Mafate Speed 4 or Speedgoat 5? Tough choice when they're both this good but we've got some tips.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Both have loads of cushion and bounce, both have epic traction, both eat pure adventure for breakfast. But there are some differences that might swing you one way or the other, based on fit and ride preferences.
    #MafateSpeed4 #Speedgoat5 #Ultra-Trail #UTMB #UTA100 #UTA50 #UTA22 #UTA11 #trailrunning #runningshoes #flyhumanfly

КОМЕНТАРІ • 35

  • @garyhaber6957
    @garyhaber6957 9 місяців тому +1

    Out of all of the channels on here, no one has explained it like you. So thank you, and you've done a great job..... Mafate would be more to my liking 👍

  • @mikaramatthews1226
    @mikaramatthews1226 Рік тому +2

    Thank you for breaking down the differences. This helped a lot for me trying to decide which would suit me best.

  • @Chat-tw1gb
    @Chat-tw1gb 29 днів тому

    Thank you for showing the flex!

  • @spuds1002
    @spuds1002 Рік тому +1

    Best comparison review of these shoes on the interwebs, nailed it Roger 👊

  • @Blank-Knight
    @Blank-Knight Рік тому +1

    Excellent comparison. Few else mentioned the different wide/fit of the midshoe, but now I see why I often read to take one size up with the Mafate. Seems to be the more narrow fit there. Thanks from Europe!

  • @CcCc-f2s
    @CcCc-f2s 18 годин тому

    This bod it's very good
    I need it.
    I live marrakech in Morocco

  • @dextersuarez9948
    @dextersuarez9948 Рік тому +5

    As a bodybuilder interested in trail running, my ankles aren’t the most stable, I rolled both on my first trail in the Appalachian mountains trying to hit a technical trail with a road shoe 3 weeks ago, I think the mafate will be the shoe to choose for heavier guys like me, maybe even just people new to the sport who want a little extra from the outsole.

    • @BruceRunning
      @BruceRunning Рік тому

      What is your weight?

    • @dextersuarez9948
      @dextersuarez9948 Рік тому +1

      @@BruceRunning im on a bulk right now sitting at 200, my normal weight is 185

  • @amyhoop9651
    @amyhoop9651 Рік тому +2

    Excellent review! I was wondering which one to buy. I think I want them both now. lol

  • @sheldonjanuary4058
    @sheldonjanuary4058 4 місяці тому

    Awesome explanation. Cheers!

  • @morganflockhart5825
    @morganflockhart5825 Рік тому +2

    For a more aggressive mountain shoe the Mafate probably should have total coverage on the outsole I collected a fair bit of damage on the exposed rubber on the Evo mafate similar to the Tecton X

  • @TheHutanudan
    @TheHutanudan 11 місяців тому

    Excellent review! Very good video, thank you for the insight regarding the stability between this two shoes. I used 300 km mafate 4 and very instabily on running down hill, also because i overpronated. So, thank you for your insight. did you intend to release any trail shoes for overpronation?

  • @wawanbalik
    @wawanbalik Рік тому

    Excellent explanation, thank you. I'm using Mach 5 for now and was wondering what should the be replacement for the Salomon SC 5 for trails. Most probably it'll be the Hoka SG5.

    • @colinstewart1432
      @colinstewart1432 Рік тому

      If you can still find a pair, get Speedgoat 4. I've owned both and the 4 is definitely better.

  • @lennertminten2453
    @lennertminten2453 2 роки тому +2

    I would also like to know: which one is the best if you want to avoid ankle sprains on technical downhill terrain as much as possible ?

    • @Ni1zz
      @Ni1zz 2 роки тому +1

      Try to use kinesiotherapy patch around your feet. There should be a video how to apply it. It helped me a lot

  • @petmas
    @petmas Рік тому +8

    Can i have one.. my name is mafate☺️

  • @maxkuhn7024
    @maxkuhn7024 6 місяців тому

    I am recovering from a hip surgery and I need more cushion for plain gravel roads. What do you suggest between mafate and speedgoat?

  • @_craig.
    @_craig. 2 роки тому +3

    which is more stable? for a flat footed overpronator like me. My first Hoka speedgoat was the sg3, but after a couple of trail runs on it, I stopped wearing it, because it gave me ankle sprains after ankle sprains.

    • @paddywiggle
      @paddywiggle 2 роки тому

      Probably the mafate. It’s a more technical shoe (usually means its more stable on even terrain)

    • @CoachMattPowered
      @CoachMattPowered 2 роки тому +2

      The speedgoat feels a ton more stable, I love the mafate other than I have to be pretty careful about rolling ankles. The mafate provides more underfoot protection for technical stuff, but it feels less stable and higher off the ground

    • @_craig.
      @_craig. 2 роки тому

      Mafate Speed 4: 1
      Speedgoat 5: 1
      more responses please 😊

    • @travroy
      @travroy Рік тому

      If you're prone to ankle sprains, try a shoe with little to no drop like Altra

    • @HOKAau
      @HOKAau  Рік тому

      @@_craig. Your greatest asset for control is balance, so if you feel more balance in something plush with a broad base the Speedgoat may be your choice, but if you like more flex from your shoe then it's the Mafate Speed.

  • @Kaisersozze
    @Kaisersozze 4 місяці тому

    I picked the Mafate because it has more room in the toebox. I don't like my toes being squished because it creates instability and unhealthy feet. Simple.

  • @Rick999888
    @Rick999888 Рік тому

    And where does the torrent 2 sit in comparison?. I'm guessing shorter distances and very technical terrain?

  • @providencephelps1497
    @providencephelps1497 2 роки тому +1

    Which has MORE cushion??

    • @HOKAau
      @HOKAau  Рік тому +1

      Identical stack heights - more cushioned feel from Speedgoat but just as plush ride from Mafate only more rebound

  • @shikharsingh3961
    @shikharsingh3961 Рік тому

    Can i use them on road too? usually the route i take has concrete road at the start and then loose small gravel and then off road trail.

    • @HOKAau
      @HOKAau  Рік тому +1

      Fine to use on incidental road.

  • @chrisfr3480
    @chrisfr3480 2 роки тому

    J’aurais tellement voulu que cette vidéo soit en français pour mieux comprendre 😞

    • @elaineyang7604
      @elaineyang7604 Рік тому

      Le coussin et la traction extérieure sont similaires pour les deux chaussures. Cependant, le Mafate est plus flexible, ce qui peut être préférable pour les terrains rocheux. Le Speedgoat est moins flexible, ce que certaines personnes peuvent préférer.

  • @ittotaq
    @ittotaq Рік тому +2

    which of these two for long distance hiking?