Festool CT Cyclone Review | Not Great!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 сер 2024
- Watch our newest video: "A Fancy Dead Blow Hammer, a Back-Saving Quick Lift, and a Bargain Router Plane | Tools Unleashed 02 "
• A Fancy Dead Blow Hamm... -~-
Festool recently launched their new CT Cyclone. My first reaction was one of curiosity since most cyclone separators are fairly bulky with a large conical shape. Festool's offering is very "Festool" and looks to a Rubbermaid tote sandwiched between two Systainers. I use multiple CT Vacs in my shop and it would be great to have something that's fairly compact, attaches directly to the CT vac, and gives me the option of putting additional Systainers on top of the stack. Unfortunately, after hooking the CT Cyclone to my vac, I immediately notices a loss in suction. This prompted further investigation. To spoil the ending, it's not all bad news. If you typically use the small hose with your vac you'll notice a typical amount of suction loss and it's by no means a deal-breaker. But if you use the larger hose, like I do, you might be better served with one of the other cyclone separators that have already been on the market for years: such as the Oneida Dust Deputy or the ClearVue CV Mini. If you really need the Festool form-factor, take a look at Oneida's Ultimate Dust Deputy.
The original Cyclone Separator Shootout: • 170 - Cyclone Separato...
Oneida Dust Deputy - amzn.to/2CqOWqy
ClearVue CV Mini - www.clearvuecyc...
Oneida's Dust Deputy for Festool Vacs - amzn.to/2q0kuwb
My cyclone test results: docs.google.co...
*Quick correction: I mention that the previous version of the ClearVue Mini was hampered by a short top. It was actually the conical portion of the unit that was shortened.
SUBSCRIBE!
www.youtube.com...
TAKE YOUR WOODWORKING TO THE NEXT LEVEL
thewoodwhispere...
SUPPORT US ON PATREON!
/ woodwhisperer
PRODUCTS RECOMMENDED BY MARC
www.amazon.com...
CHECK OUT OUR SECOND CHANNEL
/ woodwhispereroffcuts
CHECK OUT OUR SHOP TOURS
www.thewoodwhis...
GET INSPIRED BY OUR VIEWER PROJECT LIBRARY
www.thewoodwhis...
DOWNLOAD OUR FREE APP
Android: bit.ly/1MQ4ks1 or iOS: bit.ly/177u4An
WIN FREE TOOLS!
thewoodwhispere...
Follow me on:
TWITTER - / woodwhisperer
FACEBOOK - / thewoodwhisperer
INSTAGRAM - / woodwhisperer
Pinterest: / woodwhisperer
Download my results here: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQn26pgEWCn3ltGXISeCdxuPblN4wj7IBSASOVsO5WOP_DyDxGpKGcTj5-FiDoMRdZqINlLZLROjQKZ/pubhtml And check out the original cyclone shootout here: ua-cam.com/video/-Ct5R6_bj80/v-deo.html
Thought your testing procedure was good, you kept the hose in the same place on the meter, and made sure to do controls too with just bare kit.
I watched this video before buying my CT Cyclone, so I knew what I was getting into when I got it. I also picked up an airflow meter to do some testing of my own & found a 27% drop in suction when running it through the 27mm hose.
So, I started do ing some testing & experimenting. I added some tape to act as gaskets to the perimeter of the 90º elbow where it seats into the lid, as well as the bottom of the conical piece that seats down into the Systainer.
These two modifications were able to bring the total CFM loss down to only 14%. I'll be searching for a thin foam tape to make for a more permanent gasket, but it would be great if Festool developed their own proper gasket set, as it improves things dramatically.
I also built a testing apparatus and have been improving efficiency. I'd like to implement your modifications and test it. Care to share any more details?
Wow, especially in this pricerange its a shame they didnt construct proper gaskets.
It’s a brilliant separator I’m a professional floor sander . Use some tape to seal a couple leaks and run it all day long on big machinery . Small footprint in vehicle.
Hi Mr Wood Whisperer - interesting review, just came across it - bit late. When the CT Cyclone came out, I bought one as well to use it and to compare it against my Oneida cyclone. Instead of a wind speed measurement instrument, which I tried as well, I have used a tool to measure pressure - which I think is a bit more reliable and it definitely produces numbers which can be reproduced. To cut a story short of many evenings of measurements and comparisons between cyclones and vacuum cleaners - the conclusion was that you really need to keep your filters clean, because that is where you really loose pressure. Not so much the 90 degrees angles (which I expected) and not so much the cyclone type. Of course hose diameter makes a difference and so does hose length, but the largest influence on the efficiency of the whole system, that lies in the filters. So the new Festool midi vacuum cleaner with the filter-cleaning handle on the outside - that is a good improvement.
