US history isn't shorter than the history of any other nation. Every modern nation is a descendant of some older historical state and culture, so are the US.
Because the Indians are playing tricks. In fact, Bhutan applied to join China several times in the last century, but India kept interfering, and China kept focusing on the southeast Sea and did not take care of this matter.
You might not be the biggest countryballs Channel but man oh man the quality of your videos... From the funny images, jokes, Microsoft Sam voice, and immense history detailing... I love and appreciate your videos my dude.
5:02 Even thought Tibet was de facto independent during that period, nobody including USA really recognized Tibet as an independent sovereign state that is separate from China. With China not agreeing to Simla Agreement, Tibet never stood a chance of being on world stage despite not being under Chinese control during that time. In order for a country like South Sudan or Bougainville to be independent, all parties involved must agree.
Not only Dalai Lama but almost 90,000 Tibetan refugees live in india too they are mostly situated in indian city of dharamsala. Indian army also have military unit called "Special Frontier force" which have most of Tibetans.
WOW VERY DANGEROUS I WILL NEVER GO TO TIBET 😠😠 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
they are very kind people. In fact, stop believe those non-sense culture destruction, Chinese perserves their culture or even support their spreading. You guys should really look at its population of those minorities after CCP rules, their population has significantly increase in the past decades
@@Elemenobanii I hate hypocritical Americans. They constantly push for the independence of Tibet, when they don't understand anything in the history of Tibet, but at the same time when you ask them about Hawaii they'll say something like "Come on don't be silly, all land is stolen, what, maybe give all land to the neanderthals now?"
Buddha was actually born in an Indian Empire but the place is inside of modern day Nepal (only 2 to 3km from indian boarder) and Gautam Buddha got enlightenment in modern Indian state of Bihar, he first teach his believes and also died in Bihar, Nepal was not an entity as country during that time, it was in 1700s when Gorkhas fought against Mughals and created there own Empire which later becomes Nepal.
@@Roachh2877 in Vedas india is mentioned by many names like, Aryavart, Bharat varsh and Bharat, all this concept helps later king like chandragupta, samudragupt and Ashoka to build an empire which can be said "Bhartiya Samrajya" or indian Empire.
@@sourabhgupta4853 Yeah, then during Buddha's time, India and Nepal both were divided into various kingdoms. Idea of Bharat existed, but competition for the top dog status to "rule them all" was very much alive.
I think you forgot to mention the alliance between Chinese And India's Lalitaditya Muktapida of Kashmir, who allied to defeat Tibetan empire, Lalitaditya's empire later drove out tibetans in bengal, defeated turks and established an empire that spread from Caspian Sea to Ganga Planes.
WOW VERY DANGEROUS I WILL NEVER GO TO TIBET 😠😠 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
@@mint8648 its a fact, a historical one. The ruined Martanda Sun Temple in Kashmir is the proof, it used to be a majestic temple, but was later destroyed by the turkic sultans who invaded after karkota dynasty fell in later centuries.
@@jagdpanther2224 As an Indian, I love Chinese Culture..... the current conflict between India and China is based on territory dispute. We ( the Indians and Chinese ) should not hate each other and let our governments solve the dispute
Fun fact:after liberation of tibet, China did gave privilege to former tibet ruling party (before the rebellion). The 14th Dalai Lama was 1st, 2nd Vice Chairperson of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress. (quite high ranked)
and banned Dalailama having traditional slavery system, which pissed off him, in Tibetan Buddhism slaves and their families are talking animals serving lamas but this tradition strongly disagreed by Mao's new government
@@brandonlyon730 Mao should make a deal with european liberals by importing caucasoid fanboys to replace local tibetan peasent slaves which could preserve the pure tibetan curture rather than just cancel it.
@@brandonlyon730 not sure where you got your info dude, I've been Tibet seeing Dalai's skin arts made from his slaves, that art tradition got banned as well. Mao basically treat these Tibetans like first class citizen but treating his own Han chinese like 4th class, if you want to criticize commie china you should target the fact not the western fake new lies. I still dont get it, CIA can easily use the human rights situation of Han chinese been treated, instead, they decided to make up some bs about minority been treated in china, that's just gonna get debunked when people travel to those minority. I can only guess because of the racisim to minority in western is a thing so it's easy for western govs to convince their people, but this won't help them crack china because the racisms in china go opposite way
Your videos are always so nice to watch. You provide multiple perspectives and views on each side of an issue, and always have a sense of personal detachment from the video.
@@redhood3748 No it's not okay. But do you mean a brutal monarchy Tibetan ruler is better than current situation? It is bad now, but Dalai Lama would only make it worse. In traditional Tibetan ideologies citizens are strictly classified, and an upper class have the right to slavery and own lower class people. I'd say even an depressing and surpassed Chinese ruling life is ten times better than monarchy Tibetan rule.
@@qikaigao3991 Tibet was not a monarchy it was a theocracy if communists didn't come right now Tibet is the only Buddhist theocracy state in Asia. That would be great
In fact, the name Tüpüt (Tubo) is now older than Tibet. The name that is older than it is ZANG (Tibetan: gtsang. That is, the source of the pronunciation of Chinese ZANG.) It means the north and south sides of the upper reaches of the Brahmaputra. That is to say, the headquarter of the Tubo Dynasty. Actually counted by dynasty, Tibet has more than 240 years according to the clear document history. After the collapse in AD 877, there was no more unified dynasty, and it was successively ruled by the Central Plains dynasty. However, it can be determined that Han and Tibet were divided more than 5,000 years ago.
