Thank you so much for this eye opening lesson which i will share.i am aware of the massive evidence and i have also shown many proofs,but this lesson truly was stunning יישר כוח וברוך תהיה
Great video, Rabbi! I haven't heard this really important acknowledgement about the discoveries of the exodus made by xtians from other rabbis. Thanks for that public acknowledgement.
I am a ger so my opinion really doesn't mean much, and am still on the fence.... But dang! This is great information! Baruch HaShem, am hoping continuing archeology reveals even more evidence in the near future. Great presentation, Rav, mahalo shalom! ✡️❤️🔥🙋
Listen to this criticism of Exodus Decoded: "In Exodus Decoded, filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici suggested that Yaqub-Har was the Patriarch Jacob, on the basis of a signet ring found in the Hyksos capital Avaris that read "Yakov/Yakub" (from Yaqub-her), similar to the Hebrew name of the Biblical patriarch Jacob (Ya'aqov). Jacobovici ignores the fact that Yaqub-Har is a well-attested pharaoh of the Second Intermediate Period; and Yakov and its variants are common Semitic names from the period. Furthermore, Jacobovici provides no explanation as to why Joseph would have a signet ring with the name of his father Jacob." I think the biggest fault in Jacobovici's hypothesis is the last sentence ...
re: the excerpt at the beginning - how can one be sure the yakub seals are related to biblical joseph? i understand they are dated between the 200-yr period in question but there is no direct evidence that the seals actually belonged to joseph. and why would the seal say yaqub if it was meant for joseph? Is there no historical evidences of yaqub-named citizenry in egypt at that time period? would seem it was a common name.. what of the other inscriptions found on the seals? do they make reference of the yaqub-joseph lineage link?
Thnx Rab. You must check Simcha’s docus, since Pharaoh may be “AmMoshe” (kinda, meaning Moshe’s brother). And Simcha show us his mommy, it fits better the dates and a couple centuries after him, came the “monotheistic Pharaoh “ married with Nefertiti, his grandfather was semitic. They were “crypto jews” and didn’t helped some semitic king in Ysrael attacked by hebrews from the Desert when asked for Pharaoh help.
Also, what does the Druze community have to say about the exodus in general and this new exodus discovery in particular? It seems to me that the descendents of the prophet Yitro, Moshe rabbeinu's father-in-law and the first convert to Torah Judaism, was instrumental in the freeing of the Hebrews from Egyptian slavery by assisting in the escape route. I conjecture that Moshe was told by Yitro and his clan about this escape route. Additionally, Moshe had likely traveled this area as a shephard and when he escaped from Paro as a young man so he knew the path.
Springs. Moshe divined for water with his staff. Before modern tech with high falutan gizmo's it was the only way to find water. An accurate diviner is superior and cheaper than modern tech which often fails anyway. You'd be astonished at what lay beneath these arrid lands.
@@debrapaulino918 If you read the Torah, you know Moses was denied entry to the Promised Land for doing this. Numbers 20:11-12 "Moses raised his hand and struck the rock with his staff twice, when an abundance of water gushed forth, and the congregation and their livestock drank. The Lord said to Moses and Aaron, "Since you did not have faith in Me to sanctify Me in the eyes of the children of Israel, therefore you shall not bring this assembly to the Land which I have given them." Creating a false narrative that is not in the Holy Torah is idolatry. I invite you to do teshuvah, repent your wicked ways, immerse yourself in the Torah, and turn away from idolatry back to the light of HaShem. 🙏
Those seals have the name of Meruserre Yaqub-Har, a Pharaoh from the XVIII century BC, not the name of the biblical Jacob. And the most astonishing issue is that your source is the documental Exodus Decoded by Simcha Jacobovici, the same discredited documental that claims that the plagues of Egypt were caused by a volcanic eruption, do you agree with that? The same director that made another documentary claiming that he found the lost tomb of Jesus with his bones inside… Do you agree with that?
