ECHO vs STIHL String Trimmer Reviews | Which Cordless String Trimmer You Should Buy -
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
- Mike Gunn of Gunn Landscaping bringing you his comparison of the ECHO CDST-58V and the STIHL FSA 57 cordless trimmer attachments. He trials both products and lets you know which one is most suitable for green pros!
Products
ECHO CDST-58: rb.gy/cfqdkm
STIHL FSA 57: bit.ly/2YntRaO
Article: bit.ly/377CDPk
.........................................................................................................
Hi there! New to EMB?
ECHO Means Business (EMB) is a brand-neutral website and mobile app that enables peer-to-peer conversations between green professionals. It offers content, tips, and advice to help you grow your business.
LET’S STAY IN TOUCH
★ Instagram: bit.ly/31PLoZW
★ Facebook: bit.ly/3ao1u0L
★ Newsletter: bit.ly/3fRSeDd
DOWNLOAD OUR APP
★ App for IOS: apple.co/3avM1Mt
★ App for Android: bit.ly/33ZPAt3
VISIT OUR WEBSITE & JOIN OUR COMMUNITY TODAY:
★ bit.ly/33Uwm7O
INTERESTING IN JOINING THE UAG 2021?
★ Apply here: bit.ly/3kB1mjg
The fold down wire guard on the Stihl is for trimming around FLOWERS so you don't cut them off by accident---NOTHING to do with Edging.
I bought a Stihl and found that the brass grommet where the string comes out wears through in about 30 days. The head can be replaced for about $36.00 but very poor quality. A cheap Black and Decker I used before on my property, this grommet lasted about 18 months.
Done commercial and residentials for over 25 years have used both still and echo products as well as a few others I prefer still for blowers and chainsaws and small handheld blowers then the echo small handheld blower having them side by side and using them Deco seems heavier and doesn't seem to have as much volume at the pipe maybe because of the diameter but the echo blower handheld just doesn't seem to hold up as long as the stills I prefer ECHO line trimmers, for the price point I've had still four strokes which I really didn't care for as well as Hondas the Honda four-stroke line trimmer is 14 lb that thing is a boat anchor to carry around all day long so if that echo electric trimmer is 14 lb it's a big no for me as well as the batteries puking out any expense of the battery especially when you only get a couple seasons if that even with light use and since I've been rebuilding and repairing 2-stroke dirt bikes since I was 12 and started racing at 9: so I do all my own repairs I even do a little porting and polishing as well as a few other little tweaks to gain a little extra power something you really can't do with that electric weed eater and or if that electric motor blows out or bearings to be replaced shafts and the whatnot I think I'll stick with gas power for ease of maintenance and rebuilding since I do actually put rings in my weed eaters that are very inexpensive if and when need be to get another season or two out of it I'm sure the battery powered stuff will get a little better eventually but it's funny like the Husqvarna Roomba looking outdoor mower that little robot mower if it hits a dog dip where he's dug out the ground that thing gets stuck if it runs over a soft serve dog Patty it'll sit there and spend its little plastic wheels but they praise these little mowers even though it won't cut tall Grass the crass has to be cut short one time at least before you can use their little electric lawn mower Roomba gimmick which doesn't work in the rainy seasons in Florida cuz it rains morning noon and night so hopefully their weatherproof LOL
Stihl 135r wrecks it
I love my echo 58volt
I think this dream is not a reality, a magic word that nobody speaks, how many houses can be cut with a single battery, I only cut between 25 to 30 properties per day, will I believe that this is not good option for professional landscaping .
You cut and trim 1 yard every 20 minutes for 12 straight hours every day?? 🥴🥴 Ok.
@@giantranga414 every 30 to 40 minutes, 12 hrs every day
Entry level home owner equipment. Don't even consider it.
BAD comparison, you non Stihl guys really don't want to be fair.
