GUYS! I have a Patreon now: patreon.com/eerietheghost?Link& Part 2 is out now where I review Polars music videos! Polar actually STEALS music?Yep! ua-cam.com/video/6jSSmuqqWeY/v-deo.html
I wouldn't call them evil Evil requires malice and malice requires intelligence They made 5 minute crafts, these people don't have half a braincells between them
And some songs are questionable but you don’t care anyways because it’s a bop. Butsomepeopleoutsideofthecommunitystartstomakememesasrantsstartoversaidmemeandlikecalmdownpl-
But what about, we turn Polar into a UTAU character and then make her sing her song called "Close to you" with more emotional things like a toxic relationship but in Japanese language?? (I've ever dreamed to make Polar looks more different and make her as Miku sister who pretend to be her, idk why this idea came from my mind just because of how I felt bad for Polar voice actress???)
The idea of Vocaloid existed back in 1999-2003 and came out in 2004, so vocal synthesis for singing isn't a new idea. Hatsune Miku, the face of Vocaloid, was released by Crypton Future Media back in 2007, and was followed up by Megurine Luka, and Kagamine Rin/Len. Meiko and Kaito were released before Miku, but they didn't get much success. Miku's appearance is so appealing because of her futuristic look and eye catching hair, as well as boasting an adorable feminine voice, so although her price tag is expensive, because of her popularity and public domain status, she is able to be used to make money quickly as producers can use her to make songs, get them licensed and go through all those processes. Vocaloids are also generally loved because of the flexibility of their software and character. Polar, a metaverse born singer, has none of these attributes that Miku has. No one can buy and make music with Polar, her design is unappealing and in a way scary because of the unrealistic proportions. She is not some genius idea as Vocaloid was, and her voice sounds very generic. Another thing is the songs themselves, with so many ways to tune in Vocaloid, with so many different Vocaloids, you get tons of different songs that all sound different, not because they are all different genres, but even with only Miku songs, you get the robotic, deep, raspy, cute, or high pitched Miku in all songs, which also all tell stories in a way. Polar was created as a money grab. She will sound the same, her songs will never be anything valuable, her appearance will always be ugly. Nothing will save her. I'm totally going back to my x0o0x_, Hiiragi Kirai, and guchiry. Polar sucks.
To be fair her model may not have gotten the best rig, that being said you would think they would invest a lot more money in the rigging and the 3d model, it's way worst the Miku's earlier models.
Especially try improving their motion capture. With how choppy this model moves, it looks like the motion capture actor/actress tripped every few seconds
I just want to imagine she's like Mileena from Mortal Kombat and is just hiding a mass of fangs that suck the artistic integrity out of her victims. Also, I've been to a Miku concert at a con once. Fuckin' fantastic. Waay better than what we got going on here.
Mouthless characters can exist and express emotions, but the eyes must do the heavy lifting when it comes to expressing, I don't think I've ever seen polars expresion change
@@AverageZardySimpalan becker’s stick figures dont even have faces and they express more emotion than polar lmao i cried watching animation vs minecraft episodes 29 and 30 😭😭😭
Imagine, they also come out with the Metaverse mirror images, twins, one a boy and one a girl. They have a yellow color scheme and some of their songs are Grief Butterfly, Tv Remote, Daughter of Meanness, Servant of Meanness, BRING IT, Kiddy Battle, and Lost Student’s Sadness. 🤣
And they're called East and West because Soulless publishing isn't clever enough to come up with a play on the words to come up with actual names, like Rin and Len being a play on Right and Left. Heck, they don't even gotta think, they can just steal the names Eas and Wes from Fresh Precure. Which would be perfect, tbh... the world those two come from is about as bland and soulless as the office and the people coming up with this whole mess. And don't forget the song "I deleted your game progress"
@@Hannah-bird you're right. Chicks are fluffy and cute and snuggle up to you for warmth. This Hatsune Miku look alike does none of those things. I'm sorry to all chicks
And this is why I love miku hatsune is because her songs tell a story and I hate cheap hatsune miku clone and I simp over miku hatsune and gumi and It's like miku hatsune is a better singer than her and I want to see a song battle between miku hatsune and cheap knockoff miku hatsune I would pay good money to see that happen and miku hatsune is better than cheap dollar store miku hatsune
The funnier part is that they keep saying "Polar feels this, Polar wants that, We discussed with Polar" like it's a real person. Just admit she's not a real person, Miku isn't portrayed as a real person.
Let's take miku make her hair a bit more green, make her face red all the time for no reason, give her way too much makeup, give her eye lashes that regularly goes true her hair, and can't forget some weird face mask type of thing so we don't have to animate a mouth.
Another problem is the fact that there's no individual underneath Polar. Since there's no company that makes all the vocaloid music, but it's instead individuals, you can actually connect with the real person who express what they want through vocaloids. People who say that Vocaloid is corporate garbage can pack their things and leave immediately. This is 100% companies trying to get the attention from young people after seeing the success of Vocaloid; but fail to see the importance of connection. We can already see this in the way Polar talks in the interviews. Hatsune Miku is largely shaped by the community, where this is just censored corporate money schemes.
im actually fucking terrified that shes gonna become really popular and get all the credit for doing vocaloid-like hollogram performances. but i also think that ppl r gonna forget about her by next year.
