Test of the best PS5 SSD Heatsinks - EAGLE vs. SABRENT
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2024
- ko‑fi.com/mckuc
Test of the best PS5 SSD Heatsinks - EAGLE vs. SABRENT
Just buy the cheapest one and do not worry :D
Ambient temp was 21 to 22°C during the tests.
I am not talking about my feeelings in this video. This are facts and numbers.
Like , subscribe and share if you feel good today :D
you can watch it in 1,5x speed ;)
PS5 Phat Fan Model Numbers:
NMB V1 - 10247GA-12M-WB-01
NMB V2 - 12047GS-12N-WB-01
NMB V3 - 12047GS-12N-WB-0
Nidec V1 - G12L12MS1AH-56J194
Nidec V2 - G12L12MS1AH-56J194 (B)
Nidec V3 - G12L12MS1AH-56J14 (C)
Nidec V3.1 - G12L12MS1AH-56J141 (C)
Delta V1 - KSB1212HGG4E
Delta V2 - KSB1212HGH2M
Delta V3 - KSB1212HGHU1
Foxconn V1 - PVB120L12H-P01
PS5 Slim Fan Model Numbers:
NMB V1 Slim - 11541GS-12M-WB-01
Nidec V1 Slim - G12E12MS1AH-56J14
Delta V1 Slim - KSB1212HEJF9
Foxconn V1 Slim - PVB120L12Q-P02-AE
Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction
01:04 prices
02:38 Airflow design comparison
09:08 What is inside the package
11:12 weight comparison
12:08 it is not nicely cut??
12:59 dimensions comparison
18:01 removed the thermal pad
18:29 density comparison (also Elecgear weight/ density)
20:27 looking at the Samsung SSD i used and Elecgeal EL-P5C
22:52 how not to do it + my test setup + fan data
28:54 Update PS5 and wiring explained + Max read speed
36:09 Test results
39:33 Test results with mod panels or Darkplates v2
43:53 conclusion and my opinion
44:48 opinion on JEYI EAGLE vs. ELEC GEAR EL-P5C
47:53 test process fast forword + BiH Rap Musk
50:07 replacing the heatsinks fast forword
52:18 pressing x on custom paddles and outro
musik:
◇ Rima D i frenkie - povratak repcuge (instrumental)
• Rima D i Frenkie - Pov...
◇ Frenkie 95 posto (instrumental)
• Video
get the best nidec v3 from elecgear with noise damper:
amzn.to/3krcofB
rpm meter: amzn.to/3IrpuBK
this m.2 cooler is the king, but it also costs a lot: amzn.to/3lUfolb
not sure if thisone fits inside the ps5 but it is OP: amzn.to/3ExCip3
looks like the Jeyi Eagle - price performancw king: amzn.to/3IqIRL0
this m.2 cooler is also okay:
amzn.to/3xL3psN
m.2 cooler that does the job well enough.
amzn.to/3xM7ddy
this m.2 cooler is too expensive and has no support for underneath the ssd a lot of youtubers got paid to review them. i would not recomend it: amzn.to/3KwRVRw
Thank you for watching! - Ігри
And this is the reason i always encourage everyone to support smaller youtube channels... You can clearly see that this is a comparison that is not sponsored by any company! I dont want to say that sabrent heatsink is bad but you can see so many reviews online which clearly show that all these videos are sponsored. And i am really sad that there are so many people out there that dont even use a liitle bit of their mind to judge what is authentic and what is not. This is a complete! amazing review and congratulations, but for starters how hard is to tell that in a simple heatsink, more material means better heat dissipation... Great work and i appreciate your hard effort.
Thanks for your kind words :)
The youtuber(s) i watched triggerd me so hard with his "reviews" and "test" aka advertisements, so that i had to make my own video.
I have to work on my english skills to make better videos ;)
Totally agree with you!
Thank you once again.
If you buy Sabrent for example you also pay more because Sabrent invested in ads on youtube ;)
Yes exactly. All these heatsinks will do the job but the whole point of these comparisons is which heatsink gives you the best results for less money! And right now eagle is the winner. Even if elecgear runs 2 degrees cooler at the price of 37 euro!!! +shipping its ridiculous! It is just a heatsink for christ's sake...