I love these reviews because this pushes the manufacturers to think outside the box and make improvements. You carry the mantel well Marc by being a voice for these comparisons and pushing these guys to try harder to make quality products that cater to the woodworkers needs, especially when they ask for a pretty penny. Thanks for doing this!
I too have had mine since they came out. It’s a great bag saver. I use mine with my CT-Sys which has a notoriously small bag. I now change the CT-Sys bag once every 9 to 12 months. Before I changed it monthly or more on a big project. With the new larger capacity, the CT-Sys is now my dedicated “portable” Dust Extractor. I use it with all appropriate Festool tools and for clean up. I just remodeled a laundry room and bath room and the CT-Sys with Cyclone was my only Dust Extractor for sawing, routing, sanding, and even Kapex duty. My CT-36 with Dust Dust Deputy now stays in the shop.
yeah i just picked up this cyclone from Festool and cant wait to use it. I was wondering how often I'm gonna need to change the Bag in my ct26... wow you say 9-12 months!! that's a heck of a great deal of money savings in filter bags...
No one seems to mention pressure drop. Thanks for bringing that up. Great video. Thanks for sharing.
I bought my first Festool tool last week, a TS 75 with a track long enough to cut a 4x8 sheet of plywood. I haven't even used it yet, but you can tell a lot of thought and precision was put into it, the fact it comes with it's own hard shell box alone is a huge step up. I think it will be Festool all the way from here, slowly though, they are pricey. But I've learned that if I save my money and buy something that is known high quality I won't have to buy it again any time soon. Thanks for the review.
What I would really like to see is a compact system by someone that utilizes a cyclone separator that is integrated into a short vacuum unit. There's no need for 4-6 gallons of debris storage in most shop vacs if you're using a separator so I'd rather have something that the total height can live under a bench or miter station.
I've been using the festool cyclone for a year now and I am extremely satisfied with it. I have not seen any problems. Only benefits so far.
But do you have the cfms to drive the turbo nozzle beater bar which requires the larger hose? I just bought this when they couldn't tell me which size connection to the vacuum it had. Saw the thin hose, though I'll use one of my other fat whip hoses, opened the top, has an inch thick black plastic duct. It can't drive my festool beater bar brush on a 7m hose. How could they make it without at least the mid sized hose in mind? Dropping to the small sander hose from the start is a major drop in volume. I run planex, renofix, both larger hose, both create bulk, as well as cleaning attachments. Guess I'll go back to sweeping more to save my filters and picking up the things I won't have lift for. They should at least offer another lid\duct for larger hose. It's gonna have to go back as it fails at 80% of what I do. I cat handle the rotex with their proper hose but that's it. Takes forever to fill a bag with one of them anyway. So it's just added bulk and complexity for reduced performance in my operation. Mid hose even would have been great.
Would just like to add ,, I use mine on a syst vac , and no loss of suction at all. It fits neatly in the van as it's a systainer... if I didn't have this I would be emptying the tiny bag every 5 min on a router table or thicknesser..
This is not for a casual users, got slammed a lot in the reviews here, but I use it with the festool drywall sander and it is amazing. There really aren't a lot of options to collect drywall dust without ruining your vacuum as the dust clogs your filters and overheats the vacuum. So money well spent for me. Good review, but left out some uses.
I just saw a review that showed the Festoool cyclone suck up half a container of sawdust with only 2.5% finer dust left in the lower unit. Seems to be working pretty good to me.
I've had great luck with it for over a year. Before I had it, drywall dust in the non-AC dust extractor would clog the bag and destroy suction in minutes. Now, nearly no dust makes it to the bag.
I am sure I told you this in the past, but you have such an amazing voice! You really need to get a side job as an audiobook reader!
I’m tinkin Festool have ripped people off for years, they do have some unique engineering advances over competitors however a little vacuum cleaner with connectable dust hoses & hyper inflated prices make it difficult to purchase, nice review 🍻👍
Festool tools are built as an entire system. If you have a festool saw then you would use the festool dust extractor so that you can properly use its switching and dust extraction.