It wont, i hope. I think most of us, including me, sometimes underestimated how big Vocaloid actually is. She wont be taken over by some random devianart oc looking girl, at least not in this timeline. Also, we kinda have other Virtual Idols/singer like Gorillaz, KDA and especially Vtubers to back us up so...
It seems she gets like 7k views per vid on tik tok. That is AWFUL considering she supposedly has millions of followers. Not even 1% of her "fans" watch her video, which makes sense when you can fake followers, but it makes her look really bad. The awkward first gen iphone talking tom level animations definitely don't help. The only pro is that I like her mask. I love visual synthesizers, aside from that... hard pass.
@@franziska9260 nah nah nah we gotta give the enemy side hope, and after they think they are in the lead and will win we will pull out the trump card and obliterate them
Yes miku hatsune is queen vocaloid we will not let you take miku hatsune thrown miku hatsune is still queen and I love miku hatsune and my cousin loves miku hatsune
I’ll argue that Meiko or Luka should be queen based alone on vocal quality, but Miku had the cuter character design and so here we are. Not to say Miku’s voice is bad. If that were true she wouldn’t have a multi-million person worldwide fanbase.
It seems youtube nuked my original comment. Anyway! I completely agree with your public domain argument. Miku and the other Vocaloids have such reputation in the public because people wanted to share it, not because they were riding the algorithm but there's a genuine interest to share and craft which is a true backbone for growth! This is just 10 steps backwards. In fact, if anything this reminds me of those creepy channels from 2017 where you had nursery rhymes with cheap bottom of the barrel animation, performing whatever was popular at the time, it had eerily similar production value with all this cheap mocap and all that. Now, imma go pop in some Po-Pi-Po for therapy. 🎵
The voice isn’t bad, they just gotta make polar look extremely different than Miku, and probably improve the animation (Get rid of the mask just animate her mouth)
Why did ABBA do a hologram concert? Do they think that Vocaloid concerts didn’t have anything to do with that…… like Miku already had concerts with Lady Gaga. MMD has been a thing and when I was playing VRchat there were already a ton of models and even unity extensions made to support MMD models in unity…. Its not like multiple producers died an early death but were so driven to produce music that they drove miku’s popularity before they did. Its not like the western media when Miku first cane to the US was saying she was fake… Miku is voiced by a real person with lyrics written by real people and midi programmed/composed by real people. It gas never been a magic AI process and only recently are there some Vocaloid offshoot programs that use neural networks to learn how to sing. Its always been about being able to be more real because Miku has +1 charisma because she’s designed to be cute. Crypton just made her cute so she would sell, but the community used her as a mask to make music thats too edgy for them to make otherwise with a huge range of genres and topics. You cant build a community like that with the same struts as influencers or human pop stars, the peppers ghost concerts are just the icing on the cake. A community like Vocaloid/Vocal synth is built with the true thoughts of people shared around the world, with as Mary pop pins puts it a spoon ful of sugar helps people accept it long enough to listen to the idea, or for a few people to just appreciate the character for the cuteness only. Its not like other people dont have teal hair but have the sense to notice a movement and do your research before you launch your cringy product.
I dont think abba did that concert to diss on vocaloid concerts but to be some sort of reunion and tribute to what they looked like when they were younger doing concerts (though i could be wrong, but all i know is that they didn't do the concert to diss on vocaloid concerts)
Beginner MMD riggers can even make better movements than this metaverse avatar (I just couldn't say AI since her character doesn't really have any sentience lmao)
the one time i animated something on mmd, it was just simply miku walking, it looked so surprisingly realistic to me at the time that i had to question if I was really just a beginner or actually a pro. polar is simply painful to watch, it looks almost like she has no joints and they animate her in some crappy 3d software. honestly if i had the mental energy for it and the will to look at her for more than five minutes, i would animate her so much better. And im an actual noob in 3d animation.
I swear, if a kid walks up to me, no matter how young, and asks "Have you heard of Polar? She's so good" to my face I'm going to give them free dental treatment. And throw in a Vocaloid indoctrination program in for free.
after seeing how far vocaloid has come and with all the amazing work newcomers like kamitsubaki and CeVIO are doing to advance the vocaloid/utaita landscape, it is so incredibly sad to see such a superficial and soulless project... the worst part is that people who dont know about vocaloid and utaita will think that this shit is just like it and will have a bad image of it
6:02 Several other animes do this type of stuff to,not only Miku and Vocaloid,but VTubers like the ones from Hololive or Kizuna Ai,even the Callie and Marie from Splatoon as well as Gorillaz got their own irl virtual concerts. Polar is nothing but blasphemy compared to them.
