Optifine vs Sodium vs Vulkan Renderer vs Vanilla | Benchmark

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 130

  • @CaHe4ka123
    @CaHe4ka123 Рік тому +176

    Vulkan is faster than OpenGL because its new gen of graphics API which more low-level and have async command queues when OpenGL works only in single thread
    Additionally Vulkan uses much less CPU then OpenGL
    If Minecraft devs will add native Vulkan API support I think it will boost performance
    But now we have only one mod which written in Java and as a result we still have low performance because its mod
    Its not a native Vulkan API support

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +14

      yeah

    • @aetimes2
      @aetimes2 Рік тому +25

      What you said is partially true, but the reason it would be faster is not because it wouldn't be a mod, but because it would be better developed with the power of the full Mojang team. Both the mod and Minecraft are written in Java. This mod is literally replacing the Minecraft renderer. The only overhead from it being a mod is on startup

    • @emperorgalaxy4495
      @emperorgalaxy4495 Рік тому +1

      ​@@aetimes2It will be possible to add RTX.
      And everything else can also be optimized over time for several processor cores. Sorry for mistakes, my English is bad

    • @aetimes2
      @aetimes2 Рік тому +1

      @@emperorgalaxy4495 Adding shader support (including raytracing/rtx shaders) and optimization is definitely something VulkanMod is working on (and something that has been done by the community before with Sodium and Iris for OpenGL)

    • @emperorgalaxy4495
      @emperorgalaxy4495 Рік тому +2

      @@aetimes2 Interestingly, and mojangs will be interested in acquiring this mod, it was very cool because this mod would give not only RTX but also a new generation of shaders.

  • @thisfeatureisbad
    @thisfeatureisbad Рік тому +32

    Honestly, this is just incredible. Imagine if Mojang had changed their rendering engine. I'm afraid they would need to redo the whole game including the mod loaders changing their API. But so far, this is a giant leap for the modding community. My Ryzen 5 2600 can finally have a bit of rest while playing Minecraft and rather let my GTX 1650 struggle. Steam Deck can definitely take this huge advantage over Vulkan.

    • @sv69n
      @sv69n 2 місяці тому +2

      redoing the entire game is too much for mojang since they add like 1 thing every 3 months

  • @heroes-of-balkan
    @heroes-of-balkan 8 місяців тому +10

    Considering Vulkan Renderer is still in alpha and how hard is it to write a Vulkan program (let alone rewrite existing OpenGL), I can only say I'm impressed!

  • @SyntaxDaemon
    @SyntaxDaemon Рік тому +71

    I notice Optifine stuttering a lot, even more than vanilla. :O

    • @Nafiur13
      @Nafiur13 Рік тому

      Settings?

    • @thisfeatureisbad
      @thisfeatureisbad Рік тому +16

      Yeah. OptiFine is no longer your #1 option to optimize your game anymore. The Sodium became a new OptiFine. The only thing I don't like is that the OpenGL is being used as it's single-threaded and pretty outdated. Imagine if Vulkan's graphics API was baked into the game by Mojang. Of course, the compatibility would be an issue for some older systems, but the CPU would be less stressed out.

    • @v-14415
      @v-14415 11 місяців тому +4

      For me Optifine is still getting more fps than Vanilla and Sodikm, it's different for everyone.

    • @zakariya2011_
      @zakariya2011_ 9 місяців тому +2

      It’s simply because in 1.19.4 mojang actually improved the game’s perforemance while optifine was stuck using the slow forge

    • @SyntaxDaemon
      @SyntaxDaemon 9 місяців тому +4

      @@zakariya2011_ Optifine doesn't require or use forge. Forge can load it but that's different.

  • @rhmbwt
    @rhmbwt 5 місяців тому +5

    Vulkan power usage is significanly lower than optifine while delivering the same performance thats impressive

    • @arnetes
      @arnetes 5 місяців тому +2

      nah it isnt vulkan always better

  • @eineatombombe
    @eineatombombe Рік тому +10

    The mods you showcased optimize minecraft's rendering, so what's the point in showing world creation and launching the game

  • @Aboody
    @Aboody  Рік тому +4

    Hello! If you have any Videos ideas, I would greatly appreciate it if you could share them with me. Thank you!🤭

  • @NeuroatypiqueGDMC
    @NeuroatypiqueGDMC 8 місяців тому +2

    Finely, A benchmark !
    Imagine Vulkan and Sodium port O_O (+nvidium for nvidia users)

    • @ncredibledark7926
      @ncredibledark7926 Місяць тому

      Vulkan and Sodium together cannot and will never happen

  • @alihene2225
    @alihene2225 Рік тому +15

    I haven't read the code of vulkan mod but vulkan can only get you so far in terms of performance if you don't use it for performance. It is also easy to mess up (accidentally setting a buffer to host visible, for example) which can easily lead to performance losses. Sodium also optimises other parts of the game, not necessarily the graphics. The two mods have a somewhat different purpose and vulkan mod (assuming the use of vulkan is correct) would absolutely provide a far greater performance increase.

