i made every pasta shape to prove a point

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @answerinprogress
    @answerinprogress  Рік тому +379

    Thanks to Milanote for sponsoring this video! Sign up for free and start your next creative project: www.milanote.com/answerinprogress

    • @ГеоргиГеоргиев-с3г
      @ГеоргиГеоргиев-с3г Рік тому +11

      URGENT!!! You said there are 3 bread shapes, there are more.
      Baguette, square shaped, oval, round big, round small, sliced, creative and sunflower.

    • @TheCrimsonKnight.
      @TheCrimsonKnight. Рік тому +6

      Petition for a "20 minutes of random pasta facts" video?

    • @peaxoop
      @peaxoop Рік тому +7

      rice comes in a lot of different shapes and textures and can be cooked in to even more, then you have rice noodles in all sorts of varieties, then all sorts of cakes and confectionary as well as Rice Krispies. I think you owe rice an apology. also I am now very hungry.

    • @ehname1
      @ehname1 Рік тому +1

      I'm just here for milanote ad tbh

    • @stiltschen
      @stiltschen Рік тому

      reply

  • @yairennyr
    @yairennyr Рік тому +7083

    I like that Sabrina's solution to dealing with food it's just handing it over to Melissa

  • @egekahraman8985
    @egekahraman8985 Рік тому +2118

    its really funny seeing sabrina slowly go mad about finding arcane knowledge about the pasta and not being able to tell anyone while melissa cooks 50 different pastas

  • @lore5751
    @lore5751 Рік тому +1431

    the cut away from Sabrina talking about how women liked to experience with pasta as an art form to Melissa making pasta by hand and complaining about how it’s so bad as it’s handmade not machine made is something that is so, to me personally, human

    • @jesseingram7914
      @jesseingram7914 5 місяців тому +12

      The best part is the “Don’t run away!” to the pasta dough.

  • @CatbaronAle
    @CatbaronAle Рік тому +320

    There’s a channel called pasta grannies that you may love. Lots of women who have made pasta for decades and each dish and pasta has a unique artistry to it.

    • @lisam9233
      @lisam9233 Рік тому +7

      It’s one of my fave channels. They share their dishes and stories about life with pure love ❤

    • @tomaszsosnowski9279
      @tomaszsosnowski9279 10 місяців тому +1

      Agree. This comment should be pinned, these ladies deserve all the recognition possible.

    • @meganm.9513
      @meganm.9513 Місяць тому

      I was scrolling the comments to see if someone mentioned pasta grannies!

  • @Niki_Schreiber
    @Niki_Schreiber Рік тому +1371

    Fun Fact: It's not just Italy that has 1300 sorts of pasta. Germany has over 3000 types of Bread and France has between 1000 and 1600 types of Cheese
    Edit: I first said germany has over 300 types of bread and 1200 types of pastries but the comments that answered that there are now counted over 3000 sorts of bread so after a quick fact check i changed my comment.

    • @andrewgrant6516
      @andrewgrant6516 Рік тому +18

      Don't eat all the cheeses without your lactose pills.

    • @KuyaEyo
      @KuyaEyo Рік тому +127

      I'm german and when i heard "there are only 3 types of bread" i've frowned

    • @Niki_Schreiber
      @Niki_Schreiber Рік тому +3

      @@andrewgrant6516 that would be a disaster :D

    • @Niki_Schreiber
      @Niki_Schreiber Рік тому +19

      @@KuyaEyo as a fellow german, i know exactly what you mean

    • @RyugaruSenbi
      @RyugaruSenbi Рік тому +36

      ​@@andrewgrant6516 most cheeses are fine for lactose intolerant people tho. The cheese making process of most cheeses as well as the aging process cause little if any lactose to remain in the mayority of cheese varieties.

  • @darioferretti3758
    @darioferretti3758 Рік тому +2998

    you see, as an italian i can tell you that the one reason why there are so many shape is simply diversity, so every day of the year we can eat a different one

    • @mandranmagelan9430
      @mandranmagelan9430 Рік тому +134

      oh, is this like the great variation of potato dishes? :-)

    • @bonk2935
      @bonk2935 Рік тому +172

      ​@@mandranmagelan9430yeah I'd say it's a good analogy, I don't eat pasta every day as some other people do, but if a day I'm eating spaghetti al pomodoro the next day I might eat penne al pomodoro to trick my brain into thinking it's eating something else

    • @themiddleones11
      @themiddleones11 Рік тому +44

      ​@mandranmagelan9430 and then we put gnocchi in there and it's all kinds of crazy

    • @mandranmagelan9430
      @mandranmagelan9430 Рік тому +2

      @@bonk2935 this is the way :-)

    • @mandranmagelan9430
      @mandranmagelan9430 Рік тому +5

      @@themiddleones11 mmmh, gnocchi :-D

  • @nope_118
    @nope_118 Рік тому +1227

    Fun fact "maltagliati" are pasta noodles and it translates to poorly cut.
    So whenever your pasta doesn't turn out perfect, remember we have a name for that and it's wonderful :)

    • @christythies548
      @christythies548 Рік тому +35

      This is my new favorite pasta fact

    • @teresaellis7062
      @teresaellis7062 8 місяців тому +5

      @@christythies548 Same! 😁 I have made a small amount of "maltagliati" in my life, but only because, after putting all that work in, only my mom and I liked my homemade pasta.

    • @Aromantic_alien
      @Aromantic_alien 6 місяців тому +3

      ive made pasta from scratch a few times, most of it has been maltagliati

  • @brekkoh
    @brekkoh Рік тому +2020

    i want a podcast episode from melissa where she exclusively talks about her very strong opinions and why she's correct

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +191

      half of it will be "just look at it! it's horrible!" and i will be nodding my head like yes precisely what a profound and evident point.

    • @hundvd_7
      @hundvd_7 Рік тому +43

      With a voice like that, I could listen to a podcast about _anything_ she says

  • @ramses1033
    @ramses1033 Рік тому +200

    As an italian i always thought scoobi doo pasta was named after "scoubidou", which is a french "game" where you get some strings and tie them together by "corkscrewing" them on top of each other to make little decorations. They were pretty popular in italy in the early 2000s still.

