+Goggles Tigerkhan It's not really that good. It doesn't really sound much like the original, and it certainly doesnly look like it. The only slightly impressive thing is how they shot the balls out. 3/10 looks like it was thrown together in a few days.
@@polymetric2614 1. They're playing the original soundtrack. The only sounds made by the machine is the clicking. 2. It's not supposed to though. It has its own style and theme 3. The amount of work that they'd had to have gone through to program all of those launches and servos is super impressive for 90 days. Ok thank you for understanding my need to start arguments in 2 year old threads
or because its not actually playing anything its a glorified button pusher, how do we know the hits that are being registered are even whats playing the song. its the Robotics impressive sure. but as an instrument and as just a demo sorry is not that impressive.
@@ItsBugtronic it's even more glorified. There are no buttons. It's just some balls getting launched at the right times and lights turning on at pre-programmed times to make it LOOK like it's playing it.
To all the comments saying this isn't impressive because it's faked, it still proves that the physics and coordination is possible. All that's needed is more space and stronger force so that the sound could activate. That, and making the belt accurate to the notes, and not a simple platform. But seriously, this is super amazing, since it's shows that it is POSSIBLE!
So enough time has passed that there is tech to recreate pipe dream in real life, but there's STILL no Animusic 3 by then?? It would be incredible if someday there would be tech that could create fiber bundles in real life.
Animusic 3 got successfully kickstarted many years even before this comment. Problem came when the money ran out, because of botched production. The last update was in 2015, six years ago, and that update confirmed one of the original Animusic artists left the team because he literally couldn't afford the financial strain since the project was taking so long. With the team shrunk, one guy was basically doing a TON of the actual legwork to make it happen. And then he got diagnosed with a bunch of stuff ranging from ADHD, Depression, Bell's Palsy, and RSI (Repetitive Strain . It's safe to say the project for Animusic 3 is dead. Regardless of Wayne's claims that it's at the forefront of his mind every second, we haven't heard anything in more than six years.
While I have to note that the music is pre-recorded as multiple times you can see the ball not hit a lit up LED when the note plays, I can still enjoy this as the fun attempt it was, bravo.
@@valovanonym Yeah, I'm saying if it worked like the balls actually triggered the sound (and they hit properly) it would sound just as pre-recorded as what this is, which is an audio recording with sync'ed lights
It's amazing how much talent and smarts went into making this machine and the audience gives it a, "NICE!" and a "WOO!" If I were there I'd be flipping my shit.
+Brandon Beck (BoastfulGhost) Except this isn't actually playing the music, or doing anything that they say it's doing. The music is superimposed over the machine. If you watch the balls and follow the sounds of the corresponding instrument, they don't add up. It's basically just for show.
Yep, he's right, the music is slightly off, and while I'm surprised that no balls went off and hit other stuff, the sound is far from perfectly matching up to the original animusic. So unless they went and recorded their own version of it and then played that, then this actually was happening.
ya... I was expecting a HUGE "YAAAAA LETS GO!!!! THAT WAS AWESOME!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!
@@a2pha lol you obviously have no idea what’s possible with computers and robotics especially when talented people who have a grasp of physics are involved. It would literally be more of a pain in the ass to fake this than it would be to just actually do it. If you knew anything about anything you would see how obvious this is - but since you don’t I imagine lots of things seem fake to you. What a stupid ass way to live.
I don’t think it’s that incredible if it’s a visualized synchronization. if the impact of the balls was actually the thing making the sound, then it would’ve been impressive.
That robot gave the most intense glockenspiel solo that it's ever had in its entire music career, and the audience gave it a "nice". DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH TALENT THAT TAKES? cuz I don't, I play the bass.
WOW. I remember watching an Animusic DVD in my 2nd grade music class, and pipe dream was ALWAYS my favorite. It's really cool that a huge company like intel could take notice and use it to show off their chops!