  • @drawerganizer785
    @drawerganizer785 10 місяців тому +6

    The vulkan renderer has fewer glitches with transparent textures and renders the shading on dirt paths correctly. In my case (integrated amd graphics, linux/wayland) sodium still gets better performance (even though a lot of people report the vulkan renderer beats sodium in their case), but vulkan is still leaps and bounds better than vanilla. I use the Vulkan renderer because the performance is good enough and it doesn't have the glitches sodium does.

  • @ShadyHero
    @ShadyHero 5 місяців тому +2

    crazy that optifine is actively less stable than vanilla now

  • @urisinger3412
    @urisinger3412 2 місяці тому +3

    Vulkan is still really unoptimized

  • @lowerding
    @lowerding 4 місяці тому +3

    Thanks to vulkan renderer i can even play smoother on my phone

  • @jensenthegreen6780
    @jensenthegreen6780 Рік тому +2

    Not going to lie every new version i keep praying mojang will add LOD to Java and give each version Vulkan renderer, That would make porting mods to that new version absolutely hellish, But i think it would be worth it for the sake of performance.

  • @myo1490
    @myo1490 2 місяці тому +2

    Great choice in music~ It brought me memories from PC Building Sim XD
    I'll have to try Vulkan and compare it to Sodium in my gear.... Thanks for the video!

  • @dragzcraft123
    @dragzcraft123 Рік тому +3

    The time between lags when I use vulkan is longest (1h or even longer) =))

  • @Ibrahimahmed79961
    @Ibrahimahmed79961 Місяць тому +1

    considering most mod are using openGL i would stick to sodium as vulkan is still in alpha

  • @someone4229
    @someone4229 8 місяців тому +1

    In my experience, sodium has a lot of tiny lag spikes but vulkan is really smooth. Fps is slightly lower than sodium, but i don't need 500fps so i'm going with vulkan.

    • @myo1490
      @myo1490 2 місяці тому

      This.
      I have other performance mods aside from sodium but it sometimes stutters despite the high fps count... but with vulkan is all the opposite, it's so smooth and plays more fluently...
      Sad that it isn't compatible with some mods and crashes from time to time.

  • @LgdFanta
    @LgdFanta Рік тому +2

    I use Vulkan Zink on PojavLauncher and its crazy how fast mc 1.20.1 lauch even tho im using a device that should not be able to support versions above 1.12.2 im getting 32fps but its still good

  • @NitinTechtips21
    @NitinTechtips21 7 місяців тому

    All these fps doesn't matter if the monitor doesn't support that much refresh rate. And it causes screen tearing which looks ugly(turn on v-sync for once and you will feel the difference). Even though I run minecraft with a lot of optimization mods(35), I always have v-sync enabled

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  6 місяців тому +2

      idk for me i fell the game fell more responsive on v-sync disabled and the tearing issue i have never seen it on Minecraft

    • @TL_HISOKA
      @TL_HISOKA 2 місяці тому

      Does extra fps uses more power ( here extra means more than our refresh rate support )

    • @MatuMatUu
      @MatuMatUu 23 дні тому +1

      Are you aware of the stupidity you just said?

  • @Avexiron
    @Avexiron 5 місяців тому +1

    this is great thank u SODIUM THE GOAT

  • @freefireindiaofficial6441
    @freefireindiaofficial6441 3 місяці тому +1

    I tested vulkan with few optimisaion mod while i was getting 90 fps in sodium i got 500 in vulkan with exact same settings ( in low end laptop ) (mods i used were modern fix with few cosmetics mod)

  • @gumiho.c
    @gumiho.c 8 місяців тому +1

    the avarages are cleary wrong, you didn't reset the benchmark before recording, sodium stayed above 700 fps most of the time and somehow got an avarage of 300

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  8 місяців тому +1

      👍👍

  • @basedlocation3738
    @basedlocation3738 Рік тому +7

    Bro can u make more videos.
    Make similar videos with comparison.

