Elektron Analog Heat vs Sherman FB2 quick comparison test
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 лис 2016
- Quick comparison test between Analog Heat and Sherman Filterbank v2.
Elektron Analog Rytm output connected straight into Analog Heat, and AR headphones out straight into Sherman.
No post processing, each comparison is normalised to match levels, and in mono because Sherman is mono.
Both sound great to me, but for sure the Filterbank has something special about. It makes great sound greater :P
Sherman hands down , i got one and although its a bit tricky to use it does overdrive like no other unit.
Great video! It shows the sonical intersection of the two amazing gears. But I guess both can do things the other can't. Personally I prefer the Analog Heat as it seems to me the more versatile one. Just wish it would have the many knobs of a Sherman for a more immediate and direct control.
fantastic clap!!✌
Very tasteful use of the Sherman Filterbank, but I don't think your Analog Heat settings showed off its potential very well. I definitely appreciate you taking the time to make and post this video though, and it was a good reminder of how much I love the Filterbank.
I think if the Drive knob was set a tad bit lower, the amount of clipping would have been more similar between the two devices. Thank you for the nice video.
wow! Sherman kicks ass!!!
Extreme settings on the Analog Heat don't really give a full accounting for its overall possibilities..
sherman 👍
thanks!
sherman is the King of filters
I have a Filterbank 2, do you think getting a Analog heat would be too redundant? I use these effects as outboards effect to give some analog texture from my daw
Nah, it's like a palette of colors, you have options to choose from.
I have both. I got the Analog Heat because it’s stereo!
Got Heat+FX. It's very interesting box and it is STEREO )
Bout to swap my mk 2 for a fx. The sherman does seem really nice tho. The heats lfo's are huge for me too
The Millennium Falcon cupholder test ;-)
which one is more suitable than the other one in what different usecases?
I think sherman sounds best in this example :)
Great clip! Do you use a hardware usb-to-din-midi converter for the nanokontrol? If so, what is your solution?
Thank you! Nanokontrol is usb connected to computer, to control Reaktor sequencing AR
***** I see, thanks :-]
Way too much drive on the heat, but that Sherman is a classic for a reason!
Yep the heat was set on max drive i wonder what the Sherman's settings were...
Of course the Filterbank 2
can you do one with analog heat with drive at half, I want to see some sound enhancement and saturation not distorsion :D
in this clip all the heat sound is too distorted, sherman sounds cleaner..
je possède plusieurs sherman fb2, ainsi qu’un analog drive qui apporte une couleur supplémentaire, (assez surpris en bien)
j’hésite à me prendre un analog heat et le mettre en fin de chaine pour grossir encore le son et les EQ, Est ce que ça pourrait être pertinent ? sortie vers un ordi sous ableton
Is it possible to get stereo image out of filterbank 2?
yes
i don't get this comparison .. you try to make them sound similar. But both machines are very different. The Sherman can go a lot wilder than the Heat and still sound nice, while the Heat can sound more controlled an d subtle. Both are are great but for different things
+1000
Denk nochmal genau über deine Aussage nach... Die beiden Einheiten sind sich doch in fast allen Hinsichten gleich - auch wenn die Herangehensweise eine ganz andere ist.. Tendiere stark zur Sherman Bank ( auch wenn der ebbe&Flut Kollege bei mir als erster eine wohnungsbesichtigung haben wird..), aber definitiv werden bald beide bei mir im Studio stehen :)
Grüße aus Regensburg ;)
I get the comparison, out of the devices available on the market at the moment the Heat most seems to provide a similar array of options to the Filterbank.
Liked FB2 sound more
Overall AH doesn't seem to be "worth it" IMO.
Also, they should've put those filters on Octatrack 2 (or Decatrack for that matter).
Whats decatrack
Merci pour la vidéo, cela dit je trouve dommage que le sherman n'est pas du tous mis en valeur dans la vidéo alors que c'est un très bon filtre avec overdrive/disto, vous n'avez pas branché le OUT 1 et essayé le mode série des filtre, le réglage du potard vert (INPUT) a gauche permet d'ajouter une jolie distortion également (passé les 3/4)
Il est également dommage d'utiliser toujours le même son pour le test car le sherman réagit tellement différemment en fonction de la source sonore (je ne connais pas du tous l'Analog Heat en revanche) , j'aurai beaucoup aimé quelque test avec différent branchement/PATCH comme une 2e source sonore branché dans l'entrée Trigger ADSR en mode suiveur d'enveloppe (switch adsr position basse), sa donne des résultat super intéressant parfois !
J'apprend encore a me servir du sherman, il est pas évident a prendre en main mais je le trouve vraiment exellent sur des live Hard Techno, basseline etc...
so much more you could of done with the sherman tho...... barely touched it. Both are amazing
Heat just farts here
Sounds good but no offense, the clipping audio is annoying on my end. I get the filterbank can go above and beyond useful audio range, trim the video audio next time, please.
Interesting... I think same result could be achieved when u mess around with both of them!! I will say I would love to the black analog HG-2 or Thermonic Culture Vulture stacked up against the AH esp when you consider the price difference
The sherman is much deeper and sounds much better imo
From that I prefer the SFB. Its hard to tell without having hands on & mirroring parameters as best as possible.
Heat sounds more cluttered in the low mids. Almost BRR, but tho it's analog.
SFB has more air.
Obviously the big plus with the Elektron is stereo capability.
BlueWolfSe7en you forgot to mention overbridge and being able to save your presets. Its also a soundcard
True there is the OB side of things. TBH, I've given up on that these days, it doesn't really deliver, for me anyway. Don't want to derail, but suffice it to say, the OB issues are well & truly documented on Elektronauts.
BlueWolfSe7en its just added functionality to which i wouldn't say no to. Not the most important aspect of the unit but still useful in certain situations
On the FB2 there are 2 outputs, so you can get panning if on separate channels.
I appreciate the comparison but both units are clipping out of control. It would be nice if we turned down the input volume and didn’t fully overdrive so we could hear their individual sonic nuances. But I do appreciate the video. Thanks!
Heat !!!
Seems a little Bias of a test, your giving the Heat way more play.
and the filterbank still floors it!
Sherman is more musical
Face it, you really have no idea how to use the Sherman.