I am currently in the Jiangsu Province of China and returning to America in august, my family and I are going to Tibet next year and i am really interested in the Tibet culture, thanks for sharing us this (and yes im using some kind of vpn 😊)
TIBETANS can get out if thry dont like , get out and never coming back! The entire Tibetan pleateau belongs to China! Cries for Dali Lama's stupudity, he betrayed Tibet! Hahahahaha
xinjiang has been a part of China since 2000 years ago(Han dynasty) because of the silk road, even earlier than anglo-saxon people went to England and was buddhist for 1000 years, then muslin people came from west asia. Han chinese is actually the native people of xinjiang
The Qing dynsaty didn't really kick the Dzungars out of tibet, they more just geocided them out of existence. They even teamed up with the Uyghurs to wipe them out! How times change.
@@masternobody1896 it was a pretty vague answer, to be more specific: USA - early industrialisation with massive influence and military might gained after all possible rivals were weakened after ww2. Russia - mostly because of the Soviet Union and the power left over there however Russia has the most land on earth to work with a huge amount of resources. It is the weakest of the three however. China - absolutely massive work force however it industrialised very late which Europe and Japan exploited. Recent capitalist policies are making it very rich so it is expanding its influence and power in modern times. These are the main individual factors however they would mean nothing without the fact that the three countries are all: very big, very populated and have a good amount of wealth.
Short answer is that these three countries were winners of WW2, along with UK and France. But in the case of China and Russia, China back then was the Republic of China (ROC), or what we now know as Taiwan (an independent country), they were recognized as victors of WW2, not their communist counterpart, and used to have a seat in the UN until Communist China came along and kicked ROC out from UN (cough cough USA) because of the whole One China Policy. Meanwhile, in Russia, USSR was a thing, and its not just Russia, but also includes the Caucasus, Central Asia, Warsaw Pact, and the republics that Russia has today (Karelia, Chechnya, Sakha, etc.).
Geographically the Tibetan Plateau is pretty much Switzerland on steroids. Imagine if it also had come to resemble it militarily, invading it would have been an absolute nightmare.
Tibet local population is a huge disadvantage for defending such a large territory . The Tibet autonomous region, region shown in the video, only have less than 3 million. This is due to majority of the region have altitude nearly or over 5000m, which is not suitable to live. Aiming to control some strategic sites and major cities is enough to defeat the troops in the region.
I love learning about Tibet, I already knew the answer when I clicked on this video, but I still like watching videos on Tibet. It's not very often someone makes a video on Tibet, and it is even rarer when someone takes about the Tibetan Empire.
ccp maintains its culture,But there's a thing I want to say.tibet is strongly controlled by CCP and it is only called an autonomous region for the sake of listening well.this is a big difference from Russia.
this has happened since the fall of qing dynasty.many people didn't believe that there were someone like god can save them.they have been controlled by emperor for thousands of years.the religion is regarded as the tool of domination.
but i also want to say although many people call themselves non-religious person,they actually still have a sense of reverence for the god and many people burn incense.it's just a pattern of tradition.
0:26 translations (top to bottom) “Long live China. Taiwan is a Chinese province. Hurrah.” “We really want independence but mainland China would be really mad. I love earning mainland Chinese money.”
The Taiwan script is so cringe honestly. ROC constitution dictates them to be a province and a part of mainland China. All thanks to the separatist DPP brainwashing the newer generation. A Chinese province led by a Japanese puppet. So sad
At that time there was no india or nepal just an hindu kingdom and he belong to that. Both india and Nepal are hindu majority state thus both should realise they have a shared history
@@medanchess7892 we learn about other nations just like any other country, but my main point was we should really be learning more about other countries
Turks who advocate for east Turkestan independence should also advocate for the independence of all previous Greek land which they took, as well as leaving Cyprus and returning land to Armenians.
@@yuliusjrt9917 first, those lands are also not belongs to them. They took it from Persians first. And persians took it from Native Anatolians. Turks controlling İran when they taking over Anatolia. So no. Those places are not Greek lands. Second, greeks in meddival era Calling theirselfs Romans. They see theirselfs different and superior than helenized people in Anatolia. And people from anatolia are also not Greeks either. Thry helenized, thats true, but thry not Greeks. Other wise we need to say Persians occupied Greek lands in İran . And this logic goes for Egypt to modern day Afghanistan. Third, unlike Uighurs, greeks and Turks sign mutual deportation agreement. Affectivelly ended any ethnic conflicts(accept Western Thrace) Fourth, the part thry took from Cyprus is Turkic majorty. Thry didn't took greek majorty parts. Fifth, Armenia itself is literally a failed Nation. And thry were already partinied by Romans and Persians. Do blame them instead, Turks just took whatever left there. Even the modern day Azerbeijan and Turkey wasnt dominated by Armenians. Thry dominated by helenized anatolians and Caucasian Albanians. Sixth, China is literally controlled by Mongolic and Tungistic people until they became a Republic. So this is means, they didnt conqured those lands theirselfs. And their modern day borders are historically limited to Ming Dynastys borders.
Most people who know literally nothing about China or have been to China shouldn't spread their subjective perspectives on the Tibet. I've been to Qinghai province, which is a province that's next to Tibet with many Tibetans living there. Throwing all the politics away, what Tibetans got are brand new houses with access to water and electricity, highways, railways and high-speed-rail on construction. Their living standard is improving dramatically year by year with visible development. As for the cultural reserve, there are no genocides! Tibetan and Mandarin are both the language that they require to learn. One detail I observed was that all the road sign in the regions are marked with two or three languages(including English if it's a major road). Tibetans get perks. Eg. Easier to attend top tier university in China, high pensions, etc. No matter what you say, Tibet is experiencing the globalization, gradually connecting with the world is definitely a good sign for the people.
I seen Tibetans on Quora talk about this. They say that China isn't as bad as it is and that the only separatists are Dalai Lama and his CIA gang. I may not be pro-China but screw the west for all that propaganda!
