Vocal Coach Reacts Encanto - Waiting On A Miracle | WOW! She was...
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 січ 2022
- Check out this Vocal Coach Reacts Encanto - Waiting On A Miracle! Watch and learn to sing like Mirabel Madrigal as this singing teacher breaks down the vocal styles and techniques from this Lin Manuel Miranda penned Disney hit.
Now let's sing something! La La La!
‼️⚠️Join my ENCANTO Watch Party on my Patreon!
bit.ly/3NGUa6m
‼️⚠️We Don’t Talk About Bruno was BLOCKED by YT so I made it available right now on my Patreon for all tiers:
bit.ly/3NGUa6m
🎵⚠️ Think you CAN'T SING, but wish you knew HOW??
Join my Karaoke Club!!
We host live Masterclasses, get feedback on your singing videos, vocal warm up drills, and just hang out with me!
👉 www.SingWithAudrey.com
✅ Check out my website for online singing lessons and DISCOUNTS:
👉 www.SongsFromaSuitcase.com
❓🤔 WANT TO IMPROVE YOUR VOICE FAST? You need the QUICK FIX course!!
👉 songsfromasuitcase.com/quickfix/
❓🤔 WANT TO SING? ...THINK YOU CAN'T?!
Sign up today for private voice lessons exclusively with Audrey:
👉 songsfromasuitcase.com/one-on...
🎥 Get my PRIVATE FEEDBACK on a video of you singing:
👉 www.wisio.com/sfas
📸 Get more behind the scenes footage and sneak peeks on my IG:
👉 / songsfromasuitcase
Vocal Coach Reacts Encanto:
• Vocal Coach Reacts Enc...
WATCH PARTY:
/ @7deadlybananas
⚠Watch the FULL MOVIE w/screen and audio! Come watch it with me!
👉 bit.ly/3NGUa6m
You should react to the Spanish versions to Encanto Soundtrack, are really really good!!
I thought you would find it amusing, since you were talking about how the Mirabel actress nasalizes her character, this interview about Galaxy Quest (around 0:40s) talks about how the actor used "the seven resonators" to inform his alien species voice
ua-cam.com/video/Y2d04uKZiQ8/v-deo.html
Fun fact: Stephanie Beatriz, who played Mirabel was actually in Labor when she sang this song!
React to DICE by NMIXX MBC music festival
I really appreciate that this song doesn’t go extremely high. It’s alto friendly. Personally, the ending “miracle” high note was enough climax for me. Like that one note makes me wanna cry lol. The context also helps, because she’s the only one without a power, making her a more “normal” or “relatable” character. So her voice being imperfect and not an open belt makes her different from the typical powerhouses we see in musicals. I felt like I could be her. That’s what I appreciate about this song 💕
I don't know if the songs originally written that way or if they just really loved Stephanie Beatriz as Maribel and then brought the songs into her range ( I think it's probably hard for her to sing those higher notes so they wanted the songs to be comfortable for her), but I really like the way they did it too.
@@crownmagus8291 I've seen somewhere on the internet that it was pretty intentional to make the songs more 'singable' to add to the relatablenss of the movie. I can't really remember the source so I might be making this up.
I’m an alto and can’t sing her super high note at the end. Luckily, my son is seven years old and always happy to step in for that part 😆
Honestly, every song in this movie is so lovingly crafted and my family can’t get enough of any of them. Each song lends itself beautifully to real emotions that everyone can relate to, and that’s why it’s my favorite Disney movie.
It also still sounds like mirabel as she’s singing which is hard for voice actors that sing to stay that character while singing.
I agree. Everything is sooooo soprano based and everyone can't sing that high. I find myself being able to sing all these songs to perfection because they are more alto based songs which is extremely rare.
This is NOT the "Let it Go" of Encanto. Let it go was a song about freedom, this is a song about being trapped. Elsa sang more open and upbeat at the end because she was finally free. Everything about Mirabel is tight. She hides her feelings, she puts on a brave face, she tries so hard to just be part of her family. This song is her want song. Her voice is tight because of the pain behind the words. I honestly hear her on the verge of tears through the beginning of the song. It is an amazing portrayal of how emotion changes everything, ESPECIALLY your voice.
THIS
wait who said this was the let it go of encanto?
Compared to "I want" songs from other Disney movies, this one is just not very strong.
@@videomissionary I think this song is very different from other Disney 'I want' songs, so it is hard to compare. It has a raw feel to it, which is a change from most Disney songs.