You only think it is expensive because you have no idea what to use the tools for. Mafell is about 3 times more expensive than festool.
It's only a rip off if you're forced to buy it. But we live in a mostly free market economy so you actually have no justification for bitching. Are you a cashier at 7-Eleven?
I have about $5G in Festool stuff and based on the piss poor after purchase service of Festool USA I'm unlikely to buy any of their tools when it comes time to replace them except for their sanders and the domino tools.
After watching this video I got an idea. You have your dust collector and you also have your dust extractor like these for small tools as you know large system is not that great for hand tool dust collecting applications. So, I bought a Kirby vacuum cleaner motor head which has an impeller that is separated from the motor, which has a separate assembly to get cooled. The impeller sucks the dust and within few inches exhausts it to a bag via 3 inch pipe. I’ve removed the bag and connected the three inch hose to a 4 inch hose to my large shop three stage dust extractor with cyclonic action. This way I have one place for all the dust from the small and large tools, none of the filter expense of expensive small systems like festool and other, takes very little space and it’s in-line install setup for under 100 bucks. Awesome video as always very informative. Thank you.
I love your unbiased reviews and this one is no exception. Personally - if I could afford, and justify buying one of these - I would walk away from the purchase feeling that I had just let go of $375 for a plastic box with some plastic bits in it, while the cost of e.g. the Festool CT SYS CLEANTEC, with a 1000W motor and all sorts of technology and accessories costs only $20 more at $395. I think that most people will agree that while Festool do produce some very high quality tools, but there is a quite big snob factor connected to the brand name too, which, as in this case, allows them to charge a ridiculous amount of money for almost nothing.......and, in many cases, get away with it too!
+J F
That is not the reason Festool accessories cost so much. They employ about 700 people and have revenues of about $350 million.
SO everytime they produce something new for their tool system it is going cost money and they are not going to be making a large profit on the accessories either.
@@bighands69 I am not sure how the number of employees, and their revenues, has anything to do with the asking price of $375 for this cyclone plastic box? Besides, all other tool producers who invent, design and produce their own tools also have employees, and of course revenues too. Where is the difference?
I agree that superior quality obviously cost more to produce, and therefor also cost more to purchase for the end user. I also agree that a lot of Festool's tools are indeed very high quality, well designed, and produced with fine tolerances and made to last. This cyclone box is, however, just a "plastic box" that has clearly been developed on the basis of the existing systainer box. In my mind this does not justify an asking price similar to that of an entire vacuum system with a motor, intricate motor parts and electrics, along with a lot of accessories.
If you decided to buy an above average quality and expensive lawn mower, an then had to buy the grass collector separately, and that cost almost the same as the lawn mower, I don't think you would be smiling all the way home with your new lawn mower priced grass collector.
I noticed the same issue on drop in suction but I gained back what suction I perceived to have lost by ditching the short 27mm hose supplied with the cyclone kit and using a 50mm hose cut down to the length of the short supplied hose. In your test you used a long 50mm hose.
There still is a slight decrease In cubic foot per sec/min but if you then upgrade the tool end hose to 36mm hose all together you end up with more cubic foot than you had with the basic set up.
Basically ditch the shirt 27mm gap hose and ditch the tool side 27mm if you want superior sucking for Kapex, router, track saw etc…
If you are only using sanders the cyclone is fine with the 27mm hoses because you need to turn down the suction anyway or the vacuum pulls the sander into you work surface and causes sanding abrasive cut circles/swirl marks.
I have 3 of these set ups. One for Kaypex, one for sanding and one for high chip creating tools like the router. All gave the cyclones on them all on the original provided bag.
The suction loss is coming from the part that goes from the center of the cyclone to the connector hose. Looks like it's only an inch, inch and a half in diameter.
Home Depot's Dustopper with some insulation foam tape added to the lid can't be beat at $45 all included (buck and tape).
I went with the Oneida a while ago for the CT vacs. It works very well, little drop in suction.
As a hobbyist, my rationale for Festool is time savings. The Domino has been amazing in that regard and has not only saved me some of the precious little time I get to go into the shop (I work full-time) it has also allowed me to do some pretty creative things I would have been hard-pressed to do before. Their Quad drive drill is a monster. I have a Dust Deputy over a shop-vacuum (a la Jay Bates) and it works great, but I was hoping for good reviews for the Festool Cyclone so I could have something lower to the ground and easier to move. (Or I could just put better wheels on the shop-vac cart...)