Thanks for the feedback. Historians don't know for sure who the Yaqub-Har seals belonged to. They have been dated to somewhere around the 15th or 14th dynasties. It is thought he may have been a Pharaoh, or a Hyksos ruler, or even a Canaanite vassal of some sort. So, I think it is very possible the seals could have something to do with the Biblical Jacob. Simcha Jacobovici has done some interesting work, most of which I personally do disagree with. However, that doesn't mean that every single thing he says is false!
@@Mavors1099 "These people [who have agendas] are pretty sure." Whether or not this is really Yaakov/Israel, the historians who have agendas don't matter unless they have facts/evidence to back up their "sureness."
There is ton of evidence that contradicts the Torah. The Hyksos being the Hebrews in Kemet is not convincing. The Hyksos were Amorites or "Shepherd Kings". So are you admitting the Hebrews were Amorites and not descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob? Or, is it like what Professor Daniel Bodi has stated and are the Torah stories old Amorite stories that came to Canaan? Oh, by the way, the Aramaens were also the descendants of the Amorites.
@@peshfra6026 Your argument made absolutely no sense. My IQ just dropped after reading it. Spanish and Portuguese are Latin languages. The language you speak doesn't make you that language. I know people who speak 3 to 5 languages. This absolutely nothing to do with my original comment to the video.
@@Biblical_DNA You contradict yourself, so were they the same as Amurru or in contact? LOL Cant keep it straight? Conflating Aamu with Amurru now? I have a PHD and have publisbed 3 books on the bronze age. Stay in your lane.
There was a whole load of evidence destroyed from my past life. Nearly almost erased my existence and so people really only had the 'lore' to refer to. HAHAHA! There are plenty of embellishments, but I can verify the truth to what is said and more. I long to visit Jerusalem for the nostalgia factor and past life memory recall.
Wait. Is it important that these things academically happened. What about sacred divine inspired writings that communicate and encode the soul of a people, their families, their history in a memorable format with divine instruction for each individual, the characters being actual living spiritual principles that play out thru history and in each individual. IMO give up the need for literal academic evidence for inspired writings that cover all people and all history and each individual. Academic objective historical research is a modern phenomena and encoding a peoples historical and spiritual journey for each individual was an ancient phenomena. Context of content. When you see an inspired movie we don't discuss day and night "how" the movie was made, the living characters etc while we are watching the movie nor should we while learning a sacred history. There is a time for watching and there is a time for composing. imo but..im a follower of Yeshua so I don't speak with authority on this. imo with the explosion and importance put upon academics, we must learn the difference and learn and teach the value of scripture...as scripture and the truth will set us free. Scripture is revealed in the divine inspiration to the prophet of his/her cultural sacred history from the divine....and the divine uses the mind , knowledge and ability of the human to do it. Its "trueness" is not academic.
"facts still dont care about your feelings". if youre going to use archeology as proof, consider the many facts. the torah is full of plagiarism from other civilizations and nations before moshe. egypt archeology has produced a similar ark as described by the torah and much older. Hammurabi laws are copied almost word for word. creation myths, horus not eating pork because of set, el is a name of a canaanite deity. many hebrew artifacts pulled out from the earth are clay images of baal, yahu, ashorah, many idols...we have remains of the inca, the maya, the egyptians, the babylonians, the assryians, the greeks. we dont have any definitive remains of david or shlomo. not like the remains of other nations. most remains are from herod the edomite. אמת מארץ תצמח וצדק משמים נשקף jerusalem was already a city before benei yaaqov arrived. from the days of avraham ירש שלם ירושלם
@@stellarspacetraveler theyre called civilizations, silly! why was the rubbish preserved pyramids/sumerian clay tablets? where is the proof of shlomos temple or the ark of the covenant? all religions are proven rubbish
@@stellarspacetraveler theyre called civilizations, silly! why was the rubbish preserved pyramids/sumerian clay tablets? where is the proof of shlomos temple or the ark of the covenant? all religions are proven rubbish
Wonderful, precise, concise, exciting. Thank you and thank g~d for giving you the merit to ha e the ability to share this. I found you on pesach 2022/5782 🤝💞🎑
This should have much more views; 500K at minimum.
