Swarbrick is worried about weather intensity while Kiwis freeze and lose their jobs due to energy shortages cause they their oil and gas ban and the closure of Marsden Point. They don't mind flying all over the world and burning jet fuel.
Swarbrick is illogical and hysterical and desperate… clutching at straws to seem relevant. She knows at heart she’s a joke…look at her delivery…she doesn’t believe what she’s parroting…she’s just reciting it for her pay. As for Hipkins..he’s a school boy.
They are deluded to be wearing garments that have such hateful agenda tied to them. If they only researched the truth, and knew what would happen to them if they were put in the centre of Gaza. Do they think they'd be treated with love and kindness? I can't understand the Greens attitude to the reality of "antisemitism and that children of Gaza are taught to kill and hate from such a young age. The speaker of the house needs to maintain some order of what outfits are allowed in Parliament.
I think her choice of scarf (probably shoplifted of course) would suggest she is pro-Hamas. She's demonstrating her stupidity because Hamas and Palestine would probably stone her to death if they had the opportunity - Gays for Palestine - ah ha ha, she is simply too stupid.
We should ask them all how the most secure nation in the world allowed people on mopeds and parachutes to enter their country on mass and murder and kidnap civilians....
David Seymour is absolutely right. Climate change is huge, and tiny New Zealand with one-tenth of one percent of global emissions cannot possibly influence it one way or the other. Instead of 'tilting at windmills' and screwing up our economy and energy supply, we should be putting our money into adapting to climate change rather than trying to stop the un-stoppable.
Accelerated climate change is what we are currently experiencing. Reducing the production of CO2 will slow down that acceleration. We all live on the same planet so if we are generating one tenth of one percent of global emissions then we need to take responsibility for it and reduce it. Aotearoa has a history of leading the way on important issues which have caught on internationally. Women's right to vote is a great example of our ability to influence others. Furthermore, our demand for goods by larger, poorer countries who produce those goods increases the CO2 generation by those places. Therefore, we actually have a greater hidden CO2 emission than what we record and we should take greater responsibility than one tenth of one percent of global emissions. If we try and adapt, we will fail because once we finally adapt to what climate change is now, it will have gotten much worse. We cannot keep up with the rate at which the climate is changing.
@icehawke543 Sorry, mate, but we can make no measurable difference. As long as China and India continue to commission hundreds of new coal-fired power plants each year, they will offset our annual savings in a day. All we are doing is "being seen to be doing something," and frankly, I am not willing to damage our economy, tax ourselves to death (like that moron Trudeau in Canada), and publicly flagellate ourselves just to make a show. It just isn't worth it.
JERRY you need to stop those people wearing those tablecloths in parliament. They can wear them outside in their own time but never in parliament. We need to support ISRAEL 😊
@@janetihaka799 Educate yourself about the conflict and stop embarrassing yourself with your ignorance. Agreed I can't stand either but your lack of knowledge regards this subject is laughable............lol.
@@novak7970 no. Hamas started this round with the murdering and kidnapping of innocent people. They build armery storage tunnels under strategic hospital and social community sites and the people living there let them. I think you would think very differently if the problem was here. Hamas and Islamic terrorists have caused this round. Then they cry genecide to capture the world's pity. I'm not buying any of it, I feel truely sad for all the innocent lives on both sides. I abhor war. But put the blame where it belongs. I don't codon terrorism of any kind.
Chloe just can't get it through her thick head, if you import coal, or you use your own coal, it still has emissions, but the imported coal has worse emissions, the overseas coal also has to be shipped here, with a higher Carbon footprint,, A real Nimby
The questions from the opposition show how ignorant and uneducated they are, wasting our time and money. We need to change the rules around who can be a politician. Only educated folk with suitable qualifications should be charged with running our affairs correctly and professionally with the same level of accountability as directors of public companies.
no domestic gas or fuel Chloe so we rely on imported fuel.What happens if there’s a problem in the northern hemisphere ( like war ) and we can’t get supply anymore.So stupid to burn our bridges locally.How relevant will green house gas BS be if this happens and people starve here.
They don't need them... they only talk the talk... they would never walk the walk. Swarbrick can't even keep herself off of jet planes and if she knew what "Palestinian liberation" really was... she would RUN.
