What Did Rommel and the Germans Think About Australian Soldiers in WWII?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 тра 2022
- Rommel and the Afrika Korps fought against Australian soldiers and others of the British Commonwealth. What did he and regular German soldiers think of the Aussies in North Africa? Believe it or not, he actually wrote down what he thought and it is presented in this video in a good way.
#WW2 #Australia #rommel
@TheImperatorKnight
@MarkFeltonProductions
@MilitaryHistoryVisualized
@MilitaryHistoryNotVisualized
@WorldWarTwo
If you enjoyed this video, then you may also like:
Ten World War II Interesting Facts -- Eastern Front
• Ten World War II Inter...
Conscientious Objectors -- World War One
• Conscientious Objector...
Why Did the Plotters Try to Kill Hitler on July 20th?
• Why Did the Plotters T...
If you enjoyed this video, then you may also like:
Ten World War II Interesting Facts -- Eastern Front
ua-cam.com/video/Qovo1HNDrkM/v-deo.html
Conscientious Objectors -- World War One
ua-cam.com/video/sur0cX8pJNw/v-deo.html
Why Did the Plotters Try to Kill Hitler on July 20th?
ua-cam.com/video/kJusk8euADE/v-deo.html
it was British Empire then, not commonwealth
Except Australia already had federation... so it wasn't all the empire.
Ausies massaging their fragile chipped ego again.
Thanks for the recommendation 👍👍👍👍🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
My great uncle was in the 6th. There training in Australia was done with broomsticks. When they got to North Africa they were issued guns but no bullets. Hence the attempted raid on the enemy's stores.
Story from Tobruk...
A English officer(lieutenant) approached a group of shirtless Australians digging in at Tobruk.
Berating the Australians for not saluting an officer and saying they were undisciplined rabble.
The Australians ignored him except one who stopped and started putting his shirt on revealing that he was a captain.
He ordered the English lieutenant to salute and piss off.
^5 on that one! Sorry Captain, Thank you for treating me as an arsehole said the lieutenant
I'm Australian and that sounds about right.
Thats gold!
Sounds about right. Probably a fresh lieutenant begging for praise.
"Story" ? Fairy tale might be more appropriate. The Australians were under Gen. Morshead, the Australian commander at Tobruk. The "English'" officer would have had no reason to give orders to the Australians, and probably no authority.
After the majority of Australian troops had been evacuated from the tobruk seige, a german officer captured in a offensive asked why the company of Australians who captured him were dressed in Australian uniforms . He said, "all the australians have left, that's why we attacked." The Aussies insisted, no that they were in fact Australian troops. The German officer replied, "no you are British, you only dress like Australians to frighten us."
I saw that account too, in a book, and the reason was that when Tobruk was being relieved of Australians, to send to New Guinea, the last group's ship was sunk; so they had to stay on, and frightened some enemy during the (next) battle to re-take Tobruk.
@@noplanb8853 I would like to read that, which book please?
Well actually, the British 70th Division who relieved the Aussies not only suffered the siege but also broke out and pushed Rommel's armies back. Also remember, that even when the Aussies were holding out for 241 days, there were 6000 Brits there too, including Commando Units who carried out the Twin Pimples raid. There are so many invented quotes when it comes to the Aussies, some of which may even be true, but give actual references rather than saying "my Uncle once told me that a German officer said etc etc..........."
@@OldWolflad jealousy isn't a good look.
@@SamO-ik2cm I agree, but bullshit is even worse (:-
I have two friends who fathers were Italian soldiers in North Africa. They were so impressed with the Australians that they migrated to Perth WA to start a new life...
Many on the losing side fled retribution from their own people after the war.
Argentina got German Nazis, Australia got Italian Fascists and Greek Communists.
G'day from WA
That's grand
Western Australia is the best place in the world I reckon
Perth is a great city to live in.
The Germans , esoecially Rommel was impressed by the Italians too. The Bersagleri in particular
My Dad landed in England with his Canadian Dragoon Regiment and were held on the docks for inspection along with a newly arrived Australian group. After a long wait in ranks waiting for a VIP, the Australian officer dismissed his troops by saying "Right, we're off to the pub. Send a runner when the muckety muck arrives". My Dad always admired them for their toughness and their irreverence for authority.
Lol, this sounds about right to me. Hello from down under!
Australian units weren't in England in WW2 except as part of the RAF. The units serving in the RAF didn't arrive by sea to England. They all arrived in Northern Ireland and then went to England by ferry. Any inspections would have taken place in NI or at their destination air bases. So ...... nice story, but didn't happen.
My grandfather served with the 2/9th Infantry battalion AIF which was diverted to the UK en route to the Middle East in 1940 as France had fallen.
Part of the 18th Brigade moved to Salisbury then Colchester.
There were also Australian army forestry units felling timber in Scotland during the war.
The 2nd Australian Imperial Force in the United Kingdom
The third Australian Imperial Force convoy left Australia in November 1939 bound for the Middle East, but was diverted to help garrison Britain, which was threatened with invasion. The Australians began disembarking at Gourock, near Glasgow, on 17 June 1940. The force was 8000 strong, almost half of the 6th Australian Division. The Australians were sent to a tented camp on Salisbury Plain. Brigadier Winter, who was with the convoy, was appointed to command the AIF in Britain. On 4 July 1940 King George inspected the men and a week later the AIF suffered its first battle casualty when a German aircraft strafed the camp, wounding Private Arthur Webb of Adelaide, South Australia. Training was completed in September and the Australians were given the role of mobile reaction force, to deal with any German parachute landings in the region. None came, and with victory in the Battle of Britain and the arrival of winter ending the possibility of a German cross channel invasion, the Australians were sent to the Middle East at the end of the year.
Britain had also asked its Dominions for specialist non-combat troops. Three companies of Australian Foresters, numbering about 600 men, arrived in July 1940 and as 6th Division elements were leaving Britain a new Australian force came: the Railway Construction and Maintenance Group, 300 strong. Based at Longmore in east Hampshire, they built storage sidings and maintained strategic railway tracks.
The foresters included many volunteers from Commonwealth and State forest services. War is a great consumer of wood and the foresters were set to cutting timber in Northumberland, and later Scotland, working in snow, which most of the men had never seen, in the unusually harsh winter of 1940-41. The specialist foresters, assisted by Italian prisoner of war labourers, produced ten million metres of sawn timber in three years in Britain.
In Dumfries in 1942 the Australian Foresters won the 'championship of Britain', an axeman-ship and sawing competition, against their New Zealand counterparts. The New Zealanders were defending the title, having won in 1941. The hero of the day was Sapper Ian Harrington, from Beech Forest, Victoria. Though he had been in bed sick the day before, he easily won the two main events for the Australians, setting the team on the road to victory. The Australian High Commissioner, Sir Stanley Bruce, came from London for the event.
From 1943 the Foresters, the last large body of AIF troops in Britain, began returning to Australia.
A small AIF headquarters and liaison office was maintained in London under Brigadier-General Wardell. It was enlarged in January 1945 to deal with the thousands of AIF prisoners of war (POWs) that began to arrive in Britain from liberated POW camps.
The staff of 2/3rd Australian General Hospital (AGH), arrived at Gourock and Liverpool from May 1940. Six nursing sisters of the 124 Australian Army Nursing Service that served in the UK were posted to the Tidworth Military Hospital on Salisbury Plain, where they assisted in providing medical care for the AIF force there. During the Battle of Britain the remainder established 2/3rd AGH at Hydestile, Surrey, 50 kilometres south of London. Bombs fell near the hospital and staff often worked wearing helmets and respirators.
I joined the Australian Army in 1958 as a 17 year old and I can tell you we all looked up to those who went before.I served for 27 years and would like to think that we carried on the tradition of the "Digger" I served in malaya within a british Regt of ROYAL ARTILLERY I also did two tours of VIET NAM I feel sure that we did the memory of the DIGGER proud.
Dave, you may enjoy this video:
A Vietnam Veteran's True Story
ua-cam.com/video/Qixfo8iR-LE/v-deo.html
Thanks for the comment!
I just watched the documentary on the battle of long tan for the 7th time. Still get a bit teary about what you boys went through. Thankfully for your service.
Dave, it was you lads who "raised" me after I joined at 17 in '83. You did a good job of upholding the ideals. Sadly, after you, our mob started the softening of the ADF with lowering of standards and I am ashamed that happened on my watch.
Thanks for your service mate
Thanks mate
My grandfather emigrated to Australia from Scotland before the war. He fought in Tobruk and told me a couple of amazing stories one of which was about the night some Aussies dismantled and entire steam locomotive and buried it in the sand. He may have told me why but I was just a kid then and that explanation is lost in time. Another story was about how the aussies he was with found a piano in a bombed house and carried it back to the trench and played it during a bombardment. He was very proud to have served with the Australian army.
Vox AC30, I can't easily imagine them burying an entire steam locomotive, but only two guesses come to mind: 1) Deny it to the enemy. 2) Come back to it as a memorial years later. Either way, it's crazy...but crazy things happen in war. They must've had a lot of energy, been drunk and/or a lot of spare time with nothing to do, imo. In WWI, both sides had weird things in the trenches -- to make themselves at home. A piano is not so weird as it sounds. Thanks for your comment and watching!
@@EmersusTech you might find the recovery of one of the first German tanks in ww1 interesting. Saw it at the Canberra war museum. Recovered by Aussie soldiers and sent back to Australia where it’s been a museum piece since. Also saw the ‘red barons’ articles of clothing there.
@@SirBigzalot Here in Brisbane, Queensland, we suspect we've been swindled out of that A7V tank, the last remaining WW1 German AFV on Earth. They were supposed to return it to Brisbane - where it has been since 1918 - ages ago !! As for the Red Baron items, this is due to a common belief in Australia that it was an Australian machine gun crew who shot down the Red Baron, not the Canadian pilot Roy Brown. I have no opinion to offer on this controversy, but the War Museum in Canberra certainly pushes the "our boys did it" story heavily !!