@@TheGuzeinbuick British DID NOT massively improved HK's standard of living. Hong Kong raised due to its geopolitical location, similar to Singapore. Hong Kong developed due to the fact that it was the only major illegal "foreign" lands that connect the rest of the China(land by unequal treaty after the war). As a result, continuous wealth flew to Hong Kong from rest of China, caused Hong Kong to become rich. If Hong Kong is an island in the middle of the ocean, it's development level will be exactly like typical British ruled Pacific islands, or even worse. One thing that I have to mention that the British was the exploiters, Hong Kong should be much better with massive flowing assets, yet most of them had transported back to Britain, like rest of the British colonies. The Governors of Hong Kong were British all the time, they rampaged through the city like gangster, basically did nothing to contribute to the economy.
@@TheGuzeinbuick The hardworking Hong Kong citizens improved their living standards not the British. Plenty of former British colonies like Burma, Sri Lanka have not done so well. Stop giving Hong Kong’s success to British.
Very few people know but india and had a war in 1800s between Sikh Empire of india and Qing Dynasty of China which was strategically indian victory and since then ladhak become part of india and Tibet was more friendly towards india as Chinese get kicked in a$$.
Manipur has Hindu population go & see Infact "Pur" itself defines why it's Indian Many Indian Independence Movement took place in Manipur with Azad Hind Fauj 👍
@Dorin Tenzin and which pathetic beggar are you？I see you so thirst for a sense of existence here that you start a chat with me with a topic that has nothing related to what I said😫
I don't think india could face china at that time. They had a war in 1962 and lost pretty badly, even losing territory. If China could keep the U.S at bay in Korea it could easily clean the floor with India.
@@chiefengineer7607 Yeah. Our leadership was weak. Otherwise if Sardar Patel or Lal Bahadur Shastri was the PM. We would have beaten the crap out of China.
Next, Afghanistan and Tajikistan, where their land landscape is still connected to Tibet and their culture for thousands of years, namely both adhered to Bon and Buddhist religions before they converted to Islam and were influenced by Arabs.
According to what you said, they all received the influence of China, which directly copied Chinese technology and suppressed Europe in the Middle Ages.China loves 回-shaped ornamentation.
Well whatever As Indian i also know how it feels like when someone says to cut a part of of your country Same with Chinese gov, they also have same human feeling but atleast they should care about Buddhist Tibet culture It is really horrible to spread communism and atheism forcefully .
stop believe those non-sense culture destruction, Chinese perserves their culture or even support their spreading. You guys should really look at its population of those minorities after CCP rules, their population has significantly increase in the past decades
@@tianlingchen5523 We'll Tibetan language is close to Sanskrit. And almost all of ancient Buddhist texts are in Proto Sanskrit or Maithili, so it makes perfect sense.
Untill 1980s bhutans foreign policy and defence was India's responsibility and even now bhutan has signed defence treaty with India. Your fact is also wrong as just after independence bhutan signed treaty of friendship with india, both countries recognise each other and use indian currency for value manipulation in Bhutan.
Tibetan people are very peaceful by nature. And they wont ever engage in any ear. My best friend is a Tibetan Immigrant,( his family came in the 60's) and he says Buddha will provide a path, endless violence won't. I'm as an Indian respect that. But if I was in his place, i would have fought for my motherland.
Non-Tibetans: Tibetans should remain traditional and independent, even in poverty. Real Tibetans: I need stable electricity, clean running water, hospitals, quality education, mobile phones, internet, cars, roads, security, work.
Hey Guys you need to know that a normal human cant go to tibet they would be exhausted by the high altitude and the harsh climate it is no joke tibetans are superhuman for thousands of years the tibetan empire fended off many enemies and took on many conquests even reaching to the mediterian and even reached as far as to bagdhad it is only when the tibetan empire broke of from internal turmoil please do research and the only reason why china was able to invade tibet was that tibet had less population than before it had almost no good weapons only from ww1 and with the chinese manpower and technological superiorty did they invade tibet. but it still took 28 years for the chinese to take the last region of tibet from the people of tibet.
He's a big chungus He's a big chunky boi Such a big bun, yes We are so overjoyed To have a big chunky boi A big and wonderful chungus such as he Oh such as he He's a big chungus He's a big chunky boi Such a big bun, yes We are so overjoyed To have a big chunky boi A big and wonderful chungus such as he Oh, such as he Huh Buns come in all shapes and all sizes This one has so many surprises I've never seen a giant quite like him There's no one like him Nobody like chungus Huh Get the game for PS4 For a limited time Huh Don't miss what it has in store You're running out of time Play the game of the year The game with that colossal boi He's a big chungus He's a big chunky boi Such a big bun, yes We are so overjoyed To have a big chunky boi A big and wonderful chungus such as he Oh, such as he Huh Buns come in all shapes and all sizes This one has so many surprises I've never seen a giant quite like him There's no one like him Nobody like chungus Huh
The history is relatively short, but still longer than the entirety of US history
Based
@@stephmod7434 Is speaking a obvious common fact based?
us doesnt have a story besides slaves, and the only culture that has is the afro american culture
@@axsemotel yes
US history isn't shorter than the history of any other nation.
Every modern nation is a descendant of some older historical state and culture, so are the US.
A Suggestion for Another video :- Why is Bhutan Isolated for a long time and how did it distinguished itself from Tibet?
it distinguishbecause bhutanese king want to remain king
And why it doesn't become part of india when it's brother Sikkim did!
@@oksowhat makes sense
@@sourabhgupta4853 let them decide brother they have their rights
Because the Indians are playing tricks. In fact, Bhutan applied to join China several times in the last century, but India kept interfering, and China kept focusing on the southeast Sea and did not take care of this matter.
You might not be the biggest countryballs Channel but man oh man the quality of your videos... From the funny images, jokes, Microsoft Sam voice, and immense history detailing... I love and appreciate your videos my dude.
yeah this guy is the goat
Wait... there are other countryball channels?
