouldnt Zirkzee thrive better in the Bruno Position!
Exactly what I've just posted pal 👌💯👌
Another bruno stinkfest this season m8. Thats 5 from 5 now for him. Awful
Like Rashford soon as they get a new contract they go backwards
As always….🙏🏾
Bruno isnt firing - he was a bit off it today. I dont understand the decision to bench MR10. Maybe fear of injury crises but you've got to play him when he's on form
A player who hadn't hit the net since March scores 3 in 2 then is dropped and it's a football decision? Not a fan of Rashford as much but that is a baffling decision
I think it was more to give Garnacho a start after a few substitute appearances where he's smashed it. I also think he did it with an eye on Wednesday.
@@coconutzmilk true. however Garnacho impacts better as a sub sometimes but he did impact the game. Unlucky not to score tbf.
Onana - 8
Dalot - 7
De Ligt - 7
Martinez - 7
Mazraoui - 6
Mainoo - 6
Eriksson - 7
Amad - 6
Garnacho - 6
Fernandes - 6
Zirkzee - 6
Subs: (Didn’t give ratings)
Rashford
Hojlund
Ugarte
And after doing this I see Andy has recapped at 8:26
After watching Liverpool's highlights from yesterday, I'm far from upbeat about United. We remain so far off the form needed. Bruno was in and out yesterday and that lack of fluency is all over the squad. Very happy to be completely wrong but top 4 is looking a long way off yet again.
If Onana doesn't pull off the saves the picture would look very bleak.
And if their keeper doesn’t do the same? Since when did football become about never conceeding a chance?
The mowers cut the grass not clean up around the ground 😂😂😂
Cant believe how low we have sunk,this was another toothless performance, better side in the first half but their manager improved them after the break, in contrast Ten Hag had us going backwards with his changes, we did not deserve to win!
Stewards at grounds must hate Andy, always the last to be thrown out! 😂
6 for mazraoui 7.5 easy at least he didnt give rashford a 9 this time
Bruno was a 5 at best. Zirkzee and Mazraoui more than 6's. Same for Amad. When JZ and Amad went off so did our impetus and ingenuity.
We got battered there 4-0 last year, are we seeing progress, they went to Brighton and selhurst and controlled large parts but were just not seeing it in the results which is inevitably how you get judged
It felt like a loss...
Bruno is a big problem and has been for a long time
6 for Maz wtf?😂
The season is already over because of the silly useless manager. Wield the sword.
Mazraoui should not be 6, he was the best player on the pitch. He should be given 8.
you need to be sprinkling the gold dust to stay in the team, i love andy but i didn't see much gold dust from anyone in the front 3 and in the midfield. the back 4, the keeper and zirkzee looked really good, amad and grenacho are decent the rest are struggling.
Amad god dust to stay in the team like Rashford?? 😂
People have to wake up to the fact that Bruno is simply not good enough.......he's a second rate player and will never cut it in the Premiership. If Ten Hag's system is going to work, he has to replace Fernandes and Rashford.......the pair of them are consistently inconsistent, and cannot perform at the level that will get us challenging for the league.
If Fergie was in the dugout, those 2 wouldn't even make it on to the bench until they could prove they can be reliable performers......it's that simple.
Andy Maz 6 !!! come on
Off on these scores
Can't score in the premier League shocking again don't know what to make of it we needed to get Harry Kane when he became available man is a goal machine these are the players we need at the club proven at the top level we were always able to get top players now it's a struggle big time ffs
Andy is a manager and a manager as big as a club like ours supposed to manage to always get the team he's managing the vitals points the cycle needs 🤷♂️ well this lads outta of his depths with his favouritism management how he could not see Bruno was having a mare and not whip him off is beyond me when he whipped Casa off against the bindippers that ain't management putting favouritism over 3 points for the cub which is to be honest is to big a job for the man his woeful substitutions ain't helping the so called project even, last gasp management , I just see another shift in management of our club mid season and favouritism is going to be the mans downfall ,we need points not mollycoddlin sulky players that's not putting in a shift and no doubt believe me he'll pick another player out soon enough to have a go at to cover up his shitty management of a cub just to big for his management qualities 🇾🇪💯🇾🇪
Bruno was horrible
Rashford has not been playing well. He has scored a couple of goals. He was shit today.
1 step forward 2 steps back as per with this club…
What’s the two steps back? Seems pretty clear we are progressing to where we want to be. Getting better in every game.
Mazraoui 6 is a joke surely?
Is it a coincidence? After Bruno signed the last contract, before this new contract, he had a stinking few months, almost a season. I hope he doesn't repeat his poor form this time.
"HOLLYWOOD" passes? People are being influenced by Mark Goldbridge....That's his language :-)
Last night he criticised Bruno for playing a pass with the outside of his foot. I've got news for him, there are people that feel just as comfortable playing with the outside as with the inside of the foot, all depends what you want to do with the ball, direction you want to bend the ball will dictate a lot on what part of the foot you kick the ball.
I don't remember anybody teaching me how to kick a ball at the age 6 but I do remember my school PE teacher forcing me to kick with my right foot as well. I learned the rest playing on the street with my mates, that's what usually happens in South America.
Kick it with his knees if he wants but the ball needs to arrive with a member of your own team. He's a pain in the backside and needs to be taken off when he has these games.
Poor team selection and failure to respond to Glasner’s changes, followed by awful substitutions, are repeatable offences by our inept manager.
GONE BY NOVEMBER
You’re an inept fan. Zero critical thinking skills.
Can't believe the hate I'm seeing directed at Bruno
No mention of Martinez two footer and he gets a 7? Maz one of the best players gets a 6?
Nothings changing here.🫣🤬