@@sarahkwast1250 you're right, they can't be compared. But the likes of Ariel, Mulan, Belle, and Simba are just in another league compared to sweet Mirabel [strictly speaking about their I Want songs]
Gonna have to STRONGLY disagree with you on that last opinion. Not every song like this needs to have a big progression and massive belt to be amazing and beautiful. This song feels much more real and personal than Let it Go. Don’t get me wrong I love Let it Go but there’s a lot about her coming out of her shell finally in a space where she can be free after so long while Waiting On a Miracle is Mirabel still stuck… wanting to let it out but being forced to keep it all in to please the family like Elsa did before her big song. There’s sentimental value to it being more “flat” supposedly and down to earth while Let It Go is the thing we all wish we could do but it’s super showy and over the top
yeah i think she shouldn’t say such things without actually watching the movie. the song is perfect and fits well.
YESSSS
Spot on! I could ot agree more. Contextualizing the piece makes a hug difference. I find this song is underrated. I think Beatriz's performance works because it fits Mirabel exactly.
Not to mention that wasn’t another factor to not belting because of the character voice? Like how most of the singing was kind (i forgot the word) of, “in character” throughout the movie. Whether that’s Mirabel or anyone else. I’m no expert, but I assume you can only go so high and away from that chosen voice (the “up in the nose” voice) when singing without kind of “losing” it🤷♀️
I agree. The song fit the situation. I feel like she took this out of context, comparing it to other movies when they were not in the same metaphorical boat. Bringing up lin manuel miranda was just a low blow too. Burn from hamilton was just as pulling as She used to be mine. Thats just her opinion.
With Lin-Manuel Miranda coaching her, I can almost promise you there's a reason she sings at the same note for each repetition of "Open your eyes." The whole song is her singing about waiting and being stuck in one place and never being able to move forward from the moment that has so far defined her life. That's probably something to do with it.
Yeah, as well as in “Burn” there were more dynamic and growing version first, but Lin Manuel Miranda had to remake it cause it didn’t fit to Eliza’s character and to the fact that she forgave Alexander later.
I almost feel like it's supposed to show her feeling stuck in place or like she's been trying to say it over and over and over.
Yeah agreed, people have to remember also that Mirabel's character is a child. She's only 15 years old and honestly despite the fact she's not belting it out it's still one of the most emotional songs I've ever heard from a Disney movie. I get very teary half way through this song every time. Sometimes belting out a song is not right for a character for several reasons and I just feel they got it right with this song
Yes it’s similar to “what’s beyond that line, will I cross that line” and “this island” getting rhymed many times to itself in Moana. It’s indicating a feeling of being stuck
@@Wigfield84 I think in the case of moana it was more her anticipation building since during the song she starts getting on the boat. But I absolutely agree for this song it’s to indicate she feels stuck in her position
The imperfections of this song in my opinion are what make it so relatable. I cried during this song in the film because for me the way she was singing it was so down to earth. I felt like I could sing it too.
That said I understand your criticisms of the song. I just think that, at least in this particular instance, the way the song was made for the movie and what they were trying to say perfectly.
Agree 💯
I think the repeated 'open your eyes, open your eyes' part is sung the same pitch each time and doesn't build because that's the point; she's constantly trying to get people to notice what she's trying to do and help and she's constantly overlooked, especially by her grandmother (who she's singing to in that moment); she's banging her head against a brick wall and not getting through to them, so I think it's a conscious decision to have the melody hang like that. The whole thing is an 'I want' song, for absolute sure, but there's a further layer of absolute frustration and hurt given to her by her family as well compared to something like Go The Distance or Part Of Your World
Abuela is always telling them open their eyes to share the miracle with them. But come the end I think she realized the miracle wasn’t hers and she had to open HER eyes to see it’s for the family entire. Open your eyes is a recurring theme in the movie. I think everyone in a family wants to feel seen and to be loved for who they are. So I totally agree with you on this!
I feel like it’s more obvious (that it’s not just “Let it go”, and more “I want” + extra frustration and emotion) at the end, where is she ends with a whisper. THAT. You just know it’s not “Let it go”, but instead a depressed teen who’s admitting to the fact that, yes. They may be a little depressed.
Well part of your world is by Mencken,
And Miranda is something very different.
@@margicates553 * Alan Menken
So, this is my take. Lin is good at interpreting the character. The constant battle of pulling and pushing. This is in Burn, Waiting on a Miracle and Wait for it. Specially Wait for it, you can hear it here too. Like you said, you want them to let it GO! but they can't, without risking family or tradition, or society. The song and the melody gives you that frustration of wanting to do something and cant do it.
Your analysis is perfect. As an audience we genuinely feel their frustration, and it’s a clever bit of manipulation!
I also feel like Burn shouldn’t be like super she used to be mine belt-y like she described, I feel like the way Burn is written fits Elizas character.
