How do trig points actually work?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 717

  • @neilfoster814
    @neilfoster814 Рік тому +130

    Fun fact. below each Trig pillar is a chamber, this chamber contains a piece of rebar or scaffold pole driven deep into the ground and the coordinates and height to datum noted. If the pillar was ever destroyed, or it moved, it could be replaced to the same accuracy as the original one. My late father was a surveyor for the Ordnance Survey for nearly 40 years. He retired just before GPS became the tool of the trade for the OS. I myself worked as a surveyor for an Internal Drainage Board for 15 years surveying ditches, rivers and the coastline.

    • @ballagh
      @ballagh Рік тому +9

      Interesting to know. We’ve got a trig point on some land and I’ve often wondered about accuracy as it’s been hit by various tractors and towed implements over the years. I don’t think it’s moved much but it’s definitely been rotated by wheels rubbing against it.

    • @Fatsimbacat
      @Fatsimbacat Рік тому +1

      This was made for radio

    • @mikemiller209
      @mikemiller209 Рік тому

      Are those scaffold poles magnetic ?

    • @neilfoster814
      @neilfoster814 Рік тому

      @@mikemiller209 no, they aren't magnetic

  • @rogerwhittle2078
    @rogerwhittle2078 Рік тому +282

    My absolutely favourite story about the Ordnance Survey and how accurate the people who hauled that much concrete and brass to build a Trig Point were, all revolve around Major Martin Hotine. Hotine was directed to survey the entire country and ensure the grid system as it existed, was as accurate as possible. As the map man says, they started with the Liddington Baseline (or datum.) The country had been triangulated sometime in the 1790's using a short baseline on Hounslow Heath and later on Salisbury Plain, but Hotine's retriangulation used an 11 km baseline near Liddington in Wiltshire. Two trig points marked the ends of the datum and a third provided 'triangulation'. By using lamps and theodolites, the measurements were taken at night, as being more accurate.
    Most of the country was triangulated by the late 1930's, but war interrupted VERIFYING the survey. It wasn't until about 1962 that the checking got to the terminal datum near Inverness. What they found and calculated was astonishing. After all those tons of concrete, steel chains and dark nights with lamps and theodolites, they found the error was......this much. 17" or 42cm. In thousands of miles of calculated and measured distances, the error was less than an arms length. This meant Ordnance Survey maps are among the finest IN THE WORLD and every time I see a Trig Point - no longer used because we have satellites, GPS and laser beams - I think of Major, later Brigadier Martin Hotine and his precise mappers and thank them again and again. Don't forget him or them.

    • @Megahegs
      @Megahegs Рік тому +20

      Great information, but theres a common misconception that trigs are not still used with GNSS equipment. I use them weekly in Australia for this purpose.

    • @welshpete12
      @welshpete12 Рік тому +3

      Very interesting , thank you for the information

    • @monroe3004
      @monroe3004 Рік тому +3

      When I joined the OS in 1965 as a surveyor I was amazed that they were already working in metric.

    • @Blagger3000
      @Blagger3000 Рік тому +2

      The Corps of Royal Engineers (Survey) were amongst our earliest surveyors.

    • @Ensign_Cthulhu
      @Ensign_Cthulhu Рік тому +3

      How did he measure his baseline accurately, given that the ground between might have had obstacles? Or did he pick it for that purpose?

  • @klaasvanmanen8214
    @klaasvanmanen8214 Рік тому +2

    So far, I've only watched the intro, and I must say: job very well done! Introduce the subject, tell what others say about it and then raise the question that so few tried to answer. Now I can no longer leave this video: I have to watch it! And b.t.w.: you have a terrific voice for telling stories.

  • @ScouserBerny
    @ScouserBerny Рік тому +39

    Of all the 300+ trig pillars I have visited in the UK, today I learned how they really work. Thank you for this. Totally enlightening,

    • @tomvalentine4928
      @tomvalentine4928 Рік тому

      Same here. Surprised to learn it's so relatively recent. so I assume the 1037 date quoted was part of the Retriangulation.

    • @dickJohnsonpeter
      @dickJohnsonpeter Рік тому

      I've come across trig points in the US just hiking but they were always a metal circle like a medallion with geological info cemented into a round piece of cement on the ground. My theiry is they would probably just place a ruler on top of that since they are flush with the ground.

  • @pnwxplored
    @pnwxplored Рік тому +31

    In the late 80s I GPS surveyed many of the New Zealand trig stations from helicopter for NZ GOVT. Been in mapping ever since and the basics of trig has never let me down. The traditional trig calcs were very good ! Very little error was identified with modern satellites use. I spent often half a day at waiting until 1-2am to get southern hemisphere says to lock in back then! Spent a night often on top of a mountain waiting for the helo to get me! Couple of times I had to walk out for poor weather. Best job I ever had.

  • @glenn7245
    @glenn7245 Рік тому +50

    Brilliant.
    Never knew the details of the ' flush bracket ' or what it was called for that matter.
    Your style of delivery is excellent.
    Keep up your excellent work.

  • @TradieTrev
    @TradieTrev Рік тому +27

    I love how you've presented maths in a real world way. That's how you get the kids to learn!

  • @tfatcher
    @tfatcher Рік тому +6

    As a 78yr old oldtimer, I enjoy dusting off some of my old math skills. This was fun and your explanation of using trigonometry to calculate distinces between two points was exceptionally well done. Thanks for the memory!