    • @ambergris5705
      @ambergris5705 10 місяців тому +19

      This theory both satisfies my curiosity, scratches the itch in my brain on a pure translation level, and brought back memories and nostalgia. Congratulations, you earned a like (I wish I could give a double one!)

    • @krankarvolund7771
      @krankarvolund7771 10 місяців тому +5

      I was searching for that comment because I had that exact impression XD
      I've always wondered why they named the dog like a scoubidou, but I guess they don't have those in the US ˆˆ

    • @EuskaltelEuskadi
      @EuskaltelEuskadi 9 місяців тому +3

      We had this game in the UK too! They were called scoobies or scooby doos. Now I'm wondering if that came from France or they got it from us...

    • @krankarvolund7771
      @krankarvolund7771 9 місяців тому +1

      @@EuskaltelEuskadi Apparently it was invented in France in 1958, and named Scoubidou also in France in 1959, after a singer made a hit with a song called "Scoubidou" that everyone associated with the new toy because why not XD

    • @AbiSaysThings
      @AbiSaysThings Місяць тому

      Scoobies ran our school back in like 2004

  • @DraakjeYoblama
    @DraakjeYoblama Рік тому +150

    I love the abrupt change between Sabrina with a bunch of books to Melissa talking about what pasta is her favourite like it's a primary school presentation.

  • @carolynthomas3938
    @carolynthomas3938 Рік тому +3532

    Sabrina: So I’m not supposed to use Penne in everything?
    Melissa: *the world is falling to savagery*

    • @fabianp.2986
      @fabianp.2986 Рік тому +67

      Spanish speakers agree

    • @gamekiller0123
      @gamekiller0123 Рік тому +113

      Also Melissa: My two favorite pasta shapes are long and thin penne and fat penne.

    • @fabianp.2986
      @fabianp.2986 Рік тому +6

      @@pikameer8325 Eyo 🧐

    • @JamesTDG
      @JamesTDG Рік тому +9

      THe irony is though, I hate angel hair more than penne.

    • @sergiom3988
      @sergiom3988 Рік тому +7

      That's true, the world is falling to savagery, too many people using oregano
      If you don't understand the joke, you probably haven't watched the One Piece Netflix adaptation. Oregano is for savages!

  • @bluehourcore
    @bluehourcore Рік тому +850

    i’m so obsessed with sabrina’s chaotic energy when she’s in her room and then it cuts to an extremely calming voiceover by melissa

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +30

      one of my favorite elements about this video LOL

  • @jedisalsohere
    @jedisalsohere Рік тому +1306

    Melissa's cupboard being full of beans is such great continuity from the bean episode

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +37

      she's so real for that

    • @UnknowinglyDerpy
      @UnknowinglyDerpy 9 місяців тому +2

      I don't know if that was put there as a prop or she's actually just got too many Beanz,

    • @Lennon-rz2ly
      @Lennon-rz2ly 6 місяців тому

      Thanks for that, im totally gunna go watch that episodes 5 times

  • @nobleeverett5980
    @nobleeverett5980 Рік тому +51

    I hope you guys take this as a compliment, but incredible change of thumbnail and title, made me realize how subconscious a lot of my video watching choices are lol. Every time I saw the old thumbnail I though "There are probably many pasta shapes" and was satisfied. But now I gotta know what point you're proving so I immediately clicked on the video before I realized it was this one

  • @Thraeryn
    @Thraeryn Рік тому +248

    Melissa & Sabrina: WHY IS PENNE
    Also Melissa: this rigatoni is my second favorite *[holds up a piece of penne with a larger internal diameter & w/o the bias cut]*
    BRUH

    • @RyugaruSenbi
      @RyugaruSenbi Рік тому +1

      For real, that shit looked like a worse penne

    • @hundvd_7
      @hundvd_7 Рік тому +46

      Rigatoni is unironically so much better though

    • @merobo5066
      @merobo5066 Рік тому +26

      Penne rigate are great imo, penne lisce however are deserving of all the hate

    • @OneTrueCat
      @OneTrueCat 11 місяців тому +5

      It's not penne if it doesn't look like a pen nib, 🤷‍♀

    • @DawnDavidson
      @DawnDavidson 10 місяців тому +7

      I like penne! I wouldn’t want it to be the only shape I ever ate though. And I agree that rigate is the better form. In general rigate or other methods of ruffling or creating surface texture are there to hold sauces. The smooth forms are just useless at holding a decent sauce.
      It’s so true that the different shapes interact differently with various sauces and ingredients. Some of the ones they were unsure about were made for soup, for instance, not sauce. Again, a different use requires different characteristics. With a soup, you need it to be sturdier and to hold its shape during long cooking.
      One of my favorite shapes is busiate, a coil of flattish pasta. It’s great for holding many sauces. My housemate imports that from Italy, too, and it’s just fantastic. Worth every penny.

  • @purplelord8531
    @purplelord8531 Рік тому +418

    a two-member video is a treat, i knew this was going to be a banger
    edit: no seriously, this feels so much more professional just because the scenes with melissa and sabrina are edited together, it's incredible

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 Рік тому +25

      Answer in Progress always has good editing, but this is an entirely different kind of editing that was executed flawlessly.

    • @jayayeonetoo3335
      @jayayeonetoo3335 Рік тому +23

      so true, this hits different compared to their other videos together, which i think is primarily because there's more back-and-forth between their POVs (compared to the wine or AI recipes videos, for example)
      in this one, sabrina does the intro, meets up with melissa, they do their own separate research on "what pasta shapes?" vs "why pasta shapes?" and then sabrina's research just goes so well with melissa's in-person experience/interview at the restaurant

    • @dhillaz
      @dhillaz Рік тому +2

      Over the years they have improved big time. They were always a good channel but you can really see the progression in professionalism and detail

  • @purplelord8531
    @purplelord8531 Рік тому +1154

    sabrina talking about pasta shapes being about womanhood and creativity only to experience a creative awakening when making her own pasta made me actually cry

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 Рік тому +120

      The real pasta shapes... were the pasta shapes we made along the way.

