The Mk I Martini-Henry: The CHAP's Black Powder Mad Minute Challenge

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
  • If you would like to support the Channel you can do so through our Patreon Page.
    / britishmuzzleloaders
    And Follow us on FB for updates and projects!
    / britishmuzzleloaders
    Thanks to Balazs at Cap and Ball for use of his clip of the Werndl rifle! Have a look at his Channel at / capandball .
    For your Martini and Snider needs email Martyn at xringservices@yahoo.com
    For your P53 Enfield Rifle-Musket or Short Rifle ammunition needs, Contact Brett at - www.papercartridges.com
    And for further reading on all British Victorian (and earlier) arms stop by the British Militaria Forum and say hello. britishmilitari...
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 248

  • @Candrsenal
    @Candrsenal 2 роки тому +70

    Tell me there is a webpage with the list, both what's been done and what's still wanted.

    • @TchaikovskyFDR
      @TchaikovskyFDR 2 роки тому +8

      There has not been one with a rolling block, or Springfield Trapdoor. Or the Berdan. I think maybe the Werndl has been done.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +15

      Neither of us has a website 😅
      I’ll publish there Peabody next week. Coming up in collaboration with SBAM will be Carcano 1867 and Mauser M71. I‘m hoping to have CapnBall do the Werndl.

    • @lptomtom
      @lptomtom 2 роки тому +7

      Othais and Mae to the rescue!

    • @mikehoare6093
      @mikehoare6093 2 роки тому +2

      @@thebotrchap there´s a nice series about the war of 1870

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +4

      @@mikehoare6093 There is indeed 😉

  • @pmgn8444
    @pmgn8444 2 роки тому +40

    Ah! A black-powder nerd-out with Rob and Le Chap. The two guys getting me to think about US Civil War black powder arms instead of my beloved Cold War guns. Nice job gentlemen, I hope to see future collaborations.

  • @YerluvinunclePete
    @YerluvinunclePete 2 роки тому +22

    Making it a test of "aimed fire" also tests the shooting ergonomics of the rifle. Sights and furniture make difference.

  • @papercartridges6705
    @papercartridges6705 2 роки тому +8

    This came up on auto-play while I was listening in the background… heard BotR guitar and then…. was very confused.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +4

      The luxuries one has when one is not neck deep in desert and ordnance.... 😀

  • @grantlancaster9051
    @grantlancaster9051 2 роки тому +5

    “Well we haven’t done a Springfield Trapdoor yet, we don’t have one”
    *InRange Karl intensifies*

  • @JosipRadnik1
    @JosipRadnik1 2 роки тому +7

    If you are armed with a single shot black powder rifle... don't challenge Rob :-)

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +2

      Haha! If there are more than you 12 of you, I'm done for...

    • @JosipRadnik1
      @JosipRadnik1 2 роки тому +1

      @@britishmuzzleloaders
      I've just a bid over an old werndl 1877 rifle. rifling looked good and mechanics seemed to be solid and working. Brass, bullet molds and dies have to be organised yet but I'm hoping to get this old thing shooting by next spring. I live in the same country as the chap does which famously istn't a big one. So maybe he can do another mad minute. let's see

  • @kevingarrett2559
    @kevingarrett2559 2 роки тому +6

    Thanks for this Rob. The Women’s Institute applause clips gave me a chuckle

  • @kenibnanak5554
    @kenibnanak5554 2 роки тому +5

    I have done my own mad minute tests with a Rolling Block, a .50-70 Trapdoor, a .45-70 Trapdoor, a Sharps .50-70 carbine and a Martini-Henry. There is no question that the Martini Henry (using Kynoch ammo) was the fastest operating system, followed by the Sharps. The Rolling Block was the slowest. In point of fact I expected you to run out of pouched Martini Henry ammunition before your minute was up. :) Good video. In my 1866 Trapdoor .50-70 video I do indeed hold some rounds between my fingers to demonstrate the technique. I do know that some Buffalo Hunters wrote of doing that, but that is different from soldiers in a unit.