even mihoyo can do better modelling and movements than metaverse born polar. and mihoyo isn't even a vocaloid company?? geez I thought conductor elysia from dreamy euphony concert was kinda stiff until I saw polar
Gorillaz: A British band that mixes and matches different genres with the animated musicians representing a particular genre. Made in response to the industry focusing on the celebrities behind the manufactured music polluting the industry. Has years of lore to the characters that give them depth and intrigue and became a smash hit with this combination of artistic genre blending and charmingly oddball characters. Hatsune Miku: A vocal instrument that was produced as a tool for a wide variety of music that can fit any genre. Passionate artists use it to create thousands of songs with their unique tone, style, and vision and create a community. The mascot became a star by accident because of how well it took off and she performs the songs at concerts and expos as a way to further show off the creativity the community has. Studio Killers: A European electronic band whose draw is their entrancing music and visuals. Shares the philosophy with Gorillaz of focusing on the music itself instead of the real people behind the curtain and creates some of the best vibes in the genre. Animated singer and other musically involved characters that stand in for the real world creators have a look that isn't conventionally attractive but is well designed and pops nicely. Polar: Virtual singer created by a corporation infamous for putting out mountains of garbage (and highly questionable) content. Music feels extremely manufactured to reach the most people possible and like it was written by an AI. Character has a design with alarming amounts of plagarism, somehow already got to the 500K-1M follower range with uncanny movements and lack of personality beyond virtual girl who wants to perform in the real world and whose creators either are extremely ignorant of what came before her or are the most pathetic liars hoping people are too stupid to call them out. *One of these things is not like the others...*
Splatoon: A video game about squids and octopi with idols singing in a completely made up language but still manages to make better music than polar. And not only that, they have also done irl hologram concerts.
Hell. Even Nintendo have done holographic concerts with the characters of Splatoon. Which even with gibberish lyrics have more emotion and passion than whatever "gen z xyz" is.
Not only Hatsune Miku had virtual life concerts, even gorillaz did. They pretend like it's new to mankind, but they're missing out since 2009. Like common, it ain't that new anymore
As a die hard vocaloid fan when she says "just type me in I'm in the screen"in Miku's song called anamanaguchi she says "hiding in your wi fi open secrets anyone can find me"they sound very familiar it could just be s coincidence but still,its polar
@@averyepicguy Lava Tail Miku is the Miku from my AU. Due to a timeline glitch, she got transported 200 years in the future and got corrupted by a virus that hates a certain guild. Now Miku wants to kill everyone in the guild.
polar has nothing that makes virtual singers unique, she just mimics real-life tiktok influencers in cheap 3d. and her clip just mimics other clips, made by real people. btw, real people are boring to look at when they dont move, and polar's movements look awful.
Yep your right. Right now polar has 1 mil subs (and if you compare her channel with the other channels that are from her company, you'll see that her sub count is way too low and not only that, there are a lot of comments saying that most of her followers/ subs are most likely bots) but whenever she releases a new song, the views are way too low for a channel that apparently has over 1 mil subs. So you can say polar is a bit of a flop when it comes to popularity.
Best tribute to MIKU ever, thank you so much for this, and I can't wait to see more commentary and events like this soon. Keep up the great work my new friend 👍🏾 😇🥰😇👍🏾
I think that everything about her is just....fine? Singing? Fine Character design? Fine I suppose VA? Fine Song? Okay this one isn't fine Is this revolutionary? NO HAVE YOU EVEN HEARD OF VOCALOIDS????
how cutting edge, her movement is so fluent, even fluent than what Hatsune Miku could do in that 2009 concert, i have to say only Toy Story (1995) can march her fluent movement
It’s 2023. Polar came out in 2022. Hatsune Miku first came out in 2007 and had her first live concert in 2009. *Miku and the other Vocaloids’ movements are smoother than Polar, and are getting even better as time passes.*
There is also some newer vocaloids such as Yameii and lil hdd who are impressively good. Not like accuracy to really human voices but rather approach and sound. The visuals are actually amazing too. Seeing them develop throughout the past few years has been one of the most rewarding things in my life. I recommend that people check them out!!!
The thing about this is how they claim how they claiming of being the "very first" of creating boundaries of virtual and physical from concert performance in metaverse etc, but Vocaloid has been doing all this and all for decades now and even the teal hair, the twin tails on one of her outfits? Even one of polar songs is like MitchiM song of miku wanting to split from virtual and physical realities (I cant think of name but saw on MitchieM channel and compared it). This is and feels like a westernize tiktoker Hatsune miku
She's not trying to capture the feelings of the current generation, she's trying to guide the thought of the coming generations. She's not made for us, she's made to change the ones who will come later, or who have only recently arrived.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
GUYS! I have a Patreon now: patreon.com/eerietheghost?Link&
Part 2 is out now where I review Polars music videos! Polar actually STEALS music?Yep!
ua-cam.com/video/6jSSmuqqWeY/v-deo.html
What? Why is she wearing a mask? 😷
@@brianwilliamson4922 because she’s allergic to authenticity
At least she wears her mask
Yay!
@@eerietheghost8925 nah she lost her mouth so her mask is the mouth
Vtuber models are more advanced than anything they made
As someone who works for a rigging company… yes. Ty.
yes
me who watches juniper: can confirm,
even V-tuber from small agency/circle and indie V-tuber has much better models and animation
wtf mark suckerberg
Vtuber designs are also hella more epic!
How the people who made that thing didn't die of cringe is beyond me
The people who made polar are behind the five minutes crafts channel.