Always used to love Resonant Chamber, found it on UA-cam after i got recommended the Marble Machine by Wintergatan, and then Pipe Dream, so on, i fell into the deep Rabbit Hole. I rediscovered it in 6th or 7th grade again, and i just love it. I always used to try making "remixes" of Resonant Chamber - since it was my favourite - but hardly failed, i did it on GarageBand, lol. I just hope that Animusic 3 will come out, and if not, i am gonna make it, haha.
The cowbell moves out of the way, but the backing track still plays it's 4 notes. Milli Vanilli robots giving a visual representation of what is being played.
This was truly an amazing achievement. Remember, the original video had all the balls on exactly the same 'flight path' with funnels that never failed to catch them. Real World physics is far more complex, and there's a large element of randomness in the flight of a ball discharged from even a precision machine. (Note that quite a few of the balls end up outside their catchbasins - but the small cheat of refilling between performances is one easily forgiven). :-)
It helps that the lights and sounds are pre-programmed, and the balls are just synced to hit as an add on. You can see it most clearly on the cowbell high hat contraption where the cowbell will still sound and light up even when the balls miss due to the rotation, but its also noticed when stray balls hit pads but don't produce sound or light.
@@ShpiggityShpike if the balls actually played the music then it will be not good cause of stray balls hitting other panels. It's practically impossible to make a machine like pipe dreams due to simple laws of physics
This is amazing for a live version, but if you look closely, the spent balls are falling to the floor, and not into the catch tubes seen in the animated video. Also they shortened the piece being played. The reason there are not catch tubes is because as I said in a comment for the Animusic Pipe Dream 2 video, the physics are controlled in the animation, which obviously cannot happen here. The balls don't bounce exactly the same every time. So they just fall to the floor, and don't get recycled though the Pipe System. Also if you look close at the circular xylophone, you can see that the ball firing mechanism is aiming its fire in different directions. and the part that opens the xylophone to be played is jerky, not smooth like the animated version. In real life the laws of physics cannot be rewritten! Still, the effort was well thought out for this version, so I give it a like!
A neater system could still be derived; there's a channel on UA-cam where a guy uses this principle of using marbles to player instruments to make a song with an a analog mechanical "Marble Machine" and it has the clean up pipes that catch most of the marbles
I never EVER thought that this could potentially exist in real life. Intel had the budget and technical ability to bring this to life. I love the animation, but this is a whole new level!
None of those people actually saw the original back when it was the bleeding edge of CGI animation. I didn't even know this was a thing until now and I'm just finding that this was done a DECADE AGO. That would have been absolutely jaw dropping to see IRL.
My Google Rewards app asked me if I'd seen any part of this video, I said I hadn't, but being a Animusic fan I decided to check this out. Did not disappoint.
I don't care if it was doctored a little, this is an amazing feat! The first time I saw animusic (specifically pipe dreams and the drum machine) I wondered how far off the animation was from real physics. The recycling of the balls after they strike their note was the most unrealistic, hard to imagine part. It would be nearly impossible to launch the ball in a way that you could predict where it would bounce after striking the note every time, so it's no surprise that they weren't able to pull that part off. I thought the same thing about the hihat hits, but it looked like the closed hihat may have been a different cymbal altogether to me. I'll have to watch again. Either way, this the most discouraging part, IMO. The opening and closing of the hat does seem very possible to pull off in real life and it's pretty crucial for the authenticity of the original version. bad call
Wow how did I not know about this!! I've been obsessed with the animated version for years and I had no idea they'd gone ahead and actually made it real!! I'm losing my mind over here!!!!
The instruments aren't real; at best there are sensors that generate electronic sounds. Look up "Wintergatan" on UA-cam. He's building the REAL thing -- real steel marbles playing real acoustic instruments, AND the marbles get caught and recycled.
If the only true flaw with this machine is that it can't catch and reuse every ball it launches, which is a perfectly natural flaw with even the most precise projectile launching systems due to simple physics, then this really is an uncontested masterpiece of engineering.