  • @88porpoise
    @88porpoise 2 роки тому +11

    As someone completely inexperienced with such rifles, the operation of a Matini-Henry just seems so natural and fluid for a single shot rifle, where you are already lowering the rifle from your shoulder and the force of the action is up and down.
    Whereas the bolt action your forces are going primarily backward and forward, which works great with repeaters staying in your shoulder.
    However, even if there is an advantage it is likely far smaller than the quirks of the rifles, ammunition, equipment, shooter, etc, etc.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +6

      There is a comparison of the Magazine Rifle and the Martini on the Channel if you are interested.

    • @onpsxmember
      @onpsxmember 2 роки тому +2

      Shortcut via partial youtube url: /watch?v=dzZNWIICWBs

    • @peterconnan5631
      @peterconnan5631 2 роки тому

      Shaun, there is something immensely satisfying in the action of shoving a big fat cartridge into the chamber of a falling or tilting block single-shot.

  • @JasperFromMS
    @JasperFromMS 2 роки тому +4

    Excellent point about ammunition availability. The slow, aimed fire makes sense when you ghink about early industrial shipping methods. Think of the cost of having to transport a case of ammo from the factory to the other side of the world. Then unload it at the port, onto a rail car if you're lucky, then by animal power to its "final" destination, the soldier's pouch.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +2

      Definitely an important aspect to consider

    • @mpetersen6
      @mpetersen6 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders
      Theres a scene in Nicholas and Alexandra early in the film in which one of the Russian Imperial Staff* is making the point that every round of ammunition being g used in the Russo-Japanese War has to be shipped from the armories in European Russia all the way to the Far East on the mostly single track Trans Siberian Railroad. The TSR along with the Suez were the mega engineering projects of the 19th Century. The TSR made the US trans continental line look like an industrial branch line.
      *played by Jack Hawkins in his last role if memory serves.

  • @davidbriggs7365
    @davidbriggs7365 2 роки тому +2

    Speaking as a U.S. Army Veteran (Vietnam Era, I went to Germany), having the pouch on the belly makes a lot of sense. Placing a single pouch on the side unbalances a person, and so it is best to split the single pouch and have two pouches, one on each side of the midpoint. While having a single pouch in the center means that you have to reach under the rifle to get more ammunition, that is less of a bother than trying to reach WAY UNDER the rifle to access the left hand pouch (especially if you are right handed) while trying to reload when the right hand pouch is empty. In fact, I sometimes found that it was easier for me to use my left hand to access the left side pouch than trying to use my right hand to access that pouch on my left side. Just FYI.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +1

      Interesting thanks!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Not a lot of "unbalancing" going on.. The P71 is certainly an asymmetric set when it comes to ammo and it's not really an issue.

  • @yojimbo6879
    @yojimbo6879 2 роки тому +3

    Drinking coffee and listening to you both makes for a perfect Sunday morning. Thanks!

  • @Pedro8k
    @Pedro8k 2 роки тому +6

    I could back in the day get 12 arrows a minute off a 50 pound longbow at fifty yards so very similar to your demo we called it a speedshoot Good video

  • @tokencivilian8507
    @tokencivilian8507 2 роки тому +7

    BM at Desert Brutality...using a Martini-Henry. Then have Ian run the same course with the same rifle. Then the fun would begin...to see BM run the course with Ian's rifle of choice. :-) But seriously, great vid BM.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +5

      One day!

    • @mpetersen6
      @mpetersen6 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders
      Odds are Ian's rifle of choice would be some obscure version of a French service rifle of the period. For another non European single shot Karl on In Range really ran the Trapdoor Springfield faster than I thought one could.

  • @TheWirksworthGunroom
    @TheWirksworthGunroom 2 роки тому +5

    Great stuff gentlemen. Thank you!

  • @ShaDOWDoG667
    @ShaDOWDoG667 2 роки тому +2

    Oooooh a hour long mad minute video!!!

  • @mikehoare6093
    @mikehoare6093 2 роки тому +4

    Well done Rob, someone has to save the honour of the empire !

  • @EXO9X8
    @EXO9X8 2 роки тому +2

    Most ambitious anime crossover as of late. Bravo, I say to your conjoined effort.