    • @Veilure
      @Veilure Рік тому +1

      "making pasta is a feminine trait. men should be thinking about war"

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +4

      SAME

    • @mayomay516
      @mayomay516 Рік тому +29

      Same because this probably happened 100s of year ago, just two women having fun making pasta

    • @crookie7656
      @crookie7656 Рік тому +14

      Honestly it’s one of the most heartwarming things ever. It’s such a real and human thing and just 🥹

  • @AnaLogical-rx1oj
    @AnaLogical-rx1oj Рік тому +354

    fun fact! "strozzapreti" means priest choker, "orecchiette" means "tiny ears". Also, the "leftovers" is actually a pasta type, called "maltagliati"! Literally means "badly cut"

    • @Idiomatick
      @Idiomatick 4 місяці тому

      And gnocchi means vagina

  • @fatimak6440
    @fatimak6440 Рік тому +20

    i love how the guy from the store is so passionate about talking and explaining... he's so proud of it...

  • @fabiozaccarini6762
    @fabiozaccarini6762 Рік тому +44

    Bread does not only have one shape!!! There are at least a hundred different types of bread in Austria and Germany.
    You should definitely do a video on that

  • @Xartab
    @Xartab Рік тому +533

    Sabrina: "bread has like three shapes"
    The whole of Eurasia: "lol can you imagine?"

    • @sebazamorano583
      @sebazamorano583 Рік тому +13

      the whole world

    • @ididntknowtheyhadwifiinhell
      @ididntknowtheyhadwifiinhell Рік тому +21

      same thing with constantly mentioning rice as a comparison as if a) rice doesn't already come in a million different varieties before you do anything to it and b) there arent a million types of pasta and pasta adjacent things made with rice in a million different shapes. tteok for tteokbokki alone has at least 6 different shapes you can buy in america, never mind south korea: long cylinders for rabokki, short cylinders for the regular type, flat ovals for soup, the super huge chewy bunmoja type, the type filled with cheese, and the kind that looks like a fat 8 or two balls connected to each other

    • @cameronschyuder9034
      @cameronschyuder9034 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ididntknowtheyhadwifiinhelltteok is made from rice that’s true, but the rice has to be made into rice flour first, and doesn’t fit into our idea of what rice looks like. Also rice noodles. They’re made from rice, but it’s not rice, it’s noodles, bc you eat them like noodles. Still, interesting thought

  • @aka_slendy
    @aka_slendy Рік тому +506

    i think you should make an end of year video every year just giving us all the facts from each video that didn't fit so your notes + research doesn't go to waste :D i'd watch it

  • @atheistlinguist542
    @atheistlinguist542 Рік тому +720

    Here are a couple more pasta facts! "Penne" is the plural form of "penna," which literally means "pen" or "quill." The pasta shape was presumably named as such because the slanted ends resembled the points of old-fashioned quill pens. Also, "penne" is a bit of a pronunciation trap for those who don't speak Italian. In Italian, a double consonant actually reflects the duration of the spoken consonant. You literally hold the sound for a tiny bit longer if the corresponding letter is doubled. This can make a difference in meaning, and one of the starkest examples is that "penne" refers either to pens, quills, or pasta noodles of a particular shape, whereas "pene" literally means "penis." Humorously, the pronunciation used in this video sounds more like the latter, at least to my admittedly non-native Italian ear.

    • @_disruption
      @_disruption Рік тому +87

      So, they ate pene. This should be on a different website 😭

    • @zyaicob
      @zyaicob Рік тому +54

      Oh yeah English doesn't have long consonants so if English speakers are approximating a language with long consonants we usually do it by lengthening our vowels

    • @Artofcarissa
      @Artofcarissa Рік тому +31

      I always found how subtracting that extra n turns a pasta shape into an anatomical term 😂😂

    • @retr036
      @retr036 Рік тому +51

      As an italian i'll confirm: it does sound like the latter. 😂

    • @TomBombadil3791
      @TomBombadil3791 Рік тому +18

      Do you prefer penne lunghe (long) or penne corte (small)?

  • @chriskuzin9650
    @chriskuzin9650 Рік тому +10

    This is the exact type of thing I come to UA-cam for. Informative, wholesome, funny, just a joy to watch thank you for making this

  • @Grace.24647
    @Grace.24647 Рік тому +45

    Eating pasta for dinner rn in honour of those lil crafty Italian gals who just wanted to play with their food 🫡

  • @KenkuCry
    @KenkuCry Рік тому +413

    "eating pasta for dinner in honour of women" is a phrase that will definitely alter my vocabulary

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +14

      im going to say that phrase to myself every time i eat pasta from now on

  • @Chareads
    @Chareads Рік тому +264

    This video was meant for me!! I'm working on a generative art project called Semolina, so far I've designed 17 pasta shapes with code, and have about 6 more I want to add, it is the most fun. There's an incredible book called Pasta By Design which has the parametric formulae for ~100 pasta shapes, hard to get your hands on but Sabrina you would LOVE it.

    • @goplants
      @goplants Рік тому +11

      This needs to be top comment! Future collab were she cooks your pasta shapes incoming?

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 Рік тому +10

      That sounds like a good book; I like the idea of a taxonomy of pasta. It must be a hard task for that author to actually classify the whole cluster that is pasta shapes.

    • @dcd2994
      @dcd2994 Рік тому

      +

    • @zeam-h3133
      @zeam-h3133 Рік тому

      +

    • @graceb1949
      @graceb1949 Рік тому +1

      Where can I learn more about that?!