@@johnwise9811 yep and A LOT at that. My favorites are this one of course and also Mr. Spherical
Well, i think im lucky to discover this channel
🤣
5:02 Even thought Tibet was de facto independent during that period, nobody including USA really recognized Tibet as an independent sovereign state that is separate from China. With China not agreeing to Simla Agreement, Tibet never stood a chance of being on world stage despite not being under Chinese control during that time. In order for a country like South Sudan or Bougainville to be independent, all parties involved must agree.
Funny how that doesn’t apply to white European controlled lands
Indeed I agree
Well south Sudan had a recognisable celebrity help
@@jettmclachlan1804 who? Clooney? Bono?
Taiwan is an independent country despite not being recognized by most major countries
I would like a video on yugoslavia or the central asian countries (ex. Tajikistan)
No
Yes
Isnt like kazachstan a good example to you?
Yes
Yes
Not only Dalai Lama but almost 90,000 Tibetan refugees live in india too they are mostly situated in indian city of dharamsala.
Indian army also have military unit called "Special Frontier force" which have most of Tibetans.
good...the Indians paid a heavy price for them and lost territory.
always love your humor in the video 😂
Agree
Yess
"after china finish beating itself" man i completely lost it there... 🤣
He refered to the fall of 1949 when the Chinese civil war has ended in mainland after the communist won!
Stop beating yourself.
@@jagdpanther2224 at the end, capitalism won 😂
The Communists defeated the Nationalists, who ran away to Taiwan ....
name a country haven't break out a civil war now @@cyberassassin6241
Don’t mind me just boosting the UA-cam algorithm
Dont mind me just boosting this comment.
Boosting moment
dont mind me liking this comment
-10000 social credit score
WOW VERY DANGEROUS I WILL NEVER GO TO TIBET 😠😠 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
In the West, we have Romanization.
In the East, we have Sinicization.
And in north we have Russification.
@@Amanbiswas_2003.
In Asia we also have islamisation and indianisation
Indianisation is little weak as our government don't fund it much
Tibetan culture was the inspiration of the air nomads in avatar the last Airbender
True
Why am I not surprised Britain had something to do with this.
They have something with every conflict even the Ukarinne one
@@forgaoqiang *Ukraine
Also how?
@@detdvr4498 okay, bro that wasnt the question
@@stevetheheadcrab7110 well supplying Weapons to Ukraine to weaken Russia and being Anti Russia blindly
@@forgaoqiang thats a lie
Very neutral and objective points with entertaining while accurate explanations.
Nice Video ! I'm waiting for more of that :D
Tibetian people are the sweetest people I have ever met
they are very kind people. In fact, stop believe those non-sense culture destruction, Chinese perserves their culture or even support their spreading.
You guys should really look at its population of those minorities after CCP rules, their population has significantly increase in the past decades
I don't think so!
@@jagdpanther2224 Why
Do you know about the slavery stuff in traditional Tibet?
@@ArghyadeepPal They were ungrateful to Chinese rule!
Make a video about how Hawaii became a part of the US
pretty sure he has
@@Elemenobanii nice
@@Elemenobanii I hate hypocritical Americans. They constantly push for the independence of Tibet, when they don't understand anything in the history of Tibet, but at the same time when you ask them about Hawaii they'll say something like "Come on don't be silly, all land is stolen, what, maybe give all land to the neanderthals now?"
Up
US just use force to get Hawaii
Surprisingly quite accurate using a simplified historical context
Buddha was actually born in an Indian Empire but the place is inside of modern day Nepal (only 2 to 3km from indian boarder) and Gautam Buddha got enlightenment in modern Indian state of Bihar, he first teach his believes and also died in Bihar, Nepal was not an entity as country during that time, it was in 1700s when Gorkhas fought against Mughals and created there own Empire which later becomes Nepal.
India and Nepal weren't a thing then.
@@Roachh2877 Bharat👍
Hey he died in Uttar Pradesh
Kushinagar 🙄....👍
@@Roachh2877 in Vedas india is mentioned by many names like, Aryavart, Bharat varsh and Bharat, all this concept helps later king like chandragupta, samudragupt and Ashoka to build an empire which can be said "Bhartiya Samrajya" or indian Empire.
@@sourabhgupta4853
Yeah, then during Buddha's time, India and Nepal both were divided into various kingdoms.
Idea of Bharat existed, but competition for the top dog status to "rule them all" was very much alive.
I think you forgot to mention the alliance between Chinese And India's Lalitaditya Muktapida of Kashmir, who allied to defeat Tibetan empire, Lalitaditya's empire later drove out tibetans in bengal, defeated turks and established an empire that spread from Caspian Sea to Ganga Planes.
Yes
woh woh, finally
a sign of relief as an indian ;)
maharaj lalitaditya rai vijayaso!!!!!
WOW VERY DANGEROUS I WILL NEVER GO TO TIBET 😠😠 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
I can’t tell if this is a joke or not
@@mint8648 its a fact, a historical one. The ruined Martanda Sun Temple in Kashmir is the proof, it used to be a majestic temple, but was later destroyed by the turkic sultans who invaded after karkota dynasty fell in later centuries.
Tibet was a place which was a grate cultural bridge between India and China
ideologies changes with time and borders too
No! We(Chinese) don't want any cultures from India, that's just worsen us!
@@jagdpanther2224 As an Indian, I love Chinese Culture..... the current conflict between India and China is based on territory dispute. We ( the Indians and Chinese ) should not hate each other and let our governments solve the dispute
@@jagdpanther2224 UA-cam is banned in China. Lmoa may be your paxtani
@@AtharvaAgarwal no they have VPN Don't be so much ignorant i am a maldivian studying in China
@@jagdpanther2224
Then return our influence on saolin monks and don't don't kung-fu , it also have influence of southern India's martial arts
Fun fact:after liberation of tibet, China did gave privilege to former tibet ruling party (before the rebellion). The 14th Dalai Lama was 1st, 2nd Vice Chairperson of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress. (quite high ranked)
and banned Dalailama having traditional slavery system, which pissed off him, in Tibetan Buddhism slaves and their families are talking animals serving lamas but this tradition strongly disagreed by Mao's new government
@@tl1539 Didn’t seem to stop Mao from treating the rest of his people as slaves themselves in all but name only and disposed them just as easily.