  • @benjaminhenegar291
    @benjaminhenegar291 2 роки тому +4

    This is awesome, wish I was able to do this, these old rifles are amazing, gotta get one soon love both of these designs

  • @titanscerw
    @titanscerw 7 місяців тому

    Thank you for your hard work Rob and Chap for getting the train moving, it is invaluable and it turns my thinking to those years of old that decided direction of events to come. In my case War of 1866 - Königgratz Battle.
    God bless you and yours, gentlemen!
    +][+

  • @presidentlouis-napoleonbon8889
    @presidentlouis-napoleonbon8889 2 роки тому +1

    That's a new Britishmuzzleloaders opening. I like that.

  • @earlyriser8998
    @earlyriser8998 2 роки тому +1

    i loved both the shooting and the conversation that follows

  • @avp5964
    @avp5964 2 роки тому +10

    I love this collaboration I hope you guys can do more. Fabian I'm sure you know but just in case Karl from inrange has done a bunch of trapdoor content I bet he could help you out. Rob love your point on shooting sequences not being perfect, that's why I like that you guys try to use correct accoutrements because they really do matter for the effectiveness of the soldier.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +4

      I have asked Karl many times 😔

    • @avp5964
      @avp5964 2 роки тому

      @@thebotrchap Damn I'm sorry :(

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +4

      Its a fun undertaking... especially when the parties involved each bring their own piece to the puzzle, as it were.

    • @jordanwalsh1691
      @jordanwalsh1691 2 роки тому

      @@thebotrchap Any idea whether he's too busy, or just not interested in participating? If it's the former then maybe some of his Patrons can let him know that we'd be interested in seeing that content. Loves me some trapdoor action.

  • @louislarose6613
    @louislarose6613 2 роки тому +5

    Great Shooting and a very informative discussion ! A very enjoyable video ! Well Done !

  • @Digmen1
    @Digmen1 Рік тому

    Wow that was fantastic to watch you fire those 12 shots from the Martini-Henry in one minute.

  • @hamm6035
    @hamm6035 2 роки тому +2

    I have only done a kinda mad minute is with my Snider. You got 8 and I'm remembering 5 or 6 so. I have an original Peabody Martini so I'll have a go as you say.

  • @djwoody1649
    @djwoody1649 2 роки тому +5

    Fantastic video and great shooting (both of the breeze and of the target). These videos are absolutely a treasure and I look forward to every one.

  • @onpsxmember
    @onpsxmember 2 роки тому +8

    YES! That's what I was looking for. More collaborations please! Maybe with C&Rsenal, a black powder trap shooting thingy including Karl from InRangeTV. Thank you! Karl can do the trapdoor.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +4

      I have asked him many many times 😢

    • @EXO9X8
      @EXO9X8 2 роки тому +1

      Have you tried asking the nice gentleman from capandball

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      It's all about time and scheduling....

    • @onpsxmember
      @onpsxmember 2 роки тому +1

      @@thebotrchap
      @InRangeTV
      Do the thing. The planets have aligned.

  • @NomadShadow1
    @NomadShadow1 2 роки тому +1

    Hey, two of my favorite gun nerds in one place! Huzzah!

  • @graemesim40
    @graemesim40 2 роки тому +2

    Great video and great collaboration, more please 👍

  • @earlshaner4441
    @earlshaner4441 2 роки тому +1

    Hi from Syracuse NY USA brother and thank you for sharing your thoughts and history

  • @rockymountainstranger3754
    @rockymountainstranger3754 2 роки тому +1

    Howdy from just south of the boarder! Thank you both for doing such in-depth videos on your channels! I really enjoy the history that you present. Being half Canadian find British military history especially interesting. thank y’all again

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      You are most welcome. Glad to hear!

    • @bunk95
      @bunk95 7 місяців тому

      Half of the stories you share are [Canadian citizen] approved?
      Get a bigger caliber and/or other system(s).
      Only specific types of [Nazi]s get that, [Canadian], north-whens 7.62N going to go?

  • @minutemanqvs
    @minutemanqvs 2 роки тому +1

    I particularly like these conversations, thanks!

  • @Hambone_FN
    @Hambone_FN 2 роки тому +1

    This channel always brightens my day.

  • @rrkeyes3
    @rrkeyes3 2 роки тому +1

    Well done lads

  • @SKNAZIR-sx1th
    @SKNAZIR-sx1th 2 роки тому +1

    After many days I saw your new video. The discussion of the video was awesome..