@@anidiot4801 Yes, they aren't afraid to make cringy stuff
They invented cringe.
money
Dying of cringe is a one thing, how they are able to show their faces and speak about it so seriously is beyond me
Miku performed in a Lady Gaga concert and there is no chance for polar to appear at an Ariana Grande concert
The lizardman's ties are good enough to make it happen as a promotion of a metaverse
Even better, Miku was there because Lady Gaga herself was a fan of her. Doubt Polar would even be known by Grande.
Mhm
Really!?
It looks like a knockoff Xbox live avatar
Xbox avatars were the SHIT… way better than this despicable usurper trying to uproot the deep throne of our queen Hatsune Miku…
they made a clone of miku in the "new" Xbox live avatars but forgot to edit the mouth so they added a mask XD
Don’t insult my beloved Xbox 360 avatars, they deserve better than being compared to Polar.
This comment got me good, XD
LMAO
“Evil cannot create anything new, they can only corrupt and ruin good forces have invented or made” ― JRR Tolkien
I wouldn't call them evil
Evil requires malice and malice requires intelligence
They made 5 minute crafts, these people don't have half a braincells between them
Soulless corpos are gonna be soulless corpos
@@happynihilist2573 tbh they are really smart. They literally get money from people with single 0.5 braincell.
Just saw someone quoting this in another comment about 10 minutes ago
Life is a flat circle man
I mean it's a widely used (not to mention very relevant) quote given today's circumstances.
At least vocaloid songs tell stories.
and at least they make you feel something (*cough cough* servant of evil *cough cough*)
Tell stories?
OFFER YOUR HEART LIKE A DRUG-
And some songs are questionable but you don’t care anyways because it’s a bop. Butsomepeopleoutsideofthecommunitystartstomakememesasrantsstartoversaidmemeandlikecalmdownpl-
Because they are made by people not corporation. You, yourself, can make one.
*Servant of evil starts playing*
I want to see someone turn Polar's voice into an UTAU and make her sing Miku's song
Oh yeah. That would be the day. Better yet Teto or any UTAU can sing Polar’s song.
i literally want to do this now, i hate you
but we need the vocals only though, hmm
Don't give them an idea or i will f*cking find you whenever you are
im thinking miku miku ooeeoo
But what about, we turn Polar into a UTAU character and then make her sing her song called "Close to you" with more emotional things like a toxic relationship but in Japanese language??
(I've ever dreamed to make Polar looks more different and make her as Miku sister who pretend to be her, idk why this idea came from my mind just because of how I felt bad for Polar voice actress???)
The idea of Vocaloid existed back in 1999-2003 and came out in 2004, so vocal synthesis for singing isn't a new idea. Hatsune Miku, the face of Vocaloid, was released by Crypton Future Media back in 2007, and was followed up by Megurine Luka, and Kagamine Rin/Len. Meiko and Kaito were released before Miku, but they didn't get much success. Miku's appearance is so appealing because of her futuristic look and eye catching hair, as well as boasting an adorable feminine voice, so although her price tag is expensive, because of her popularity and public domain status, she is able to be used to make money quickly as producers can use her to make songs, get them licensed and go through all those processes. Vocaloids are also generally loved because of the flexibility of their software and character.
Polar, a metaverse born singer, has none of these attributes that Miku has. No one can buy and make music with Polar, her design is unappealing and in a way scary because of the unrealistic proportions. She is not some genius idea as Vocaloid was, and her voice sounds very generic.
Another thing is the songs themselves, with so many ways to tune in Vocaloid, with so many different Vocaloids, you get tons of different songs that all sound different, not because they are all different genres, but even with only Miku songs, you get the robotic, deep, raspy, cute, or high pitched Miku in all songs, which also all tell stories in a way.
Polar was created as a money grab. She will sound the same, her songs will never be anything valuable, her appearance will always be ugly. Nothing will save her.
I'm totally going back to my x0o0x_, Hiiragi Kirai, and guchiry. Polar sucks.
we can make an utau vb with polar though 😏😏
@@underscoredotpng I could totally make that.
@@spatial_rind we dont want that but minnemi would
@@pluviocore Yeah probably
Ayo fellow x0o0x_ enjoyer
To be fair her model may not have gotten the best rig, that being said you would think they would invest a lot more money in the rigging and the 3d model, it's way worst the Miku's earlier models.
Especially try improving their motion capture. With how choppy this model moves, it looks like the motion capture actor/actress tripped every few seconds
I just want to imagine she's like Mileena from Mortal Kombat and is just hiding a mass of fangs that suck the artistic integrity out of her victims.
Also, I've been to a Miku concert at a con once. Fuckin' fantastic. Waay better than what we got going on here.
Ironically, that idea is much more interesting than what she actually is
Miku could write Generation Z but Polar could NEVER write World Is Mine 😤
Even I think Polar can't beat Disappearance of Hatsune Miku 😏
@@Mahlukhidup10 oh. I would actually watch them try to do that.
Not the actual final project. But the process.
@@usonohoshi6165 Wow... I will see it when it was done :)
Miku didnt write World is Mine.
@@SethTwiright_ Yes i know, that song was created by Ryo right?
