Tesla Bot Is OFFICIALLY Ahead Of Boston Dynamics!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- Tesla with Tesla Bot and Boston Dynamics with Boston Dynamics Atlas and Boston Dynamics robotic dog Spot are revolutionizing the world with robotic technology and also autonomous robots. In this video, we take a deep dive into the world of robots and the future of technology and robotic development such as the Boston Dynamics and Tesla Bot Optimus. Robots are the future of the workforce as they can do many technological operations better than people. Will robots replace us all? A.I. is everywhere and that’s only the beginning. Advanced technology such as humanoid robots are getting better daily with robotic machine learning. The innovations in the robotics space are huge and we’ll take a closer look at all of the latest robotic technology and innovation in the robotic space such as Boston Dynamics and Tesla bot Optimus. Here are the best news in agile and dynamic robots. Tesla robots and Boston Dynamics robots are the best robots in the world.
![Evolution of Boston Dynamic’s Robots [1992-2023]](/img/n.gif)
Several points; this video does not demonstrate or provide evidence that Tesla bot is “ahead” of atlas, the two robots have entirely different functions, atlas has never been ‘shot’ nor was it ever intended to be.
its just computer generated garbage like most Tesla videos.
@@Withnail1969You are one of those people who say every year that Tesla will go bankrupt and 'somehow' it never actually happens lmao
@@davidkosiba624he isn't wrong though. To he fair, musk is the one who is saying tesla will go bankrupt if they don't finish FSD soon.
Way ahead.
@@Withnail1969 yep. These Tesla/Musk videos are just for the obsessed Musk fans to fondle themselves over. They get clicks so they keep being made.
You really shouldn’t use Corridor Crew’s CGI Bosstown video as actual footage of Atlas
😂 ikr
Boston Dynamics never shot their bot with a firearm.
Vidio plz
@@highspeedpiTV Faked
I know lol😂
Also, that screenshot of the hockey stick attack was a joke cgi video. There was a real video with a hockey stick but it was not used to beat the Atlas, it was just used to move a package it was trying to pick up.
@@highspeedpiTV : CGI
Wow, this video is soooo off base. lol. First, the Boston Dynamic robots do use AI. They are just smarter about where to use it. Why "learn" to walk if it can be so completely programmed, with adaptablability included? Seems more like a fanboy video than a true evaluation.
Actually, Boston Dynamics robot also uses AI for computer vision. Just check what Spot, the robodog is capable of!
He specifically said Boston Dynamic's Atlas ... not BD robots in general.
Hopefully BD will leverage ChatGPT into Atlas as well.
@@MaximGhost OMG dude, Atlas does it too, this whole video's premise is wrong and the creator should feel foolish
@@HyphenVM Then Boston Dynamics has been playing catch up. Boston Dynamics, first and foremost, was never an AI company. For that matter, neither was Tesla. However, Elon Musk did co-found OpenAI and was its initial significant investor. Musk even placed OpenAI's cheif scientist, Ilya Sutskever, at OpenAI back in 2015. Even recently, Tesla's former Director of AI, Andrej Karpathy, is now working at OpenAI, specializing in deep learning and computer vision. So, Tesla, through Musk's own egghead network, has a direct pipeline to the leading AI scientists on the planet, bar none.
Frankly, what Musk is doing now with his Tesla bot is what Google should have done at Boston Dynamics after Google initially purchased it in December 2013. Apparantly Google's leaders didn't have the perseverence to force Boston Dynamic's hardware eggheads to work with Google's AI software eggheads ... so Google simply sold Boston Dynamics to SoftBank in April 2019. Softbank in turn sold BD to Hyundai, it's current parent. More importantly, do you know Hyundai as being an AI expert let alone a software expert? Right, neither do I.
As industrial robotistist Scott Walker, PhD, has said multiple times on other channels, anyone can build robots these days but the "secret sauce" that has been lacking all this time has been self-learning software to make bipedal co-robots an every day sight on the factory floor. He also added that Tesla's other advantage with their own co-robots is that they are the only manufacturing company that are able to develop and test their own AI-enabled bipedal co-robots on their own factory floors instead of going through customer's who may or may not see the need yet for bipedals.
Let's face it. Boston Dynamics had 10+ years to make Atlas prolific on their customers' factory floors. The fact that the world isn't looking to Boston Dynamics to make any more ground-breaking products of PRACTICAL use is proof that they make interesting stuff, but not useful stuff. If you REALLY want me to change my mind about that, then show me videos of Atlas working on a factory line instead of videos of it doing cute dances or parkour. That stuff doesn't generate revenue. If it did, then Google or SoftBank would still own Boston Dynamics as a BUSINESS interest, dude.