Isn’t he comparing similarly priced models? The comparable stihl is like $650
@@MrSkunknuts Fsa 57 MSRP on that one is 200 with al 101 and ak 10
For the last 18 months I've not let the lawn crew edge or use a weed eater in my back yard. ua-cam.com/users/postUgkx_rBCFuDW1zD6blTGhLkvAkxU657uR_lG I didn't like the fact that they just kept cutting the edge of the lawn further and further from the rock lining the flower beds and leaving bare ground. And the grass was trimmed or scalped several feet around trees, etc. It was a constant battle with them so I told them to just mow and no trimming. I have Zoysia grass so it grows pretty slow. Obviously after a while it could use some trimming. I'm in my 80's so I can't do much of it myself.Finally I decided that if I could find a lightweight battery powered trimmer I might be able to do some light trimming. I decided to buy the LST201 20V trimmer. And it works great for my needs. I have back yard with about 150' of flower beds and several trees to be trimmed. I can lightly trim the whole yard with a single charge! The grass I trimmed was only a few inches high but the trimmer was more powerful than I expected.
The Echo is obviously much more powerful but at 14 pounds you may as well have a gas trimmer.
No need to mix and go buy gas so I would definitely keep the battery model anytime, no odor, no vapor, no carburetor to service if the diaphragm dried and no longer pump the gas to the engine, no maintenance, etc. No brainer for me.
A Stihl residential toy vs a commercial trimmer. Lol
Right, this isnt a good comparison
I have this particular Stihl. I like it, but I know this comparison is a joke. You are dealing with 2 totally different classes of equipment. This is like comparing a $300 push mower to a $10k+ zero turn riding mower.
not a very fair comparison. the stihl is a more consumer level unit. a comparison between the fsa 90 R would make more sense.
actually a fair comparison would be the fsa 130 R because the echo is very powerful on high mode.
It is a pretty fair comparison when you look at price. It’s the closest Stihl model. The fsa 57 is 200 bucks compared to the echo at 269. The stihl fsa 90 that you refer to is 600 bucks.
@@johnmorgan8075 you got a point there, and that seems to be the case across all their products, stihl's fs 240 r goes for a hulking $630 whereas echo's srm-3020T goes for $430. Even their new srm-410X is less! Goes for $550. I have had an srm-225 since 2011 and its still going strong so echo in my experience is a very solid name.
The Stihl is more for residential use. It is also a lot lighter especially if you have a bad back. For professional use the Echo wins hands down. But for my use as a homeowner I would choose the Stihl because it is a lot lighter and will do all I need to do in my yard. Kind of a unfair comparison, because the Echo is more heavy duty professional trimmer
Yeah you are right: 36 Volts for the STHIL vs 58 for ECHO, oranges and apples really...
silly to compare the Echo with a less powerful Stihl model when Stihl to pro machines
My girl likes the stihl because of the light weight.
How about a cost comparison because Stihl makes more powerful professional models too
I’ve got the Stihl. Love it. Got an extra 20 battery, which runs longer. It is so light and easy to handle I actually enjoy using it. Far more user friendly and convenient than gas. Plenty of power for my 1/4 acre lot with lots of trimming to do.
Echo can go pound sand. I have the echo and after 2 light residential seasons the battery is junk and a new battery is $160.00. Look up reviews on the echo, great trimmer $hit battery and apparently no support. I’ll be buying the best stihl for my needs.
Watching the video you got here they both seem like pretty good trimmers however we're going to get to the price price can make a lot of difference and does it come with a handle vehicle Cardiology out the cost on this too I don't know if it has the automatic head we'll find out.
Would be nice to see a comparison against some of the more powerful Battery operated Stihl trimers not just against this entry-level version. Funny Echo sent this one lol.
Thanks for the vid!
Dude not even a fair camparsion u didnt cut nothing but little grass with stihl and you cut tall stuff with the echo and the echo has too different speeds come on lol. Fair my *** stihl kicks echo everyway everday
The echo looks way more powerful
At least you're honest saying that they asked you to compare these 2 products. What will give you the downvote is that most viewers will be gone before they realize that this is a completely unfair comparison of tools. Why dont you pick the Stihl equivallent instead of their prosumer product.
Shame on you.
Your biased as hell for echo kept repeating yourself . Compare them even Steven same volts!