@@brandonlyon730 Mao should make a deal with european liberals by importing caucasoid fanboys to replace local tibetan peasent slaves which could preserve the pure tibetan curture rather than just cancel it.
@@brandonlyon730 Basically Mao saying you are not allowed to have slaves, only I have that authority to have slaves
@@brandonlyon730 not sure where you got your info dude, I've been Tibet seeing Dalai's skin arts made from his slaves, that art tradition got banned as well. Mao basically treat these Tibetans like first class citizen but treating his own Han chinese like 4th class, if you want to criticize commie china you should target the fact not the western fake new lies. I still dont get it, CIA can easily use the human rights situation of Han chinese been treated, instead, they decided to make up some bs about minority been treated in china, that's just gonna get debunked when people travel to those minority. I can only guess because of the racisim to minority in western is a thing so it's easy for western govs to convince their people, but this won't help them crack china because the racisms in china go opposite way
Your videos are always so nice to watch. You provide multiple perspectives and views on each side of an issue, and always have a sense of personal detachment from the video.
Tibet had a history of being a long independent kingdom for thousand of year before being captured.
@@gies9057 so you saying you sistematically ok with their asimilating in 21s ceuntry?
@@redhood3748 No it's not okay. But do you mean a brutal monarchy Tibetan ruler is better than current situation? It is bad now, but Dalai Lama would only make it worse. In traditional Tibetan ideologies citizens are strictly classified, and an upper class have the right to slavery and own lower class people. I'd say even an depressing and surpassed Chinese ruling life is ten times better than monarchy Tibetan rule.
@@qikaigao3991 Tibet was not a monarchy it was a theocracy if communists didn't come right now Tibet is the only Buddhist theocracy state in Asia. That would be great
@@user-Void-Star it was still a feudal state which may or may not have serfdom
In fact, the name Tüpüt (Tubo) is now older than Tibet. The name that is older than it is ZANG (Tibetan: gtsang. That is, the source of the pronunciation of Chinese ZANG.) It means the north and south sides of the upper reaches of the Brahmaputra. That is to say, the headquarter of the Tubo Dynasty.
Actually counted by dynasty, Tibet has more than 240 years according to the clear document history. After the collapse in AD 877, there was no more unified dynasty, and it was successively ruled by the Central Plains dynasty. However, it can be determined that Han and Tibet were divided more than 5,000 years ago.
I am currently in the Jiangsu Province of China and returning to America in august, my family and I are going to Tibet next year and i am really interested in the Tibet culture, thanks for sharing us this (and yes im using some kind of vpn 😊)
Free Tibet.
PS: Tibetan themselves don't want any war, they just want the peaceful retreat if CCP and more autonomy.
@Maximilien Robespierre(Anti-religion) 🤡
Free Kashmir!
ps: There is not Indian's land!
TIBETANS can get out if thry dont like , get out and never coming back!
The entire Tibetan pleateau belongs to China! Cries for Dali Lama's stupudity, he betrayed Tibet!
Hahahahaha
Free Tibet?
-1 000 000 social credit
Yes
Great video. Loved how you explained it from many points of view. Would be awesome if you could do one for Xinjiang as well.
Funny how that doesn’t apply to white European controlled lands
Yea
@Not Mentioned no
xinjiang has been a part of China since 2000 years ago(Han dynasty) because of the silk road, even earlier than anglo-saxon people went to England and was buddhist for 1000 years, then muslin people came from west asia. Han chinese is actually the native people of xinjiang
All of China's (potential) Break-Away Provinces & Territories would be sick.
Macau, strangely seems fine wuth autocracy. The rest. Nope.
The Qing dynsaty didn't really kick the Dzungars out of tibet, they more just geocided them out of existence. They even teamed up with the Uyghurs to wipe them out! How times change.
Just as Europeans do in the Americas, we Chinese want to make all ethnic groups more Chinese
hehe ha
Reminds me of Turks and Kurds being buddies to kill Armenians back in the good ol'days (sarcasm).
Kazakhs, hui, khalkha mongols participated in the geocide too
@@mint8648 this is a sad story
I wonder what will happen if tibet was independent, anyways good video!
It will be India's puppet
Then you will see paintings made of human skin, or drums made of human skin. Will you still find it interesting?
@@香香鸡 CCP bot detected
country balls how did usa, russia and china got so so strong
Large land and large population with enough wealth. That’s about it for now.
@@maxdavis7722 i see
@@maxdavis7722 time to make myself a superpower. joking
@@masternobody1896 it was a pretty vague answer, to be more specific:
USA - early industrialisation with massive influence and military might gained after all possible rivals were weakened after ww2.
Russia - mostly because of the Soviet Union and the power left over there however Russia has the most land on earth to work with a huge amount of resources. It is the weakest of the three however.
China - absolutely massive work force however it industrialised very late which Europe and Japan exploited. Recent capitalist policies are making it very rich so it is expanding its influence and power in modern times.
These are the main individual factors however they would mean nothing without the fact that the three countries are all: very big, very populated and have a good amount of wealth.
Short answer is that these three countries were winners of WW2, along with UK and France.
But in the case of China and Russia, China back then was the Republic of China (ROC), or what we now know as Taiwan (an independent country), they were recognized as victors of WW2, not their communist counterpart, and used to have a seat in the UN until Communist China came along and kicked ROC out from UN (cough cough USA) because of the whole One China Policy. Meanwhile, in Russia, USSR was a thing, and its not just Russia, but also includes the Caucasus, Central Asia, Warsaw Pact, and the republics that Russia has today (Karelia, Chechnya, Sakha, etc.).
