If nothing else, the level of transparency (ala Compass Box, etc) is just exactly what we nerds are looking for. So many blended Scotches are just 20% good stuff and 80% cheap grain filler. A touch of good quality grain just to fill out mostly malts is a different idea. And at the price they're going for is well worth it.
Nailed it. Compass Box kinda showed the way, set it up for those coming next to knock it down. I have alot of time for those that are following this format. High Malt content is a must. Like you said, price is right too. Cheers Sugar Kitty! 🥃
Yeah, I keep forgetting I have a Adelphi Private stock open. I should put them head-to-head. But then I'd have drink blends and you know my stance on that XD Good video! Glad to see you keeping going =D
Thanks man, it's good to be back to feeling closer to 100%. I'd be interested in hearing about that side by side too! But, with so much good malt I'm not surprised to hear you forgot about that Adelphi Private Stock Blend. Cheers buddy! 🥃
C$50 Alberta a good price. I pay 70% more in Hong Kong but still an acceptable price and value. Sounds like your getting your voice back! Good whisky better review!
Yeah, $50 is an excellent price. Unfortunate that it's more but it's encouraging to hear that you're able to get it in Hong Kong as well! Slowly but surely with the voice. And strangely enough, I was watching hockey highlights yesterday of a game between Hong Kong and North Korea. Random lol. Cheers eh! 🥃
Nice one Matt! I've not tried this one before but if I'm being honest I'm not super excited about it either. If it comes my way sure I'll give it a shot but with so many whiskies out there and in my cabinet I hardly see myself reaching to this one over and over again. Hey taste is subjective so I'm happy you love it and I could edit my response once I try it 😅 Cheers my friend 🥃
Yeah I hear you Sertug. I think that's why I landed on it being a bottle I wouldn't replace. I can see the charm, but will I got to this often enough over my other bottles or even over Ardnamurchan AD? It's a fair question. Can't deny the Price/Performance ratio is great. Hope you get to try it man. Thanks for watching buddy! Cheers! 🥃
Unfortunately, I don't like most Ardnamurchan (the exception being the Paul Launois), so I don't really like Maclean's Nose either; I'll stick with the Thompson Brothers TB/BSW for blended in that price/quality bracket...
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Ardnamurchan and Maclean's Nose, it is good to hear input from a dissenting opinion. TB/BSW is no slouch whatsoever and a completely different profile so it's a great option to try for anyone who doesn't click with this. Cheers Andrew! 🥃
Hey Matt, I have no experience with Maclean's nose yet but I picked up Ardnamurchan AD recently. It's a bit young, hits on a lot notes for my palate. Yeah it is more money in Ontario as usual but at least some bottles showed up here. Appreciate you sharing your thoughts on Maclean's. I think I will wait it out. Cheers!
Glad the bottle at least showed up in Ontario for those who are looking for it. It's a good bottle, but with that Ardnamurchan already in your set I'd say you're in good hands. Cheers Rohit! 🥃
Hey Matt great review and channel! Wondering if you’ve had the Compass Box Glasgow Blend and how this compares? I love the CB blend, it’s got a hit of peat and the profile seems similar to this MacLean’s Nose. Cheers!
Thanks Mark, I really appreciate the feedback. I had the Glasgow Blend a few years ago and I did enjoy that Blend, I'd say more so than the Artist Blend. I'd say the big difference for me is how spirit forward, and mineralic with a touch of salinity the Maclean's Nose is. The Glasgow Blend is, from my memory, a decent comparable. Cheers Mark! 🥃
Maclean’s is certainly hard to beat on value. I paid $35 in California. That’s significantly cheaper than what I’d pay for other craft presented blends from compass Box or Thompson Bros. It wouldn’t supplant my favorite budget Single Malt (Benromach 10 @ $40-$45) which is clearly not craft presented. I’m an unabashed Benromach Fanboy though. Whisky of The Year? A bit of hyperbole methinks, but to each their own. Cheers.