  • @alexkalish8288
    @alexkalish8288 Рік тому +36

    I was looking all day for a trig point on the Ile d'Cavana in Brasil years ago. It was described as a square foot of concrete with a brass plate embedded in the top.This pre-GPS, we were going to be using transit satellites to resurvey the island.We located the exact spot but no marker.
    I gave up after 10 hours searching called for a chopper and went to get a beer at the local restaurant/shack at the landing field.After about 20 minutes speculating what happen to the marker we saw the trig marker in a rather smaller piece of concrete holding the front door open. Cheers , good video-

  • @christopherschenk9108
    @christopherschenk9108 Рік тому +18

    I came across this video by chance. What a gem! Charming and delivered by such an enthusiast. Whoever thought that algebra could be so entertaining! Thank you very much

  • @simongee8928
    @simongee8928 Рік тому +30

    I watched a documentary about the planning of the trig points in the 30s. All the concrete and other construction materials were taken to most of the sites by hand due to the remoteness of many of them. And all the calculations were done three times, each time starting from scratch, to ensure accuracy. No calculators then; slide rules and log tables - ! 😊

  • @crashnburnband
    @crashnburnband Рік тому +52

    If only my teachers in school explained this stuff as well as you did. Practical application is the key if you can see a purpose for something it becomes interesting and easier to learn.

    • @philpaton3812
      @philpaton3812 Рік тому +4

      Absolutely! In school I thought "when will I ever use this crap", but now I am interested in maps and navigation!

    • @robt2151
      @robt2151 Рік тому

      @@philpaton3812 we did learn this at school and actually used it on field work, but that was back in the 60s. Later, when I needed a job, I was able to become a surveyor setting out roads and buildings; it all started from those practical lessons.

    • @fredtaylor9792
      @fredtaylor9792 Рік тому +2

      Yes! It's easier to understand how to drive a car if you're told what the controls actually do, rather than being given a set of directions to move them in a specified way to get to point A.

    • @rudolphguarnacci197
      @rudolphguarnacci197 8 місяців тому

      Those that can, do. Those that can't, teach.

  • @jefftheaussie2225
    @jefftheaussie2225 Рік тому +14

    The first trig site in Australia was done in May 1828 by Thomas Mitchell. It is on Mt Jellore in the Southern Highlands of NSW. He used a team of convicts to clear the trees off the top of it so it could be seen. That was the start of mapping here. Although they are not used anymore it is always fun to find one and means often you are in a quite remote place. I always think of the surveyors who found and built these too. Ours are often a short pipe mast with two steel discs about one metre in diameter at right angles to each other painted alternately black and white so a black and white circle would be seen. Australia can be both very rugged and extremely flat, it can be a very long way between them on flat country, trying to find a slight rise to put one on must have been a job in itself.

  • @EMo5ive
    @EMo5ive Рік тому +3

    “Is knowing all of this going to make you a better navigator…no it’s not. I just find it interesting!”
    We are cut from the same cloth, my friend! :) I’m probably young enough to be your kid, but I’m guessing we’d make good friends. I went to college for GIS but never finished. Maps have always fascinated me, even as a kid. Thanks for the video. Very well done. Glad I found your channel!

  • @CoatsandGaiters
    @CoatsandGaiters Рік тому +18

    What a fabulous video and brilliantly presented. Just shows how important the teacher is and it's not about buying the best tech to teach with. Hands on learning at it's best.

  • @daztastic147
    @daztastic147 Рік тому +7

    No idea how or why this video popped up on my feed but it was extremely interesting and I enjoyed watching it. Very engaging the way it was produced👍

  • @dukesublime4178
    @dukesublime4178 Рік тому +2

    How times change. I’m 47 and was absolutely hanging on to every word you said lol. Brilliant video sir. Many thanks

  • @GaryLaaks1
    @GaryLaaks1 Рік тому

    Learnt something new today. 55 years old. Always wondered how it worked and then forget to Google when you get home etc. Tks mate.

  • @level1804
    @level1804 Рік тому +30

    FINALLY!
    After being an ‘A’ grade student in mathematics and arithmetic, someone shows me a practical use for trigonometry!
    I knew there was one, but no teacher ever explained the uses. Probably because they didn’t know themselves.

    • @MrRedeyedJedi
      @MrRedeyedJedi Рік тому

      It's also used in phase diagrams/angles in physics

    • @Anon54387
      @Anon54387 Рік тому

      Math teachers often don't know the practical uses, but they know the math so thoroughly that sometimes engineers, scientists, biologists do go to a mathematician for a specific answer on how to approach something. The joke about mathematicians is that they spend all day developing a problem in general to finally get around to the specific case people are working on, but in the process they do learn it thoroughly. People doing cancer and vaccine research sometimes talk to topologists, for instance.

    • @jefftheaussie2225
      @jefftheaussie2225 Рік тому

      I thought the same thing when a builder showed me how to square up a building using Pythagoras. Sin,cos and tan used to haunt me at school too because no teacher I knew could show me a practical use for trig.

    • @johnmckay1423
      @johnmckay1423 Рік тому

      I use it in DIY construction regularly. Although I often cheat and go back to the ancient Egyptian method of multiples of the 3,4,5 triangle which always gives a precise right angle. Saves needing a calculator and you look less of a geek!

  • @carlthor91
    @carlthor91 Рік тому +11

    In Canada, we refer to them as Geodetic Stations. The instruments used before GPS, where WILD T-3.
    A friend originally from Nepal, was a instrument tech. One time he went to visit family, as soon as the government found out his trade, he was hired to calibrate all the T-3's in the country, he got a lot of trips back home paid for.
    Also, the little bit of trig-work, that I took part in, was a series of 20 observations, from each point, mining work, not Geodetic work.
    Noways it's all GPS, with Lidar, for mapping.
    Best wishes from the far North.