Amazing 👍👍👍
Your content definitely true.
You did a good research 👍
Never stopped sleeping faster to watch a video
UK : Hong Kong! Come back to papa!
It had me dying out of laughter XD
@علي ياسر yes a colonization evil
@@Jeffrey21058Arabisation too
Geographically the Tibetan Plateau is pretty much Switzerland on steroids. Imagine if it also had come to resemble it militarily, invading it would have been an absolute nightmare.
Tibet local population is a huge disadvantage for defending such a large territory . The Tibet autonomous region, region shown in the video, only have less than 3 million. This is due to majority of the region have altitude nearly or over 5000m, which is not suitable to live. Aiming to control some strategic sites and major cities is enough to defeat the troops in the region.
@@hc-eq9dn I said "Tibetan Plateau" not "Autonomous Province of Tibet", the former including the whole Qinghai and parts of Gansu, Sichuan and Yunnan.
@@hc-eq9dn in the past tibet had 10 million people but that was 1000 years ago
@@mint8648 greater Tíbet does
@@greenmachine5600 yea but still its crazy tibet has the same population back then as now
I love learning about Tibet, I already knew the answer when I clicked on this video, but I still like watching videos on Tibet. It's not very often someone makes a video on Tibet, and it is even rarer when someone takes about the Tibetan Empire.
0:24 lmaoooo didn’t expect to see Carrie Lam in this video. Imma wash my eyes😂
Tibet maintained its autonomy and distinct cultural identity.
ccp maintains its culture,But there's a thing I want to say.tibet is strongly controlled by CCP and it is only called an autonomous region for the sake of listening well.this is a big difference from Russia.
@@潘越-o1m Then explain why the Chinese people are 93% non religious while during early times it was more religious
@@bhawnabansal1156 he meant ethnic minorities and the actually number of ireligous people is way lower than that like 40%
this has happened since the fall of qing dynasty.many people didn't believe that there were someone like god can save them.they have been controlled by emperor for thousands of years.the religion is regarded as the tool of domination.
but i also want to say although many people call themselves non-religious person,they actually still have a sense of reverence for the god and many people burn incense.it's just a pattern of tradition.
Always a joy to watch your videos
0:26 translations (top to bottom)
“Long live China.
Taiwan is a Chinese province.
Hurrah.”
“We really want independence but mainland China would be really mad.
I love earning mainland Chinese money.”
Cool!
Is this a new level of based?
And that seems to be poorly translated. Should be:
中国万岁。
台湾是中国的一个省。
万岁。
Which translates to:
Long live China.
Taiwan is a province of China.
Hurray.
@@jasonp500 I mean that’s just a rephrasing of what I said
I’m also literally native Chinese so bruh
The Taiwan script is so cringe honestly. ROC constitution dictates them to be a province and a part of mainland China. All thanks to the separatist DPP brainwashing the newer generation. A Chinese province led by a Japanese puppet. So sad
i have an idea for a video: look where are all the audience are from
1:24
that dude was from nepal, but he got enlightened/ achieved nirvana in India (under a tree in bodhgaya, bihar in india)
He lived in India for most of his time he was only born in Nepal never lived in it
We still don't know cuz different dialects have different Stories.
Siddhartha Gautham was born in Nepal
He became Buddha when he arrive in India
Agar Nepal me rahta to bas momos ka thaila lgata
At that time there was no india or nepal just an hindu kingdom and he belong to that. Both india and Nepal are hindu majority state thus both should realise they have a shared history
Nepal didn't existed bro, Lumbini was part of Magadha, which was one of the Mahajanpadas of Indian Civilization 👍
0:09 I like how Chiang-Kai-Shek looks like Shrek
Chiang Kai-SHREK?
This is why Tibet could not be in AoE 2 despite it has expansive medieval kingdom
U can create your own civ in AOE 2 just name it Tibet
sad..
The Dali lama just loves fleeing it seems
Tibetan government in exile would like to know your location.
Can you name one geopolitics conflict without British interference?
Well there was the time when Roma invaded Carthage and- oh shit! The British got a time machine!
Nagorno-Karabakh.
Fergana valley in central asia, with Soviet/Russian meddling
These videos are the best
Tibetans despite being annexed, still maintained their autonomy, their language and culture
I LOOOOVEEE your videos OMG ❤ It's SO funny
California deserves independence!
And Scotland!
And Tibet
@@green_hedger_68 Sikkim
@@green_hedger_68 Kashmir should get their independent from India!
The Red Corridor run by the Maoist also should get indepent from India!
@@green_hedger_68 And Naxalite Kashmir Khalistan Assam Manipur
1:08 based
Ohh lol your video is out
It is 4:30 am here in India and I am having sahri while watching your video
Btw its very good 👍👍👍
great video as always
Everyone is a gansta until nepal starts claiming all of the universe
In 8 minutes I learned so much about Tibet, Canadian schools do not teach enough about the world
I don't think any nations will teach another Nation's history which is like 5K Km away
@@medanchess7892 we learn about other nations just like any other country, but my main point was we should really be learning more about other countries
Sometime after the CCP won the Chinese Civil War...
Tibet; **Exists**
People's Republic of China; **Insert TF2 Soldier "Mine!" sound effect**
How long have Hawaii and Texas been part of the USA?
America stolen Hawaii from the Hawaii Kingdom since 1893!
Afghanistan: Mountainous terrain and unconquerable people
Afghanistan: "IT SMELL LIKE BITCH IN HERE"
Also it’s a barren land, not much to loot and exploit from.
7:30
I love how you put Turkey and Russia on East Turkistan, ım almost going to cry :')
Same :'(
NO such a country known as East Turkistan! Only Xinjiang, new territories of China!