$35 USD is undoubtedly a fantastic price. But I am fully there with you on the Benromach 10 at that price. I'm on my 3rd bottle of Benromach 10 and will continue to replace it. Strong take on the W.O.T.Y. topic too. Cheers Tim! 🥃
Great review & honest one too....Now W.O.T.Y. 2024 ? No way, it's too soon & I'm sure there' ll be better whiskies released this year. W.O.T.Y. 2023 then ? (makes more sense), for me yes, but only in my Blended whisky (all countries) category & also ok in the "best value" one too...but in 2023, if you've seen my 2 parts "unending" Highlights of the Year video, you'll notice a bunch of greater whiskies released imho (starting by an indie SC of Ardnamurchan, btw !) & especially a stratospheric French one which completely kicked out the Scots, for example...and everyone else too...(not value wise, mind you, I gave a red flag price wise to the shop "storepicking" it, otherwise I'll already have the bottle on board, believe me). Now if I had a bottle of this Maclean's nose on hand, I might be able to evaluate it better than I do now, so we'll see...Cheers !
It is a solid whisky, no doubt and very capable amongst it's like class of value or affordable Blended Scotch whiskies. But for me as well, it is not my pick for a whisky to represent this year. I do know Ralfy puts alot of thought into his "Whisky For The Year" selections and with this one it seems he was highlighting an affordable but quality bottle of whisky with cost of living and inflation up. Hope a bottle of this makes it's way to you Greg! Cheers my friend! 🥃
Thanks Tyler! Man, this sickness kicks yer arse! 37 days in now, one day the cough will go away. Sounds like you're in it too. Here's hoping we're both feeling better post trade deadline. Let's see if the Canucks get something else done before the deadine comes. Cheers buddy! 🥃
@scrimmy45 Didn't mean to offend the church of Ralfy lol. He does make the point every year to emphasize the FOR the year but I make mistakes. Cheers 🥃
If nothing else, the level of transparency (ala Compass Box, etc) is just exactly what we nerds are looking for. So many blended Scotches are just 20% good stuff and 80% cheap grain filler. A touch of good quality grain just to fill out mostly malts is a different idea. And at the price they're going for is well worth it.
Nailed it. Compass Box kinda showed the way, set it up for those coming next to knock it down. I have alot of time for those that are following this format. High Malt content is a must. Like you said, price is right too. Cheers Sugar Kitty! 🥃
Close to 2000. I’ll be looking for this. Thanks.
Just passed 2000! Didn't know if others would notice it. Thanks for watching. Cheers eh! 🥃
I have not seen it on the shelf yet, but .... this sounds like it would hit for me. Great review and tasting. Cheers!
Thanks Jon! I feel like it would be up your alley too! Cheers buddy! 🥃
Yeah, I keep forgetting I have a Adelphi Private stock open. I should put them head-to-head. But then I'd have drink blends and you know my stance on that XD Good video! Glad to see you keeping going =D
Thanks man, it's good to be back to feeling closer to 100%. I'd be interested in hearing about that side by side too! But, with so much good malt I'm not surprised to hear you forgot about that Adelphi Private Stock Blend. Cheers buddy! 🥃
C$50 Alberta a good price. I pay 70% more in Hong Kong but still an acceptable price and value.
Sounds like your getting your voice back!
Good whisky better review!
Yeah, $50 is an excellent price. Unfortunate that it's more but it's encouraging to hear that you're able to get it in Hong Kong as well! Slowly but surely with the voice. And strangely enough, I was watching hockey highlights yesterday of a game between Hong Kong and North Korea. Random lol. Cheers eh! 🥃
Great review, Matt! I was curious about this one so thanks for reviewing it. Cheers!
Thanks Sheldon! So many people have been singing its praises it's tough not to be curious about it. Cheers buddy! 🥃
Nice review! Agree great value for money these days.
Cheers 🥃
Thanks John! Yeah, great bang for buck whisky. Cheers buddy! 🥃
Nice one Matt! I've not tried this one before but if I'm being honest I'm not super excited about it either. If it comes my way sure I'll give it a shot but with so many whiskies out there and in my cabinet I hardly see myself reaching to this one over and over again. Hey taste is subjective so I'm happy you love it and I could edit my response once I try it 😅 Cheers my friend 🥃
Yeah I hear you Sertug. I think that's why I landed on it being a bottle I wouldn't replace. I can see the charm, but will I got to this often enough over my other bottles or even over Ardnamurchan AD? It's a fair question. Can't deny the Price/Performance ratio is great. Hope you get to try it man. Thanks for watching buddy! Cheers! 🥃
Unfortunately, I don't like most Ardnamurchan (the exception being the Paul Launois), so I don't really like Maclean's Nose either; I'll stick with the Thompson Brothers TB/BSW for blended in that price/quality bracket...