Note him being good at interpreting the character becomes super prominent when you know that Lin actually asked to be a part of the making of the movie as early as possible to the point he actually had a big hand in shaping the story (The two co-directors and Lin shared how being a part of a big family shaped them, thus making the family the core part of the narrative, and Lin inspired the setting because of his general background culturally. That last bit is not 100% accurate hence general.)
Yes! The reason Lin is a songwriter that even some people who normally don’t like musicals tend to latch onto, is because he writes songs to fit the characters… the character always comes first. He sits in the character and writes until it sounds true. It isn’t always gonna make the most technically perfect song then, but it will be extremely relatable and honest.
I think this song perfectly fits Mirabels character. Compared to Elsa and let it go, Mirabel is still a child and this song is about her trying to be honest with herself about how she truly feels. And how she feels is kinda sad and lonely in a way. I really don’t think this was meant to or needed to be a big belting moment.
The fact that Stephanie recorded this song WITH CONTRACTIONS it’s just WOW!!
To those, who might have not catch that. She was in active labour while recording the song. Which makes it even more powerful if you think that she was really literally waiting for one of the greatest miracles to happen. Words "I am ready! Come on I'm ready!" and later "Bless me now" have a completely new power once you realise that!
WOWWWWW
It doesnt mean if she sings it higher it will make much better. The way she sang is so relatable and beautiful. The imperfection of it.
Yeah it really makes it clear that she’s imperfect and that’s ok
Maybe she likes higher note songs.. I don’t blame her I love songs with high notes
I adore this song, annd I love Stephanie´s performance.
Her voice isn´t flawless and perfect in it, but it´s also not supposed to.
It´s an emotionally charged moment for Mirabel, so from a character standpoint it makes sense that she isn´t singing perfectly.
I think specifically in the very beginning you can hear that very well with "I´m not fine. I´m not fine."
I have to disagree, frozen and encanto are two different feelings and scenarios story. I feel that for the feelings and cultural background, this song hits the spot very well
I feel when most people say this is the "Let it Go!" of Encanto they mean it's the standard "finding yourself" that Disney is known for. Where they have a principal character belt out their intentions or shed what's holding them back. It's a trope for musicals, but in terms of voice Idina Menzel is pretty nasal in Let it Go (she gets so much better in Into the Unknown and Show Yourself), but then again Elsa's a grown woman while Mirabel is a 15 year old who has a high nasal based voice. I think the parts where you hear the open vocals here are Stephanie Beatriz's real vocals.
well, Elsa was 18 in the first movie, younger than Luiza (19), Delores(20), and Isabella(21), but older than Mirabelle(15), Camillo(15-16), and Antonio(5)
@@digitool5944 Elsa was 21 when she became Queen. She was 18 when her parents died.
@@Jayde419 that seems weird, because generally a queen would be crowned asap, which would be at 18
@@digitool5944 just rewatch the movie and see for yourself :/
"what else I can do "is more the "let it go "in terms of emotions
“im wanting more from it” lmao thats the whole point 😂 Mirabel wants more, but she doesnt know how to do it. Let It Go ‘grew’ because she was running away and trying to find her place. Mirabel literally COULDNT ‘grow’ because she was stuck, both metaphorically with her singing and physically, in her family dynamic.
Mirabel is WAITING for something to come to her at this point in the movie, Elsa was proactive in her actions and her voice.
Exactly what I was going to say. There is a narrative reason to the choice. We need to feel where Mirabel is coming from. Day after day she's frustrated and searching for a change.
i personally didn’t mind that the song lacked a huge modulation or development with this song, the song and how she sings makes it feel like she’s trapped in the shadow she’s in, uncertain of when or even if she will get the chance to go beyond her limits and expand
I personally feel this song is so much better than let it go because it feels more real and emotional. That closed off sound I felt it was because she’s choking down her pain which of course made me personally emote and connect way more to the song than let it go
I think judging these songs/singers outside the context of the film’s narrative misses the mark. A good song in a film reveals something about the character and advances the narrative. I don’t know much about Stephanie Beatriz’ singing background but I think this song appropriately conveys Mirabel’s pent up pain and childhood trauma. A triumphant vocal as in Let it Go or plaintive yearning like Part or Your World would not work here.
She appeared in the heights so she has worked with Lin before plus he had a cameo on Brooklyn 99 so they are good friends. She is an accomplished singer, actor as well as a trained dancer. Having heard how good her voice is on in the heights it's clear to me this performance was character driven and not a testament to just how well she can belt out a song. Mirabel is only 15 years old and honestly I feel this is much more emotional than it would have been had she been really stretching her vocal chords. Also wanted to add that she suffers with very severe astigmatism and is actually legally blind, she has achieved extraordinary things regardless of this. Watch brooklyn 99, she is an absolute badass
I love that Encanto is the first Disney movie (I think) to give Altos the Melody!