The xylophone fountain looked viable. Several times it didn't look like it was putting out the necessary number of balls to match the Animusic song 1 for 1, but it looked like it could play, same with the drums. The stringed instrument would be harder with actual strings.
I actually attended that NI week in Austin TX where it was shown. It was very impressive in real life. It took 6 interns to gather the balls for a reset to play again. It only demoed 5 time a day.
Was there better applause to the performance during the other demos? T he video cut the reaction on this one a bit, but it seemed like the crowd barely noticed. :/
Animusic has always lived in a sort of uncanny valley for me - I find the idea of music being played by nobody for nobody deeply unsettling. This solves that for me, and now I can properly appreciate the music itself. Thank you for that.
Computer graphics synced to MIDI tracts is never going to be the same as real time physical machinery. Kudos to Intel for their valiant attempt. Too bad the somber crowd didn't take much notice. Perhaps they never heard Animusic. 🤷♀️
its what they did you can see on some of the actual light up effects there is a 1 second delay after the ball hits showing that they already had the lights and sounds pre recorded and the balls were just for show
Quite! Im amazed at how accurate it could be, and with how far technology is advancing a few tweaks could make this into a working drum machine in essence.
thats the most fucking badassery vision brought to life i have seen in a LONG Time, with the Animusic craze making a sudden revamped reboot in people's minds. Hands down i wish i would have seen this in person. as a owner of both DVD's.
I'm noticing a lot of the time the marbles don't actually hit when the note plays and thats when I realized it's not actually buttons controlling it, it's just a semi-synchronized marble launching to the pre-set program :::/
Something I suspected. In the CGI when the balls were caught by the funnels, it was all precalculated. In real life, those balls fall anywhere after hitting the instrument. :) Also I'm hearing tones a tenth of a second before the balls hit. Sad to say this machine is not generating that music but prerecorded audio with "hit or miss" on the balls.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure I even saw some balls totally miss their targets, yet still produce sound. Pretty disappointing. Look up Wintergatan if you haven't heard of him -- there's a guy trying to make a fully functional machine similar to this, but without any of the cheating :)
You're absolutely right. This was a prerecorded script regardless of the success or failure in choreography. Without prerecording the soundtrack the beans/balls are far too unpredictable in size, weight, and density being slightly off center mark and the entire reason for every note to be digitized. The leds actually cause just enough of a visual distraction the viewer might not see a double strike by a bean/ball which does not produce any sound. Either way, attempting this without prerecording, even on digital instrumentation, would not be a small undertaking.
that is actually really awesome, the fact they brought this whole set up into real life is actually pretty impressive, though, I had no doubt intel would be up for the challange and they pulled it off beautifully.
Automated song into reality means exact time and exact placement. Over all great vid . It came close it came be done better than the automated CGI musical instruments.
OMG, IT'S REAL!!!! :D :D :D I love Animusic so much, and the make believe machines that play the music were so cool looking. I had always wished someone somewhere would try constructing functioning machines like this, so, this is totally awesome!!!!! :D
If anyone is wondering why everyone's reaction is sort of non-existent, these people are at an American (dry) tradeshow, where a certain level of decorum is required. (European shows are somewhat more and less lax - depends if they serve alcohol)
12 years since this! I know I'm amused, to say the least. I suppose it lacks the wow factor, because the instruments are artificial. And I imagine that real instruments are too inconsistent for this to be 100% accurate. Still, I appreciate the time and effort put into this! Kudos to Intel! I like their software!
this audience wouldn't be impressed if they saw a machine that made food out of thin air.
+Goggles Tigerkhan It's not really that good. It doesn't really sound much like the original, and it certainly doesnly look like it. The only slightly impressive thing is how they shot the balls out. 3/10 looks like it was thrown together in a few days.
@@polymetric2614 1. They're playing the original soundtrack. The only sounds made by the machine is the clicking.
2. It's not supposed to though. It has its own style and theme
3. The amount of work that they'd had to have gone through to program all of those launches and servos is super impressive for 90 days.