  • @ephraimgadsbyjr.9441
    @ephraimgadsbyjr.9441 Рік тому +10

    Thanks for the very interesting video. Here in Ingham County, Michigan, USA there is a park dedicated to a surveyor error that made the map of the county not be a perfect rectangle.

    • @Anon54387
      @Anon54387 Рік тому +1

      Fun fact, no one knows exactly where the state line between Oregon and California are to this day due to some SNAFU from the 19th century (I forget the details off the top of my head) so the sign saying welcome to Oregon when heading north is about 100 yards from the sign saying welcome to California when heading south.

  • @jamescampbell7780
    @jamescampbell7780 Рік тому +4

    Essential viewing! I’ve used a theodolite for drainage gradient once only and being an amateur, I found that the new drain actually works!

  • @srl6018
    @srl6018 Рік тому +10

    I find triangulation pillars fascinating (yes I am a geek). And after watching this today I know a hell of a lot more about them than I did yesterday. Thanks.👍

  • @tararuaman
    @tararuaman Рік тому +9

    Thank you for explaining 'trig points.' Here in NZ our trigs are built in the shape of a pyramid, which consists of a steel frame with wide boards fixed to it, they stand approximately four to five metres high. The top metre is painted in black and white squares. in the middle of the trig, on the ground, is a concrete pad and in the centre of that is a steel pin. If you Google NZ trigs you will see photos of them, but all serving the same purpose as the UK ones. Enjoyed the video. ATB Cheers from the mountains of NZ ☺☺

  • @vinnalls375
    @vinnalls375 Рік тому +3

    The flush bracket demo is very good. Worth watching.

  • @Baycliff
    @Baycliff Рік тому

    Thank you. UA-cam has some interesting suggestions sometimes and this was one I just had to watch from beginning to end. Thank you presenter and camera person(s) etc. What a teacher. So clear.

  • @johnnytoronto1066
    @johnnytoronto1066 Рік тому +20

    I worked as a surveyor's assistant as a kid here in Toronto. We mostly measured urban projects for streets, bridges and tunnels. Our triangulation points were usually found in the concrete sidewalks (Pavements in the U,K,), and sometimes like your flush brackets on the sides of buildings. We called them all benchmarks. Our tools were the transit (your theodolite) and the level, a telescope with crosshairs and a levelling bubble. We relied heavily on tripods and plumb bobs. Horizontal measurements were made with the chain, which in my day had evolved down to a 100 foot steel tape marked in tenths of feet. The rod which accompanied the level for taking vertical measurements was similarly marked in tenths. We made extensive use of 2"x2" pointed wooden pegs about 14" long, which we drove into the ground with a sledge hammer. We would top the pegs with a small, dimple-headed nail to mark the precise point. That nail was generally the target for a later positioning of the transit. Where we had to drive one of these wooden pegs through a concrete sidewalk, we employed our bullprick, a two-foot long solid steel cylinder, pointed at one end and at the other, battered and bruised frommany stubborn battles with the sledge. All this was about 1965, the pre-digital age, but I imagine the terminology in Canada hasn't changed much since then. Thanks for the video and the great memories of one of the best times in my life!

    • @HweolRidda
      @HweolRidda Рік тому +1

      FYI "Transit" is short version of "transit theodolite". I think the designation means that it has the ability for the telescope go to vertical and then flip over ("Transit") down the other side.

    • @mikelong9638
      @mikelong9638 Рік тому

      @@HweolRidda I believe you are correct. It is a transit because the telescope can be inverted.

  • @nicholaskeep1605
    @nicholaskeep1605 Рік тому

    Brilliant!! That took me back to school in the mid-70s with my elementary surveying and the late 70s to the 90s navigating and hydrographic surveying... I'm now retiring to a small village in Dartmoor, so will keep a sharp lookout for the trig points...

  • @stupatrick
    @stupatrick Рік тому +11

    Amazing. Like so many people, I've ended up navigating to trig points for years without knowing what their purpose was (other than having something to do with trigonometry). Now I know 😁 Thanks!

  • @arcadia1081
    @arcadia1081 Рік тому +7

    I once had to match up GPS derived data to survey derived maps. The detail I had to get into was unbelievable, from what are known as Molodensky 3 parameter or Bursa Wolfe 7 parameter shifts. I was a humble GIS man using map reprojection systems and man was it a challenge!

  • @alexday5892
    @alexday5892 Рік тому

    This is brilliant ! I love your description and presentation. Making something curious feel quite understandable.
    I have had to navigate in white out circumstances with snow and fog obscuring all forms of references. Walking from a trig point allows you to know exactly where you. Superb video

  • @pwblackmore
    @pwblackmore Рік тому

    An informative video presented in a way most people could relate to. What I found amazing is the accuracy of the OS team... just recently I came across the National Library of Scotland with its collection of maps dating back to the late 1800s, and the comparison with satellite imagery is spot on... originally, of course, all done from ground level. Thankyou, Presenter.

  • @bobwallace5257
    @bobwallace5257 Рік тому +4

    During my time on Canadian submarines we used theodolites to calibrate the periscopes and the torpedo tubes and all other machinery requiring precise placement so that they were all aligned exactly with each other. Much like the concrete pillars in the video we had datum plates from the time the ships/submarines were built.

  • @daklakdigital3691
    @daklakdigital3691 Рік тому

    FASCINATING.
    What gives me vicarious satisfaction is notwithstanding the wonders of GPS, dotted all over the world are ground reference points used to correct GPS errors. I know of 3 in VietNam, where l live.
    Russia sought permission to install similar points in North America but we're denied.