Mouthless characters can exist and express emotions, but the eyes must do the heavy lifting when it comes to expressing, I don't think I've ever seen polars expresion change
if theyre not even gonna bother animating polar’s face, might as well hide the whole face itself
I think its just the stupidest and lazy-est idea to make a singer mouthless...
take the character “tack” from the thief and the cobbler for example, he expresses wayy more emotions WITHOUT TALKIN
@@AverageZardySimpalan becker’s stick figures dont even have faces and they express more emotion than polar lmao i cried watching animation vs minecraft episodes 29 and 30 😭😭😭
Oh my god, she's the kidz bop of vocaloid
oh God your right
WHAT
Not wrong
OH MY GOD
THIS IS THE COMMENT EVER
Imagine, they also come out with the Metaverse mirror images, twins, one a boy and one a girl. They have a yellow color scheme and some of their songs are Grief Butterfly, Tv Remote, Daughter of Meanness, Servant of Meanness, BRING IT, Kiddy Battle, and Lost Student’s Sadness. 🤣
They'll definently do that.. im not even joking lol.
And they're called East and West because Soulless publishing isn't clever enough to come up with a play on the words to come up with actual names, like Rin and Len being a play on Right and Left.
Heck, they don't even gotta think, they can just steal the names Eas and Wes from Fresh Precure. Which would be perfect, tbh... the world those two come from is about as bland and soulless as the office and the people coming up with this whole mess.
And don't forget the song "I deleted your game progress"
Don't forget Sapporo stuffed bear and broadcaster e-boy 😱
@@platypus3674 WHAT THE HELL IS SAPPORO LOL
They’re just ripping off vocaloids and vocaloid songs.
I feel sorry for Polar’s voice actress, she’s probably getting attacked for being part of this atrocity. I don’t think her singing is that bad.
Was thinking the same thing. While it’s not my favorite, the singing is not half bad at all lol
I don’t think anyone even knows who actually did the songs
She also voices for other thesoul's project aswell like pinky z
Her voice is ok just the song lyrics lol??
@@eudouriau5667 the lyrics is so flat and it feels too cheesy and generic, the song mixing is bad. Her voice is decent
This chick: metaverse influencer
Miku Hatsune: vocal synthesizer
I'll take the one that can sing what i want them to sing. Thx
Dont insult chicks like that
@@Hannah-bird you're right. Chicks are fluffy and cute and snuggle up to you for warmth. This Hatsune Miku look alike does none of those things. I'm sorry to all chicks
aint no way they think we gon like that cheap hatsune miku knockoff 💀💀💀
wish miku :skull: :skull:
And this is why I love miku hatsune is because her songs tell a story and I hate cheap hatsune miku clone and I simp over miku hatsune and gumi and It's like miku hatsune is a better singer than her and I want to see a song battle between miku hatsune and cheap knockoff miku hatsune I would pay good money to see that happen and miku hatsune is better than cheap dollar store miku hatsune
I think polar isn't a voice bank
@@nicalennieee she is just gross and her songs don't even tell a story they are just lazy
@@nicalennieee Yeah I’m like 50/50% sure it might be a voice bank or some womens voice.
The VA of Polar doesnt deserve the hate. The people who made her should burn in the depths of the internet hell
The funnier part is that they keep saying "Polar feels this, Polar wants that, We discussed with Polar" like it's a real person. Just admit she's not a real person, Miku isn't portrayed as a real person.
for REAL like polar who? polar the voice in your head?? 😭😭
Let's take miku make her hair a bit more green, make her face red all the time for no reason, give her way too much makeup, give her eye lashes that regularly goes true her hair, and can't forget some weird face mask type of thing so we don't have to animate a mouth.
I still expected some animation
@@dizzyheads her rig is so wish quality lmao
Don't forget a painfully generic wardrobe
they copied K/DA All out Akalli and fuse her with miku.
@@neoe5970 dont forget the totally animated clothes.
Another problem is the fact that there's no individual underneath Polar. Since there's no company that makes all the vocaloid music, but it's instead individuals, you can actually connect with the real person who express what they want through vocaloids.
People who say that Vocaloid is corporate garbage can pack their things and leave immediately.
This is 100% companies trying to get the attention from young people after seeing the success of Vocaloid; but fail to see the importance of connection. We can already see this in the way Polar talks in the interviews.
Hatsune Miku is largely shaped by the community, where this is just censored corporate money schemes.
And the concept of 'metaverse' is also not new, since similar things like that has been exist for a long time.
im actually fucking terrified that shes gonna become really popular and get all the credit for doing vocaloid-like hollogram performances. but i also think that ppl r gonna forget about her by next year.
It wont, i hope. I think most of us, including me, sometimes underestimated how big Vocaloid actually is. She wont be taken over by some random devianart oc looking girl, at least not in this timeline.
Also, we kinda have other Virtual Idols/singer like Gorillaz, KDA and especially Vtubers to back us up so...
It seems she gets like 7k views per vid on tik tok. That is AWFUL considering she supposedly has millions of followers. Not even 1% of her "fans" watch her video, which makes sense when you can fake followers, but it makes her look really bad. The awkward first gen iphone talking tom level animations definitely don't help. The only pro is that I like her mask. I love visual synthesizers, aside from that... hard pass.