  • @darksentinel082
    @darksentinel082 Рік тому +307

    Four minutes in and I have a strong hypothesis. Pasta has so many shapes because pasta dough is very shapeable, and people love making funny shapes - it’s part of human nature to make little wiggly tubes to cook and eat

    • @AndreiFierbinteanu
      @AndreiFierbinteanu Рік тому +28

      Playdoh is basically pasta dough, with some additives to make it last longer and not dry off so much. It's a fun substance to play around with.

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому +14

      and you would be correct!

    • @sillygoosetaur
      @sillygoosetaur Рік тому +7

      DING DINNG DING

    • @parkchimmin7913
      @parkchimmin7913 Рік тому +3

      ⁠​⁠@@AndreiFierbinteanu I have eaten Play-Doh before and it’s oddly salty. It was in kindergarten and I was a weird kid hanging out with other weird kids. We all sneakily nibbled on Play-Doh and crayons for the heck of it.

    • @charliedechauvin911
      @charliedechauvin911 5 місяців тому +2

      The video says rice only has one shape but they might ne forgetting rice noodles, rice cakes, rice leafs, etc exist in as many shapes as wheat noodles.
      I think once you can make a paste out of it with a fun texture to eat you just innovate different shapes over time and territory.

  • @Hormiga59
    @Hormiga59 Рік тому +18

    The podcast that Melissa showed is Gastropod a very interesting food-science podcast. But the topic that she mentioned is the creation of Cascatelli by Dan Pashman. Host of The Sporkful, he created this new pasta shape because he believes its the perfect pasta. He had a complete saga on this. I recommend both podcasts.

  • @bhangela
    @bhangela Рік тому +16

    I LOVED THIS VIDEO!! combined so many elements of some of my fave AIP videos. genuine surprise and awe and love for the human effort & love that goes into pasta! the project that sabrina might have forced melissa to do was so cool. bug kudos to melissa for making those pastas! this inspires me to do projects like this and do new things too! and yalls energies put together is so fun. well done guys!!!!

    • @bhangela
      @bhangela Рік тому

      from farfelle to scoobi doo to buccatini to even the ever-hated penne.... pasta, i love you

  • @sobertillnoon
    @sobertillnoon Рік тому +1729

    If I don't get an explanation of why Melissa hates penne so much I'll be sad.
    UPDATE: I am sad

    • @Daniel-yy3ty
      @Daniel-yy3ty Рік тому +8

      Well, if the penne she has access to are smooth it's understandable, as not even early pandemic managed to sell those...
      Every other shape + rice + flour + yeast were gone, but the penne lisce remained 🤣

    • @freshrockpapa-e7799
      @freshrockpapa-e7799 Рік тому +25

      same

    • @ailen9859
      @ailen9859 Рік тому

      idk but "penne" in spanish, with only one N, "pene" means d*ck, HAHHA

    • @teazen_tea
      @teazen_tea Рік тому +44

      We never get an explanation????

    • @seagummy
      @seagummy Рік тому +150

      i think it's because of the common view that penne doesn't hold onto sauce like most pastas are supposed to

  • @caleb.z
    @caleb.z Рік тому +94

    I love that this video utilizes Sabrina’s skills of diving deep into a topic’s history, as well as Melissa’s skill with relating to people over food.

  • @Lo_Pit
    @Lo_Pit Рік тому +122

    As an Italian who really loves eating pasta this video was delightful! Also, I think that the Penne drawing at which Melissa was pointing (8:14) represents "Penne lisce" which are kinda bad at holding sauce and therefore not great for many pasta dishes; however, if you try "Penne rigate", which are basically the same but with ridges all around, I think you'll like them a lot more, since they work way better with sauce. Anyway, I wish you all the best, keep up the amazing work!

    • @GiovanniGiordano79
      @GiovanniGiordano79 Рік тому +10

      And ridged pasta exist because the pasta from industrial doughes extruded from teflon dies isn't rough enough to absorb well the tomato sauce, so the ridges should allow the sauce to stop on the pasta and allow that.

    • @Artofcarissa
      @Artofcarissa Рік тому

      My bf’s from Chicago and prefers penne lisce (or mostaccioli as he calls it) over penne rigate but I keep telling him rigate is better because the ridges hold the sauce better!

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 Рік тому +4

      @@Artofcarissa I've only heard the term mostaccioli refer to a baked dish, which I think is the only purpose for which penne lisce is actually worth anything. Even the lamest of pasta shapes can find a time to shine.

    • @MrDannyDetail
      @MrDannyDetail Рік тому +3

      I've always thought of the ridges as being part of what makes it penne. In fact I'm not sure if we even have the non-ridged kind here in the UK.

    • @ehmzed
      @ehmzed Рік тому +2

      Penne lisce are the worst 😭
      I've only ever eaten them when we bought them accidentally lmao

  • @drGeppo
    @drGeppo Рік тому +28

    if Sabrina was entertained by "rat tail" pasta it's a shame she didn't look up the translation of "strozzapreti" (priest chocker)

  • @WKS32
    @WKS32 Рік тому +17

    Official *we demand a video of Sabrina telling us all the pasta facts and Melissa explaining her hatred of penne* request

  • @starjake
    @starjake Рік тому +72

    I really enjoyed watching the pasta expert just being a pasta expert. It's so satisfying to experience someone who really enjoys a thing and is really good at that thing doing said thing.

  • @felipebraganca6328
    @felipebraganca6328 Рік тому +62

    Someone below commented about the quality of the edition with Melissa and Sabrina together. But I can't express how perfect every transition is, from the energized and megalomaniac Sabrina to the sweetest thing on the entire internet, which is Melissa's voice in narration. Really amazing job, girls; you are both an inspiration to me

  • @bearair
    @bearair Рік тому +235

    Love the collab with Sabrina and Melissa in their elements! Also so FAR, the jokes are landing

    • @xzonia1
      @xzonia1 Рік тому +6

      This crossed my love of cooking with my love of nerdy in-depth research on a topic and I'm so happy right now! Best video I've watched this week on UA-cam. :D

  • @marshmallowsandtrash
    @marshmallowsandtrash Рік тому +3

    I love the chaos of these videos. Such a jump from the og solo Sabrina vids but 3x the chaos

  • @Othique
    @Othique Рік тому +3

    As a huge pasta fan I thought I had this all pinned down from the start - dough to sauce ratio plus how the mixture of oxygen plays into the flavor your tongue perceives seemed like a simple enough explanation. And then you told me the history of the dry vs fresh pasta and that added a little surprise...
    I love pasta.
    And like Melissa, bucatini and rigatoni are some of my favs. Spaghetti and macaroni are nice little "childhood throwbacks", whereas bucatini and rigatoni are like sightly more sophisticate versions. LOL
    I need to make some pasta soon.