  • @KarlWitsman
    @KarlWitsman Рік тому +4

    Very interesting! In the US, we have geodetic survey markers and through time some have been lost or they were on a bridge that has been replaced. I used to go around, while geocaching, and try to find them and report those that still existed to a website. It was educational and fun. I need to look back at some of the photos I took of them to see if the elevation was on them too.

    • @Anon54387
      @Anon54387 Рік тому +1

      One of those is set in concrete near a restored train station near to where I grew up in California. My brother, until very recently, worked as a surveyor and one of the first things they do is look for this at a property corner, they have a metal detector for this purpose as they very often wind up covered by dirt over the years.

  • @victorherrera5506
    @victorherrera5506 Рік тому

    I’m impressed. I always was curious how the surveyors would communicate with one another when one guy is looking through the eyepiece and the other is holding the elevation stick. Aerial photos show straight lines and traces of vantage points. The accuracy is amazing and I think the subject matter should’ve been shared long ago.

  • @attadudepc
    @attadudepc Рік тому

    What an extraordinary lesson, excellent in presentation. You, sir, are an amazing teacher and I'm in awe of the manner in which you've incorporated so much information

  • @chrisbryden8102
    @chrisbryden8102 Рік тому

    Thank you very much for putting together such a detailed explanation! It’s absolutely mind blowing how accurate they were when you would think even the slightest error would compound.

  • @bowlingbuddie
    @bowlingbuddie Рік тому

    Why this should appear on my youtube recommendations, i've no idea but it was so informative and easy to follow and understand, just wish you were my teacher when I was at school (50+ years ago) studying Chart work & Navigation. Thanks.

  • @user-pd5ot4zd4b
    @user-pd5ot4zd4b Рік тому +1

    Really cool viceo. I love stumbling on benchmarks. Id' argue that knowing all this would make one a better navigator! By increasing ones depth, intuition and practical knowledge of the art.

  • @rogerspencer2292
    @rogerspencer2292 Рік тому +2

    A couple of points of clarification if I may, both of which indicate the accuracy to which the Ordnance Survey works.
    1. The small support ‘stick’, upon which the spirit level was placed, must be removed. The point upon which the bottom of the staff is placed should be at exactly the same level as the top of the arrow, otherwise an error would manifest itself. Old brackets were shaped (concave) so that a temporary reference point on the bracket stood away from the face of the trig point; so the support for the spirit level, which bridged between this and the top of the arrow, was necessary - the support pieced had to be removed before the level reading was taken.
    2. The reference ‘arrow’ is only for establishing levels (the Z component) - neither the flush plate nor the staff is used in the measurement of angles. The top of the trig point/pillar has embedded metal grooves, set at 120° about the precise reference point (in X & Y) of the trig point. These grooves enable the siting of theodolites and/or their ‘targets’ with easily repeatable precision - repeatability over time and by different surveyors. Theodolites (and targets) sit on the top of the pillar, without the need for the usual tripod used by surveyors and engineers when measuring for, or setting out new, infrastructure. The central point on the top of the trig point is it’s reference point in X & Y.
    NB - I’ve learnt that links are not permitted in comments - my previous, now deleted, comment had links to images of brackets and the tops of trig points. These can be found by searching for ‘os flush brackets’ and ‘os trig point plates respectively.

  • @davidwilkinson1480
    @davidwilkinson1480 Рік тому +6

    Please correct me if I am wrong but isn't the length of T1 to TN = 11.15 and the length of T2 to TN 13.25?? The ratio of Sin 68.5 to 11.15 is not equal to the ratio of Sin 51.5 to 13.25 as pictured in 13:05 of the video.

    • @terrypold
      @terrypold Рік тому

      Yeah, wasn't the shorter side longer than the longer side?

    • @terrypold
      @terrypold Рік тому +1

      @@beeble2003 you know, I did not read the video description. Thanks for pointing it out.

    • @davidwilkinson1480
      @davidwilkinson1480 Рік тому

      Thank you all. I really enjoyed the video and I learned a great deal. I spent the next two days researching numerous trigonometric laws and reviewed many other land navigation videos.

  • @lyfandeth
    @lyfandeth Рік тому +3

    In the US, the survey markers are usually a bronze circle, about the size of your pslm, set into rock, or concrete flush with the ground.
    The problem is that every time a sidewalk is replaced, or a road widened, or some other routine work done, the old markers are either buried or removed, with no attempt to put in replacements or surrogates. So especially in urban areas, finding marks and confirming whether they still exist can be quite challenging.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому

      We (in the UK) would call them a Bench Mark, not a trig point

    • @akulkis
      @akulkis Рік тому

      ​@@TheMapReadingCompany
      Same in the US.
      On US Geological Survey maps, they are literally marked with × symbols.

  • @buxvan
    @buxvan Рік тому

    I'm not a Hiker, Explorer, Fell Runner or Russian Spy, But I really enjoyed your Trig point explanation.
    Brilliant & well done.
    Takes me back to school & the horrible book of cosines, tangents & angles.

  • @dannycbe949
    @dannycbe949 Рік тому

    Brilliant. 63 year old civil engineer here....
    If onky our professors had explained this as good...

  • @oscarrox
    @oscarrox Рік тому +2

    Great explanation of something I've walked past countless times. Your videos are very interesting and educational, thank you.

  • @LarsDahlin
    @LarsDahlin Рік тому +1

    I did some civil engineering in Sweden for a decade in the 90's. Lovely reminder of the craft. Except you seem to have less mosquitos and bugs flying around at the moment.
    All the best!