Thanks, Marc, for another informative video!
I have the Oneida Dust Deputy that sits on top of the CT and I’ve been mostly happy with it. I get almost no material whatsoever into the CT. My one complaint is that the CT clips don’t hold it very steady and it comes loose pretty often, but, not having my CT full of dust and constantly changing HEPA filters, it’s been worth the tradeoff. However, recently the hood on my CT 26 fell apart and by “fell apart“ I mean the plastic disintegrated. Festool said that happens, especially in hot, humid conditions, which we have here on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. I ordered a new hood and the design has changed and now the Festool clips don’t interact properly with the Oneida collection box whatsoever. I’m probably going to have to fasten it with bungee cords.
I have the Oneida Super Dust Deputy that you mentioned at the end. They released a second version (the one I have) that is made out of anti static material and I notice a loss, but like you said for tool use it isn’t a big deal. I like the Festool version’s ability to have a systainer on top, but don’t feel the need to replace mine (yet!). Thanks to doing the review, I know we were wondering how the Tupperware would perform! 😀
Good news is if you don't want to use the cyclone, you can always store your Sunday leftovers in it.
The Wood Whisperer leftover brisket!
I have the Oneida too. After seeing Marc’s review, it occurs to me that the biggest advantage of the Festool design might just be that transparent collector bin. Sure would be nice to know how full it is without risking a face full of fines.
I would say that's crazy talk, but you might have given them a new idea for a Festool warming drawer.
I bought it and so far it works fine. Not sure how long I'll get that back in savings on bags as I go through maybe half dozen bags a year now. Having finished a new shop and have more clients that will ramp up a bit but, I have a dust collector now and use a table saw a lot more. Time will tell. It is a good well built accessory.
Thanks for the review Marc, I have the Oneida for Festool, was wondering how the F-for-F stacked up. The cone on the Oneida is about 11" high, with the router and miter saw I have not noticed a big loss in performance. The Oneida uses a large hose from the cyclone to the CT, with one straight and one 90-deg fitting. The separation is very good, very little dust in the vac, it's all captured in the Oneida bag. thanks again, cheers...
Peter Parfiit showed 98% capture od sample shop dust with the Festool attachment. Hard to believe Oneida could signiicantly better.
$375 for a rubbermaid bin, a tortilla holder and mid-size plastic toolbox.
That's what it looked like!
"tortilla holder" hahaha
*Slaps roof*
"This bad boy can hold so many tortillas."
Allen Arrick lol too good
Bags are ridiculously expensive so in the long run it's a money saver. Stick to your Harbor Freight 👍🏻
Surprised to see you doing a Festool review after hearing about your opinions about reviewing products your podcast but I do enjoy your take on these comparisons.
Where did you get that shirt Marc? I was the Art Director on that God of War for the first 2.5 years of the project. I have been watching your videos for years. Worlds collide. Keep up the great work.
Christopher Sutton hahahahaha! From me. Good to see you here Chris. Miss you bro!
Nice review. I have the Dust Deputy you reviewed in the past, mounted the bucket to a small Harbor Freight furniture dolly ($7.99) and it fits perfectly, also provides stability far superior to the plastic wheels that come in the kit.
For me as a trade person, works better an long life filter bag, which I’m using for couple years now.
I don’t see myself spending another few hundred dollars just to do the same thing.
CT 26 with long life filter bag is the best! 🙂
On a jobsite for a one day job, I think it would be practical to keep the dust enclosed in the system. No bags or buckets and less cleanup. But in a stationary shop I would definately use the money on a dust collection system. You can get a lot of pipe for those money
You did well-Thank you. I will build a another simple working cart to combine my Festool Middi and Oneida Dust Deputy above it.
I'm a little surprised to see you do a product review Marc. It seems lately you shy away from product review videos. However, I'm glad you made this video. It's full of a lot of good useful information.
Cool to see in action, thanks!
Not trying to be a troll here, but for me, shop vac cyclone performance is based on suction power (vs airflow) as that is what helps me pull dust through my tools. The second is how well it separates the fines to keep the filter clean (and thus longer lasting suction). And with all that said, I admit I haven't tested many out to have an educated opinion.
Interesting cyclone design... Can't remember where I saw that before...
