The Path NO ONE Takes As FRANCE 🏳️
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 сер 2022
- Rescue the last sanctuary of humanity and lead our civilization towards immortal prosperity!💥
✅ Install Land of Empires for Free: bit.ly/3vAOZdY
✅ Use my redeem code: FEEDBACKLOE in the official website land-of-empires.com/cdkey.html to get a $10 in-game reward
ANOTHER French revolution! Its another episode of hoi4 the path no one does. This path is really cool allows free wars vs all neighbours and a bunch of interesting spy operations. SO settle down and enjoy before hoi4 by blood alone drops. Beaware this video was record a month ago so I do the old light tank recon hoi4 templates always changing.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Discord! / discord
Support me on Patreon! / feedbackgaming
Follow me on Twitter: / feedbackgaming
Follow me on Twitch: / feedbackgaming
Sub to my second UA-cam: @FeedbackIRL
Sub to memes channel: @feedbackmemes
Hearts of Iron IV is a grand strategy wargame developed by Paradox Development Studio and published by Paradox Interactive. Released on June 6, 2016, it is the sequel to Hearts of Iron III and part of the Hearts of Iron series of grand strategy games focusing on World War II. The player may take control of any nation in the world in either 1936 or 1939 and lead them to victory or defeat against other countries.
Feedbackgaming is known for his exploits, cheats, unlimited money videos. Is inspired by other successful influencers like the spiffing brit, isp, bokoen and tommykaylive.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Business email: davefeedbackgaming@gmail.com
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
#hoi4 #frenchrevolution #landofempires - Ігри
Rescue the last sanctuary of humanity and lead our civilization towards immortal prosperity!💥
✅ Install Land of Empires for Free: bit.ly/3vAOZdY
✅ Use my redeem code: FEEDBACKLOE in the official website land-of-empires.com/cdkey.html to get a $10 in-game reward
For some reason this video doesn’t show up on your channel unless you are looking at the HOI 4 playlist
You have it set to unlisted
Democratic Russia has probably never been played before in vanilla hoi4, understandably so, as there isn't a part in the new Russian focus tree for a democratic Russia,there's the 3 different communist paths, the fascist Russian empire path, and then the non-aligned third Rome path, honestly, the third Rome path and democratic Russia non-existent path have pretty much never been done before, so these are 2 video ideas that you could use
can you play the "New Ways" mod?
the connection between a French revolution and communism is the Paris commune of 1871, the worlds first communist government
13:43
All those "I'm, like, 16% Irish" people shed a single tear of joy.
Meanwhile 4 seconds later the northern Irish shed many tears of sadness😭
I dont understand im playing france vanilla no dlc and I cant find destroy the revolution focus
@@datboi6671 its dlc
@@yets0 but for some reason when I hover my mouse over the looming fascist strike and it says I need to get destroy the counter revolution, probably taunting me
Japan partitioned by Chinese warlords, and entire North America is Irish?
Perfectly historical hoi4 moment, probably.
Most historical game
@@DaveFeedBackGaming most hoi4 game
Aaaah so this is why I see so many MPs where France dies spectacularly. They want to grind army xp and forget that Germany is not npc that will wait to set time to declare war. Classic.
The greatest enemy of France. France
in non historical its usualy no justification before 38. france can finish war in spain easy before that, specialy with soviet sending volonteers and air.
also in non historical game europe that ahve the same climax and germany often go kaiser.
I don't really see how France will be able to do anything 90% of the time in MP. If you play the short term you lose, long term you also lose if Germany just declares war later or sooner.
Imagine playing MP
@@rizkiramadhan9266 imagine having no friends and playing singleplayer
As a French, seeing all those strikes makes me so happy, it's hard to describe
lol hey your country once didn’t have big strikes
"as a french"
I KNEW IT
You call yourself, "a french" interesting
Get out of here
The true, one and only french focus tree : revolution, political violence, strikes, and being at war with everyone, that's my France
For a short period (1870-1871, Franco-Prussian War) there was the Paris Commune. Although this wasn't during the French Revolution (Napoleon was long gone at this point) and lasted only 2 months, it did inspire much of the leftist sentiment in France in the 1930s. I might be wrong but this the closest thing I can think of.
