o my god...what a rollercoaster of thoughts, emotions, images......i am exhausted, weeping and praying...this film is eerily relevant in our today world... god....or godless......which world do we really think we are living in.....
Watched whole movie through subtitles, as being an Indian I don't understand Russian but these three parts have taught me enough about different aspects of human life. Wonderful 🙏
Хвала од Господа! Душа, ум, срце, љубав, живот, смрт....све је ту. Ко разуме Достојевског, спасен је човек. Достојевски, Русија у мом срцу - заувек! Праштајте!
Мени грешној опростите сви! Људи, животиње, биљке...сви ....Данас сам се причестила, хвала што се јављате. Од Господа Вам мир, љубав и радост. Срећан Празник1 @@CPE-j1u
@@CPE-j1u potpuno si u pravu.. ja sam '67 godiste, i sjecam se odrastajuci u bivsoj Jugi, ucili su nas da postujemo svakog ko je stariji, a podgotovo strance.. stranci su bili kao bogovi, kao da su bili neka "visa rasa" u odnosu na nas.. sad kad sam u stranoj zemlji shvatam koliko smo grijesili, da nismo bili u pravu.. u stvari, mi smo bili ti koji su bili "visa rasa" u svakom pogledu, prvenstveno po kulturi i nacinu razmisljanja.. stranci ne uce njihovu djecu ljubav, toleranciju, i postivanje, hladni su kao led.. ta ljubav, tolerancija, i postivanje se olici na licu svakog od nas , i ja u stranoj zemlji mogu po licu (faci) da prepoznam koji je sa prostora bivse Juge.. prastanje je nama u krvi, ali sta mi to treba da prastamo, ugnjetavanje i haos koji su nam stranci donosili u svojim pohodima..
After five years of reading the great novel, I finally knew the perfect end. I expected nothing less... oh my poor Mitya, my favourite character, you were proven innocent at least in the eyes of those you cared about, poor Ivan, your own anguish thoughts devoured you... That really ended in Karamasov's fashion.
It's been some time since I've read the novel, Dostoviesky is great and reading it is a great experience. I'm not sure what to say about the adaptation, it does recreate many crucial spots and it's difficult to find fault in it. One has to tune to the movie's terms, but that's fine, one as the audience has to participate too, this happens in many forms of art. Surely it can't replace the book, which is perfectly fine too. I'd say it's a great watch after reading the book, not sure how others would experience it without reading the book. And who cares really? I'm sure these questions come up, and I don't have the answers. Great movie, great to have this people restoring these movies and putting them up for free. I might give the book another read soon also, so in the end, stupid questions aside, this is great actually.
As a big fan of the book, I was impressed most by the perfect casting of the characters. They were all more vivid than they were on the page. The story was drastically foreshortened, but the characters blossomed with liveliness.
A compelling and wonderfully acted adaptation of one of the greatest books ever written. I read the book for the second time recently and enjoyed it even more than I did the first time. This is a book that everybody should read in their lives, classic literature doesn't get any better than this. A shame that there were several omissions from the film, most notably the story of The Grand Inquisitor, the story of Father Zosima's life and the subplot involving Ilyusha, but if these were included the film could easily have run for five hours.
I think it is much more important which of the characters you identify with, although, probably like FD, and most people on earth identify themselves to a certain extent with all four Karamazovs.
Thank you for the upload of all three parts. Dostoevsky is difficult to film, since so much must be left out from the novel. But this version boiled down to the basic plot retains enough of the philosophical arguments to make it work. I'm interested now in watching the 1958 version with the US cast, although it's hard to imagine William Shatner as Alyosha.
I enjoyed the 1958 film for what it was. The acting is uniformly excellent with Lee Cobb stealing the show as the dissolute father. Yul Brynner is appropriately brooding, intense and hot headed, Maria Schell is mischievous and entertaining and Claire Bloom is luminous as always. It did a good job summarizing the basic plot in two hours and keeping within the spirit and essence of the novel with some of Doestoevsky’s philosophical elements-mainly the idea of crime being permissible in the absence of a higher authority. It’s kind of hard watching the “confession/re-enaction” scene with Albert Salmi though, knowing how he met his end in real life.
Yeah, Shatner is completely flat as Alyosha ... but Lee J. Cobb is brilliant as Feodor (the father) and makes the whole film worth watching. Now eager to see the Russian version, which I've heard is the real deal.
@@neelabh06 I was referring to this one, which I have since watched. It's very good and, as one might expect, much better on the philosophical ideas of the novel than the Hollywood (Yul Brynner) version. Nonetheless I still think the Hollywood film is quite good. For one thing the plot of this complex tale is made crystal clear.
at first in the novel alyosha was my favourite character, but as i knew more and more about the three brothers, mitya was the one who deeply affected my heart.