And the reason why I think it lacks open chest is because Stephanie, who’s a grown woman, has to try to sing like a 15 year old, which *is Mirabel’s age* .
Lin has written an “I want” song that is slightly better…. “How Far I’ll Go” from Moana. So he can do it.
omg i TOTALLY FORGOT about how far ill go! lin KILLED that soundtrack
it's because she's really trying to transfer the emotion of mirabel being really upset and almost in tears which we do get more nasally when that happens, it's not as open or pretty, but fits the moment way more, she's very capable of sounding pretty and open, but it was an acting choice not to to keep it more emotionally impactful bc you won't sound pretty when you're so hurt
I think this is one of those times where seeing the song in its full context helps a ton.
i think this song interpreted Mirabel’s character very well. It doesn’t have to compare to Elsa. Try watching the movie maybe :))
thank you omg
Think it's important to add that Elsa is an adult , in the first Frozen movie she is 21 years old while Mirabel is very much still a child being that she is only 15 years old. Honestly I feel like it was a good move on Lin's part and it made Mirabel more relatable and believable
In my opinion this isn’t the Let it Go for Encanto, it’s What Else Can I Do. Those songs are very thematically similar, all about the character letting go and embracing who they really are.
I actually wasn't sure how I felt about Waiting On a Miracle at first, but I came to love it after listening to it a few times. You're right that it isn't really as "belty" as some other major Disney ballads, but I guess that didn't bother me too much. There's a lot of emotion in Stephanie Beatriz's voice, I think. She has a more nasally tone here for sure, but she's warm and real and raw. And that moment when she gets on the roof and sings, "I am ready! Come on, I'm ready!" I get chills.
It's more nasally and less belly because she's a child, Elsa is an adult so I don't think they really are comparable. Mirabel's vocals I feel were more believable and relatable for her character
@@jackwhitbread4583 To be fair though, I wonder if that's just how Stephanie Beatriz sounds. Mirabel's voice actress is an adult, and from what I've heard of her singing and speaking outside the film, she does use more of a nasally tone. So while I will agree that the tone lends itself well to the character, I think the real reason might just have more to do with the actors' voices.
I think she sounded really nice. The voice fit the tone of the song. I think that she doesn't build during the segment about "Open your eyes" because nobody IS opening their eyes to her. It's also a mirror between nobody seeing her and her not seeing herself.
Also this song was recorded while her voice actress was in labor so honestly, this is just amazing how it is.
It's kind of a rude thing to say, but I feel like you completely misunderstood the point of this song(
It's a character moment, and a low one at that. This isn't Let it go, Mirabelle isn't realising anything new about herself, she doesn't get any new powers. She is kind of stuck in place with her life and other's opinions on her, and she is desperate to get out of this. But through this song she realises that she simply can't change her situation with just a wish, and... kind of gives up. That's why the song is repetitive in some places and doesn't resolve in big finale: because the issue isn't resolved. It's still here, and as long as it's there, Mirabelle can't fully let go and move on, so the whole song feels uncomfortably tense
Its not rude its her opinion and her analysis
@@sixteen.candles.4644 I was saying that my statement was kinda rude
Encanto songs resonated with me a lot more than any of the songs from Frozen. I’m more tied to it because of the message and the emotions.
I believe in an interview Lin said that he set this song specifically in 3/4th time rather than 4/4th time like the rest of the songs to show Mirabel’s disconnect from the rest of her family
What amuses me about this analysis is it’s picking apart how Mirabel’s performance isn’t where it could be. And I can only conclude that that’s on purpose because that perfectly describes her character at this point in the story. Not good enough, feeling unheard and undervalued. But her being tight and closed up makes absolutely perfect sense for where she is in her story. Context matters, and it feels like LMM is several steps ahead of us here.
As many have said; I think the imperfections are what makes this song so perfect. I think both showcase their characters extremely well; which is why they can't be judged the same. It's like judging two different people expecting them to have the same shine.
The point is that her vocals are suppose to fit the character, Mirabel. It doesn't need to be all like Elsa Let It Go and crazy. It's nice with something new and not all extreme.
Well… to be fair: Let it Go was written for Idina Menzel, a powerhouse in belty high tone explosive songs. This song was written for someone who doesn’t really have that range, so it doesn’t go as grand as Let It Go. She naturally has a lower, nasal voice. Essentially, we are comparing a song made specifically for a professional theatrical singer and one made for an actress who happens to have a nice voice. Not a good comparison.
I’ll just say that the moment she goes “I’m ready cmon I’m ready, I’ve been patient and steadfast and steady” it gives me chills. Mostly because I didn’t expect her to go that high and powerful at that moment.