Edit: thanks for the corrections from those replying, I didn’t know this would be one of the top comments!
now i know France had 2 napoleons ruling. but most people will not know:P so expect people saying the napoleontic era ended in 1815.
@@TheIsemgrim it did? Napoleon I led France to completely dominate Europe, which is why it is called the Napoleonic period. Not because there was a napoleon.
@@blazingfish8486 there was another Napoleon ruling france at around 1850-1872, he retired after losing the franco prussian war, who was called Napoleon III that was the nephew of the great Napoleon the first, he was a more liberal and diplomatic leader compared to his uncle. In his lead, france went to another great time, influencing europe once again, but this time more friendly with the British.
Given that the commune is something written about extensively as practical lessons by marx, lenin and trotsky I'd say it inspired more than just "leftist movement in france"
it was at the end of the franco prussian war not napoleonic wars
I've been inspired to do this one after listening to Mike Duncan's Revolutions podcast. Here's a brief rundown from his content:
So, the basic idea of this is the French revolution in the 1700s. When it was really going hard under Robespierre and the Jacobins, there was a basic idea of igniting revolutions against monarchies all across Europe. Some of this was because the monarchies attacked France in an attempt to restore the French monarchy. This was partially done out of concern for stability but also largely led by the Austrians since Marie Antionnette was an Austrian monarch and they didn't want to see her get killed. The French as a nation/people were deeply suspicious of the Austrians for decades prior since they were at war a lot, so they didn't like Marie Antionnette to start with. Austria (and later Britain) declaring war on them in some ways united the French despite the difference between revolutionaries and the aristocracy because they provided the old common enemies to unite against. The French state at this point became totalitarian, and the entire population was mobilized to fight and/or support the war effort in its own defense. At first, the lost a lot of battles, but then the wave of manpower and many lessons learned in hard fighting (young Napoleon as an example, and his cadre of future marshalls) led them to start steamrolling their enemies. The revolution became a bizarre combination of French nationalism as well as an effort to spread the revolution to oppressed peoples more broadly. Then the Girondists took power, and the revolution swung to the right, and eventually Napoleon stepped in and turned into more of a dictatorship. That's the cliff's notes of 1790-1815 anyway.
BUT....
Despite the reign of terror and endless wars, a fair number of French leftists and radicalists survived by various means- Lafayette as an example. After the monarchy was re-established by the rest of Europe following Napoleon's defeat, those leftists and radicals never really gave up. They had another revolution in the 1830s, briefly, which was full of barricades in Paris (Les Miserables). This inspired and taught other oppressed peoples throughout Europe, and in 1848 there was a wave of revolutions across almost all of continental Europe with the aims of both nationalistic autonomy for conquered peoples (e.g., Poles) against the greater powers who controlled them, as well as just "eat the rich" types. Almost all of these failed, except in Italy (which became a state) and Hungary (which eventually gained equality with Austria in the Aus-Hung Empire). The French revolution failed again.
THEN...
Napoleon 3rd (his nephew or great-nephew if I remember right) takes power, and you have the Franco-Prussian war in the 1870s. The Paris leftists AGAIN take over and you have the Paris commune. By now these leftists are the grandchildren of those in the first revolution, but the old ideas remain and have never gone away. The Prussians win and crush the commune, but the ideas linger all the way to WW1 and after.
MEANWHILE...
The revolutions in 1848 inspire guys like Marx, and the early proto-communists throughout Europe basically learn a ton of lessons from all of these revolutions and their effects and aftermaths. They also learn from (and participate in) revolutions in Haiti, Spain, South America, and Mexico throughout the 1800s and into the early 1900s.....
UNTIL....
1905, Russia.... which fails
And 1917 Russia.... which does not.
Which is all a really long way to say that the HOI4 focus trees for France, Mexico, the Soviet Union, Spain, and some others are really fun to play through if you also spend a good 2 years bingeing through all of Mike Duncan's podcasts.
Note here- Duncan starts off with the English and American revolutions, and he does a magnificent job of linking the ideas and peoples who were shared across each event. I really wish he had continued on to do Spain, but given he spent 2.5 years on Russia alongside writing two books I can see why he was ready to hang it up. It's a GREAT podcast series though, if you have the time. His Lafayette book is magnificent also (and the Rome stuff he did before is really good too).