Sounds about right lol
@@TomasFunes-rt8rd That "common belief" has since been proved by Canadian war historians. They even narrowed it down to which Australian soldier did it.
It certainly makes a fella feel proud to be Aussie hearing things like this about our courageous soldiers. I remember seeing the late US senator John McCain being asked about war one evening and he replied something similar to... if he was in a raging battle, the best he could hope for was to have an Aussie by his side.
Preview43, yes, I've read other comments by Australians writing that your WWII isn't really taught to this detail. Thank you for your comment!
As I mentioned above my best friend was a US Marine in Vietnam in '67. He had a good deal of contact with diggers and had nothing but the highest respect for them.
You should be! Lineage of Lions!
Quoting McCain tells us all we need to know about you...
As an Aussie I'm very thankful that our small nation can punch above its weight.
As mentioned in the video... they fought for their mates.
God rest the souls of those Diggers.
Aussies were tough, and Australia was a very tough country when these men were growing up close to a century ago. My Popa served in Egypt and then on to the Front in France where he was mustard gassed and repatriated to England. These men of that time were strong willed and bred tough as nails, and we all owe them so much.
Kerra 369, thank you for your Popa's service in the fight in World War I! Thanks for your comment and watching!
Oh yeah like multicultural cesspit Australian cities are now.
And if they were like my grandfather, wounded and discharged three times but still re-enlisted to serve on the Western Front, they had an idea of service that baffles me.
The British had the deepest respect and admiration for the Australian soldiers. WE STILL DO, AND ALWAYS WILL.
Keith Shwalbe, thank you for that nice comment!
we are going to need it unfortunately
God save our Charlie...
Doubtful. Britain has long treated Australia with contempt. General MacArthur was appalled at Britain’s disloyalty to Australia and ensured that they had command of British forces in the occupation of Japan and the Korean War.
@@seanlander9321 Thats what i was thinking.
Aussies had huge losses in every war commanded by British.
Aussies were used as cannon fodder and barely get credit for defending britain.
The Australians were the first to defeat both the Germans and Japanese in land battle, 2nd battle of El-Alamein Tobruk and Milne bay respectively. Paving the way for the defeat of Axis. My uncle Tommy AIF 2/15 and 10th fought in both battles plus more, along with my uncle Gil RAN CMF (choko) Milne bay. From the blistering desert to mountainous rain soaked jungle, how good are Australian soldiers? RIP thank you for your service.
My dad was at Milne Bay👍🏻
My great uncle fought at Milne bay at 18 I believe. Virnal Cooney rip.
Interesting point about Milne Bay.
Have never read anything on surviving Japanese.
Think the boys took to them with the bayonets,right into the surf.
Japanese weren’t up for surrendering and our boys would have hated them by that stage.
My gramps and his brother were up north at Wewak at the time. 2/4th. Gramps, brother won the v.c then.
Damn man, had no idea, and really pissed off that this wasn't taught more in depth in schools growing up.
Us Australians go hard.
As an Australian (with mostly English background) I want to bow and give my most heartfelt thanks to everyone who commented that their ancestors served Australia during times of war. Thank you for their service. I can’t imagine how proud you must be. And to those from other nations that have fought for (and alongside) your Australian friends. This video makes me so proud to be Australian. It should almost be compulsory viewing every Anzac Day morning.
johnnys8393, There's a new video out that you may want to see:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
Beautifully said, thank you.
It's really interesting to know what different nationalities thought of a particular nation's troops. I remember watching a documentary on the Kokoda trail in Papua New Guinea during WW2. An American pilot based in Port Moresby told the story of his interaction with Australian troops. He put in a request for a transfer as he felt the Australian troops all hated him and he didn't know why. They just constantly kept making jokes at his expense. The commanding officer, an Australian, just laughed and said that if they're making fun of you, then they consider you one of their own. If they didn't like you, they'd just ignore you. I found it a pretty interesting observation.
Over here (Australia) its commonplace to make fun of your freinds is it different in the states or where you are from?
It does depend on the relationship. Imo, if you've known the person for many years and you're really close, then a little good-natured jabbing is okay. Other than that, no, I don't think it's a good thing to "make fun of your friends" nowadays. Years ago, maybe in the US. People in the US have gotten so sensitive that it's near impossible to make almost any sort of joke because people get offended by the least little things, even things that shouldn't be offensive to anyone. People read things into emails that aren't there -- "reading between the lines". I have run into this relatively recently and it's very irritating. Jerry Seinfeld and other comedians have mentioned this that they simply can't do comedy much anymore -- because someone always gets offended. Look at the Chris Rock thing with Will Smith. I'm not defending what Chris Rock said, but he certainly didn't mean it offensively. In fact, Will Smith was laughing at it at first before he turned back to look at his wife. Thanks for commenting!
@@EmersusTech So true. At least, at this point in time, Australian humour has held mostly true. When looking back at the ANZACs in WW1 and 2, the concept of mateship and being their for your mates was key. And, as they were your mates, you could be as rude and brutally honest as you want, and that was respected. I'd personally still take that today over fake media outrage, regardless of your political opinions. You see it during the fires and floods. I think it's what made the troops that bit different. It's why I like the story of the American pilot at Port Moresby. At the end of the day, it's inclusive, but you've got earn your entry pass. :)
As an Aussie, sounds about right. I worked for an employer where we had a yank. I'd rib him, which us Aussies do to each other, but was pretty sensitive about it until he got used to my humour.
It’s basically spot on. Hard for foreigners to pick. An Aussie who doesn’t like you will either ignore you or seek to provoke you into a response/altercation.
There is a subtle middle ground where Australian’s (men especially) largely dwell... ‘taking the piss.’... out of anyone who strays into their field of fire... self-deprecating in equal measure tho.
The Germans in WW1 hadn't just heard of the Australians from Gallipoli, they had fought them all through France and were well aware of the capabilities of Australian troops.
Charles DuMar, you're totally right, however, I was simply mentioning a WWI front in passing. Thank you for bringing it up, even so!
Also they saw what happened at Beersheba
There is a story about Generals Montgomery & Freyberg, NZ Div Commander with LRDG Troopers. “Monty: Your chaps don't salute much! Freyberg: Oh if you wave ... They'll wave back!”
There's another story about two British junior officers complaining to their superior officer about the Australian refusal to salute British officers.
The senior Brit officer had served in WW1 and knew the Australians quite well from that conflict. He told the two junior Brit officers that they were lucky, because in WW1 not only would they not salute Brit officers they would walk over them!
I once read a story about a badly wounded American Soldier who was being cared for by an Aussie nurse during WW2.
"Excuse me ma'am, did I come here to die?"
The nurse replied, "No mate, yer came 'ere yesterdie".
Grumpyoldfart, that's really funny! You get a heart for that one! Thanks for watching and the joke!
Captain Mannering said the same joke on Dad's Army
@@johnwatters6922 So I wonder which one copied the other ?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Princess Anne told that joke in an interview years ago.
As a Australian we aren't actually taught our own history. So this is refreshing to know.
Stephen Bachman, yes, that's one thing I love about UA-cam -- you can watch what you want to watch, for as long as you want to watch. I would like to say that UA-cam doesn't edit channels, but that's not true -- I was subscribed to a channel that disappeared one day. So, not perfectly free speech. Thanks for watching!
I'm an Aussie and exploits of our Diggers and the esteem that Rommel held them was known by many of my generation (I'm in my 50s now and come from a military family).
@@EmersusTech UA-cam is an odd place since channels are more likely to get in trouble over copyright claims than ToS (which is mostly from jerks who false flag and usually not anything automatic from their bots, which would rather de-monetize or not give algorithmic boost).
That’s so false, if it’s true for schools today thats fucking disgusting, majority of my Australian history and military history and it’s fairly extensive comes from school. Though I grew up in a town that sent soldier to the battlefields of ww2 I’d think all Australians are taught it.
@@sharpshooter_Aus most schools barely cover ww1 and ww2
My grandad died in Kokoda and my uncle Alf fought at Dunkirk, North Africa, Crete and then finally (& by this time a Major) at Milne Bay PNG. In the last few months of his life Uncle Alf became distraught about the lives he had taken. (Crete btw was a bloodbath, completely out of ammunition it came down to bayonets and hand to hand) how could he face God he said after all that he had done? And that’s the legacy of war. Broken Men, sundered family’s. Destroyed lives. My mother losing her father at 6 years of age. An entire generation of the young men of my country sacrificed. Twice. In two world wars. That’s why ANZAC day is such a big deal to both us and the Kiwis.
Lest We Forget….
PlanetDisco, yes, it haunted him -- what he did. A lot of that wasn't well understand back in those days. Yes, Lest We Forget! Thanks for your comment!
Least We Forget
Thank you for your story and comments.
I sometimes wonder that as we remember them, how do we not end up in more unnecessary conflicts and will the current generations be able to pick the fights we ought to fight in time to stop bigge r problems developing. Your forebears came from serious hard working stock not propped up by social welfare or weakened by the diseases of entitlements and woke culture?
I would have encouraged your Uncle Alf to look at it this way: yes,millions of people died...soldiers and civilians,But it,unlike some wars,was a war that *had* to be fought lest psychopaths like Hitler and Tojo were allowed to rule most of the world. I have no doubt that God,although He is always displeased by warfare,understands that there are times when people must resist men like them.I'd wager that your Uncle Alf had little,or no,trouble standing before Saint Peter whereas Hitler....
And one last point: the US Marines 1st Division has "Waltzing Matilda" as their unit "theme" as a sign of gratitude for the amazing hospitality that Australians showed them during WWII. I can't recall the entire story but you can look it up if you have a few free minuted.