Germans concentration camps i think
Good review. I bought one of these a couple of years ago, and the suction does suffer, although as you say, the CT Cyclone still does its job perfectly. Using the anemometer won' give you meaningful results, as with the smaller hose you will have a higher velocity airflow, and with the larger hose, a lower velocity BUT more than likely an increase in volume throughput. Need to measure cubic ft min / litres per second to get a decent comparison 🙂
He wasnt comparing the differences between hoses it was to compare if the drop was more significant depending on the hose used
Great review, thanks for taking the time to do so. Each brand seem to do an adequate job for most small tools like you said, but I think my main concern was how wobbly and breakable the Festool system looked all stacked up and clipped together like that. One accidental knock from manoeuvring a two by four for instance and it looks like the money spent would instantly turn into a sorry pile of cracked and broken plastic! I expected something far more solid looking from those guys. Thanks for the advice and information.
Cool idea thanks for showing it off for us.
But it took 5 minutes to figure out it wasnt norm talking to me. Digging that beard!
Haha thanks
Thanks for the review. It might be obvious in your shop but in the video at a 1.07 it isn't clear if the exhaust goes through the central column from the bottom or from above the horizontal baffle into the column not shown on the opposite side to the intake. Winston Moy had a similar CNC made design that the exhaust went into the column sides. A thien baffle has a 270 drop slot but this is in-between in concept.
I was considering this purchase but after the review the hesitation I was feeling seems justified. Thanks!
Marc, as always I appreciate your honesty. That’s very important. I currently use a Dust Deputy with a small hose with my Festool vac. The Festool might be a good option for me if I can find a way to justify the cash to but one. When I go in that direction I’ll need to look closely at the Dust Deputy and Festool options. Thanks.
Good review. I like it. I think the problem is Festool in the narrow pipes of the cyclone. Therefore, on a large hose, you lose a lot of power. It is sad. I wanted this for myself. I will think now. Thank.
It is not a problem because their machines have perfect dust extraction. It is a problem for people that will be trying to use this set up with other tools that may have poor dust extraction.
Two things I noticed on the product. First the fittings on the inside are not tight. There is not even a gasket to provide a tight seal. So you may be loosing some suction there. Secondly the the internal hose from the cyclone to the external port appears to be small. So your airflow is going to be restricted no mater how big of a hose you connect to it.
I can see how a contractor on a job site would really like this, but I can't possibly imagine how a hobbyist would justify the cost over the convenience.
Even if it outperformed the competition it would be a tough sell for hobbyists.
on the many many jobsites I have been on I have never seen a Festool product
I am still saving up for a premium table saw. -- 2 years later.
I’m a hobbyist and I buy Festool, but I don’t know if I would as a pro. The ROI concern would be much heavier as a pro, but as a hobbyist it’s an expense for which I have fewer financial expectations and I can simply enjoy the tool. Not this tool, though. It sucks.
issue with Festool is its plastic theres a fellow on here that tore one down and its all plastic sure it performs ok but in the very very harsh environment of the field and being lugged all over job sites I dont see it lasting. As a professional I wouldnt own it. I prefer Dewalt . Is Dewalt as fancy and does it make such perfect cuts nope. Can it last in a dirty job site for many many years. Absolutely
I used an old festool sustainer box as a base for my homemade cyclone. Way cheaper and just as convenient.
Given the need for airflow to collect from machines that usually produce the larger chips, that separators are meant to pick up to save filling bags, that drop using the 36mm hose really makes it a bit redundant for woodworking. Shame. I wanted to want it. Thanks for the review. This is the only one I’ve found looking at that airflow. The suction pressure tests only test how well the drop box seals work. Which can usually be fixed easily but not airflow restrictions
Hey Marc, I won't say anything bad about your testing process. It's more than I have done and you explained it as well as you could without taking us down a one-hour rant about air pressure, airflow, and whatever else some people have thrown at us.
Nice video and test. Science without over complications. Thanks!!!
I see the problem, the tubes in side are small and causing a restriction.
I have the Oneida model (current design) that fits on top of the CT vac and locks on using their systainer system. The durability and apparent quality of the plastic is impressive. Festool makes great stuff, and as a hobby woodworker who obsesses over the details of my work I appreciate thoughtful and careful engineering. It will be interesting to see how the Festool compares to the relatively simple-yet-robust Oneida in terms of longevity.