@@irregular0x www.amazon.de/dp/B09QLX65NG/ref=cm_sw_r_awdo_6Z4PMFJ95VG0QSPEGMP3
Looks like the Eagle ;)
You did excellent comparison! You have full equipment and deep details provided. Thanks a lot. The only issue is video a bit long than usual comparisons which is not big deal
Thank you for the comment...You are right. It got very long. It also took me a long time to make it. I wanted to show some bad youtubers that are not objective and only talk about their (paid) feelings instead of showing facts, how a real test should look like. I added timestamps for people that have no time.. or just watch it in x2 speed ;)
Brilliant video. Definitely do the Eagle v the elecgear. But also add in a conventional heatsink but a good one like the arous full copper heatsink with the original ps5 metal case covering it. So we can see the difference between all 3. Keep up the great work 🙌
Thx Leon. I already ordered and recieved two heatsinks that are not specially designed for the PS5..
Nr.1 JEYI Warship Pro
Nr.2 Jonsbo M2-3
I will see how the response on this video is and maybe i will buy a temperatur datalogger with 4 channels or connect some small NTC-resistors to the ESP32 and build my own logger for less money. :S
So much ideas but not much time..
@@McKuc ok many thanks. Would be a great watch Although i believe the elecgear will beat the Eagle. I myself have a normal heatsink inside my ps5 but its the full copper arous one with 17 w/mK 1.5 thermal pads attached to both the top and bottom of a firecuda 530 4tb ssd.
@@leonprez231 this is also more then enough
Excellent and honest review. I knew that the eagle was the best deal for the money. The eagle does a great job. Thank you.
Thank you too. The video got longer than i planned :D
Great job!
Thx
Thank youuuu
I came here after watching someone else review his Eagle, and it triggered the shit out of me.
Firstly, even after visibly seeing the temp results are LOWER than the other one, he still managed to find a way to say that the Eagle was worse ("it's bigger so it should have performed better anyway" is so poor).
Secondly, it is clear he was salty at paying 6x the price. It's his own fault for not doing his homework properly and buying it for a tenner (£10). This saltiness was evident when he was trying to show the Eagle was poorly packaged (which in fairness it was, but only because of the UK seller, not the manufacturer), and thus it was a terrible purchase.
Thirdly, he seemed adamant that the quality of the Eagle was bad - my take is that he sees this as some no-name brand and therefore cannot possibly be better than a branded Sabrent. And thus cannot possibly perform better.
Fourthly, he was saying that it looked badly made and flimsy, and said something along the lines of "i can bend the ends of it" - like wtf? It's a solid piece of metal that has been shaped, being able to bend it is not an indication of build quality. What a numpty.
You have taken a objective look at this and backed it up with evidence, and concluded correctly. You get my like and a sub.
Thank you bro. Did you also look at the article on the webpage? The wiring of the probe is really bad and it makes the results unusable. The video from the guy who is talking about his feelings and not the truth should be deleted in my opinion. It triggerd me so hard that i had to make a video :)
Thx for the sub bro
I just got the Sabrent heatsink, but instead of using the stock thermal pad, I used the Gelid Ultimate thermal pad. Donyou think it will improve the temperature/s?
I do not know the W/mk of the stock thermal pad.. i would recomend you to add a 3mm Thermal Pad underneath for the reasons i already explained in the video..
52:11 Which back-paddles are those?
The green textured controller case looks like eXtremeRate Rise 2.0 BUT the paddles are not.
Great vid, looking forward to the ElecGear comparison.
ua-cam.com/video/LWYRvO8PLRc/v-deo.html
Hi again. So gamer nexus was actually incorrect then. As your results show the ssd, heatsink and playstation 5 itself actually ran hotter when you added plates with cut outs to increase air circulation correct?
Hej, nono i totally agree with Gamers Nexus and his results are facts that are also logical.(just check how close the panels are to the fan) The components inside the PS5 are running cooler when you remove the Panels or make holes. He measured for example the RAM and underneath the APU. He did not measure the M.2 SSD temps. So everything has pros and cons. When there is less air passing the SSD Heatsink, there is worse cooling (logically). Just wanted to see the impact on the SSD temp.
If you use a bad SSD cooler or no SSD cooler combined with Darkplates 2.0 (no filters), the SSD will heat up (throttle) faster then with normal Plates.