  • @mistl
    @mistl 2 роки тому +1

    Awesome

  • @dennis2376
    @dennis2376 2 роки тому +4

    Very interesting video, I learned that more about the reasoning why things where done a certain way. Very cool, thank you. Have a great week. PS In your The Battle of Inkerman series have you found any information on Canadians in the fight?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      There were "Canadians" that partook in the war. The concept as we know it today, can't really be applied though... "William Hall" will come up in the conversation...

  • @earlshaner4441
    @earlshaner4441 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for sharing this brother

  • @johnfisk811
    @johnfisk811 2 роки тому

    Ooh, new form Chassepot cartridges to look forward to as well from le Chap.

  • @Schlachtschule
    @Schlachtschule 2 роки тому +3

    More Snider! A great video, Rob, this approach is really telling and is very valid.

  • @stephanl1983
    @stephanl1983 2 роки тому

    As you both have mentioned the Trapdoor and the practice of grabbing some rounds and put them in the ground or a barricade, there was an article here in Germany several years ago about the Springfield M1873 and that Troopers of the US Cavalry, which operated for the most time as Mounted Infantry, grab some rounds from their pouches, and drop them in the ground when they was dismounted.
    This was unofficially or offially prohibited by the Army, because their are reports from Scouts, who have seen Native Americas, screening the ground after actions with the US Cavalry, for löst rounds as this was one of the few oppurtunities to get supply of ammunition.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Hence the practice isn't as beneficial and straight forward as some might think.

  • @314299
    @314299 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting video Rob, always enjoy hearing from "the Chap" of BOTR.

  • @MASSspec1990
    @MASSspec1990 2 роки тому +2

    You, Chap, Ian, and Karl need to do a project similar to Project Lightning. 1870’s and 80’s rifles.

    • @diestormlie
      @diestormlie 2 роки тому

      *Lightening. Yup, it took me ages to notice as well.

    • @MASSspec1990
      @MASSspec1990 2 роки тому +1

      @@diestormlie I couldn’t remember which way it was and I was about to run of too work, thus I couldn’t look it up.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Maybe one day... those are very busy guys....

  • @christopherpeary7290
    @christopherpeary7290 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for a great video gentleman thoroughly enjoyed watching it.

  • @joemorganeatmyshortschannel
    @joemorganeatmyshortschannel 2 роки тому +1

    I thoroughly enjoyed this

  • @mongo5564
    @mongo5564 2 роки тому +2

    Great content as always.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you!

    • @mongo5564
      @mongo5564 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders you’re welcome sir. If I do decide to dedicate more time to my channel I want it to be as informative and wholesome as your content. Thank you again from Beautiful northern Arizona.

  • @IamtheIZ0D
    @IamtheIZ0D 2 роки тому +2

    Love the comparisons and discussions. I personally did a "Mad Minute" with my 1888 Springfield a while back loading from the belt. I think I hit 10 shots? Aiming is a treat with the Buffington sight, since the battle sight is somewhere in the zone of 275 yards. I aimed a full foot below the target at 50 yards.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Nice!

    • @mpetersen6
      @mpetersen6 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders
      One thing that would be interesting is running these Mad Minutes with shooters running the rifles with the level of training with the rifle that troops would of had. Given the general penny pinching of the US Congress towards the Army in the era I suspect the Trapdoor would run slower and possibly other rifles as well. Not because of the rifle but the training.

  • @quentinversa5058
    @quentinversa5058 2 роки тому +1

    The gras 1874 m80 frist french metal cartidge rifle very diferent to the martini-henry but the same beauty !😀 when the video of the french gras ? 😉

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      "Britishmuzzleloaders", 😀......... The Chap fired it as part of the Challenge already...

  • @SootHead
    @SootHead 2 роки тому

    Nice to watch a skilled and drilled rifleman at work.

  • @carlorrman8769
    @carlorrman8769 2 роки тому

    Mate, your demo with the Martini Henry was bloody brilliant. Had no idea you could achieve that rate of fire. Accurate too. Thanks, man.

  • @downunderrob
    @downunderrob 2 роки тому +1

    "Very good, Sir. The scouts report, Zulus to the South-West. Thousands of them."

  • @_Steve_W
    @_Steve_W 2 роки тому +1

    Awesome stuff!