Subscribing to the view that each of the brothers represented an aspect of FD's personality/character it is intriguing to consider which of the four he identified with the most...
All of them, at different stages of his life and perhaps simultaneously as well. He ist the father too, mentioning himself as their creator everytime he uses the patronymic Fyodorovich. Fyodor Dostoyevsky/Fyodor Karamasow the father.
Love this movie adaptation because it brings the characters and certain scenes alive. I think one must have read the book to fully understand and appreciate the film but aside from that it was greatly done! To me the magic between Dimitri and Grushenka was very prevalent and the dancing scene with the gypsies gave me a true feeling of how they lived and enjoyed the moment fully. Something I didn’t get when reading the book, this was because I couldn’t picture the enjoyment and liveliness. Rather (when reading) I thought it superficial and annoying for Dimitri chasing Gruschenka and spending all that money on excesses. But this scene I loved very much and I’m thankful for the movie! Anyone else really loved Kolya in the book because I thought he was such a great little character, he was the hope for the future. Much appreciated ❤
I have heard a lot about this novel. something like it is the greatest . even osho loves it and says it has great insight . however i have not read it yet. the movie i did not find anything great as such. i was yawning. hope the novel turns out to be something great and insightful. but i loved the comment of somebody who said . dimitri is bull. ivan is overly intellectual. aluosha is innocent .
Kudos to the cast and the custom designers but It would help to point out that many scenes were not included which made the movie feel very rushed so one is better off reading the book and maybe watching this as a btw,also the descriptions as given in the book do not quite match some of the actors like Alyoshka. It's such a great story that the cut out scenes seem to me such an injustice but i understand it would have been so expensive to include them all but then again if you set out to do something the least you can do is to do it Right and Fully.
It is, but make sure to read the book if you have not already done so because this is NOT the end of the novel. I understand that they had to cut out parts of the story due to runtime (and other logistics like paying actors), but there are a lot of essential scenes and extra characters that are cut out of this adaption. One chapter of the book ("Grand Inquisitor") is studied wholesale on its own in academia, and unfortunately isn't in this adaption. What's here in this adaption is well-portrayed, but you'd regret not experiencing the whole book.
ngl i literally watch the entire thing just wanted to see my baby alyosha interaction with his future husband *cough* i mean, his incorrigible socialist close friend
o my god...what a rollercoaster of thoughts, emotions, images......i am exhausted, weeping and praying...this film is eerily relevant in our today world...
god....or godless......which world do we really think we are living in.....
The acting is simply superb! Ulianov is simply brilliant here.
Watched whole movie through subtitles, as being an Indian I don't understand Russian but these three parts have taught me enough about different aspects of human life.
Wonderful 🙏
The thought of the crime is as punishable as the crime itself.. Dmitry understands that. He gets the deepest sympathy here.
Хвала од Господа! Душа, ум, срце, љубав, живот, смрт....све је ту. Ко разуме Достојевског, спасен је човек. Достојевски, Русија у мом срцу - заувек! Праштајте!
Vesna, sta da prastamo?
Мени грешној опростите сви! Људи, животиње, биљке...сви ....Данас сам се причестила, хвала што се јављате. Од Господа Вам мир, љубав и радост. Срећан Празник1
@@CPE-j1u
@@CPE-j1u potpuno si u pravu.. ja sam '67 godiste, i sjecam se odrastajuci u bivsoj Jugi, ucili su nas da postujemo svakog ko je stariji, a podgotovo strance.. stranci su bili kao bogovi, kao da su bili neka "visa rasa" u odnosu na nas.. sad kad sam u stranoj zemlji shvatam koliko smo grijesili, da nismo bili u pravu.. u stvari, mi smo bili ti koji su bili "visa rasa" u svakom pogledu, prvenstveno po kulturi i nacinu razmisljanja.. stranci ne uce njihovu djecu ljubav, toleranciju, i postivanje, hladni su kao led.. ta ljubav, tolerancija, i postivanje se olici na licu svakog od nas , i ja u stranoj zemlji mogu po licu (faci) da prepoznam koji je sa prostora bivse Juge.. prastanje je nama u krvi, ali sta mi to treba da prastamo, ugnjetavanje i haos koji su nam stranci donosili u svojim pohodima..
Управо тако ❤☦️🙏
Многие через Достоевского пришли к Богу.
That was simply brilliant. Thank you
Brilliant. Thank you Mosfilm.
Unforgettable. Thank you.
This movie is gonna torment me for days, now..
Thank you so much for your work, Mosfilm! Greetings from Germany
Excellent work bringing this brilliant film and work to a wider audience. Many thanks!