I would still use Darkplates or Mod Panels like i have combined with a good Heatsink. (SSD Temp with a good Heatsink like the EAGLE will rise a bit, but the more importent internals of the PS5 will be cooler)
There is a sweetspot
Example:
SSD Temp will maybe rise from 38°C to 45°C which is still totally fine.
RAM/VRM and APU will cool down from 87°C to 83°C
This will boost efficiency and longavity and is a good tradeoff in my opinion.
Some are worried about more dust because of the holes. But the airspeed from the sucked in air is decreasing when you have holes and is not going to suck in so much dust, that is sitting on the console for example. (if the air, that is getting inside the vacuum cleaner is slower, the vacuum cleaner will suck less dust in)
Even if my thoughts about dust are totally wrong, the PS5 is easy to clean and has dustcatchers. The first thing you can get out is the Fan. lift the fan and you can already see the heatsink and clean it with compressed air. On the PS4 the fan was the last thing you could remove. For me there are much more pros then cons for holes in the panels. Watch out who you ask. Some people are earning money from repairing consoles (repair shops), so they will maybe not tell the truth ;)
ua-cam.com/video/VhKsR-kEh0Q/v-deo.html
Does it ( elecgear) works in the ps5 slim digital? You know it has 4 covers and more slim. And elecgear is a huge cooler i am not sure about sizes...
No it is not compatible with the slim
good afternoon, I have such a question, how to install JAVA EAGLE in ps5 with netac 7000, it has memory chips on both sides if there is no metal board from below, but there will be a thermal pad, is it dangerous from overheating of the ssd?
As long as you have any kind of cooling it is fine. Check the community tab on my channel for pictures
In the video you say to use 3 mm at the bottom and top of the SSD, how much to use? Note: regarding the thermal pad, I will install the JJ Eagle model, thank you very much
I used 3mm
@@McKuc both on the bottom and top of the SSD?
@@drive7918 only on bottom 3mm
@@McKuc I would like to know what you used on the top of the SSD
Mc Kuc,
Excellent work and review, congratulations!
I'll wait for your review between the heatsink Eagle vs Elecgear EL-P5C.
I have a question about them...
How should I apply thermal tapes from Eagle and Elecgear to the WD Black SN850 SSD?
Tks for your help
Hello Amilton,
still a lot of room for improvement ;)
Do not know what you exactly want to know. Can you be more specific with the question?
With the Eagle heatsink comes some thermal tapes and I wanted to know if I should use them all by putting them on the WD sn850 ssd and if it really is necessary to remove the factory sticker from the ssd.
Sorry my english..
@@zardors on my SSD i used the 3mm one for underneath and the 1mm for above the SSD.
It is not necessary to remove the stickers.
In my opinion it is better to remove them but you do not have to worry if you let them on the SSD.
I do not have mesurements to tell you exactly how much the stickers will effect the temps.
@@McKuc thank you
Hello, thank you very much for your video.
Indeed I saw the eagle heatsink review and didn't agree with it.
I went ahead and bought the elecgear as well just to be safe.
I will purchase the gammix S70 blade 2tb and see how it goes.
Please make a video comparing the eagle and the elecgear.
Thank you very much and good luck !
Hello Alex,
nice to know that there are still some people that use their own brains and do not believe everything they hear.
im am not sure if i wil make another comparison. this video took me a lot of time and as i said at the end of the video, in my opinion no tests are needed because all 3 heatsinks will do the job.
if you live somewhere, where you have tropical temperatures, then maybe do not buy the Sabrent and go with EAGLE or Elecgear.
This test was an almost worst case scenario. During gaming, the fans will spin faster and how often are you going to transfer 0,5TB from the internal to m.2. even if it throttles during transfer, who cares... the gaming performance is the one that matters.
The thing that matters most is which is the best bang for the Money!? IT IS 100% EAGLE
sorry for the late reply
Congratulations on the work! Very good! Doubt: is it possible to put two layers of thermopad? does this help with cooling? or can I use the bottom part of the heatsink that comes with the SSD? Thanks.
Thank you. Still a lot to improve :)
Do you mean, if the thermal pad is not thick enough? Just check if the pad is pressed nicely onto the ssd. To much pad is also not good.
So you have a ssd that already has an heatsink on it? If yes, then this should also be okay. Do not worry to much about temp.
yeah.. I think I'm very worried about the temperature... I even researched those plates with openings for ventilation.. but here in Brazil still don't have these things.. thank you and success with the videos!