RIP, your Grandad
I (German) served with Aussies in the Rhodesian Security Forces. My BN CO was Aussie, Joe Flanagan, the COY OCs were Aussies, Bruce Ralston and Gordon Forgoty. Great Guys. I had the DAK Sign (GermanAfricaCorps) painted on my "Puma" (Armoured Vehicle) and the Aussies Känguruhs. Excellent Soldiers, hard drinkers and very disciplined (could be mistaken for Germans lol)
Sounds very interesting to me. Did you ever write about your experiences during the rhodesian conflict in german or english language? Thanks for a reply.
Did you ever meet an American named Jeff Apolonario?
Possibly because several states had significant German (and other central European) migrations between the 1830's-1890's (plus a significant migration post WWII). Indeed, up until 1915, German was the second most common language in the state of South Australia, with many South Australian units having fluent German speakers in their ranks. Also, many of the Kopi's in PNG (a sort of blended police officer and government representative in the remote highlands of Papua New Guinea) were required to speak German, as the north of New Guinea had previously been a colony of the German Empire. In fact, in WWII, many Germans served in Australian and Dutch forces in SE Asia against the Japanese. Several Coastwatchers (an Australian naval intelligence service) were Germans by nationality, but were vital sources of information for some of the biggest campaigns of the Pacific (and Burmese) War! In an intriguing fashion, many families would have sons and husband's away at war in the Australian forces while the wives and children were interred as Germans (although in most places, while there was some suspicion of ethnically German families, the families would continue working their farms as part of the war effort. Again, South Australia was rather unusual in that Air Raid Wardens, Militiamen, Post Masters, etc, would often be people of German ancestry who were too old or unfit for regular military service).
Of added interest, Barossan German is still the dialect of German spoken in many parts of South Australia, named for the Barossa Valley, which is an area mostly populated by German descendents, and a noted wine region.
I ( also born in Germany) served with Aussie’s in Vietnam 1970, signed on to be career soldier, that came to an abrupt end when I was critically wounded after our patrol was attacked with a command detonated anti personnel mine . Good for you .
So you were a Nazi killing Zimbabwean freedom fighters?
I had the privilege of meeting and being trained by a soldier from the 9th, who had been a Rat of Tobruk, brought home and served through PNG and the Solomon Islands, then after WW2 taken part in the occupation of Japan (where he met his wife and took her home to Australia), then served in Korea and finally served 3 years in-country in the AATTV in Vietnam (the most highly decorated unit of the Vietnam War), again brought his wife home from Vietnam (his Japanese wife had sadly died from cancer in the '50's). This was in the early 80's and he had served from 1941 as a 17 year old, was a WO1 / Regimental Sargeant Major and had been allowed to serve at 59 years old, part time beyond mandatory retirement age (his mate was the Chief of the Army)...boy now he had some stories - very weird when your 'old' Major who had also served in the AATTV with him, was all googly-eyed over his stories ;-). Well departed now, such a great man - god bless WO Robby.
thats awesome !!!,
my grandfather fought in ww1 then africa and new guinea in ww2, got wounded in both wars, my father was an underaged cadet when the korean war started so he stowed away on a ship going to korea, he was placed as a batman to an officer until he turned 18 and was allowed to fight, he then served in malaya then joined the Aussie SAS in their early days, becoming a platoon commander, later he transferred to the AATTV and was unfortunately killed in action in 1966, RIP dad, you relentless warrior :).
Yes AATTV was "the most highly decorated unit" *of the Australian units* in Vietnam....
Good story. I guess he may had known my great uncle who also was in the 9th division and fought in Tobruk in 1939/1941. And he may had known my farther who also served in Vietnam. My dad was in the battle of long tan he was with the special ops SAS my dad did 5 tour's in Vietnam from 1963 to 1970
Wow you have to admire a commitment to others that strong, and for so long, it makes my day that he has someone like you to keep his name alive. We cannot repay that generation enough so thanks for your respect you show to them. 😉👍🏴☠️
Those stories if you remember them clearly are worth writing down and sending to the national war museum in Cambera mate, that is history that will be lost other wise
G'day ET, I'm an Australian military historian who, for nearly 16 years has focused, part time, on the life and career of Field Marshal Sir Thomas Albert Blamey. Australia's first and only Field Marshal. When given the job of Commanding General of the 2nd A.I.F. in 1939 he wrote a Charter of how his forces would be used in the upcoming World War. It stipulated that Australian forces could not be used by British or other Allied commands without his express written permission. This was to avoid Australian soldiers being used by British commanders as 'cannon fodder' as they sometimes were.
While the 2nd A.I.F. was still training and acclimatising in Egypt General Blamey became concerned that British officers were repeatedly accusing or trying to charge Australian troops with minor and serious disciplinary offences.
Blamey, personally, and with the aid of his command's senior legal officer, formerly investigated every single case or charge levelled at the Australians.
After due investigation Blamey met with General Wavell to inform him that all allegations against Australian troops were foundless.
Then followed a semi-private, heated argument between the two commanders.
Blamey used his Charter, signed by the Australian Prime Minister, exactly as Blamey had written it, to dissuade Wavell from entertaining anymore accusations brought against Aussies by any British officer. (NB: later in the war Blamey and Wavell became genuine friends.)
It was Wavell himself who flew to Greece to personally evacuate Blamey. Blamey agreed to leave Greece only after he was certain "his boys" were safely on or near the evacuation beaches he designated on his very first day in Greece.
He wasn't defeatist, he was a highly intelligent soldier who knew the entire Greek campaign would fail before he arrived. He had word that he'd find the Greeks 'thinner on the ground' than promised. Blamey didn't accuse the Greeks of any cowardice, on the contrary.
He knew the entire theatre was another one of Churchill's 'stunts' for the benefit of F.D.R. to keep showing the American President that Britain was serious about attacking the Nazi threat.
Sadly, these days in Australia, Sir Thomas Blamey is barely known of, or if he is he is remembered as a highly controversial officer, mostly because of his short inter-war stint as the Chief Commissioner of Police in the State of Victoria, Australia.
As to Rommel, I have every one of your citations in our extensive private archive. The quip that is attributed to Rommel about attacking Hell etc. It does appear in some old ‘copied’ documents I discovered in the British National Archives among some files held about Rommel, and referred to among the many papers, signals traffic and some diaries pertaining to, or by Rommel himself.
I'll say I think that quote has around a 98 percent probability of being genuine.
While Rommel admired Australian and New Zealand troops, I can assure you from stories from my uncle Dan (an Australian Officer of Engineers with the 9th Division) who said, generally speaking, Aussie troops were not likely to admire any enemy commander as the Aussies saw them as the reason they were in the fight and so far away from home.
Lastly, to redress many untrue yarns of Aussie troops disliking General Blamey; when Field Marshal Blamey died in 1951, in Melbourne, Australia, many thousands of former WW2 soldiers voluntarily marched behind their old 'Bosses' coffin in what many sources said, at the time, was the largest funeral in the history of Australia.
Cheers, ET and all the best, Bill Halliwell
For anyone interested in Field Marshal Blamey they can visit:
www.TheBlameyEnigma.com.au
Bill Halliwell, it is nice to have an Australian historian comment on a video about Australians. It's even better to state that he has the quotes that I used from FM Rommel! Yes, Field Marshal Sir Thomas Albert Blamey was in at least one of the pictures in the video -- perhaps two (I'd have to look it up if I wanted to know for sure). Thank you for your contribution -- you get a heart!
Could you give the reference / specific location please for the hell quote, otherwise it remains as hearsay, I will happily check it out and vindicate it, if it was indeed said by Rommel. If I had found it in any archives I would have replicated it and noted exactly where it was found for authenticity reasons. If you say it happened, I do believe you, but when I know for sure, I would then go back and correct my previous posts, in fairness to everyone. I have struggled finding any authenticity for this quote, having contacted German historians who know nothing about Rommel having said it and who feel it is totally contrived , and I have today contacted the British national Archives to see if they can vindicate it where you say you found it. I will feed back if I get anything, but it would help greatly if you could expand further regards what exactly you were looking at when you saw it.
You left out the ‘run rabbit run ‘ comment by Blamey about withdrawal along Kokoda Track. With the men hissing him……An utterly complete misreading of what the soldiers faced and their lack of equipment, just the barest basics.
@@rossmcintyre1710 He was hated more for the run rabbit run than his activities in Melbourne. NSW and Queensland to a lesser extent didn't give a stuff about Victorians especially the aerial pingpong. When he visited the troops in the hospital the patients were eating lettice (whether this is true or not I don't know) so he got the sh**s and turned around and walked out
I agree. There was some tarnish on Blamey's reputation, especially after the "Australians fight best when their tired" quip. But to be fair, he did a hell of a lot dogged and excellent negotiating in shielding, sheperding , coercing, and good all round foil for Monash in the first stunt.Organising and sorting out the other nation's officers, the competent from the ambitious etc . I recall Monash was quoted as saying he was my "good attack dog". I think Blamey's Father was a drover, so really tough beginnings
The Germans knew what the Australians were like in WW1. They faces the 5 divisions under General Monash. the "Black Day" coined by General Ludendorf was caused by Australians routing his army.
Yep Australians and Canadians who made more ground that first day.
The History Guy:History Deserves To Be Remembered channel has a great video on the John Monash and the Australians in WWl, I highly recommend it if you've not already watched it.
@@tobinsarttrading1733 The attack was planned by General Monash. It involved 4 Australian , 2 Canadian and the New Zealand divisions. It was reported in British press as an "Allied Success" They were unwilling to let on it was dominion troops for fear that we would perceive it as being used as expendable troops. Hence it was many years before the truth came out.