Ok thank you for understanding my need to start arguments in 2 year old threads
I see you furry fuckers everywhere get away from me
RabidCris im calling it now, somebody is going to get triggered and argue against you
@@OPETRAXSTUDIOS nope
Intel: *Literally brings the realm of fiction to real life*
Audience: Best i can do is "nice"
Probably because their souls were sucked from their bodies by LabVIEW
or because its not actually playing anything its a glorified button pusher, how do we know the hits that are being registered are even whats playing the song. its the Robotics impressive sure. but as an instrument and as just a demo sorry is not that impressive.
Well..
It's faked..
On both the OG.
And this.
So uh.
Yeaaah..
@@ItsBugtronic it's even more glorified.
There are no buttons.
It's just some balls getting launched at the right times and lights turning on at pre-programmed times to make it LOOK like it's playing it.
To all the comments saying this isn't impressive because it's faked, it still proves that the physics and coordination is possible.
All that's needed is more space and stronger force so that the sound could activate.
That, and making the belt accurate to the notes, and not a simple platform.
But seriously, this is super amazing, since it's shows that it is POSSIBLE!
So enough time has passed that there is tech to recreate pipe dream in real life, but there's STILL no Animusic 3 by then?? It would be incredible if someday there would be tech that could create fiber bundles in real life.
they probably could, but it would be even cooler if they made starship groove or pogo sticks
Seriously though. I loved these as a kid learning piano. It's probably go apeshit of they made acoustic curves real.
Animusic 3 got successfully kickstarted many years even before this comment. Problem came when the money ran out, because of botched production. The last update was in 2015, six years ago, and that update confirmed one of the original Animusic artists left the team because he literally couldn't afford the financial strain since the project was taking so long.
With the team shrunk, one guy was basically doing a TON of the actual legwork to make it happen. And then he got diagnosed with a bunch of stuff ranging from ADHD, Depression, Bell's Palsy, and RSI (Repetitive Strain .
It's safe to say the project for Animusic 3 is dead. Regardless of Wayne's claims that it's at the forefront of his mind every second, we haven't heard anything in more than six years.
@@Tinkatube
I’ve pretty much accepted long ago that Animusic 3 will never exist.
@@newtfigton8795
I hope, at least, if Wayne passes away, we get project files released for all the songs. Then someone could finish it.
The song hasn't even started yet and my jaw is already on the floor.
me too
While I have to note that the music is pre-recorded as multiple times you can see the ball not hit a lit up LED when the note plays, I can still enjoy this as the fun attempt it was, bravo.
Yeah, it definitely sounds pre-recorded
@@drnarwhal2888 If it worked correctly, it would also sound pre-recorded
@@emdivine there are moments when you can see leds turn on but the ball doesn't hit at the same time
@@valovanonym Yeah, I'm saying if it worked like the balls actually triggered the sound (and they hit properly) it would sound just as pre-recorded as what this is, which is an audio recording with sync'ed lights
Agreed some balls completely missed but the light and sound played
Could the audience look more depressed
Maybe they never saw the original, so they didn't get why this is so cool?
There's at least a few guys in the back left who seem interested.
Pretty sure they realize the music is prerecorded. Shame.
Amazing engineering, underwhelming performance.
Probably because their souls were sucked from their bodies by LabVIEW
It's amazing how much talent and smarts went into making this machine and the audience gives it a, "NICE!" and a "WOO!" If I were there I'd be flipping my shit.
i know right?!
+Brandon Beck (BoastfulGhost) Except this isn't actually playing the music, or doing anything that they say it's doing. The music is superimposed over the machine. If you watch the balls and follow the sounds of the corresponding instrument, they don't add up. It's basically just for show.
+Dj Dixon it's not the same samples as Animusic uses, there's something more behind this
Yep, he's right, the music is slightly off, and while I'm surprised that no balls went off and hit other stuff, the sound is far from perfectly matching up to the original animusic. So unless they went and recorded their own version of it and then played that, then this actually was happening.
ya... I was expecting a HUGE "YAAAAA LETS GO!!!! THAT WAS AWESOME!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!