@@fabriciozelesnikar9502 if you use plates with holes, then less air is going over the ssd cooler. The air wil get sucked in directly.. pqnels with holes = warmer ssd.. i talked about it in the video
I watched another video review about the eagle heatsink and was worried i made a wrong decision to buy it.. i will be pairing it with WD SN850.. Will the eagle be a good heatsink for it? It should arrive by next week..
For sure it will. It is more then enough
@@McKuc nice explaination on the video.. keep up the work.. + subscribed.. thank you..
Hi.. So which is better? Vent Hole on the left side or on the right side of the ps5?
Hello, i am currently testing it. So far it looks like on the left side... will upload a video and talk about test results so far. Just need to collect some more data to be 100% sure
ua-cam.com/video/VhKsR-kEh0Q/v-deo.html
Hey!
Are you planing to check cfm on all the different ps5 fans?
Great channel keep it up!!
I measured the rpm of the air. (Right and left air intake and at the exhaust. Not sure if i can tell the cfm
@@McKuc sounds good! Cant find the video though. Maybe it’s a coming video?
@@aanders0n vodeo not uploaded jet.
@@aanders0nua-cam.com/video/VhKsR-kEh0Q/v-deo.html
So i am getting the gammix s70 2tb gen 4 with heatsink will it be best to buy a thinplate since the ssd I'm getting its only one sided
I would not use the standard heatsink that is provided, and go with the EAGLE instead. It hast the best performnce for less money
@@McKuc which heatsink on the ssd you Will recommend on the ssd I mean bc for the cover I'm going with the eagle
@@francorottier8221 This Heatsinks (Eagle/Sabrent/Elecgear) are not covers, they are Heatsinks and you will maybe run into issues when you try to use them on top of another (smaller) heatsink. Just use the already provided one or remove it, so you can use the Eagle for example (with thermal pad inbetween)
is your ssd still ok after all these years?
About the SSD speed, I installed an Aorus 7000s that reached between 5300gb/s and 5800gb/s. I called tech support, but they say the problem is with the PS5.
Thank you for the info
ua-cam.com/video/X7AGl7nSO04/v-deo.html
Can both be installed on a ps5 digital ?
Yes all 3 can be installed on a PS5 Digital Edition
@@McKuc many thanks because the Pny one that came out similar to the Sabrent is only PS5 disc version compatible
@@GAMERGUSTO i do not know about the pny. Disk and digital edition are the same. The only difference is the bluray drive
Thank you very much for your video, the youtuber you are talking about should be ashamed that he was irresponsible about the tests. But I want to clarify one point. I have exactly the same kit with an eagle heatsink, there are 3 thermal pads, green from segments, pink thick and blue thin. Did I understand correctly that blue or green should be placed between the heatsink and the SSD, depending on preferences, and pink under the ssd so that it does not sag from the pressure of the heatsink? In your opinion, is it possible to use a thermal pad even thinner than 0.5mm, and use a copper plate instead of the rest of the thickness? I would like to get the maximum efficiency of the radiator, and this can only be achieved with a thinner thermal pad. On the sabrent radiator, for example, it is simply too thick. Now I have a seagate 530 in my ps5 and a snowman heatsink with a heat pipe, there are very thin thermal pads in the kit and everything suits me except for an open SSD compartment, that's why I bought an eagle heatsink. Sorry for my English.
Hello. For me (on Samsung 1TB) it looks like only the blue one is for between the SSD and the heatsink. The green ones are probably also for underneath. If you have a SSD that has also modules underneath (or is thicker) you can use the thinner green ones instead of the 3mm, or maybe cut and mix them. You can try a 0.5mm pad. I do not know if it is going to make good a contact. I am not a fan of a lot of layers because there will always be air inbetween. The cooling performance of all 3 is good.
I think it is better to use a good quality thermal pad with higher W/mK then playing around with cooper plates. If you want to try it with a copper plate and thinner pad, you should use a good thermal paste between copper plate and heatsink. The pad underneath is also improving the cooling performance imo. Did not test it with and without.
I have another 1tb ssd. Maybe i will test the Elecgear with and without pad undeeneath and also with stickers and without stickers on SSD.
Hii, I really wanna see Elecgear vs Jeyi Eagle ^^
Hello, i do not think that i will do that. Both are very good and cool more then enough. The best option is EAGLE. Best performance/$