Thank you so much for this eye opening lesson which i will share.i am aware of the massive evidence and i have also shown many proofs,but this lesson truly was stunning
יישר כוח וברוך תהיה
Thank you!
@@EfraimPalvanov you are very welcome
@@EfraimPalvanov you are vry welcome
Amazing information! Thank you for sharing.
How did I miss this? Anyway a blessing now.
Make a part two!!!
What an awesome video, these are absolutely amazing, thank you so much for sharing.
My pleasure!
Thanks for putting this together. It is amazing and has helped put pieces together that I have ran across for many, many years.
My pleasure!
Great video, Rabbi! I haven't heard this really important acknowledgement about the discoveries of the exodus made by xtians from other rabbis. Thanks for that public acknowledgement.
Very welcome!
Thank you.
Im sharing these. Im astonished at the topics you cover!
Thanks!
I am a ger so my opinion really doesn't mean much, and am still on the fence....
But dang! This is great information! Baruch HaShem, am hoping continuing archeology reveals even more evidence in the near future.
Great presentation, Rav, mahalo shalom! ✡️❤️🔥🙋
Your opinion matters just as much as anyone else's! Thanks for the feedback :)
Never heard any of this. Very awesome.
Thanks!
@@EfraimPalvanov❤
Thank you
Listen to this criticism of Exodus Decoded:
"In Exodus Decoded, filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici suggested that Yaqub-Har was the Patriarch Jacob, on the basis of a signet ring found in the Hyksos capital Avaris that read "Yakov/Yakub" (from Yaqub-her), similar to the Hebrew name of the Biblical patriarch Jacob (Ya'aqov). Jacobovici ignores the fact that Yaqub-Har is a well-attested pharaoh of the Second Intermediate Period; and Yakov and its variants are common Semitic names from the period. Furthermore, Jacobovici provides no explanation as to why Joseph would have a signet ring with the name of his father Jacob."
I think the biggest fault in Jacobovici's hypothesis is the last sentence ...
re: the excerpt at the beginning - how can one be sure the yakub seals are related to biblical joseph? i understand they are dated between the 200-yr period in question but there is no direct evidence that the seals actually belonged to joseph. and why would the seal say yaqub if it was meant for joseph? Is there no historical evidences of yaqub-named citizenry in egypt at that time period? would seem it was a common name.. what of the other inscriptions found on the seals? do they make reference of the yaqub-joseph lineage link?
are you familiar with the archaeological hagaddah by Cecil Roth?
Don't think so.
Hashem is Great!!!!
Thnx Rab. You must check Simcha’s docus, since Pharaoh may be “AmMoshe” (kinda, meaning Moshe’s brother). And Simcha show us his mommy, it fits better the dates and a couple centuries after him, came the “monotheistic Pharaoh “ married with Nefertiti, his grandfather was semitic. They were “crypto jews” and didn’t helped some semitic king in Ysrael attacked by hebrews from the Desert when asked for Pharaoh help.
Also, what does the Druze community have to say about the exodus in general and this new exodus discovery in particular? It seems to me that the descendents of the prophet Yitro, Moshe rabbeinu's father-in-law and the first convert to Torah Judaism, was instrumental in the freeing of the Hebrews from Egyptian slavery by assisting in the escape route. I conjecture that Moshe was told by Yitro and his clan about this escape route. Additionally, Moshe had likely traveled this area as a shephard and when he escaped from Paro as a young man so he knew the path.
Mt Sinai is Mt. Karkom in the Negev. All the other sites don't have the right time frame for their archaeological remnants.
Can you suggest a link?