I can't believe they brought this to life. Truly a spectacular age to be living in.
***** in that case I'm sorry for the insult
Totally agree Jon
+TheDukeofJuke you're polite as hell
I wonder who would bring Future Retro to life.
It's fake watch closer
ONE DAY ALL OUR MUSIC WILL BE PLAYED BY BALLS
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
shabadoo1 Um, no... you can't bend notes this way...
Hey, sometimes it takes balls to play music :p
@@KalonOrdona2 True.
*Just stop it*
I wonder which was more expensive the animation or this machine.
probably the machine
Probably the machine,cuz it took alot of money too buy the parts
Yes
In financial expense, the machine. The animation takes the cake in creative expense
Definitely the machine. The animation was free cause the animators made their own MIDI Animusic software. The animation probably took longer tho.
an overhead camera would have been good..
+arrgh garry This wasn't professionally shot, this is someones personal clip.
Yeah, or at least not recording it right where you can't see the ball action.
@@a2pha Erm, they recorded it at the literal best spot
Ah, but then you would see the whole thing is a sham.
@@a2pha lol you obviously have no idea what’s possible with computers and robotics especially when talented people who have a grasp of physics are involved. It would literally be more of a pain in the ass to fake this than it would be to just actually do it. If you knew anything about anything you would see how obvious this is - but since you don’t I imagine lots of things seem fake to you. What a stupid ass way to live.
None of it is percussive. It's a visualized synchronization. Even so, it's incredible.
I don’t think it’s that incredible if it’s a visualized synchronization. if the impact of the balls was actually the thing making the sound, then it would’ve been impressive.
@@XaxtonRevolution2The mechanism would be the exact same though.
It was a little percussive, it went click clack
That robot gave the most intense glockenspiel solo that it's ever had in its entire music career, and the audience gave it a "nice". DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH TALENT THAT TAKES? cuz I don't, I play the bass.
That was a vibraphone ☝️🤓
WOW. I remember watching an Animusic DVD in my 2nd grade music class, and pipe dream was ALWAYS my favorite. It's really cool that a huge company like intel could take notice and use it to show off their chops!
yea same, we watched fantasia , animusic and another one where it was a bunch of people banging on trash
Always used to love Resonant Chamber, found it on UA-cam after i got recommended the Marble Machine by Wintergatan, and then Pipe Dream, so on, i fell into the deep Rabbit Hole. I rediscovered it in 6th or 7th grade again, and i just love it. I always used to try making "remixes" of Resonant Chamber - since it was my favourite - but hardly failed, i did it on GarageBand, lol. I just hope that Animusic 3 will come out, and if not, i am gonna make it, haha.
The cowbell moves out of the way, but the backing track still plays it's 4 notes. Milli Vanilli robots giving a visual representation of what is being played.
This was truly an amazing achievement. Remember, the original video had all the balls on exactly the same 'flight path' with funnels that never failed to catch them. Real World physics is far more complex, and there's a large element of randomness in the flight of a ball discharged from even a precision machine. (Note that quite a few of the balls end up outside their catchbasins - but the small cheat of refilling between performances is one easily forgiven). :-)
It helps that the lights and sounds are pre-programmed, and the balls are just synced to hit as an add on. You can see it most clearly on the cowbell high hat contraption where the cowbell will still sound and light up even when the balls miss due to the rotation, but its also noticed when stray balls hit pads but don't produce sound or light.
@@ShpiggityShpike if the balls actually played the music then it will be not good cause of stray balls hitting other panels. It's practically impossible to make a machine like pipe dreams due to simple laws of physics
@@user-tp6hj4bj7o It's possible, but not with an Intel Atom processor and cheap launcher mechanisms.