@@jagdpanther2224 yeah, you are right. İts actually known as Şarki Türkistan. Not as East Turkistan or Xijang. My bad.
Turks who advocate for east Turkestan independence should also advocate for the independence of all previous Greek land which they took, as well as leaving Cyprus and returning land to Armenians.
@@yuliusjrt9917
first, those lands are also not belongs to them. They took it from Persians first.
And persians took it from Native Anatolians. Turks controlling İran when they taking over Anatolia. So no. Those places are not Greek lands.
Second, greeks in meddival era Calling theirselfs Romans. They see theirselfs different and superior than helenized people in Anatolia. And people from anatolia are also not Greeks either. Thry helenized, thats true, but thry not Greeks. Other wise we need to say Persians occupied Greek lands in İran . And this logic goes for Egypt to modern day Afghanistan.
Third, unlike Uighurs, greeks and Turks sign mutual deportation agreement. Affectivelly ended any ethnic conflicts(accept Western Thrace)
Fourth, the part thry took from Cyprus is Turkic majorty. Thry didn't took greek majorty parts.
Fifth, Armenia itself is literally a failed Nation. And thry were already partinied by Romans and Persians. Do blame them instead, Turks just took whatever left there. Even the modern day Azerbeijan and Turkey wasnt dominated by Armenians. Thry dominated by helenized anatolians and Caucasian Albanians.
Sixth, China is literally controlled by Mongolic and Tungistic people until they became a Republic. So this is means, they didnt conqured those lands theirselfs. And their modern day borders are historically limited to Ming Dynastys borders.
Don't mind me, just putting respect on this mans name
Ladakh is sometimes called little Tibet.
Arunachal pradesh is little tibet
Not Bhutan is little tibet
难的在外网看到这么理性公正客观的讲中国的视频，点赞了
India still has 14 Dalai Lama who is respected highly by Indians too
Indians support China's separatist forces. China will support President Manipur's visit to China.
Hindus respect all dharmic religions like Sikhism, Buddhism, Jainism.
@@sourabhgupta4853 use indians instead of Hindus
@@preetchheda7626 Santani *
@@sourabhgupta4853 sahi kha Bro Yai Log Dharm ka naam oar desh Bata Ga
I love this channel so much
Most people who know literally nothing about China or have been to China shouldn't spread their subjective perspectives on the Tibet. I've been to Qinghai province, which is a province that's next to Tibet with many Tibetans living there. Throwing all the politics away, what Tibetans got are brand new houses with access to water and electricity, highways, railways and high-speed-rail on construction. Their living standard is improving dramatically year by year with visible development. As for the cultural reserve, there are no genocides! Tibetan and Mandarin are both the language that they require to learn. One detail I observed was that all the road sign in the regions are marked with two or three languages(including English if it's a major road). Tibetans get perks. Eg. Easier to attend top tier university in China, high pensions, etc. No matter what you say, Tibet is experiencing the globalization, gradually connecting with the world is definitely a good sign for the people.
Yep, interesting how Western media always forget about that little piece of information eh? Almost like there's a narrative going on here.
I seen Tibetans on Quora talk about this. They say that China isn't as bad as it is and that the only separatists are Dalai Lama and his CIA gang. I may not be pro-China but screw the west for all that propaganda!
The British also massively improved HK's standard of living by taking it over. Did that give them the right? Something to think about...
@@TheGuzeinbuick British DID NOT massively improved HK's standard of living. Hong Kong raised due to its geopolitical location, similar to Singapore. Hong Kong developed due to the fact that it was the only major illegal "foreign" lands that connect the rest of the China(land by unequal treaty after the war). As a result, continuous wealth flew to Hong Kong from rest of China, caused Hong Kong to become rich. If Hong Kong is an island in the middle of the ocean, it's development level will be exactly like typical British ruled Pacific islands, or even worse. One thing that I have to mention that the British was the exploiters, Hong Kong should be much better with massive flowing assets, yet most of them had transported back to Britain, like rest of the British colonies. The Governors of Hong Kong were British all the time, they rampaged through the city like gangster, basically did nothing to contribute to the economy.
@@TheGuzeinbuick The hardworking Hong Kong citizens improved their living standards not the British. Plenty of former British colonies like Burma, Sri Lanka have not done so well. Stop giving Hong Kong’s success to British.
FINALLY A NEW VID!!!
Very few people know but india and had a war in 1800s between Sikh Empire of india and Qing Dynasty of China which was strategically indian victory and since then ladhak become part of india and Tibet was more friendly towards india as Chinese get kicked in a$$.
But now more than 60000 sq.km of India is part of China as Akshai Chin🤷♂️
How did Hawaii become a part of America? How did Northern Irland become a part of British? And how Manipur become a part of India?
You get the spot on man
Manipur has Hindu population go & see
Infact "Pur" itself defines why it's Indian
Many Indian Independence Movement took place in Manipur with Azad Hind Fauj 👍
@Dorin Tenzin just your wet dream lol
You will get to answer these questions, if you put the effort to education out of your CCP propaganda, maybe?
4:30 that invasion to tibet by 🇬🇧was a horrible time for tibet. Beautiful natures getting destroyed by wars. Tibet woman are getting raped. Etc
@Dorin Tenzin and which pathetic beggar are you？I see you so thirst for a sense of existence here that you start a chat with me with a topic that has nothing related to what I said😫
Tibetans and Chinese are like distant step siblings who took distant paths
Indias lack of foresight which let PRC takeover Tibet.
With Buffer Tibet, the border dispute would be minimal
India was not that much developed at that time
@@chiefengineer7607 Neither was China.
I don't think india could face china at that time. They had a war in 1962 and lost pretty badly, even losing territory. If China could keep the U.S at bay in Korea it could easily clean the floor with India.
