The Crypto Reformists Of Our Era
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
- These people are sellouts to the modern world, this idea that the sharia in its entirety needs to be kept in the books and not implemented because it’s ‘bizarre’ and ‘problematic’ is borderline disbelief. May Allah bless the brothers at AMAU for this podcast and defending traditionalist Islam. • Is The Sharia Barbaric...
#yasirqadhi
#hamzayusuf
#amau
#abdulrahmanhassan
#salafi
#athari
#sharia
These people are sellouts to the modern world, this idea that the sharia in its entirety needs to be kept in the books and not implemented because it’s ‘bizarre’ and ‘problematic’ is borderline disbelief. May Allah bless the brothers at AMAU for this podcast and defending traditionalist Islam. ua-cam.com/video/oz3a5Lkz6nk/v-deo.html
Asalam alykum warahmatullahi wabarkatu I seen a post with uthman ibn faruuq and oksha kameny is he upon manhaj salaf
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz are you serious??
There is a huge difference between a sinner ruler and a guy who wants to change the laws of Allah.
Wallahi you are such a ignorant if you think that someone who wants to change the laws of Allah and a sinner ruler are the same 🤦🏽
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz are you saying the 2 holy city’s are in a atheist country?? And where in Saudi did you find alcohol??
There is difference between one who does a sin even though he believes it to be haram and one who does sin and believes it to be not haram.
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz "madkhalis too vs the bullied victims of the madkhalis" -
well you obviously seem to be bullied by them, so you calling yourself one of nifaq too? irony. Sh. Rabee did a good refuting sufi shi'a masonic kariji Ikwanis who allowed bida'a & sin, before we get to your error, do you condemn ikwanis too? or are you like Yaqin making up standards?
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz "allowing zina & alcohol is not changing the laws?" - is passing a sinful law in a land changing laws of Islam? If one lets his child play videos games with music did he say its halal? no. The 1st may falls under ayat of Fisq in Tafsir Q 5 :44 ibn Kathir. recall Bukari Athan & khaibar hadith, Prophet peace and blessings on him didn't invade a city until he didn't hear the athan. So if you want to change it, don't complain on the internet keyboard warrioring, change it halal way after seeking education and educating the society peacefully.
I love you akhi for the sake of Allah, and I really hope brothers like Abdulrahman Hassan and Muhammad Tim Humble become famous to cancel out reformist deviants!!!
Scholars of Salafiya and us promoting them and learning from them is just as if not more important!
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 yes
@mas-udal-hassan9277Your whole post can be refuted with 3 ayat from Surah Mu'minoon. You are an ignorant person and should not speak about the Deen of Allah without knowledge, seek knowledge because it has the answers to the doubts that you have.
Surah Al-Mu'minun 23:5-7
[Allah talking about the believers] And they (are those) who guard their private parts
Except [Only] with their wives or those their right hands possess,[female slaves from the war booty] for then they are free from blame.
*But whoever seeks (to fulfil his desires) beyond that, then those are the transgressors*
.
The only way a man and women can relieve their sexual desires is strictly through their spouse, as females from the war booty is extremely rare/non existent today as sadly the Muslims have abandoned Jihad against kuffar. These same ayat are what make masterbation haram and whoever does that are transgressors with Allah, only their spouse can satisfy them so they must be patient with their desires until then.
Also your nonsense point about making women financially independent your just spewing the modernist & feminist rhetoric: I am not talking about the women who have a halal job with all of the conditions such as there is 0 presence of men, they are covered with the full Hijab & Jilbab .. & Niqab if they take the view that it is obligatory, the place she works is not of a haram type or income such as working in a bank (interest), she can fulfill her rights at home and her children are not deprived, she must have the permission of her husband if married, she must not be beautified if leaving the house and all of the conditions of a halal job apply to her. After that with just one Ayah:
Surah An Nisa: 34
"Men are the caretakers and maintainers of women"
So stop this path that your treading and come back to the book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger (Hadith) S.A.W. If you refuse to do so then remain silent. May Allah swt guide you and me
Edit: The things that you are saying are not issues or something that exists with the with Muslims, they are issues pertaining to the kuffar. The things your talking about are disgusting, I've not heard/read about these things in a very long time. You should spend less time in the circles of kuffar and more time with the people of knowledge - Hamza Yusuf is not a person of knowledge but a person who will lead you astray from the Qur'an and the Sunnah and will make it seem alien to you. Be very careful and watchful who you take your knowledge from
Muslims: the golden age of Islam
Yasir Qadhi : medieval islam
“Medieval” “modern” “rethink” “problematic”, “fundamentalist” “literalist”
Yasir Qadhi’s whole M.O
May Allah guide HY and YQ , they could do alot cuz of their eloquence and manners but their knowledge is sooo corrupted
May Allah guide us all and keep us steadfast
Alhamdulillaah, Allaah has and will continue to bless the people of Sunnah with more eloquent scholars and dae'es who will stand to defend the Sunnah from these callers to Jahannam.