  • @Dudleymiddleton
    @Dudleymiddleton Рік тому +3

    There is one on the A1101 near Nordelph( Cambs/Norfolk) and another at Mepal( on the way to Ely from March) Old Airfield, and at Beeston regis cliffs near Sheringham, Norfolk. Fascinating stuff! :)

  • @kimamey
    @kimamey Рік тому

    It's not something I need to know, but having seen a lot of them this was very ingesting.
    You did get one thing wrong when you said, "As you'll remember from school." All I remember from school, over 50 years ago, was that I didn't understand it, and that hasn't changed. Maybe I should try again.
    Thanks for a facinating video.

  • @malcolmstead272
    @malcolmstead272 10 місяців тому

    I did a presentation on this exact subject to my Explorer Scouts, this was to give them a better understanding of their maps; excellent video.

  • @zabaleta66
    @zabaleta66 Рік тому +2

    A video like this is exactly what the internet should be all about! Well done 👍

  • @123xqp
    @123xqp Рік тому +2

    Very interesting. I've seen the plates in the side of trig points many times but I never knew their purpose. I always assumed that the theodolite sat in the brass disc on top of the pillar and the plate on the side was for identification plus some random goverment marks. One small correction, which doesn't affect your video at all - you've swapped the calculated side lengths between Tn and the other two points. The longest side is opposite the largest angle. In practice this would have been noticed when the adjacent pillars were surveyed. Thanks for the video. I learned something new and that makes my day.

  • @Olan...
    @Olan... Рік тому +13

    Great info you are providing here, well done lad. Is the plate on the trig point put on the side that it is on for any specific reason ? I was in the military for 15 years and we would make/build a model of the terrain that we was going to cover out of sand so that we could discus things like potential ambush points and cover anti ambush drills or select observation point positions before we deployed so we had a good idea that we could see a target area from where we would be located. Sometimes the vegetation or tree line would hamper this but it was a good way of becoming familiar before we deployed and very often you wouldn't need to get a map out en route. It's something i still practice today and i am always selecting features to handrail while i am walking to a certain feature . I have tried GPS but always go back to a map because it gives me a better overall picture of the landscape rather than trying to look at a small screen that kind of blisters up when it's raining. Its like having a birds eye view in my opinion and i just prefer maps plus they dont cost an arm and a leg.

  • @madeljacky
    @madeljacky Рік тому

    The first video I have seen that explains the trig towers and how they work, I often wondered what the flush plate was for but it was even better to see a practical example how the attachment worked, thank you sir.

  • @Bokooda
    @Bokooda Рік тому +1

    Fascinating. I'm 56 and I 'sort' of knew what they were for and why they were there (ordnance = military) but not how they were created and not why they aren't all the same. It would be interesting to learn why those 2 particular reference points were chosen as the 'standard' for distance and average sea level... Cheers! 🙏🏽

  • @Takn835
    @Takn835 Рік тому +5

    You are a wealth of good knowledge. Very insightful 👍

  • @geoffmatthews2353
    @geoffmatthews2353 Рік тому

    Just for your own (useless) information, the arrow is a “broad arrow” from the predecessor of the Ministry of Defence- the War Office. When Ordnance Survey was formed, maps were secret, your Ordnance Survey maps used to have GSGS - Geographic Section (of the) General Staff - printed on two corners of every map. I’m not sure when that stopped, it was certainly printed on every map I used in the Army as a Map Reading Instructor in the 80s and 90s. Keep up the good work, I really enjoy the channel!

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +1

      A broad arrow. Thanks for that. I didn't know that.
      We learn something new every day 😉

  • @garymucher4082
    @garymucher4082 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the tutorial about how to figure things out like this. I knew it was going to be pretty precise mathematics to get the answers for these measurements and elevations. I like it too... Thumbs Up!

  • @loskop100
    @loskop100 Рік тому +5

    I recall working as a chainman in the late 60's in New Zealand and the end of the wire was connected to a tension spring so as to be able to calculate the sag in the wire but and also the temperature recorded to allow for the expansion of the wire. Cutting bush and scrub so that the chain wasn't touching anything was also the job of the chainman but I was a lot fitter back then. Thanks for the video, it bought back many memories of a time that I enjoyed very much.

    • @williamhall8683
      @williamhall8683 Рік тому +3

      I was a few years behind you in NZ, working for the MOW conducting deformation surveys on the Waikato dams .. `Maraetai, etc Fortunately, the EDMs had just arrived, so triangulation became trilateration. Still, we had to clear the bush!.. Happy memories …….. I gave up survey when GPS took over; survey then became boring

  • @1a1u0g9t4s2u
    @1a1u0g9t4s2u Рік тому

    Some of my memory cells are telling me I watched a TV show (yes before the internet) explaining how a team surveyors used this principle to calculate the height of Mt Everest. That team was very accurate but I don't remember to what that was. Perhaps one of your viewers knows this. Very interesting post, Thanks for sharing.

  • @timothykeech7394
    @timothykeech7394 Рік тому +7

    There's an error there somewhere. Given the angles you have measured, the sloping side to the right should be shorter than that on the left. You should be calculating using opposite angles. The sides you have calculated should exchange positions. Apart from the mathematical error, this video is fascinating for its information and explanation and very well presented. I studied this stuff nearly 60 years ago when the job was very much hands on with microwave measurement in its infancy then, so it is all familiar and nostalgic.