1905 Russian Revolution didn't fail.
Back in la resistance when the operations worked, the one for the UK made them lose cores on Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, and also triple the resistance target and gain there. So not exactly that great but good for memes or trolling in MP
It would've been so cool if it still worked and caused the downfall of UK.
12:05 About that:
I think this revolution is inspired by two things: First of all, it of course is, as someone already explained, inspired by the Paris commune, because, well, first attempt to create a communist society in france. But that is more or less the case for all french communist paths, since there´s this focus "celebrate the commune", that one has to take to flip to communism anyway.
This revolution specifically is I think still mainly inspired by the french revolution. According to marxist views on history, history progresses when the oppressed class of a period rises up, defeats and replaces the old ruling class, and this progression eventually leads to socialism and communism, a society in which there are no classes anymore. Thus, both the french and the american revolution were very important and greatly celebrated moments in history for marxists, as those revolutions swept away the old feudal order of europe and replaced it with the bourgeois industrial capitalist order, which basically brought the world one step closer to socialism and communism (of course Napoleon and after him the congress of vienna kinda restored feudal order for a while, but the ideas, that would change europe forever and eventually lead to the downfall of many monarchies were laid during the french revolution between 1789 and 1799). For example, the american revolution was a favourite subject of GDRs historical literature or adventure stories, my father for example had to read a story about german general von Steuben in school, who fought for the US in the revolution. Also, many great leftist thinkers and many leftist ideas first emerged during the french revolution (althought according to Marx these guys were of course utopists and not really followers of modern communism).
Now, it was thus always clear to many, that the first french revolution, the bourgeois one, would eventually be followed by a second one, a socialist one. When they talk about the "second french revolution" and "finishing what they started" in the focus tree, they mean, that according to marxist interpretation of history, the first french revolution wanted to establish liberte, egalite, fraternite, but couldn´t because all they could do for now, was replace the old feudal order with a new bourgeois one. This new bourgeois order would allow for industrial capitalism to develop in france, which would create the social and economic material conditions under which a socialist revolution could and would happen, which would then finally succeed in achieving liberte, egalite, fraternite (or solidarite).
Many great socialist revolutionairies were thus often compared to french revolutionairies, many saw Lenin as a second Robbespierre for example. So yeah, this revolution in HoI is kinda inspired by the french one and robbespierre and shit, because according to marxists, a second revolution would eventually follow the first one and achieve, what they back then wanted to achieve but never could.
Paris commune wasn't the attempt of creating communist society in France, it was Parisians refusing to accept peace after they've lost Franco-Prussian war. The communist myth was created by the communists, so that they would have martyrs to honor. The government of commune actually was a bit leftist, but not communist.
It’s crazy how many people and different sub groups were inspired by revolutions in the two most powerful empires of the time. Without the French or American revolution you wouldn’t have the Russian and without the Russian you wouldn’t have the Chinese or Vietnamese revolutions. At least not under the socialist banner.
Best way to intervene as France in the civil war is to wait until the war in China to send an Attaché, which will bring you above the war support limit without tanking your stability with the intervention decisions
France is my favorite nation to play in hoi4 and I get directly involved in the Spanish civil war almost every time. I tend to play as an aggressive democratic powerhouse. It's super fun!
hi feedback, its me, the guy who tweeted at you saying you could join the war against nationalist spain 🗿
❤️😊❤️
Aaaah yes. My spies told me this was coming
Great stuff dave
😱🔎
Sending air volunteers to spain is the most op thing in hoi4. You can max your doctrines before 1938(also send to China yo max it quicker)
As Germany I love sending tac, cas, and fighters to China to fight Japan. Plus Spanish volunteers, I can have the whole air doctrine unlocked by like, 38-39
When Equestria at War? We are waiting. *angry boot tapping*
Hoof*
@@DaveFeedBackGaming
Oh crap, my bad
Another excellent video. You're quite funny. Many revolutions in France, but to be honest they were inspired by the American Revolution. But failed. Then 1789, 1830,1848, and some events like 1871...
For a second there, I could have sworn I was watching iSorrowProductions.
ifeedbackproductions
Perfect thumbnail, as always.
Imperfect perfection.
Agreed.