I wish the crowd would actually realize how amazing this is
This is amazing for a live version, but if you look closely, the spent balls are falling to the floor, and not into the catch tubes seen in the animated video. Also they shortened the piece being played. The reason there are not catch tubes is because as I said in a comment for the Animusic Pipe Dream 2 video, the physics are controlled in the animation, which obviously cannot happen here. The balls don't bounce exactly the same every time. So they just fall to the floor, and don't get recycled though the Pipe System. Also if you look close at the circular xylophone, you can see that the ball firing mechanism is aiming its fire in different directions. and the part that opens the xylophone to be played is jerky, not smooth like the animated version.
In real life the laws of physics cannot be rewritten! Still, the effort was well thought out for this version, so I give it a like!
A neater system could still be derived; there's a channel on UA-cam where a guy uses this principle of using marbles to player instruments to make a song with an a analog mechanical "Marble Machine" and it has the clean up pipes that catch most of the marbles
Search UA-cam for "Wintergatan". It's way more impressive than Intel's version.
With the tech in 2016, this could be perfected
How's the tech today
@@alexanderharrison7421 Better
@@encode42 what a legend you replied to someone who commented on your comment which you wrote 4 years ago pure resepect.
...and with the tech of 2022, it'll be even better/smaller/faster. But your pingpong balls are stuck on a truck in Canada.
I never EVER thought that this could potentially exist in real life. Intel had the budget and technical ability to bring this to life. I love the animation, but this is a whole new level!
None of those people actually saw the original back when it was the bleeding edge of CGI animation. I didn't even know this was a thing until now and I'm just finding that this was done a DECADE AGO. That would have been absolutely jaw dropping to see IRL.
I watched this when I was 6 in 2006 every day. this it a dream come true!
same!...
JumboDS64 cool!
Same here, I was about the same age when it came out and I was so impressed, this is amazingly cool to see
same here my teacher told me about that
same feels here! Watched in 2005 when I was 12 and am still impressed
My Google Rewards app asked me if I'd seen any part of this video, I said I hadn't, but being a Animusic fan I decided to check this out.
Did not disappoint.
I don't care if it was doctored a little, this is an amazing feat! The first time I saw animusic (specifically pipe dreams and the drum machine) I wondered how far off the animation was from real physics. The recycling of the balls after they strike their note was the most unrealistic, hard to imagine part. It would be nearly impossible to launch the ball in a way that you could predict where it would bounce after striking the note every time, so it's no surprise that they weren't able to pull that part off.
I thought the same thing about the hihat hits, but it looked like the closed hihat may have been a different cymbal altogether to me. I'll have to watch again. Either way, this the most discouraging part, IMO. The opening and closing of the hat does seem very possible to pull off in real life and it's pretty crucial for the authenticity of the original version. bad call
You should check out wintergatan's marble machines.
Wow how did I not know about this!! I've been obsessed with the animated version for years and I had no idea they'd gone ahead and actually made it real!! I'm losing my mind over here!!!!
The instruments aren't real; at best there are sensors that generate electronic sounds. Look up "Wintergatan" on UA-cam. He's building the REAL thing -- real steel marbles playing real acoustic instruments, AND the marbles get caught and recycled.
something about animusic and how we all had and or are having a homestuck phase 🤕🕺
If the only true flaw with this machine is that it can't catch and reuse every ball it launches, which is a perfectly natural flaw with even the most precise projectile launching systems due to simple physics, then this really is an uncontested masterpiece of engineering.
The xylophone fountain looked viable. Several times it didn't look like it was putting out the necessary number of balls to match the Animusic song 1 for 1, but it looked like it could play, same with the drums. The stringed instrument would be harder with actual strings.
Double bounces off vibrating strings would be physically impossible to get the same result twice, that's part of the magic of the animation.
I actually attended that NI week in Austin TX where it was shown. It was very impressive in real life. It took 6 interns to gather the balls for a reset to play again. It only demoed 5 time a day.