  • @slowhand1198
    @slowhand1198 2 роки тому +1

    Great stuff, gents. I do miss the Rolling Block here, but imagine it would fit well within the parameters of the others. There were a few of them built, and fielded. Carry on.

  • @georgegillett6059
    @georgegillett6059 2 роки тому

    You know it's great content when even the tech gets overexcited! Beepbeepboomboom

  • @HypocriticYT
    @HypocriticYT 2 роки тому

    An amazing amount of effort goes into these videos, great content! In fact some of these videos allowed me to reload 577-450 with success using the paper patch method.

  • @NellaCuriosity
    @NellaCuriosity 2 роки тому

    Superb video!

  • @kearnsey64
    @kearnsey64 2 роки тому

    Thanks Rob! Like the Bloke a lot!

  • @ilfarmboy
    @ilfarmboy 2 роки тому

    had to be a challenge to find all the empty cases in that tall grass

  • @RichardGoth
    @RichardGoth 2 роки тому

    Gotta try this with my .50-70 rolling block when I get some more ammo made...

  • @WalterBurton
    @WalterBurton 2 роки тому

    The PiP is very cool.

  • @michelguevara151
    @michelguevara151 2 роки тому

    it would be interesting to mark a range with pickets and have a line pulled marker, [perhaps a straw filled hessian bag], over the ground before the shooter, at the rate that one may have advanced over the given terrain, [including any time for returned fire from the advance, bearing in mind that the shooter would need to halt in order to reload and make fire], to see how many rounds can be sent before the theoretical assault comes into bayonette range.
    this would give a realistic maximum rounds under duress.
    this could coincide with ordered volley at maximum range, until the picket where the order 'fire at will' would have been given.
    this would give 1, the evolutions in combat conditions, 2, the order of command and of course, 3, the timing of transition to bayonette and preparation to recieve the enemy.
    this would necessitate also, the advancing view over said terrain and it's possible speed/rounds returned to the defended position, [which you have done for a number of theretical engagements, in advance].
    all period correct for the given rifle, of course.
    an interesting discussion, I can quite see this sort of conversation between enlisted men familiarising each other by experience over a new issue before any combat, [that number of practice rounds permitted as per doctrine], and it would be interesting to hear this conversation, 'after the combat', having used the new rifle in 'anger'.
    perhaps this would be an interesting collaboration with inrange's carl, and ian of forgotten weapons as well as yourself and bloke/fabian.
    I appreciate this may take some doing, I'm sure it is in your collective powers!
    in anticipation of a bp breachloading brutality event! perhaps with a certain sergeant of our acquaintance and a load of spuds..
    huzzah rob! huzzah!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      There is a video covering rate-of-advance and rate of fire with the Martini on the Channel, if you are interested.

  • @irondwarf66
    @irondwarf66 2 роки тому

    Yall have me almost wanting to do the trapdoor video for you

  • @johnfisk811
    @johnfisk811 2 роки тому

    Nice haircut. Ooh, Tabatiere to come from the Chap! Something to look forward to.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому

      Friend of the channel Budi has one but ammo is not easy. We’re going to have to start from scratch.

    • @johnfisk811
      @johnfisk811 2 роки тому

      @@thebotrchap I have seen them made from thin wall 12 bore cases and 12 bore plastic cases sized to the chamber by heating the plastic just soft and pushed into the chamber. I will have a look around my records and send you anything useful on Tabby cases.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому

      @@johnfisk811 I’m not a fan of the plastic case method. I do have some cut down brass 12g from a tabby I had years ago which should do if they fit the chamber of his, if not it’s going to take a custom die set. CH4D makes one (based on measurements I sent them years ago) but it’s too expensive for occasional use. We’ll get there but it’ll take time.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Had to mention the Tabatiere... Just one more in a long list, for sure!