  • @mygetawayart
    @mygetawayart Рік тому +124

    as an Italian, what makes identifying how many pasta shapes there are is especially hard because not only there are so many types of pasta that look different but have the same name (think Maccheroni or Gnocchi) but just as many pasta shapes which look exactly the same but have wildly different names depending on which region or country you're in (like Busiate, Strozzapreti and Trofie which are essentially the same thing). Once you get over that hurdle, you truly fall into the pasta rabbit hole andyou find out there's a WHOLE BUNCH of extremely local, niche, hyper-regional types of pasta which even if you were Italian, you would've probably never heard of unless you were specifically from that area.

    • @oscarcacnio8418
      @oscarcacnio8418 Рік тому +9

      So, in short...
      Compiling a visual "dictionary/encyclopedia" of pasta shapes will forever be a long and painful endeavor?

    • @DasGanon
      @DasGanon Рік тому +2

      ​@@oscarcacnio8418I feel like there's a certain point where knot theory says hello

    • @quinnfarris
      @quinnfarris Рік тому +2

      ​@hex697 Gnocchi di patate ('di patate' meaning 'of potato') is a type of pasta which is most commonly made with potato. it can be made with other bases, but just Gnocci usually means the potato kind

    • @defenestrated23
      @defenestrated23 Рік тому +3

      ​​​@@hex697did you just (unsuccessfully) try to "well actually" an Italian about pasta? 🤌
      And yes Gnocchi is a type of pasta made with wheat flour and potato (and sometimes egg and/or cheese). The age and variety of potatoes affects the texture and density of the gnocchi. Northern gnocchi are typically more fluffy but in Lazio where my family is from they are dense and chewy (my favorite).
      Gnocchi (possibly meaning "knot" or "knuckle") are pretty ancient, going back to Roman times, which is why there are so many varieties and recipes.

    • @oscarcacnio8418
      @oscarcacnio8418 Рік тому +2

      @@DasGanon "In the future, pasta shapes will be randomly generated".

  • @thereddestsuninthesky
    @thereddestsuninthesky Рік тому +268

    I really can’t believe that Sabrina is the woman who I watched in school with those crash course kids episodes

    • @collinswanyeki
      @collinswanyeki Рік тому +13

      Wait what 😂
      Where can I view them 😂

    • @thereddestsuninthesky
      @thereddestsuninthesky Рік тому +23

      @@collinswanyeki on the crash course kids channel, with all the science episodes

    • @fabianp.2986
      @fabianp.2986 Рік тому +13

      No freaking way, it's true!!!

    • @goplants
      @goplants Рік тому +15

      Wait what? As a Hank/John Green enthusiast I didn't know that but also it makes sense

    • @azuarc
      @azuarc Рік тому

      I encountered these randomly the other day.

  • @TheCalucita
    @TheCalucita Рік тому +72

    And this is how we ended up going to the store, buying 6 kinds of pasta we had never had before, and had 5 different kinds, with 4 different sauses for sunday lunch.
    Sabrina and Melissa deserve a cut of the increased sales of pasta this month 😂👍

  • @MichaGrandel
    @MichaGrandel 2 місяці тому +1

    Did I really, honestly just watch basically 30min of two women eating pasta, and had fun doing so and enjoyed the video and learned some things about pasta shapes? yes, totally! Your content is the best 🙃 I really love watching your videos 🎉

  • @justintroyka8855
    @justintroyka8855 Рік тому +1

    This is one of my favorite Answer in Progress videos so far. I love pasta and have always wondered why there are so many different shapes, and Sabrina is right - the answer is so cool! I love how this video intersperses the history, the cooking, the interviews, etc. into one overarching story.

  • @bobrong9645
    @bobrong9645 Рік тому +856

    I'm not a rice expert, but even I can name two shapes of rice: long-grained and short-grained.

    • @KOZMOuvBORG
      @KOZMOuvBORG Рік тому +44

      Heard of Pearl Rice?

    • @penguinpingu3807
      @penguinpingu3807 Рік тому +73

      There 3 rice lengths, short, medium and long but 2 types species verity: japonica and Indica.
      I have to edit.

    • @octochan
      @octochan Рік тому +46

      @@penguinpingu3807 there's also aromatic and glutinous

    • @Amaling
      @Amaling Рік тому +24

      @@octochan those aren't difference taxonomically as far as I know. But yeah with enough localities and care put in there's a lot of variety in terms of what comes to our plates

    • @bobrong9645
      @bobrong9645 Рік тому +4

      @@KOZMOuvBORG
      Nope, but when I search wikipedia, it redirects to glutinous rice, which is short-grained shaped.

  • @jessicavanik6040
    @jessicavanik6040 Рік тому +57

    The concept and editing execution on this video is just *SO* good! I absolutely LOVE the paralleling and ping ponging between Sabrina and Melissa's journeys. Just the little details in the transitions are so intentional and purposeful while feeling organic and playful. This is art!

  • @wiiza4ever
    @wiiza4ever Рік тому +171

    Scoubidou is a French craft that uses plastic lanyards and braids them into corkscrew shaped objects. That's where the name of the pasta comes from.

    • @0.-.0
      @0.-.0 Рік тому +6

      Apparently the name of that craft is also named after the French song

    • @wiiza4ever
      @wiiza4ever Рік тому +4

      @@0.-.0 I've heard it was the other way around.