@@donutchan8114 yeah, a good chunk of her "followers" r definitely bots...
She better be forgotten
dont worry she didnt
Not gonna lie, I kinda wanna see Polar and Miku have rap battle.
you've heard the disappearance of hatsune miku. we all have. she'd end this bargain bin knockoff in 10 seconds flat
@@franziska9260 too early! Don't bring out the big guns yet
@@franziska9260 nah nah nah we gotta give the enemy side hope, and after they think they are in the lead and will win we will pull out the trump card and obliterate them
@@alikuoli Very good idea.
miku and all of her sekai versions would win easily
Ah, yes its Poor-lar again. Those fashion style she wore are so colorful it bleeds my eyes.
No one can replace Hatsune Miku she is vocaloid queen
Yes miku hatsune is queen vocaloid we will not let you take miku hatsune thrown miku hatsune is still queen and I love miku hatsune and my cousin loves miku hatsune
Exactly Miku is the vocaloid queen they could never replace her
@@ron_delite1 hello zenitsu team Miku
I’ll argue that Meiko or Luka should be queen based alone on vocal quality, but Miku had the cuter character design and so here we are. Not to say Miku’s voice is bad. If that were true she wouldn’t have a multi-million person worldwide fanbase.
Miku have everything
You already know she’s going to be capitalizing off of teen tiktokers when you hear how she says “singer”
Seen-grr
@@normanclatchers in grrrr
It seems youtube nuked my original comment. Anyway! I completely agree with your public domain argument. Miku and the other Vocaloids have such reputation in the public because people wanted to share it, not because they were riding the algorithm but there's a genuine interest to share and craft which is a true backbone for growth! This is just 10 steps backwards. In fact, if anything this reminds me of those creepy channels from 2017 where you had nursery rhymes with cheap bottom of the barrel animation, performing whatever was popular at the time, it had eerily similar production value with all this cheap mocap and all that.
Now, imma go pop in some Po-Pi-Po for therapy. 🎵
Honestly, calling polar wallmart miku is an insult to wallmart...
agreed
More like a bargin bin Hatsune Miku.
@@ragdll4791 I feel bad for that garbage bin
@@--florien-- I'm trying to hold back from laughing in front of my family rn
True shes poo and pee fake water hair
The voice isn’t bad, they just gotta make polar look extremely different than Miku, and probably improve the animation
(Get rid of the mask just animate her mouth)
snuuy pfp
“Mom, can we have Hatsune Miku?”
“No, we have Hatsune Miku at home.”
Hatsune Miku at home:
5:16 Polar should make a “I wear a mask with a smile for hours at a time” cover LMAO
and when they ask me how im doing i say im just fine.. 😔💔💔
Why did ABBA do a hologram concert? Do they think that Vocaloid concerts didn’t have anything to do with that…… like Miku already had concerts with Lady Gaga. MMD has been a thing and when I was playing VRchat there were already a ton of models and even unity extensions made to support MMD models in unity…. Its not like multiple producers died an early death but were so driven to produce music that they drove miku’s popularity before they did. Its not like the western media when Miku first cane to the US was saying she was fake… Miku is voiced by a real person with lyrics written by real people and midi programmed/composed by real people. It gas never been a magic AI process and only recently are there some Vocaloid offshoot programs that use neural networks to learn how to sing. Its always been about being able to be more real because Miku has +1 charisma because she’s designed to be cute. Crypton just made her cute so she would sell, but the community used her as a mask to make music thats too edgy for them to make otherwise with a huge range of genres and topics. You cant build a community like that with the same struts as influencers or human pop stars, the peppers ghost concerts are just the icing on the cake. A community like Vocaloid/Vocal synth is built with the true thoughts of people shared around the world, with as Mary pop pins puts it a spoon ful of sugar helps people accept it long enough to listen to the idea, or for a few people to just appreciate the character for the cuteness only. Its not like other people dont have teal hair but have the sense to notice a movement and do your research before you launch your cringy product.
I dont think abba did that concert to diss on vocaloid concerts but to be some sort of reunion and tribute to what they looked like when they were younger doing concerts (though i could be wrong, but all i know is that they didn't do the concert to diss on vocaloid concerts)
5:37
“See guys? I’m hip and trendy with the kids 🤪”
-5 Minute Crafts Hatsune Miku
Ariana grande would preform with Hatsune miku way before polar stands a chance
I’m going to cry if a kid says “ MIKU IS A COOY OF POLAR “ like you can see Miku has been out longer. Just look at the popipo date.
I love the Hatsune Miku's "Miku's Little Dark Age" and "Ms. Miku After Dark" , it's just really amazing how she has so many different songs.
Hatsune Miku has already become a GODDESS of music!! half of Japan goes crazy for it!!
Miku is life, and no one can change my mind! 🤗
AGREED
AND NO ONE GOING TO REPLACE HER!!
AGREE WITH THIS COMMENT!!!!MIKU IS THE QUEEN!! 👑 SHE RULE THE WORLD!!! 🌎💫👑💙💙💙💙💙💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖❤❤❤❤❤
@@rianneraldrete NO, SHE OWNS THE WORLD!!!