Was there better applause to the performance during the other demos? T
he video cut the reaction on this one a bit, but it seemed like the crowd barely noticed. :/
I'd like to see these people's reaction on Wintergatan's Martin playing his MMX live
What a world !! Computers are doing amazing virtual life - and men are standing arround like dead. :-)
Guess who created those ingenious machines...
Matt Baum robots my friend robots...
humans just programmed the robots !!!
Amazing how much PVC can sound like brass. Must be a miracle. Couldn't be fake.
Animusic has always lived in a sort of uncanny valley for me - I find the idea of music being played by nobody for nobody deeply unsettling. This solves that for me, and now I can properly appreciate the music itself. Thank you for that.
I grew up with Animusic. This is awesome, and I wish I’d seen this video when it first came out.
Computer graphics synced to MIDI tracts is never going to be the same as real time physical machinery. Kudos to Intel for their valiant attempt. Too bad the somber crowd didn't take much notice. Perhaps they never heard Animusic. 🤷♀️
Excellent, but Animusic are still the masters.
No yet ua-cam.com/video/w_YaUQJAQSU/v-deo.html
For all we know they could of just played a soundtrack and shot balls at the instruments
My thought exactly. Is it just an elaborate computer program with near flawless synch? Or is it really a touch sensitive feedback?
I guess that's exactly what happened... Lame as that is, it's still kinda awesome as shit to watch.
its what they did you can see on some of the actual light up effects there is a 1 second delay after the ball hits showing that they already had the lights and sounds pre recorded and the balls were just for show
If you watch closely, some of the balls miss the spinning rack but still produce a sound. I can only assume the visual and sound were totally separate
Quite! Im amazed at how accurate it could be, and with how far technology is advancing a few tweaks could make this into a working drum machine in essence.
Nothing like a little reimagined nostalgia!
Something that only aired occasionally for a short time on late Saturday nights on PBS has come far.
Had they used AMD, they would have actually been able to make the music instead of faking it.
FuckinGoogleIDont want to use my real name let's see amd pull this off then
it's 2022 and this is STILL amazing.
This is so wild!!!! I'm a big fan of Animusic and I always felt someone, somehow would come up with this. I love it!!!
thats the most fucking badassery vision brought to life i have seen in a LONG Time, with the Animusic craze making a sudden revamped reboot in people's minds.
Hands down i wish i would have seen this in person. as a owner of both DVD's.
Wow I used to watch the original all the time when it was first made and wondered if someone could do it in real life. This is amazing!
I'm noticing a lot of the time the marbles don't actually hit when the note plays and thats when I realized it's not actually buttons controlling it, it's just a semi-synchronized marble launching to the pre-set program :::/
Something I suspected. In the CGI when the balls were caught by the funnels, it was all precalculated. In real life, those balls fall anywhere after hitting the instrument. :)
Also I'm hearing tones a tenth of a second before the balls hit. Sad to say this machine is not generating that music but prerecorded audio with "hit or miss" on the balls.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure I even saw some balls totally miss their targets, yet still produce sound. Pretty disappointing.
Look up Wintergatan if you haven't heard of him -- there's a guy trying to make a fully functional machine similar to this, but without any of the cheating :)
You're absolutely right. This was a prerecorded script regardless of the success or failure in choreography. Without prerecording the soundtrack the beans/balls are far too unpredictable in size, weight, and density being slightly off center mark and the entire reason for every note to be digitized. The leds actually cause just enough of a visual distraction the viewer might not see a double strike by a bean/ball which does not produce any sound. Either way, attempting this without prerecording, even on digital instrumentation, would not be a small undertaking.
This is cool on a really high level! Nicely done!
It blows my mind that not one spectator is cracking a smile
I'm seeing a few balls go astray every now and then while remaining transfixed by this spectacle. This is jaw-dropping!!
And WHY aren't these people applauding this!?
Ребята, БРАВО!!!!
Прекрасная реализация!!!
Yo that was insane. I want one!
Hats off to Intel... Awsome Engineering... Just Fabulous
The video was made 11 years ago and it's still good
I love Animusic and I love LabView. Would love to see the code for this. Well done.