@@Will_CH1 my Australian grandfather a farrier,Jack, was In those battles and commented in his diaries that the English professional forces had been shot right out and had very young poorly trained skinny boys conscripted (flying Tommys) which everyone made an effort to keep them out of harms way
Monash didn't plan the entire Advance on August 8th, just the Australian part. The Canadians were led by the equally as venerated - Arthur Currie who planned and led their own operation beside ours.
My Grandfather fighting in France ww1 shot a German and then went to help him. He stayed with him and they showed each other family photos .My grandfather cried with him while he was dying
No more brother wars
Deep down we are people and we have empathy to fellow soldier
War kills good men
My closest uncle whom was in WWII, said to me, even though a soldier is serving his country, shooting or killing a man who has done nothing to you, will haunt a person. He even said, he hoped he would be forgiven. Bless your late grandfather and the German soldier.
All Militaries success to this day can be atributed to Sir John Monash the grandfather of combined arms. Rest in peace you legend!
Sharpshooter, I've heard others make this comment -- about being the originator of combined arms. Thanks for your input!
@@EmersusTech There were a few others to attempt simmilar ventures to combined arms prior but Sir John Monash was the one who managed to plan it right and perfect it, the others mainly resualted in failure or complete choas on both sides so it can't really be considered a "tactic", The success of hemel where the Allies but mainly australians defeated the germans Monash showed the world what Australia could do, Monash predicted a 90 minute campagin but it took 93 minutes, it was so successful Monash himself provided hot meals to front line soldiers.
@Gavin Coleman Wrong, combined arms isn’t sending everything in to die, it’s coordinated and planned, what you’re referring to is a blitzkrieg and that never really works, look at Russia and Ukraine. Sure they pushed far but it’s not a tactic you can sustain.
@Gavin Coleman
No, Monash perfected it.
Sir John Monash was an engineer. I used to cross a bridge he designed in Hurstbridge (northern suburbs of Melbourne Victoria). It was opened in 1917 and its still there but its only one way. I can't help but think that he turned his engineers mind towards the problem of crossing a German trench line.
My Dad, who fought in the desert at El Alamein and elsewhere, told me some interesting stories. One of them always made him laugh as he remembered it. A captured German officer, who was very arrogant, proceeded to lecture his Australian captors about how they were all going to die when Rommel came through them with tanks on his was to Cairo. One of the Australians, a big sergeant, said, "You bastards have to get through us first," shoved him in the back towards the other prisoners and added "Now get on your way!" Everyone laughed uproariously.
That was a very gracious report about our soldiers. Thank you for the time that you took in this. Rommel also was a true soldier but not a nazi, earning him the respect of the allied troops
Anthony B, yes, I plan to do one on NZ too, but I need to do more research on certain things. It'll be a while, no doubt. Yes, I enjoyed making it and it was a lot of hard work. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@EmersusTech The better half of the ANZACs - or so they’d have you believe.
@@EmersusTech If you do one on NZ'ers, in WW2, try to include the formation of the LRDG (Long Range Desert Group) in N Africa, mostly Kiwis with some S Africans, they were the forerunner (and later worked with) the SAS. They travelled, mapped, and attacked the enemy, far behind enemy lines, travelling over terrain that was thought to be impassable to vehicles. Really interesting story for military historians. I knew an ex member, back in the 80s, he was in our chess club, never finished a game with him because we would talk about his exploits the whole time :-)
My father was on a merchant ship transporting german pows to England. A small riot started and they tried to take over the ship(to do what? - they probably didn't think that through). The captain came on the loudspeaker and said that if the unpleasantness didnt cease and all german go below, the australians on the ship entering the harbor would board. The germans went below and behaved well the rest of the way to england. My dad never knew if the captain was BSing or not but the germans believed it and wanted no part of that.
If you used to see the on field brawls from Aussie Footy and Union Codes they could knock your head off and a broken nose was a tickle
Aussies and Kiwis are a tough breed, although not about the war, this is a little story Kiwi All Black legend, Wayne ‘Buck’ Shelford told once. “About 10 minutes into the second half, I got kicked in the nuts. And man did it hurt. I felt nothing of it and continued playing," (Later in the dressing room, after a rare loss to France) “It is very morbid, very quiet after the loss, I had to get dressed, I stood up and pulled my strides down and one of the guys from across the room said ‘holy s**t, look at that!’, and one of my testicles had been ripped out of the scrotum and it was hanging between my legs.
I went upstairs into a medical room and had it tidied up and put back together. These things do happen and you’ve just got to play on,” 😯😯(He never mentions he also lost four teeth in that match as well!!😆)
My late father fought with the desert 8th army , he was in the Royal army service Corp , attached to the 51st Highland division , after the large barrage at the opening of the second battle of el Alamein, the Highland division went forward under a creeping barrage with the new Zealanders to there left and the Australians on there right , each division had heavy losses but took there objectives , each of these divisions depended on there colleagues to there left and right , my dad used to quote ( thank god they were ausies and New Zealanders, ), the finest brothers in arms you could wish for , and an honour to serve with , j p
Good on you James, the Brits fought bravely in Africa.
In WWI, the Germans called the Scots "the mad women from hell". They considered the ANZACs and Irish to be "their husbands".
RIP to your Dad... Lest We Forget.
Who on earth would face up to that combination. Brave tribes all
My father (English) fought with Australians in the first siege of Tobruk and El Alamein.
We migrated to Australia because my father wanted to see what it was about Australia that created the men he fought alongside.
One day he said to me if you ever hear stories about the boys pulling the pin out of a grenade and then throw it to each other then out the slot in the pillar box….just before it went off.
It was true…..
George Woods, yes they were made out of special stuff -- brave! Thank you for commenting and watching!
Have you seen our wildlife?
I met a man and his family 50 years ago in Wollongong NSW. He was of German descent and had been a soldier in WWII. He told me he had served under Rommel in North Africa and had fought the Australians at Tobruk, where he was wounded. He told me that he made the decision then that when the war was over, irrespective of who won, he was going to emigrate to Australia to live, such was his respect for Australians and the bravery and tenacity they showed during the many attacks they suffered. He felt so proud of their fighting prowess, he couldn't live anywhere else.
Sadly, he passed away about 10 years later. His wife told me he had refused to be repatriated back to Germany after his death, he wanted to remain in the land of those brave people he had come to love and respect.
sniperneil53, what a nice story! For this, you get a heart!
Actually bardia was taken when an australian officer came forward under a white flag and said he had a large force of australians who had been angered by bardia fortress and would massacre them. The italians surrendered to one man with a pistol. I spoke with one of the italians who had been there and he said there was many rumours throughout italy with how australians didnt take prisoners, and performed atrocities and mutilations. These rumours were certainly started by the australians themselves
There is a book written by a german who called them angels and ferocious bayonet fighters after 3 australians surprised them and bayoneted all 12 of them in a few seconds. The same soldiers came of a night after that to give the wounded first aid snd water until the Germans recovered them. I dont know about rommels quote about hell, but he certainly wrote to hitler saying give me 5 divisions of australians and i will win this war when he was in france
Garry Mercer, thank you for your great comment! You get a heart!
I've read hundreds of books about Australians in North Africa during WW2 and I've never heard of these stories, except for the last one but Rommel only said 1 Division of Australians not 5, lol! What book was that? The Afrikakorps is the only formation in Germany to this day that are able to have reunions because there where no atrocities committed in North Africa on both sides.
There was probably one incident involving New Zealand soldiers but when explained to Rommel by the New Zealand officer in charge who had been captured, Rommel forgave him and believed what the N.Z. officer told him. It was dark as it was a night attack and the German soldiers who stood up where actually wounded German soldiers resting in a small building. As the saying goes "Don't believe anything you read and only half of what you see!" This stuff happened over 70 years ago who the hell knows what really happened!
@@stuwhiteman3810
With regards to the Australians' abilities in close quarters fighting, it might be attributed to a little known fact about our sporting preferences from the turn of the 20th century until just after the end of the WW2. Cricket and Aussie rules football and neither of the rugby codes was the most popular sport in those years. It was boxing.
During the very tough years of the Great Depression, many Australian pro boxers might have fought as often as two or three times a month, just to put food on the table. Although there may only be two boxing tents now following the agricultural shows circuit around the country, back in those days there were many more and the young locals, in the city or the bush, were very willing to jump into the ring against the tent fighters for the chance to pick up some badly needed cash. It's little wonder that the Germans found them to be a bit of a handful!
@@stuwhiteman3810 yeah well, I believe there was a Kiwi Soldier who masqueraded as a German soldier by donning a uniform, then shot some Germans in the back. I can't remember where, may have been Crete. Not really within the rules of war old chap.....
You wouldn't happen to know the name of the book? It sounds like a great read.
Three armies you never want to face combined Australians/NZ, Scotish and Canadians.
The Gurkhas would have to be right up their at the top.
As a Canadian I would add the Gurkas in there.
You would want to face the Australians a lone Nor New Zealand
That’s 4 armies
That's right.
My father was in the 9th division, and I also had an uncle in the 6th division. The Afrika Korps, in terms of relative numbers and the length of time spent fighing them were perhaps the best, and most effective, troops the Second AIF ever fought. They fought well, often, and hard. They also had a pretty good sense of humor. To explain - My father was a Forward Observation Officer at Tobruk and El Alamein. There was a German machine gun which was such a pest that they decided to take it out with an artillery shoot. So the Tobruk artillery, including Australian and British artillery, opened fire on this solitary machine gun. The barrage included captured Italian 150mm, Royal Artillery 25 pounders, etc. When the barrage ended, the German machine gunner popped up, waved a "Miss" and ducked back in to his position. This was much to the amusement from the Australian infantry and my dad, who'd watched the whole thing. At that moment, he was the safest guy in North Africa. Nobody would have dreamed of shooting him after that.