    • @Darisiabgal7573
      @Darisiabgal7573 Рік тому +4

      The formula which should have been written is Sin A/a = Sin B/b = Sin C/c
      We can rewrite this for the Application
      T1°/lenT2T3 = T2°/lenT1T3 = T3°/lenT2T1
      Just as a side note here. If we were actually doing this on a large triangle we need to kniw that as the len of any side increases this measurement would not reflect statute distances because of the curvature of the earth surface. In that situation we need to recalculate given the cord and converting the cord to an arc (And the ancient babylonians would be smiling at you).
      T3° = 60°
      T2° = 51.5°
      T1° = 68.5°
      lenT1T2= 12.34 m
      The equation we select first is T1/lenT2T3 = T3/lenT1T2
      we can then insert the givens and solve Sin 60°/12.34 m = Sin 68.5°/ lenT1T2
      lenT1T2 * Sin 60°/ 12.34 m = Sin 68.5°
      lenT1T2 = 12.34m * Sin 68.5°/Sin 60°
      lenT1T2 = 12.34m * 1.074
      lenT1T2 = 13.2575 m
      And so we can see he assigned the length he calculated to the wrong side.
      Good thing im not a cartographer or I might have got it wrong too.😎

    • @timothykeech7394
      @timothykeech7394 Рік тому

      At a glance it didn't even look right. I'm sure if I'd done that I would have realised immediately just from the angle sizes - well, actually, I did. I am aware of adjustment for curvature but his distances were very short so not an issue worth raising for the purpose of the video.@@Darisiabgal7573

    • @bluestormcloud791
      @bluestormcloud791 Рік тому

      @@Darisiabgal7573 The three angles of a triangle on a flat plane add up to 180 degrees. on a sphere they will a up to slightly more than 180 degrees. Earth curves about 8 inches in the first mile.

  • @jg2072
    @jg2072 Рік тому +2

    This is very interesting. I did a presentation about the Public Land Survey System here in the USA. You do a much better job that I did. The other challenge to explain is how chaining can be done over elevation. As a Forester we used chaining when walking to determine locations. My chain is 12.5 paces to 66 feet. My last half pace was a little short.

  • @MichaelOnines
    @MichaelOnines Рік тому +16

    At 13:20 you made an error in calculating the unknown side lengths and got them swapped around. The T2-TN length is 13.258m, and the T1-TN length is 11.15m. You always want to use the angle opposite the side you are trying to calculate in your equation. You used an adjacent angle.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +9

      Oh. Sorry about that. Trying to do maths on a board in a tree is always slightly difficult.
      The basic idea is correct though - I've just watched it again and you're correct I got the "T's" mixed.
      Well spotted

    • @MichaelOnines
      @MichaelOnines Рік тому +5

      @@TheMapReadingCompany No worries. That example tool you built for the flush mount monument was really neat.

    • @bimocular4312
      @bimocular4312 Рік тому +2

      I hunted for somoene else who noticed!!

    • @modularinspiration
      @modularinspiration Рік тому

      I had to come hunting through the comments to check this too. Great tutorial even with the minor maths mix up.

  • @peterchamberlain4448
    @peterchamberlain4448 Рік тому

    When I was in the Royal Navy we surveyed the Malacca Straights for supertanker transition, we set up two Decca stations on the Malay coast and used the ship as the third leg in the triangle .

  • @evelearmont8545
    @evelearmont8545 Рік тому +1

    Thank you for your video, I have often wondered how/why trig points work as mapping. I am rubbish at maths but even I could understand your explanation. Brilliant !

  • @MrBasildondave
    @MrBasildondave 9 місяців тому

    Very interesting, thanks. I figured how the position of TN was found myself, but I always wondered how to get the height. You cleared that up for me 😊. Great video

  • @graememartin196
    @graememartin196 Рік тому

    One of the most interesting explaining videos on UA-cam. Very interesting

  • @henrytomlinson3634
    @henrytomlinson3634 Рік тому

    Thank you for taking the time and effort to explain all this to all of us. All the best from Henry in Central UK

  • @paulf2529
    @paulf2529 Рік тому

    Brilliant, by farr the best explanation ive read and one i could follow even with my school maths knowledge that i havent used for years!

  • @bareenlars
    @bareenlars Рік тому

    Such a lovely video! Love how you explained it so well! These things is so strangely fascinating :D

  • @matthewsheeran
    @matthewsheeran Рік тому

    Strictly speaking the compass bearing is a magnetic asimuth and actual theodolite bearing i.e. angle measurement wirh respect to the baseline would be more accurate because of magnetic variation from place to place but the priciple is the same. I am not a surveyor but I am GIS guy who has been a surveyors' assistant. Great stuff. I once did a GPS assignment atop of a Trig Station so that I could be sure of the actual position although we ignored the plate tectonics way back then too, hehe!

  • @wilkoone9155
    @wilkoone9155 Рік тому +1

    In the early 1800s a mile long bi-metal strip was placed near the village of Bellerena at the mouth of the river Roe in Northern Ireland. This was the baseline from which the whole island of Ireland became the first country in the World to be surveyed to 6" to the mile in wonderful coloured maps, which were finished in 1846.

  • @LoftechUK
    @LoftechUK Рік тому

    This is brilliant and have joined the club. Happy to see more when posted.

  • @grahamlait1969
    @grahamlait1969 Рік тому +5

    There is a lovely story (which we must hope is true) that when the OS were doing their original mapping of the UK in the Highlands of Scotland, they asked the locals what the name of various hills and mountains were. As in many parts of the Highlands the locals spoke only Gaelic and the surveyors spoke none, the surveyors would note the answers phonetically, in standard English. So far, so good. When the new super duper OS maps were about to be published, a Highlander read the proofs and realised that a lot of the Scottish mountains had very strange names, because if pronounced as written, in Gaelic, they were apparently called things like 'Who's asking?' and 'What business is that of yours?' or 'Why do you care?' and 'Just stop bothering the sheep'. Of course, the necessary corrections were made, but It may be that some Scottish hills on the OS maps still have such names and Hamish in Auchtermuchty is still having a bit of a laugh to himself.