In the Qur'an they were called they'd have great eloquence
I was watching that clip of him praising Norway yesterday and now you upload it today 😂.
Jazakallah khairan
That’s why you can’t get knowledge from everyone. May Allah give us beneficial knowledge and protect us from misguidance.
It hurts to even listen to this nonsense
If not that Allaah ('azzawajal) preserved this deen with the scholars of salafiyyah, these charlatans would have changed the deen beyond recognition, just like the yahood and nasaarah before them.
How can a person whose in doubt about Allah swear about Allah🙄
He said he asked Yusuf Qardaawi....🤣🤣🤣🤣
Joker's of this era, may ALLAH guide us from these... والله المستعان عليه تكلان
Ameen
Time stamp
I HAD NO IDEA HAMZA YUSUF HELD THESE BELIEFS. NAUZUBILLAH!
Man...
Jazakallahu Khair
Hamza Yusuf holds even much stranger beliefs like making dua to the graves of the dead.
At 4 minutes 42 seconds, Yasir Qadhi claims the "texts have some laws that are somewhat bizarre."
Same guy who has doubts in the preservation of the quran. This is the outcome of being brainwashed in IUM and being taught to hate the classical scholars, thanks to whom we have the Quranic, Hadith, and Fiqh sciences present with us today.
I dont understand the point of people like hamza yusuf. If its permissle to reform the shariah law and rule with democratic law, why cant you then reform rules about salah, wudu marriage etc.? Where is the line ? What are their evidences? I really dont get their point.
@@viadeiserviviadeiservi2567 So if someone is drowning we also drown instead of trying to save them?
Imagine actuality defending these filthy statements
May Allah bless you brother Ibrahim and the team at amau
listening to this hamza guy was absolutely painful.
6 : 81
وَكَيْفَ أَخَافُ مَا أَشْرَكْتُمْ وَلَا تَخَافُونَ أَنَّكُمْ أَشْرَكْتُمْ بِاللَّهِ مَا لَمْ يُنَزِّلْ بِهِ عَلَيْكُمْ سُلْطَانًا فَأَيُّ الْفَرِيقَيْنِ أَحَقُّ بِالْأَمْنِ إِنْ كُنْتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ
Why should I fear what you associate with Him? Why do you not fear to associate with Him things for which He has sent you no authority? Tell me, if you know the answer, which side has more right to feel secure?
Hellfire is the worst of all punishment so Yasir might say it is there just to just terrify and scare people? Shallow reasoning.
If these individuals want to reform and modernise Islam, they should create their own religion with whatever laws and legislations they see fit and not associate themselves with Islam.
Salam Alaykum 2:11 May Allah protect and guide us All. Did Allah not know we are not going to shake hands, thats why he put such a punishment? We wouldn’t be able to shake hands but no one would dare to come close to stealing bcuz of its sever penalty. Why are they talking as if islam is not suitable for All ages? Allah made the legislation, who is more perfect in ruling than Allah? Today people kill other people saying: “well it won’t be to hard for me to kill you, I’ll just be in for a few years and will come out (its that simple)” By Allah a man said this to his wife before trying to burn her. May Allah protect us from misguidance, indeed the heart is in between Allah’s fingers, and he turns them as he wishes. All praise be to him, for he is the only one who deserves to be praised.
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
be very careful people! munafiqs tried destroying islam from within when nothing else worked in the time of Prophet peace and blessings be upon him(after him too). dont compromise your deen and dont try to find a loophole to make haram halal for you. read seerah and the lives of the sahaba and act according to it. the deen of Allah doesn't change .
Subhanallah, May Allah Azzawajal guide our ummah from the people who are putting the Laws of Allah Azzawajal down
The Question we should be asking is...
Do your hands actually belong to you or do they belong to Allah? Allah has only put us in charge of these bodies which we claim to be ours. Allah says: Quran 6:162
Say, “Surely my prayer, my worship, my life, and my death are all for Allah-Lord of all worlds.
Our lives are for Him! So if He wants to do anything He wants with us then so be it! Did you create the hands? Or even one strand of hair on these bodies which Allah entrusted upon our souls?
@Juley Beeb exactly
Good point
SLM IF Mufti Taha said that, we abandon it, however Mufti Taha Keraan criticized people who elevated reason above revelation.
🎉
Nothing written in stone? Subhanallah! This person claims to be a Muslim?
" فاى الفريقين أحق بالامن ان كنتم تعلمون "
Hamza Yusuf and Yasser Qahi are just actor, are they should be categorize as Ulama? No they are not. He is teaching something new to us. Talking few words in Arabic and take degree from Islam institutions does not make anyone ulama.
"YoU cOuLdN't ShAkE hAnDs"
Yh then don't commit the crime and you'll be fine
@@onlyallahisworthyofworship5599 He said nobody could shake hands
More like no one would steal. So whose hands would be cut off?
