Franz Schubert un(Finished) Piano Sonata in F-sharp minor D.571, first movement

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 12

  • @MXChan
    @MXChan 10 років тому +5

    This must be the most unique completion of D571 out of all of them. Love it!

  • @iconicshrubbery
    @iconicshrubbery Рік тому

    Dear Neil, thanks for helping Franz Peter for finishing this sonata.

  • @Wooden_boxand_stick
    @Wooden_boxand_stick 2 роки тому +1

    Such an emotional piece, I cry every time.

  • @최승해-z5c
    @최승해-z5c 4 місяці тому

    최고의 슈베르트 숨어 있는 명곡입니다

  • @thierrybaer
    @thierrybaer 10 років тому +6

    Strange completion. More Crossland than Schubert in the interpretation of the sonata form. This piece can be left incompleted (A. Schiff plays it that way). Other completists (Badura-Skoda, Tirimo) were more humble and didn't add so much of their own music to Schubert's.

  • @ldskts
    @ldskts 9 років тому +1

    Natural ending !

  • @HK-yy8xe
    @HK-yy8xe 3 роки тому

    シューベルトのならではの美しいメロディー😌✨✨

  • @a9marita
    @a9marita 10 років тому +11

    It's beautiful but in my opinion when it's "completed" we lost a great feeling of Schubert.

  • @kovvvas
    @kovvvas 7 років тому +5

    Schubert would've never composed such an uninspired ending.

    • @Grondorn
      @Grondorn 6 років тому +3

      Schubert's own version wouldn't have been radically different, after all the unfinished part is a recapitulation based on the exposition of the movement.

  • @alexanderhoffmann346
    @alexanderhoffmann346 3 роки тому +2

    Neil did not understand the Sonata. He could even not play the melody in a right way. So do ist again and delete this record.

  • @andrews582
    @andrews582 5 років тому

    Not the greatest thing Schubert ever wrote