@KimyonoKodo Maybe Elvis Presley? He's the true KING
@@zdzistrix (use google translate) entonces ve a decir eso en un vídeo sobre Elvis y no aquí
Whenever her arms bend, it looks like she's folding 😰
Miku will always be the number one princess in the world
Beginner MMD riggers can even make better movements than this metaverse avatar (I just couldn't say AI since her character doesn't really have any sentience lmao)
the one time i animated something on mmd, it was just simply miku walking, it looked so surprisingly realistic to me at the time that i had to question if I was really just a beginner or actually a pro.
polar is simply painful to watch, it looks almost like she has no joints and they animate her in some crappy 3d software.
honestly if i had the mental energy for it and the will to look at her for more than five minutes, i would animate her so much better. And im an actual noob in 3d animation.
I swear, if a kid walks up to me, no matter how young, and asks "Have you heard of Polar? She's so good" to my face I'm going to give them free dental treatment. And throw in a Vocaloid indoctrination program in for free.
Can’t believe people actually contribute to making this.
Polar trys to make everyone convince she's a real person while everyone else trys to convince you she's not wish Hatsune Miku
after seeing how far vocaloid has come and with all the amazing work newcomers like kamitsubaki and CeVIO are doing to advance the vocaloid/utaita landscape, it is so incredibly sad to see such a superficial and soulless project... the worst part is that people who dont know about vocaloid and utaita will think that this shit is just like it and will have a bad image of it
Fun fact: Hatsune Miku is older than Polar
You mean their "in-universe" age or when they were invented
no sh sherlock
3:09 “5-minute craft”
Ya know? That somehow explains everything.
With troom troom, they make hell a this is their child.
6:02
Several other animes do this type of stuff to,not only Miku and Vocaloid,but VTubers like the ones from Hololive or Kizuna Ai,even the Callie and Marie from Splatoon as well as Gorillaz got their own irl virtual concerts.
Polar is nothing but blasphemy compared to them.
EXACTLY
even mihoyo can do better modelling and movements than metaverse born polar.
and mihoyo isn't even a vocaloid company??
geez I thought conductor elysia from dreamy euphony concert was kinda stiff until I saw polar
Gorillaz: A British band that mixes and matches different genres with the animated musicians representing a particular genre. Made in response to the industry focusing on the celebrities behind the manufactured music polluting the industry. Has years of lore to the characters that give them depth and intrigue and became a smash hit with this combination of artistic genre blending and charmingly oddball characters.
Hatsune Miku: A vocal instrument that was produced as a tool for a wide variety of music that can fit any genre. Passionate artists use it to create thousands of songs with their unique tone, style, and vision and create a community. The mascot became a star by accident because of how well it took off and she performs the songs at concerts and expos as a way to further show off the creativity the community has.
Studio Killers: A European electronic band whose draw is their entrancing music and visuals. Shares the philosophy with Gorillaz of focusing on the music itself instead of the real people behind the curtain and creates some of the best vibes in the genre. Animated singer and other musically involved characters that stand in for the real world creators have a look that isn't conventionally attractive but is well designed and pops nicely.
Polar: Virtual singer created by a corporation infamous for putting out mountains of garbage (and highly questionable) content. Music feels extremely manufactured to reach the most people possible and like it was written by an AI. Character has a design with alarming amounts of plagarism, somehow already got to the 500K-1M follower range with uncanny movements and lack of personality beyond virtual girl who wants to perform in the real world and whose creators either are extremely ignorant of what came before her or are the most pathetic liars hoping people are too stupid to call them out.
*One of these things is not like the others...*
Splatoon: A video game about squids and octopi with idols singing in a completely made up language but still manages to make better music than polar. And not only that, they have also done irl hologram concerts.
Hell. Even Nintendo have done holographic concerts with the characters of Splatoon.
Which even with gibberish lyrics have more emotion and passion than whatever "gen z xyz" is.
Not only Hatsune Miku had virtual life concerts, even gorillaz did. They pretend like it's new to mankind, but they're missing out since 2009. Like common, it ain't that new anymore
Polar has no drip compared to Miku.
As a die hard vocaloid fan when she says "just type me in I'm in the screen"in Miku's song called anamanaguchi she says "hiding in your wi fi open secrets anyone can find me"they sound very familiar it could just be s coincidence but still,its polar
1:21 "Meanwhile everything else doesn't have that many views." AND THAT IS HOW YOU KNOW THEY BUY FOLLOWERS!
As someone named Polar, on the behalf of those named Polar in every community, I don't claim this girl
3:50 Hatsune Miku!
Hatsune miku will disgusted if she saw this
Yep. Especially if Lava Tail Miku saw this. I think she will obliterate Polar in a matter of seconds.
Just that "are you British?" Shitpost but "are you Polar? Ono, ononono"
@@unknownvesselelenadediego4236 who’s lava tail miku?
@@averyepicguy Lava Tail Miku is the Miku from my AU. Due to a timeline glitch, she got transported 200 years in the future and got corrupted by a virus that hates a certain guild. Now Miku wants to kill everyone in the guild.