Just cos u don’t want to miss out on shaking hands, it is okay to steal? This guy is ridiculous
May Allah reward you with good
ameen
yaqin has many ppl who promoted kawarij revolts and here in teh west they sell out... wanting dunya
it reminds me of how Thul Kuwaisirah argued with the Prophet peace and blessings on him over booty! (Edit - for who don't get it, kawarij want dunya & hypocritical with din).
Can you name a few? I'm interested as this would be a very good point to use.
@@SAEECLIPSE Yasir has promoted revolts, Omar Suleiman has praised ppl in jail like Salman al Audah! and as for those who at Yaqin compromising the din, though he has Aqida flaws with regards to the rulers, DAniel H has exposed them.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 jazakallahu khairan akhi. Could you give some more names? I'm afraid I'm not sure who else you might mean that DH exposed.
@@SAEECLIPSE DH exposed J. brown teaching disbeleif is ok like attacking Nabi Muhammad peace and blessings on him or aiding qoem loot, O. Suleiman sopposedly repented for his disbelief ritual, ok but why didn't he speak out against disbelief rituals his followers did? Jalal taught bani Adam mates with animals, etc. and i think they are funded by rand
@@SAEECLIPSE it looks bad because one side has a history of extremism like kawarij, the other selling out in 1 group, doesn't look sincere. in Islam we avoid sects as it misguides and wastes time and efforts of the Muslims to the point where there is basis for more loss... much of this is on video too. So we are to follow Sunna.
Brother how can you slander Sheikh HY? This is dangerous to cause such fitna. This man carries the banner of Islam very well.
He doesnt. He may aswell be a kaafir because of how he denied that oraying to jesus isnt shirk
Also. He dwnies hudud in islaam.
He permits homosexuality in usa
@@taimurahmadThat's not true, He absolutely said it's Haram. He never support homosexuality
this video is so unjust while trying to look like it is justice SubhanAllah
Shaykh hamza and Shaykh Yasir had their point and their point wasn't to abrogate the hadd punishment, the question which was asked to Ustad Tim, were "were those punishment for that time, and culture"
this wasn't the point of the 2 first speakers with all due respect
Try as hard as you can, these charlatans have been unmasked already😅😅
Some people follow these figures blindly.
Yasir Qadhi is a preacher of confusion. And Yusuf Al-Qardawi died without performing tauwbah from his statements of Kufr
May Allah break guide yasir qadhi or break his back , aamin
نعوذ بالله من الحور بعد الكور
Akhi, do you have any respect regarding their age and how long they have been studying the Deen? I understand you have an opposing view, but you’re dismissing them like they have no knowledge or that they want to purposefully destroy the religion. All I’m saying is, they are speaking from an academic mind and using islam as their bases to form their opinions.
May Allah bless you, I’m sure you have good intentions and I understand that you may have an attachment to these speakers as I once did. However they’re completely neglecting Islam here as they’re saying the holy law of Allah should be kept in the books and not implemented. The brothers speaking after are the ones truly defending Islam.
@@ibmsulaymani Thank you for your response. I think the hard part to take in from what they’re saying for some people is that they speak in generalities and they don’t necessarily state specifics. I also think it is hard for us to judge them when we don’t hear specifics. Maybe they mean a similar situation with what Umar (RA) did with stealing for a period of time.
@@idisagree8902 Umar suspended the punishment of stealing because of famine which was a necessity. These people on the other hand say that the sharia in its entirety shouldn’t be implemented because it’s outdated, problematic, bizarre and that there needs to be discussions on reforming these laws. All of these statements can found in the video. الله المستعان
@@ibmsulaymani These are the Muslim progressive ideas. Yasir Qadhi has a very clear opinion about the so called progressive Muslim society. He strongly opposes them and constantly mentions that this is not his message. Are you putting him with that deviant group?
Who is this Mufti Taha that Yasir is looking up to?
He mentioned Qardawi, is Mufti Taha another Ikhwanul Muslimin figure?
He’s from the deobandi movement in South Africa, he died a few months ago, may Allah forgive him.
Assalamu'alaikum Ibrahim, can you let me know the time stamo of the clip from the full AMAU podcast? JazakAllah khair
I believe the part is a AMAU Podcast named is the Shariah barbaric(not entirely sure of name). Check out their podcast play list on their channel
Check his 1st comment the link is there.
@@RochelleHa JazakAllah khair, yes I got, AMAU has time stamp for it too making it more easy Alhamdulillah
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Cringy !
some of this has been taken outta context
Like what exactly
They really haven't, they do say these shambolic things on the daily 😂
True, this user’s channel needs to repent of his wrong doing by spreading half false information and fitna in the ummah
@@hazel_mvedits9082 Bruhhhhhhhhh, a man is mocking the punishment of Allah right in front of you, and you're saying this is taken out of context????? Another guy is using some big boy english words and trying to sound educated when in reality this guy is completely misguided. Like I wonder what Yasir Qadhi thinks when Allah said "today I have completed the deen for you." Does he think oh wait, I'm just gonna completely ignore that and I'm gonna start changing some of the fundamental rulings of our religion. Smh
No.
Hamza Yusuf is amazing
check his video on qaseedah burda