Emissions IN New Zealand, emitted FROM New Zealand do not mean weather intensity and severity IN New Zealand. It's in the last IPCC report, big section on regional impacts. It doesn't happen in that mechanical, directly attributable way because the emissions are global, the atmosphere doesn't give a rat's bunghole where they come from, the emissions and the atmospheric effect is at global level - eg average 2% temp rise. The variegation in local effects is from the global levels / concentrations, and local dynamics. NZ has El Nino / La Nina, for example. Some regional variation means more storms, more rain, or more droughts. But NZ emissions DO NOT equal localised, short-term weather effects. This is like a child's conception of karma, or providence. The science is more complicated, but makes far more sense. In NZ went to zero emissions tomorrow, which is a bad idea, we would still face adverse weather effects due to unabated emissions in the northern hemisphere in particular. That's where the problem is.
Over the "point 9f orders" ..is the opposition going for a world record on how many they can raise.. or just acting like sulky kids when they don't like an answer.
It's pro Palestinian clothing that says she supports the murder and mutilation of Israelis on Oct 7th 2023.....and is totally ignorant of the fact that she would be killed for being lesbian and an outspoken woman. Send her to Gaza, if she's so sure of herself and has such care for terrorists. The speaker of the house needs to put his house in order.
0:15 By renewable, I presume you mean weather-dependent and intermittent. Why would we want that, Mr Luxon? Can't you see what is happening to the Australians?
The crybaby says increasing greenhouse gas increases the frequency and intensity of devastating weather events. Do they? Compare to 2014, there has been a drop in CO2 emmision per person world-wide. How to explain that?
Will always entertain me how all i ever hear these people talk about is "new zealand needs this, this, that, and this" to pull at the hopeful heartstrings of people who would want such things realized, in a bid for support knowing full well they are things they will never receive. Year after year.
Green house gases least of your problems Wind , water you get very limited sun Waste of time arguing over frivolous things shunting each other childish
Its not greenhouse gasses that cause weather events, its all the weather modification techniques which are now widley acknowledged. Im dissapointed in Luxon respoding with a Yes to her question on greenhouse gasses...
Has Swarbrick and her communist cohorts ever been to Palestine or better still - lived in Palestine amongst terrorists ? This girl has lived a privileged life and lacks for nothing! Easy to criticise from the safety of your parliament privileged seat! If your family was massacred by terrorists would you just sit there and do nothing? Talk to your “friends” the Poms whose politician Lord Balfour sipped on a gin bottle and smoked cigars - while he drew borders in the Middle East - oblivious and couldn’t care where the borders should be after the demise of the Ottoman Empire! The Poms are to blame like soo much else in the world. Ask them!
Can someone educate me... is there any clear evidence that greenhouse gases does make the weather worse? The reason I ask is there has been many times people have said that, and then you look at the rainfall stats and weather reports going back a hundred years or so and find it's all rubbish.
The argument here isn't if climate change is real. It is real. The argument is how to try and fix or mitigate it. Shipping in foreign coal is worse for the world's environment than digging it up locally. Common sense, surely?
Suppose the people have to suffer thru a decade of dumb during the good times so that things can get so bad thru complacency that any common sense or nouse seems like wit in comparison to none...what a low bar/no wonder we are so far in arrears. The end of the beginning ffs...Long way to go to modernize at this rate we need more workers and less consumers somehow...the workers we have are exhausted.
Swarbrick is worried about weather intensity while Kiwis freeze and lose their jobs due to energy shortages cause they their oil and gas ban and the closure of Marsden Point. They don't mind flying all over the world and burning jet fuel.
The greens have the most efficient planning. The loose fitting table cloths conceal both shoplifting and shirtlifting.
They also show their support towards their fellow terrorists.
Swarbrick and her cohorts should be fined for wearing Hamas scarves. My taxes pay her salary. If they feel so strongly about Palestine, just go there
Where are we with that, because I was led to believe that MPs are no longer civil servants ?
Absolutely appalling behavior by Swarbrick. She's a posturing nobody
Swarbrick is illogical and hysterical and desperate… clutching at straws to seem relevant.
She knows at heart she’s a joke…look at her delivery…she doesn’t believe what she’s parroting…she’s just reciting it for her pay.
As for Hipkins..he’s a school boy.
she's not the smartest is she?
The adults are in charge now Chloe , sit down and stop wasting our taxes
And someone please just get her to shut her stupid mouth.
That women child Swarbrick has been living on the high life to long and doesn't know how real life is for the rest of us...
Need coal, oil and gas to make real money to rebuild the economy.
LOL!!
They should take their tablecloths off.. a bloody disgrace to Parliament!!! Time some rules were changed!!!!!!!
Where is Speaker? Impose some rules!