Yes!! Not to mention Beatriz recorded this song while in labor.
the nasal aspect of Mirabel's voice is intentional. I think they wanted her voice to sound moe realistic for a 15 year old, being that the average 15-year-old is not going to be a broadway-style singer. It makes the song and the movie even moe brilliant tbh. Great video though!
A song doesn't have to be 'belty' to be good. I'm honestly tired of big belty numbers, they feel lazy at this point, everyone is doing it and using high notes to denote a climax, a climax can be more subtle than that. It's so refreshing to hear a song that showcases the protagonist's character and wants without having a million high notes.
I wouldn’t say this is the “Let It Go” of Encanto. The 𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘭 “LIG” of this movie is Isabela’s “What Else Can I do?”. This is bc both characters, Elsa and Isabela, are doing the same thing (don’t know if you’ve watched Encanto yet, so I don’t wanna spoil too much😅).
the imperfections in this song are what make the song so great, for the simple reason that it will stand out in the Disney I Want song compilations
i think you are a bit too harsh on this song. I wouldn't compare it to let it go. let it go has a trained broadway singer doing the singing. While Indina did a fantastic job as elsa we don't really relate to elsa nearly as much as mirabel. Stephanie has a normal vocal range that the average person can hit while Indina's pitch would take a lot of training to hit. if you watch the movie you will see there is build up to the song. Mirabel is an outcast in her family and shes portraying how hurt she is in the song you can hear the pain in her voice so there's no need to belt it's a song about being hurt and wanting to fit in with her family. The same with burn. in burn it's not meant to be belty it's another hurt song and the actors need to be actors first and portray that emotion over having the perfect range.
Yeah I tend to agree while I like those songs where people really belt it out. That kind of song wouldn't actually fit here. Because the character is battling with too much insecurity and anxiety (from being compared to her sisters and cousins) for her to let loose and belt the song out at this point. I think in fact this is why so many who struggle with these things relate to this song because you can see she's not confident enough to literally "Let it Go" yet.
If they were to make a sequel with songs in it. That's where I'd be thinking a belting song from her would make sense, as she's growing in confidence. And there's so much possibility with the story for sequels or maybe a Disney animated series to happen.
@@Loulizabeth 100% agree. If theres a sequal there will be room for bigger songs but this movie had the most relatable songs in a disney movie I've ever heard.
@@toriacrouse2449 I think she was referring to the scenes and the whole vibe of the song, it can be easily compared to let it go the “I want to do” kind of song
@@RAnonimo its not a huge i want song though its more of a im hurting. Which has fans relating. The want is to please her family so it's type of song. Let it go was letting go of fear. She said she wants belts but this song isn't meant for belts. shes hurting and looking for validation. Shes not looking for a big journey she just wants to be seen by her abuela like the rest of the family.
I think this was my favorite song in the entire movie. I've genuinely never related to a Disney song as much as I have this. I love the way Mirabel sounds like she's practically bursting at the seams. She's holding in her tears but just barely. Like when you're trying to talk to someone about something personal and your voice starts to crack because you're on the verge of crying.
I'd say it's more closed because her character is trying to hold back tears as she's singing
The thing is when it come to the songs I feel like Lin wants us to relate to these characters and not worry about how loud they can sing it’s all about the meaning of the song
The thing about this performance that always comes to mind every time I hear it, is that Stephanie Beatriz was in labour as she was recording it (I’m guessing the early stages as really she should have been on her way to a hospital), and I don’t know if it’s just me, but that real life emotion just bleeds in to the emotion of the performance.
It does!! It’s not just you.
@@CliffRichardFan2001 I’m embarrassed to say that outside of Brooklyn 99 I didn’t really know much about Stephanie Beatriz before watching Encanto (I live in the UK, there’s only so much US stuff that gets exported over). But, from ‘The Family Madrigal’ until the end my jaw was on the floor. She is such an amazing talent and an all round wonderful human being. And her singing in Encanto was able to bring me to tears of both laughter and emphatic sadness.
Fun fact: the part of "open your eyes, open your eyes, open your eyes, I would move the mountains" was all done in one breath.
Bonus: this is the only song done in 3/4 cadence, all the rest are in 4/4. Lin-Manuel said it was to make a point that she out of order with the rest of the family
I think this song is placed very well, with the held back motif, as Mirabel herself is held back by her desire to have a gift, and held back in her potential by her family.
It's not a 'let it go' where she would grow, more closed but also so mucb more unsure of how or what to achieve.
I know you were looking for something big and epic, but personally this song moved me much more than “let it go“ ever did. And I do love that song, “let it go“. The lyrics and the delivery struck a chord with me. To the point where I was surprised you had any criticism of it. See you love you!
