I like how the video points to all these diferent people being the villain, maybe even Sothis and Byleth themself. Especially at the end when Byleth can't make peace when going with any of the lords, they start to doubt themself that maybe they're the reason everything goes bad.
this so accurately captures byleth in this game and their mindset, like they play as all the timelines, they're both the heroes and villains, and see all perspectives and all the lords (and rhea) at one point as heroes or villains. its poetry, truly.
@@hammylove821 Considering she is the only one against the insane Lizard Pope from the start, yeah I'd argue she's the most sensible one actually. She was the only one apparently to see the Red Flags. Ironically.
I mean, in 3 of the 4 paths Edelgard is the bad guy... So I really fail to see the ambiguity. Especially as her path could have been resolved simply by revealing the evil organization she was supposedly fighting to everyone else who would have joined her without her having to declare war on the world... So yeah... It's not that gray.
It's a bit more complicated. The evil organisation (TWSITD) are practically holding a knife near her throat and it would hard to prove that they exist without risking her own life. Her uncle who got replaced, helps corrupted nobles that could potentially talk against her and even reflect her accusations at her. There is always somebody there watching her. Firstly there was that old guy who got quickly replace by Kronya pretending to be Monica In addition, the war is a bit more complicated. Edelgard wants massive changes in the society and demolish the whole system of nobility and crests. She basically wants to introduce democracy and it would rather hard if we consider the fact that Faergus (Dimitri's kingdom) is slowly corrupted by TWSITD. Plus, there is mentally unstable Rhea that altered history of Fodland and she is well known for severe punishments. Add to that whole situation the fact that Edelgard has a short life span thanks to TWSITD and she ends up being a tragic character. She is a grey character, but a bit more darker spectrum if we consider everything.
I would think that revealing a secret organization that has mastered spycraft to their worst enemy and local lords would be akin to suicide whether to you plans or person.
I'm just imagining how Byleth must've felt, probably going through ad many timelines as possible to find a "good one" where they don't have to kill Dmitri, Claude, or Edelgard, and thr immense disappointment they must've felt when they found they couldn't, no matter what they did.
I just want to point out that when they're showing off "heroes" killing with the lyrics "We all pretend" etc. at 1:15 , they have Edelgard killing Dimitri, Dimitri killing Rhea, and finally Byeth killing Edelgard. None of which includes Claude doing anything evil, scientifically proving he truly is our Golden Boy who can do no wrong. I will be accepting no questions or counterarguments at this time.
Damn this is really good it. Love the quick flash of "Ashen Demon" when showing the crest of flame before swapping to the actual subtitles. The shot of the Byleths standing parallel to each other. The cut from watching Edelgard killing Dimitri then the opposite ah so good. Only issue is Claude he's too good of a guy to even be called a Villain in any story so he doesn't fit, that's not your fault it would feel wrong without him here. That's just the game.
I mean arguably Byleth was always a form of the villain. She was a mercenary before the story and either side that she joins is guilty of many travesties.
i- ?? i love this??? this is so well done and amazing and i cant believe it was your first animation and aaa??? this is just super breathtaking and awesome and i wish i could use some words that are more eloquent than the ones i said to tell you how great this animatic is. like, its been ages since i even thought about this game but this animatic is grabbing me by the ankles and trying to shove me back into the hellhole that is fire emblem
![Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story [FE3H Animatic] (Read Desc.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rV6V2p2Uuas/mqdefault.jpg)
![Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story [FE3H Animatic] (Read Desc.)](/img/tr.png)
I like how the video points to all these diferent people being the villain, maybe even Sothis and Byleth themself. Especially at the end when Byleth can't make peace when going with any of the lords, they start to doubt themself that maybe they're the reason everything goes bad.
this so accurately captures byleth in this game and their mindset, like they play as all the timelines, they're both the heroes and villains, and see all perspectives and all the lords (and rhea) at one point as heroes or villains. its poetry, truly.
This is why Three houses is my favorite Fire Emblem because besides those who slither in the dark there aren't any real villains.
Except the underground mole people
Edelgard is literally the red faction/villain.
And Rhea is the only one who always goes insane and tries to kill everyone, including her allies, in every route.
@@hammylove821
@@GigiBranconi Does that dispute what I said?
@@hammylove821 Considering she is the only one against the insane Lizard Pope from the start, yeah I'd argue she's the most sensible one actually.