Just bought it after my preseparators were spitting out puffs of dust when my festool punches the filter. Bought it quick. Can't believe there's such a small restriction. I need to use the larger hose for several items. The times we need a separator we're using larger diameter hose for bulk dirt. The grinder, vacuum scraper etc. Can't believe it drops to the small hose. Can't use their turbo nozzle beater bar with it. If I can only use it with the standard sanders which will take a month to fill up with running full out what's the point of the extra bulk and trouble? Trying to think how I could rig a thing to run 50 mil hose to the separator and make a part of the same diameter to switch in for the black lid thing. I need to use at least a 36 mil hose as I am running a planex and a renofix, grinders and want to vacuum bulk dirt without filling my filter bags. This defeats the purpose. Harbor freight just came out with a dust deputy knockoff for a bucket. Just need a thick bucket. Oneida also came with a separator that rides on festool. Just can't put your vacuum nozzle box on top of that.
Have to say I'm super happy with my Festool cyclone... also, all my Festool hoses are super smooth - zero ridges - surely this would make a big difference? Also worth mentioning that the festool hoses are very clever in that they actually taper from wide to narrow along their length to minimise any suction loss from reducers. And... I'd already bought the thing before seeing this. ;-)
super helpful as always. Sure do appreciate your candor and thoughts!
So I think movement of air by cubic feet would need to be calculated to really get an idea of quality. So the speed alone is one factor. I think speed is good for machines that try to "throw" the dust far and the speed catches it before it flies away.
I'll take the bait!
Did you look at pressure drop (measured in inches of water column, an indicator of overall friction in the system) with your manometer? That tells an important part of the story too. As velocity decreases pressure drops off more - so a 36% loss in velocity (festool) is a 60% loss in pressure, and a 14% loss in velocity (clearvue) is a 26% loss in pressure. My understanding of the cyclone design (at a 3:1 ratio of height:width) is to minimize friction and therefore pressure loss , because it plays a vital role in keeping dust entrained in the airflow. That has always been the shortcoming of the Thien baffle designs. The second I saw the CT Vac I knew how the numbers would look
guitarchitectural ooh physics me likey!!
Have you tried out the Dustopper? Works with standard big box buckets. Performs about the same as dust deputy in suction loss and dust separation. However its vertical footprint is tiny compared to the deputy, the small one even.
Festool seems like the Apple of the woodworking industry
I always appreciate testing like this. Good stuff.
On the plus side, you can probably store small tools/accessories in the dead space of that container...?
hmm. I can't see the need for this. Surely as a trades person, you want to be carrying less crap to/from a job, as well as having less crap in the way. I'd much prefer a small vacuum and just deal with having to empy the bag more frequently. From a hobbyist point of view, the price is ridiculous, and again, a simple vac seems like the better option in terms of how much space it's going to take up.
Trades people who use festool on site may also use the exact same tools in their workshop.
These cyclone separation systems are great for the fact they put way less strain onto the filters of the vacuum. Therefore increasing the life span of the tool and decreasing the impact on your wallet for new filters, bags, motor parts. You'll also generally just get a lot better suction from the tool if its running un-restricted.
Generally, people test the vacuum pressure as well as the air speed. Couldn't tell you why they do it, I'm neither an engineer nor a liquid.
Measuring the static pressure tells you how flow rate will be affected by adding constrictions (eg. reducers, gates, extra hose length) to the path.
What I would like to see is the difference in the quantity of material collected, like you did in the older cyclone shoot out with the CV Mini and the Dust deputy. Only a very minute amount was in the Oneida bucket and I didn't see any at all in the Clearview bucket. That is the whole purpose of these cyclone separators
That is the purpose, but if the unit has a dramatic loss of suction, separation is a moot point. unless you’re OK with losing suction. I’m not. I’ll have to wind up selling this unit.
Marc, I am a mechanical engineer and I specialize in industrial HVAC, which includes dust collection.
I agree your methodology for testing is decent enough to observe a relative difference. Kudos for being practical and not measuring arbitrary things like static head and watts and whatnot.
As for those 90 degree elbows: they are not as bad as people think. They have an equivalent length of like 5 feet of straight duct. Additionally, one foot of corrugated hose has an equivalent length of about 5 feet of straight duct.
But, those 90 degree elbows are actually really large and don't function like an elbow in this case. Kind of hard to explain, but since it is at the opening the airflow hasn't "developed" like it would in a long run of straight pipe.