@@HyphenVM You are speaking the truth! Boston dynamics can easily add an AI layer into their system. They can even use their existing code to train an AI layer how to walk and move in the same way. It's similar to how tesla cars are trained using human driving behavior. Or how AI image generation is trained using human art styles. Boston dynamics can benefit greatly from their already well working system.
@@UnidudeNine Which realistically would be a massive waste of their time as Atlas isn't made for mass production. Its a show piece, a good show piece, but thats what it's built for. BD (MD or CEO, I can't recall which) have stated that they don't have the budget for a billion dollar super-computer or mass manufacturing facility to do the things Tesla is doing. Thats why they developed and market Spot. Even then they're 70-100k each, with the arm that looks like a neck. They're either remote controlled or pre-programmed.
The Tesla bot walks like a 90 year old man!
At the same time it's a 6 month old baby 😅
It will get better.
Asimo was a way better than that 13 years ago.
@redgeciccone8218 And nothing comes out that... all demonstration of its agility but no real-world application. Why do you think that is?
A superior elder indeed to Boastin' Dodonamics' "Alsdard:" bot, which rolls in on four wheels and waves its big blurry fists in high velocity circular attack spins in convincing workplace warehouses. The velocity is superior to any comparable speed, rate of travel or pace of motion known to movers.
Boston Dynamics bots are like soldiers. Tesla bots can barely do house chores. lol
The Teslabot can't even barely do chores, it can't do them at all. The robot was under remote control by humans when it was carrying out tasks in the videos.
Too early to judge. But the speed Tesla bot has been developed is impressive
@SkylinesAerialProductions it's not even up to date with modern robotics lol...and it's not like they are starting from scratch here
Boston Dynamics bots are like soldiers.. Dead? RIP Atlas 🫡
Apparently the author of this video is merely offering an uninformed opinion.
The Boston Dynamics Atlas robot has a massive library written by Engineers of movements.
Atlas then uses AI to evaluate its environment and task at hand, then from the library, it chooses the correct scenario and then adjusts and adapts that scenario to fit the specific task at hand.
The concept that the Tesla bot uses does indeed show more potential for greater growth. However the current software algorithms are still in their infancy. Hence the current difference in performance between the two robots.
Each company would truly benefit by incorporating both software algorithms to form a hybrid heuristic algorithm. Unquestionably it would then become an industry standard!
Teslabot = Like a newborn. Can hardly do anything else than wiggle around a bit.
BostonDynamics = State of the art, lightyear ahead of competitors.
The problem I have with this video is that the uses for the TeslaBot and Atlas are fundamentally different. Atlas is a platform used for R and D at Boston Dynamics. And TeslaBot is supposed to be a product for consumers. They are designed to be 2 different things therefore they’re functions are different
Ummmmmm.... What?? That is some serious cope! What could possibly be the "consumer product"?
I can think of one thousand things for a pre-programmed robot.
But something that "learns" very poorly and might not do what you want it to....... Like their horrible cars. Nope.... Can't think of anything besides a neat toy
If i were betting on robots - Atlas would be my bet! I wonder if Elon approached B.D. to try to collaborate. That would have been the best of both worlds!
Most Def, this title should be inversed. Backflipping, balance recovering from the hard kick robots are from Boston Dynamics. I hate liars, who is or are the "Future Mission"
@@selocan469 I think that this video has the opposite purpose than what it's title says. It is designed to have people protest that the B.D. robot is actually far superior which it obviously is (for now). I was embarrassed for Tesla when it show-cased the silliness of the Optimus robot. The whole world was embarrassed for Tesla when the human in the robot costume thing happened. Hopefully soon things will switch around and Optimus will become a real boy but for now it's a pretty silly thing.
@@tralfazy for now, and most likely for later B, D. will be better one. This is just another marketing and advertesment trick of Elon Musk. Such announcement will keep Tesla Stocks warm and cozy for a while and that is that
Atlas somehow has more soul than the more humanoid teslabot.
Well it was animated *
(The software not the robot) to look like it does
@@NumberBreak Well, the movement is derived from how humans move, right?
It's all about autonomy. If the robot is given just a basic command, then figures out the rest, on its own, then it's a true robot.
If every movement is programed in by a human, then it's just an r/c toy.