Grateful to have seen this! Thank you, Mosfilm!
After five years of reading the great novel, I finally knew the perfect end. I expected nothing less... oh my poor Mitya, my favourite character, you were proven innocent at least in the eyes of those you cared about, poor Ivan, your own anguish thoughts devoured you...
That really ended in Karamasov's fashion.
This is a Marxist spin on a Christian novel. Ivan is not mad.
@@aclark903 what is he to you?
@@aclark903 he literally goes mad?
@@stevowilliams8279 It is a while since I read it tbh.
Dmitri is my favorite too.
Beautiful .
It's been some time since I've read the novel, Dostoviesky is great and reading it is a great experience. I'm not sure what to say about the adaptation, it does recreate many crucial spots and it's difficult to find fault in it. One has to tune to the movie's terms, but that's fine, one as the audience has to participate too, this happens in many forms of art. Surely it can't replace the book, which is perfectly fine too.
I'd say it's a great watch after reading the book, not sure how others would experience it without reading the book. And who cares really? I'm sure these questions come up, and I don't have the answers. Great movie, great to have this people restoring these movies and putting them up for free. I might give the book another read soon also, so in the end, stupid questions aside, this is great actually.
As a big fan of the book, I was impressed most by the perfect casting of the characters. They were all more vivid than they were on the page. The story was drastically foreshortened, but the characters blossomed with liveliness.
@@meofamily4 obviously this was a very serious effort to make justice to the source material. You can't top it, but this adds to it for sure.
A compelling and wonderfully acted adaptation of one of the greatest books ever written. I read the book for the second time recently and enjoyed it even more than I did the first time. This is a book that everybody should read in their lives, classic literature doesn't get any better than this. A shame that there were several omissions from the film, most notably the story of The Grand Inquisitor, the story of Father Zosima's life and the subplot involving Ilyusha, but if these were included the film could easily have run for five hours.
For the Ilyusha subplot you can watch the movie "Boys" ("Мальчики") shot in 1990'ies. Even grandson if Dostoyevsky participates in it.
A powerful ending. It is a great adaption of the great novel.
Way worse than the original ending, though.
magnificent production!!
I want to go home to St. Petersburg, Russia. Have not visited since 2018. I love Russia. I will be back.
@@olgac7610 come to my heart this is your home...
what a masterpiece!
I just saw the part 1 and 2. Thanks.
Kudos. This is a remarkable production.
(Sniffs...) You are greatly appreciated for this wonderful upload ❤
I thought I could not watch a film longer than 4 hours in one shut anymore . I was wrong!
I think it is much more important which of the characters you identify with, although, probably like FD, and most people on earth identify themselves to a certain extent with all four Karamazovs.
So, how was it?
@@gaHuJIa_Macmep I loved it :)
@@gaHuJIa_Macmep I loved it :)
Thank you for the upload of all three parts. Dostoevsky is difficult to film, since so much must be left out from the novel. But this version boiled down to the basic plot retains enough of the philosophical arguments to make it work. I'm interested now in watching the 1958 version with the US cast, although it's hard to imagine William Shatner as Alyosha.
Didn't know there was a US version lol. I guess I should watch it before dunking on it...
I enjoyed the 1958 film for what it was. The acting is uniformly excellent with Lee Cobb stealing the show as the dissolute father. Yul Brynner is appropriately brooding, intense and hot headed, Maria Schell is mischievous and entertaining and Claire Bloom is luminous as always. It did a good job summarizing the basic plot in two hours and keeping within the spirit and essence of the novel with some of Doestoevsky’s philosophical elements-mainly the idea of crime being permissible in the absence of a higher authority. It’s kind of hard watching the “confession/re-enaction” scene with Albert Salmi though, knowing how he met his end in real life.
Yeah, Shatner is completely flat as Alyosha ... but Lee J. Cobb is brilliant as Feodor (the father) and makes the whole film worth watching. Now eager to see the Russian version, which I've heard is the real deal.
@@jhm1313 Which Russian version are you referring to, this one or is there some other one? Please name it so others can benefit as well.
@@neelabh06 I was referring to this one, which I have since watched. It's very good and, as one might expect, much better on the philosophical ideas of the novel than the Hollywood (Yul Brynner) version. Nonetheless I still think the Hollywood film is quite good. For one thing the plot of this complex tale is made crystal clear.
Это великое достояние фильмографии, пронизывающее глубокими чувствами. Иван Пырьев как острейший меч Достоевского
Thank you so much @Mosfilm for uploading this.
Oh my god…incredible. I was expecting it to be good, but I never imagined it would be this good!
This book is one of the most brilliant ever written in history. Masterpiece.
Complete. Such a gift. Thank you.
Omg, that was absolutely amazing.