Should compare the echo to the Stihl Fs 90r.
I still checking it out one main factor about this trimmer seems to have the power to little heavy and I think it's I think it's going to mess it up is going to be the cost I think it's going to be way too high for what it is
I have the Echo trimmer and while it is has been a good machine the battery is completely dead, won’t accept a charge. Replacement battery is so expensive that I will toss the trimmer out. I bought a Stihl battery mower and will be buying their trimmer. Replacement batteries for the Stihl are much more reasonably priced.
The video shows quite clearly which one is the better one. I am 6 foot 7 inches tall (2.00 meters). Why is nobody talking about usability for tall people (even taller than me). And I mean give a height what people can use what machine. I know it's not your job to do that. The manufacturers should do that, but they don't. So it's only through channels like yours that I can find this out. I hope you can help me.
You should at least have used the Stihl FSA 60 a for comparison.
The Echo does look a lot powerful handsdown. But I personally favor the STINHL because its light and really takes pressure of my back. Its quiet and thats a plus for me. I's also adjustable for a short or tall person. Though its not as powerful as the ECHO, its enough power I need for my for my back and front yard.
I must ask, do you call this an honest demo? are you unaware of the proper comparable unit?
I bought an Echo battery trimmer and blower at Homedepot so when I went to buy a new battery, it turns out that Homedepot had already stopped selling them. I ran out of trimmer and blower. Here in Puerto Rico only Homedepot sold them.😕
i have 2 of the echo trimmers and i love them. they completly replaced my gas powered ones on my mowing rig. i keep extra batteries charged. i usually get through about 4-5 average lawns per battery. they do have a larger capacity battery as well its a 4ah vs the 2ah that comes with it.
I'm in favor of echo products hands down! Although i have a really good pair of stihl loppers that i like! Thee all new 56V e-force echo products that are even more powerful are coming in 2022!
Mike I might have missed the information about the batteries that come with these two trimmers. Do both companies provide Battery Chargers with your purchase of a Trimmer. Do they both come to full charge in about the same time. How easy is it to reload the Trimmer Spools with new line, are they both Tap and go systems to advance new line.?How many months do the warranties last on these two trimmers.?
Echo gives this guy a weed eater . Echo win's .
Echo is just a beast compared to Stihl
Really couldn't tell you kept using it backward then forward then backward again
You use a string trimmer like my mom
So far huskavarna looks like the winner
And I refuse to buy anything huskavarna... except for my xp288 chainsaw
Yeah wasn’t quite liking how he was using the trimmers lol.
What's the vibration like on the Echo?
I have the echo 58v trimmer and dont like it. The batteries dont charge right and there very hard to disengage from the trimmer and Charger. I would not buy one again. Batteries sometimes wont charge either. I Think the Stihl is much better with there new models.The echo is however very powerful.
Echo's most powerful one they make against the Stihl's cheapest one they make . Impressive how a home use only can keep up with a farm use or commercial grade weed eater . That is only one way to look at it . Or I can say it this way . The Best Echo's weed eater beats Stihl's littlest and cheapest weed eater . Echo pays for this ! How low can a company do . Make's me not to trust them .
A 56volt vs a 36volt of course it has more power. Its also heaver. Im thinking about a trimmer and blower and possibly a chainsaw down the road.leaning towards Stihl.
Glad to see this. I just ordered a few today! Glad I made the right choice! Go echo!
Be prepared to trash your feet and legs with the Echo. You cant move the guard and all the debris flies into your legs and feet an hurts to boot. Wish I would have tried it first.
Gunn getting it done. Well done 👍🏻
Thanks for the demo. I think I will stick with my gassers. I am definitely impressed with the power of the echo though. The things I look for in a trimmer is durability, power, weight and run time. Well if a battery unit I would be looking at how safe the battery and charging it would be. Don't want my shed going up in smoke.
Does the head on the Stihl turn clockwise and the echo counterclockwise? How does that effect operation?