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +2

      Thank you for the motivation!
      I can, but I have school and other life responsibilities that leave me with very little time to work on UA-cam videos.

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      This video took me like 9 hours to finish. The recording was easy, but the editing was hard. At first, I was editing on Sony Vegas, but it crashed for no reason. The sad part is that I didn't save my work, and I had to start again. So, I switched programs and went with Adobe Premiere Pro, but it took me longer to edit because I'm not used to the software. In the end, I completed this video. If it wasn't the weekend, I don't think I would have finished this video.

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      If you have any Videos ideas, I would greatly appreciate it if you could share them with me.🤭

  • @Clyde6790pYoutube
    @Clyde6790pYoutube Рік тому +4

    what fps counter did you use? It looks better than my current one

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +4

      MSI Afterburner RivaTuner OverlayEditor.dll Plugin search it up on youtube you will find some tutorials

  • @iLokas_
    @iLokas_ Рік тому +2

    How the clock of rx 570 is 1340mhz and in the AMD web it says boost clock is 1244????

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +2

      you can overclock the speed in the AMD Software :)

    • @iLokas_
      @iLokas_ Рік тому

      Your Gpu model is Sapphire NITRO+ RX 570 8 GB
      ?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому

      yeah how did you know xD "its the 4gb ver"@@iLokas_

    • @iLokas_
      @iLokas_ Рік тому +1

      @@Aboody its obvious from the clock speed

  • @GlitchPG3D
    @GlitchPG3D 5 місяців тому +1

    I have a question, So I run my Minecraft on most of the default settings but configured it in a way where I get good FPS and still can maintain good settings (Running 16-20 chunks rendering and simulation distance, Fancy graphics and everything on like that but I have smooth lighting at the max, Which I usually have at minimum) I was wondering why You are getting that high FPS with Sodium, I have it too; I also compared all the mods just last week looking at how they preform and Your FPS for Sodium stood out for me because I get around 700 at the max and 350-600 looking anywhere else. I have an RTX 3070ti, 32GB of some Corsair or something like that ram and an I9 11 gen I think, I also have my ram allocated high like 8 GB allocated to Minecraft, I can change it but my FPS isn’t high like yours. If I run shaders I use most of the default settings for it but change the rendering to FXAA2 and use my shadow quality at 1.5, I also have another one changed but I don’t have my PC at the moment but I think it’s something with the sharpness of the blocks. I changed that because I tried using a few shaders and it was kind of Blurry when I was looking around and everything was a bit soft or fuzzy looking so I changed it. I run Bliss or Chocapic or some other ones like seus but I just want an FPS over 150 or 200 because I can play on Hypixel and be in a lobby with shaders and be sitting at a comfortable 120-150 fps, with 30-50 players and somehow my FPS is at 125 or less in single player. Do you know how to fix that or anything that can prevent or do anything about it? I can list my settings once I get back to my PC and check everything. I use Sodium most of the time because I like some options but I like Optifine too, More settings and a few cool features. Vulkan is nice because I tried running 32ish chunks or around there and most of my settings were maxed and still got about 90 fps on average, I noticed a few lag spikes though they were occurring a bit often.

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  5 місяців тому +1

      I think 700-300 is fine for 16-20 chunks. In the video, I was using the default, I think it was 12, so that could be it. Or maybe.... I guess you can try updating your graphics card drivers or allocating less RAM to Minecraft cuz In my test video, I gave Minecraft only 4GB. You could also try closing some background apps, but I don't think that's the problem because you said you have 32GB of RAM, so that's a maybe. Or you could check your CPU and GPU temperatures; maybe your CPU needs new paste, which could impact performance. Also, keep in mind that the FPS test in my video was done at 1080p resolution. If you're playing at a higher resolution, that could be impacting your FPS too. Hope this helps!

    • @GlitchPG3D
      @GlitchPG3D 5 місяців тому

      @@Aboody thank you, my drivers are up to date on my 3070 ti, I allocated about 4.1 GB to Minecraft, it runs 1080P all the time and the temps hover around 55-60c and everything seems to be fine. My CPU fans werent working yesterday so I booted into BIOS and my AMI popup said that it detected no fan movement so I cleaned out my pc today, it runs a bit cooler but FPS stay the same. I use a couple different shaders like Bliss and Sildurs and a few others but I’m eating now, I set my render distance to 8-12 and got 1600 fps with no shaders but shaders just pulls my FPS down alot. I’ll try some more stuff, Thanks very much!