  • @SuperNova-py1ec
    @SuperNova-py1ec Рік тому

    Fascinating thanks. I came across one of these whilst holidaying in Yorkshire.

  • @Patriot-bn9om
    @Patriot-bn9om Рік тому +2

    In 8th grade Trigonometry class we all probably thought it was useless math. I wish the teacher knew enough to tell us how it was used to map a country hundreds of years ago. We just needed an accurate measurement between just two trigs points, and a theodolite to accurately measure angles between points, then just simple math to calculate the distance between all points and the elevation of each.

  • @stoatrepublic
    @stoatrepublic Рік тому +1

    Good base for Amateur radio antenna as well...

  • @djs5074
    @djs5074 9 місяців тому

    Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant. Thank you. My girlfriend is now going to get a full history and workings of trig points on our next walk, I'm sure she'll be thrilled 🙈

  • @StevenB-081
    @StevenB-081 Рік тому +2

    Great video and fascinating.
    Keep up the good work and amazing info

  • @t23001
    @t23001 Рік тому +2

    I am math (or maths) challenged, but I have always been curious about benchmarks and their use. Thank you for the clear and detailed explanation. Kudos on your maker/wood working skills, too.

    • @TRPGpilot
      @TRPGpilot Рік тому +1

      I would suggest that 'Mathematically' is the word that you were looking for .

    • @kaboom-zf2bl
      @kaboom-zf2bl Рік тому +1

      a simple way to make the math easier ... is find one trig point ... find a spot 30 units way ... then on a right angle ... put a compass on TOP of the trig point and level it locate the 30units marker you have put and then at 90degrees to that line up or down measure 40 units away .... the final side will be 50 units and all you need is to get the angle to the 30unit point or 40 unit point from the other point you placed ... again the compass ... you just made your self a perfect right triangle and now have a good square reference point set to work from ...
      the joys of the 3 4 5 triangle ... they always make a right triangle .. because of pythagorus ... a squared + b squared = c squared ... or 9 + 16 = 25 ...

    • @jefftheaussie2225
      @jefftheaussie2225 Рік тому

      A bench mark is a starting reference point, all the levels and angles relate to this point which is made as permanent as possible. Future surveys will relate to this mark. I am not a surveyor but have done a bit at ag college in relation to farm dam construction.

  • @michaelcerkez3895
    @michaelcerkez3895 Рік тому +2

    In the USA, we have Geological Survey Markers. They have a precise center, as well as distance above or below sea level. Most of these are along railroad bridges and the like. Very interesting video, thank you.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +2

      Ours also have a very precise centre.
      If you notice the small hole at the base of the trig, they used to be on each side, but 3 are normally plugged up with concrete. The 4th hole is left so that any water seeping into the trip can evaporate.
      They were used these to site a plumb line from the top so it was very exactly positioned.
      I did have this sort of "stuff" in the video but edited it out, or it would have been too long.

    • @michaelcerkez3895
      @michaelcerkez3895 Рік тому

      @TheMapReadingCompany As soon as I saw the triangles it took me back to college and learning Trig for machine trades. Good times. Well done Sir.

    • @TexasEngineer
      @TexasEngineer Рік тому

      As an engineer for the power company I am very familiar with the USGS markers. I had a large 300’ crossing tower fail because it was hit by a tornado. I went out with the construction crew that was removing the tower and foundations. I noticed a USGS marker had been placed on the foudations that were 60’ deep concrete piles. I also noticed the foundations had moved and were the source of the failure. I had a delema, what to do with the unauthorized marker that had been pulled up slightly by a tornado. I ordered the crew to preserve the marker and I hoped the USGS would work out the variance in elevation if they releveled. The site was on the Houston Ship Channel and was subject to subsidence. The replacement foundations were 150 feet deep wth 34” diameter steel piles, 8 per leg. It was really bad soil.

  • @thecornishmaker5285
    @thecornishmaker5285 Рік тому

    Great video, I've always wondered if they were actual triangles. Just a quick note, I'm pretty sure you calculated the right hand side at 12:38. The sine rule refers to the angle opposite the side you want to find.

    • @colm1478
      @colm1478 Рік тому

      Yes, something felt wrong to me with the results. The lengths of the sides of the triangle calculated didn't make sense given the comparative angles. You can even see it has to be wrong in the roughly sketched triangle.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +2

      Have a look at the video description. I got the graphics the wrong way round. Sorry.

  • @alan2804
    @alan2804 Рік тому +1

    Very interesting and informative, ive often wondered how these things were used and what the height should be measured from. I never knew about that flush bracket and had forgotten about the line in the harbour innCornwall. The baseline was a new one on me too, i think years ago there was a docudrama on this surveying forcOS? However id forgotten most of what it taught!

  • @Megahegs
    @Megahegs Рік тому +15

    The 'ruler' is called a staff in Australia. Staves for plural. The arrow is a traditional broadarrow, signifying ownership of the Crown. Also most commonly seen on convict uniforms.

    • @lambtonrob
      @lambtonrob Рік тому

      I’ve seen hole & broad arrows used as RMs instead of the usual drill hole & wing in a suburb where I’ve worked. A rare example of a surveyor with too much time on their hands.

    • @Megahegs
      @Megahegs Рік тому

      @@lambtonrob really old suburb?

    • @alexandermenzies9954
      @alexandermenzies9954 Рік тому

      No use in South Australia and Northern Territory then!
      (No convicts allowed to settle in those colonies. :-)

  • @jime8532
    @jime8532 Рік тому +4

    nice demo, thanks. But if I may, the use of the sin law step -you had the wrong sides with each angle. IE the longer side is opposite the larger angle. Besides that, I learned a lot. thanks.