@@debrapaulino918 ua-cam.com/video/XUZIRSQn-gU/v-deo.html
@@debrapaulino918 search - Emmanuel Anati - Har Karkom: Archaeological Discoveries on a Holy Mountain in the Desert of Exodus
Despite Josephus is not reliable for his information in his books, as he wrote it under pressure from the Rome’s, Toisfot brings him at least ones.
You're probably going to want to let the Academics who have dedicated their careers to studying him about this
southern sinai has almost no arable land and less water wells. what and where did all the livestock eat and drink?
Springs. Moshe divined for water with his staff. Before modern tech with high falutan gizmo's it was the only way to find water. An accurate diviner is superior and cheaper than modern tech which often fails anyway. You'd be astonished at what lay beneath these arrid lands.
@@debrapaulino918 If you read the Torah, you know Moses was denied entry to the Promised Land for doing this. Numbers 20:11-12 "Moses raised his hand and struck the rock with his staff twice, when an abundance of water gushed forth, and the congregation and their livestock drank. The Lord said to Moses and Aaron, "Since you did not have faith in Me to sanctify Me in the eyes of the children of Israel, therefore you shall not bring this assembly to the Land which I have given them." Creating a false narrative that is not in the Holy Torah is idolatry. I invite you to do teshuvah, repent your wicked ways, immerse yourself in the Torah, and turn away from idolatry back to the light of HaShem. 🙏
Why the Egyptian Ankh on the seal?
Because I know who and what that represents, and it isn’t ABBA
Those seals have the name of Meruserre Yaqub-Har, a Pharaoh from the XVIII century BC, not the name of the biblical Jacob.
And the most astonishing issue is that your source is the documental Exodus Decoded by Simcha Jacobovici, the same discredited documental that claims that the plagues of Egypt were caused by a volcanic eruption, do you agree with that? The same director that made another documentary claiming that he found the lost tomb of Jesus with his bones inside… Do you agree with that?
Hmmm....
What is truth, what is not? Wishing everyone a wonderful journey into finding our way through this maze of reality that is life!
@@pandora770
What is truth? That demonstrated as truth.
Thanks for the feedback. Historians don't know for sure who the Yaqub-Har seals belonged to. They have been dated to somewhere around the 15th or 14th dynasties. It is thought he may have been a Pharaoh, or a Hyksos ruler, or even a Canaanite vassal of some sort. So, I think it is very possible the seals could have something to do with the Biblical Jacob.
Simcha Jacobovici has done some interesting work, most of which I personally do disagree with. However, that doesn't mean that every single thing he says is false!
@@EfraimPalvanov
Historians are pretty sure ( jacobovici is not an historian). You can think whatever you want to think, though.
@@Mavors1099 "These people [who have agendas] are pretty sure."
Whether or not this is really Yaakov/Israel, the historians who have agendas don't matter unless they have facts/evidence to back up their "sureness."
Ron Wyatt 😊
There is a connection between Moses and Remses II.
What do you think of Josephus’s claim that the Hyksos in Egypt were the actual Israelites
I wrote about it here: www.mayimachronim.com/did-the-jews-build-the-pyramids/
Wow! Thank you…amazing content. Tired of people saying it’s just a myth…
He made a mistake, was given bad info, drew a wrong conclusion.
Velikovsky had a good rebuke for that argument
The Hyksos were the people in power that enslaved the Israelites
There is ton of evidence that contradicts the Torah. The Hyksos being the Hebrews in Kemet is not convincing. The Hyksos were Amorites or "Shepherd Kings". So are you admitting the Hebrews were Amorites and not descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob? Or, is it like what Professor Daniel Bodi has stated and are the Torah stories old Amorite stories that came to Canaan? Oh, by the way, the Aramaens were also the descendants of the Amorites.