  • @bobbeck1907
    @bobbeck1907 2 роки тому

    Regarding minute 36: yeah i had a box of rounds. I had to start from standing to sitting! and 200m with a garand on my left and some poodle shooter on my right! :)

  • @HypocriticYT
    @HypocriticYT 2 роки тому

    A large, heavy and long bullet. These rifles kick! I found on the underside of the lever on my MH it is colour case hardened. Most all MH I’ve seen the finish is gone

  • @nerome619
    @nerome619 2 роки тому

    I recall looking at a MH 577/400 (not 450) in the Victorian State Museum ages ago that had a small box magazine on one side of the receiver that held 5 rounds ... of course you still had to pull them out one by one and insert them.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      There were attempts made to increase the rate of fire of the Martini. One was the item you speak of.. trialled but not issued... it was simply a container for ready-use rounds. Was part of the system that would have become the "Enfield-Martini" in .402.

  • @johnn.3887
    @johnn.3887 2 роки тому +1

    Is that a breach-loader or a machinegun? I imagine lots of Zulus are glad as hell you weren't born 150 years earlier. Nice videos - appreciate all the detail.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Haha! It was a good run... maybe I could squeeze another round there, but not two...

  • @WhatIfBrigade
    @WhatIfBrigade 2 роки тому +1

    On holding rounds in the fingers I think archeology of the Little Big Horn showed many live rounds scattered on the ground. In an actual battle, soldiers already drop plenty of ammunition. Having a fist full at a time seems like it would greatly increase the number of rounds lost.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +1

      Absolutely, you’re hurrying to work the action, aim, shoot with sweaty bloody fingers AND you’re supposed to keep them clenched to retain a few cartridges?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Very much a "range-ism" distilled by the power of the inter-web.

    • @WhatIfBrigade
      @WhatIfBrigade 2 роки тому +1

      @@britishmuzzleloaders One thing I think people don't think about enough is that if soldiers had 100 rounds of rifle ammunition, at 8 rounds a minute they cannot fight a sustained engagement longer than 15 minutes.
      Present day, just get another 100 rounds, but historically they needed to stretch out the ammo or switch to the bayonet.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      @@WhatIfBrigade Sure thing, that!

    • @matthewcharles5867
      @matthewcharles5867 2 роки тому +1

      Holding in the fingers was a quigleyism, (shown in the movie quigley) shooting a sharps from cover of a upturned boat. In terms of shooting the Martini rifles quick have seen civilians with a pouch set-up in a similar way on a crossbelt where the British army has cap pouches for there muzzle loading Enfield s. Appreciate the great work you blokes put into your respective channels, cheers from Australia.

  • @peterconnan5631
    @peterconnan5631 2 роки тому

    Great work! Really smooth with both rifles! If I may, perhaps Carl from InRange could be sucessfully hounded into contributing an episode featuring the Trapdoor?

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +1

      Please hound away, all my attempts have been in vain.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      As Le Chap has eluded..

    • @peterconnan5631
      @peterconnan5631 2 роки тому

      The hounding has started... In return I would be grateful if you (The Chap) could hound the Bloke for a mad minute in return. With the BMS Cam rifle...

  • @schwadevivre4158
    @schwadevivre4158 2 роки тому

    A Snider squibbed in the jungle,
    Somebody laughed and fled,
    And the men of the First Shikaris
    Picked up their Subaltern dead,
    With a big blue mark in his forehead
    And the back blown out of his head.
    Kipling, the Grave of the Hundred Head

  • @johnforeman6620
    @johnforeman6620 2 роки тому +1

    I wonder if there might be a change in timing when rapid-fire shooting with others, at the same time, rather than doing it alone.

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому

      Probably but it would have the same influence across the board. In the same vein so would someone firing back or running at you with something stabby. Over the minute perhaps 1 max 2 cartridges due to adrenaline. I would expect accuracy to decrease though.

    • @johnforeman6620
      @johnforeman6620 2 роки тому

      @@thebotrchap I suppose we are then looking at the character and training of the shooters and I do not know how that could be determined experimentally.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      There is the distinct possibility of firing becoming wild and inefficient... that's why the role of NCOs and Officers is so important...

  • @GrumpyGenXGramps
    @GrumpyGenXGramps 2 роки тому +1

    Looks like Chef Boyardee’s hat.

  • @washingtonradio
    @washingtonradio 2 роки тому

    What struck me is the rate of fire in a 'mad minute' with these rifles is about 1 round every 5 to 6 seconds compared to about 4 seconds per round with a SMLE. The magazine helps rate of fire but not by as much as one would assume. These results mean the idea of magazine cut-off, which to modern ears sounds stupid, is actually rather sound. Shoot like a single shot at 1 round at about 6 or 7 seconds (or slower) but have a reserve for more rapid (2 or 3 seconds per round) when needed.