I watched Polar’s Generation Z music video, and I can confirm,
She is indeed inside my screen.
HELP UR EVERYWHERE
@@avinoired
I am?
I feel honored to be one of those people!
polar has nothing that makes virtual singers unique, she just mimics real-life tiktok influencers in cheap 3d. and her clip just mimics other clips, made by real people. btw, real people are boring to look at when they dont move, and polar's movements look awful.
"Discover her personality"
SHE DOESNT HAVE ONE
5:07 Missed opportunity to say" **TheSouless** corpos".
Miku's voicebank released in August 31st 2007.
Her first ever live concert came out 2 years after her voicebank release [August 2009]
2:14
They had the chance to read z as "zed" to make it ryhme bettee but they went with "zeh?" USE THE OTHER PRONUNCIATION AT LEAST IT SOUNDS GOOD
wtf in indo we say it as zed lmfao
The Soul Publishing: What's Japan? Never heard of it!
Also The Soul Publishing: What do you mean someone already made this?!
I think most of those follows are just bots
The people in soulpublishing are bots
Basically 🤖
I think the same too
5:31 Ariana would be so scared if she was performing with her.
She's the type of person to pronounce Hatsune miku like *"hat soon miku"*
Somehow, I don’t feel like the 5 minute craft people might not be all that good in the music department
Yep your right. Right now polar has 1 mil subs (and if you compare her channel with the other channels that are from her company, you'll see that her sub count is way too low and not only that, there are a lot of comments saying that most of her followers/ subs are most likely bots) but whenever she releases a new song, the views are way too low for a channel that apparently has over 1 mil subs. So you can say polar is a bit of a flop when it comes to popularity.
4:09 bacon man that you??
I CANT UNSEE IT
Best tribute to MIKU ever, thank you so much for this, and I can't wait to see more commentary and events like this soon. Keep up the great work my new friend 👍🏾 😇🥰😇👍🏾
''Thrift store miku''
THATS SO DISRESPECTFULL TO THE THRIFT STORE'S NOT EVEN THE THRIFT STORE WOULD WANT THAT.... thing..?
I like how everyone knows Hatsune Miku, meanwhile I bet this "metaverse influencer" doesn't become popular
1:49 Shit's so fire I don't want to be part of Gen Z anymore 🔥
I think that everything about her is just....fine?
Singing? Fine
Character design? Fine I suppose
VA? Fine
Song? Okay this one isn't fine
Is this revolutionary? NO HAVE YOU EVEN HEARD OF VOCALOIDS????
how cutting edge, her movement is so fluent, even fluent than what Hatsune Miku could do in that 2009 concert, i have to say only Toy Story (1995) can march her fluent movement
I feel like Polar only increased everyone’s respect for Hatsune Miku
It’s 2023. Polar came out in 2022. Hatsune Miku first came out in 2007 and had her first live concert in 2009. *Miku and the other Vocaloids’ movements are smoother than Polar, and are getting even better as time passes.*
"My dream is to perform with Ariana grande"
THAT HAD ME DYING HAHAHAHA
There is also some newer vocaloids such as Yameii and lil hdd who are impressively good. Not like accuracy to really human voices but rather approach and sound. The visuals are actually amazing too. Seeing them develop throughout the past few years has been one of the most rewarding things in my life. I recommend that people check them out!!!
2:27 wtf I love this song but I think that gremlin from iceland xd
no matter what happens, miku will always slay
She is a such a "pick me girl" and yeah that's all
Miku ran so that Polar could crawl.
to call her a knock-off Miku is a disgrace to miku's name
My daughter has to do a presentation of her own choice.
She added a sentence that goes like "A vocaloid is like a virtual singer, but polar is not"
6:09 bruh, every vocaloids, Kasane Teto and Akita Neru did that.
They're the same people who just found about Second Life and the concept of buying digital goods in a virtual environment like a novelty.
The thing about this is how they claim how they claiming of being the "very first" of creating boundaries of virtual and physical from concert performance in metaverse etc, but Vocaloid has been doing all this and all for decades now and even the teal hair, the twin tails on one of her outfits? Even one of polar songs is like MitchiM song of miku wanting to split from virtual and physical realities (I cant think of name but saw on MitchieM channel and compared it). This is and feels like a westernize tiktoker Hatsune miku
I love how the proper PROMOTIONAL articles about Polar are just of the same company that made her.
She's not trying to capture the feelings of the current generation, she's trying to guide the thought of the coming generations. She's not made for us, she's made to change the ones who will come later, or who have only recently arrived.
They will not succeed.
As smokeebee once said: "its basically the great value hatsune miku" , and thats pretty accurate
It'd be so funny if Ariana performed with Hatsune Miku instead kdjfkds
0:11 so polar… your pretty much a bad influencer…heh
The fact that you made this video at 7 percent battery is incredible
I just hope this reignited the vocaloid fandom
As a member of the Gen Z Imma bout to sue the creators of Polar for misrepresentation of my age.
I’m sure Hatsune Miku would love this video.
Polar isn't ripping off Hatsune Miku however, but an entire Band from a MOBA: KDA from League of Legends