Not sure where I was going with this. Uhhhhh bye.
That’s all good to know. Thanks, man!
maybe you can answer a thought i had, doesn't pressure drop exponentially as speed decreases? IE a 30% loss in velocity is more like a 60% pressure drop... meaning the speed reduction is a lot worse than one thinks. I've ready on the FOG forums that people feel their shop air is much dustier with the CT vac on - if a 14% reduction in air speed is more like a 30% pressure loss it would certainly explain that
More concerned that it drops to the small hose right out of the gate. And it's the same size from the lid duct inside so swapping to my other fat whip won't do me any good. Can't believe I bought this. I asked how big the hose was over the phone. They said they couldn't say but it should run the 2 larger hoses for the larger tools. If it doesn't have the volume flow to run the turbo brush beater bar it's useless to me. I bought it for planex, renofix and bulk dirt. There are major losses with the hoses my system requires. They think we need a preseparator most when we're running fine particulate sanders? The biggest loss with the cleaning tool with the hose that fits the OD instead of the ID.
THANK!
YOU!
And, PLEASE test the Oneida as well.
Thanks a lot for another interesting review. overpriced on its own and I would agree they should have given something back to its customers by offering a much lower price as this is mainly shaped / moulded / blown plastic. It comes across as many have already said as a rip off and Festool ought to do better. On the positive integration is superb and a very convenient way to colect (fine) dust - I have an Oneida system I am very happy with but I will be on the look out for a better price for this CT Cyclone and when that is found it will become part of my other Festool vac system
@@Tensquaremetreworkshop I have plenty of Festool kit and it is my fav brand but albeit we all appreciate all that is about Festool not everything they make is priced fairly...and not everything they make is golden dust. Oneida has got better systems (it is their specialty...) - what Festool did here was to jump on tech invented by others and integrate it with (some of) their vacs and in the process (clearly) overcharge for the convenience.
People saying for a hobby woodworking the quality of Festool is worth it but .... I'm not convinced yet. Some of the tools are several factors more expensive.
Now the dust collection, which is incredibly important I think for a hobbyist, is where Festool starts to earn their $$. I consider Festool specifically for that. Though I haven't been able to justify the cost for myself yet.
There's a fairly new solution that's also low profile that's sold at Home Depot for $40 - Dustopper. I can mount the bucket + Dustopper on top of my Festool vac and achieve the same results.
I have the Oneida super dust deputy that fits the Festool ct26 exactly. It is great and cheaper than this one. If I didn't have the Oneida already I might consider this.
Thanks for your response.
I have no complaints about your testing method. Airflow at the end of the pipe is what determines the amount of dust that can be collected. That is what you measured. It is also useful to know that it is fairly affective at separating dust. That said, I won't be buying it. I would prefer a standard cyclone.
The loss at a 90 bend depends on the density of the flow. Clean air incurs a lower loss than air with dirt in it. Thats probably why the dual bend hose works so well between the separator and the vacuum.
Clearly the only proper testing methodology would be to attach both cyclones to two identical vacuums, then connect them together and see what one sucks the other one up #science
#greatidealancestuchell
We’ll call it The Great Suck Off 2018!
The Wood Whisperer that’s what she said?
Should get a few views with that tile.
What if they both suck the world apart. Don’t do it.
It’s like typing google into the google search bar it will open a new dimension
Would it be possible to test air quality when using each one? Festool is known for dust containment, so I'm wondering how it would stack up to the Clearvue. In such a test, using the best filter in each one. One reason to buy Festool would be to keep the fines at a minimum if there was a big difference. I don't have a Festool vac, just a Ridgid with a Clearvue and it works really well for visible dust. I've always wondered about the fines, though.
IT'S FESTOOL OF COURSE IT DOESN'T SUCK.;) small joke......very small..some good info Marc thanks for sharing that. I'm doing okay with my harbor freight d.c. with the Wynn environmental filter on top. No separator I do have one hooked up to a 5.5 hp shop vac for my table saw. And jointer. I'll take that 375 and put it towards a kapex miter saw or a domino either way festool gets my money..lol
I was really hoping for Muppet Marc to make his tool review debut ;)
I bought the dust deputy for my festool midi after watching a video from The New Brit Workshop... he tested the dust deputy for loss of suction...which he determined was minimal...I’m very satisfied with unit in my basement workshop but it would not be practical for a mobile contractor
I bought mine after his review. I'm not so sure that my figures match his just yet, so I'd be interested to see exactly what he was vacuuming. My test was a general clean of my workshop floor and I will wait until one or the other is full and report back. Jury is out at the moment.