  • @wjf0ne
    @wjf0ne Рік тому +6

    As a child at school my maths teacher droned on putting us all to sleep with no connection with his droning to the real world.
    Imagine if he had put it into context of how it was used, heck we might have been interested and I may have had an understanding of maths and gone on to do great things rather than becoming the factory fodder we were destined to become.

    • @Anon54387
      @Anon54387 Рік тому

      There is such a thing as personal responsibility. Just because your math teacher doesn't do say why or how it is used doesn't excuse you. Ask him, and if he can't or won't answer go look it up online. My parents taught me that I'm the one responsible for myself, not my friends, not my teachers, not even my parents when it comes to it. Apparently you missed that lesson somehow. If you rely on others you will always be disappointed.
      Teachers are sometimes, perhaps even often, boring but it is still in your interest to learn it despite that.

  • @kurtnowak8895
    @kurtnowak8895 Рік тому

    This was so interesting, I watched right to the end. Even though you filmed it on the windiest day of the year. 😉 thank you.

  • @JM-jd7yp
    @JM-jd7yp Рік тому

    Absolutely fascinating. I enjoyed every minute of this video and I didn't like maths at school. Thank you and I wish you well.

  • @compostjohn
    @compostjohn Рік тому +2

    My friend Charles ('veggiebagger' to some) is a collector of trig points, and photographs them, sometimes repaints them. He will love this vid, and I'm sure his friends will find it interesting to find out what they're for and how they were used.

  • @Jo-NZ522
    @Jo-NZ522 Рік тому +1

    I have always known they were something to do with measuring land but didn’t know how. Now I do thank you very interesting.

  • @bobwallace5257
    @bobwallace5257 Рік тому

    Absolutely love this video. I try to learn something new everyday and you are very entertaining.

  • @Fragrantbeard
    @Fragrantbeard Рік тому

    Fascinating! Thank you for educating me about something totally new to me today.

  • @KidCurry666
    @KidCurry666 Рік тому

    Love maps but never knew the full story of trig points, very enlightening, thanks for posting 👍👍

  • @martintierney7187
    @martintierney7187 Рік тому

    That was actually pretty informative, well done and a great explanation. Thank you for your time in doing this video. Not that it made my memories of the Army’s land nav course’s and practical field maneuvering any better 😢 but it make me think there were other n
    Knuckle heads out their before me laying it down. 😂😂😳😳 Thanks again and we’ll done.

  • @SeanGavin-rf5vd
    @SeanGavin-rf5vd Рік тому

    As a kid in South Africa I first became fascinated with the word Trig beacon during a geography class when i was 11 or 12.
    Out on a hike a few years later I came across a Trig beacon. But only many years later learnt what they are used for.

  • @nikob5899
    @nikob5899 Рік тому +2

    Fascinating 🎉 another great video. 😮

  • @UK_Lemons
    @UK_Lemons Рік тому +1

    The BBC made an excellent program called "A very British map. The Ordnance Survey Story." It is on UA-cam.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/w5_kWzUahQU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared

    • @UK_Lemons
      @UK_Lemons Рік тому

      ​​​​​@@TheMapReadingCompanyNice of you to post a link. Your explaination if trig points was excellent. One thing I don't think you mentioned is the plate on top which has three machined slots at 120 degrees to each other and metal loops to allow secure clamping of instruments to the trig point.
      Regarding height calculations around 200 "fundamental bench marks" (or FBMs) were located across the country. The visible section of an FBM pillar is usually about nine by eleven inches and around a foot tall (to use the units of measurement from the Imperial era in which they were built), with a brass bolt set into the top and a name plate declaring it to be an ‘Ordnance Survey BM’. There is also an underground chamber containing the “master” precise reference marks for the point. Between these 200 FBMs, around 750,000 "lower order benchmarks" were established. Precise levelling built up a picture of the profile of the land, giving rise to the spot heights and contour lines you see on OS maps. The elevation benchmark points are still maintained and in use today.

  • @richardbrown1895
    @richardbrown1895 2 місяці тому

    Watch this on TV have to come on the phone to make a comment .
    Thanking tou so much its. Helped me understand mapping ,
    It's like the penny's dropped. ..100% thanks mate ..👍💥

  • @TrainDriverRob
    @TrainDriverRob Рік тому

    Great video, thank you. As I understand there’s a bit going on inside the trig point which includes a sighting tube, a centre tube and at the bottom a centre mark.

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому +1

      Yes. If you look at the thumbnail photo you can still one of the sighting tubes - at the bottom of the face.
      I did include a fuller description of the trig and how it was constructed but I had to edit it out as the video was becoming too long.

  • @dysfunctional_vet
    @dysfunctional_vet Рік тому

    i learned navigation while in high school and being in the united states, our start point is meads farm (spelling subject to correction), and the navigation team spent 2 weeks working precise (off pans of oil if i remember corrected with corrections for oil sights), to get where the start point was.
    your short presentation was a great refresher for what i learned so long ago. it was actually the into to celestial nav, as you could not get there before you mastered piloting. it is interesting that the old guys that mapped the world with instruments were pioneers and while we have better optics and more precise measurements with lasers, nothing has really changed at all.
    very to the point video, i will share

    • @dysfunctional_vet
      @dysfunctional_vet Рік тому

      i forgot to state that meads farm is considered the exact center of the united states

    • @TheMapReadingCompany
      @TheMapReadingCompany  Рік тому

      I went to the center of Great Britain - the exact 1cm square.
      It took quite a while to find it.
      ua-cam.com/video/KgGOnqPa4e0/v-deo.html