New is just better in basically every way better inst, better sprites, more realistic lava movement (compared to the old's dancing lava) an ending cutscene not hating on the old tho it was good for back when fnf mods weren't as crazy as they are now
Personally, I liked both because the old one was always my favorite, but I like the new remix one. There is just more stuff in the music that was missing in the old one, but I miss the I Hate You Text when the Dead Marios are coming. Both are good in their own way, but I say new already.
I think V2 vocals get overshadowed by the instrumental. V1 shines with it's vocals while the instrumental helps support it. V2 is better in a lot of ways. But it also feels a bit overpowering.
I prefer the old one,because it sounds more clean,and i respect those people who love the new one more,because it sounds good too,but i still prefer the old one
Though V1 is definitely an A-Tier, V2 just blows it out of the water with just a couple changes. Take for example, now, at the start of the song, there are little pauses, making it more dramatic. The vocals sound better, the instrumental is better, the visuals are amazing, the tone of the song is executed better, and so on and so forth. Though, again, V1 is a great song still.
Tbh the new one is better but the only complaint about the new one is that the song is to reverbed, and before you start complaining that my opinion is “bad” I actually make fnf songs, so I know what’s good and what’s not, no hate intended.
I love the insane ass drums in the new version and the vocals don't make me want to rip my ears off so I think the new version wins with this one... in my opinion
Creo que me gusta más la antigua me gusta ese toque retro y lo que se asemeja al breakore en el fondo de la primera la segunda me recuerda un poco a nivel de playa por los instrumentos :v
"IHY" Old or New?
New is just better in basically every way
better inst, better sprites, more realistic lava movement (compared to the old's dancing lava) an ending cutscene
not hating on the old tho it was good for back when fnf mods weren't as crazy as they are now
Personally, I liked both because the old one was always my favorite, but I like the new remix one. There is just more stuff in the music that was missing in the old one, but I miss the I Hate You Text when the Dead Marios are coming. Both are good in their own way, but I say new already.
The old
New
all ive been seeing is night and day improvements tbh. new ihy if u ask me, ez
I love how they didn't change the song by a lot. It still sounds like i hate you.
That's why it's still a banger tho
It was too good
I like both
V1 holds up really well, but V2 made it better
tbh both are basically the same in rate to me but the v2 version is like a boss battle kind of theme so i like the new one
I think V2 vocals get overshadowed by the instrumental.
V1 shines with it's vocals while the instrumental helps support it. V2 is better in a lot of ways. But it also feels a bit overpowering.
New song is more epic. But the old is Very good too
Loco se puede jugar las canciones del mod anterior no actualizado en la v2 de Mario madness 😅
I like them the same, they are very similar, but I'd say the new one is just a bit better
all of Luigi's clothes torn and his skin burned, his boots:✨✨
I like ho in V2, instead of trying to make the shoes fit the worn and teared look, they made the shoes shinier
1:28 and 2:02
V1:head bobbing
V2:break dancing
the old one feels slightly akward listening to it now, and the inst is like really quiet.
The part of end of i hate you v2 is awesome because Bf hit IHY luigi in lava again
La vieja esta bien, pero la nueva me parece mil veces mejor
V2 is so much more intense I love it
HI I'M LUIGI I'M BURNED I HATE MARIO'S MADNESS, MARIO'S MADNESS IS MY RIVAL
I love the new form 😊
Art: new
Music: old
Pero remix
Same man
Both good.
Old vocals: normal
New vocals: echo
I prefer the old one,because it sounds more clean,and i respect those people who love the new one more,because it sounds good too,but i still prefer the old one
Bro, same! 😆
Me to
Respect Your Opinion😀👍
My most hated part of v1 is that luigi looks fatter than he actually is tho😭
The hell was that? 2:09
In v2 i cant really hear luigi at some moments
New
0:12
Imo, i like the old one better because the song sounds cleaner, while V2 has this random sound in it that bothers me, but the art is definitely V2.
They are almost the exact same song in charting and song wise. Nothing Major was changed.
The old one sounds 8-bit rather than clean tbh
I prefer V2 but I Respect Your Opinion
Though V1 is definitely an A-Tier, V2 just blows it out of the water with just a couple changes. Take for example, now, at the start of the song, there are little pauses, making it more dramatic. The vocals sound better, the instrumental is better, the visuals are amazing, the tone of the song is executed better, and so on and so forth. Though, again, V1 is a great song still.
Honestly the only thing that got improved is the quality and intesity
They just changed the instrumental
V2 sounds a lot better than V1 tbh
In my opinion v1 is better but v2 hits
Both
V1 Luigi looks like green Mario tbh
I like V1 IHY sprites better except for the hat.
I like v1
I think the original IHY's instrumental would be better than V2's if V2's didn't have more variety than V1's
I like the old one for the breakcore.
V2 is just an official remix
New
I hate you v1 is the 1 song from the v1
Tbh the new one is better but the only complaint about the new one is that the song is to reverbed, and before you start complaining that my opinion is “bad” I actually make fnf songs, so I know what’s good and what’s not, no hate intended.
V1 bad situation V2 ic battle
New
Both
I love the insane ass drums in the new version and the vocals don't make me want to rip my ears off so I think the new version wins with this one... in my opinion
Creo que me gusta más la antigua me gusta ese toque retro y lo que se asemeja al breakore en el fondo de la primera la segunda me recuerda un poco a nivel de playa por los instrumentos :v
When you hear tne new version the old change i hare not so much instrumental how before i hare more instrument
What? Old vs New?😮
Новый лучше
This song hits tho
Luigi and BF in V2 have moves.
Definitely new one
New
New one by a long shot
Pq no me gusta la song 🥺
2:18 💀
💀💀💀
Remember guys FNF is not for kids
El "IHY" New es buenísimo 😄
El "IHY" Old está bien, pero le falta más energía 🤷♂️