I disagree I use mine all the time as flooring contractor on a midi vacuum
I noticed the difference in suction, opened the top and adjusted the plastic parts and it fixed it. I use it every day, looks professional, can’t do anymore diy things.
Video please
Clearvue only had patent issues because after they came out with the CV Mini, Oneida created the Dust Deputy and patented it, forcing Clearvue to change the design. If you don’t believe me, ask Wilbur Pan, he’s the one who pointed that out years ago on Sawmill Creek.
Good video, Marc! Interesting that the 90 degree turns really didn't affect it. That surprised me.
I noticed that the Festool vac was set at it's lowest power level. Would that make a difference?
It would if that were actually the case but it was set at the highest setting. 😁
Despite them adding a bottom section. The clear section is not attached to it so the assembly just wobbles! I actually wonder just how stable this is?
I am definitely a large hose user.... ever since my days as a young lad
Your testing procedure is greate ! Thanks for the video
I just got the idea to by an empty systainer and build one of my own
I noticed that even the poly bag has Festool printed on it! I bet they are probably $15 each! ;)
They are a small company that employs about 800 people have have revenue of about $350 million.
You are not just paying for the accessories but innovation on all their tools. The only manufacturer that beats them is Mafell and they cost about 3 times as much.
If Festool did not charge that sort of money there would be no such thing as track saws or Domino jointers.
Small companies that innovate with high accuracy products are expensive for a reason.
Hey! What about about DUSTOPPER Home Depot has? We swear by it at work. It takes a regular bucket as the body. No real assembly required & it’s only $20. I don’t know if it compares but I’d like it if you could add it to your testing. I’m interested in how it compares.
One thing missing, I would like to see the filtre after the demo.
The reason it is so expensive is that a lot of new large moulds had to be created to produce this.
Not many of these separators are produced, making the individual unit costly as the moulds are very expensive and have to be paid off at some point.
They should have used more off-the-shelf components to produce this seperator, bringing the cost down. Then again, its festool.
Nice rewiew, thanks!
I would like to know if this system works with fine dust, like concrete dust or fine wood sanding.
Hey Marc, good test! 👍Looks like both systems sucked! (scientifically) I wish Festool made toothbrushes! I'd take out a small loan and buy a few! 😆
When you have your Cyclone and you have a liner in it does it suck the bag inward a little until you get a couple inches if saw dust in it. or should the plastic liner suck to the walls of the container. I just purchased one and installed it on my CT36 and that is what its doing.
Wow the hate for what people are calling "some plastic bits". Got to understand the price is for R&D and the engineering of the device no t the $5 worth of plastic. This is like complaining that you got a bunch of 1's and 0's after spending a bunch of money at the iTunes store.....
I think it's a good design and does what festool designed it for, maximum separation with the smaller hose which is probably the typical hose used with their ct-vacs. The reason the large hose drops in efficiency so much is because to maximize separation for the lower air volume the higher volume chokes the separator.
Thanks for this, Marc
Nice review. I see you changed the festool mitresaw to bosch mitre saw to a dewalt mitre saw. Any reason why? Would love to hear. Thanks
Great little review, as always.
Just take a look into the left side of the openings on the systainer cyclone and see a massive reduction in diameter. There is your explanation for your massiv drop in suction for the bigger hose. For the smaller it does not matter, but just 20% more (compared to the ordinary cyclone) in loss is huge and dismissis this cyclon for the big hose and all application in that context. And the price is just rediculous, 200 would be worth it but nothing more.
Please forgive my ignorance but my ct 36 has a bag inside it that catches all the rubbishy and sawdust, when it fill up I simply empty it.
I’m a little confused as to why I would need so ting like this ?
Festoon Vacuum + dust separator $1,000 Really for a stinky vacuum, some of us needs to get a ridgid. Vacuum and some dust bags as a dust separator they work great and takes 2 mins to change the dust bag... oh and they don't loose suction... well may be a little bit who knows, but I still recommend a ridgid shop vac with a dust bag and you can also get a wireless remote control for extra $10 bucks