    • @popupdrivein
      @popupdrivein Рік тому

      oh my god THANK YOU for explaining that one

    • @killianmotto2684
      @killianmotto2684 Рік тому

      I THOUGHT IT WAS AMERICAN but it's only in francophone region

    • @QuikVidGuy
      @QuikVidGuy Рік тому

      like macrame

  • @thaagirrasaurusjr5443
    @thaagirrasaurusjr5443 Рік тому +2

    I really enjoy the food episodes y'all do. I love learning about the history of food and what factors influenced its creation.
    I now have a new profound appreciation for pasta and it's rich creative history. Thanks for learning about stuff and then sharing it so I can learn about stuff too! 💜

  • @ClaudiaDCD
    @ClaudiaDCD Рік тому +1

    Really fun video. I love how Sabrina's crazy reading and researching and organized presentation matches so well with the more kinesthetic and visually fun interviews and work of Melissa's.

  • @blankets5782
    @blankets5782 Рік тому +87

    Melissa: *listing types of pasta purely off of memory*
    Sabrina: *already looking like she wants to return to school to catch up on the “Pasta Unit” required for graduation* 😭😭😭

  • @bassetts1899
    @bassetts1899 Рік тому +50

    I'm not even Italian, but I am Greek so in the first 3 minutes of the video I knew you'd discover the creativity and extremely local history behind different pastas :) p.s. here in Greece we call all pasta makaronia!

  • @geekazoid47
    @geekazoid47 Рік тому +50

    The love of a mother feeding her family and being creative is the best explanation you could find. Lovely.

  • @Adamborries
    @Adamborries Рік тому +3

    Loved every part of this. The history, the interview, the taste testing, the editing. 10/10

  • @0reo2
    @0reo2 Рік тому +2

    I love pasta (in all shapes) and your channel so this was the perfect episode for me!

  • @dziooooo
    @dziooooo Рік тому +144

    Sabrina, I'm an Eastern European potato woman and I literally have five kinds of rice in my kitchen! Not to mention three kinds of rice noodles and rice paper. What do you mean "just one rice"?!

    • @charleslambert3368
      @charleslambert3368 Рік тому +4

      Are you from a bit of Eastern Europe that does potato dumplings? How do i make them neither fall apart in the pot nor feel like wallpaper paste in my mouth?

    • @sanzidhasan2
      @sanzidhasan2 Рік тому +32

      I think they just mean the shape. Like most rice is close to same shape just either longer or thicker.
      Ofcourse there are several types of rice but like shape wise they are similar.

    • @dziooooo
      @dziooooo Рік тому +3

      @@charleslambert3368 I am, but that's a question for my grandmother, because I have no idea. XD

    • @mekkio77
      @mekkio77 Рік тому +8

      @@sanzidhasan2 But shape does matter though. If I am making a thick curry, I will always grab the long grain rice. It can handle being slathered in sauce due to its length and size. For my Spanish and Puerto Rican dishes I'll go for short grain or bomba rice which is good for when you flavor using only stocks and spices rather than heavier sauces, again, like curry. Bomba rice would be terrible to make Chinese fried rice because it is too delicate to be handled so rough like you need to be in fried rice.

    • @bowel_movement
      @bowel_movement Рік тому +20

      ​@@sanzidhasan2rice isn't handmade, it's literally the seed of a type of grass. That's why rice itself doesn't have too many variations in shape and size. Products derived from rice DO vary greatly, from noodles to paper to flour. Which is pretty much as varied as pasta.

  • @mimi_h
    @mimi_h Рік тому +84

    the dichotomy of sabrina and melissa's energies is made even more hilarious by their shared distain of penne

  • @Lix_Skywalker
    @Lix_Skywalker Рік тому +17

    Italian here!
    This video was so interesting, you made me learn about a part of my culture that I didn't know about (even though i eat pasta basically everyday) while also being really entertaining, great job!

  • @danielmarton2505
    @danielmarton2505 Рік тому

    I can believe that you made a video on this. I ask this question every time I eat any type of pasta and seems like you finally answered the question! Thank you! 🙏

  • @popupdrivein
    @popupdrivein Рік тому +8

    the more of them Sabrina compares to a little taco, the more I understand why this video needed to be made

  • @SeiphersZone
    @SeiphersZone Рік тому +34

    Reasons why I love this channel:
    I can watch a video about why there are pasta shapes and not be bored

    • @Fybinex
      @Fybinex Рік тому +4

      same, some of these video topics are so random and stupid but they design the video so well and then suddenly im researching more about pasta shapes lol

  • @ricdavid
    @ricdavid Рік тому +13

    The structure of this video is perfect. Not to mention it's the perfect mix of educational and funny. I was getting a real jealous "aw man I wanna be there at that lil pasta party" feeling at the end there.

  • @SuperTommox
    @SuperTommox Рік тому +119

    Hi, as an Italian i can help in some ways.
    In Italy, we have 4 "official" courses during a meal:
    1-Antipasti
    Which are basically appetizers
    1- Primo piatto
    Which translates to "First dish" and it's pasta. It can be almost anything. Pasta with meat inside. Pasta with pesto. Pasta with fish and so on.
    3-Secondo piatto "second dish"
    It's meat or fish.
    4-Desert.
    Since pasta is one of the main foods during a meal (almost always at lunch) we had to have variety.
    The difference between bucatini and spaghetti is that bucatini, as the name suggests, has a hole inside.
    In Italy you can still find hand-made pasta.
    Especially there is still a tradition in Bari, a city in the region of Puglia, where old ladies sell pasta made on the streets.
    That kind of pasta is called "orecchiette" since it resembles a little ear.
    The unknown-shaped pasta looks like "gnocchi" (pronounced nhocchi).
    If you have any questions, ask away! As an italian I can talk about food all day.

    • @frenzyXprime
      @frenzyXprime Рік тому +1

      What part of "bucatini" suggests it has a hole in it? Genuinely asking.