The Tesla bot will be as successful as the fully self driving car and hyper loop.
and as jam-solving as the tunnel :)
FSD is quite successful tho, its the leading technology in self driving cars. And now we got Gen 2 video which puts Tesla Bot way ahead of Boston Dynamics.
ahead? 😂 they still need stabilizing cables to not fall
@@nightowl0815
Who needs stabilization cables? Boston dynamics and Tesla bot, both no longer uses those, for quite some time by now. So what are you talking about here?
This is some serious cope! What could possibly be the "consumer product"?
I can think of one thousand things for a pre-programmed robot.
But something that "learns" very poorly and might not do what you want it to....... Like their horrible cars. Nope.... Can't think of anything besides a neat toy
Poor take buddy
@@sa34w you up for a bet? $1000 bucks says Tesla is worth 1/5 or less than what it is now in 5 years?
Tesla bot is hype.
Atlas is dead
Before making this video, make sure you know how BD's robot works and how AI wased used in Optimus. Based on my superficial knowledge of motion control and artificial intelligence, the facts are not as simple as you described, namely "Boston Dynamics programs the motions" and "Optimus uses artificial intelligence".
Its just an chat GPT video
The Tesla bot still can't dance, and what good is a robot that walks around like a little old man, when Atlas can run into a burning building and carry out a person, and as for Atlas, they are starting to incorporate AI to control it's movements and area guidance.
Sure if it can identify a human being on its own, avoid obstacles and identify the best path for safety. Tesla has a better chance at this than BD
@@sa34wjust wow😂😂
Tesla is not ahead. They are different robots. Bottom dynamics is wayyyy ahead! The tesla bot can't even run!!!!!!!!!!!
If Optimus battles Atlas in a CGI world, with CGI bots, it's even money.
trust me boston has some serious stuff behind the curtain.. they used to be a defence contractor for the army
Boston Dynamics over 33 years Tesla in 1 year achieve everything they have lol
Tesla works with Ai constantly
The robot uses the same navigation system as the cars dont they
Boston dinamics has self balancing Robots Spots can scan facilities climb stairs at amazing speeds and is very very effective in my opinion
Tesla is trying to make Ai
Boston Dinamics wants Robots
We canot compare them
I need one of these to help me in my day to day. Just having one would make a world of a difference.
So the Tesla robot, which is something any engineering undergraduate could cook up during a night of getting wasted, is better because it uses 'A.I.'...A.I. being software, a term that has lost its meaning because it's become a buzzword thrown at anything in the same way 'plant-based' has and in the case of Tesla, A.I. powered by an off the shelf Nvidia processor.
Or put it another way. Do you want a robot that slowly learns how to slowly shuffle around and cook your dinner or you want one programmed to do it perfectly, every time, in five minutes. Or better still, one with 'A.I.' that slowly learns how to do it, then does it with absolute precision, every time, in five minutes because it finely tuned, stabilised mechanics.
Bearing in mind the robot comes from a musk company, it's very likely that it will kill you anyway.
Multiple sources online say that Atlas can and does in fact move autonomously? I mean, obviously the parkour isn't autonomous, but I think it can at least walk and maybe jump autonomously.
Atlas is semi-automatic. Basically the engineer would work out the kinks for each behavior like jumping and rolling, but only for one specific model case. To account for variations in the actual run, the controller software adapts the numbers on the fly based on stuff like Atlas's current speed, footing, surrounding obstacles, platform height differences, etc. So all the driver needs to do to get Atlas to do parkour is guide it through the track and Atlas works out the details on its own. (Scott Kuindersma, Atlas' control team lead, explained the technical stuff in great detail on a Robotics Today seminar in 2020, available on YT.)
I think this approach is much better in achieving the level of reflex and dexterity required to do accurate back-to-back stunts compared to the AI approach, since the adjustments are much faster. I also believe there is an article about the dance video featuring one of their engineers stating that they streamlined the preprogramming process so they didn't have to manually compute too much stuff, which dramatically sped up the video production.
@@iyafath Huh. The more you know. Thanks for the interesting tidbit, internet stranger.
The best test for an autonomous moving bot, is the random fall.
If it can recover from any position, it's good.
I don't like these kinds of videos but the primary message that Optimus is based on AI and Atlas isn't is pretty much correct. Whoever knows robotics and programming knows very well the monumental difference in the frameworks. Anyone who compared the atlas and Optimus from the start just showed everyone how little they know. The surface level capabilities of the robots are almost irrelevant in fact, in this case. The difference is military robots made by BD will function more like piloted or semi autonomous drones. Optimus will be like an individual.
Don't get mad at AI, it's pointless. This one will keep pumping out videos to anyone that can press the Subscribe button.