Thank you so much for this film
Mitia deep Russian soul with so much feelings that he can easily die for anyone
at first in the novel alyosha was my favourite character, but as i knew more and more about the three brothers, mitya was the one who deeply affected my heart.
Everything ha been said in the comments , Masterpiece, Superb Acting.everything and more. Thank you 💐💐💐
A classic of Russian television, worthy of the Academy Award Best Foreign Language Film nomination in 1970 February.
Thank you for making this available.
Subscribing to the view that each of the brothers represented an aspect of FD's personality/character it is intriguing to consider which of the four he identified with the most...
All of them, at different stages of his life and perhaps simultaneously as well. He ist the father too, mentioning himself as their creator everytime he uses the patronymic Fyodorovich. Fyodor Dostoyevsky/Fyodor Karamasow the father.
@@TVDandTrueBlood yes, really!
Beautiful movie
Лучшие фильмы 🍿
Love this movie adaptation because it brings the characters and certain scenes alive. I think one must have read the book to fully understand and appreciate the film but aside from that it was greatly done! To me the magic between Dimitri and Grushenka was very prevalent and the dancing scene with the gypsies gave me a true feeling of how they lived and enjoyed the moment fully. Something I didn’t get when reading the book, this was because I couldn’t picture the enjoyment and liveliness. Rather (when reading) I thought it superficial and annoying for Dimitri chasing Gruschenka and spending all that money on excesses. But this scene I loved very much and I’m thankful for the movie! Anyone else really loved Kolya in the book because I thought he was such a great little character, he was the hope for the future. Much appreciated ❤
I loved Kolya and the other boys in the book, one of my favourite parts!
@@Hippogriffs_Rule yes😊
@@Hippogriffs_Rule Kolya Krasotkin?
@@gaHuJIa_Macmep The one and only!
Wow!
What a work of art !!
Thanks!
I really picture DImitri' and Grushenka's actors in my head when I read the book again, but not so much rest of the cast.
Ну вот и наступили времена когда сцена с Дьяволом стала реальностью.
I want to just say, "Thank You".
Here it is 🎥
Spanish please camaradas
Thanks mosfilm! What about part 1and2 ??
Есть they
They are there under this one
I have heard a lot about this novel. something like it is the greatest . even osho loves it and says it has great insight . however i have not read it yet. the movie i did not find anything great as such. i was yawning. hope the novel turns out to be something great and insightful. but i loved the comment of somebody who said . dimitri is bull. ivan is overly intellectual. aluosha is innocent .
it's alright guys, mitya escaped with grushenka to america.
Magnificent
a pale but great imitation of an incomparable book.
Not so pale, I would say...
Kudos to the cast and the custom designers but It would help to point out that many scenes were not included which made the movie feel very rushed so one is better off reading the book and maybe watching this as a btw,also the descriptions as given in the book do not quite match some of the actors like Alyoshka. It's such a great story that the cut out scenes seem to me such an injustice but i understand it would have been so expensive to include them all but then again if you set out to do something the least you can do is to do it Right and Fully.
por favor subtitulado en español gracias
Is this the last part?
It is. Also this is Dostoyevsky's last novel. He planned to bring the plot further in his next novel, but it was never meant to be.
It is, but make sure to read the book if you have not already done so because this is NOT the end of the novel.
I understand that they had to cut out parts of the story due to runtime (and other logistics like paying actors), but there are a lot of essential scenes and extra characters that are cut out of this adaption. One chapter of the book ("Grand Inquisitor") is studied wholesale on its own in academia, and unfortunately isn't in this adaption.
What's here in this adaption is well-portrayed, but you'd regret not experiencing the whole book.
В романе изображен великий, неугасимый дух России
Эти слова лишены смысла.
please post a 4th part🫂
Is this the final part of the series?
Yes, unfortunately.
Wow, Son of Man's given Right to forgive as shall inherit Earth. Soviet Russia hasn't seen such anywhere in Freemason archive.
Tempted human after lusts as Tempter Devils too blinded see God found bodily a life fixated..
The director took a lot of liberties with that.
Where is the last part. Death of Ilyusha. His funeral. +They find a way to escape Mitka to US.
For this you have to watch another movie, title "Мальчики" ("Boys"), year 1990, it's available on UA-cam. Also a very good adaptation.
❤
Amigos de moslim, por favor en español. Gracias
THANKS RUSIA.....
ngl i literally watch the entire thing just wanted to see my baby alyosha interaction with his future husband *cough* i mean, his incorrigible socialist close friend
Wait explain
🙋♀️🇵🇪👌🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻💎💫💰👍🏻💖✨️1/8/24.
Look at russian soul and russian strength.
please post a 4th part🫂
❤