TRUE ! 😂😅😂
Yeh, I wrote to him, he is weak! I like debates, he is the worst speaker I've heard! These peo0le are running the country! Why should NZ tremble!?😢😢
You are offended by someone wearing essentially a scarf? How is it a disgrace to parliament? PC gone mad..
@@icehawke543and what do the scarfs symbolise? Any idea?
Swarbrick needs to clean up her party before attacking others.
Chippy your mum is calling you! You need your afternoon sleep and she has a sandwich and a glass of orange for you
More likely a sausage roll, but wonder if Cis Duncekins realises his mother might be a woman
Does he know what a mother is?
Hahaha awesome
@@robf1862 his mum would be a they/them
He's had enough orange, I think.
They should not be allowed to wear the Keffiyeh while in parliament , if they want to wear it on their OWN time so be it .
treason in my book, supporting and promoting a terrorist organisation to the world
They are deluded to be wearing garments that have such hateful agenda tied to them.
If they only researched the truth, and knew what would happen to them if they were put in the centre of Gaza. Do they think they'd be treated with love and kindness?
I can't understand the Greens attitude to the reality of "antisemitism and that children of Gaza are taught to kill and hate from such a young age.
The speaker of the house needs to maintain some order of what outfits are allowed in Parliament.
Correct 💯
Could you ask swarbrick , what did she think of the attack , murders, butchering ,torture on Israel and does she want the hostages returned?
She has answered that question by wearing the satanic tea towel and her river to the sea screeching. She/it doesn't care.
I think her choice of scarf (probably shoplifted of course) would suggest she is pro-Hamas. She's demonstrating her stupidity because Hamas and Palestine would probably stone her to death if they had the opportunity - Gays for Palestine - ah ha ha, she is simply too stupid.
We should ask them all how the most secure nation in the world allowed people on mopeds and parachutes to enter their country on mass and murder and kidnap civilians....
Speaker of the house needs to enforce dress standards.
Twice as much rain feel in 1929. Sorry Chloe.
David Seymour is absolutely right. Climate change is huge, and tiny New Zealand with one-tenth of one percent of global emissions cannot possibly influence it one way or the other. Instead of 'tilting at windmills' and screwing up our economy and energy supply, we should be putting our money into adapting to climate change rather than trying to stop the un-stoppable.
Accelerated climate change is what we are currently experiencing. Reducing the production of CO2 will slow down that acceleration. We all live on the same planet so if we are generating one tenth of one percent of global emissions then we need to take responsibility for it and reduce it. Aotearoa has a history of leading the way on important issues which have caught on internationally. Women's right to vote is a great example of our ability to influence others. Furthermore, our demand for goods by larger, poorer countries who produce those goods increases the CO2 generation by those places. Therefore, we actually have a greater hidden CO2 emission than what we record and we should take greater responsibility than one tenth of one percent of global emissions. If we try and adapt, we will fail because once we finally adapt to what climate change is now, it will have gotten much worse. We cannot keep up with the rate at which the climate is changing.
Climate cultists should just remove themselves from the non occurrence so their virtue signalling can be noted for future humans to laugh at 😅
@icehawke543 Sorry, mate, but we can make no measurable difference. As long as China and India continue to commission hundreds of new coal-fired power plants each year, they will offset our annual savings in a day. All we are doing is "being seen to be doing something," and frankly, I am not willing to damage our economy, tax ourselves to death (like that moron Trudeau in Canada), and publicly flagellate ourselves just to make a show. It just isn't worth it.
What a disgrace...if they feel so strongly about Pelestine, eff off over there a be human shields for Hezbollah....FFS.
Hopkins and SWarbrick are clueless
They look ridiculous wearing those scarfs
I thought it was there table cloths it does look stupid but it is the greens a bunch of crazys.
Cause they are ridiculous
worry about urself
@@Givito-xs4sxwe are.
Attention seekers they are
and we pay for these puppets wake up people
Its great to have a sane government for once
Lets get our mines busy and add jobs to the economy
like that scene from lotr when they build isengard!
Yes, let's get drilling and digging soonest. God knows we need to.
Send the greens and labour to Afghanistan
Keep talking Chloe. Best way to keep you out of winning an election.
The circus continues and today the clowns are performing
I notice the greens are even wearing arabic scarfs
@@JamesBrown-wq7wv satanic tea towels
Hipkins and Swarbrick really are hopeless.
NZ needs protection from green party and Labour
All the greens need to finish the 'look' is a crystal ball each. The performance would have equal value.