Very Honest video! unbiased .I'm Echo products All the way and some Craftsman,Still Chain saws are awsome! but overall I'm Echo.great honest unbiased vid.thanks
Nope. For a blade edger I don't care, but for a string trimmer I need a true variable speed trigger. I haven't seen one yet, so it's either electrically impossible, which I doubt, or it would add two bucks to the cost of the unit.
Geee, Totally no bias with this channel 😂😂 You may as well have used a Black and Decker from walmart and claimed a fair comparison
Love the Echo as I can run the battery in the mower, blower, trimmer and chain saw.
I have used Stihl chainsaws my whole life and considered myself a fan. I was sick of dealing with small engine issues due to corn syrup in gas. Never had an issue with Stihl saws (assume due to conditioners in Stihl 2-stroke oil mix), but did have issues with my non-Stihl pressure washer (Honda) and homelite leaf blower. So, I thought I would give the Stihl FSA 57 a try. It works, but compared to a gas powered trimmer it feels kinda gutless. I still have the FSA 57 Stihl as my only weed eater/wacker and I use it, but I find myself getting a little impatient with it as I feel I have to go over an area twice. It feels a bit short (the pole) and I feel like the guard is too close to the mower wheel and therefore the cutting thread/line/string never feels quite long enough. I don’t think I would buy this Stihl model again. For a small yard for a few quick zips around a quarter acre city lot it may be enough. But for an acre and a half with fruit trees, blueberry bushes, side walks and work to do around raised garden beds it lacks the extra power I want.
Too bad they gave you the Stihl low end model to compare against the Echo commercial one.....
Could use that echo as a brush trimmer! Especially on high speed! Crazy machine
It’d be funny if he trimmed the lens off his camera. Make a good gag.
If Ehco sent the two strimmers for comparison there was only one strimmer you are going to choose.
How long the battery takes to discharge? When I working?
The Echo neds to go up against a Pro Stihl not the domestic line
Echo did not send 2 equal rivals. Compare the prices on the 2, Stihl around $100 cheaper.
Are you sure ? Name the country please. If talk about LT/Europe - its ~ 40 Eur difference (with same battery), assuming the fact ECHO is 58 V, Stihl - 36V. I do have more poweful Stihl battery (AK 30, for my chain saw) but I refused the idea to buy FSA 57 as for me its too little power, too small cutting swath. I need at least FSA 85 or FSA 90R for my need but prices are killing me - additionally they are not compatible with AK line (its AP) so I need to pay full price to get sufficient set for work.
I only use echo trimmers and the lawn mower battery I will have this spring
Nice!
Electric the echo easily wins
Gas tge sthil all day!!!
I have used echo and yea I agree the echo kicks ass
This video does cover some important points but I could not tell if the Stihl was single speed or not. In the early days of weed whackers single speed was common but today it is totally obsolete. Is the Stihl FSA 57 a single speed trimmer?
Yes mine is a single speed
@@surfearth1 Thanks for the info. You are doing a public service by giving the information that the manufacturer should have published in the first place. Their specifications are fake by omitting the mono-speed limitation.
How often to you have to put line on that stilh I like the way the Echo worked.
I bought my 3rd Stilh 3 years ago. Just got it out of the shop and wanted to beat it to pieces in the middle of the road. First product by them that I litterly hate. Looking at some options before I go buy onother.
Anybody know where the echo battery trimmers are made?
Echo 58v cordless equipment is made by TTi in China (TTi makes Ryobi and Milwaukee gear). Do not buy the 58V line as it has been discontinued by Echo. The Echo 58v tools are great, but the batteries are horrible as they simply don't last and are outrageously expensive to replace.
@@sailenthusiast8007 I ended up getting the Echo 56V. The tool itself says Asembled in USA (which doesn't mean a lot actually), but the charger and battery are Made in China. The performance is good, but the build quality doesn't feel nearly as good as the Stihl. I wish I had gone for the Stihl, but their disallowing online sales combined with their dealer network being so bad (at least around here, it's mostly Ace Hardwares) made it too difficult to buy one.
Would you do a comparison what's the echo vs Husqvarna
I have the Husky. The Echo is better. I’m getting that one tomorrow...