My favorite proof of ghosts in Ghost of Thornton Hall is during one of the hauntings: At one point, you can look down the hallway with Charlotte's room at the end, and the door is open. It stays open for a moment, and slams shut, seemingly by itself. The reason this is weird is because you can see the fireplace in her room and the clock on the mantelpiece, which _Nancy doesn't know is there yet._ She had no way of knowing what was in Charlotte's room because no one had described her room and she hadn't yet seen it. With Charlotte, Nancy sees the picture of her on the book and hallucinates her right after, but there's no explanation for seeing her room before unlocking the door.
Also who carved Nancy’s name on the tomb stone? Because both she and Wade saw it so it wasn’t a hallucination. Some people say it was Harper but there’s really no reason for that and also how would she be able to do that with wade literally standing like 20 feet away. And also the swing moving by itself on the front porch at the very beginning of the game. You literally haven’t even been inside the house yet so carbon monoxide poisoning at that point is a bit too far of a stretch Also for that matter the number of haunting that occur far away from the main house can’t be that easily brushed off. At this point I might be looking at it too much but I don’t recall any haunting that occur in the basement (except for when you screw something up and die) which is directly the source of the CO. And yet you’re still “hallucinating” far away from the house which is not effected by the gas, true you still might have some in your system, but it should have totally worn off by them.
I actually laughed out loud and spit my drink when you said that men only have one thing on their mind.. Tesserae. and giving Nancy his rotten sausage ? That should be a fridge magnet 🤣
I loved these theories! I'm convinced ghosts are real too because even in games like MHM where some of the ghost sightings are caused by Abby, there are other sightings that Abby definitely didn't do! Also, I wanted to know Yumi's secret too and who did the writing and if it was a ghost!!
Feeding myself the illusion that the letters were faxed and that sis was in town for like a single day and would've repaired their relationship had they gotten together... but Takai kept them from meeting up and sis simply couldn't afford to come back for the funeral (or came back at a later time)
You fit almost tooo well in yumis apartment 🤔 Chloe is in Japan conspiracy theory starting now…. Mary Ann? More like SNUGHLY Collin and the rotten member 😳 I’m so sad we didn’t get the og script for mid 🥺 I would have loved the gf connection. I’m so curious about Yumi’s secret?? I completely forgot that happened, I’ve gotta replay it soon! Great video and investigation work!
Imagine if it's the same Alicia, and after leaving Dagny she moved on to have a thing with Jason (it's been 3+ years and I'm still deeply disturbed by her "I love cheese" comment). Then all of Dagny's issues in Sea of Darkness are completely understandable and forgivable.
It never even dawned on me that Alicia could be Dagny's Alicia. I'm choosing to believe this based on the little bit we get from Dagny about Alicia. Seems fitting.
Love this meta detective work. You go, super sleuth! On top of that, your look is absolutely giving sassy detective Nancy vibes, right up to the red hair :-)
So I always assumed it was rentaro who messed with Yumi window. It's stated in the game he stays over so I could see him staying there and Yumi staying at a friends house like she did with nancy
My favorite proof of ghosts in Ghost of Thornton Hall is during one of the hauntings:
At one point, you can look down the hallway with Charlotte's room at the end, and the door is open. It stays open for a moment, and slams shut, seemingly by itself. The reason this is weird is because you can see the fireplace in her room and the clock on the mantelpiece, which _Nancy doesn't know is there yet._
She had no way of knowing what was in Charlotte's room because no one had described her room and she hadn't yet seen it. With Charlotte, Nancy sees the picture of her on the book and hallucinates her right after, but there's no explanation for seeing her room before unlocking the door.
Oh that's so interesting!!!
Also who carved Nancy’s name on the tomb stone? Because both she and Wade saw it so it wasn’t a hallucination. Some people say it was Harper but there’s really no reason for that and also how would she be able to do that with wade literally standing like 20 feet away. And also the swing moving by itself on the front porch at the very beginning of the game. You literally haven’t even been inside the house yet so carbon monoxide poisoning at that point is a bit too far of a stretch
Also for that matter the number of haunting that occur far away from the main house can’t be that easily brushed off. At this point I might be looking at it too much but I don’t recall any haunting that occur in the basement (except for when you screw something up and die) which is directly the source of the CO. And yet you’re still “hallucinating” far away from the house which is not effected by the gas, true you still might have some in your system, but it should have totally worn off by them.
"A ghost wrote it."
Me, a ghostwriter: *Sweats*
Super hyped up for more theories!
🤣🤣🤣 I really missed an opportunity for a pun there!
Describing Rentaro as an "incel with engineering talent" is the funniest thing I've ever heard
I actually laughed out loud and spit my drink when you said that men only have one thing on their mind.. Tesserae. and giving Nancy his rotten sausage ? That should be a fridge magnet 🤣
I loved these theories! I'm convinced ghosts are real too because even in games like MHM where some of the ghost sightings are caused by Abby, there are other sightings that Abby definitely didn't do! Also, I wanted to know Yumi's secret too and who did the writing and if it was a ghost!!
"an incel with engineering power" killed me. Why is that so true, truly the most accurate description of Rentaro I've ever heard
Feeding myself the illusion that the letters were faxed and that sis was in town for like a single day and would've repaired their relationship had they gotten together... but Takai kept them from meeting up and sis simply couldn't afford to come back for the funeral (or came back at a later time)
God I would love if that were true...Kasumi's story makes me so sad 😢
You fit almost tooo well in yumis apartment 🤔 Chloe is in Japan conspiracy theory starting now…. Mary Ann? More like SNUGHLY
Collin and the rotten member 😳
I’m so sad we didn’t get the og script for mid 🥺 I would have loved the gf connection.
I’m so curious about Yumi’s secret?? I completely forgot that happened, I’ve gotta replay it soon! Great video and investigation work!
This video was amazing, it itched my brain in the best way learning new Nancy stuff makes me so happy
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed 💕
Imagine if it's the same Alicia, and after leaving Dagny she moved on to have a thing with Jason (it's been 3+ years and I'm still deeply disturbed by her "I love cheese" comment). Then all of Dagny's issues in Sea of Darkness are completely understandable and forgivable.
the rintaro part literally made me laugh out loud
It never even dawned on me that Alicia could be Dagny's Alicia. I'm choosing to believe this based on the little bit we get from Dagny about Alicia. Seems fitting.
Still my favorite content you put out. That first one was pretty mind-blowing.
Thank you!!
Love this meta detective work. You go, super sleuth! On top of that, your look is absolutely giving sassy detective Nancy vibes, right up to the red hair :-)
Ahh thank you so much!! :D
So I always assumed it was rentaro who messed with Yumi window. It's stated in the game he stays over so I could see him staying there and Yumi staying at a friends house like she did with nancy
The sentence at 4:54 is making me cry laughing.
🌭🌭🌭
Please keep making more of these!
God your writing is fantastic 😂 bar after bar
Ahh thank you so much!!
I'm still wondering what is yumis secret