I saw the lady with the rug arround her but had to laugh 😂 when i saw the mouse in the corner
why is she allowed to wear Hamas colors In parliament .....wtf , hey Mr speaker do your job ???
ABSOLUTELY.
JERRY you need to stop those people wearing those tablecloths in parliament. They can wear them outside in their own time but never in parliament. We need to support ISRAEL 😊
@@janetihaka799 Educate yourself about the conflict and stop embarrassing yourself with your ignorance. Agreed I can't stand either but your lack of knowledge regards this subject is laughable............lol.
@@janetihaka799fool
@@novak7970 no. Hamas started this round with the murdering and kidnapping of innocent people. They build armery storage tunnels under strategic hospital and social community sites and the people living there let them. I think you would think very differently if the problem was here. Hamas and Islamic terrorists have caused this round. Then they cry genecide to capture the world's pity. I'm not buying any of it, I feel truely sad for all the innocent lives on both sides. I abhor war. But put the blame where it belongs. I don't codon terrorism of any kind.
The planets going to be here millions of years after you’re null and void Chlo Chlo !!!
must be cold in the House as the Greens are wearing scarves. are they made recyclable NZ merino wool ?
It's like the opposition has just landed in N.Z ,
They just haven't a clue
chloe wearing a war scarf is hilarious
..Somequeer over the Rainbow...
...green birds fly....
The ideology of the scarf wearing. Fail.
Totally pathetic, just like Chloe. Cannot even sort out the problems in her own party.
Can't even sort out the problems in her own head.@@jasperhorace7147
It is disgusting that she is allowed to wear that in support of Hamas. Especially in that building while being paid by New Zealand taxpayers.
Chloes mustache actually really suits her
What have the green party done for NZ since election day?
What have the green party ever done 😂
Why doesn't swarbrick go over to Israel and protest about the pollution the war is causing 😅
Omg the left are thick
National ACT Nz first, 😎😎😎😎
Is Swarbrick aware that the severe weather coincided with intense sun activity hence the magnificent aurora seen by many.
Just love the way Tom Thumb thinks he has it all sorted !
Greens wearing teatowels, disgraceful
Greens still wearing their gang patch (black and white tea towels).
Chloe just can't get it through her thick head, if you import coal, or you use your own coal, it still has emissions, but the imported coal has worse emissions, the overseas coal also has to be shipped here, with a higher Carbon footprint,, A real Nimby
Young, Dumb & at home with Mum. ❤😮
😂😂😂😂
The questions from the opposition show how ignorant and uneducated they are, wasting our time and money. We need to change the rules around who can be a politician. Only educated folk with suitable qualifications should be charged with running our affairs correctly and professionally with the same level of accountability as directors of public companies.
Educate them, there are some things that are impossible 😅
no domestic gas or fuel Chloe so we rely on imported fuel.What happens if there’s a problem in the northern hemisphere ( like war ) and we can’t get supply anymore.So stupid to burn our bridges locally.How relevant will green house gas BS be if this happens and people starve here.
not to mention the additional emissions created from shipping in the foreign coal
When are we going to have the dress code restored to respectful within parliament walls?
Chloe ... Time for a bidet... 😂😅😂
I am sick of the GREENS and there bollocks.
The tea towel brigade again.
How ? … who? … why!! Did people vote her in !!???
She is wasting so much time in the house .
Kick the greens out
We stand with the current government🙏
And WTF green party members are wearing . You wanna wear hijab than wear the whole thing 😂😂
Chole a typical drop kick ,should not be there in Parliament
Will Dipkins not just stand down now, rather than later when he will get the boot
Ideological parrot vs basic sensible practical steps. Good policy = economy = progress. The sense of liberation is profound.
Chloe Potter and the westerners hipocrosy
The green party needs to go
Where are the Green's prayer mats?
They don't need them... they only talk the talk... they would never walk the walk. Swarbrick can't even keep herself off of jet planes and if she knew what "Palestinian liberation" really was... she would RUN.
What the hell is Swarbrick wearing?
Emissions IN New Zealand, emitted FROM New Zealand do not mean weather intensity and severity IN New Zealand.
It's in the last IPCC report, big section on regional impacts.
It doesn't happen in that mechanical, directly attributable way because the emissions are global, the atmosphere doesn't give a rat's bunghole where they come from, the emissions and the atmospheric effect is at global level - eg average 2% temp rise.