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Ardnamurchan and Maclean's Nose, it is good to hear input from a dissenting opinion. TB/BSW is no slouch whatsoever and a completely different profile so it's a great option to try for anyone who doesn't click with this. Cheers Andrew! 🥃
Hey Matt, I have no experience with Maclean's nose yet but I picked up Ardnamurchan AD recently. It's a bit young, hits on a lot notes for my palate. Yeah it is more money in Ontario as usual but at least some bottles showed up here. Appreciate you sharing your thoughts on Maclean's. I think I will wait it out. Cheers!
Glad the bottle at least showed up in Ontario for those who are looking for it. It's a good bottle, but with that Ardnamurchan already in your set I'd say you're in good hands. Cheers Rohit! 🥃
Whisky FOR the year ;)
And it is very nice for my palate, cheers
You got it man, very interesting distinction with For the year rather than than of the year. Glad you're enjoying it! Cheers eh! 🥃
Hey Matt great review and channel! Wondering if you’ve had the Compass Box Glasgow Blend and how this compares? I love the CB blend, it’s got a hit of peat and the profile seems similar to this MacLean’s Nose. Cheers!
Thanks Mark, I really appreciate the feedback. I had the Glasgow Blend a few years ago and I did enjoy that Blend, I'd say more so than the Artist Blend. I'd say the big difference for me is how spirit forward, and mineralic with a touch of salinity the Maclean's Nose is. The Glasgow Blend is, from my memory, a decent comparable. Cheers Mark! 🥃
Maclean’s is certainly hard to beat on value. I paid $35 in California. That’s significantly cheaper than what I’d pay for other craft presented blends from compass Box or Thompson Bros. It wouldn’t supplant my favorite budget Single Malt (Benromach 10 @ $40-$45) which is clearly not craft presented. I’m an unabashed Benromach Fanboy though. Whisky of The Year? A bit of hyperbole methinks, but to each their own. Cheers.
$35 USD is undoubtedly a fantastic price. But I am fully there with you on the Benromach 10 at that price. I'm on my 3rd bottle of Benromach 10 and will continue to replace it. Strong take on the W.O.T.Y. topic too. Cheers Tim! 🥃
Great review & honest one too....Now W.O.T.Y. 2024 ? No way, it's too soon & I'm sure there' ll be better whiskies released this year. W.O.T.Y. 2023 then ? (makes more sense), for me yes, but only in my Blended whisky (all countries) category & also ok in the "best value" one too...but in 2023, if you've seen my 2 parts "unending" Highlights of the Year video, you'll notice a bunch of greater whiskies released imho (starting by an indie SC of Ardnamurchan, btw !) & especially a stratospheric French one which completely kicked out the Scots, for example...and everyone else too...(not value wise, mind you, I gave a red flag price wise to the shop "storepicking" it, otherwise I'll already have the bottle on board, believe me). Now if I had a bottle of this Maclean's nose on hand, I might be able to evaluate it better than I do now, so we'll see...Cheers !
It is a solid whisky, no doubt and very capable amongst it's like class of value or affordable Blended Scotch whiskies. But for me as well, it is not my pick for a whisky to represent this year. I do know Ralfy puts alot of thought into his "Whisky For The Year" selections and with this one it seems he was highlighting an affordable but quality bottle of whisky with cost of living and inflation up. Hope a bottle of this makes it's way to you Greg! Cheers my friend! 🥃
Hey Matt, Great review and great hat! Been down and out sick recently but by the sounds of thing we are both on the mend! Keep it up and Go Nucks Go!
Thanks Tyler! Man, this sickness kicks yer arse! 37 days in now, one day the cough will go away. Sounds like you're in it too. Here's hoping we're both feeling better post trade deadline. Let's see if the Canucks get something else done before the deadine comes. Cheers buddy! 🥃
Ralfy's whisky FOR the year , not OF the year. Pay attention !
@scrimmy45 Didn't mean to offend the church of Ralfy lol. He does make the point every year to emphasize the FOR the year but I make mistakes. Cheers 🥃