Oh my god this is amazing how did I not know of this until now?!
This is so fucking incredible. It’s not perfect, but it’s still amazing even today
I always dreamed that this could be done in real life. And to my surprise I was right, it could be done!
not really, there are a lot of things that they just couldnt implement, but tis still cool. And there were about 3 misfires at the beginning
Very entertaining and fun to watch. Thanks for posting this.
Wow. For a large chunk of my adult life, I have been wishing that Animusic was actually real. This blows me away!
9 years ago. WOW how much innovation has passed
that is actually really awesome, the fact they brought this whole set up into real life is actually pretty impressive, though, I had no doubt intel would be up for the challange and they pulled it off beautifully.
That’s amazing! Almost
I LOVE THIS!!!!
The fact this was taken 11 years ago is just something else, makes me wonder what they could do now
I think we need proof that the instruments would still make their assigned sound without benefit of coded music.
now try to make aquatic harp real live :P
yea nemos ass can get a job...
wot. i was talking about the animation by animusic, not finding nemo
yea its a joke cus all those fish look so hard at work...
Lucifag i would rather like to see stick figures
For 2011, this thing is not even close to being of that time, it is on time with the beat perfectly i am glad.
Nice! They should have made a Tom Servo head feeding out those xylophone balls. :)
this is absolutely fantastic! love it!
For 10 years and in 2022 still sound nice.😊
back in the day, we thought that this was not physically possible an intel basicly said fuck that
all this and we can't even make phones that don't bend in your pocket
iphones aren't the only phones out there...
istyleonu
none of them bend
They don't bend. Just cause some 300lbs guy sat 4 hours and his iphone bent doesn't mean they will bend in your pocket.
Maro18Z actually you can bend them with your fingers.
The Countess I bet I could bend my phone (sgs3) with my fingers also if I try.
To everybody talking about how the audience has no reaction
I don't think a single person at the convention has the same levels of nostalgia as you
all i can hear is the machine making popping noise and midi sound but AWESOME INTEL WELL DONE
I liked the enthusiasm of the spectators at the end.
Wow a real Pipe Dream. I bought the Animusic DVD probably 16/17 yrs ago.
even after 11 years i still love this
holy fuck I used to watch this back when I was a kid! This is amazing :D
It was only a matter of time before somebody did it in real life. It's just amazing.
This needs more view's! It's actual talent!
And this was 6 years ago. Imagine what could be done now.
I love this drums. glockinpel piano bass etc
This is so insane and awesome!!!🤩
Automated song into reality means exact time and exact placement. Over all great vid . It came close it came be done better than the automated CGI musical instruments.
8 years later this is still cool!
Childhood dream come true, pipe dream that is.
I can't believe they made this in real life dude that's awesome
OMG, IT'S REAL!!!! :D :D :D I love Animusic so much, and the make believe machines that play the music were so cool looking. I had always wished someone somewhere would try constructing functioning machines like this, so, this is totally awesome!!!!! :D
***** Yeah! :D
Still better than Bieber or Kanye
Simply amazing!!!! I thought it's not going to work.
MP3 players covered entire showroom floors back then.
10 years later: Intel's still leading. Well done, m8s
If anyone is wondering why everyone's reaction is sort of non-existent, these people are at an American (dry) tradeshow, where a certain level of decorum is required. (European shows are somewhat more and less lax - depends if they serve alcohol)
THAT IS AMAZING!!!
This is so awesome!
I wish Animusic 3 would come out.
It got funded on kickstarter a year ago and there has been no update on it
12 years since this! I know I'm amused, to say the least. I suppose it lacks the wow factor, because the instruments are artificial. And I imagine that real instruments are too inconsistent for this to be 100% accurate. Still, I appreciate the time and effort put into this! Kudos to Intel! I like their software!
Absolutely incredible! 💖💖💖👏👏👏
You had my curiosity, now you have my attention.
Incredible set
This is such a throwback