The variegation in local effects is from the global levels / concentrations, and local dynamics. NZ has El Nino / La Nina, for example. Some regional variation means more storms, more rain, or more droughts. But NZ emissions DO NOT equal localised, short-term weather effects. This is like a child's conception of karma, or providence. The science is more complicated, but makes far more sense. In NZ went to zero emissions tomorrow, which is a bad idea, we would still face adverse weather effects due to unabated emissions in the northern hemisphere in particular. That's where the problem is.
A lot of hot air coming from greens /labour
Doesn't need renewable energy unless it's more hydro
Iwi won't allow it
Haast an obvious for a manapouri style hydro.
Green Party, are you mourning for Sinwar with your table cloths?
Whats with sorebricks granny shawl all about?
The record sun storms may have more to do with recent extreme weather
Over the "point 9f orders" ..is the opposition going for a world record on how many they can raise.. or just acting like sulky kids when they don't like an answer.
Stuff green house…bring on the more fuel, cheaper fuel and more jobs on the market
Is scarf support of Hamas appropriate in Parliament?
why is she wearing a table cloth
It's pro Palestinian clothing that says she supports the murder and mutilation of Israelis on Oct 7th 2023.....and is totally ignorant of the fact that she would be killed for being lesbian and an outspoken woman.
Send her to Gaza, if she's so sure of herself and has such care for terrorists.
The speaker of the house needs to put his house in order.
It’s sad to see more of the same as happens in Canadian parliament.
Cloe is an absolutely a chocolate.... 😂
stop talking about fast track and do it
Why is wearing this? Who votes for these people?
Wasn’t it the Greens & T.P.M that did the most flying? Wonder how there carbon footprint is looking.
Greens did the most flying typical hypocrites
0:15 By renewable, I presume you mean weather-dependent and intermittent.
Why would we want that, Mr Luxon? Can't you see what is happening to the Australians?
Why they wearing tea towels?
The crybaby says increasing greenhouse gas increases the frequency and intensity of devastating weather events. Do they? Compare to 2014, there has been a drop in CO2 emmision per person world-wide. How to explain that?
Petty Hipkins. Nothing better to say
How can we progress to a coal free society ..without fossil fuels to power an answer???
Nutty greenies
Will always entertain me how all i ever hear these people talk about is "new zealand needs this, this, that, and this" to pull at the hopeful heartstrings of people who would want such things realized, in a bid for support knowing full well they are things they will never receive. Year after year.
What's with clocks very disrespectful to our parliament
Green house gases least of your problems
Wind , water you get very limited sun
Waste of time arguing over frivolous things shunting each other childish
Chloe does not have a clue!
Its not greenhouse gasses that cause weather events, its all the weather modification techniques which are now widley acknowledged.
Im dissapointed in Luxon respoding with a Yes to her question on greenhouse gasses...
Its got no connection with worsening weather events.
Has Swarbrick and her communist cohorts ever been to Palestine or better still - lived in Palestine amongst terrorists ? This girl has lived a privileged life and lacks for nothing! Easy to criticise from the safety of your parliament privileged seat! If your family was massacred by terrorists would you just sit there and do nothing? Talk to your “friends” the Poms whose politician Lord Balfour sipped on a gin bottle and smoked cigars - while he drew borders in the Middle East - oblivious and couldn’t care where the borders should be after the demise of the Ottoman Empire! The Poms are to blame like soo much else in the world. Ask them!
It's slike sthis sis
Are they wearing Hamas scarves? Stupido’s
“Intensiddy”? “New Zillund”? “Communidies”?
Why does she only make an effort to pronounce Te Reo correctly? 🤔
Have you got people trying to knock me off Mr.Luxon? Id like to tell you your wrong.
How did Luxon get up so quick and not feel wary
😂🤣😂😂🤣😂👍
Can someone educate me... is there any clear evidence that greenhouse gases does make the weather worse? The reason I ask is there has been many times people have said that, and then you look at the rainfall stats and weather reports going back a hundred years or so and find it's all rubbish.
The argument here isn't if climate change is real. It is real. The argument is how to try and fix or mitigate it. Shipping in foreign coal is worse for the world's environment than digging it up locally. Common sense, surely?
It's a globalist scam to tax us into poverty, that's all
Suppose the people have to suffer thru a decade of dumb during the good times so that things can get so bad thru complacency that any common sense or nouse seems like wit in comparison to none...what a low bar/no wonder we are so far in arrears. The end of the beginning ffs...Long way to go to modernize at this rate we need more workers and less consumers somehow...the workers we have are exhausted.
CHINA
She should be ashamed for wearing support for Hamas
Clearly she has no idea of what’s going on over there