That argument doesn't disprove the evidence. Latin Americans can call them Americans so can the US Americans... showing it can be used in both cases
@@peshfra6026 Your argument made absolutely no sense. My IQ just dropped after reading it. Spanish and Portuguese are Latin languages. The language you speak doesn't make you that language. I know people who speak 3 to 5 languages. This absolutely nothing to do with my original comment to the video.
Hyksos we’re not Amurru hahahahah they weren’t even from Retjenu. Armchair stay in your chair.
@@giffica The Hyksos were Amurru. The Hyksos kept in contact with the Babylonians westerners "Amurru" who were Amorites. Stay in your lane!
@@Biblical_DNA You contradict yourself, so were they the same as Amurru or in contact? LOL Cant keep it straight? Conflating Aamu with Amurru now? I have a PHD and have publisbed 3 books on the bronze age. Stay in your lane.
There was a whole load of evidence destroyed from my past life. Nearly almost erased my existence and so people really only had the 'lore' to refer to. HAHAHA! There are plenty of embellishments, but I can verify the truth to what is said and more. I long to visit Jerusalem for the nostalgia factor and past life memory recall.
Schizophrenic rubbish
🪔
Wait. Is it important that these things academically happened. What about sacred divine inspired writings that communicate and encode the soul of a people, their families, their history in a memorable format with divine instruction for each individual, the characters being actual living spiritual principles that play out thru history and in each individual. IMO give up the need for literal academic evidence for inspired writings that cover all people and all history and each individual. Academic objective historical research is a modern phenomena and encoding a peoples historical and spiritual journey for each individual was an ancient phenomena. Context of content. When you see an inspired movie we don't discuss day and night "how" the movie was made, the living characters etc while we are watching the movie nor should we while learning a sacred history. There is a time for watching and there is a time for composing. imo but..im a follower of Yeshua so I don't speak with authority on this. imo with the explosion and importance put upon academics, we must learn the difference and learn and teach the value of scripture...as scripture and the truth will set us free. Scripture is revealed in the divine inspiration to the prophet of his/her cultural sacred history from the divine....and the divine uses the mind , knowledge and ability of the human to do it. Its "trueness" is not academic.
Crazy because there’s literally zero evidence of Jesus
"facts still dont care about your feelings". if youre going to use archeology as proof, consider the many facts. the torah is full of plagiarism from other civilizations and nations before moshe. egypt archeology has produced a similar ark as described by the torah and much older. Hammurabi laws are copied almost word for word. creation myths, horus not eating pork because of set, el is a name of a canaanite deity. many hebrew artifacts pulled out from the earth are clay images of baal, yahu, ashorah, many idols...we have remains of the inca, the maya, the egyptians, the babylonians, the assryians, the greeks. we dont have any definitive remains of david or shlomo. not like the remains of other nations. most remains are from herod the edomite. אמת מארץ תצמח וצדק משמים נשקף
jerusalem was already a city before benei yaaqov arrived. from the days of avraham
ירש שלם ירושלם
Those other religions are proven rubbish.
@@stellarspacetraveler they arent religions, silly. theyre called civilizations. and all religions are proven to be rubbish.
@@stellarspacetraveler they are cilvilizations, silly! sure, you say the pyramids are rubbish. others would disagree. all religions are proven rubbish
@@stellarspacetraveler theyre called civilizations, silly! why was the rubbish preserved pyramids/sumerian clay tablets? where is the proof of shlomos temple or the ark of the covenant? all religions are proven rubbish
@@stellarspacetraveler theyre called civilizations, silly! why was the rubbish preserved pyramids/sumerian clay tablets? where is the proof of shlomos temple or the ark of the covenant? all religions are proven rubbish
No this is an apologetic stretch not matched by reality at all.
Misleading and making it up to shoehorn pre decided conclusions & outcomes.
Time for you to disprove it. The burden is now yours.
Wonderful, precise, concise, exciting. Thank you and thank g~d for giving you the merit to ha e the ability to share this.
I found you on pesach 2022/5782 🤝💞🎑
Thank you!