She was the only one apparently to see the Red Flags. Ironically.
This is so good and portraits the game so well! Nobody in it is totally good nor bad, that's what makes the game so good! Well done 👍
Not that it would happen, but I would love to see a Three Hopes update to throw Shez in the mix.
This is absolutely lovely & needs more attention!!
Oh my gosh I love this so much!!! Amazing work!
Thank you
This is amazing
This is amazing!!!!!!! ^^
This is really lovely!
This would be perfect for pokemon black and white
Then there is three houses Claude
Just not really being villainous
I mean, in 3 of the 4 paths Edelgard is the bad guy... So I really fail to see the ambiguity. Especially as her path could have been resolved simply by revealing the evil organization she was supposedly fighting to everyone else who would have joined her without her having to declare war on the world... So yeah... It's not that gray.
It's a bit more complicated. The evil organisation (TWSITD) are practically holding a knife near her throat and it would hard to prove that they exist without risking her own life. Her uncle who got replaced, helps corrupted nobles that could potentially talk against her and even reflect her accusations at her. There is always somebody there watching her. Firstly there was that old guy who got quickly replace by Kronya pretending to be Monica
In addition, the war is a bit more complicated. Edelgard wants massive changes in the society and demolish the whole system of nobility and crests. She basically wants to introduce democracy and it would rather hard if we consider the fact that Faergus (Dimitri's kingdom) is slowly corrupted by TWSITD. Plus, there is mentally unstable Rhea that altered history of Fodland and she is well known for severe punishments.
Add to that whole situation the fact that Edelgard has a short life span thanks to TWSITD and she ends up being a tragic character.
She is a grey character, but a bit more darker spectrum if we consider everything.
I agree 100% but the animation is still very good.
I would think that revealing a secret organization that has mastered spycraft to their worst enemy and local lords would be akin to suicide whether to you plans or person.
I'm just imagining how Byleth must've felt, probably going through ad many timelines as possible to find a "good one" where they don't have to kill Dmitri, Claude, or Edelgard, and thr immense disappointment they must've felt when they found they couldn't, no matter what they did.
I think at that point it would be despair, not disappointment
I just want to point out that when they're showing off "heroes" killing with the lyrics "We all pretend" etc. at 1:15 , they have Edelgard killing Dimitri, Dimitri killing Rhea, and finally Byeth killing Edelgard.
None of which includes Claude doing anything evil, scientifically proving he truly is our Golden Boy who can do no wrong. I will be accepting no questions or counterarguments at this time.
Spoiler
His path basically ends racism
Actually it's Dimitri killing Edelgard
Damn this is really good it. Love the quick flash of "Ashen Demon" when showing the crest of flame before swapping to the actual subtitles. The shot of the Byleths standing parallel to each other. The cut from watching Edelgard killing Dimitri then the opposite ah so good.
Only issue is Claude he's too good of a guy to even be called a Villain in any story so he doesn't fit, that's not your fault it would feel wrong without him here. That's just the game.
I come from the future (well, not really you only wrote your comment 7 hours ago), three hopes finally has war criminal Claude
@@batsybatsybats_ oh I've played golden wildfire and seen Azure Gleam and I'm very happy with our schemy boy
@@PhillipOnTakos I'm so proud of him 🥺🥺🥺
This is amazing!!! I love that you added in so many heart wrenching scenes!
Fire Emblem Three Hopes trailer 2: Byleth may be the villain for a bit?
I mean arguably Byleth was always a form of the villain. She was a mercenary before the story and either side that she joins is guilty of many travesties.
@@serronserron1320 Well if you kill their dad, then yes, they will try to kill you with no regrets other than your own.
WORDS CAN'T DESCRIBE HOW GOOD THIS VIDEO IS I LOVE IT SO MUCH💙💙
The cycle turns over ever onwards. Beautiful work
This is amazing! And captures the game so well.
Excellent Video here's another subscriber
Very good!
this needs to have more views oml
omg well done!!! i love this :)
i- ?? i love this??? this is so well done and amazing and i cant believe it was your first animation and aaa??? this is just super breathtaking and awesome and i wish i could use some words that are more eloquent than the ones i said to tell you how great this animatic is.
like, its been ages since i even thought about this game but this animatic is grabbing me by the ankles and trying to shove me back into the hellhole that is fire emblem
This is too good omg 😭
Indeed I don't know how other people could choose anything but Edelgard
I love this