LOL. That is like the story of the Russian tank attacking the worn out German line in Ukraine. The tank bravely attacked and was promptly taken out by a German tank. Two of the Russian tankers survived and got out and drew their pistols, waiting to be shot by the Germans. No one fired a shot at the Russians and they finally threw their pistols down and walked to the German lines, stepped over and were shown the way to the coffee area. Not a word was said.
My grandfather fought at Tobruk. Part of the 9th
He used to tell me stories of how he and his mates would sneak out at night and leave messages on the wires in front of the German placements in orders to psych them out.
He was wounded in action and evacuated,then honorably discharged. He later re volunteered and went to Papua New Guinea.
I'm Aussie, My Grandfathers brother is buried over there in El-Alamein.
He fought and died in that battle, His other brother watched him drop from gunfire and just had to leave him there and keep running and pushing forward to advance the position otherwise he wouldn't have made it back either.
Shane McGrath, that's a sad story, to see a brother fall and have to leave him there. So, it seems from your story that noone has ever found the body? I saw something on TV about bodies being mummified by the dry desert. Honestly, he probably was gathered by a German burial party. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@EmersusTech No sorry, I don't mean left there forever, I just mean in the heat of battle they had to leave him and go back later to gather the dead,
He is buried in the Commonwealth Cemetary over there in El Alamein, Not sure which side gathered his body though but most likely allies.
Thanks for the video, I like to hear all sides of war good or bad, We should never forget otherwise we will repeat it.
Well he’s resting in a nice place, went to the cemetery at ElAlamein about 6 years ago and it was spotless, very well tended by the local Egyptian caretakers.
@richie4540 I was very impressed with the Commonwealth War Cemetery there, too.
The Gernan War Cemetery is where the 9th Division was stationed prior to El Alamein.
Annual war memorial functions rotate between these 2 Cemeteries & the Italian War Cemetery.
The parents of a young South African had his grave stone inscribed with "Here in the fabric of peace we place a precious jewel, our son". Emphasised for me the wickedness of those who start wars.
This video makes me very proud to be an Australian my father was a second world war veteran in Kokoda he was in the Middle East also we thank our veterans for keeping our country free
Peter Smith, it was wonderful researching for this video -- I found so much information! Stay tuned for others that are coming down the pike in the future! I'm working on one now that should be absolutely superb, but I won't give away the subject matter. Just keep in mind that some of these videos take a long time to make, because there's a lot of research and putting it all together nicely is important too! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Im Australian, apparently my grandad on my father's side was a medic in Africa against Rommel and definitely later went on to become a nuclear engineer (I have his yearbook from 1964-65) and my nan was a midwife in London dodging bombs to help bring new life into the world...
It's hard to imagine what went through anyone's mind in such a chaotic time.
Mum's dad was a merchant sailor who got packed between mattresses trying to plug a torpedo hole and woke up in hospital, never knowing who saved him to the day he died at 82 years old in about 2002.
All my grandparents moved to Australia from England in the late 50s-early 60s and shortly after my parents were born, and, here I am telling this short story thankfully.
My late father was in The 2nd AIF in North Africa, briefly. He was pulled back to fight the Japanese in New Guinea with a lot of fellow Aussies. My late uncle however, remained there longer & was a “Rat Of Tobruk”. He eventually got out & also finished the war fighting in New Guinea. Dad had many, many stories from the war, but one that comes to mind was when he was in the Middle East. One day their camp was dived bombed by the German Luftwaffe. The British had basically toy planes all lined up on the runway as decoys. The German Stukas did their attack but dropped wooden bombs on said targets with notes actually attached. They read; “We use wooden bombs on toy planes!”🤣 Dad said “Even Jerry had a sense of humour!”😂 Well after the war both had fruitful lives raised families, but carried PTSD for the next 70 years or so until their passings. That was worse than the fighting. “Lest We Forget”.
Yeah nah.. the pommys did that against German decoy aircraft in Europe
Sounds a bit like my own dad's service - over 1400 days (3 and half years) overseas service.
Great war story
My great uncle Colin Craddock served in the 2/16th Australian Infantry Battalion in both Africa and Papua where he died in action. He and some friends walked from Kalgoorlie to Northam some 500 kms to join and fight. they built them tuff back then.
@@hodaka1000 yeah nah
Couple of stories from my Father regarding his time in Africa.
1. A couple of troops would go behind enemy lines and find the location of the Fuel supply depots. At night they would drive trucks 4okm across the desert (no headlights) to those locations and nick the fuel which was rather effective in stalling tank movements for a while.
2. During one of the two man scouting trips they came across an Italian soldier on his lonesome and promptly captured him. Then one of the Aussies was injured and required assistance. When they got back to their base the uninjured Aussie was carrying his mate and the Italian was trotting along behind holding the rifles.
His response when asked "What the hell were you thinking?"
"The Safety's On".
3. On a night attack across the Desert with very little cover Dad found a nice bit of rock to hunker down beside during some heavy fire. A flare went up and it was then he realised his piece of "rock" was actually a mine that was lying on its side...said he moved rather quickly after that.
4. One Christmas day the respective Officers declared a "day off". No bombing or shooting was agreed. They combined rations for a feed and even arranged for a sports competition between the Germans and the Aussies. Next day they were back to shooting at one another.
Barry French, great stories. I read them with interest. You get a heart!
My uncle Bill, 7th Division recounted the story where he and his mate came across a hastily abandoned Axis airfield. In the mess they found a table set up for a meal hastily left , including a few bottles of wine. Bills mate quickly knocked off the top of the bottle and was about to down it , Stop , struth mate ,it could be poisoned. No worries Bill, there's only one thing I'm scared of , and that's my Missus, and she aint here !
In one of the photos used in this video 13.59 showing a line advancing my uncle Bill recounted that looking down that line you could see your mates twitching involuntarily, like they had the disease St Vitus Dance. It was the automatic reaction as the bullets zipped past your head. He always laughed that the bullet was 1000 yards down range by the time you reacted . Lest we forget the greatest generation
The turks and aussies during Gallipoli also shared anzac biscuits with the turks chocolates. Poor buggers getting those crusty old biscuits and giving aussies chocolate haha.
Photo at 8:17
My father is second from the right he was wounded in the defence of Singapore and captured in early 1942 he was one of six survivors of the Sandakan Death March North Borneo and one of the four who escaped from the extermination camp at Ranau and recovered by members of "Z" Special Force
Photo is taken at either Tarakan or Morotai around August September 1945 after their evacuation from the jungle by two seat light aircraft
The photo includes three of the survivors and three of the pilots who flew them out
The fourth survivor was injured in a takeoff accident at the captured Japanese airstrip at Ranau and has been taken to hospital on landing
hodaka1000, you're the second person to mention that his relative was in a photo in the video! Thank you so much for sharing that with us and for his efforts in the war! You get a heart!
@@EmersusTech
He testified at the War Crimes Tribunals at Rabaul and Tokyo
He passed away in 1997 but still speaks today on video at the National War Memorial Canberra
Wow, I have very mixed emotions of sadness and joy and pride for your father, what a survivor, I don’t mean to be pretentious but I’d be surprised if he didn’t carry a heavy load for the rest of his life being one of the survivors. My pop survived the Thai/Burma railway, he rarely discussed it but when he did it was only about the funny things, he passed away in 1994 at 94 years, my wife’s uncle also survived the railway, both of them were absolute gentlemen and had an incredible and infectious outlook on life.
The RAAF's Airfield Defence Guards (ADG's) lost their first men in Tarakan and Moratai thru airfield fighting patrols(outside the wire) in mopping up operations
My father was in WW2 and a German POW for 4 years, but here's the thing, he never had a bad thing to say about the Germans, yet he hated the communists who were his allies. Here in Australia growing up in the 1960s I had a mate whose parents were German. My father picked me up from their home one day and he came in and met my mates parents. They sat there drinking tea, then a few beers and for 2 hours they were speaking in fluent German and having a good old laugh. My mate who barely knew any German couldn't understand how my father spoke German and I said , "i think he spent time living in Germany" as i didn't know about his war experience at that stage of my young life.
Antipodean33, thank you for your story! For that, you get a heart!
Antipodean, your father should have read a few books about the Holocaust.
@@anthonyeaton5153 Yeah Tony, and he should have blamed every single man, woman and child in Germany for it. Given your lack of education, it's called "Painting everybody with the same brush".
My school friends Father was a german Soldier . I was jealous of the Toy Gun he had made from a Grease Gun
I visited the Punchbowl memorial in Hawaii and to see the respect and recognition to our Australian , New Zealand forces was very humbling.
ANZACS. 💯
Thank You to all our allies too.
Together we are strong.
matcole2891, there's a new video out that you may want to see:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
My father was a gunner in Matilda tanks and fought right through the middle east before finishing up in New Guinea.
He used to say that the only thing he really feared was the German 88. Out of his company of 52 tanks only 8 survived. His being one of them.
The Anzacs had a great deal of repect for Monty. As a lad Monty went to school in Tasmania. His father was Minister and teacher at the private school and because of his slender stature and speech impediment made him a target for bullies. He seemed to take it in his stride and eventually won the respect of his fellow students.
Without looking at the video, I'll tell that he was frightened of them and we Americans without question, admire and fear them as enemies!
Australians often feel more tied to the US than Britain.
They are fantastic allies and are all-in-all fantastic people!
I've several Aussie friends here in Colorado and they all say I need to get there!
I doubt I can but wish I could!
I've always admired those good folk and love them all!
Chris Long, thank you for your interest and comment!
“More tied to the US than Britain” is just not true mate, an I say this as an anti-monarchist Australian Republican. Our slang and manner of speech are very close, pubs, cricket, the monarchy, the commonwealth, a huge diaspora here and there that is larger per capita than in America. There are many things but most Australians do not feel any relation to America but a large one to Poms. We take the piss out them, and them us, but it’s out of respect.