I thought it was a nice touch that "Open your eyes" was sung directly to Abuela.
I think the whole movie was really a quest story about earning the respect of the matriarch.
Contextualization is what makes this song perfect.
I am very satisfied with the story and how some Colombian musical genres were captured. This song has influences from Pasillo and Bambuco, two musical genres from the interior of Colombia.
If you watch the making of Encanto videos you will see this song was meant to be an anti Disney Princess song. The character isn’t a perfect “princess” so neither is her hero song. There is a perfect ballad in the movie, it’s in Spanish but the language doesn’t matter, it’s so emotional you know what it’s saying. Lin wrote that one because it fit the grandparents story and he wanted to make us all cry (Dos Orguguitas).
Don’t want to wait??? Watch this video RIGHT NOW on my Patreon account:
bit.ly/3NGUa6m
Waiting on a Miracle and Let it Go has a different context, you can see that clearly wherein Elsa was smiling since she's finally free like she has nothing to hide anymore. Whereas Mirabel is still waiting on a miracle, it's an emotional song and an emotional song well not all songs need to have that belting part. The climax of the song is just fine and the fact that a lot of us cried in this part says it all.
Fun Fact. When Stephanie Beatriz recorded this SHE WAS IN LABOUR with her first baby. 🤯
it's entirely possible her holding back was on purpose. it's not easy to notice right off the bat because you're focusing on her, but she's singing to herself. the first two lines actually showcase what she's doing really well; "don't be upset or mad at all. don't feel regret or sad at all"
she's telling herself to not feel what she's feeling. to lock it away and hide it from everyone. she wants to convince people that she's okay when she isn't. she's holding back. literally, and musically.
she's expressing to _herself_ that she's upset, that she's angry and sad, and doesn't understand what makes her so worthless compared to everyone else. but not to anyone else.
this song isn't supposed to be "correct" or whatever you wanna call it. these songs are almost entirely done with the character in mind. at least for me, I think that's why it feels like their songs. this song _feels_ like Mirabel in a way I can't explain. in the same way Surface Pressure feels like Luisa, or how What Else Can I Do feels like Isabela. the music is fit for them in a unique way. that's why Lin had them sing in a specific way too.
I also don't think it's that fair to compare this song with Let it Go either. it's different in almost every way. the singers are different. Idina has been doing musicals for a long time and has a very specific, trained voice and range that's hard to hit. plus she is portraying a grown woman. Stephanie is an alto that is singing more in an alto range, in a character-driven song, that is portraying a fifteen-year-old girl. Elsa in the movie is LETTING GO of her grievances and moving on. Mirabel is not. she's expressing her grievances but she isn't moving on, because like I said before, she's still holding back and not telling anyone what's wrong. this goes along with her only being fifteen. she's still a child and she's still living at home. still very much under the bonds of her family. if anything, What Else Can I Do is more of a "Let It Go" song.
This song reminds me of "Legally Blonde" from Legally Blonde the musical...I don't think it was meant to be an "I Want Song"
They gave us "What Else Can I Do" instead as the uplifting inspirational song...
I think hearing it in context would make more sense that there isn’t a huge build and send off. It isn’t her “coming into herself” type moment like let it go was for frozen. She’s still in her feelings and feeling like she has something to prove, she didn’t have that full break through so she doesn’t get to that point with the music either. I feel like it was a very deliberate choice.
even though i partially agree with the lin manuel part (and you were able to put into words why it took me a bit more of time to love burn) i do really think in THIS case it was the better option. mirabel is the only "common" person of the family, seen as the weakest link in the chain. so it makes a lot of sense for her character to be more average as a singer. having a let it go time would break that perception of mediocrity (despite mirabel is everything but mediocre)
I think some of these vocal and song choices are going to make a lot more sense once you watch the entire movie in order. I personally think they fit for the character and what is happening in her life and how she is feeling at this point in the story.
i personally love the nasally sound to her voice
The repetitive "Open Your Eyes" is my fave part, it's so different!
I love this song😌 I always thought that the nasal sort of singing went with her emotions like holding back her tears (I hope u know what I mean it's hard to describe) then at the end she belts the last high note and it's like she calmed down and is able to actually do something and she's not gonna cry she's going to go forward with her chin held high. Also I would of disliked it if it had 'stronger' vocals than it does, I love all the songs in this film as they are. They're more relatable and more realistic ect than old Disney films (tho I love a lot of their music too) expecially knowing what this movie is about and stuff it just makes more sense. Each character has a style which I definitely like since they aren't making their voice sound different than their normal voice and it goes with their character (if that makes sense) anyway good video but I do disagree with many of your points but each to your own😁
I'd be interested in your thoughts on the voice placement she uses here vs. what she's using in All Of You, at the end, where I feel like she's using a more forward, open placement, as if she's using the placement to mark Mirabel's growth not only internally but in her relationships with her family.