@@AC-qe1io you're so right
The only educated and intelligent comment on this video. People who comment on topics of robotics and AI are usually the least qualified bigots.
I do understand what you are saying, and there is definitely impressive work that went into optimus. However, you can't simply compare the boston dynamics robot to what optimus will be (might be ) (might not be) (probably wont be) in the future. Im hopeful for the future too, but hopes don't beat reality.
Boston Dynamics has delivered robots to customers, Tesla can’t even deliver FSD after many years.
no facts showing tesla bot being better than BD. SMH
Robot receiving speech commands from a safe distance (2 to 8 meters): No. Just vaporware until then.
Boston dynamics is a company that I find much more trustworthy than Tesla. I don't really want to throw any of my money at Elon Musk.
But I do agree that while Atlas is amazing, a robot available for the general public doesn't need to do somersaults. It just needs to be able to do manual tasks around humans without endangering anyone when it slips or falls over. I assume the weight alone could be dangerous for a human when hit by a falling robot. And I hope that they will give the robots a proper face like Ameca. Just a black mask looks a little scary.
As far as l can see, nearly all the footage of Tesla's robot is CGI.
Atlas is good but Honda was the first very good bot, could walk,run etc... Tesla need to do more than that to impress.
Teslabot: Grandpa bot.
Atlas: Parkour Gigachad bot
No more ironing, washing, hoovering, drying, dusting, cleaning household chores would be worth it’s weight on gold!
The Tesla bot can shuffle, yea they are way ahead 😂😂😂
My favorite is Atlas❤️❤️❤️
Oh, I get it. You did a Sarcasm...Nooice!
"The AI in the Tesla bot is the same one found in the Tesla's vehicle." 😳...Oh, dear!
Agree. No proof of Tesla ahead....no sir. Boston is ten years ahead of all others in robotics like Tesla is in autonomous driving cars..
You got the right answer the wrong way. 0:56 bro that's a corridor crew video, they make VFX videos, that's not real.
2:30 it literally has to be conneted to a tether from the ceiling that attached to the head of the robot to keep it from falling over, these things are a joke
I would order a Teslabot now, if possible
Ah yes, the Ponzi Bot is OFFICIALLY ahead of Boston Dynamics
I don't think it's accurate to say that Optimus is ahead of Atlas. They each are built for different functions and each have something over the other.
Artificial Intelligence self-learning has great potential. Your robot could figure out that performing all household chores becomes easier after humans have been processed by the wood chipper in the backyard.
what your saying is the robot will logically think the problem with the house keeps on being untidy is the human, get rid of human , problem solved A.I THINKING.
Tesla may have their delays but they always deliver.
I love Atlas tho, its adorable
I think they got the title backwards. Boston Dynamics is at least five years ahaed of Tesla. Atlass is only one of a half dozen progams they are running.
I just hope im able to buy a bot to do my job rather than my company buying a bot to do my job 😄
Tesla bot is legitimately nowhere near BD and atlas... Telsa bot can sort coloured cubes and walk like a grandpa... also they both use AI?
Anyone claiming that Tesla is ahead of Boston Dynamics is a fool. Don't mean to be disrespectful.
Tesla never said they were releasing a smartphone.
The teslabot is programmed to learn how to function. This seems dangerous, as if it learns the wrong skillset, it can and sounds like it will use this knowledge that was instilled into it, for bad. Despite atlas and teslabot being designed for different reasons, teslabot is still in its early production and highly doubt they aren't looking to innovate further. If they continue with their design of being programmed to learn new skills, and then use this skillset based off its programming and learning functions, I feel like it could be compared to Boston dynamics "military killing machine". This isn't good news, but overall excited to see how tesla and bostondynamics plan to reduce the risks associated with their programming and functions.
Officially disliking this video,
taking proofs from Atlas CGI videos is really funny 😂😂😂😂
Tesla bots look like Pepsi Man on PS1
Those Photoshops of it being shot is from a VFX UA-cam video
Tesla does NOT have a lead over Boston Dynamics! What are you smoking?
Let them fight!
This hasn't aged well (December 2023)
So, Boston Dynamics robots are almost "hardcoded" with physics specific to the desired movement and Tesla Bot is using something like deep reinforcement learning?
I had to tap out when the video said tesla is inexperienced in the world of robotics... Their cars are robots, which are built by other robots
Atlas is soldier, Optimus is worker.
Boston dynamics is now owned by Hyundai which has great production capacity and resources equal to tesla
so your premise is teslabot is better because it might be better one day in the future!
"The AI found in the tesla bot is none other than the one found in tesla's vehicles".
lol, god help them.