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  5 місяців тому

      ​@@GlitchPG3D here is my fps with shaders if you interested : ua-cam.com/video/q-CbxwhETbo/v-deo.html

  • @hunt8709
    @hunt8709 Рік тому +6

    depends on pc, optifine is more performance for me

  • @tjonesy2283
    @tjonesy2283 Рік тому +2

    I don’t understand where your fps is coming from? I have a r5 5600x and my frame rate in vanilla and sodium are no where close

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      I encountered the same issue when I first got my PC. The Task Manager was indicating that I only had 2 cores and only 6 threads, which worried me because I had saved up a lot of money for this PC. However, after installing the motherboard software, I discovered an option to enable all the cores and the threads.
      It might not be the same issue, but it's worth noting that the AMD Ryzen 5 5600X is generally considered superior to the Ryzen 5 5500. I would recommend conducting thorough research on the internet to gather more information about their respective performances. In my personal experience, I was able to resolve my problem by seeking help from the PC Part Picker Discord community, which has a supportive and knowledgeable user base.
      If you need any assistance, feel free to contact me on Discord. I'd be happy to help you with any questions or issues you may have. "Aboodi#4144" 😊

    • @tjonesy2283
      @tjonesy2283 Рік тому

      @@Aboody Thank you but regarding if my cpu was not using all the cores and threads it has (it is) it still would not matter as Minecraft only uses one core to run the game, this is why the 13600k runs the game much better because it has better single core performance even though the two chips perform the same on other games

    • @tjonesy2283
      @tjonesy2283 Рік тому

      I’ve chosen to upgrade my 3060ti to a 4070ti to help with shaders I think this was the root of my problem

    • @Cyber_Monke
      @Cyber_Monke Рік тому +3

      @@tjonesy2283 My GPU isn't even a 3060, but I play with moderately heavy shaders and Vivecraft Mod and still maintain enough FPS where my refresh rate prevents me from getting more, but optimization is very important

  • @inconnn
    @inconnn Рік тому +8

    for me on the latest version of sodium and vulkanmod as of july 2023, vulkan mod was better. i could play with 32 chunk render distance at 1440p and consistently get 165fps, which is my monitor hz. sodium could only hit around 115-119 at 32 chunk render distance.
    this is on an amd 7900x w/ an nvidia rtx 3070 on linux.
    i did have vsync on

    • @orcvs6297
      @orcvs6297 9 місяців тому

      noted thank you

    • @edc324
      @edc324 9 місяців тому

      for me its like 800 fps with 32 chunks 1080 with sodium and ~450 fps with vulkan (both using gtx 1650 and win 10)

  • @CNG.I
    @CNG.I Рік тому +1

    شكرًا ❤

  • @Israelfuckedup
    @Israelfuckedup Рік тому

    Vanilla performance has improved

  • @ii2yman
    @ii2yman Рік тому +2

    Thx for helping

  • @نواردرويش-ذ4ي
    @نواردرويش-ذ4ي Рік тому +2

    بالله عليك نزل نفس هل فيديو بس مقارنة sodium vs optifine في الshaders

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      على طريق

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +2

      Go watch it its ready

  • @elotkarloketh166
    @elotkarloketh166 Рік тому

    What about Optifine with optimal settings? Some settings have huge effect to performance

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      I didn't change anything I use the preset settings

    • @capofantasma97
      @capofantasma97 11 місяців тому

      Optifine is not optimal in the first place. If you want performance, you have to look into Sodium, Starlight, Nvidium, C2ME, Enhanced Block Entities, ModernFix, LazyDFU.

    • @RryhhbfrHhgdHhgd356
      @RryhhbfrHhgdHhgd356 7 місяців тому

      Finding the optimal settings for Optifine in my experience is a heckish trial and error experience that I would rather not go through the effort for alas. I am sure it can get there. I just don’t have the patience personally.

  • @angelvrkunv7872
    @angelvrkunv7872 3 місяці тому +2

    Actualmente optiffine no sirve para nada

  • @wolteron494
    @wolteron494 9 місяців тому +1

    Is rubidium for forge the same as sodium?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  9 місяців тому +2

      i think its just a fork of sodium so yes its sodium for forge. (not sure)

    • @wolteron494
      @wolteron494 9 місяців тому

      @@Aboody thanks

  • @nicocraft31
    @nicocraft31 Рік тому

    My like was number 100. ;D

  • @arnetes
    @arnetes 5 місяців тому +3

    why tf is vanilla winning :((

  • @averageyoutubehandle497
    @averageyoutubehandle497 8 місяців тому

    I dunno man for me vulkan gets more fps than sodium (way more) and around the same as sodium with a ton of others.