I also think keeping the same note on "open your eyes" was deliberate because she's pleading with her abuela over and over again to just take a moment to see Mirabel, and there's a "stuck" emotion behind it that's being communicated there.
I ABSOLUTELY agree with your assessment. I kept waiting for that song to open up and grow and was felt left really wanting. I mean, there are so many bits and pieces of it that are incredibly beautiful and they just dont quiet get the support they need.
I believe that's was the purpose they did that, the reason the song didn't open up and grow was to reflect Mirabel's character and how she feels being the outcast for not having powers. She feels constrained, so the music reflected that.
Definitely not the 'Let It Go' of this movie, that honor goes to 'What Else Can I Do?', which I think absolutely blew Let It Go away. At least in lyrical content and story payout. Elsa sang an empowering song and then... hid in her room, except this time it was a castle. Maybe if she'd had Anna there to encourage her like Mirabel did Isabelle, they'd have had a lot less drama and heartache.
I feel like this song was more held back on purpose. In this scene she's feeling so many things, hurt, angry, frustrated, forgotten and i feel like the tone chosen for the song really gets that across
You stated that you didn't listen to the songs from Encanto in order so I want to point that Waiting On A Miracle! is an "answer song" to the opening song The Family Madrigal in the first song Mirabel sings about how everyone in the Family Madrigal is "Fantasical and Magical" and how great is it to be part of the Family, in Waiting On A Miracle she exclaims "I'm Not Fine." and expresses how she really feels.
I can really hear Lin-Manuel Miranda in this song too… thats “Can’t control the morning rain or a hurricane” is sooo him. And in one of the last songs “we see how bright you burn-“ really sounds like him as well. I just love how much he shines through like that.
4:02
Can’t lie every time you did the closed nasal talk/singing it cracked me up 😂👏
Another great reaction, I liked that you kept it real!
Not fake liking something just to not get the viewers upset.
A think a big reason this i gravitate towards this song so much is because Stephanie Beatriz was actually having contractions/in labour while recording this song, she was having her miracle. Which I think is beautiful.
MIRABEL DESERVES MORE
I think it's definitely a character thing. Stephanie Beatriz has a relatively deep voice and the voice she does for Mirabel is higher and brighter than her normal voice
I screamed in the theater when I realized it's Rosa from Brooklyn Nine-Nine!!!
Totally agree with you!! Hearing it from a vocal coach feels so validating
I've been singing since I was 4 and as a singer I love your videos you catch things that I've just never picked up in down to the smallest details it helps a lot. I've been trying to use it on my own voice so thank you
I love EVERYTHING about Mirabel’s tone when singing this song-you can just FEEL the tears she’s trying to hold back and the desperation and pain and hopelessness. I cry every time I hear this song without fail.
In the defense of "Burn" in Hamilton, there's actually an original version called "First Burn", and that one was more belty and loud, but they changed it to the current version, and i think I know why and i think it was for the best. The current version makes Eliza sound more sad, tired, and just utterly done with Hamilton, like she's so tired she doesn't even want to spend energy getting extremely angry at him, which I think was the preferred emotion Lin wanted Eliza to portray. She's withdrawing from the situation ("I'm erasing myself from the narrative") because she's just done. If they went with "First Burn" it would've made her sound more vengeful and hateful about the situation. While the angry cheated-on spouse is a justifiable reaction, exploding in anger isn't a part of Eliza's gentle character in my opinion, so "First Burn" would've felt kind of out of place, so they changed it to sound more soft. But both are honestly really good and are both favorites of mine
we also need to keep in mind that the singer was in labor during the recording of this song
Y’all should watch the Encanto cast guessing Disney songs on IGN’s UA-cam channel. There’s this moment (only a few seconds) where Stephanie sings a song from The Little Mermaid. It’s an entirely different side of her voice. She continues to surprise
"what else can i do" is more like encanto 'let it go'
Let it go was a song about finding herself and its positive. This one is not, she's admitting she doesn't know who she is or what she's supposed to do making it a sad song. That's why it didn't build up as much as let it go, this one was supposed to leave a deeper longing ending as she herself is longing for acceptance.
Waiting on a Miracle isn't the Let it Go of Enchanto, that's What Else Can I Do. Let it Go is a song about freedom that's been attained while Waiting on a Miracle is about being trapped and wishing to be free.
I think we were supposed to feel a little let down and wanting for more because that's how Meirbel felt when she didn't get her gift and how she's feeling now.