You got that one wrong, the poms were ours brothers and still are!!
As an Australian I can tell you that we feel tied to Australia, not moreso the US or the UK.
Those are other countries not ours
Thanks mate! My good mate married a USA girl and lives in Gettysburg now. Both him and me are ex infantry. My son is serving too. Love the heart of the core USA people too.
My great uncle fought in Tobruk. He was killed 1941 coming home when an Italian aircraft hit his ship. This made my grandfather join the ADF in 1941 when he was 17 years old. Knowing about his older brother was killed he wanted revenge but didn't end up fighting the Germans he ended up in the 7th division fighting against Japanese. At the end of the war my grandfather was court-martial as he shot up Japanese wounded in a hospital camp that ADF had giving medical to. He hated the Japanese. I guess he had his reasons for it.
The Japanese were very cruel. An old friend of mine told me when he fought the Japanese they came by this Japanese encampment base. One of the the Australian soldiers found this sack with some contents in it. When they emptied the sack out fell the heads of the Japanese enemies. My friend never forgot that moment. It haunted him through out his life. He said he struggled to forgive the Japanese people. He was always suspicious of them even the generations that had nothing to do with the war. One time when he assisted a car load of Japanese young people after they broke down he considered it a test from God.
@@andrewh6367 interesting, my grandfather was in a Japanese concentration camp from the age of 14. He was living in Shanghai China when the Japanese came. The Steven Spielberg movie empire of the sun is based on the camp he was in. He also hated the Japanese for a long time. After getting to England after the war he had joined the RAF as a physical instructor and later special forces. I was told he wanted to kill Japanese, nearly deployed to Korea but my grandmother talked him out of it. He always had a bad temper, suffered nightmares. Undiagnosed PTSD we were told later. They moved to Australia and he later studied the Bible and it helped him become a much calmer person and inadvertently have dealings and friendships with Japanese.
Must only be the ones on the losing side that get executed then....
My dad fought here in the 2/24th, first defeat the Germans had suffered, then went off to PNG and inflicted the first defeat the Japanese had suffered. Makes me incredibly proud to think he survived that and you would never even have known he was a veteran by his demeanour. He marched, but apart from that you'd not know he'd fought and survived history-defining battles.
byronstjames, that was a good comment. Yes, my dad was also a Vietnam veteran and he didn't like to talk about the war too much. Thank you for your comment and watching!
@@EmersusTech keep up the great work. I love these videos.
You wouldn't know these days but that's right it was Australians who first stopped the Japanese in the Pacific, not the Yanks although they were there. My Dad did his bit in New Guinea too, never talked about it,, a nice quiet bloke.
As a child I was often in company of my dad and his mates at the regular barbeques they held.
It was only in later years, as my understanding of history grew, that I really appreciated that I was sitting in the middle of some of the most awe-inspiring men to have lived, jovial, polite, and able to end you in a heart-beat if necessary.
You could sense their potential when they gathered to do some volunteer work. They organized, they were focused, and when one finished their assigned task, they went to look for someone else to help out.
The stuff of legend.
In this comment "he marched" means that he would take part in the massive marches held in Australia on Anzac Day - a public holiday and the national day of commemoration of all who actively served in the armed forces. Australians take war very seriously.
In 75 I had a holiday in Germany. Beautiful country and very hospitable people. I was 15 and had a conversation with a bloke who had served in the German Army. When he realised I was an Aussie as he thought I might be British or American he really opened up about his thoughts. He told me that the ANZAC soldiers were a dangerous enemy he respected. Remember that in 1975 Germany is divided into east and west and the locals weren't impressed by all the British and American bases and were often treated poorly by them. Many old soldiers are loath to talk about their war time experiences.
Re your last sentence... that's why until after his death in 1969, I never knew that my grandfather was at Gallipoli before being invalided back to NZ on the "Maheno".... a man who kept very much to himself.
As the daughter of a WW11 soldier, I am deeply grateful for this overview. My dad's best friend was a Rat of Tobruk, I my dad had the deepest admiration for him.
I remember the returned service men from my childhood, and one of my best memories is, the barbecues on a Saturday night, when our families would get together, and of course a keg of beer was cracked, and rum on hand, and at some point in the night a fight would break out between two of the men.
We all watched as the punched the sh.t out of each other, until one couldn't stand any more, due to too much alcohol, and the fight would stop, and the opponent would grab the guy he had been punching and say: Hey mate, you okeay? And then would tend to the injured man's needs (even though he had blood pouring down his own face), and all the men would help out.
These diggers were exceptional men, so different from other people, they genuinely cared about each other.
When I travel, I tell people overseas that it is the landscape and climate that cultivated these people. You had to take care of each other, and you had to be innovative to survive. It is a harsh world that creates physical, psychological and emotional strength in its people.
Djollo's Australia, I'm very glad that you loved this video! I very much enjoyed making it. For your story, you get a heart! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Those generations of Australian men who built Australian society and fought for freedom around the world are gone. The Australian male today is of weak character and timidly compliant in speech and opinion with political correctness, is scared of offending feminists and leftists, he does whatever women tell he to do, he is always apologizing, even brush past him in a shopping centre and he says "sorry", which seems to be his favorite word, he never whistles happily or winks reassuringly, he does not stand upright and walk confidently, and he is generally depressed. Even Australian women complain there are no good men in Australia and call for more immigration.
@@just-a-fella3212 This is what happens when you ban conscription completely.
For the life on me I can't remember his name, but a friend told me that there was a German general that had to surrender, and he told the British officer "I hope in the next war, the Italians are YOUR allies". That always cracked me up. Would anyone know the general's name?
R.S., well, I read somewhere that Rommel said something similar, but not exactly. Sorry I can't help you on that one. Thanks for your comment!
Congratulations on a very well-presented video. Some things mentioned within it were known to me but other aspects were previously unknown, I found it both enjoyable and educational to watch as well as it gave me a sense of pride to be Australian and that I have family that fought in both World Wars. Thank You very much and keep the videos coming I've also given it a thumbs up. 10/10
Richard Coulson, thank you very much! I worked very hard on this video and did a lot of research. I will keep the videos coming! Thank you for watching and commenting! You get a heart!
@@EmersusTech If you are interested in this part of the war look into the LRP Long Range Patrol which expanded to become the LRDG Long Range Desert Group which was exclusively manned by men from the New Zealand Division and Officered by the British started by Major Ralph Bagnold the first allied Special Force of WW2
I have always been of the opinion that Rommel was an excellent tactician and a worthy foe. It’s truly sad that the Gestapo forced him to commit suicide on Hitlers orders.
Yep much respect for Rommel , he should have left Germany and gone to the west where he would be be respected
He knew what was going on in Russia and what they were doing to the Jews in the camps. Turning a blind eye to it is no excuse he was as guilty as the rest of the murderers. And of course slaughtering our boys on the beaches so his cronies could stay in power to do there vile work in Europe. Rommel was as bad as the rest of them pretending to be on the side of right.
@@lena19191 Just like Mr. Heisenberg.
@@lena19191 His strong principles as a man, his honor and loyalty as a military, his love for the family and country didn't let him to do that. Nowadays way to few people are guided by this healthy way of thinking.
@@lena19191 my thoughts exactly!
Being Australian and a decendant of a ww2 vet, l both thank you for this video and feel proud of what our boys did.❤
thebrokestbassist1048, well, I appreciate what y'all did over there too! Thank you very much! You probably will like this other video:
LG Sir Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
Interesting video. My grandfather ( QF4084 ) became a cipher operator due to blowing his knee in basic, and got to see and hear all the top level intel and orders. Never would have survived the whole war otherwise he reckons. His war diaries whilst at Tobruk are quite revealing, and he had a lot of respect for Rommel in return, who as an example, agreed to cease fires so the wounded could be collected. I think the battle in Africa especially, although brutal and unimaginable to those of us never having seen war, was a place where two strong armies held a pretty high regard for each other. He had endless stories of Aussie shenanigans, and some of the night raid things they did well into German lines in Africa is stuff of legend. He was captured and escaped at the Benghazi handicap with his precious code books, which the Germans were after, one of very few to do so apparently.
Greg Roles, yes, I believe that FM Rommel fought honorably -- allowing the temporary truces to collect the dead, etc. If you have any stories about Aussie shenanigans and night raids, I'd like to read about them! Thanks for your comment and watching!
I would love to read your grandfathers diaries. Have you ever considered making them available - either to a professonal historian/author or self publishing?
I suspect you could essentially just photograph them with a phone and put them into a PDF and self publish that on Amazon or some other ebook publisher.
You could leave out any parts that are private to your family.
Sources like this - i.e. people who had first hand access to the high level signals as well as people who had what it sounds like pretty adventurous experiences are not all that common - especially people who aren't septics or poms.
My Grandfather, Claude Reid was a Sergeant with 6th Div transport and told us many stories of his experencies in North Africa and the Middle East. As kids we would pore through his photographs of his adventures in Cairo, Tripoli, Palestine , Damascus and other Middle East locations. He even had one of him and some mates on top of one of the pyramids.
When in convoys, air attack was always a threat, even from their own aircraft because using salvaged enemy trucks made it difficulr to distinguish who they were. When aircraft were spotted the sop was to go as far off the road as possible, abandon the truck and find some kind of cover.
His pet peeves were the .303 and bayonet which was always in the way. As for the rifle, he said "I humped that bloody thing over two thirds of creation and never fired a shot in anger". He made it through, returned home and died at age 98 in Brisbane. He was always a true gentleman.
Peter Reid, thank you for telling us about your grandfather. That must've been fascinating to pour over those old photos. To tell you a personal story, my grandpa once was in his attic in the 1980s and he said to me, "Well, look at that!" and he handed me a pristine telephone book from early in the 20th Century -- probably the 20s or 30s. I can't remember. There were only a few numbers, like "8833", "8832", etc., because so few people had phones. And this phone book looked like it was printed only a few years before and had survived many home moves. As a teenager, I was always fascinated by old buildings. Thank you for watching and commenting!