  • @RylanPlayzYT1234
    @RylanPlayzYT1234 22 дні тому

    this isntt really a fair test, ofc sodium is bbetter here, the rx 570 is not good for vulkan as its more of a legacy gpu

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  20 днів тому

      Still a Test tho

    • @RylanPlayzYT1234
      @RylanPlayzYT1234 20 днів тому

      @@Aboody true, but atleast use an rx 7600

  • @ItsOnlyMe360
    @ItsOnlyMe360 Рік тому

    Sodium that is better than Optifine that is better than Vulkan that is better than Vanilla OpenGL

  • @moonyl5341
    @moonyl5341 8 місяців тому +1

    music?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  8 місяців тому +1

      Music : A Thousand GigaFLOPs Without You - C.P.U

  • @Avexiron
    @Avexiron 5 місяців тому +1

    can you use vulkan and sodium at the same time?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  5 місяців тому +1

      No, I don't think so because Sodium, it's his job to optimize the OpenGL rendering, and Vulkan is not the same as OpenGL, so no. But perhaps in the future, we'll see this happen.

    • @Avexiron
      @Avexiron 5 місяців тому +1

      @@Aboody oh ok thanks

  • @TypicalDaveMC
    @TypicalDaveMC Рік тому +2

    What is the song?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +3

      A Thousand GigaFLOPs Without You - C.P.U

    • @TypicalDaveMC
      @TypicalDaveMC Рік тому

      @@Aboody Ok thank you!! :)

    • @IVTMOFFICIAL
      @IVTMOFFICIAL Рік тому

      ​@@Aboody PC BUILDING SIM song

  • @VerbraucherYT
    @VerbraucherYT 8 місяців тому

    Use Vulkan and Sodium huge fps 😉

  • @IamFrost
    @IamFrost Рік тому +2

    You get worse performance on vulkan because you are using AND gpu

  • @fantik3848
    @fantik3848 6 днів тому

    вулкан 1000 фпс
    содиум 400 фпс

  • @Xrizzii
    @Xrizzii Рік тому +2

    which is best for low end pc

  • @iLokas_
    @iLokas_ Рік тому +1

    How to play sodium?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому

      If you want to use Sodium without any hassle, make sure you've got the most up-to-date version of Fabric Loader and Fabric API set up first. Once that's done, it's as easy as pie - just drop the mod right into your mods folder. No need to worry about any extra downloads or mods, Sodium's got you covered!🐧🐧

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      Or you can search for it on UA-cam; there are plenty of tutorials available there!

    • @iLokas_
      @iLokas_ Рік тому

      I recommend to make a video explain how to play sodium starts with the client and end to the lunch or just till me wich client should i use to give me the best Performance cuz i watched Several videos and all of them make the game dorps to 10 to 17 Fps without the sodium i get round solid 80 to 90Fps 🦆

  • @apalu9839
    @apalu9839 25 днів тому +1

    Plis link download sodium

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  23 дні тому

      modrinth.com/mod/sodium

  • @kquack
    @kquack 8 місяців тому

    what's with the dramatic ahh music bro

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  7 місяців тому

      no idea 😂

  • @rch5395
    @rch5395 Рік тому +1

    where rubidium at?

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +2

      Rubidium is an unofficial fork of "Sodium," crafted to seamlessly work with Forge Mod Loader. It can be seen as Sodium with a touch of enhancement, optimizing the overall experience for Forge users. 😊

    • @rch5395
      @rch5395 Рік тому +1

      @@Aboody I know I'm just curious to see if there is s significant performance difference between sodium and rubidium.

    • @thisfeatureisbad
      @thisfeatureisbad Рік тому

      @@rch5395 I wouldn't say it's not really different apart from the API, since it's Forge.

  • @Jackpot7z
    @Jackpot7z Рік тому

    Try Cubed Optimized

    • @Aboody
      @Aboody  Рік тому +1

      I'm not quite sure where I can find this mod. I tried searching it up on Google, but it seems like I got results for something else instead☹️.

    • @Jackpot7z
      @Jackpot7z Рік тому +1

      @@Aboody it's a modpack, you can find it con curseforge as "Cubed Optimized FPS", I found it better than faboulously optimized

  • @golimonkey
    @golimonkey Рік тому

    optifine lags pretty bad

    • @LgdFanta
      @LgdFanta Рік тому

      latest versions do, but trust me the 1.12.2 latest preview optifine is op you dont have to change anything to get over 1000fps