You have this set to unlisted
Shhhh
That double Irish whammy at the end was 😂
13:46 damn bro you did the irish dirty ☠️
That's very strange that paradox decided to give a boost to communist popularity by giving women the right to vote. In real life the french left was against giving women such a right because they were extremely conservative. When women obtained the right they indeed voted massively for the right and contributed a lot to De Gaulle's ascension
If anything, giving women the right to vote should result in a lower communist support
WOMEN
French commies during 20th century were weird.
I mean Engels wrote that women's liberation must go hand in hand with workers liberation.
i mean communist is very broad, in the modern day essentally all communists are progressive, but leftism advocates for equality so thats likely why
I never understood why “full desegregation” in America is locked behind 30% communism support. America pulled it off in real life with nothing even remotely close to that.
@@frozenflame5858 They didn't. USA isn't fully disegregated to this day.
I wish it was, but it just simply isn't.
I literally just abandoned a run when I was doing exactly that.
I abandoned because I was losing in game and I was having an ictus. I had no idea what i was doing.
WW2 endend in late '42 and a year later WW3 started with me against the soviets and all soviets spoils of war, including Italy and Germany (again)
I had no intention on hurting myself, so I simply left.
I do this path in non-hist mp and usually have like 60+ mills by the start of 1938
That 365 day strike triggers if you go popular front and don’t do matignon agreement fast enough
I just got this path, but was destroyed on 1940 in the Blietzkrieg :(
Theres something about this historical game of Kaiserreich thats throwing me off. Maybe its the fact that Kaiser Wilhelm II is being replaced by some guy I've never heard of? I'm going to have to pop open a thick history textbook for this one.
You need to try soviet union with Alexey rikov 0 consumer good, op industry and all the generala is so good bro
These thumbnails are getting better and better
When you take the focus "Ban the leagues" you don't get any of that violence event anymore.
I've done this path but for some reason I was not able to declare war on others without them producing world tension. Basically I was communist France but my war laws were like Democratic France. I dont understand why. It has to be a bug but if not I didn't see any reason for this so I haven't done this run in awhile because of that problem.
End up in the Allies?
@@johnnyboy95101 No. I was doing my own solo run and wasn't in any faction. I couldn't figure it out.
Superb thumbnail as usual
The operation causes a crash for you? I've yet to have a problem with the revolution ops, so I'm very interested in what the spaghetti code has done to you.
never seen a more historical game ever
Hey feedback gaming, can you make a video playing as non-aligned America? I found out you can play as royal america with mcAurthur in charge just by going to fascist route but not fully going fascist and staying non-aligned after the civil war!
The very minute feedback gaming said northen Island was British people where outside his door with ak 47s and uzis
You lied on the thumpnail xd. I took this focus as france in a multiplayerround
After La resistance this was the first path I did.
ohh men i love this bro a new inspiration on my gaming
💪❤️💪❤️💪❤️
The Louisiana Refund is definitely a cursed timeline.
Have you done a "the path nobody takes as the UK" because if not then I'd love to see it
SOON
@@DaveFeedBackGaming lets goooooo
I actually take that path pretty often. It’s my favorite path as France. I do it even in multiplayer.
Baaaaaased person
Hmm yes lore moment of the second french revolution
Can you do quick tutorial about how to win wars? and how to invade UK by sea\paratroopers? I have many hours in the game and i still don't know how to play
There isn't really much way to win Wars exept micro managment encirclement and to invade the uk just prepare everything before the war since they don't put their navy before and take a ship and look on the ports to see where they are the less guarded
Ireland taking NA was hilarious
that moment when the french leader changes 3 times
day 3 of waiting for Albania guide
lmao like this when you find out an unlisted video just got released to the public
Patreon heros
Great video
its the french commune kind of French Revolution
I actualy love that path
The video is SO MUCH BETTER on .75 speed he sounds SO WASTED it’s hilarious
feedbackgaming plays the game no one plays like
What do you mean no one takes this path, communist France is like the strongest France. With all the bonuses combined you get 35% defence on core territory, which is insane. Plus you lose disjointed gov quite quick and for some reason victors if great war
It is what it is. No 1 picks it cos it has no achievements and the operations cause the game to crash XD
@@DaveFeedBackGaming that's a huge shame tbh. My first playthrough (when i didn't have any dlc's) i roleplayed as trotsky with a "no annexation" rule, so every country had to be overthrown and join the comintern as a free nation (oh the lag) and these operations seem geared to that.