    • @88porpoise
      @88porpoise 2 роки тому

      Well the idea that magazine cutoffs were dumb is just plain wrong. Given the context where they were developed: for magazine rifles without clip loading they make a ton of sense. You could argue they stuck around longer than the should have but the oft-mentioned Lee-Enfield kept it as a safety, not to be used in battle.
      As to the benefit of a magazine and clip, I suspect these videos are a bit misleading in that they are probably firing substantially faster than your average rifleman would. The other big thing is I would expect a noticeably tighter group at a given rate of fire with a magazine rifle simply due to maintaining your position versus dropping the rifle. Finally, if you are loading five round clips, you have one fifth the number of opportunities to fumble a reload or whatever and that is a significant benefit.
      /The magazine was nice, but I stand by the clip being far more transformative.

    • @salvadorsempere1701
      @salvadorsempere1701 2 роки тому

      Mind you that the 4 secs for the SMLE (15 rounds/minute) were with a target at 270 meters. I´m pretty sure that a 50mtrs target can conduce at a faster rate of fire

    • @washingtonradio
      @washingtonradio 2 роки тому

      @@salvadorsempere1701 The point I was making was the rate of fire without a magazine vs a magazine is a lot closer than one might expect. A trained soldier with a Martini-Henry or similar rifle could keep up a surprisingly high rate of fire.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +2

      Most of these rapid fire "contests" are just that... they don't speak to the reality of battle in the era.... the amount of instances that an infantryman would have had a minute or two to shoot at his fastest rate at a target that is presenting itself for the whole two minutes were few and far between... That said, small bursts of rapid fire at short range would certainly have been common place. Add to this, supply issues both tactically and operationally were of extreme importance.... 70 rounds will go very quickly if fire discipline is eroded...

  • @renngretsch
    @renngretsch 2 роки тому

    I want to see a britishmuzzleloaders skit, where Rob is up on charges for arguing with Lord Raglan that the French are not the enemy in the Crimean War!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Did you see last years Christmas video?

    • @renngretsch
      @renngretsch 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders Haha, l assume I did!!! But I was laid low with Wu-flu so the many things I watched while isolated over Christmas are a bit of a haze!
      Clearly I need to review what I think I have already seen from a year ago

  • @18robsmith
    @18robsmith 2 роки тому

    ...and home in time for tea and medals
    Chin Chin :-)

  • @polymathart
    @polymathart 2 роки тому

    Can a Martini Henry bullet-the bullet, not the casing-fit down a smooth bore Black Bess flintlock musket?
    I had a middle of the night idea of taking a bullet out of its case, pouring half the cartridge’s powder down the front of a musket and the other half into the pan and then using the bullet as a ball.
    Probably a horrendous idea.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      I'll let you do the math,... 😀.... a .45 bullet in a .75 bore....

  • @salty4496
    @salty4496 2 роки тому +2

    :)

  • @MrLotrecht
    @MrLotrecht 2 роки тому

    Henry Stutzen as in the German Version of Winetou film was so often called-! It was the better one!

  • @lptomtom
    @lptomtom 2 роки тому +2

    How hot was the rifle afterwards? Great to see the MH put through its paces like this!

  • @WalterBurton
    @WalterBurton 2 роки тому

    👍👍👍

  • @PenDragonsPig
    @PenDragonsPig 2 роки тому +1

    Only slightly sexier than the SLR.

  • @jmullner76
    @jmullner76 2 роки тому +1

    Call it now! Every down vote are just people jealous of that stache.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Haha!

    • @18robsmith
      @18robsmith 2 роки тому

      Dammit Man, I voted the wrong way. I'm envious of those with old smoke sticks but I gave a thumbs up (for the entertainment value)

  • @strydyrhellzrydyr1345
    @strydyrhellzrydyr1345 2 роки тому

    Continental European.. what does he mean by that... About the Snyder. And martini.

  • @DillyDilly95
    @DillyDilly95 2 роки тому +1

    Doesn't Karl from inrangetv have a trapdoor?