I would argue that the level of nasal-ness in Mirabel’s voice is indicative of where she is in her (and the hero’s) journey. The songs at the beginning of the movie are more nasally because the conflict of Mirabel’s character is still present. This song has a heavy nasal sound, probably the most of the movie’s tracks, because it’s addressing the heart of Mirabel’s conflict and what’s preventing her from reaching her potential (or at least desired potential for her). She’s the only one in her family without a gift and therefore is left out and held back (like the full sound in her voice) by a sense of inferiority and by her abuela (perhaps unintentionally) singling her out as the weak and flawed link since she can’t perform miracles like the rest of her family. That nasal sound gets stronger as the conflict grows. But in the end, as the conflict gets resolved, the sound of her voice is opened up and gets fuller
This song got a Lin's signature writing and I got a vibe of Breath from In the Height too
I'm a fan of Lin and yet I could agree with your opinion, it does lack a bit open heart open chest yk hahahah. Love your reactions!
Then you may not like it that much because that big belting solo number this isn’t that type of movie I believe it’s more subdued on purpose
I think it fits. Mirabel is very self- contained, and like the one person in the family that is holding everything together. Once she comes into her power, the dysfunctional family dynamic isn't working anymore and they build it on a new healthier foundation.
It's ok to say what you think that's why I'm subscribed to your channel. Yeah I do agree that this song lacked what you said (I was used to more songs like let it go type of build up) but then weirdly it got stuck in my head and now I cannot stop singing it 😭
You need to listen to “What else can I do?” Beautiful voice and the music 🤩🤩❤️
It's always kind of funny to hear people claim Lin-Manuel Miranda's his music isn't good enough. Especially when they can't even DREAM of being at his level. *Lin-Manuel has a MacArthur Genius Grant, a Pulitzer, and multiple Grammys, Emmys and Tonys. And most likely, next month, he will have an Oscar for music AND directing.* But, sure, he's not good at writing these songs. 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Anyhoo, Mirabel's "I Want" song is sung in that way because of her character trying to find out who she is. She is the only one in the entire Madrigal family who doesn't have a special gift. She loves her family and supports them but felt left out BECAUSE she doesn't have a gift. *You have to watch the whole movie to understand the moment that led her to sing this song. If you do, you'll fully understand why she sings it in this way.* 🤗🥰🎵
Isabella's song was the 'let it go' song for sure.
I got more frozen vibes from Isabela’s song. Especially when she had the different colors coming off of her hands like how Elsa did with ice/snow. Also, heard this from UA-cam, when Isabela broke her one statue it was kinda like when Elsa broke the Hans ice sculpture.
Fun fact about Encanto. During the song “waiting on a miracle” the voice actress for Mirabel went into labor and didn’t tell anyone until she finished the song.
Holy S that true talent
You have an awesome voice and you’re beautiful too that’sa great mix keep up ur good work
I feel like maybe for this song, she had that tight back placement kinda to show like she was holding back from crying, emphasizing that she's not fine
This song is the song to show how trapped she is. It’s more of the movie not a song.
4:14 I did the exercise and my cat ran up to me, concerned meowing 😹
Stephanie Beatriz was over 9 months pregnant and in active labor while she was recording this. She didn’t tell anyone until afterwards. She had her baby girl 2 days later. 💕🦋✨
She was literally waiting on a miracle!
I actually like that her voice doesn’t have a lot of growth to it in this song. As the story progresses, her voice changes and grows more open. It reflects her character growth. In this scene she’s still a bit more immature and self-centered (in terms of not seeing the pressures and issues other family members are facing).
I think you kinda missed the point , she wasn’t selfish for not seeing her family’s problems . They were HIDING their problem . She was the one who got them to open up. Its not her fault others were hiding it
Was agreeing until you said self centered. She had a whole song about her family to AVOID talking about herself. She is absolutely the opposite of a self centered character. None of the family seen eachothers struggles not just mirabel
@@lilac3266 she hides her emotions from Antonio so he will have be happy , literally so kind
@@yeeeeeeeeeeeeeee_ya5786 fr mirabel is like the least self centered person in that family she even had the courage to relive the worst night of her life just because she wanted to help antonio :(
@@lilac3266 I know , she’ll do anything for her family even if it hurts her . How is that selfish ?
U should react to dos oruguitas (Spanish version aka normal version) from encanto and also look up what the lyrics mean its beautiful!
totally can relate to this song all the time❤❤❤❤❤❤😢
I love seeing your facial expressions at about 1:20. Even though you haven’t seen the movie you recognize the separation she feels from her family as they gather for a photo!
I think the reason it’s not more of a belt is because when she still has that tight “nasal” voice we can hear how broken she feels through her voice but also trying to sound like she’s fine.
She recorded this song when she was 8 months pregnant!