@@VishuK-t8f Indian leader were promoting India China unity before 1962 war
@@chiefengineer7607 Yeah. Our leadership was weak. Otherwise if Sardar Patel or Lal Bahadur Shastri was the PM. We would have beaten the crap out of China.
After long time video is uploaded
Next, Afghanistan and Tajikistan, where their land landscape is still connected to Tibet and their culture for thousands of years, namely both adhered to Bon and Buddhist religions before they converted to Islam and were influenced by Arabs.
I thought Afghan culture was influenced mostly by eastern iranian culture?
Influenced😂 they genocided them to convert to Islam,like Persians
According to what you said, they all received the influence of China, which directly copied Chinese technology and suppressed Europe in the Middle Ages.China loves 回-shaped ornamentation.
@@Tabish_Nooristani Yes, but at first the majority of their people embraced Buddhism
Zoroasterism is a real religion of Afghanistan. Not Buddhism
every history video has the "Mongols came" line
Well whatever As Indian i also know how it feels like when someone says to cut a part of of your country
Same with Chinese gov, they also have same human feeling but atleast they should care about Buddhist Tibet culture
It is really horrible to spread communism and atheism forcefully .
well, i think it is ur own freedom for a religion
but from my point of view, communism is at least better than tibetian serfdom...
stop believe those non-sense culture destruction, Chinese perserves their culture or even support their spreading.
You guys should really look at its population of those minorities after CCP rules, their population has significantly increase in the past decades
I think it is enough to turn Tibetan culture into an Indian-like culture 😂😂😂
@@tianlingchen5523 We'll Tibetan language is close to Sanskrit.
And almost all of ancient Buddhist texts are in Proto Sanskrit or Maithili, so it makes perfect sense.
Just forget it all, its Akhand Bharat Ultimately😁😁😁
Finally one video with Correct Map of India
tibet feels bad
They were ungrateful to Chinese rule! Arrogance people!
Majority of Tibetan vocabulary derives from Brahmi script the rest derives from sino-Tibetan
Chinese derived from Tibetan
here a another video: why didn’t bhutan recognize any country until 1960s?
Untill 1980s bhutans foreign policy and defence was India's responsibility and even now bhutan has signed defence treaty with India.
Your fact is also wrong as just after independence bhutan signed treaty of friendship with india, both countries recognise each other and use indian currency for value manipulation in Bhutan.
Bhutan is a satellite state of India. Their foreign Policy is mostly made by Indian Government.
I love the little captions on each slide - just come in randomly so smooth and catchy. Just like covid!
*_Through coercion and Military. FREE TIBET!!!_*
Tibetan people are very peaceful by nature.
And they wont ever engage in any ear.
My best friend is a Tibetan Immigrant,( his family came in the 60's) and he says Buddha will provide a path, endless violence won't.
I'm as an Indian respect that.
But if I was in his place, i would have fought for my motherland.
No
FREE KASHMIR ! INDIA RAPIST ARMY BUT BE DEFEATED!
youre back :D
Free Tibet
(Gun relodes behind me)
No
BULLSH;T!
@@jagdpanther2224 are you Chinese bot?.
Eyy love ur vids im early bro
Keep up the good work BTW love from pakistan
-300,000 social credit score
as always another perfect video
Wonderful video! Obviously great
Non-Tibetans: Tibetans should remain traditional and independent, even in poverty.
Real Tibetans: I need stable electricity, clean running water, hospitals, quality education, mobile phones, internet, cars, roads, security, work.
True
Maybe not the next Taiwan.
Dignity is more valued in Buddhism than materialism.
Amazing how your 8min videos last for an hour!
Mongolia be like, "Nah, China can have those traitors." 😂
Hey Guys you need to know that a normal human cant go to tibet they would be exhausted by the high altitude and the harsh climate it is no joke tibetans are superhuman for thousands of years the tibetan empire fended off many enemies and took on many conquests even reaching to the mediterian and even reached as far as to bagdhad it is only when the tibetan empire broke of from internal turmoil please do research and the only reason why china was able to invade tibet was that tibet had less population than before it had almost no good weapons only from ww1 and with the chinese manpower and technological superiorty did they invade tibet. but it still took 28 years for the chinese to take the last region of tibet from the people of tibet.
I helped Tibetans to make free Tibet flag on r/place
As if that does anything, jeets are funny people
@@Marc-. atleast they don't eat snakes and bats
I love how Liu Yi fei is always included as a model specimen of ethnic Chinese people. Frankly, no complaints there.
Thanks for the history lesson sir
Ah, yes
this is my request months earlier
thanks for creating this such vid
i love your colorful content.
@ 0:43 what is the 2nd-to-left countryball?
Xinjiang▪︎Tibet▪︎???▪︎Taiwan▪︎Hong Kong
Inner mongolia
Great video again
Free Tibet? Already did.
Colonizing Tibet? Currently happening.
yes.from slavery system of Dalai
He's a big chungus
He's a big chunky boi
Such a big bun, yes
We are so overjoyed
To have a big chunky boi
A big and wonderful chungus such as he
Oh such as he
He's a big chungus
He's a big chunky boi
Such a big bun, yes
We are so overjoyed
To have a big chunky boi
A big and wonderful chungus such as he
Oh, such as he
Huh
Buns come in all shapes and all sizes
This one has so many surprises
I've never seen a giant quite like him
There's no one like him
Nobody like chungus
Huh
Get the game for PS4
For a limited time
Huh
Don't miss what it has in store
You're running out of time
Play the game of the year
The game with that colossal boi
He's a big chungus
He's a big chunky boi
Such a big bun, yes
We are so overjoyed
To have a big chunky boi
A big and wonderful chungus such as he
Oh, such as he
Huh
Buns come in all shapes and all sizes
This one has so many surprises
I've never seen a giant quite like him
There's no one like him
Nobody like chungus
Huh