Peter, also, you get a heart!
When I was a soldier for the Australian army in the 90s we were told a story of a German soldier who said that during a night engagement he had been bayoneted by an Australian soldier and later that night the Aussies returned and he thought that they were there to finish him off but to his surprise the Aussies provided first aid and took them prisoner. I have no idea if this is a true story or not, just wanted to share a story I was told.
This story comes from a German soldiers letter in Diggers: The Legend of the Australian Soldier by John Laffin
Mark Moncrieff, thank you for the information!
A B, that wouldn't surprise if it were true, the Australian generosity and all.
@@EmersusTech Not disagreeing with you, but a part of the Australian psyche was to help out others.
Floods, Bushfires, Droughts....eventually YOU might end up needing a hand, even if your helping a neighbour out today.
Hard country makes for hard people, not cruel.
Not going to say that the incident recorded in Laffin's book is the norm. But if you look carefully, Germans and Australian's ended up becoming probably the most cordial relationships between a former Axis power and an Allied one.
Two World Wars fought and their respect for each other deepened!
(There's a lot of mutual respect along the lines of 'finally, a worthy opponent').
@@EmersusTech Your welcome, check out the book it's a good read
I should add to my previous comment the although I have lived in Australia most of my life ,I was born in the UK. If anybody asks me about my nationality I just tell them "I am an Englishman by birth, I am an Australian by choice", and a proud one at that.
Richard Carolan, thank you for watching and for taking the time to comment!
My dad was in the Pacific for 39 months and thought the world of " those Aussies" they were damn good jungle fighters he said! He loved them.
He was a Company Commander in the 158th Regimental Combat Team.
Highly trained and several islands invaded. He specifically talked about New Guinea and the Philippines but he didn't talk about it much, mostly anecdotes.
I miss him. Had him until he was 96...thanks
Stan Logan, yes, my dad told me the Aussies were "...big guys. You know they were descendants of prisoners!" Thank you for your comment and watching!
My grandfather was a sapper for Australia in this campaign. He hated the Nazis, but respected and admired 'the Desert Fox' his whole life.
Noel Page, you might like these two other videos:
Rommel's Death -- The Interesting Details
ua-cam.com/video/iYTzjh3rmtc/v-deo.html
Rundstedt vs. Rommel Normandy Debate -- Who Was Right?
ua-cam.com/video/882CEHFvNJY/v-deo.html
Thanks for commenting and watching!
@@EmersusTech Thanks mate!
Thanks for sharing. I was at a trade show in the USA in 2007. A gentleman introduced himself as an ex military commander (I can't remember his rank but sounded impressive) - when he heard my accent he said "I've been to Australia - we were sent to Townsville to "train" the Australians - we ended up gettin trained"!
There's a new video out that you may want to see:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
One of the reasons we have such a huge Italian community in Australia is that many Italian POWs from Africa were sent to Australia to work on farms. After the war many stayed in Oz rather than head back to Italy which had been destroyed by battle. More than one Italian POW ended up fathering children of Australian women out of wedlock, whilst their husbands/boyfriends were overseas fighting. So whilst the military history is important in terms of the western desert campaign, the social history aspect back in Australia is frequently overlooked.
Also you should include the Maori Battalion aka the 28th Battalion from New Zealand as they made significant contributions to the western desert campaign.
Regarding the so many Italian's in Australia, guy's you have it wrong. I learnt this in primary school, I'm a first generation Australian with parents coming from Italy with there parents. In the 50s more so mid 50s the Australian government put out posters advertising immigration to Australia to boost the population on the promise of plenty work, food and opportunity. My Grandparents remembered going to seminars where the Australian officials would talk and give spin how great Australia is. Also question and answer time. They went to more than one. Europe was devastated by WW2 and was still in ruins 15 years later with bombed out building everywhere, there was little work, little food and life was far from good. My Grandparents from both sides made the sort of easy decision to come to Australia like alot of other Europeans. They decided they wanted give there children the best chance at having a better life, they all came by boat which took 3 months with there suitcases. What also happened was a flow on effect friends would ask by letter whats it like, if they were on the fence about it then the letters would convince them. They all prospered and i 54 year old with a family of my own is forever grateful to my grandparents for coming to the best country on the planet 🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺.
Italy was not destroyed in WW2. There was no fighting in Rome and other major cities and Allied bombing was minimal.
@@maxrpm2215 Yes there was a lot that just migrated from a government program during the 50s and 60s like you stated. But there was many was POW amongst them too. And brought over their families from Italy some married Australian women. Many Italian from Mildura Victoria and surrounding areas from the farming sectors was actually POWs soldiers captured in Tobruk campaign during ww2
The many POW camps in Aus were in the Goulburn valley of Victoria. Mildura,TC, but massively evident is the Italian orchard owners in Cobram. I lived there as a teenager and was blown away how many of one people can make up such a huge portion of a town of 3500. 40 min from the old POW camps that still have some buildings standing. And 3 hours from a major city. Might be coincidence, but in 2002 my atlas at school still had a very large country titled USSR……
I have met an ex POW Italian about 20 years ago. He was drafted out to a farmer near Penrith in Sydney as a labourer . The farmer treated him well and he became like a son to him. As the farmer was childless he left his estate to the Italian . The Italian bloke increased the business and started breeding a particular type of short legged cattle named "Square Metres". I took the Minister of Agriculture from China to the farm as the Chinese love these little cattle and they got thoroughly pissed on Cognac.
I didn't realise Crocodile Dundee fought at El Alamein (10.57). No wonder we won!
mrmockatoo, yeah, mate, he was a good help! I'm glad someone noticed and commented on it -- others probably noticed and smirked. :) Thanks for watching and commenting!
And they all had girlfriends as pretty as Olivia-Newton John. Haha
Yeah, and he only had a knife!
Great video mate, thank you. I'm very proud to be an Aussie with ancestors that served in both world wars. I'll never get tired of learning about these horrific events that shaped our world. Peace to all and let's try and do whatever we can to prevent these things happening again.
Anthony Young, thanks mate! Yes, we study war that we may live in peace! :) Thanks for the comment!
@@EmersusTechI suspect more Germans had an understanding of Aussie soldiers from battles in France in WW1 then from stories from Gallipoli.
John Monash, the first commander of the Australian Corps (first 5 AIF divisions), planned what became the text book Battle of Le Hamel. US General Pershing ordered his troops to not participate but many US soldiers who were training with AIF units donned Aussie fatigues so they could fight with their new mates.
Other Allied units studied this battle and its replication meant the war ended in 1918 - most planners believed it would continue into 1919.
My family had members which faced the Germans in both World Wars, after getting over the initial post war antagonism they all agreed that the professional German soldiers were very impressive and hardy opponents that deserved much respect and that they (the Germans) also showed a great deal of respect to captured and wounded enemy soldiers.
Yes, after the immediate aftereffects of the war was over, many people did as you stated -- noticed that Germans fought really well! Thanks for your comment!
Thank you for this amazing video as I'm Australian with Italian heritage. You really can see the hard work. Keep it up new subscriber.
My Grandfather , Sir L.F. Smith, was a huge part of this entire event. I loved his stories. He was the RSM of 8th/12th Field Regiment.
I'm an Aussie, my great grandfather marched to Beersheba through the desert. When asked what being in the war was like by my father he simply said "Hot".
Brad, thanks for your great-grandfather's recollection!
My father was RAF Bomber Command Far East WW2 - he described the situation and climate as "a bit sticky". He escaped Singapore, Java, Sumatra and fortunately boarded the Kote Gede which heading towards Darwin changed direction to Ceylon. The other ships heading to Australia didn't make it.
Thanks for making this tribute. many of my family fought in both wars and I'm a proud Australian.
onlyactingup, thank you for watching and for your nice comment!
You get a heart!
By the way, have you seen this video? You may really like it:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
I'm always glad to get a notification that you've made another video. I wish I had enjoyed learning when I was young
Ash Dobbs, yes, I recognize your name and know that you've made some comments in the past. I appreciate your support!
We’re always learning. Everyday is an opportunity to learn something new.
My Grandfather was in the 2/8th in El Elemein. I'll never forget him. His father was a Light Horseman in WW1. My wife's Grandfather was a Rat of Tobruk, he died when she was very young though. God bless them, forgive them, and we thank them for the life they won for us.
Scovid Cafe, yes, it was good that there were people willing to fight for freedom halfway around the world. Thanks!
Enjoyed your work mate thanks for taking the time for us
Brennan, I'm glad to have made the video! Thanks for commenting and watching!
My neighbour Mr Connolly was in North Africa during World War 2 and said it was the best time he ever had. RIP Mr Connolly, I miss you.
Barnstormer79, that was a nice comment! You get a heart!
Us Aussies do have a reputation that follows us everywhere....and im damn proud of that!!
Craig Mckinlay, yes, you have a great reputation! Thank you for watching and for your comment!
As an infantry combat veteran (Vietnam Era) with a fascination for military history that began with the European campaigns of WWII this is a great presentation
Wilfried Matusch, thank you very much for the compliment! I worked hard on it! Thanks for watching and commenting!
I had two uncles in the AIF in Egypt and my mother lost a cousin at El-Alamein. I also had an uncle on the Kokoada Trail and at the battle of Milne Bay and my dad was a POW after the fall of Singapore. I had one brother who served in the Australian Army in Malaya and myself and an older brother both served until retirement in the Royal Canadian Navy.
your blood is worth bottling mate
The fact remains that the first loss the Germans experienced in WW2 was in fact at El Alamein at the hands of the Australians with British and New Zealand contingencies not too far away. The Germans didn't know what hit them with the sheer size and commitment of the Aussies. Brilliant video EmersusTech. Thank you.
smeary10, you're totally right -- the Aussies gave them the first land loss and stopped them cold. I appreciate your compliment!