    • @hugofontes5708
      @hugofontes5708 Рік тому +8

      As someone who is not Italian but into maths, one could take a page of topology and knot theory and make essentially arbitrary amounts of pasta shapes by combining and linking multiple existing shapes. But that's more something up Matt Parker's Stand-up Maths alley than Answer in Progress

    • @vicesig
      @vicesig Рік тому

      Gnocchi are potato based

    • @SuperTommox
      @SuperTommox Рік тому +12

      @@frenzyXprime Basically "buco" means "hole", so something that has a hole in itself is "bucato". Something that is small and has a whole is "bucatino". The plural of "bucatino" is "bucatini".

    • @hugofontes5708
      @hugofontes5708 Рік тому

      @@vicesig cool, new not potato based pasta just dropped

  • @vanessamccann294
    @vanessamccann294 Рік тому +3

    This video just made me feel so close to Italian great-grandma who taught me to make pasta growing up 😋 the passion and the knowledge of the man at 12:59 - she was just like that. We made all kinds of pasta together when I was growing up. She would also sell them on the bus to pay for her flight to visit us every year, and teach other women in her town how to make pasta and sell it as a side hustle. A true icon, entrepreneur, and creative woman, just like you say. I was really missing her today. Thank you

  • @TheIrishBanana.
    @TheIrishBanana. Рік тому +5

    I like how they are both learning some of the same stuff but in different ways

  • @farzaan1479
    @farzaan1479 Рік тому +26

    great video! one thing to note is that most Italian Americans emigrated from Sicily which is also why our pronunciation of mozzarella is different then how mainland Italy pronounces it. also re rice my guess would be that rice is already good straight from the grain and can also be used to make dough so a lot of the variety in rice dishes is from what you're pairing it with, while wheat tastes nasty unless you process it so a lot of the variety there is at the dough stage

    • @deirenne
      @deirenne Рік тому +6

      And also there are rice noodles, with several shapes, sizes and uses to them!

  • @micolsalamarobino1939
    @micolsalamarobino1939 Рік тому +8

    As an Italian I learned so much from this video! I never would've thought I would learn so much about pasta from a Canadian channel but you are always so good that I'm not even surprised! Thank you so much for your great work!

  • @makcraft
    @makcraft Рік тому +16

    Okay Sabrina and Melissa episodes are sooo chaotic fun. Love this.

  • @oilyvio
    @oilyvio 4 місяці тому

    i almost skipped this video and got absolutely got dragged into it and i'm so glad I did, thank you for the high quality production and research! i'm glad to know more about it now and i...have now a new goal of makingand creating different shaped pasta with friends! haha

  • @StuartGeers
    @StuartGeers Рік тому +9

    Pasta Grannies is a channel dedicated to documenting and archiving this knowledge before it's lost to time :)

  • @TheLokiBiz
    @TheLokiBiz Рік тому +6

    8:27 - "Weird information I'm surprised to find so interesting" is honestly my favourite UA-cam genre, so keep it up lol

  • @MyNeLi_cr
    @MyNeLi_cr Рік тому +90

    Finally a video on a topic that actually matters: pasta.
    I adore pasta, and my entire existence revolve around them being cooked aldente with parmesan cheese and vegetables.
    (though I must agree, penne sucks and I also stand by this opinion. And macaroni is overratted.)

    • @bruhzzer
      @bruhzzer Рік тому +7

      you're wrong -an italian

    • @MyNeLi_cr
      @MyNeLi_cr Рік тому +3

      @@bruhzzer The never ending hate between the italian and the french people, I see

    • @shant756
      @shant756 Рік тому +4

      Penne is supreme and you can't convince me otherwise.

    • @xzonia1
      @xzonia1 Рік тому +1

      Penne is one of my favorite pastas to eat with veggies. It's delicious! :)

    • @bruhzzer
      @bruhzzer Рік тому

      @@MyNeLi_cr ew you're french

  • @mikthingspossible
    @mikthingspossible Рік тому +315

    someone please make pasta shapes of sabrina's, taha's, and melissa's face

    • @pigeonshit440
      @pigeonshit440 Рік тому +32

      like a box of novelty macaroni

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 Рік тому +6

      let's start a massive letter-writing campaign to get Kraft to accept this lucrative brand deal.

    • @xzonia1
      @xzonia1 Рік тому +2

      I'd rather someone start selling Sabrina's pizza pasta! YUM

    • @thecoolbird13
      @thecoolbird13 Рік тому +5

      nooo dont turn answer in progress into marketable pasta!

  • @GeraldMountaindew
    @GeraldMountaindew Рік тому +2

    I really enjoy seeing you guys collaborate like this instead of just being separate

  • @Muffin420man6
    @Muffin420man6 8 днів тому

    10:33 after some time of wondering about this i get the answer “just bc they wanted to make art” i love food and art and this gives e whole new appreciation and motivation ti jnow more about pasta.

    • @Muffin420man6
      @Muffin420man6 8 днів тому

      Ty for doing the work ro find out the history and make it into a fun video to follow along with your discoveries. Everything is si dynamic and its so fun seeing so many peoples personal voices and experiences

  • @quartsuniverse8395
    @quartsuniverse8395 Рік тому +14

    3:14 the genuine shock and fear of Melissa’s reaction is hilarious to me

  • @hugofontes5708
    @hugofontes5708 Рік тому +19

    So you took food and added a layer of topology, awesome. Best of luck with that beast!
    Also, petition to name the pasta Sabina came up with a sabrini

  • @St1ckY72
    @St1ckY72 Рік тому +5

    Y'all never fail to deliver great info I wasn't expecting to need in my life!

  • @UkuleleEllie22
    @UkuleleEllie22 Рік тому

    Excellent video! Enjoyed the back and forth between Sabrina and Melissa’s sections, and the interview with pasta maker was great as well.