Preprogrammed may not be a bad thing, especially with thinking about them helping make space liveable for humans. You would want them to perform direct functions that are programmed, but a non programmed one you can't guarantee it would take the same actions
Preprogrammed will only work on a case by case, very expensive. And if the environment changed, it won't know what to do. If you parked a forklift in front of the Boston Dynamics box picker it will just sit there. Tesla Bot already knows how to interpret different objects and work around them.
I think you're selling the Atlas bots programing a bit short. Boston Dynamics original design purpose was for nuclear power plant disastears. Tesla bot can barely stand on it's own.@@zigadabooga
Hopefully, soon, a boxing fight between Optimus and Atlas
The difference really is the ability to manipulate objects.
wanna see both robots fight; maybe we get a winner ;)
So they dont have a 'properly functioning robot', but they are miles ahead of Atlas? Futhermore, they are completly different platforms, for solving completly different problems, comparing these use cases is pointless.
I keep having to stop this video because i am so embarrassed for the guy talking! No one can believe this! Unless you are already a member of the Tesla cult.
Atlas has MUCH better balance, speed, and general athleticism. Makes the Teslabot look like it has an illness.
? We don’t need to watch thick robots we got humans
So basically what you are saying is a shaky robot that is AI powered is superior to a robot that can do back flips?? Like BD can write code that allows Atlas to run via AI, they actually could be working on that as you presented this video. I feel you are a Muskite!
Atlas fully uses deep reinforcement learning just like everything else.
This is way better realistic looking than Boston Dynamics. Soon Elon Musk will have this be way faster than Boston Dynamics 😂
I don't agree with you. Atlas has the most advanced bot. At this point in time the difficulty of creating a bot is mobility, in the end atlas will be run by AI. Boston Dynamics doesn't need to invest in AI because there are companies developing they will just need to implement it.
So if self driving cars don’t take off can I have the Tesla bot do it for me?😂
personally while i do see how tesla's *aka Elon Musk's* robot is technologically better, I like the model of boston's robot way better, so my ideal would be that they were combined.
So the AI used in the cars that have been supposed to be fully autonomous since 2017? Will it be as good as Hyperloop? I can't believe people still listen to this shill and take him seriously.
I would love to see Tesla aquire Boston dynamics. The two robots are like apples and oranges by comparison. A merger of the two could be very interesting 🤔
Are you daft??? Boston Dynamics is worth WAY too much for anyone to just "aquire" 😂
More like apples and a pile of shitty tesla vaporware.
@@petrichor3797 it got acquired by Hyundai in 2021
Isnt Boston Dinamics working with the army?
@@Stranger-gl6ieThey used to at some point but stopped after they had a moral crisis. Cowards
this is the first thing out of Tesla that I'm impressed with, but am very impressed.
This is just the very tip of the iceberg, oc.
I don't see it doing back flips. I wouldnt be surprised if the recent Tesla robot video is sped up like previous video.
Wrong and biased analysis. Tesla's robot has humanlike appearance but moves like a slow, old-fashioned robot. Atlas looks like a robot and moves like a human.
The solution to this hazard is really very simple. A big red stop button that cuts the power. Just like any other machine.
Imagine if Tesla and BD collaborate 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
I’m pretty sure if I pushed Optimus, he would fall. He moves like Biden
Optimus now can do Yoga.
that is really cool. I hope they consider use this technology to help disabled people. I think it will significantly improve their life
You forgot to mention if the Tesla Bot runs on an internal processor, or it runs on a room full of AI servers????
With Hyundai purchasing Boston Dynamic, then Boston Dynamic robot may be the first robot to use chopsticks? 😅
Tesla bot and Tesla AI, vaporware PR, 2023.
Much better if they work together.
"It looked like it was decades behind Atlas." Uhhh...that's because it is.
No, it looked like it because it was like 2 years into making while Atlas is like 20 years. But now... Atlast is heavily preprogramed robot, we had those decades ago. Tesla Bot is actually autonomous one.
I think you are wrong here, Boston one is ahead
I don't know why, but they look so medical.
No true that Boston Dynamics robots pre-programmed. They are programmed with very basic skills, then they learn by doing. They build upon the initial skills and figure out problems and communally grow and learn...
Robots making robots we are in trouble
It’s like the Tesla bot is a baby you just got to teach it
Never heard TeslaPhone, just rumors.
There of course is no Tesla phone and never will be.
They don’t want to go to war with apple
Boston dynamics is a straight line. Tesla is a parabola. At first the straight line beats the parabola. Then the parabola catches up and blows past it, never looking back.