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +1

      Yes but so far my efforts to convince him do take part have been unsuccessful

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      As Fab says.

  • @ogilkes1
    @ogilkes1 2 роки тому

    Good thoughts. A question though. The ready pouch does seem awkward, even with ou practiced use, id the Brits, or anyone else for the matter, experiment with a battlefield ready use bandolier, which seems to me to be far more practical and fast?

    • @exploatores
      @exploatores 2 роки тому

      the good thing with a ready pouch. is that it´s the same place all the time.

    • @KarltheKrazyone
      @KarltheKrazyone 2 роки тому +1

      The trouble with bandoliers is that they don't handle getting wet very well, and as a storage solution are quite heavy compared to a pouch. If you watch any cowboy action where they sometimes use cartridge belts, there are quite a few limitations that come into play. I'm sure experiments were done, and I'm sure there were limited uses, but I think that they would have been well understood at the time, and so that would have limited the experiments to a particular cartridge, or particular set of webbing.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Bandoliers were used extensively in the era. What we see is essentially either "a bag" with a bunch of loose cartridges in it or a a strap of leather with a bunch of loops on it.. the breechloading era necessitated individual cartridges and therefore individual loops when bandoliers were concerned.. these need a certain degree of tension on the cartridges to prevent them falling out and therefore are a bit more problematic in removing the cartridge from them.

  • @dennis2376
    @dennis2376 2 роки тому

    Sorry another question pop up in my head. You where not wearing the period gear in this episode, would that made any difference to the time. I know in the past you have pointed some kit was making shooting a challenge.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Clothes have very little to do with anything... equipment on the other hand does... hence the inclusion of the latter and the exclusion of the former...

  • @earlgrayteabeard8471
    @earlgrayteabeard8471 2 роки тому

    Is this challenge only for friends of the BOTR channel?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому +1

      Well, anyone can go ahead and shoot it of course,... but I think that Fab's idea was to collect examples of the shooting as a project on BotR....

  • @HypocriticYT
    @HypocriticYT 2 роки тому

    How’s your shoulder after that? In the heat of battle (or fast target work) you won’t notice too much but later in the evening?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Just fine, actually. It's a hefty recoil, but nothing to write home about...

    • @HypocriticYT
      @HypocriticYT 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders I've only shot about three MH 450/577 at a time. The same weight bullet (500gr) in my 458 Win Mag is much more recoil, difference between BP and smokeless powder.

  • @PunchCatcher
    @PunchCatcher 2 роки тому

    Doesn't Karl @inrangetv run a trap door with some regularity (and more importantly make his own ammo) ?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      I believe he does, but The Chap has had little success in convincing him to partake...

  • @philipsturtivant9385
    @philipsturtivant9385 2 роки тому

    Anybody who sings the song "Rounds fired rapidly don't matter, unless they're well aimed at a particular target" is fine by me.
    Even if you'd need the talent of Steven Sondheim (R.I.P.) to make the sentiment remotely lyrical.

  • @eVVigilance
    @eVVigilance 2 роки тому

    What diameter straws for Chassepot? I have thought of doing this but haven't tried.
    Also Rob always looks odd without a hat.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      I think that The Chap is going to elaborate in a stand alone video at some point... Cheers!

    • @thebotrchap
      @thebotrchap 2 роки тому +3

      12mm outer diameter. Putting the info out is going to be tricky since YT doesn’t tolerate reloading anymore 🤔

    • @eVVigilance
      @eVVigilance 2 роки тому +1

      @@thebotrchap Thanks. Wanted to be sure as I saw .4 .5 11mm 12mm and all sorts of sizes... Found some on amazon, delivery tomorrow. Bamboo paper apparently, we will see how that works!
      I'm sure I can 100% port the rest of my method over and save hours.

  • @strydyrhellzrydyr1345
    @strydyrhellzrydyr1345 2 роки тому

    Ok.. what about the fire tactics of today... I'm not really worried about how they. Did things back then, of how the military and firing doctrines were way back then... The point is, it's the past. Obsolete... Frankly... Terrible idea of how to go about doing things... It is wierd to think about, a military doing that. I mean.. the times were sooooo very different.

  • @ahmet42selim65
    @ahmet42selim65 2 роки тому

    Do you feel like your weapons wear out?