And the events in the 30s were taking inspiration from the great rev of 1791 but also from the 5 or 6 failrd revs france had in the 1800s, especially the 1871 paris commune, and the Russian rev.
“the irish have taken north america!”
*father coughlin joined the chat*
“they’re irish communists!”
*father coughlin has left the chat*
Is Democratic Japan on the list? That focus tree is interesting imo
We just gonna ignore liberia at the end there?
Show us how to make Holy Roman Empire as Germany Please 🥺🥺🥺
SOON
good ol' classic colonial bigrade
Ty for the video
❤️
why does his army group frontline look like that, and how do I make it look like that in my game?
Louisiana shoplift
As an Irish person, America for Northern Ireland is fair. (I'm irish but this is a joke - I have no opinion on pixelated land.)
I always intervene in the civil war and not get my own civil war even though i have political violence
Happens it's pretty RNG
@@DaveFeedBackGaming not really. I found a way to intervene in the war and avoid the civil war without any risks or shenanigans.
1. Don't bother with removing the political violence it's a waste of time
2. Instead do woman suffrage and reform the labor laws as quickly as possible
3. Never pick a decision that lowers the stability
4. Click the allow covert intervention and arm purchase
And you will end up with enough war support and stability to intervene and avoid civil war. Also always chose to aid the Republicans when they ask because the extra communist support mean you can skip strengthen the union and celebrate the community.
Very nice
ah yes, 9:22 "religious zeal" *points at revolutionary zeal*, you got a, problem, because this keeps happening all the time,
REVOLUTION FOR EVERYTHING
you can't not assume hoi4 players love strategy
I assume you like exploits
@@DaveFeedBackGaming obviously :)
The flag on the title Is not the surrender flag but the french monarchist flags with the "fleur de lys" if anyone talk about it, feed back Saïd it so dont take it Bad
🔎👍
Love the joke at the end! Great video.
feedbackgaming is so cool
❤️😊💪
Beautiful thumbail😯👌👌👌
🇫🇷🥖
The absolute disappointment with paradox not doing qa testing and making sure the mechanics work, WHY WOULD THE OPERATIONS CRASH THE GAME, I've played this path before and that felt like a slap to the face la resistance costs like 20 fucking dollars
“It crashes the game” and they STILL haven’t fixed it? Ofc lmao fucking pdx
That was wild🙃
Window xp
Thank you
copied this exactly and so far 7 out of 7 times civil war has started during my war with spain...
Same here, I can even get to a fully communist France but my stability is only 15 by that point and the civil war fires almost immediately
Mfw when that’s my favorite French path… oh god lmao I’m being called out
chosing france is already a path nobody does
Do you use any mods if yes what?
I think no one takes that path because Napoleon is the best path for France, also no achievements for it lmao
Very true
Imagine if irl worked like hoi4, there would just be emperor Dave the great of earth
And that would happen within like 4 years
BASED
As an American I'm happy with being part of Ireland.
I never took The Orleans Path
I’m from Louisiana and I have to say 😊
Wait, you mean the path France take every single time you toggle off historical?
Nobody? Everyone and their mother does this path, it's the best
👏👍
It would have been hilarious if you'd given the whole UK to the Irish.
I just sneezed
Wow this path is broken
Too true
I actually take this pass
I have a very bad feeling about the white flag in the title
French monarchist flag 😑
It was going so well until borders
Out of interest, why cancel the ships in progress if you have the resources to make them without needing to trade? Is it just the hassle of allocating them?
__________________
Personally, I think that man the guns just made the naval side even less intelligent, although in a multiplayer environment I can see it adding an additional element.
Less micro and more convoys
France is the only nation I'd do that with, as they are chronically short on manpower (depending on path taken) and fuel, I even delete some of the starting ships such as the manpower hungry aircraft carrier, an easy 10k or so manpower back
Generally though if it's got at least 10% progress it's probably best to let it complete
The French were actually the first to have a communist revolution in the form of the Paris commune.
Did ISP get subtly get embedded in this video???
Only the UK operation seems to crash the game, the others work fine. The Spanish one is a bit strange, I did it and the new communists won but when the war ended the Republicans were still in power like nothing happened.
You can’t have Northern Ireland tho 😂 sensational
Viva Le Anarchy