You also get a heart!
That famous photo with those two soldiers with fixed bayonets storming a German tank, and the tank commanders lifts his hands to surrender were from the Greek Brigade--the bravest among the brave.
Abraham Levi, wow, I did not know that! Sometimes you learn something new every day! For that, you get a heart!
I really liked this one! Thank you!
Ralph Patrick, I'm really glad that you liked it. I put a lot of research and thought into it! Later, I'll follow on with other Commonwealth videos! Thank you for watching and commenting!
In WW2 my grandfather was a special services paratrooper who parachuted behind enemy lines and blew up German supply lines. He done 4 tours in the war the Aussies were a special type of soldier who never stopped. I am proud of my grandfather he embodied the memory of the ANZACs his story is of just one man’s effort and all Aussies have their own story. They were and are true heroes they never had the top line weapons but done more damage due to their heart and bravery.
brutalbrital, sounds like your grandfather had an exciting WWII job! Thank you for watching the video and commenting! You may like my newest video:
Why Was World War II Worse Than World War I?
ua-cam.com/video/cky159m1yqk/v-deo.html
That was very enjoyable, thank you very much.
Simon, I really appreciate that viewers enjoy the videos. There really are many enjoyable ones on my channel, imo. Thanks for your comment. You get a heart!
Mate thank you for putting out a pod cast about Aussies that all Aussies but very few other know...we are a race of peace lovers that understand to keep our country as free as it is we often have to take the battle and fight fiercely overseas to have an undamaged and free homeland to come back to. What many may not also know, Australia has sent troops to every major war since the bore war in South Africa to WW1, WW2, THE KOREAN WAR, the Malayan war, Vietnam, Timor, Iran, Iraq and Afghanistan not to mention various peacekeeping role.
Will Hawney, yes, I've gotten a lotta love from Aussies about this video! I really enjoyed making it and I'm happy that you enjoyed it too! Yes, Aussies have supported most/many of the wars that have been fought. Y'all are generous and have a reputation for sturdy fighters. Even my dad was impressed with y'all and he was a Vietnam vet. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Taken from German officers diary. "Our opponents are Englishmen and Australians. Not trained attacking troops but with nerves and toughness tireless taking punishment with obstinacy ,wonderful in defence. Ah well the Greeks spent ten years in Troy From .. PM Churchill l to Australian General Morshead after El alamein The whole empire is watching your steadfast and spirited defence of this important outpost of Egypt with gratitude and admiration
Pat Russell, that's a good comment! Thanks for watching!
We cant have the English being put on a par with Australians. That would ruin the myth!
@@EmersusTech I had relatives there for full siege wearing smae clothes for about three months
Growing up in Melbourne, I had the honour of meeting a number of the men who served in the 2nd AIF and the 39th Battalion of the Militia, including some of the Rats of Tobruk. One still had his great coat with with special T unit markings they were permitted to wear after the Siege of Tobruk.
I can confirm that the taking of prisoners was not a high priority for these men. They had enlisted and trained for War, and water, food, and medicine was in very short supply in the Western Desert and New Guinea. They were not inclined, after suffering such great privations, to share what little provisions they had with captured Axis forces. In return they also expected no quarter and so could be relied upon to fight to the death.
Roulandus-le-Fartere, thank you for commenting!
Thanks Mate, appreciate this.
grekiely6245, sorry for the late reply -- thanks for your comment! I appreciate it!
@@EmersusTech No probs, I appreciate your content.
By the way, have you seen this video? You may really like it:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html
The germans had been well aware of australians from WW1.
They had a rule of thumb that if the guys in the trench opposite you where Australians or Canadians it was trouble.
If you ever found out that the trench opposite you was manned by Australians and Canadians, then a big attack was coming.
I don't think this is entirely true but I get your drift
I don't know what the Germans thought of Australians, but during his time in North Africa my old dad always said that when the shit hit the fan you could do far worse than be shoulder to shoulder with an Aussie or a Kiwi.
Terry Jacob, yes, I've never heard any bad things about Aussies. I did see a bad comment about Kiwis from a guy's dad, but I don't believe it. Everything else about Kiwis has been good/excellent! Thanks for watching and commenting!
I'm an Aussie and I agree, if thrown into a trench with an allie I would prefer they be Australian, American, New Zealander, or British.
Proud to say my father was one of those in the 6th Division. He was a migrant from Poland and Jewish but jumped at the opportunity to serve his adopted country of Australia. We march on his behalf on ANZAC day, "Lest We Forget."
standupandbecounted972, it's wonderful to hear stories like your father's -- joining the military of a new country! Thank you for taking the time to comment after watching the video!
You get a heart!
Both of my grandfathers fought in New Guinea. My mothers father moved back there with his brother in law as they felt a great debt was owed to the people there for everything they'd done to help them and their mates.
Unfortunately my fathers father didnt live long after his return. His health never really recovered and he suffered terrible nightmares and much torment in his life. He could never let go of his hatred for the japanese and was unable to see humanity in any Asian people. I can only imagine what he must have witnessed.
William Irwin and Bruce Jeffery. May god keep thier resting souls in peace.
sloth_e, thanks to your grandfathers' service against the Japanese! I'd rather not know what the Japanese did, because I've read what other Australians have written...about the Japanese POW planes returning empty after a short flight, etc. Thank you for your comment! You get a heart!
I have heard that quote by Rommel many years ago but instead of hell it was " the world ". Can't remember the source but am sure it was a BBC documentary about the Africa campaign. Excellent video and well done on finding those quotes.
Aussie's never saluted the british officer's as it only encouraged them.
Yes they did. With two fingers
Thanks mate. Loved that. Good onya!
Frank Lee, you're welcome! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Makes me proud to be an Aussie 🙂👍🏼🇦🇺
Awesome video. Very interesting.
Julz Hunt, thank you and your country for its awesome contributions in both WWI and WWII! I enjoyed researching for this video and finding the information that I did. I just love some of your Aussie slang. My favorite Aussie expression is "No worries, mate!" Thanks for your comment and watching!
@@EmersusTech no worries mate. 😄 it was a very well researched and presented video. Very respectful. Have you had a look at Gallipolli?
@@julzhunt7790 Julz Hunt, I watched the video (VHS!) a few times with a very young Mel Gibson. Great movie! I've read some on it, but I'll need to do much more research before I make a video about it. I will put it on a my list of videos that I want to do and see if I can get to it! Thanks!
@@EmersusTech awesome work.
@@EmersusTech you should try danger close, the Lighthorseman and Kakoda if you like aussie war films.
Rommel and his Officers were well aware of the Australians exploits during WW1, not necessarily at Gallipoli but in France, most notably their involvement against the German's Operation Michael in 1918, when they were stopped.
Andrew Hart, yes, Rommel probably knew about the Australians' actions during WWI, and that would influence his thinking later. Even so, he saw first-hand how this new generation of Aussies did so well in the desert. Thank you for your comment!
@@EmersusTech Sure, however not so much a 'New Generation', but rather an inherited Tradition of 'ANZAC' and a way of fighting to win against all odds.Some even viewed this Conflict as unfinished business from WW1. Including Veterans from the former. Cheers.
I saw a documentary where an Aussie was taking shelter in a shell crater under Italian bombardment, When 2 Germans jumped in the same hole. Seeing the Australian one of the Germans said in English, "Bloody Italians", And the pair of them continued on their way crater hopping. 😂
Shane Ferris, I bet that happened! WWII (and probably WWI) was one of those strange wars where so many weird things happened. That's one of the reasons that it is absolutely fascinating to talk about! Thanks for your comment!
Great video, mate
user-qm5sx9dj1s, thank you! I appreciate your appreciation! :)
That is most generous of you and I thank you, kindly, Emerus Tech. I'll be sure to give them a look.
Thank you for this. My dad , an Australian, fought in Northern Africa, but said nothing about it. Now I have a better understanding of that campaign from an Australian perspective
Marylou Myles, thank you for watching and for taking the time to comment!
An officer had to earn the respect of the Australian soldier. British officers considered an ANZAC soldier to be an insubordinate colonist.
So true
Nah, you've been listening to Pommie haters like Mel Gibson. The Aussie are British, though not so much today, but then again the British today are not the same people either. This applies to the Yanks as well. The clue is the language their Constitution is written in. British officers considered a British soldier to be a insubordinate little oik! No difference.
@@johnbobson1557 That's true. Officers was àlways a prick to the unranked. An common soldier was considered expendable.
Not sure about how a British officer thought of the rank and file. My grandfather, who died before I was born, served in the Pacific (?on Morotai). According to my father, my grandfather didn’t think much of any officer until they earned his respect. He was busted down to private from NCO several times because he was forever telling his superior officers exactly what he thought of them! I don’t think Australian soldiers from WW1 and WW2 would have been easy troops to manage until they had been in action a few times to knock the “10 foot tall and bulletproof” attitude off them.
A British officer complained to Montgomery about the fact that Aussie and Kiwi troops didn't salute him. Monty replied " Oh well, they're friendly enough. If you wave to them, they usually wave back . "
Thanks, a very respectful video regarding all the soldiers on both sides
Christopher Whitney, you're welcome! It was a pleasure to make it. I wish people would watch some of my other videos more often. Granted, I put a lot of effort into this one, but there are others that are worth a few minutes here and there. Thanks for watching and commenting!
The Brave Anzac spirit makes me so proud to be Australian 😊
user-ro9zx8mk5h, thanks for your comment and for watching! You might like this other video:
Monash's Masterpiece: The Battle of Hamel
ua-cam.com/video/93mVu2vgErs/v-deo.html