  • @taxonomaly
    @taxonomaly Рік тому

    absolutely loved seeing you develop an appreciation for, and become visibly passionate about, the wonderful world of pasta
    absolutely hated every moment of penne slander and simply do not understand what could drive you to say such harsh things about such a wonderful shape

  • @mjears
    @mjears Рік тому +11

    For years (before the internet) I wanted to have a comprehensive knowledge of pasta names! Then, as I learned more words in Italian, I saw that they’re mostly just ordinary Italian words, which takes a lot of the mystery out of it. I’ve watched only the first 4 minutes of this so far, and I’m betting that while mouth feel and sauce-carriage are factors in some of the shape choices, most of them arose just because people will try everything they can.

  • @HeisenbergFam
    @HeisenbergFam Рік тому +62

    18:37 "where am I supposed to put all of my pasta facts" Sabrina is either slowly going insane or has already gone insane after 5 years of doing YT

    • @Limonenmixgetraenk
      @Limonenmixgetraenk Рік тому +9

      5 years? She started in 2012, 2013 she had a video on the vlogbrothers channel - so more than enough time to be affected 😅

    • @bartz0rt928
      @bartz0rt928 Рік тому +5

      She started doing UA-cam at like 15, something like 10 years ago. The sanity train has long ago moved beyond the horizon.

    • @kredonystus7768
      @kredonystus7768 Рік тому

      Are you me in disguise? I swear everyone I follow you comment on.

  • @Northfan42
    @Northfan42 Рік тому +29

    I don't have many Schadenfreude reactions, but Sabrina's crazed urge to share ALL of the pasta facts is giving me more joy than makes sense.

  • @MilkCried
    @MilkCried Рік тому +4

    I actually used Milanote as a college student and then printed my screenshots in the studio printer. I worked for me.

  • @leona5167
    @leona5167 Рік тому

    I love that I just came to get a simple answer but ended up being amazed. What fascinated me the most was how a casual question can lead to them researching, reading books, watching videos, listening to podcasts, hand-making these pasta shapes, going to a professional like they're collecting date for a big project, and in the end being super happy to learn all the interesting facts and enjoy pasta together

  • @hayushiii
    @hayushiii Рік тому +4

    in some middle eastern countries its popular to roll the dough into whiteboard marker thick tubes, cut it into little pieces, and then run it on a cheese grater to create little holes on it. then you boil in in oil and salt. some people add garlic to it too, its called "maakroon". i always make it with my grandma when im not sure what to eat :) (its made using the dough without egg)

  • @mixiekins
    @mixiekins Рік тому +6

    I was wondering the same thing a long time ago, and was told that it's because those few shapes tended to survive shipping best, so it's nice to get confirmation on that. For the skeptical: you might notice there's fewer broken fragments at the bottom of the box of elbow mac and pene than there is for the equally popular rotini. If you get your hands on more "exotic" shapes that made the same trek, you'll find there's even more of a disparity in breakage. There is, also, a matter of popularity; orzo holds up like a brick house, but we usually only use it in my house for a dish akin to rice-a-roni, because we're lazy. Shelf space is limited so whatever is popular is what gets stocked, so more people only get exposed to whatever on the shelf and it becomes a vicious cycle.

  • @Mafuyuassahina
    @Mafuyuassahina Рік тому +12

    I love green pasta, in my old school (im swedish) we’d sometimes have multiple color options when eating pasta and the green ones were always the best
    I dunno if it actually tastes different, maybe its just me as a child being happy that i could eat colored pasta lol

    • @xzonia1
      @xzonia1 Рік тому +3

      Usually colored pastas are made with veggies, so a red one is usually made with tomato in the dough, while green ones are usually made with spinach in the dough. So this probably means you like spinach-flavored pasta. :)

  • @shaerenuel9950
    @shaerenuel9950 Рік тому +4

    Sabrina, I'm going to have to be honest. This time the like wasn't for the video, its entertainment value, your research, time, and effort... it was for the meow. Please, give the good sir a treat, he deserves it for working so hard for his pet human.

  • @AMECHlKl
    @AMECHlKl 8 місяців тому +1

    Yo, first time watcher, the first 3 minutes alone just made y'all seem super fun and now when I grow up I wanna kick it with yall sometime and eat ungodly amounts of plain boiled pasta together.

  • @OrigamiMarie
    @OrigamiMarie Рік тому +33

    Someone needs to invent a machine to make mobius strip shaped pasta and call it Infiniti.

  • @hannahhaugen1694
    @hannahhaugen1694 Рік тому +11

    Absolutely loved the contrast and complementary nature of Sabrina and Melissa’s two storylines! Thank you for taking us on this pasta journey. Now I want to go make some pasta with my own two hands!

  • @hashiispep
    @hashiispep Рік тому +35

    you HAVE to make a separate video that compiles all of your pasta facts, it's too good to be lost in your brain

    • @MarineBiology-lb7zb
      @MarineBiology-lb7zb Рік тому

      +

    • @elenaKS230
      @elenaKS230 Рік тому +1

      I really recommend a UA-cam food series made by Alex French Guy Cooking. He has an entire series diving into dry pasta, how it’s made, the factory work and the science behind making it.

  • @lilabluestars85
    @lilabluestars85 Місяць тому

    This is awesome! I laughed, I cried, I learned a ton... I LOVED IT! THANK YOU!

  • @DrDumplingMD
    @DrDumplingMD Рік тому

    The vibes bruh.. Great pasta vid.. enjoyed the pasta history, types, field trip etc. Wish I could taste them. Then again I am having a shawarma atm. I think the intro with Melissa was the most entertaining part of this vid.

  • @andrerenault
    @andrerenault Рік тому +5

    “Where am I supposed to put all these pasta facts?” would’ve been the perfect setup for a Nebula Original

  • @TheAcademik
    @TheAcademik Рік тому +13

    I love that Mel only had beans , so on brand 😂😂😂

  • @sov3nZ
    @sov3nZ Рік тому +5

    melissa describing the pasta while sabrina just repeatedly says 'Cheeers!' lmao

  • @DiegoJacomussi
    @DiegoJacomussi 11 місяців тому +1

    19:30 "I'm pretty sure that's a dumpling" got me in ways I did not expect